Software Engineering for Experimental Robotics - Davide Brugali et al Part 16 ppt

B==BQW:\) :QW[= ?\:QB?>)?W 53T

H =.)R%
C88H0D 5! 84:KH"C L0D085 L0CHK3 38CH8CO% QB"))&:?6R B 3W8 B=aa! H B=&)Q6 F)&HG% ." C88H 05 H." -C!"5= H"3"C88H0D 5! H"3":0DH"4838-O

aZ! H B=&)Q6 ?& H ):6]QW F)&RHG% "O85! M"4D
5 05HC8!KH085 H8  aX! H B=&)Q6% H B?6% ?&
H )\?&B]R<:% 8338CH0L" H"3"8:"CH085ZaaXG% ?BH X% EEH 5Xa+5X@H

@3! H :?)% H B?W=R% H B?W% H :6[)W% H _6Q)?% ?&
H =:?)% "L0
L0CHK3 "5L0C854"5H H"3"8:"CH085D 05H"C&" &8C :35"HCO "N:38CH085% QB"))&9

"N:38CH085 C8L"C 8:"CH085D M0H H." D0"5" H0L0HO :355"C% QB"))&:?6R B  ?W)Q?W:B?= B?.)Q)?") B? BBW:"R ?&
[WB>W:B? F 
Pa3G F
EQ:=Zaa3G% EEH 5UZ@+5UX5H

)?") B? ?W)==:6)?W BBWR ?& _RW)>R F"WB)Q C@@@G% EEH C*UU+C*TCH

)QRB? &["W:B?% Q=B]% ?6=?&% ZaaCH

K3H085 &030HO 04K3H085 DK::8CH &8C KH8584O !"L"38:4"5H% QB"))&:?6R B _@*! H _)QR F)&HG% "48H" 85HC83 C88H0D% EQ:?6)Q9)Q=6% )] BQ<% C@@*H

=B  _=), SB:, E2 S,@<_ES@) GG@=$Y=EBT( =B$@])=B: Y,@,<AB]2$Y]S=B:( Y,@,<YS=B=B:( Y,@,<T]S:,Sa( YS4$ $EBYSE@( TG$, ,`G@ESY=EB( )=TTY,S S,T$],( ;,@Y;

$S,( B) T A]T,]A :]=),T " c9#IK

,Y_ES?,) SE!EYT ),^,@EG,) ]T=B: )=TYS=!]Y,) $EAG]Y=B: GS)=:AT( BES<A@@a $E^,S @S:, S,T( $EAA]B=$Y=B: ^= _=S,) ES _=S,@,TT B,Y_ES?TK E,3,$Y=^,@a $EBYSE@ Y;,T, SE!EYT( 2E]S $EBYSE@ TE2Y_S, S$;=Y,$Y]S,T $B !,

)EGY,)K ;,T, S,' $@=,BYXT,S^,S( =B _;=$; SE!EYT $EBY=B ?BE_@,):, B) S,<TE]S$,T YE G,S2ESA  YT? B) $B !, $EBYSE@@,) 2SEA  T=AG@, S,AEY, $@=,BYUS,AEY, ,^@]Y=EB =B _;=$; SE!EYT ;^, S,TE]S$,T( !]Y B,,) YE E!Y=B ?BE_@<,):, 2SEA  $@=,BY YE G,S2ESA  YT?U $E), EB ),AB) =B _;=$; SE!EYT $EBY=BS,TE]S$,T !]Y $Y T $@=,BYT YE $$,TT ?BE_@,):, Y  T,S^,S YE G,S2ESA  YT?U

ES AE!=@, :,BYT( =B _;=$; SE!EYT $EBY=B S,TE]S$,T( B)  YT? $B !, G,S<2ESA,) !a AE^=B:  AE!=@, :,BY $EBY=B=B: ?BE_@,):, B) S,T]@YT !,Y_,,BSE!EYTK

E!=@, :,BYT H
I S,  B,_ )=TYS=!]Y,) $EAG]Y=B: GS)=:A( _;=$;

;^, BEY a,Y !,,B ,`Y,BT=^,@a ,AG@Ea,) =B A]@Y=G@, SE!EY S$;=Y,$Y]S,T ,K:K

"cF# B) "GCC#K
T GSY E2 _=),S S,T,S$; =BYE Y;, ),^,@EGA,BY E2A]@Y=G@, SE!EY S$;=Y,$Y]S,T 2ES ;bS)E]T ,B^=SEBA,BYT( _, ;^, ,AG@Ea,)AE!=@, :,BYT YE =AG@,A,BY ]YEBEAE]T B) S,AEY, $EBYSE@ S$;=Y,$Y]S,TK
B]A!,S E2 ,`G,S=A,BYT ;^, !,,B $EB)]$Y,) YE TT,TT GEY,BY=@ 2]B$Y=EB@ )<_, ),T$S=!, E]S =AG@,A,BYY=EBT B) ,`G,S=A,BY@ S,T]@YT =B Y;, ]T, E2 AE!=@,

