Cable-operated and self-contained ultrasonic pigsCABLE-OPERATED AND SELF-CONTAINED ULTRASONIC PIGS IN ORDER to establish the integrity of ageing pipelines, intelligent pigging has become
Trang 1Pipeline Pigging Technology
Trang 2Pigging for pipeline integrity analysis
Trang 3Pipeline Pigging Technology
CONCLUSIONS
m technology, as used in the D/S tool, is state-of-the-art for giving the
operator conclusive data about the physical condition and changes of
posi-tion in a pipeline system
1 DOT: DOT Form 7000-1, 01/06/1990
2 DOT: DOT ORRSPAF 7100.1, /F7100.2.
3 D.J Jones, G.S.Kramer, D.N.Gideon and R J.Eiber An analysis ofreportable
incidents/or natural gas transmission and gathering lines, 1970 through
June, 1984
4 DJ Jones andRJ.fiber An analysis ofreportableinciden tsfor natural gas
transmission and gathering lines, June 1984 through 1987.
Trang 4Cable-operated and self-contained ultrasonic pigs
CABLE-OPERATED AND SELF-CONTAINED ULTRASONIC PIGS
IN ORDER to establish the integrity of ageing pipelines, intelligent pigging
has become of increasing interest For several decades, pigs> using magnetic
stray flux were the only tools available for this purpose on the market The
need for more accurate tools was an incentive to develop ultrasonic systems
to measure metal loss
This paper provides an overview of special ultrasonic pigging systems and
methods Conventional cable-operated ultrasonic field-proven tools for
dis-tances up to 2000m are described, as well as those using long glass-fibre cables
up to 6000m in length
Such tools can be propelled either by reversible wheel-driven crawlers, or
by differential pressure, as applied for self-contained intelligent pig
propul-sion Self-contained liquid-propelled intelligent pigs are used for on-stream
inspection of pipelines; a field-tested system (RPIT) to inspect riser pipes is
also described
INTRODUCTION
Long-distance pipelines are often equipped with launch and receive traps
to operate cleaning pigs; most of these traps are long enough also to handle
intelligent pigs Propulsion of such is by the pumped liquid
Short pipelines, most of the time, are not provided with traps; if such lines
are on land, and local excavation is possible, spot checks may be sufficient to
ensure their integrity
For short offshore pipelines, which are often weight-coated with concrete
and buried, inspection from the outside is impractical, and is prohibited by
the costs involved In this case, inspection from the inside seems more
practical; this also can provide information over the full length, and not just
as spot checks A typical example is the off-loading line illustrated in Fig.l
Trang 5Fig.l Layout of the off-loading line and PIT.
These lines are used to connect tankers at some distance from the shore
to an onshore terminal, and are often found at shallow locations or where
extreme tide conditions exist Lengths up to several kilometres are common
Only very few of these off-loading lines have launch and receive traps for
cleaning pigs; such traps are far too short to accommodate intelligent pigs
Moreover, at the offshore end of the off-loading line, there often is a
manifold of reduced diameter, to which the flexible hoses are connected As
a consequence, any inspection vehicle would have to enter from the land and
reverse at the manifold Most intelligent pigs, however, are not reversible, due
to the design of their propulsion cups, and in any case, two-way pumping
facilities do not exist at off-loading line locations
Usually the pumps of the ship are the only pumps available for off-loading
lines, although for loading lines there are of course pumps on the land In that
case, reverse pumping could be considered but, as explained above, most
intelligent pigs are not reversible
A few other considerations directed the solution ultimately chosen by
RTD At the time, in the early 1980s, when the first need to inspect an
off-loading line arose, even the best existing intelligent flux pigs (ultrasonic pigs
did not exist then) were not quantitative enough to justify their offshore
application [ 1 ] Also prohibitive was the fact that flux pigs require a
relatively-high minimum speed to operate properly This relatively-high speed in itself creates a
high risk when the pig, with its large mass, has to be stopped before entering
and damaging the manifold The approximate location of the pig could only
be indicated by the amount of liquid pumped, which is far too inaccurate
Pipeline Pigging Technology
Trang 6Cable-operated and self-contained ultrasonic pigs
Last but not least, the risk of an intelligent pig getting stuck in an off-loading
line was considered too great These lines are often old, sometimes with mitre
bends, dents or other unknown obstructions or features To imagine an
obstacle without a rescue line in what is often a "life line" for a plant or refinery
was alone reason enough for operators not to apply intelligent pigs to
off-loading lines
It is for all the above-mentioned reasons that RTD worked on a solution,
and decided to construct cable-operated ultrasonic pigs In our solution, as
Fig.l shows, we use a motor-driven crawler This self-propelled unit makes
the operation independent of pumping facilities
The umbilical for transmission of signals to and from the inspection
crawler is reinforced for rescue purposes An array of ultrasonic probes is
