DAO TAO TRU'ONG CAN BQ QUAN LY GIA0 DIX THANH PHO HO CHI MINH TIEU LUAN CUOI KHOA LOP BOI DU'ONG CAN BQ QUAN LY TRUYJNG THPT CONG Tit KIEM DINH CHAT LU'ONG GIAO TAI TRUstiNG THPT NGUYEN
Trang 1BO GIRO DIJC VA DAO TAO TRU'ONG CAN BQ QUAN LY GIA0 DIX THANH PHO HO CHI MINH
TIEU LUAN CUOI KHOA LOP BOI DU'ONG CAN BQ QUAN LY TRUYJNG THPT
CONG Tit KIEM DINH CHAT LU'ONG GIAO
TAI TRUstiNG THPT NGUYEN VAN LINH
NAM HOC 2018-2019
Nguiri thur hien: Nguyen Thi Thu Hi Don vi cong tic: Truivng THPT Nguyen Vän Linh
THANH PHO HO CHI MINH — Nam 2018
Trang 2MUC LUC
Trang
I —1„)"( DO CHON DE TAI
II — TINH HINH THVC TE VE CONG TAC KIEM DINH CHAT LliCiNG TAI TRUONG THPT NGUYEN VAN LINH
2.3 Di6"m manh, diem y&t, co hOi, thach thirc 11 2.4 Kinh nghi'e'm thgc to ding Mc kiè'm dinh chat luting gido clittc tai
TTT - KE HOACH HANH DONG THUC HIEN CONG TAC KIEM DINH CHAT LVONG GIAO DVC TAT TRUONG THPT NGUYEN VAN
ü„ )
Trang 3I Lt DO CHQN DE TAI
1.1 Co' phrip
Ngay nay, nang cao chat luting gido due la met ,yett eau khdch quan truerc xu the hei nhap quOc to va cling la yecu to mang tinh guy& dinh dOi voi the ea se gide duc Viet Nam dang trong , thei ki cOng nghiep Ilea, hien dai hea nen rat can ngu6n nhan lure chat luting cao de kip tiled nam bat nhangtien be khoa hoc Id thuat teen the
ON Neu lchOng co nhang bien phap de nang cao chat luting gião due, thi truck hét,cac
co se gido due se khOng theo kip skr pith trien cua xa hei, khOng nhan dugc skr tin nhiem cua cac lye inking xa hei va xa han naa kheing hoan tranh duge muc tieu hien dai hem dat nude Vi vay, muon ton tai va Oat trien, cac ca se gido due phai khOng ngimg van Ong, sang tao, nghien Su, tim ra nhang gidi phap pint hop vei (lac diem cila gido due Viet Nam de ;tang cao hen nfra chat luting gido due va dao tao Nang cao chat luting gido due va ciao tao chinh la nang cao chat luting va trinh de cua ngued lao citing - nhan to quyét dinh moi qua trinh ,san xuat,, cung vadich vu Nhu vay,lam the nap de met quec gia co duos met nen kinh to phat trien ben yang va chit luting hang hOa,dich vu co kha nang canh tranh cao? Cau tra lei nam a chat luting gido due cim quec gia do Cac nghien , cdu cho thay rang kiem dinh chat luting gido due di co lich sir gin met tram nam kiem dinh chat luting gido due a M9 va nhieu quec gia phat trien ten the gied da tit tranh boat deng thueng xuyen, quen thuec va tham chi tre thanh dieu kien ten tai nhieu ea se gido due Kiem dinh chat lam gido due di co nhang dOng gOp het sic quan trong dOi veit viec dam bao va nang cao chat luting gido due va dao tao
O Viet Nam, cac nha quart li gido due bat diu hieu va quan tam tuang ximg veri tam quan trong cua nO Nghi quyet 29 NQ/TW da xac dinh ro muc lieu "Tao chuy'n Nen can ban, manh me ye chat *mg, hieu qua gicio duc, dao tao" Kiern dinh chat
him giao due la met trong cac c8ng Cu quan trong cua viec dam We chat luting, gOp phan nang cao chit luting gido due, tang cueing trach nhiem giai trinh cua ea se giao due vei cac ca quan co tham quyen va ved xa hei ve hieu qua, skr minh bach nguen lure
ma ea se gido due do sir dung de cung ling dich vu gido due
Trong Lust Gide due 2005 lid Luat ,Gido due duce sira ded va 136 sung met so diet' nam 2009, diet' 17 quy dinh: "Viet kiém dinh chat luting gicio duc chivy thus hien dinh IcY trong pham vi ca ntrac va doi vai tang ca set giao duc." Dieu 58 quy dinh
nhiem vu va quyen ban ctia nha tnxeng: "Ttr dankgici chat liming gicio duc va chiu kiem dinh chat Luang giao dye cfca ca quan co them quyen kiem dinh chili Wang giao duc".