:,BYT 2ES A]@Y=<SE!EY S$;=Y,$Y]S, ),^,@EGA,BYK

˜ ¡°vFƒ| •]˜–[ 2‹n¬¶F¡c †v˜ n‹¡ ·”c¡|„c†¬Fƒ 1‹R‹¬|V£˜ 25
1 ­½\ ””˜ usˆjuhu\ ¯½½¦˜

^ 2”¡|†vc¡{=c¡ƒFv c¡ƒ|† c|]cƒRc¡v ¯½½¦

5Ua H Q66% H [% ?& H B)=<)Q

;, S,TY E2 Y;=T $;GY,S =T TYS]$Y]S,) T 2E@@E_T' ,$Y=EB \ GSE^=),T TEA,

!$?:SE]B) =B2ESAY=EB EB AE!=@, :,BYT B) ;E_ Y;,a $B !, ,AG@Ea,) =BY;, TE2Y_S, ,B:=B,,S=B: GSE$,TT =B SE!EY=$TK ,$Y=EB Z ),T$S=!,T Y_E YaG,TE2 AE!=@, :,BY =AG@,A,BYY=EB( =K,K ]YEBEAE]T B) Y,@,$EBYSE@K ,$Y=EB 9),T$S=!,T ,`G,S=A,BYT $EB)]$Y,) _=Y; Y;,T, S$;=Y,$Y]S,TK ,$Y=EB 7 =T ]T,)

YE )=T$]TT Y;, !,B,6YT B) $;@@,B:,T _;=$; _, !,@=,^, 
T E3,S  A]@Y=G@,SE!EY TaTY,A ),^,@EG,SK =B@@a( ,$Y=EB W GSE^=),T TEA, $EB$@]T=EBTK

 TE2Y_S, $EAGEB,BY _;=$; ,`=TYT _=Y;=B  !E]B),) ,`,$]Y=EB ,B^=SEBA,BY(

!]Y _;=$; $B $EBYSE@ =YT E_B ,`,$]Y=EB B) =BY,S$Y=EB =K,K =Y Aa !, ]<YEBEAE]T( )aBA=$ B) =BY,@@=:,BY H!@, YE @,SBIK
4603$ -$5G $B AE^,HES A=:SY,I !,Y_,,B $EAG]Y=B: BE),T _=Y;=B  )=TYS=!]Y,) $EAG]Y=B: TaT<Y,AK

F<F 0?C>0GC%" 749GC05-
>.0C%CG>%?

E2 )=TYS=!]Y,) $EAG]Y=B: S$;=Y,$Y]S,K ;,T, S,'

 30$5GF$AL$A < T T;E_B =B =:K FHI( =B _;=$;  T,S^,S HI( ;T ?BE_@,):,

H I( B) S,TE]S$,T HI( YE G,S2ESA  YT?K
$@=,BY HI T,B)T  A,TT:, YEY;, T,S^,S S,M],TY=B: YT? ,`,$]Y=EBK ;, T,S^,S G,S2ESAT Y;, YT? ]T=B:

=YT ?BE_@,):, B) S,TE]S$,T( B) S,Y]SBT  S,T]@Y YE Y;, $@=,BYK

 $46G$ L3KG065 < T T;E_B =B =:K FH!I( =B _;=$;  $@=,BY ;T ?BE_@<,):,( _;=@,  T,S^,S ;T Y;, S,TE]S$,T YE G,S2ESA  YT?K ES Y;, $@=,BY

YE E!Y=B Y;, S,T]@Y YE  YT?( =Y A]TY T,B) =YT ?BE_@,):, YE Y;, T,S^,SK

;, T,S^,S ]T,T Y;=T ?BE_@,):, B) =YT E_B S,TE]S$,T YE G,S2ESA Y;, YT?(

!,2ES, S,Y]SB=B:  S,T]@Y YE Y;, $@=,BYK

 6!$ 65 $45! < T T;E_B =B =:K FH$I( =B _;=$;  $@=,BY ;T S,TE]S$,T(_;=@,  T,S^,S $EBY=BT ?BE_@,):, YE G,S2ESA  YT?K ES Y;, $@=,BY YEE!Y=B  S,T]@Y YE  YT?( =Y A]TY T,B)  A,TT:, YE Y;, T,S^,S YE S,M],TY

