Global Manufacturing Outlook: Growth while Managing Volatility Global research commissioned by KPMG International from the Economist Intelligence Unit... Global Manufacturing Outlook
Trang 1Global
Manufacturing Outlook:
Growth while
Managing Volatility
Global research commissioned
by KPMG International from the
Economist Intelligence Unit
Trang 2Global Manufacturing Outlook: Growth while Managing Volatility is a KPMG International report that investigates how large
industrial manufacturers are dealing with market and input volatility
in a global marketplace The report was written by the Economist Intelligence Unit, which also executed the online survey and conducted the interviews on behalf of KPMG International
We would like to thank all of the executives who participated in the survey and interviews for their valuable time and insight The survey was conducted in June and the interviews in July of 2011, and both reflect the economic and financial conditions at that time.
Vice President and President,
Power Solutions, Johnson Controls
Dr Steve New
Fellow: Management Studies, Oxford
University’s Säid Business School
Martin Richenhagen
Chairman, President and Chief
Executive Officer, AGCO
Henry Yu
Chief Executive Officer, General
Steel Holdings
Trang 3About the survey
A total of 220 senior manufacturing executives participated in the
survey All respondents are responsible for, or significantly involved
in, finance, supply chain, procurement or strategic development
Respondents represent the aerospace and defense, metals,
engineering and industrial products sectors, including industrial
conglomerates All participants represent companies with more than
US$1 billion in annual revenue; 40 percent hail from organizations
with more than US$10 billion in revenue Nearly half (47 percent)
of respondents are C-suite executives or board members They are
geographically split among Western Europe (31 percent), North America
(30 percent) and Asia-Pacific (25 percent), with the remainder coming
from the rest of the world
$1bn to $5bn
$6bn to $10bn
$11bn to $25bnMore than $25bn
48.18%
12.27%
18.18%
21.36%
1 What are your organization’s global annual revenues in
CEO/President/Managing director
CFO/Treasurer/Controller COO
CIO/Technology director Other C-level executive SVP/VP/Director Head of business unit Head of department Manager Other
2 Which of the following best describes your title?
Engineering and industrial products (including industrial electronics) Aerospace and defense Conglomerate (eg, multi-industry organization) Metals
Trang 4h
Foreword
At the end of 2010 it looked like the long-awaited economic recovery was finally underway, but a series of global shocks throughout 2011 have taken the steam out of the positive momentum, casting doubt on a wider market recovery Despite these challenges, Diversified industrial (DI) companies –
accustomed to cyclical swings and continuous volatility – are clearly preparing themselves for the long haul
In this year’s Global Manufacturing Outlook survey, growth has emerged as a predominant theme along with a continuing focus
on cost, risk management and global supply chain resilience Today, companies are choosing to pursue growth through both product innovation and strategic alliances They are also fine- tuning product costs with more sophisticated design and process improvements, positioning production capabilities closer to growt markets, and enhancing transparency to manage global risk.
To provide context to this year’s survey results, the report contains
a broad range of insights from KPMG partners, industry experts and innovative DI companies These experts also weigh in on what it will take for companies to respond to the challenges and opportunities of today’s volatile global economy and distance themselves from the competition
Despite the prolonged uncertainties DI businesses face, many companies emerged from the 2008–2010 downturn with significantly reduced cost structures, more cash and liquidity, and a laser focus on their customers and markets In an age and industry where volatility has become a given, companies that possess these attributes and pursue these strategies will likely define the standard of success in the next five years Our report results show that DI companies are clearly positioned for growth, but they are doing so with a healthy respect for unpredictability and volatility
Trang 5Executive summary The business outlook:
growth ahead, but risks loom
Trang 6Despite a generally profitable year, many leaders of global manufacturing firms face a number of challenges Just as the global economy looked like it was gaining momentum, the Japanese tsunami struck, unravelling many global supply chains Since then, volatility has become a key watchword, as a wide array of macroeconomic risks – most notably the European and US debt crises – raise uncertainty over future demand and the spectre
of a “double dip” recession
Yet executives at major manufacturers – organizations polled in an Economist Intelligence Unit survey representing firms with at least US$1 billion in revenue – are cautiously optimistic that they can realign their businesses toward top-line growth while
Executive summary
Trang 7Some of the key findings emerging from our research include:
• Price volatility is the biggest headache for manufacturers The number-one
challenge identified for the year ahead is that of price volatility of raw materials and other inputs Bob Kickham, senior vice president, procurement, at Luvata – a global metals and manufacturing group – recounts how a few years back a US$10 shift in copper prices in one day was an extraordinary occurrence He is now immune to daily swings of up to US$250 Selected by 44 percent of firms globally, ahead of any other issue, price volatility is especially acute for Asian firms, selected by 54 percent of respondents