De thuc hien viec kiem dinh chat luting gido due, BO Gido due va Dao tao da ban hanh nhieu thOng toquy ,dinh, tieu chuan dOi veri cac loai hinh giao duc nhu , non, tieu hoc, gido due ph thOng, g due dai hoc ThOng to so 42/2012/TT-BGDDT ngay 23 thang 11 nam 2012 dm Be GD&DT quy dinh ye nett chuan clanh gia chat luting giao due va quy trinh, chu 1c3r kiem dinh chit luting giao due co se, gido due phO thOng, co sOr gido due thtneng xuyen
COng van s8 46/KTKDCLGD-KDPT ngay 15 thang 01 nam 2013 clia Cue lad° thi va KDCLGD — Be GD&DT xac dinh yeu au, gni y tim minh chUng theo tieu chuan danh gid chat luting gido due trueng tieu hoc va tnremg thing hoc
Trang 4Sér gido due Ira ciao tao ThAnh phe HO Chi Minh quy dinh cong tic kiem dinh chat him gido due dm the ea se gide due van tieu chi thi duo vi co cong van Inreng din thuc hien cong the KDCLGD vac, dau mei ram hoc "cong the kiem dinh chat twang gicio dyc : 50/100 diem" Nam hoc 2017-2018, cong van so
4091/GDDT-KTKDCLGD ve thuc hien cong tic kiem dinh chat luong gido due nam hoc 2017 ,—
2018 ?Day manh hoot tang dOnh gió ngoai a tat ca cac cap hoc, bi)c hoc Phan dau den het nam hoc 2017 - 2018 ce 43,5% trzremg mom non, 65% truing tieu hoc, 75% twang trung hoc ca six, 39% truang trung hoc phO thOng &toy danh gia ngoai "
Nhu vay, tit nhltng ca sa phdp 19 tren, to nhan thay hien nay ding tic kiem dinh
chat lugng gig.° chic la cap thiet, phdi thuc hien theo yeu eau cua cac nha quan 19 gido chic tir cap Be den cap Se
1.2 Ca sir 1.)5 luem.
Theo ThOng to se 42/2012/TT-BGDDT ngay 23 thing 11 nam 2012 dm BO twang BO Gido due va DAD tao, Kiem dinh chcit luang gicio dyc ca set gitio dyc pha thOng, ca set giao dye thufrng xuyen la hogs` dang danh gia (bao gOm to danh gill va ciónh gia ngoai) de xóc dinh miry da co sa giao dye phO thOng, ca sa giao dye thicang xuyén dap zing cac tieu chutin danh gia chat luang giao dyc va viec cong nhan co six giao dye phO th6ng, co sa giao dyc thuirng xuyen dal` tieu chuan chat luang giao dye clza ca quan quan 1y nha nuac.