mounted at the front end of the inspection tool
To deploy the tool, the pipeline has to be opened for several metres to
attach a simple open launch tray; apart from power supply and hoisting
equipment, no other facilities are needed On-line presentation of results and
full control over speed and direction makes the pipeline inspection tool (PIT)
very attractive to pipeline owners
To date, eight successful world-wide applications have proved the viability
of this concept
THE ULTRASONIC STAND-OFF METHOD
The most suitable method of quantifying internal and external corrosion
is the stand-off technique as illustrated in Fig 2 A circular array of transducers
is located at some distance from the inner pipe wall, and the liquid in the pipe,
usually oil or water, acts as the essential acoustic couplant In this way both
the distance from the transducer to the pipe wall as well as the pipe wall
thickness can be measured These readings can be undertaken
simultane-ously, and with an accuracy of far better than 1mm
To obtain a fine grid of data, a small axial sampling interval of a few
millimetres is usually applied, while for circumferential coverage, a large
number of transducers are used; the size of the corrosion pits that can be
detected and quantified will depend on the type and number of transducers
employed
Not only is the stand-off technique as shown in Fig.2 well-suited for the
measurement of internal corrosion (i.e profile), but the array of transducers
is several centimetres away from the pipe, making the tool less vulnerable to
damage This allows'a relatively-simple form of transducer suspension
Trang 7Fig.2 Ultrasonic stand-off method
ULTRASONIC PIPELINE INSPECTION TOOLS
Cable-operated inspection tools
1 The RTD PIT 2000
To inspect almost-straight off-loading pipelines of restricted length, the
cable-controlled pipeline inspection tool (PIT) was introduced Fig.l shows
an overview of the application and the tool itself in more detail At present
with the PIT, a length of up to 2000m of pipeline can be inspected to detect,
locate and quantify depth of internal and external corrosion, and measure the
remaining wall thickness in corroded areas The stand-off method is applied
as illustrated in Fig.2 The PIT applies 24 ultrasonic transducers (see Fig.3),
which can either be distributed freely around the circumference, or densely
staggered, on any sector of a pipe (see Fig.4)
Results are instantly presented, as well as being tape recorded for later
retrieval and analysis The tool is launched and operated from an open pipe
Pipeline Piggina Technology
Trang 8Cable-operated and self-contained ultrasonic pigs
Fig.3 Probes distributed around the pig circumference.
end; all the electronics are installed in a container at the shore, equipped as
a control room, from where the direction and speed of the PIT can be
controlled As the PIT is wheel driven, it does not disturb the internal pipe
condition The tool requires oil or (sea) water in the pipeline
Fig.5 shows the single-body PIT which can negotiate 3D bends for
diameters over 30in; the cable on the reel is shown in the background Fig.6
shows the newest PIT, designed to be suitable for pipelines of 20-in diameter
and over In the background the associated equipment is shown; at the left is
the multi-channel (32) ultrasonic instrument, magnetic tape recorder
(be-low), and the paper-chart recorder and control box are at the top right hand
side To allow passage of 3D bends or mitres, the PIT consists of three
articulated units connected by universal joints; its flexibility is shown in Fig.7
The tools available are suitable for inspection of pipelines with diameters
from 20-48in Until now, they have been successfully applied in North
America, Europe and the Far East for diameters between 26 and 42in To
inspect off-loading pipelines with lengths over 2000m, the tool can be
deployed from both ends; this was done in Italy, where one section of the
pipeline was inspected from the landfall as illustrated in Fig.8, with the second
Trang 9Pipeline Pigging Technology
Fig.4 Probes staggered to provide full-sector coverage.
section being inspected from the sea as shown in Figs 9 and 10 In all cases,
detachable spoolpieces or launch traps were used to deploy the PIT
2 The RTD PIT 6000
In order to inspect long off-loading pipelines in one run, preferably from
the shore, the PIT 6000 has been designed and is under construction Basically
it uses the same design and construction as the PIT 2000, although as it is
almost impossible to increase the length of the 2000-m long conventional
cable, it was decided to replace all the copper signal wires in the "galvanic"
cable by glass-fibre technology Experiments have shown that signal
transmis-sion for distances over 15,000m is feasible
For signal transmission, the new cable consist of only a few glass fibres, and
is reinforced with aramide fibres to provide a tensile strength of 5000kg The
cable, including a low-friction outer coating, has less than half the diameter
Trang 10Cable-operated and self-contained ultrasonic pigs
Fig.5 Single-body 30-in PIT with cable reeL Fig.6 20-in PIT and electronic equipment.
Trang 11Pipeline Pigging Technology
Fig.7 The bend-passing capacity of the 20-in PIT
Fig.8 30-in PIT launch trap at the landfall at Taranto, Italy Note
the cable in the background
Trang 12Fig.9 Subsea FIT deployment.
