© ISO 2017 Plain bearings — Quality assurance of thin walled half bearings — Design FMEA Paliers lisses — Assurance qualité des demi coussinets minces — AMDE à la conception INTERNATIONAL STANDARD ISO[.]
Trang 1Plain bearings — Qualit y assurance
Paliers lisse s — Assura c q alité de s demi-co ssinet mince s —
AMDE à la co c ption
S con edition
2 17-0
Refer ence n mb r
ISO 1 1 2:2 17(E)
Trang 2COPYRIGHT PROTECTED DOCUMENT
© ISO 2017, P blshed in Sw itz rlan
A ll rig hts r eserved Unles otherw ise spe ified, nopar of this p blc tion ma y be r epr od c d or utilz d otherw ise in an form
or b an me ns, ele tr onic or me hanic l, inclu in p oto opying , or postin on the internet or an intranet , w ithout prior
written permis ion Permis ion c n be req esed from either ISO at the ad r es below or ISO’s member bod y in the c u try of
the r eq eser
ISO c pyrig ht ofic
C de Blan on et 8 • C 4 1
CH-1 14 Vernier, Geneva, Switzerlan
Tel + 12 7 9 011
Fax 412 7 9 0 4
c pyrig ht@iso.or g
www.iso.or g
Trang 3F reword i v
Introduction v
1 Sc ope 1
2 Nor mati ve r eferenc es 1
3 Terms an definitions 1
4 Common potential faiure mo es, efects and causes for half be r ing shels 2
Biblog raphy 7
Trang 4ISO (he Int ernational Org nization for Stan ardization) is a worldwidefede ation of national s an ards
b dies (ISO membe b dies) The work of pr p ring Int ernational Stan ards is normaly car ied out
through ISO t ech ical committ ees Each membe b dy int er st ed in a subje t for w hich a t ech ical
committ ee has be n es a lshed has the right t o be r pr sent ed on that committ ee Int ernational
org nizations, g ove nmental an non-g ove nmental, in laison with ISO, also take part in the work
ISO cola orat es closely with the Int ernational Ele trot ech ical C mmis ion (IEC) on al matt ers of
ele trot ech ical s an ardization
The proc d r s used t o develo this document an those int en ed for it furthe maint enanc ar
desc ibed in the ISO/IEC Dir ctives, Part 1 In p rticular the dife ent a pro al c it eria ne ded for the
dife ent ty es of ISO document should be not ed This document was draft ed in ac ordanc with the
edit orial rules of the ISO/IEC Dir ctives, Part 2 ( e www iso org dir ctives)
A tt ention is drawn t o the p s ibi ity that some of the element of this document ma be the subje t of
p t ent right ISO shal not be held r sponsible for identifying any or al such p t ent right Detais of
any p t ent right identified d ring the develo ment of the document wi be in the Introd ction an / r
on the ISO ls of p t ent de larations r c ived ( e www iso org p t ent )
Any trade name used in this document is information given for the convenienc of use s an does not
cons itut e an en orsement
F or an ex lanation on the v lu tary natur of s an ards, the meaning of ISO spe if ic t erms an
ex r s ions r lat ed t o conformity as es ment, as wel as information a out ISO’ s adhe enc t o the
World Trade Org nization (WTO) principles in the Te hnical Bar ie s t o Trade (TBT) se the folowing
URL: www iso org iso / for word html
This document was pr p r d b Te h ical C mmitt ee ISO/TC 1 3, Plain bearin s , Subcommitt ee SC 5,
Qu lt y a alys i s a d as s ura c e
This se on edition canc ls and r plac s the f irs edition (ISO 1 1 2:1 9 ), w hich has be n t ech icaly
r vised
Trang 5FMEA (Faiur Mode an Efe t Analy sis) is a form of analytical method that helps t o define p t ential
defe t of the designed prod ct an t o el minat e these defe t at the s ag e of designing
FMEA is b sed on combining the ex e ienc g ined in practic in designing an o e ation of plain
bearings with the theory of pro a i ity
FMEA inc eases r la i ity an q alty of the prod ct in q es ion an that of it t echnolo y an also
