The vantage of population ecotoxicology, the science of contaminants in the biosphere and their effects on populations, was argued to be crucial for predicting extinction risk for popula
Trang 119 Conclusion
To conceive of it with a total apprehension I must for the thousandth time approach it as something totally strange
(Thoreau 1859, cited in Bickman (1999))
19.1 OVERVIEW
This section explored ecotoxicology from the vantage of the population Detail relative to popu-lations was provided to enhance the reader’s differentiation and integration of population-related information This volume also tries to bridge concepts and techniques in the two sections on organis-mal and community ecotoxicology Hopefully, by this initial effort to translate concepts and metrics among hierarchical levels, consilience might gradually emerge as a more central strategic goal of ecotoxicology during the next decades
Let us review for the moment what has been presented in this section The vantage of population ecotoxicology, the science of contaminants in the biosphere and their effects on populations, was argued to be crucial for predicting extinction risk for populations under contaminant exposure Such prediction is a central objective of much environmental legislation With the exception of federal acts focused on human health or endangered species, the intent of key U.S environmental laws is an assurance of species population viability in environments containing toxicants This can be done more directly with population-based concepts and data than with individual-based concepts, models, and information alone Potential contributions to the potential effectiveness of prediction can be found in the subdisciplines of epidemiology, population dynamics, demography, metapopulation biology, life history theory, and population genetics Related concepts and techniques afford effective description and prediction of population consequences
19.2 SOME PARTICULARLY KEY CONCEPTS
19.2.1 EPIDEMIOLOGY
Epidemiology provided a mode of describing toxicant-related disease in populations and quantitat-ively comparing disease in different populations or study groups Models identifying risk factors for individuals within populations were described, including proportional hazard, accelerated failure, and binary logistic regression models Methods were demonstrated with examples of human disease; however, they are easily applied to other species
Results from epidemiological studies also contribute to predicting genetic consequences of expos-ure (i.e., population consequences) as described for mercury-exposed mosquitofish (Chapter 18) Epidemiological studies also allow convenient estimation of mortality rates applied in simple population growth models, demographic life tables, and metapopulation models of exposed populations
Interpretation of epidemiological results is susceptible to logical errors, so evaluation of results has to be done thoughtfully The foundations of causality were quickly reviewed The intent was
to describe common errors so that they might be avoided and, to borrow a phrase from Alan Watts (1968), to cultivate a “wisdom of insecurity” about cause–effect relationships Hill’s aspects of disease association were explored as a specific set of rules commonly used to improve the process
353
Trang 2of identifying disease associations Hill’s rules are not the only ones relevant to ecotoxicology The reader may also want to review those of Fox (1991) and Evans (Evans 1976) Because of the difficulty
in assigning causality, formal Bayesian methods of enhancing belief would be extremely valuable
in epidemiological surveys by ecotoxicologists General references for Bayesian methods include Howson and Urbach (1989), Box and Tiao (1992), Retherford and Choe (1993), and Josephson and Josephson (1996) These methods are useful at all levels of the ecological hierarchy
The possibility of contaminants influencing the infectious disease process in populations was explored briefly The paradigm that toxicants increase the risk of infectious disease by weakening hosts was judged to be less inclusive than the disease triad paradigm (Figure 13.5) Toxicants, as components of the environment in which the host and parasite/pathogen are interacting, can favor either the host or parasite/pathogen Infectious disease may be fostered or discouraged by exposure
to toxicants
19.2.2 SIMPLEMODELS OFPOPULATIONDYNAMICS
Phenomenological models of population dynamics were explored inChapter 14, assuming a homo-geneous distribution of identical individuals They provided important insights despite simplification and the aggregation of information into basic parameters Models allowed a clearer understanding
of contaminant influence on the temporal dynamics of populations than afforded by conven-tional, individual-based methods alone Some population effects noted during ecological risk assessments would be inexplicable or only vaguely explicable without such an understanding Density-independent mortality due to toxicant exposure was added to classic population growth models The possibility of enhanced population productivity (“yield”) as well as reduced productiv-ity was demonstrated with the incorporation of toxicant exposure into models used to predict yield for harvested fish and wildlife populations Methods for estimating population consequences and time for recovering were described based on these basic models
