c Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006Introduction Pioneer Motor Bearing May 2006 VIBRATION INSTITUTE FLUID-FILM BEARINGS c Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 Outline n Pioneer Motor Bea
Trang 1(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
Introduction
Pioneer Motor Bearing May 2006
VIBRATION INSTITUTE FLUID-FILM BEARINGS
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
Outline
n Pioneer Motor Bearing Company
n Thursday: Journal / Sleeve Bearings
n Fundamentals
n Operations impacts
n Installation / handling
n Friday: Thrust Bearings
n Extension of previous discussion
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
Pioneer Motor Bearing Co.
n Established in 1920; family-owned.
n Offers triad of engineering, new manufacture,
and repair services related to fluid-film bearings.
n Alliance partner with Michell Bearings
n Exclusive repair licensee of Siemens
(Westinghouse) and Alstom Power in North America for large-steam, babbitted products.
n Proprietary Fluid Pivot® tilting-pad journal
bearing.
n Customized training courses available.
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
North Carolina:
Engineering Manufacturing Service & Repair
Trang 2(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
Pioneer Motor Bearing
Engineering
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
n Engineering & Technical Services
n Manufacturing to Customers’ Designs
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
n Manufacturing Pioneer’s Custom Designs
(Including Fluid Pivot® Journal Bearings)
n Repair, Modifications & Upgrades
Engineering Lyle A Branagan
Engineering Manager BSME, MS, Ph.D.
– 10 years with PG&E – Has substantial knowledge of rotor dynamics of turbomachinery – Extensive experience
in the field – An expertise in fluid film bearings and seals
Dr Lyle A Branagan
n Engineering Manager
n BSME / MSME – Machinery dynamics
n PhD – Fluid-film bearing analysis
n University of Virginia – ROMAC Lab
n Industrially-accepted design codes
n Pacific Gas & Electric – 10 years
n Specialist in bearings and rotordynamics
n Knolls Atomic Power Lab
n Pioneer Motor Bearing – 10 years
Trang 3(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
Fred C Wiesinger
Office in Lansdale, PA 1-(215) 362-4074
Technical Services Manager
•Expertise in high speed gearboxes
•Expertise in thrust bearings
•Expertise in bearing repair services
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
Frederick (Fred) C Wiesinger
Technical Services Manager
n Drexel University
n BSME With Honors
n Philadelphia Gear – 7 Years
n Manager High Speed Gear Boxes
n Kingsbury, Inc – 14 Years
n Chief Engineer
n Manager, Repair & Service Division
n Vice President, Manufacturing
n Turbo Research, Inc – 3 ½ Years
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
Presentation Goals
•Understand operation of fluid-film bearings
•Relate vibration changes
to potential bearing changes
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
n Babbitted bearing damage
n Rotordynamics / journal bearings
n Predictive maintenance interface
n Installation and handling
n Questions and discussion
Focus on Thrust (Axial) Bearings
n Thrust bearing overview
n Babbitted bearing damage
n Rotordynamics / thrust bearings
n Predictive maintenance interface
n Installation and handling
n Questions and discussion
Trang 4(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
Perspectives on Bearings
n Pioneer Motor Bearing Company
n Power Plant or Manufacturing Plant
n Maintenance
n Machine Designer
n Lubricant Vendor
n Vibration Specialist
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006
Machine Design Perspective
n Allow rotating equipment to operate
n Separate rotating and stationary components
n Support the rotating load
n Adequate operational life
n Understand impact on oil analysis
Vibration Specialist Perspective
n Common point of measurement for vibration
n Potential interaction of sensors and sensor mounting
n Defines the measured quantity
n May define allowable vibration
n Bearing clearance
n Allowable bearing loads, esp dynamic
n Faults may affect vibration signature
n Excessive vibration may affect bearings
Trang 5(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006EndIntroduction
Trang 6(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved.