• Although the push toward emerging markets continues, this does not imply the
demise of manufacturing in the West One of the more striking research findings
is that the US registers second only to China as a destination for new sourcing in the next 12 to 24 months It ranks third highest even for emerging market manufacturers
“We’re going in both directions,” says Martin Richenhagen, CEO of AGCO, a global farm equipment manufacturer, of his organization’s investment plans in both Asia and North America Of course, it is clear that emerging markets are a major driver of growth:
52 percent of manufacturers say their growth plans hinge on these markets But many plan to invest in mature markets too: 43 percent of respondents aim to expand capacity
in developed markets, more than twice the proportion that plan cutbacks
• In the pursuit of growth, manufacturers are prioritizing new products One
noticeable shift when comparing respondents’ views from the last two years versus the next two years is the added attention that firms will devote to new products Over the next two years those planning to rely on existing products in existing markets will more than halve (from 44 percent to 19 percent), whereas those planning to sell new wares in existing and new markets will increase from 37 percent to 56 percent This will put a premium on innovation, and the survey shows that organizations are placing more emphasis on research and development (R&D) Indeed, innovation/R&D will be the second-highest priority for investment/expansion, after cost management Many are opening design centers in high-growth markets In doing so, however, they will be challenged by a shortage of skills, the top human resources concern cited by executives
in those markets
• Diversification into new markets and new products will converge with a push
toward input and process standardization In response to both input price inflation
and volatility, many organizations are prioritizing increased standardization More than half of manufacturers polled (55 percent) plan to standardize production processes across sites, while nearly half (45 percent) will move toward standardized inputs across product lines Given the concomitant shift toward a greater focus on new products, however, standardization poses a risk of homogenous product lines that could fail to engage consumers Another challenge will be managing the tensions that could arise between Sales and Procurement, as one function tries to push new products into the market while the other works to standardize inputs
• Investment in supply chain risk management will continue, with a particular focus
on transparency Many organizations have already made substantial investments in
bolstering their risk management functions over the past couple of years Stung by the severity of the tsunami in Japan, this push will continue, with a particular focus on improved supply chain visibility, to better assess where potential vulnerabilities lie The use of technology to improve supply chain visibility is the number-one tool that executives plan to rely on to identify risks (selected by 49 percent of respondents)
KPMG Global Manufacturing Outlook: Growth while Managing Volatility 5
Trang 8of sentiment among procurement executives, showed that as of mid-2011, confidence among manufacturers in the US had risen consistently for nearly two years
This confidence was mirrored by manufacturing executives surveyed by the Economist Intelligence Unit in June
2011 One in four survey respondents describe themselves as “very optimistic” about their organization’s prospects for the coming one to two years, while a further 53 percent are “optimistic.” Luvata, a global metals and manufacturing group with revenues of over €3 billion, is one example “2009 was a very poor year, the eye of the recession But during 2010–11, we’ve doubled our profits and
we expect to be back at 2008 levels by the end of 2011,” says Bob Kickham, the firm’s senior vice president for procurement “Next year, we see that trend continuing, with double-digit increases, while we’re cautiously optimistic in terms of growth in profitability.”
But compared with findings
highlighted in the 2010 Global
Manufacturing Outlook1, a degree of caution has crept in, primarily triggered
by the European and US debt crises that have dominated the headlines
in mid-2011 Overall, confidence is slightly down on a year ago This matches a similar drop in the PMI (see chart) European manufacturers are the most ambivalent about prospects, while Asian firms are most bullish US manufacturers were also optimistic, perhaps because at the time of the survey, the full impact of the country’s debt crisis was not known Given the potential of downside risks, such differences are unsurprising The rate
of gain in overall economic output has declined in the US and Europe, as the global economy lost some of its momentum This is filtering through
to manufacturers Joe Kaeser, the chief financial officer of Siemens, a conglomerate with revenues of €76 billion in 2010, recently advised that increased efforts would be required
to maintain growth going forward,
as “the tailwind from the economic recovery is likely over.”2
Financial crises in the euro zone have dimmed Europe’s economic outlook Japan is still recovering from the effects
of its devastating March tsunami
Trang 91 Global Manufacturing Outlook: Relationships, Risk and Reach, KPMG International, September 2010
2 Siemens sees end to ‘tailwind of economic recovery’, Financial Times, June 28, 2011
How optimistic are you about your business outlook in the next
12 to 24 months?