r d c s the ex enses for t es ing the prod ct an for impro ing the t echnolo ical proc s
Syst ems for the implementation of a Design FMEA ar wel document ed elsew he e an ar out ide
the sco e of this document These sy st ems aid in the analy sis of complex designs, b th exis ing an
proje t ed
Trang 7Plain bearing s — Quality assuranc e ofthin-wal ed half
This document gives guidelnes for the pr paration of a Design FMEA for thin-waled half bearings used
in machine y, e.g int ernal combus ion engines (he Proc s FMEA is the r sponsibi ity of the sup le )
It ls s thecommon p t ential faiur mode(), p t ential efe t (s) an p t ential cause( ) of faiur
The n me ical ev luation of risks in t erms of oc ur enc , seve ity an det ection can be spe if ic t o each
a plcation, man factur r an cust ome
Sinc they ha e t o be as es ed in each case, the n me ical data ar not inclu ed in this document
Gene al guidanc on s atis ical as es ment can be o tained from the r fe enc s
2 Normati ve r eferences
The folowing document ar r fe r d t o in the t ext in such a wa that some or al of their cont ent
cons itut es r q ir ment of this document F or dat ed r fe enc s, only the edition cit ed a ples F or
un at ed r fe enc s, the lat es edition of the r fe enc d document ( inclu ing any amen ment ) a ples
IEC 6 8 2, An lysis te ch iq es fr sys te mre lia i ty — Proce dur fr fiur mode a d e ffec ts a alysis (FMEA)
3 Terms and definitions
F or the purp ses of this document, the t erms an def initions given in IEC 60 1 and the folowing a ply
ISO an IEC maintain t erminolo ical data ases for use in s an ardization at the folowing ad r s es:
— IECEle tro edia: a aia le at ht p:/ www ele tro edia org
— ISO Onlne brow sing plat orm:a ai a le at ht p:/ www iso org o p
3.1
F aiure Mode and Ef ects Analy sis
FMEA
method of r la i ity analy sis int en ed t o identify p t ential faiur s w hich ha e significant conseq enc s
afe ting the sy st em pe formanc in the a plcation conside ed
3.2
Design FMEA
FMEA (3.1) car ied out b designe s w hen develo ing the prod ct
3.3
faiure mode
efe t b w hich a faiur is o se ved in the bearing
3.4
faiure ef ect
conseq enc of a fiur mode (3.3) on the bearing syst em an eq ipment con ition an o e ation
3.5
faiure cause
def iciency or defe t w hich causes a fiur mode (3.3)
Trang 84 Common potential fai ur e modes, efects and causes for half bearing shel s
The conne ting rod and main halfbearing shels of a machine ar only one p rt of an int egrat ed sy st em
inv lving the lubricating oi, the lubrication sy st em, the c ankshaf, the engine block, the con e ting
rodsan the half bearing shel s themselves Even the cy lin e head mat erial, b lt tight ening an cy lin e
head g sket mat erial ha e be n known t o influenc bearing pe formanc Henc , any conside ation of
int ernal combus ion engine bearing design shal inclu e al element of the sy st em not jus the half
bearing shels
Ta le 1 givesa ls of common p t ential bearing faiur modes an the efe t of bearing faiur t og ethe
with p s ible causes of faiur It is rar for faiur s t o be encou t er d uniq ely but rathe they ar
fou d in combination such that the actual initial faiur mode, an henc the causes, ma be diff icult t o
det ermine F aiur modes of the othe bearing syst em comp nent ar not inclu ed
Trang 9Table 1 — Potential faiure modes of half be rings and their ef ects an causes
No
Pot ential fai ur
mode
Pot ential efe t of
fai ur
Pot ential cause of fai ur
Bearing -r lat ed Sy st em-r lat ed
1 F atigue
(se ISO 714 -1:2 0 ,
6.3)
R ed ced b aring
d ra ility an / r
b aring seizure
Contamination of oil by
fatigue de ris
E gine inoperative
Insuf icient b aring
diameter