Babbitted Bearing Overview
Pioneer Motor Bearing Company August 2006
PIONEER FLUID-FILM BEARING WORKSHOP
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Fluid-Film Bearings APPLICATIONS:
n Radial turbine, generator, fan, pump, and motor bearings
n Turbine, generator, fan, pump, and motor thrust bearings
n Generator hydrogen and other high pressure seals
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Opening Up the Machine
Bearing integral with shell
Bearing bolted to machine or mounted in end bell.
Opening Up the Bearing
End bell and housing top removed
Upper half and lower half showing ID
Load Orientations: radial/thrust
Trang 7(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved.
Load Orientations: radial/thrust
n Horizontal machine
n Radial bearing
nGravity load
nRadial process / misalignment loads
n Thrust (axial) bearing
nAxial process loads
nAxial process loads
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
2 Transfer loads (static and dynamics)
from the rotating to the stationary structure
n Force transmission
3 Prevent undesirable vibrations
n Primary source of damping
4 Provide cooling
Separation
n Maintain close clearances
n Motors / Generators windings
n Fan seals and blades
n Turbine blades
Trang 8(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved.
Hydrodynamic versus Hydrostatic
n Hydrodynamic – pressure
induced by relative motion.
n Hydrostatic – pressure
supplied by external source.
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Hydrodynamic versus Hydrostatic
Ref: Intelligent Mechanics Lab, Pukyong University, website
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Sleeve Bearing Geometry
Rotating Journal
Housing
Shell Babbitt
END VIEW CLEARANCEEXAGGERATED
ROTATINGJOURNALSHELL
SHELLBABBITT CLEARANCE
CONVERGINGCLEARANCE
DIVERGINGCLEARANCE
X
0 90 180 270 360 0
10 20 30
CON
G IN G
D
EG
Clearance space is filled
by a lubricant.
Clearance
n Assume 0.009” radial clearance
on a centered 12” diameter bearing
Human hair about 0.003” diameter
JOURNAL
BEARING
By comparison, the minimum operating clearance is only about 0.002”.
Clearance
n Assume 230 µm (0.009”) radial clearance on a centered 300 mm (12”) diameter bearing
Human hair about
75 µm (0.003”) diameter
JOURNAL
BEARING
By comparison, the minimum operating clearance is only about
50 µm (0.002”).
Trang 9(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved.
Fluid-Film Bearing
Critical Geometry:
n Clearance space between the rotating
and stationary components
n CONVERGING SPACES develop pressure
n Circumferential grooves carry flow
n Axial grooves spread flow
n Tilting pads reduce cross-coupled forces
n Size on the order of 0.001” 0.050”
(40-2000 µm)
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
n Determine hydrodynamic (ω>0) or hydrostatic pressures (ω=0).
n Corrections for turbulence (G θ and G z ) and cross-film viscosity variations (µ(y)).
R h x h t
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Sleeve Bearing Geometry
Converging
Film w/CCW
rotation
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Pressures developed in the lubricant due to the converging wedge provide the bearing load capacity
Theoretical negative pressures in the diverging region are cancelled by air flow from the axial ends.
Reynolds Equation – 2-D Profile
PRESSURE
Sleeve Bearing Flows
Strong rotation with shaft; average velocity about ½ shaft surface velocity.
Lower, pressure driven axial velocity.
Trang 10(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved.
“Cavitation” region, present in the upper half, generally occurs by air penetration, less frequently by oil vaporization
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Area at minimum film limits the flow available.
Downstream increased volume
is only partially filled.
Cavitation - Experimental
Plexiglass bearing showing the formation
of cavitation in the region of increasing film thickness.
Ref Cole and Hughes, Proc.Inst.Mech.Engr., 170/17, 1956
Cavitation Demonstration
n Manual
n Take (2) small plates
n Spread thin layer of grease
n Press plates together with grease in between
n Open plates from one side
n Observe pattern of grease
n Demonstration rig
Trang 11(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved.