Cable-operated and self-contained ultrasonic pigs
Trang 13Pipeline Pigging Technology
Fig 10 PIT prior to lowering into the subsea manifold at Taranto.
of the conventional cable, and the same reel as used for the 2000-m
conven-tional cable can store the 6000-m optical cable The reel will be equipped with
optical rotary joints for uninterrupted rotation
The PIT 6000, to be completed in the second half of 1991, will be suitable
for inspecting pipelines from l6in diameter The tool will be capable of
passing both 3D and mitred bends, and the number of ultrasonic probes has
been increased to 32, in order to provide more circumferential coverage
Once the PIT 6000 has been introduced, expensive offshore deployment will
no longer be necessary for pipelines with lengths up to 6000m
Trang 14Cable-operated and self-contained ultrasonic pigs
3 Stripper PIT testing
For relatively-large pipe diameters (at present I6in), wheel-driven
inspec-tion tools such as the various PlTs described are attractive; this technology
cannot be used for small diameters
To propel such tools with cables over long distances, up to 6000m, as well
as through bends, high pulling forces are required which cannot be generated
by small crawlers Therefore, the stripper technique has been developed, as
illustrated in Fig.l 1 The measuring module consists of the ultrasonic
trans-ducers and multiplexer, and thus can be quite small, and standard
compo-nents allow the construction of a transducer module suitable for a 6-in pipe
diameter, which can also pass 10-D bends A study has shown that with some
additional design effort, a 4-in unit can also be built
The transducer module is, as for self-contained pigs, propelled by
differen-tial pressure over its propulsion discs To retrieve the tool, the pressure
difference has to be reversed For proper sealing of the cable at the launch/
retrieve end of the pipe, a special closure head has to be installed in which a
feed-through (e.g stripper) has been provided This stripper contains an
air-pressure controlled flexible seal to provide the proper balance between
sealing and cable friction This technique was successfully applied in a 10-in
Fig 11 The ultrasonic tool using the stripper concept.
Trang 15Pipeline Pigging Technology
Fig 12 The stripper technique being used in the 10-in test loop.
pipeline as shown in Fig 12 The system proved its capabilities over the full
length of the pipe (400m) and several 3D bends (up to 360°)
We assume that the current cable length (2000m) is the only range limit for
this technique when applied in an almost-straight pipeline Probably the
combination of bends and cable length sets the practical limits, and this has
to be investigated further An 8-in tool (see Fig 13) has recently been
completed for a job in 1991 Fig 14 shows this tool, including the motor-driven
winch
Self-contained ultrasonic tools
4 The RTD RPIT
In order to inspect an oil riser on-stream, RTD and Shell mutually decided
to build a fluid-propelled ultrasonic pig using the stand-off method, as shown
in Fig 2; Fig 15 shows the schematic lay-out of the consequent riser-pipe
inspection tool (RPIT) which was built to the following design specifications:
Trang 16Cable-operated and self-contained ultrasonic pigs
Fig 13 8-inch stripper FIT with 2,000m of cable on a
motor-controlled recL Fig 14 8-in stripper PIT with 2,000m of cable on a motor-
controlled reeL
Trang 17Pipeline Pigging Technology
overall length of 16-in tool: 2.45m maximum
weight: less than 200kg
maximum measuring speed: 4m/sec
pressure: 150bar
temperature: 5-60°C
measuring range: 300m (without data reduction)
travelling distance: 100km
wall thickness range: up to 40mm
accuracy of remaining wall
thickness measurement: ± 1 mmcorrosion detection: internal and external
circumferential coverage: 40%
axial measurement interval: 2.5mm
The tool is also capable of passing 3D 90° bends, full-bore T-joints and
valves; 10% symmetric and 15% asymmetric diameter reductions can also be
negotiated TTie system has been designed to provide a field report of results
within 1 hour of retrieval of the tool
In addition, the RPIT is bi-directional; propulsion disc design provides
by-pass of fluid if this is necessary in the unlikely event that the tool becomes
stuck
The RPIT can be started by pressure, time, distance or bench-marker, or
any combination of these options For a delayed start, it travels in a safe and
dormant, energy-saving mode to the section of interest in order either to
measure internal or external corrosion, or both simultaneously
The on-board memory stores all the data collected After retrieval of the
tool, a powerful portable desk-top computer is used to process the data;
Fig 16 shows an example of the results obtained In practice, colours are
applied to enhance and identify thickness ranges Results can also be
pre-sented in numerical, statistical or graphic modes for further data analysis The
16-in RPIT as shown in Fig 17 has been extensively tested and validated[2] in
Shell's 16-in test loop
5 RPIT field tests
The 16-in and 20-in RPIT have been used twice offshore[3] The first
application was a wire-line field test: pending a field test of the 20-in tool, the
opportunity was given to test the 16-in RPIT in open J-tubes on the Dunlin
Alpha platform, located in the northern North Sea New flowlines were to be
pulled through the J-tubes, which were installed several years ago High forces
were anticipated on the J-tubes during the flowline pulling operation, and
therefore a thorough integrity check of the tubes was required