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit survey, 2011 and 2010.
Very optimistic optimistic norNeither
pessimistic
Very pessimistic Pessimistic
Purchasing Managers Index: Manufacturing
January 2008–July 2011, a reading above 50 indicates a general expansion; below 50 a general contraction
Source: Institute for Supply Management (ISM)
010203040506070
Trang 10Integrated Finance Governance
Financial management is becoming more central in managing risk both for companies operating in Asia and for Asian companies looking to expand globally In both cases managers are becoming responsible for transactions and processes that are occurring thousands of miles away across multiple locations To get a handle on that, I have been advising my clients
to move their target operating model toward a structure with more integrated finance governance For too long
finance has been stuck at headquarters where managers have been allowed
to see their primary function as saying
“no” to spending requests Instead, the most agile organizations are seizing
on finance as a way to bring additional value in terms of analytics and insight
As the amount of data and noise proliferates, finance offers a way to gain insights and align the underlying business case I’m seeing clients move toward center of excellence models where finance professionals, skilled
in analytics, valuations, mergers, or treasury are housed together centrally where they can serve as a repository
of knowledge for outlying offices That has been a very effective way to gain strategic leverage.
The Baltic Dry Index (BDI), an index
of shipping costs, remains close
to record-low levels Developed economies are just starting to grapple with their debt burdens, with government austerity ahead
In emerging markets, the outlook is more positive, but risks lurk there too Inflation remains high while concerns mount about the overheating
of China’s economy “The global steel industry has been volatile in
past months, and is likely to remain uncertain in coming months,” says Ding Liguo, chairman of Delong Holdings, a China-headquartered steel manufacturing group with
2010 revenues of RMB9.9 billion (US$1.5 billion) He adds that steel production in China has been affected
as the country implemented tightening measures to rein in inflation and cool its housing market
Trang 11credit-Price pressures
But the most pressing challenge for
manufacturers is the cost of key inputs
Although prices have eased more
recently, many commodities remain
at historically high levels Meanwhile,
a jittery global economy has increased
the price volatility of key inputs, such
as metals This is easily the biggest
headache for manufacturers, selected by
44 percent of respondents globally One
example is the price of copper, which
increased from US$3,500 per ton in 2005
to over US$9,000 by mid-2011
Unfortunately, executives do not
anticipate much relief A majority of
survey respondents expects price
increases on raw materials, energy,
and transport and distribution Some could be steep One in five respondents expect transport costs to increase by at least 20 percent in the next one to two years, while 16 percent think the same
of primary raw materials However, the greatest fear of price increases relates
to energy costs with nearly one in four executives expecting them to rise at least 20 percent Such sentiment may
be due to the fact that manufacturers are in the center of a price storm in 2011: industrial raw materials prices are expected to rise nearly 30 percent, according to the Economist Intelligence Unit, on the back of a 44.5 percent
increase last year (see Growth and price
forecasts) Some relief is forecast for 2012.
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit survey, 2011.
Price volatility on key cost inputs
Intense competition and pressure on prices
Uncertain demandRisk and reliability in the supply chain
Efficiency in R&D/product development process
Increased regulation in our industry
Managing geopolitical riskImprove technological efficiency
Prospect of tax increasesLack of access to capital or credit
What do you see as the biggest challenges for your business in the next
12 to 24 months?
Percent respondents
In the 25 years prior to 2005, the average price volatility (for copper) was minor It would be a news story
if it moved US$10 in a day But I am now immune to seeing swings of US$250 a day.