Fluid-film Radial Bearing
radial position.
n Simple sleeve bearing
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Bore Designs
Pressures in
an elliptical bearing at light loads.
Pressures in
an offset-half bearing.
Additional effect of a pressure dam – adds to the pressures from the cylindrical lower half.
Radial Bearing Components
ANTI-ROTATION PIN HOLE
LOWER HALF UPPER HALF (ROTATED)
BOLT HOLES
SPLITLINE
SLINGER RING GROOVE
Radial Bearing Components
LOWER HALF UPPER HALF (ROTATED)
DOWEL PINS OIL COLLECTION POCKETS
SIDEWELLS
BOLT HOLES
SLINGER RING GROOVE
Trang 12(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved.
Joint Details
Oil-tight metal joint between the bearing halves.
metal-to-Top half secured by
by (4) joint bolts.
Alignment of top to bottom half by (2) dowel pins Pins captured in the lower half.
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Dowel Pins
Damaged
Used to control alignment:
• Bearing shell halves
• Seal retainers to shell Unhardened allows deformation of the pin
Hardened dowels may damage shell under excess loading.
Care required to separate doweled pieces to avoid upset to the pieces or the dowel.
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
in the housing.
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Bearings for Motors
Insulation required.
Potential damaging electrical ground current loops.
Ref: EPRI Manual.
Bearing Insulation
OD insulation on a motor bearing
Double insulated liner for exciter bearing.
Insulation to prevent electrical discharge across bearing surface.
Potential damaging current loops.
Bearing Support
Free-standing pedestal
Motor / generator end bell
Bearing housing on integral pedestal.
Trang 13(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved.
Conforming Bearing to Shell
n Depends on the flexibility (stiffness)
of the bearing:
n Thin-shell bearings
n Liner type
n Insert type
n Medium wall bearings
n Thick wall bearings
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Distribution-Precision Halves
Oil distribution features
Common in reciprocating and gear box service.
Circumferential groove sharply diminishes load capacity but allows for wider range of load angle.
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Shell Wall Thickness
Thin wall (“liner” type):
shell conforms
to the housing geometry.
t < 0.03D
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Shell Wall Thickness
Thick wall: shell is supported by and aligned in the housing but retains its own shape.
t > 0.1D
Shell Wall Thickness
Medium wall:
shell is supported by and aligned in the housing but
“somewhat”
conforms to the housing geometry.
Tilting Pad Radial Bearings
n Enhanced rotordynamic stability
n Enhanced control
of oil flows
n More components
n Higher cost
Trang 14(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved.
Tilt-pad Radial Bearings
n Tilt-pad radial bearings
n Used to increase rotordynamic stability
nAvoid self-excited vibrations
n Segmented load bearing surface
n Mechanical pivot – load focused on a single contact point (Hertzian contact stress)
nLine pivot
nSpherical pivot (e.g ball in socket)
n Fluid Pivot®
nNo mechanical load concentration
n Flooded or directed lubrication
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Mechanical Pivot
Shaft load distributed as oil pressure and concentrated in pad to the pivot (either a circular or elliptical contact region) Pressure will balance around the pivot.
Pivot can be hardened material (e.g
E52100 tool steel).
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Tilt-pad Radial Bearings
C – pad clearance
M = 1 – C’/C
Tilting Pad Bearings
5-padLoad between padFlooded designMechanical pivotHydrostatic lift
Tilting Pad Bearings
Segmented film
Concentrated load
Single point, or line Contact support
Trang 15(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved.
Specialty Journal Bearings
n Tilting pad bearings
n Uses continuing to expand
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Conventional Pivot Types
CYLINDRICAL SPHERICAL BALL-IN-SOCKET
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Quality of Pivot Contact
Contact varies with curvature, load, and temperature.
Ball-in-Socket Pivot Contact
Contact extent varies with curvature, load, and
temperature.
Operation requires sliding,
as well as rolling, motion
at the loaded contact.