Kiem dinh chat lugrig gido due gthp cho cac nha quart li gido due nhin lai toan
130 hoat deng cua nhA train-1g met each co 114 theng de tit do diéu chinh cac hoat deng gido due ciia nha truêrng theo met chuan nye nhat dinh ThOng qua hoat dOng kiem dinh chat lugng Oa° due, bao gem hoat dOng to dinh gia va hoat dOng danh ngodi, lanh dao tnreng THPT se xac dinh dune mix de dap ung cac muc tieu gide due theo cac tieu chuan dânh gia chat luong giao due trong tirng giai doan Két qua kiem dinh chat hum gido due phan , anh chat luong dao tao nha trueng, nh& do lanh dao trueng nam dirge nhitng diem manh, diem yeu cua don vi minh, lam can dr
de xay dung ke hoach etti tier, chat lacing gide due, nang cao chat luong cac hoat deng gido due
Nhu vay, kiem dinh chat lugng gido due nOi chung, kiem dinh chat lugng corser gido due phO thOng nOi rieng IA met giai phap quail 19 chat lugng va hieu qua, nham muc dish:
+ Xac dinh mire de dap Ung muc tieu gido due trong tirng giai doan cua ca se gido due phO thong nham nang cao chat lugng gido due;
+ , Theng bdo cling khai vii cac cc: quan quart 19 nha nuêrc va xa hei thuc trang chat luong gido due;
+, De co quan chirc nang danh gia va ding nhan cu se gido due 06 thong dat tieu chart chat luong gido due
Kiem dinh chat luong gido due tao ra ca the dam bdo chat luong vita linh hoat vita chat the bao gem to dal-1h gia va danh gid ngodi Day la hai hoat &Ong co mei quan
Trang 5he bien chimg yeti nhau, luen co thOng tin phan hei gilla dam bao chat lugng nOi be ya darn bac) chat luting ben ngoai, gaup cho cac tnremg THPT kip that cal tien nhfing diem yeu \id phat huy Mang diem manh
Ket qua Kiem dinh chat luting gido dye cac truing THPT dat hay khOng dat so yeti cac tieu chart quy dinh cim BO Gido dye ya Da° tao se gOp phan dinh huemg cho cac hoat &Ong sau day cila xa 110i:
Git1p hoc sinh va phy huynh lira chon truing de dy tuyen \Tao lOp 10;
Lam co so de cac truerng THPT keu goi dau to tir cac to chfre xa hOi;
Dinh huerng phat trien cho cac tnreing THPT nham tang cuing Wang lye canh trait tren tat ca cac link ytrc ye gra() dye
Quy trinh kiem dinh chat Mang co ser gido dye phO thong dirge thyc hien nhu sau:
Buere 1 Ty danh gid cua co' sa gido dye pho thOng
Buarc 2 Wang Icy kiem dinh chat lugng gido duc cita co ser gido duc pho thOng Buerc 3 Dinh gia ngoai Ira danh gid lai (neu co) co so gido duc phe thOng
Buac 4 COng nhOn co ser gido dyc ph6 thOng dat tieu chuan chat Wong gido dye
va cap giay chirng nhOn kiem dinh chat lugng gido dyc
COng tic kiem dinh chat lugng ca so gido dye tnrang THPT Nguyen Van Linh nam hoc 2018-2019 se dive hien dUng the buck theo quy trinh nay
1.3 Co' se) thyv
Dung tnrem yeu can ena xa hei dot yeti chat lugng gido dyc not chung ya gido duc phO thOng not rieng, cac co sa gido dye phdi timg buck cong be ye chat lugng gido dye cua nha tnrerng
Nam hoc 2016-2017, Ser , gido duc ya dao tao Thanh ph6 HO Chi Minh da trien Ichai dua sting tic kiem dinh chat lugng gido due \Tao cham diem thi dua hang nam-ctia cac dun vi Vai tieu chi nay, rat nhieu truing THPT da khOng dat dirge danh hieu thi dua Dan yi xuat sac, trong dO co tnrang THPT Nguyen Van Linh
Han nfia, trong nhiing nam 119c hoc qua, M nam hoc 2015-2016, nhieu tnrerng THPT dirge thanh lap mai teen dia ban quan 8 ya tan con, lam cho lugng hoc sinh clang IcY vac) truing THPT Nguyen Vän Linh gidm clan theo timg tram , DO id didu ma Ban 1Anh dao nha truing cling nhu thp the sir pham quan tarn ya to tang Gang the tuyen sinh gap kh6 khan an den diem dau , yao dm hoc sinh thap anh huang den chat,lugng gido dye dm nha truing Ngoai ra, so hoc sinh giam cling anh huerng den yiec sap )(CP nhan sir ya thu nhOp dm can be, gide, vien, nhan yien cua nha twang