Bob Kickham
Senior Vice-President, Procurement, Luvata
KPMG Global Manufacturing Outlook: Growth while Managing Volatility 9
Trang 12Emerging market manufacturers expect
future price pressures to be even more
intense than their developed market rivals
“The greatest challenge we have
seen recently has been the overall
increase in price of raw materials,
such as iron ore and coke, which
has affected our gross margin,”
says Henry Yu, CEO of General Steel
Holdings, Inc (GSI), a privately held
Chinese steelmaker that plans to
increase output to 6 million tons this
year, from 4 million tons in 2010.
Growth and price forecasts
These cost concerns are exacerbated
by intense competition and pressure to keep prices down, the second-biggest challenge, cited by 40 percent of survey respondents For many, price increases will
be unavoidable: 63 percent of executives agree that they will be forced to pass on higher costs to their clients in the year ahead Rounding off the trio of challenges
is uncertain demand (35 percent)
Trang 13The aerospace and defense (A&D)
sector is used to weathering economic
ups and downs Its exposure to
the fluctuations in government
appropriations has made the industry a
leader in instituting and managing cost
controls That discipline will benefit it as
it looks to transfer those cost savings
into new growth opportunities
“There is no question that the next
few years will see a marked upturn
in mergers and acquisitions.” says
Phillips.
”With government coffers dry, A&D
companies are looking to invest in
adjacent markets and products.” The
challenge, of course, is choosing which
commercial sector to enter “A&D
organizations have a long memory,”
observes Phillips “Many got burned
in the 1980s when they turned to a
stream of private sector initiatives,
from transportation to gaming With
risk aversion high right now, many
companies are reluctant to sink money
into unproven technologies.” He adds,
“navigating the right commercial and
geographic markets to enter through
direct investment or joint venture can
be immensely difficult A&D companies know how to deliver when the market
is really, really good and really, really bad But the ‘in between’ makes it hard to know what path to take We help organizations work through that decision tree.”
“To gain clarity, organizations are coming to KPMG for help in shoring
up their fundamentals, restructuring their businesses, and spinning off unprofitable assets.”
One client had two business units with overlapping IT functions, for instance
By combining those units, they cut excess capacity and cost while also slimming down their management model
Phillips believes it may take until 2014 before the A&D market sees a reprieve
in current market conditions But, he notes, “A&D companies have a fairly high pain tolerance and they always make a point of seeing to it that the interests of shareholders are protected whichever way the market turns.”
Trang 14Which of the following aspects of your business will you
prioritize most?
Top-line growthCost containmentProduct qualityCustomer relationshipsOperational efficienciesR&D/innovation (including efficiencies in product
development life cycle processes)
Back-office process efficiencies/shared services
Innovation/speed to marketImproved visibility on product costs
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit survey, 2011.
Striving for growth
Despite all these challenges, many manufacturers are clearly shifting from
a dual focus on cost containment and top-line growth to a more singular emphasis on growth This is not to say that cost containment will be forgotten
Nevertheless, it signals a shift in aspiration, after years of fire-fighting
But if growth is back at the top of the agenda, where will firms look for it and what strategies will they implement to realize it? And how are supply chains being restructured to support this growth? The rest of this report will address these questions
Trang 15“A weaker US dollar and steady
demand from China have made steel
and metals one of the bright spots in
the global economy in 2011.”
But steel is a cyclical business, and
Eric Damotte, head of KPMG’s global
metals practice, warns that the
sector’s performance may be affected
by the undercurrent of uncertainty
fueled by the European debt crisis
and the tepid US economic recovery
That cyclicality is sharpening as steep
swings in the spot pricing of iron ore
squeeze profitability
The growth picture is also more clouded
“China has been the major driver of
growth representing between 40 to 50
percent of global production and demand,”
says Damotte, “but that growth rate is
probably not sustainable and foreign
entrants are precluded from getting
a piece, given Chinese government
controls.” Although some companies have
sought workarounds in the form of joint
ventures with Chinese partners, many
of these come with provisions, such as
restricted ownership and complex rules
that put into question the overall value
Where then to look for growth? With
European markets mired in the debt
crisis and the US recovery hampered
by slow growth, the metals industry
has focused its sights on countries like
Brazil, India and Russia that are rich
in mineral resources and have rapidly
expanding physical infrastructures
But those markets bring their own
challenges Damotte adds, “in some
respects, Brazil has been overly
successful The country has deep
reserves of iron ore and coking coal,
making it one of the best places
in the world to produce steel But
the accelerating economy and the
revaluation of its national currency have
made the country an expensive place
to operate.” India is another popular
beachhead, but operators must contend
with a developing infrastructure,
complex environment, and a slow
decision-making process
To compensate, Damotte says leading players are focusing on sustaining cost improvements
“There is a tremendous amount of invested capital in the steel business
To justify the heavy fixed cost, the traditional thinking was that plants needed to produce non-stop The idea
of shutting a blast furnace used to
be considered impossible, but not so anymore As technology has advanced, producers can adjust capacity to cut unnecessary costs.” The industry has gotten a lot better at flexing production capacity in line with demand and reducing what used to be a fixed cost
Intent on reducing finance and inventory risk, buyers of metals products are also keeping stock levels low “But this makes demand swings more brutal,” says Damotte “That’s because when the market anticipates possible price increases, buyers rush
in to lock up supply, prompting prices
to rocket up for a short while before dropping sharply again when the rush subsides.” As a result, better business intelligence is a top agenda item
“Scenario building has become
a real cornerstone of planning, something that has taken off over the last 12 to 18 months,” says Damotte “My clients realize they need to plot a range of variables – both quantitative and qualitative – and plan contingencies
accordingly.”
Reflecting on the sector’s near-term prospects, Damotte becomes philosophical “The economy works like a self-fulfilling prophecy When negativity abounds, results reflect that The good thing about steel, however, is that, cyclicality issues aside, there will always be a certain minimum of demand Economies are built on infrastructures, and infrastructures are built with steel.”
Trang 16Growth strategies:
managing volatility
Manufacturers are reshaping their
business models in order to deal with
this more volatile world More than half
(56 percent) of survey respondents agree
that their firms are changing models in
order to cope with market dynamics
Just 15 percent say they are not For an
industry that is often perceived as being
relatively slow-moving, this is a striking
figure There are numerous shifts that
individual firms will make, but three
themes stand out:
and demand management
Operating closer to new sources of growth
As in many other industries, the macro trend of a steady shift eastwards continues in manufacturing
However, the US surprisingly topped this year’s list for expected demand in the next 12 to 24 months, just barely edging out China for the number one position.
India and Brazil both feature in the top five as well, and Germany ranked fifth
Manufacturers increasingly see emerging markets as crucial demand engines
More than half (52 percent) of survey respondents agree that their growth strategy is reliant on these markets
Emerging markets are now more important as sources of demand than for low-cost production (54 percent) Siemens, for example, is actively exploring opportunities in lesser-developed
countries such as Indonesia and Thailand
“The core of our strategy is to shift our focus and look more toward [these] markets,” says Barbara Kux, Siemens’ head of supply chain management, “in order to ensure our planned business growth.” Meanwhile, emerging market manufacturers see little reason to leave their core markets “Demand within China
is significant enough that we have not had the opportunity to explore such avenues,” says GSI’s Mr Yu Delong’s Mr Liguo says that more than 90 percent of the company’s sales go to Chinese customers
Which countries do you expect to account for the majority of your new
business growth in the next 12 to 24 months?
Top 10 only
Trang 17As the world’s second largest economy,
some see China as having outgrown
its “developing nation” label, but Andy
Williams, ASPAC Leader for Diversified
Industrials, KPMG in Singapore, says
the reality is more nuanced “There is no
doubt that China has grown significantly
on a commercial level But, there are
enormous differences from region to
region within China Some areas boast
thriving business centers, while others are
still decades behind in their development.”
However, there’s no doubting the growth
trajectory By 2020 or 2030, the majority
of the world’s middle class is expected to
be in China
While that strategy may give domestic
brands something to chew on, Western
companies have a lot to learn from the
Chinese way of doing things as well
Chinese companies tend to go global
on a sector basis They consolidate
domestically first, then look to buy
outside Says Williams, “by the time a DI
sector, such as engineering, has gone
from being a thousand strong to just the
five top players, the scale, the cash on
hand and the acquisition experience are
usually massive.” That gives them the
means to move forward globally, buying
up big name companies and solidifying
their leadership on the international stage
“The Chinese are masters at planning,”
adds Williams
“The government issues a
meticulously detailed five-year plan
that gives a roadmap to the economic
and social priorities for China
Citizens, both corporate and private,
tend to follow it rigorously For
companies, that level of discipline
and planning helps them execute
with far greater consistency.”