19.2.3 METAPOPULATIONDYNAMICS
The consequences of uneven distribution of individuals in a contaminated environment were explored with metapopulation models The risk of local population extinction or lowered carrying capacity was assessed most accurately with this metapopulation context, a context only now being introduced into ecotoxicology (O’Connor 1996)
It is crucial to understand the source–sink dynamics of the habitat mosaic populated by a species Some poor habitats can contain a number of individuals only if a source habitat is nearby and indi-viduals move among habitats Keystone habitats and corridors for migration among segments of the population become crucial to predicting population consequences of contaminant exposure Accur-ate prediction also depends on knowledge of other important population qualities within a landscape mosaic such as potential propagule rain and rescue effects The metapopulation context also provides explanation for toxicant effects to individuals outside of the contaminated area
19.2.4 THEDEMOGRAPHICAPPROACH
Applying basic demographic techniques, discussion moved beyond phenomenological models to include heterogeneity among individuals Lamentably, much of the lethality and reproductive information currently generated for regulatory purposes—for protecting populations in contam-inated habitats—is not gathered in a manner directly useful in demographic methods Despite the slow evolution of standard methods relative to effectively generating and applying ecotoxicology data to prediction of population consequences, demographic methods are being used with increasing frequency in ecotoxicology Techniques consistent with demographic methods exist for analyzing toxicological data, for example, the survival time and LTRE (Caswell 1996) methods Simple and
Trang 3matrix-based demographic methods were described and means of including stochastic aspects of population projections were discussed
Although applied widely by ecotoxicologists today, the most sensitive stage paradigm was identi-fied as a false paradigm (weakest link incongruity) Predictions relying on demographic metrics such
as elasticity or reproductive value should replace those based on the most sensitive stage paradigm
19.2.5 PHENOGENETICSTHEORY
Although emergent properties may confound predictions, life history theory can link contaminant-related changes in phenotype to population vital rates (Calow and Sibly 1990, Kooijman et al 1989, Sibly 1996, Sibly and Calow 1989) The principle of allocation suggests that an individual with
a specific genetic make-up and living in a particular environment must allocate energy resources
so as to maximize Darwinian fitness Therefore, predictable rules for energy allocation should be identifiable, albeit expressed slightly differently, for individuals within populations Shifts in energy allocation under different environmental conditions produce differences in population vital rates For example, a contaminant may require increased energy expenditure for detoxification and repair
of soma in order for an individual to survive to reproductive age Once arriving at sexual maturity, that individual might have less energy reserve available for reproduction Adjustment in the rate
at which an individual becomes reproductively viable might also occur There could be other life history changes Such effects taken together for all individuals in a population result in changes in vital rates that could result in a change in population vitality or risk of local extinction
Reaction norms define environment-dependent shifts in phenotype (i.e., phenotypic plasticity) Reaction norms can be inflexible in which case phenotype does not change once it is expressed Some reaction norms can change during the life of an individual Reaction norms for life his-tory characteristics allow exploration of toxicant-induced shifts affecting population vital rates (e.g.,Box 16.2)
Polyphenism occurs if an environmental cue triggers expression of one phenotype or another with no intermediate phenotypes being expressed Polyphenisms are directly relevant to assessing effects of endocrine-modifying contaminants on population consequences As an example, exposure
to an endocrine-modifying contaminant could determine the sex of hatchlings that will make up the next generation of a turtle population
Developmental stability is a valuable population-level metric quantifying the ability of individu-als in a population to develop into a narrow range of phenotypes within a particular environment Beyond a certain level of variation, deviations in phenotype expression implies a decrease in fitness
of associated individuals Metrics such as fluctuating asymmetry allow easy detection of changes in developmental stability due to contaminant exposure
19.2.6 POPULATIONGENETICS: STOCHASTICPROCESSES
Population genetics can be affected by toxicant exposure Direct changes to DNA can occur and, unless repaired, these changes lead to the appearance of mutations Stochastic processes determining genetic qualities of populations can also be influenced by contaminants Contaminants can modify the spatial distribution of individuals within the population, effective population size, mutation rate, and migration rate
Several quantitative tools allow assessment of stochastic consequences to population genetics The Hardy–Weinberg principle predicts genotype frequencies if (1) the population is a large, one
of randomly mating individuals, (2) no natural selection is occurring, (3) mutation rates are negli-gible, and (4) migration rates are negligible Deviations from Hardy–Weinberg expectations indicate violation of one or more of these conditions Models of genetic drift as a function of effective pop-ulation size allow prediction of genetic change with toxicant-induced reduction in poppop-ulation size
Trang 4Selander’s D statistics quantify the deficiency of heterozygotes Those deficiencies could be a func-tion of selecfunc-tion, inbreeding, or populafunc-tion structure (e.g., a Wahlund effect) Wright’s F statistics can
provide understanding of the genetic structure of a population potentially comprised of many demes
or having genetic clines Insight about normal genetic structure is necessary for properly interpreting genetic trends seen in field populations Finally, genetic diversity itself is crucial to the long-term viability of species populations Without variation, a population lacks the raw material with which
to adapt to changes in its environment and will eventually disappear when the environment changes
19.2.7 POPULATIONGENETICS: NATURALSELECTION
Natural selection can be another important process occurring in populations exposed to contaminants Natural selection can result in enhanced tolerance, the enhanced ability to cope with toxicants owing
to physiological, biochemical, anatomical, or some other genetically based change in phenotype However, natural selection resulting in enhanced tolerance requires genetic variation in the tolerance trait and populations lacking adequate variability are at higher risk of extinction than those with adequate variability
Viability selection is often the focus of tolerance studies; however, other important selection components can be involved They include male and female sexual selection, meiotic drive in heterozygotes, gametic selection in heterozygotes, and fecundity selection Several selection com-ponents can occur simultaneously, perhaps resulting in balancing one component against another
It is important in predicting consequences of toxicant-driven selection that all selection potential components be assessed carefully
19.3 CONCLUDING REMARKS
Hopefully, this short treatment of population ecotoxicology has been, simultaneously, informative and convincing Several of the key concepts or relationships described here broaden one’s understand-ing of toxicant effects in ecological systems Hopefully, the reader is convinced of the importance
of the population context in scientific and practical ecotoxicology
REFERENCES
Box, G.E.P and Tiao, G.C., Bayesian Inference in Statistical Analysis, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1992 Calow, P and Sibly, R.M., A physiological basis of population processes: Ecotoxicological implications, Funct.
Ecol., 4, 283–288, 1990.
Caswell, H., Demography meets ecotoxicology: Untangling the population level effects of toxic substances,
In Ecotoxicology A Hierarchical Treatment, Newman, M.C and Jagoe, C.H (eds.), CRC Press/Lewis
Publishers, Boca Raton, FL, 1996, pp 255–292
Evans, A.S., Causation and disease: The Henle–Koch postulates revisited, Yale J Biol Med., 49, 175–195,
1976
Fox, G.A., Practical causal inference for ecoepidemiologists, J Toxicol Environ Health, 33, 359–373, 1991 Howson, C and Urbach, P., Scientific Reasoning The Bayesian Approach, Open Court, La Salle, IL, 1989 Josephson, J.R and Josephson, S.G., Abductive Inference Computation, Philosophy, Technology, Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, UK, 1996
Kooijman, S.A.L.M., Van der Hoeven, N., and Van der Werf, D.C., Population consequences of a physiological
model for individuals, Funct Ecol., 3, 325–336, 1989.
O’Connor, R.J., Toward the incorporation of spatiotemporal dynamics into ecotoxicology, In Population
Dynamics in Ecological Space and Time, Rhodes, O.E., Jr., Chesser, R.K., and Smith, M.H (eds.),
The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL, 1996, pp 281–317
Retherford, R.D and Choe, M.K., Statistical Models for Causal Analysis, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1993.
Trang 5Sibly, R.M., Effects of pollutants on individual life histories and population growth rates, In Ecotoxicology.
A Hierarchical Treatment, Newman, M.C and Jagoe, C.H (eds.), CRC Press/Lewis Publishers, Boca
Raton, FL, 1996, pp 197–223
Sibly, R.M and Calow, P., A life-history theory of responses to stress, Biol J Linn Soc., 37, 101–116, 1989 Thoreau, H.D., 1859 Quote from Henry Thoreau on Education, Bickman, M (ed.), Houghton Mifflin Co.,
Boston, MA, 1999
Watts, A.W., The Wisdom of Insecurity, Random House, New York, 1968.