TrirOc tinh hinh do, Ban lanh dao nha tnrOng nhan dinh, nha taxiing can nang cao yi the, uy tin truerc phu huynh yd,h9c sinh Met trong nhang bien phip him hieu dO
la kiem dinh chat lugng gra() due, de qua dO cOng WO chat lugng gide dye yai xa hei, vat phu huynh Nth hoc sinh Hon an, yao nam hoc 2014-2015, Tnrerng THPT Nguyen Van Linh da thyc hien to danh gid, khau &du tien trong tong the thehoat dOng kiem
Trang 6dinh chat lucrng co se gido duc Ban lanh dao nha tnrOng da tich lily kinh nghiOrn tir cong tic hr danh gid da qua
Vi th6, vii vai tit lanh dao quan 19 dm nha trusting, sau khi theo hoc 16p can b0 quail 19 gido due trung hoc phi thOng, tdi chip 48 tai CONG TAC KIEM DINH CHAT LONG GIAO DUC O TRU'ONG THPT NGUYEN VAN LINH — NAM HOC 2018-2019 nhu la nhan dinh, chuan bi lap ice hoach hanh ding cho nam hoc sau
Trang 7IL T1NH HINH THCC TE Vt CONG TAC KIEM DINH CHAT LLTQNG T3I TRU'ONG THPT NGUYEN VAN LINH
2.1 Gkii thieu khai khit ve truang
Throng Trung hoc pho thOng Nguyen Van Linh ,clugc thanh theo Quyet dinh
so 2836/QD-UBND ngay 01 thing 7 nam 2010 ciia Uy ban Nhan ,dan thanh phO HO Chi Minh, toa lac tat dia chi so 2 dueng 3154, throng Pham The Hien, phtrimg 7, quan
8, thanh phO HO Chi Minh Twang dugc &du to va xay dung co se vat chat moi, khang trang, hien dai ten dien tich 10.071m2 , vai 43 phOng hoc trong do co 6 phOng hoc doge lap dat may didu Ilea, 3 phOng thi nghiem , 1-16a, Sinh, 2 phOng nghe nhin, 2 phOng vi tinh, 1 nha da nang, 1 phOng truyen thOng, nhieu phOng lam viec dm Chi b0, COng doan, Doan thanh niên, giant thi, phOng nghi giao vien nha truing co dti diéu kien de xay dung moi truing gido due lanh manh, hien qua
Trueng bat dau hoat dOng tir tam hoc 2010-2011 vei 16 lop 10, den nay, tam hoc, 2017-2018, toeing da co day de 03 khei lap, v6i se lap la 26 (Kh6i 10; 9 lop, KhOi 11: 9 lop; kh6i 12: 816p) vei tong so hoc sinh 938, trung binh 36 hoc sinh/l6p Tong so dOi ngii can b0, giao vien, nhan vien cua timing la 74, trong do co 3 can
130 quail 1St (01 Hieu toeing, 02 Ph6 hieu toeing), co 57 gião vien Ara 14 nhan vien; 100% gião vien dat chuan vb 12 giao vien dat trinh do that si
TnrOrng co du the t6 chile theo quy dinh, Chi 130 co 19 clang vien, COng doan, Doan Thanh nien COng san HO Chi Minh, HOi chit thap de Tn.rerng co 10 t8 chuyen mon (TO Toan, Ly, Ho& Sinh-Tin-COng nghe, Van, Sir - Giao due cong dawn, Dia, Ti8ng Anh, The due - Gião due QuOc phOng, Van phOng)
Ve quan ly gião duc: Truing Trung hoc ph0 thOng Nguyen Van Linh dal va Bang ding biz& trueng thanh ve moi mat, luOn Man thanh tot chile tang, nhiem vu cfia mink trong quart 1Sr, hoat dOng chuyen mon va gido chic than dien hoc sinh; to chire tot cac phong trio thi dua; thuc hien tOt cac cuOc van dOng cua Wang, NM nu & ve cea nganh gide duc Chat luting giao duc than dien nha truing doge nang len, k8t qukthi tOt nghiep Trung hoc phO th8ng, tSr le hoc sinh do vao cac tnxeng dai hoc, cao clang hang tam doge nang len
Cac to chile, dean the ngay cang doge cling co, kien toan va boat dOng co hieu qua Chi be nha toeing luOn doge Quail iiy Quan 8 danh gia hoan thanh tot nhiem vu nhieu ream lien, nam hoc 20132014; 2014 2015; 2015 2016; 2016 2017; 2017