Foreign DI companies have their own
maturity curve when it comes to
partnering with Asian suppliers According
to Williams, “one mistake foreign entities make when expanding into Asia
is to assume that the outsourcing or partnership model they follow in Europe
or the Americas will work equally well here Asia-Pacific hosts a tremendous mix of people, cultures and sub-cultures all under one regional moniker For that reason, DI companies cannot apply the same solutions unilaterally whether it be globally or even within the region itself.”
Although Williams is bullish on the DI sector in Asia, he cautions that the region’s rapid rate of growth probably cannot continue at its present pace given global economic uncertainties While the region was largely buffered from the 2008 financial crisis, Williams sees them as more exposed this time around
“Domestic consumption sustained the region during the last downturn, but inflationary pressures in China, Vietnam, Indonesia and others have cooled demand, and, as we know, global markets just aren’t buying right now.”
All this has put risk management more firmly on the table One way to manage that will be through mergers and acquisitions Says Williams,
“The smart money is at the commodities end of DI Because
if you think of the value chain it really is a case of ‘he who has the raw materials wins’.”
“As a result, I expect my clients and other Asian conglomerates will pursue a more aggressive acquisition strategy to lock in access.”
Looking out over the next 18 months, Williams remains optimistic, but cautions that folks can be overly positive “The opportunity is there; the demand is there
But, success can be squandered if the risks aren’t managed properly.”
Trang 18But developed markets cannot be
discounted The Power Solutions
division of Johnson Controls, a nearly
US$40 billion global manufacturer, is
a case in point Its lead-acid batteries
sell well in emerging markets where
demand for new cars is soaring, but
sales remain steady in the US even
when car sales drop “If someone
doesn’t buy a new car, they have to
replace the battery anyway,” says Alex
Molinaroli, the division’s president
“So it’s a tale of two cities; flat or low
percentage growth in mature markets,
then emerging markets building rapidly.”
This West-East picture is even more
nuanced when it comes to sourcing
China, India and Brazil are all top-five
targets among survey respondents
But developed markets are hardly
being abandoned The US is second,
the UK fourth and Germany sixth This
development can be attributed to the
volatility of commodity costs, which
has added to the appetite of companies
to source from closer to home Higher
oil prices mean higher transport
costs, making Western companies
increasingly inclined to shorten their
supply lines Shorter and simpler
supply chains also allow firms to hold
less inventory, as restocking becomes
both simpler and quicker if your
suppliers are nearby Ever-increasing natural disasters are also causing companies to think twice about relying
so heavily on a single source or single region for key components
Even for emerging market-based manufacturers, the US is third (after China and India) as a sourcing market
For Western firms, the US narrowly leads China “We’re going in both directions,” says Martin Richenhagen, CEO of AGCO, a global manufacturer
of farm equipment with nearly US$7 billion in revenue in 2010 “We’ve got our China investments, but also in North America we’re going to invest in expanding one of our existing factories
to start manufacturing high horse power (wheel) factories, for the first time in our history.”
An emphasis on new products
A second growth theme is a greater focus on product diversification and innovation This is a significant shift from recent years Existing products will be significantly less important in existing markets, while much greater emphasis is placed on new wares –
in both existing, and new, markets
While cost management remains the top priority, innovation and R&D come
in second This will be a particular priority for US firms, which rank R&D and innovation on a par with cost management AGCO, for example, has dramatically increased R&D investment “We’ve tripled the level of spending, so it’s now close to
3.5 percent of sales,” says
Mr Richenhagen
Luvata is investing in both new products and new markets, establishing factories
in Mexico and Malaysia This helps give
it both geographic and product diversity
“The [market] changes recently have reinforced our strategy of being a global player, in multiple end-business segments It’s been a good risk mitigator for us,” says Mr Kickham “When auto was having the most horrible time known
to mankind, people were still buying MRI scanners and spending on healthcare.”
To support this drive for new products and to lower product development costs, 48 percent of manufacturers are establishing design centers in emerging markets But talent shortages will be
a concern The availability of skilled workers now tops the list of human resource concerns in emerging markets (cited by 36 percent of all respondents) There are differences between emerging and mature markets, however