Insuff icient b aring length
Incor ect material
selection (fatigue
resistance)
Localized overlo ding d e
to presence an location
of b aring fe tures (holes,
gro ves, etc )
Ex ces ive b aring
mat erial thick es
Ex ces ive overlay
thick es
Unsu ported b aring
are s
Incor ect specif ication of
cy lin er pres ures f iring lo d
Oil p mp capacity calculation
Insuff icient efective
journal length
Po r journal g ometry
(ovality,a ial form, lo ing)
Po r housing g ometry
(ovality,lo ing)
Insuff icient housing d namic
stifnes (cir umferential,
radial or a ial)
Ex ces ive oil temperature
an / r insuff icient oil co ling
Be ring sy stem
contaminated by foreign
particles or wear de ris from
other components
2 A ccelerated wear
(Insuff icient oil f ilm
thick es or de ris
contamination)
(se ISO 714 -1:2 0 ,
6.6 an 6.7.1)
R ed ced b aring
d ra ility an / r
b aring seizure
Noise
R ed ction of oil
pres ure
Insuff icient b aring length
Insuf icient b aring
diameter
Incor ect material
selection (wear
resistance,
emb d a ility)
Inap ropriate overlay
thick es (wear
resistance,
emb d a ility)
Po rly locat ed b aring
fe tures (holes, gro ves,
etc )
Inadeq ate oil gro ves
an holes
Incor ect b aring
thick es (inadeq ate
cle rance or ex ces ive
cle rance)
Incor ect b aring
thick es g ometry
(aper, ec entricity, etc )
Incor ect lubricant choice
Incor ect oil ad itive
specif ication
Po r oil an / r oil ad itive
sta ility
Po r lubricant su ply
(inadeq ate oil pres ure or
su ply capacity, driling
diameter t oo smal or
po rly positioned, etc )
A erated or “ po r q ality” oil
su ply (rough dril ings or
sharp b n s in lubrication
system, po r sump b f ling,
po r oil pick u , etc )
Inadeq at e oil f iltration
Insuff icient efective
journal length
Insuff icient journal diameter
Po r journal g ometry
(ovality,a ial form, lo ing)
Po r journal surface
t opo rap y ( f inish, lay, et c.)
Po r engine b lance
Po r housing g ometry
(ovality,lo ing)
Unsu ported b aring are s
Insuff icient oil
t emperature an / r
insuff icient oil co ling
Trang 10Pot ential fai ur
mode
Pot ential efe t of
fai ur
Pot ential cause of fai ur
Bearing -r lat ed Sy st em-r lat ed
Contamination by wear
de ris from other
components
Ex ces ive ing sted de ris
Infreq ent oil an / r oil
f ilter chang intervals
Ex ces ive co lant
contamination
Ex ces ive contamination by
fuel an combustion prod cts
3 Ex ces ive wear an
s uf (over -he ting)
(se ISO 714 -1:2 0 ,
Clause 8)
R ed ced b aring
d ra ility an / r
b aring seizure
Incor ect b aring
thick es (inadeq at e
cle rance or ex ces ive
cle rance, po r b aring
b ck conforma ility with
housing)
Incor ect b aring
thick es g ometry
(aper, ec entricity, etc )
Po rly located b aring
fe tures (holes, gro ves,
etc )
Inadeq ate oil gro ves
an holes
Inadeq ate
cir umferentiallength
(inadeq ate int erference
f it)
Inadeq ate b aring b ck
contact
Incor ect material
selection (conforma ility,
compatibility)
Incor ect difusion b r ier
material
Ex ces ive diferential
ther-mal e pansion b tween
housing an b aring shel s
or housing an shaf (los
of int erference f it)
Incor ect journaldiamet er
(cle rance)
Po r journal g ometry
(ovality, a ialform, lo ing)
Unsuita le journal surface
topo rap y
Incor ect f ilet radius
g ometry
Incor ect housing diamet er
(interference f it)
Po r housing g eometry
(ovality, a ialform, lo ing)
Insuff icient housing
clamping (b lt)lo d
Po r lubricant su ply
(inadeq ate oil pres ure or
su ply capacity, driling
diameter , to smal or po r
-ly positioned, etc )
Ex ces ive oil drain down or
delayed oil su ply
Aerated or “ po r q ality” oil
su ply (rough dril ings or
sharp b n s in lubrif ication
system, po r sump b ff ing,
po r oil pick u , et c.)
Insuff icient “ ru ning -in”
Insuff icient a ial cle rance at
en s of b aring Table 1 (c ontin ed)
Trang 11Pot ential fai ur
mode
Pot ential efe t of
fai ur
Pot ential cause of fai ur
Bearing -r lat ed Sy st em-r lat ed
4 Ex ces ive localized
wear
(se ISO 714 -1:2 0 ,
6.4 an Clause 8)
R ed ced d ra ility
R ed ced oil pres ure
Po rly locat ed b aring
fe tures (holes, gro ves,
etc )
Incor ect b aring
thick es g ometry (a ial
form, ec entricity, etc )
Incor ectly specif ied
int ernal chamfer ( f il et
ride)
Incor ectly specif ied
b aring b re relief
Incor ectly specif ied
locating tang (notch, lug
or nick)
Inadeq ate b aring b ck
contact
Insuff icient blen ing of
c an shaf oil dril ing int o
journal
Incor ect f ilet radius
g ometry
Insuff icient build cle nlines
Po r housing g ometry
(ovality,a ial form, lo ing)
Inadeq at e b aring housing
cap location
Po rly located housing
fe tures (holes, gro ves,et c.)
Insuff icient housing stifnes
(radial an a ial)
Incor ectly positioned
b aring tang pockets in
housing
Po r b aring alignment
(engine block alignment,
con ecting rod straightnes
or twist)
Ex ces ive of-set con ecting
rod lo ding
Po r journal g ometry
(ovality,a ial form, lo ing)
Po r c an shaf main journal
alignment
5 Damag e to the
b aring b ck
(se ISO 714 -1:2 0 ,
7.2 an 7.3)
R ed ced b aring
d ra ility an / r
b aring seizure
Con ecting rod
bre ka e
Inadeq ate
cir umferential length
(int erference f it)
Inadeq ate b aring b ck
contact
Exces ive diferential
thermal e pansion b
-twe n housing an b aring
shel s or housing an shaf
(los of int erference fit)
Incompatible housing
mat erial an b aring b ck
mat erial
Insuff icient housing d namic
stifnes (cir umferential,
radial or a ial)
Insuff icient housing
clamping (b lt)lo d
Incor ect housing diameter
(interference f it)
Unsu ported b aring are s Table 1 (c ontin ed)
Trang 12Pot ential fai ur
mode
Pot ential efe t of
fai ur
Pot ential cause of fai ur
Bearing -r lat ed Sy st em-r lat ed
(se ISO 714 -1:2 0 ,
6.7.2)
R ed ced b aring
d ra ility an / r
b aring seizure
Inc e sed wear an /
or noise
Incor ect material
selection (po r
cor osion resistance)
Incor ect lubricant choice
Incor ect oilad itive
specif ication
Po r oil an / r oil ad itive
sta ility
Ex ces ive oil temperature
an / r insuff icient oil
co ling
Infreq ent oil chang e
intervals
Ex ces ive co lant
contamination
Ex ces ive contamination by
fuel an combustion prod cts
7 Cavitation erosion
(se ISO 714 -1:2 0 ,
6.8 an ISO 714 -2)
Po r cosmetic
ap e rance but not
normaly dama ing
on overlay plated
b arings
Cor osion of substrate
in e treme cases
Localized fatigue
failure in bimetal ic
b arings
R ed ced oil su ply or
pres ure
Subseq ent s oring,
in enting an
em-b dment by removed
lining mat erial
Incor ect b aring
calculation
Inadeq ate oil gro ve
chamfer
Inadeq ate “ ru -n”
gro ves
Ex ces ive cle rance
Incor ect gro ve positions
Inadeq ate gro ve detail
design
Incor ect material
selection
Incor ect lubricant choice
Po r lubricant su ply
(inadeq ate oil pres ure or
su ply capacity, driling
diameter , to smal or po r
-ly positioned, etc )
Aerated or po r “q ality” oil
su ply (rough dril ings or
sharp b n s in lubrication
system, po r sump b f ling,
po r oil pick u , et c.)
Vibration Table 1 (c ontin ed)
Trang 13Bibl og raphy
[1] ISO 7 46-1:2 0 , Plain bearin s — Ap eara c e a d charac te i zation o dama e to metal c
h drody namic bearin s — Part 1: G ene al
[2] ISO 7 46- 2, Plain bearin s — Ap eara c e a d charac te i zation o dama e to metal c h drody namic
bearin s — Part 2 : Cav itatio e os io a d its c ou te meas ur s