?BE_@,):,K ;, $@=,BY ]T,T Y;, T,S^,SRT ?BE_@,):,( B) =YT E_B S,TE]S$,T(

YE G,S2ESA Y;, YT? B) E!Y=B  S,T]@YK

YE  AE!=@, :,BY H
I( _;=$; $EBY=BT ?BE_@,):, B) S,T]@YT 2SEA GS,^=E]TYT?T( !]Y BEY Y;, S,TE]S$,T =Y S,M]=S,T YE G,S2ESA  B,_ YT?K
BEY;,S :,BYB,_ :,BY T,S^,S( Y;, AE!=@, :,BY AE^,T YE $$,TT Y;, S,TE]S$,K ;,B Y;,

    







F"G B&) B? )>?&

& "& :RWQ:[W)& B>E[W:?6
Q"8:W)"W[Q)R

AE!=@, :,BY ;T $EAG@,Y,) =YT YT?( =Y $B S,A=B Y Y;, B,_ T,S^,S( ES AE^,

YE BEY;,S :,BY T,S^,S $SSa=B: =YT ?BE_@,):, B) YT? S,T]@YTK

;, ,`,$]Y=EB ,B^=SEBA,BY _=Y;=B _;=$; AE!=@, :,BYT EG,SY, ;T Y;, 2E@<

@E_=B: $EAGEB,BYT B) $;S$Y,S=TY=$T'

 N$KG065 3G&6A4 < AE!=@, :,BYT ,`=TY _=Y;=B B ,`,$]Y=EB ,B^=SEBA,BY(GSE^=),) !a A]@Y=G@, :,BY T,S^,ST T T;E_B =B =:K \K
:,BY T,S^,ST GSE<

^=), 83$B =B _;=$; B :,BY $B S,T=), B) =BY,S2$, _=Y; 2]B$Y=EB@=YaGSE^=),) !a Y;, T,S^,S $EAG]Y,SK

 A6-A4405- 5-K-$ < AETY :,BY T,S^,ST B) AE!=@, :,BYT S, _S=Y<Y,B =B ^ _;=$; T B =BY,SGS,Y,) $EAG]Y,S @B:]:, $B ,`,$]Y, EB 

^S=,Ya E2 ;,Y,SE:,B,E]T $EAG]Y,S G@Y2ESATK


 644K50G065
-$5G 9

: < Y;, A=B G]SGET, E2 Y;,


=T YE GSE^=), B =BY,S<SE!EY $EAA]B=$Y=EB A,$;B=TA !,Y_,,BY_,,B SE!EYTK

GSE^=), B =BY,S2$, YE SE!EY 2]B$Y=EB@=Ya 2ES

T( @@E_=B: AE^,A,BYG@Y2ESAT ^=  TYB)S) $EBYSE@ =BY,S2$,K

ES AES, ),Y=@ EB Y;=T S$;=Y,$Y]S,( G@,T, T,, " c9#K

 $46G$ 65GA63
-$5G < Y;, 
,`,$]Y,T EB SE!EYT Y Y;, S,AEY, @E$<

ES AES, ),Y=@ EB Y;=T S$;=Y,$Y]S, G@,T, T,, " c9!#K

=A,BYT =B Y;, 2E@@E_=B: _aT'


!8G030GO N8$A04$5GB < ]T=B: AE!=@, :,BY AE!=@=Ya YE ]YEAY=$@@a]G)Y, $EBYSE@ $E), Y S]B Y=A, =B A]@Y=G@, SE!EYTK

 K3G 63$A5$ N8$A04$5GB < ]T=B: AE!=@, :,BY AE!=@=Ya YE AE^, A=T<T=EB @,^,@ )Y 2SEA 2=@=B: TaTY,A $EAGEB,BYT =B Y;, ,^,BY E2 Y;,=S 2=@]S,K

 O540 65GA63
336G065 N8$A04$5GB < ]T=B: AE!=@, :,BY AE!=@=Ya

YE 3,$Y Y;, $EBYSE@ $;S$Y,S=TY=$T E2  A]@Y=G@, SE!EY TaTY,A H=K,K Y;,

!=@=Ya YE ,3,$Y=^,@a $EBYSE@ )=TYS=!]Y,) A]@Y=G@, SE!EYT =B Y;, GS,T,B$, E2B,Y_ES? ),@a !a GGSEGS=Y, GET=Y=EB=B: E2  $EBYSE@ :,BYIK

,<8
"9C030CK J9%>04%5C?

Y;, AE!=@, :,BY ),^,@EGA,BY ,B^=SEBA,BY _=Y; Y;S,, _=S,@,TT@a B,Y_ES?,)G=EB,,S SE!EYTK \7 YS=@T _,S, $EB)]$Y,) 2ES ,$; T,Y E2 ,`G,S=A,BYT H YS=@ 2ES_, ]T,) Y_E T,Y<]GTK

GSE:SA H I ]T,) 2ES S,AEY, SE!EY @E:=B( B) Y;, T,$]S, 6@, YSBT<2,S GSE:SA HI( ]T,) 2ES 6@, YSBT2,S YE @@E_ ]G)Y=B: E2 $EBYSE@GSE:SAT EB SE!EYTK

Y;, 2E@@E_=B: T,$Y=EBK !@, \ B) =:]S, CHI( T;E_ Y;, S$;=Y,$Y]S, )GY<

!=@=Ya ,`G,S=A,BY $Y=^=Y=,T 2ES ,Y<]G F S,GS,T,BY=B: EB, YS=@( _;=@, !@, Z

B) =:]S, CH!I( T;E_ Y;, S$;=Y,$Y]S, )GY!=@=Ya ,`G,S=A,BY $Y=^=Y=,T 2ES

,Y<]G \ _;=$; S,GS,T,BY EB, YS=@K

Q)"BQ&)& R W8) &[QW:B? BQ C WQ:=H

`G,S=A,BYT _,S, $EB)]$Y,) ]T=B: ,Y<]G F B) ,Y<]G \( =B _;=$; Y,AT

$EBY=B=B: F( \( B) Z SE!EYT _,S, ,AG@Ea,)K
S$;=Y,$Y]S, )GY!=@=Ya ,`G,S<

=A,BY S,T]@YT S, T;E_B =B =:]S, FcK

;, S$;=Y,$Y]S, )GY!=@=Ya S,T]@YT T;E_ Y;Y ]T=B: AE!=@, :,BYT( $EB<YSE@ $E), $B !, ]G)Y,) AES, M]=$?@a Y;B _;,B ]T=B:  YS)=Y=EB@ GGSE$;K

T=B: E]S AE!=@, :,BY =AG@,A,BYY=EB(  F( \( B) Z SE!EY Y,A ;) =YT $EB<YSE@ $E), ]G)Y,) =B( EB ^,S:, VKFC( -K7-( B) CKCV T,$EB)T S,TG,$Y=^,@a(_;=@, ]T=B:  YS)=Y=EB@ =AG@,A,BYY=EB( Y;, TA, T=b, SE!EY Y,AT YEE? EB

^,S:,( \7Kc-( ZWKCW B) 7\KW9 T,$EB)T YE ]G)Y,K ;, AE!=@, :,BY =AG@,<A,BYY=EBT S, A]$; M]=$?,S( !,$]T, AE!=@, :,BYT $B ,`,$]Y, =B GS@@,@(

T Y;,a S]B =B =B),G,B),BY Y;S,)T( _;=@, =B  YS)=Y=EB@ =AG@,A,BYY=EBSE!EYT S, ]G)Y,) =B T,S=,TK

,^,S GETT=!@,( YE S,)]$, ES S,AE^, ;]AB G,S2ESAB$, 2$YEST( B) YE TG,,)]G B) ]YEAY, Y;, ]G)Y=B: GSE$,TTK ,TG=Y, Y;=T( =Y $B !, T,,B Y;Y AE!=@,

:,BYT =B E]S ,`G,S=A,BYT ]G)Y, $E), A]$; AES, M]=$?@a Y;B Y;, YS)=Y=EB@

    





... S,T=), B) =BY,S2$, _=Y; 2]B$Y=EB@=YaGSE^=),) !a Y;, T,S^,S $EAG]Y,SK

 A6-A440 5- 5-K -$ < AETY :,BY T,S^,ST B) AE!=@, :,BYT S, _S=Y<Y,B =B ^ _;=$; T B =BY,SGS,Y,) $EAG]Y,S... S$;=Y,$Y]S, ),^,@EGA,BYK

 ĂvF| ][ 2nơảFĂc v nĂ ÃcĂ|cơF 1Rơ|VÊ 25
1 ưẵ\ usjuhu\ ẵẵƯ

^ 2Ă|vcĂ{=cĂFv cĂ| c|]cRcĂv ẵẵƯ