Ref: KMC Bearing web site
Tilting action through deformation.
Smaller bearings benefit from the lack of a 2nd
tolerance for a detached pad.
Trang 16(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved.
Stability Variation with Tilt Restraint
02004006008001000
n Tilt Freedom as a Function of:
Hertzian contact area or web thickness
ideal tilt pad
fixed pad
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Shell, pads, stop pins
Fluid Pivot ® - Tilt Pad Bearing
Hydrostatic pivot, NOT a mechanical pivot.
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Bearing includes shell, pads, stop pins
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Fluid Pivot®
Flange-mounted, style JC
Gear box, style JC
Pedestal mounted, style JS
Fluid Pivot®
Pad supported on self-generated hydrostatic film on the OD of the pad.
Fluid Pivot® Exciter Assembly
Trang 17(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved.
EndBearing Fundamentals I
Trang 18(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved.
Babbitted Bearing Overview
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Oil System Design Options
n Lubricant selection and maintenance
n Viscosity grade and viscosity index
n Hydrostatic lift systems
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Oil Distribution Geometry
OIL INLET HOLE
Sprea
Groe
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Oil Groove Geometry
Double loop groove & double figure eight groove recommended
for grease only.
Circular Straight
Half Eight
Double Figure Eight
Double Loop
Straight
&
Circular
Figure Eight
Single Loop
Grease grooving often passes thru the loaded region which reduces the bearing load capacity.
Do not use grooving associated with grease (long residence time) with oil lubrication (cooling flow).
Options Compared
Ref Constantinescu, Sliding Bearings, Allerton, 1985, p.474
Want to have efficiency and 100%
hydrodynamic fluid-film.
Best achieved with pressurized oil supply was effective axial distribution.
Main oil pump is shaft driven
AC & DC pumps
Sample Turbine Oil System
Schematic of Turbine- Generator Lubrication System
Each bearing has a separate pressurized supply (20 psig), orifice-metered, with a gravity (or slight vacuum) drain back to the reservoir
Trang 19(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved.
Turbine Oil System Components
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Slinger Rings
Slinger rings deliver oil from a reservoir below the bearing to the top of the rotating shaft, driven by friction between the rotating shaft and the ring.
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Oil Grooving and Distribution
Axial distribution
Ref Elwelland Booser, Machine Design, 12/7/69, pp.111-115
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Slinger Rings
Shaft
Slinger ring
Oil level (normal)
Bearing Babbitt
Ref: Mike King, Palisades Nuclear Station report
Slinger ring ID generally about twice the journal OD.
Oil level depth above slinger ring ID roughly 10% of ID.
Ring driven by shaft rotation.
n Oil depth is important
n Balance oil lift (submergence of the ID) with ring drag
Split Slinger Rings
Trapezoidal cross-section
Trang 20(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved.
Slinger Ring Guides
Subject to wear or damage, particularly if misapplied.
Seek to maintain rings perpendicular
to shaft without introducing metal-to-metal friction Made
of bronze, steel, or aluminum.
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Cast Slinger Ring Guide
Cast aluminum guide with oil scraper arrangement Single screw bolts guide upward into upper shell Guide
or screw should be staked to avoid looseness
or rotation
This guide showed rubbing wear on the upper part of the guide.
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Slinger Ring Observation
“Bulls eye”
for viewing the rotation
of the slinger ring.
Ref: Mike King, Palisades Nuclear Station report
Level indicator should show change from static to operating oil level in reservoir.
(c) Pioneer Motor Bearing Company, 2006 All rights reserved
Slinger Ring Observation
Hybrid System
n Combination of slinger ring and
pressurized system.
n Forced sump cooling
n Shaft driven main oil supply
Slinger Ring Demonstration
n Three slinger ring designs
n T-shape: common, inexpensive
n Trapezoidal:
heavier, speed
high-n Trapezoidal with grooves:
nBest oil flow