-2018 COng doan nha truing ,dat danh hieu "Ging doan virng math xudt sac" va doge cong doan Thanh phO tang bang khen, Doan Thanh ni8n COng san Ho Chi Minh lueln phat buy vai trO nth nhiem, lam nOng cot cho moi phong trio, doge cong nhan la Doan truing Yang manh - Xuat sac, doge Trung ucrng Doan tang bang khen, hoat dOng dm Doan truing ngay cang co hieu qua, thew day xay dung tnräng lap "an toan -xanh - sach - dep", gOp phan tich cue trong boat dOng giao due
Cong tic chuyén mOn: luOn doge nha truing xac dinh la nhiem vu trong tam hang dau Hang nam doge dau to thiet bi dap Ong tot cling viec day va hoc; nha toeing
da c6 nhieu bien phap dOng 1)0 tang cao pham chat chinh tri, dao dire nghe nghiep, trinh do chuyen mOn, nghiep vu; tang cao tinh than trach nhiem cea dOi ng0 can b0, gide vien nhan vien; xay dkrng kSr toting, ne neptrong day Ira hoc; day manh doi moi phueng phap day hoc va gide chic, dOi moi ki8m tra danh gia; throng xuy8n thao
Trang 8giang, dg gia; xem day la met trong nhilng bien phap tot de" bei clueing chuy8n men, nghiep vu ren luyen tay nghe cho dei ngii can b0, gide vien, nang can, chfit lugng day hoc Tham gia day du cac dot tap huan, sinh hoat chuyen mon do cap tren to chile;
tham gia day cac hei thi gido an dien dr Nhang ndm qua, nha truing da dat dugc
met so ket qua tuang dOi kha quan trong the hei thi; cac to chuyen mon da to chirc nhieu buei ngoai khoa, hoat dOng kha hieu qua
Vet tinh than "Dan chii, kY cuong, tinh thuang, trach nhiem " va sa quyet tam cao cna toan the del nga can b0, giao vien, Man vien nha truing, quyet tam thuc hien dOng be ,cac gidi phap cot ban, thiet thgc, hieu qua chat h ying day va hoc nha truing de dat &rot ket qua cao horn trong dam hoc bad
2.2 Thiirc trang cling tic kiem dinh chOt luvng a truing Trung hoc phO
Nguyen Van Linh
Thuc hien chi dao cua Ser gido due \Tao dao tao Thanh phe H6 Chi Minh, vet mong muon to xem xet, to kiem tra, de chi ra nhimg diem marsh, diem yeu, deng that
de ra cac ke hoach cal tién chat luong va bien phap de nang cao chat luong gido due cua nha twang, nang cao uy tin vii phu huynh ,va hoc sinh trong quan 8, Ban länh dao nha tnremg quyet tam thuc hien ding tic kiém dinh chat luong gido duc a dam hoc 2014-2015 Tuy nhien qua trinh thuc hien cOng tic kiem dinh chat lugng gido due
khOng dugc nhieu lc& qua Thuc hien dieu 20 Tilting to 42/2012/TT-BGDDT ve quy
trinh kiem dinh chat luong co sec gido duc phO thOng,
Mr& 1: Tu dinh gia di a co sa gido due pho thong
Nam hoc 2014-2015, truing Trung hoc phO then Nguyen Van Linh Nguyen Van Linh da hoan thanh hr dinh gia
MSc 2: Ding 14 kiém dinh chat luong giao due tha co se gido due pho thOng:
Chua thuc hien But 3: Danh gird ngoai co se gido duc pho thong
Chua thuc hien But 4: Ceng nhan co se gido chic phe thong dat tieu chuan chat luong giao due va cap gill}, chimg nhan kiem dinh chat luong gido duc
Chua thuc hien
Ket qua tir dinh Rid da dat
SO linyng va ty 1e cac chi se, dat va kW:Mg dat:
- Chi se dat : 100/108 — 92,59%
- Chi se khOng dat : 08/108 — 7,4%
SO luvng va ty Ie cac tieu chi dat vi khOng (tat:
SO tieu chi dat : 30/36 4 le 83,33%
Se tieu chi khOng dat : 06/36 ty le 16,64%
Can cu theo Muc 2, Chucmg 2, Quy dinh ve tieu chuan dinh gia chat ,luccng giao due va quy trinh, chu kY kiem dinh chat luong gide chic co set giao due phO thOng, co
Trang 9sa gido dgc thuang xuyen ban hanh kem theo ThOng to s6 42/2012/TT-BGDDT ngay 23/11/2012 oh BO Gido duc va Da° tao,TnrOng Dung hQc PhO thong Nguyen Vän Linh tkr dânh gia: ca sa gido due dat cap dO 1.
Trong phan tur rdinh gid ca sa giao dgc ph6 thong, truing THPT Nguyen Van Linh da tien hanh
But 1: Thinh lap HOi tiling tkr dAnh giA.
Diem manh:
Sau khi nghien ciru nhilng van ban huang din, NI Sr cap Ay, ban lanh dao nha truing, Hien truing da ra Quyet dinh so : 10 /QD — TP Warn 2014 de thanh lap Hei dOng tg dinh gia Arai 12 thanh vien (trong dO Hieu tnrerng la Chit tich HOi dOng) Ara de
ra k8 hoach to (Ugh gid
Hei clang to danh gia da huy dOng dugc day rig cdc thanh vien nOng cot cua nha tnremg Chit tich hei dOng da thanh lop cdc nhOm cong tic cu the, phan cOng nhiem vu danh gid met so tieu chuan, tieu chi it rang
Heil demg to danh gid da thgc hien tat nguyen tic lam viec: thao luan, th'Ong nhat, cac guy& dinh chi co hieu lgc khi co it nhat 2/3 thanh vien trong hei dOng nhat tri Diem yew
Cdc thanh vien trong HOi deng tv dinh gia co Mai dai, tup6i nghe tr& nen chin co. kinh nghiem trong cOng tic dugc giao
&rat 2 Xfiy dying ke hoach qr thinh gia.
Diem manh:
Ke hoach to danh gid dugc Chit tich HOi dens to danh gia phé duyet va phat hanh den timg thanh vien cum Wei dOng to danh gia Ke hoach da dugc xay dung rat cu the, chi tiet, trong dO
Xac dinh rO Inge dich va pham vi to danh gia
Phan cong nhiem vu cho timg thanh vien hei thing to danh gid
Dkr kik tap huan nghiep vu to danh gid cho hei d6ng to danh gid NIA can bO, gido vien, nhan vien
Xac dinh thiri gian thgc hien cho timg hoat dOng
A A
Diem yeu:
Ke hoach duce xay dung cu the, chi fiat Tuy nhien, viec tap huan nghi'ep vu danh gid cho hei dOng to danh gia con thgc hien sa sai, chin bO sung, dieu chinh k8 hoach khi can thiét
But 3 Thu that), ly vi phfin tich cic during tin, minh
Diem manh:
Thanh vien hei dOng to danh gia dirge phan cong nhiem vu I-6 rang, cu the, phit
Trang 10hop vai linh vice, cong tac dupe giao nen viec thu thap minh chimg gap nhieu thuan loi
Thdnh vién hei dog to danh gia da so con kha trê nen kha nang ap dung ding nghe thOng tin, tim kiem thOng tin nhanh nhcn
Diem yeu:
Cie minh chting bi that lac nhieu do qua trinh chuyen giao to Hieu tan:51T cu sang Hieu trueng mei (thang 6/2013), cac b0 phan, nhan sg cling thay doi thutmg xuyen (do nghi viec, ‘ chuyen trutmg), cong tac van thu luu tra, he trg giita the b0 phan c6 lien quan nhieu han che
COng viec thu dial) cac minh chUng ton nhieu thai gian, anh hu gng den chat lugng phan tich cac thOng tin minh ch gng ice() theo cong viec ma hea the minh chiing gap nhieu khO khan
Bute 4 Dänh gia mire dO (10 dirge theo trong tieu chi.
Diem manh:
Quy trinh viet va hoan thien phieu danh gia tieu chi dugc thgc hien dUng quy dinh nhu sau:
NhOm hoac ca nhan ghi day al cac nei dung theo quy dinh trong phieu danh gia lieu chi
Bei thing hr danh gia xem xet, thao luan cac nei dung dm timg phieu danh gia tieu chi
NhOm hoac ca nhan hoanthien phieu danh gia lieu chi tren co se 9 kien hei deng
W danh gia va gin thu ki hei citing to danh gia tang hgp
Diem yeu:
, Co nhang phieu ,danh gia ghi day nOi dung, nhung nOi dung con chungchung,
ke hoach cal lien chat lugng chua day chi, thieu cac bien phap, gidi phap, dieu kien -nhan luc, tai chinh, thei gian hohn thanh va tinh kha thi
Birfre 5 Viet bâo cao tkr clAnh gii.
Diem m3nh:
Bao cao to danh gia dugc trinh bay dting theo eau tnic va hinh tithe quy dinh Bao cao co day du cac hen chuan, lieu chi, cac muc nhu mO td hien trang, diem manh, diem yeu,1(8 hoach cai hen chat lugng, to danh gia
Dg thao bao cao dugc lay Y kien grip 9 cila can b0, giao vien, nhan vidn
Diem yeu:
COn sai vdi 181 danh may trong bao cao
Butre 6 COng bo bac, cao tkr dAnh gia.
Diem m3nh: