Contents Foreword ...xv Acknowledgments ...xvii Introduction ...xix Chapter 1 The Events of 9/11 and How They Affect Global Supply Chains ...1 Overview of Issues and Concerns ...1 9/11:
Trang 2Managing Global Supply Chains
Trang 3Ad Hoc Mobile Wireless Networks:
Principles, Protocols and Applications
Subir Kumar Sarkar, T.G Basavaraju and
C Puttamadappa
ISBN 1-4200-6221-2
Computer Fraud: An In-depth Framework for
Detecting and Defending against Insider IT Attacks
Kenneth C Brancik
ISBN 1-4200-4659-4
Design Science Research Methods and
Patterns: Innovating Information and
Alessandro Acquisti, Stefanos Gritzalis, Costas
Lambrinoudakis and Sabrina De Capitani di Vimercati
How to Achieve 27001 Certification: An
Example of Applied Compliance Management
Sigurjon Thor Arnason and Keith D Willett
Managing Global Development Risk
James M Hussey and Steven E Hall
ISBN 1-4200-5520-8
Mobile WiMAX: Toward Broadband Wireless
Metropolitan Area Networks
Yan Zhang and Hsiao-Hwa Chen
ISBN 0-8493-2624-9
Operational Excellence: Using Lean Six Sigma to Translate Customer Value through Global Supply Chain
James William Martin ISBN 1-4200-6250-6
Physical Principles of Wireless Communications
Victor L Granatstein ISBN 0-8493-3259-1
Practical Guide to Project Planning
Ricardo Viana Vargas ISBN 1-4200-4504-0
Principles of Mobile Computing and Communications
Mazliza Othman ISBN 1-4200-6158-5
Programming Languages for Business Problem Solving Price
Shouhong Wang and Hai Wang ISBN 1-4200-6264-6
Retail Supply Chain Management
James B Ayers and Mary Ann Odegaard ISBN 0-8493-9052-4
Security in Wireless Mesh Networks
Yan Zhang, Jun Zheng and Honglin Hu ISBN 0-8493-8250-5
Service-Oriented Architecture: SOA Strategy, Methodology, and Technology
James P Lawler and H Howell-Barber ISBN 1-4200-4500-8
The Strategic Project Leader: Mastering Service-Based Project Leadership
Jack Ferraro ISBN 0-8493-8794-9
Simplified TRIZ: New Problem Solving Applications for Engineers and Manufacturing Professionals, Second Edition
Kalevi Rantanen and Ellen Domb ISBN 1-4200-6273-5
Value-Added Services for Next Generation Networks
Thierry Van de Velde ISBN 0-8493-7318-2
WiMAX: A Wireless Technology Revolution
G.S.V Radha Krishna Rao and G Radhamani ISBN 0-8493-7059-0
Trang 4New York London
Managing Global
Supply Chains
THOMAS A COOK Compliance, Security, and Dealing with Terrorism
Trang 5Boca Raton, FL 33487-2742
© 2008 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Auerbach is an imprint of Taylor & Francis Group, an Informa business
No claim to original U.S Government works
Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
International Standard Book Number-13: 978-1-4200-6456-8 (Hardcover)
This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources
Reason-able efforts have been made to publish reliReason-able data and information, but the author and publisher
cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or the consequences of their use The
Authors and Publishers have attempted to trace the copyright holders of all material reproduced
in this publication and apologize to copyright holders if permission to publish in this form has not
been obtained If any copyright material has not been acknowledged please write and let us know so
we may rectify in any future reprint
Except as permitted under U.S Copyright Law, no part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced,
transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or
hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information
storage or retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers.
For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, please access www.
copyright.com (http://www.copyright.com/) or contact the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc (CCC)
222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400 CCC is a not-for-profit organization that
provides licenses and registration for a variety of users For organizations that have been granted a
photocopy license by the CCC, a separate system of payment has been arranged.
Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and
are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Cook, Thomas A., Managing global supply chains : compliance, security, and dealing with terrorism / Thomas A Cook.
1953-p cm.
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN 978-1-4200-6456-8 (hardback : alk paper)
1 Business logistics Safety regulations 2 Freight and freightage Security measures 3 Shipping Security measures 4 Terrorism Prevention 5
Exports Management 6 Imports Management I Title
Trang 6The World Trade Center and the United States are attacked on 11 September 2001
in New York City The photograph below shows the attack on the Pentagon These
events have changed global supply chains forever This book becomes the best
navi-gation tool for supply chain executives to utilize in managing their import/export
responsibilities
Trang 8To the heroes of 9/11 and all those who continue to be placed
in harm’s way to reduce our threat of terrorism
Trang 10Contents
Foreword xv
Acknowledgments xvii
Introduction xix
Chapter 1 The Events of 9/11 and How They Affect Global Supply Chains 1
Overview of Issues and Concerns 1
9/11: How Were Supply Lines Affected? 2
It Cost More to Ship 3
More Attention Had to Be Paid to Documentation and Logistics Detail 3
Regulations Changed, Making It More Cumbersome to Import and Export 4
Corporations Had to Modify Their Supply Lines 4
Purchasing and Selling Decisions Were Altered 4
Carriers’ Futures Were Uncertain 5
Increase in Potential Fines and Penalties 6
An Entirely New Corporate Responsibility Was Created in Security and Compliance 6
The Mind-Set of the United States Government 7
The Big Picture 8
The Risks of Global Trade: Now, Add Compliance and Security 11
The Security Concern in Our Transportation Infrastructure 13
Operation Safe Commerce (OSC) 14
Free and Secure Trade (FAST) 15
What Is the FAST Program? 15
What Are the Benefits of the FAST Program? 15
Who Is Eligible to Apply? 16
Where Is FAST Available? 16
Trang 11Chapter 2 Compliance and Security: Import Supply Chains 19
Protecting our Borders Against Terrorism 20
CBP’s “Twin Goals”: Anti-Terrorism and Facilitating Legitimate Trade and Travel 21
Better Targeting 21
Pushing Our “Zone of Security” Outward 22
Partnering with Other Countries 22
Partnering with the Private Sector (C-TPAT) 23
Inspection Technology and Equipment 23
Keeping Weapons and Money from Falling into Terrorist Hands: Outbound Inspections 24
Protecting the Miles of Open Border Between Official Ports of Entry 24
Basic Import Management 25
Classification 25
Valuation 26
Origin Markings 26
Record Keeping 27
Importers 27
Customs Brokers 28
Records Storage Methods 28
Customs Initiatives Since 9/11 29
Highlights of CBP’s Accomplishments 29
Strengthening Our Control of U.S Borders 29
Improving Selectivity, Screening, and Targeting 30
Private, Public Sector, and International Partnerships 30
Importer Self Assessment (ISA) 32
Food and Drug Administration (FDA) (Imports) 33
New (Interim) Final Rules Require Registration of Facilities, Prior Notice Filing for Food Shipments 34
Automated Commercial Environment (ACE) 35
Managing Inbound Supply Chains: Purchasing Control 37
Chapter 3 Export Supply Chains 39
Department of Commerce Census Bureau 40
Department of Commerce Bureau of Industry and Security 42
USPPI 42
Export Licensing 42
Denied Parties Screening 45
Deemed Exports 46
Anti-Boycott Compliance 47
Department of Treasury Office of Foreign Asset Controls 48
Department of State 51
Trang 12Contents ◾ xi
Implementing a Successful Export Compliance Program 52
Designating Responsibility 52
Senior Management Support 53
Developing Standard Operating Procedures 53
Best Practices 54
Internal Assessment 54
Chapter 4 Developing a Compliance and Security Management Program 57
Analysis of Risks 57
Obtaining Senior Management Involvement 59
Forming a Committee Structure 60
Creating Standard Operating Procedures 60
Infrastructure and Communication Systems 60
Resource Development 61
Risk Management Attitude 65
Disaster and Contingency Planning 65
Self-Assessment 66
Chapter 5 Managing Vendors, Suppliers, Freight Forwarders, Customhouse Brokers, and Service Providers for Compliance and Security Issues 67
Overview of Global Service Providers 67
Customhouse Brokers and Freight Forwarders 69
Specific Compliance and Security Reference Points for Forwarders and Brokers 70
Carriers: Air, Ocean, Truck, and Rail 70
Warehouses and Consolidation/De-Consolidation Facilities 72
Selling Distributors and Agents in Export 72
Purchasing Distributors and Agents in Import 73
Third-Party Providers 74
Banks and Other Finance Houses 74
Miscellaneous Companies and Services 75
Cost-Effective Logistics 78
Chapter 6 Critical Issues in Compliance and Security 93
Sarbanes–Oxley and the Interface with Global Supply Chain Management 93
DOT Hazardous Material Regulations (49 CFR 100-179) 98
Purpose 98
Overview 98
Shipping Papers 99
Marking and Labeling 100
Labeling 100
Trang 13Placarding 101
Segregation of Hazardous Materials 102
Packaging 102
Selection of Proper Packaging 102
Employee Training 103
Materials of Trade 104
Managing Hazardous Materials Transportation as Part of Compliance in Global Supply Chains 104
Facility Security Checklist 105
Security Checklist for Shipper 106
Carrier Safety Assessment 106
Employee Background Check Guidelines 107
International Port Security Program 107
The SAFE Port Act 109
Technology Issues In Compliance and Security 111
Department of Homeland Security (DHS): “Best Practices for Container Seals” 111
Plan to Require Container Seals Motivates Adoption of 13 Cargo Security Best Practices 111
Standards and Deadline to Come 112
Getting Ahead of the Curve 112
Best Practices Outlined 113
Radio Frequency Identification (RFID): Smart and Secure 115
SST Phase I Results 117
SST Phase II Objectives 117
SST Phase II Benefits 118
SST Phase II Deliverables 120
Required Shipper’s Resources 120
Supply Chain Benefits 121
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act 121
Food and Drug Administration/Environmental Protection Agency Propose Security Restrictions 122
Food and Drug Administration 123
Environmental Protection Agency 123
Ultimate Consignee 125
INCO Terms 128
Use of the Term “Ex Works” by Parties in International Contracts and Purchase Agreements 128
Routed Export Transactions under the July 10, 2000, Federal Register Notice 129
Responsibilities of Parties in a Routed Export Transaction 130
Trang 14Contents ◾ xiii
Record Keeping: A Vital Issue 132
Transfer Pricing: A Serious and Potentially Costly Compliance Issue 133
IRS, CBP, SEC, and DOJ Involvement? 133
What Business Travelers Need to Know 134
Container Security Update 2007 137
Customs-Trade Partnership Against Terrorism 137
Security Requirements for Validation of Participants 138
Business Partner Requirements 139
Security Procedures 139
Security Training and Threat Awareness 147
Information and Technology Security 147
CBP Proposal for Advance Trade Data Elements 148
Background 148
Security Filing: Proposed Data Requirements 150
Vessel Stow Plan: Container Status Messages 151
Security Filing: Responsible Parties 152
Notes 153
Annex A: Proposed Data Definitions 153
Annex B: Data Elements Comparison 155
Customs Bonds 156
Parties to a Bond 156
Types of Bonds 156
Amounts of Bonds 156
Continuous Bond 156
Breach of Bond 157
Chapter 7 Ten Steps to a Secure and Compliant Supply Chain 159
Acknowledge the Issues 160
Identify the Point Person 161
Obtain Senior Management Authorization 161
Develop an Initial Execution Strategy 162
Obtain External Resources and Support 162
Develop a Compliance and Security Committee 163
Complete a Facilities Review 164
Prioritize the Issues Finalize an Action Plan Implement the Program .165
Training and Education 165
Self-Audit 168
Concluding Remarks 171
The Challenges of Compliance and Security in our Global Supply Chains 171
Trang 15Appendix 173
Legislation Related to the Attack of September 11, 2001 173
Bills and Joint Resolutions Signed into Law 173
Other Resolutions Approved 174
Legislation with Floor Action 176
New Government Cargo Security Rules Call on Forwarders to Work with Agents on Securing the Supply Chain 181
General Aviation Security: Increased Federal Oversight Is Needed, but Continued Partnership with the Private Sector Is Critical to Long-Term Success, GAO-05-144, November 10, 2004 181 Key Acronyms 182
Glossary 185
Index 193
Trang 16Foreword
I was totally engaged and focused while reading this book I intended to read one
chapter each night over a week or so I ended up reading it all in one night I found
it to be completely intriguing and encapsulating
Tom, who was directly affected by the 9/11 attack, lays out the most detailed
and comprehensive overview of all the issues facing supply chain executives, and
goes on to review all the compliance and security rules, regulations, and
govern-ment initiatives that anyone who is involved in importing, exporting, and domestic
transportation needs to know He then provides a very in-depth analysis of logistics,
operations, purchasing, and international sales management problems that have
been created since 9/11 This is followed up by hands-on, cost-effective strategies
and solutions, and a cost-effective outline of how to develop a working compliance
and security program integrated into your supply chain
I was totally impressed with Tom’s ability to grasp all the issues, provide
com-mon sense resolutions, and keep it interesting and well articulated I have had this
book for six months now and continue to utilize it as my desk reference on all
compliance and security issues
I have read many of Tom’s books, which have all had my advocacy, but this
one is by far the best This is a must-read for every import/export manager and for
personnel engaged in supply chain process
Neil Lenok
PresidentThe World Academy
Trang 20Introduction
The events of 9/11 changed my life
for-ever They changed the world of global
trade, too At no time in history did
such a small focused act of terrorism
have such a huge effect on the people of
the world and how they conduct
busi-ness with one another
The supply chains of the world have
been forever altered Any person or
corporation who imports, exports, or
transports goods and services within,
to, or from the United States has had to
rethink how they manage the logistics,
documentary concerns, and regulatory
maze And a new vocabulary of words
and acronyms has developed: AES,
CSI, 24-Hour Manifest Rule, USPPI,
ACE, The Patriot Act, ISPS, and ISA, to name a few
This book sorts out all the issues and frames a comprehensive strategy for the
supply chain executive in successfully dealing with all the compliance and security
changes post 9/11
In this book I have made an attempt to provide a current and single source
composite of the world of compliance and security from a supply chain manager’s
perspective A comprehensive guide that outlines issues, problems, and changes in
rules and regulations in a logical format, this guide is easy to read without
“lega-lese” and the overcomplexities created by recent government intervention
The world of import, export, and domestic transportation now engages
a realism that includes compliance and security as a main staple of traffic,
purchasing, and operations management. The truly successful global company
has wrapped itself in new initiatives that deal with the new order of terrorism that
Trang 21threatens global supply chains and how best to maintain competitive advantage
while thwarting serious threats
At the end of the day the supply chain executive has to spend his or her time
with efficiency This book provides the executive with an end-all, one-stop resource
It is comprehensive, hands-on, and full of quality advice and counsel One of the
most important benefits is it instructs the reader on how to implement a
compli-ance and security program, which currently every corporation is being forced to
accomplish, if it is to maintain competitive global supply chains
Trang 22Chapter 1
The Events of 9/11
and How They Affect
Global Supply Chains
This chapter reviews the events of 9/11 and how supply chains involved in
global trade have ramifications in cost, regulation, and logistics
infrastruc-ture The chapter becomes the “eye opener” for management to take security
and compliance more seriously.
Overview of Issues and Concerns
On September 11, 2001, the world was engaged in trade Supply lines were for the
most part open and running smoothly The big issue for supply chain executives
was establishing cost-effective purchasing, logistics, and operations Disruption
from a terrorist threat was not a proactive thought
No one in global trade anticipated the 9/11 events No “contingency planning”
or “disaster programs” were thought out prior to that occurrence Such plans would
have offered a “safe harbor” recourse or plan of action to mitigate the chain of
occurrences that would follow and continue to disrupt global supply chains to this
very day
It is amazing to me and my associates that, in the aftermath, a vast majority of
firms involved in import, export, and domestic trade and transportation have done
Trang 23very little in disaster planning or paying attention to the new regulatory concerns
that have and will affect their ability to manage supply chains
9/11: How Were Supply Lines Affected?
When the world realized what was happening in New York City at the World Trade
Center, over Pennsylvania, and at the Pentagon, it was just after 9:00 a.m Shock,
disbelief, and rage combined with fear were everyone’s original sentiments
The U.S government took action shortly thereafter, shutting down areas of
New York and Washington Air traffic was brought to a halt Within an hour there
were no commercial planes in the air Inbound air traffic was stopped, diverted, or
halted Truck transportation in certain areas was curtailed Vessels coming in and
out of U.S ports were restricted as to what they could do People moving in and out
of the United States were put on hold Basically everything in motion or in transit
was brought to a halt
International business was now at a standstill.
In the ensuing hours, days, and weeks, the situation was assessed, trade was
re-established, and transportation corridors and lanes were re-opened Some supply
chains re-opened in a few days, others a few weeks Some never opened again or,
when they did, they were forever altered Every import and export company was
affected Time frames, processes, documentation, or regulatory concerns impeded
transportation infrastructures There was no more doing business as usual The
Figure 1.1 The World Trade Center Building of the United States are under
attack on 09/11/2001 from foreign terrorists.
Trang 24The Events of 9/11 and How They Affect Global Supply Chains ◾ 3
Purchasing and selling decisions were altered
It Cost More to Ship
Carriers were requested and mandated to improve security Most passed the cost
on to the shippers Fees from $25 to as much as 5 percent per shipment were added
to freight bills These charges were added in the name of security surcharges and
excess handling fees all associated with the new regulatory atmosphere between
carriers and the government Let it be known that while most of the fees were very
legitimate, many were bogus or the amount much too high and became a windfall
for the carrier In any event international and domestic shipping cost more
More Attention Had to Be Paid to
Documentation and Logistics Detail
For the individual traveling businessperson, there were now layers of
documenta-tion required to enter and depart the United States Any executive who traveled
internationally had to spend at least one to two additional hours going through
security at certain airports As we approach 2008, it is still very difficult to travel
internationally Domestic travel too is not easy, but it is tolerable
Freight coming to and from the United States has undergone new
documen-tary procedures before being allowed to transit This is covered in greater detail in
Chapters 2 and 3
Figure 1.2 Customs Border and Protection inspects inbound ocean freight
containers with x-ray technology screening.
Trang 25One example of the government’s response was the 24 Hour Manifest Rule,
which is covered in more detail in Chapter 2 This United States regulation requires
carriers to transfer detailed manifests to U.S Customs and Border Protection on
inbound ocean freight 24 hours prior to the vessel sailing from the foreign port The
new 24 Hour Rule has placed very tight communication and information transfer
responsibilities on the overseas supplier, the inbound carrier, and the importer here
in the United States
Regulations Changed, Making It More
Cumbersome to Import and Export
The new focus on Deemed Export Rules, as an example, covered in greater detail
in Chapter 3, certainly made it more difficult for both importers and exporters to
transfer information, knowledge, and wherewithal to foreign nationals The deemed
export regulations are cumbersome controls that redefine exports to include the
transfer of information to foreign nationals to be handled as if it were a physical
export So if a corporation brought a foreign national from an overseas subsidiary
plant to train in the United States, the U.S corporation would have to determine
the “export readiness” of that learning process before it could be done The nature
of the knowledge transfer, the specific individual, and the country of utilization,
along with the end use of the information, would all have to be taken into
consid-eration, before the training could begin, if at all
Corporations Had to Modify Their Supply Lines
Many importers and exporters had to modify their supply lines Infrastructure,
choice of providers or carriers, third-party partners, modes of transit, packing,
mark-ing, and labeling all became issues of change for logistics executives post 9/11
As mentioned before, the 24 Hour Manifest Rule required importers who utilized
ocean freight modes to make sure their suppliers provided detailed cargo manifests
to carriers prior to export Many overseas suppliers, to this day, struggle to meet that
requirement and are forced to find other modes such as air and ground These modes
might prove to be more expensive, adding cost to their landed calculations
The increased threat of terrorism caused shippers of hazardous materials to raise
the bar of due diligence in how their goods were packed, marked, and shipped This
added inconvenience, cost, and retraining of personnel and operational procedures
Purchasing and Selling Decisions Were Altered
When overseas suppliers refused to cooperate with certain CBP initiatives such as
C-TPAT, CSI, and the 24 Hour Manifest Ruling, purchasing managers often had
Trang 26The Events of 9/11 and How They Affect Global Supply Chains ◾ 5
no choice but to find more willing and cooperative contract manufacturers and
suppliers
Many U.S exporters who chose not to exercise greater due diligence on
reviewing Denied Parties Lists or paying attention to the OFAC Sanctions List
(both covered in more details in Chapter 3) found themselves in trouble with
fines, penalties, and loss of export privileges.
Carriers’ Futures Were Uncertain
As air travel became restricted immediately following 9/11, the airline industry
took a big hit Some airlines such as United, Delta, and U.S Airways have not been
able to recover; others such as Continental and American have had to institute
major cutbacks
All of the air carriers have reduced service parameters, cut the number of
planes, and stopped flying certain routes This has had a tremendous impact and
effect on shippers in reduced capacity and loss of certain trade-lane competitive
pricing options
The economy took a hit from 9/11 Many transportation providers were
affected: they merged, were bought out, or went out of business The landscape of
trucking companies, third-party providers, and freight forwarders dramatically
changed (e.g., Tower Group, Fritz, Con-Way, CF Freight, Roadway Global, and
Menlo) Traffic managers now had to pay attention much more closely to whom
they were purchasing logistics services from It became as much an “art” as a
“sci-ence.” The due diligence of purchasing became much more intense
Figure 1.3 The CSI program places U.S Customs’ offices in foreign ports.
Trang 27Increase in Potential Fines and Penalties
There are no specific statistics for the volume of fines and penalties that we can
identify, but in direct communication with mid- to senior-level government
offi-cials and in-depth search of the Web site, we were able to determine:
Dramatic increases in several government agencies’ scrutiny of supply chains
We were made aware that many carriers, including the integrated
mega-carri-ers, were being fined regularly for violations such as but not limited to hazardous
material movements, Customs failures, and improper filing of SED information
Shippers found themselves under increased scrutiny for an array of subjects that
led to direct fines and penalties Fines ranged from a “slap on the wrist” to more
than $25,000 Loss of import and export privileges can have even greater effects on
supply chains
Additional consequences of this scrutiny are internal costs in time and
per-sonnel involvement, mandated infrastructure changes, and legal costs Some cases
have even included criminal prosecution of corporate executives A sampling of
some of these cases can be found in the Appendix
An Entirely New Corporate Responsibility Was
Created in Security and Compliance
When I graduated from the Maritime Academy, I served in the military and
eventually came to the world of business and global trade in the late 1970s, just
as OSHA regulations were beginning to dominate corporate cultures
Corpora-tions were now forced to comply with government regulaCorpora-tions on workplace,
personnel, and work environment scenarios or face serious fines, penalties,
man-dates, and possible shut down Eventually every corporation had to create a new
management position: the OSHA Compliance Officer Today, it is a stalwart of
corporate infrastructure
Currently, we are in the same situation in managing import and export
com-pliance Corporations are not sure what to do with the new regulatory
environ-ment in import and export supply chains Do we ignore the current atmosphere
and react only to mandatory issues? Do we become proactive and take
signifi-cant initiatives in compliance and security? Do we take a moderate position and
only do what is necessary now, leaving some contingency planning for future
mandates?
Trang 28The Events of 9/11 and How They Affect Global Supply Chains ◾ 7
This is a perplexing problem with an easy answer The best response is a
methodic, proactive strategy that tackles the more immediate issues, CSI, 24
Hour Manifest, Denied Parties List, USPPI, etc., and plans a program over an
18- to 24-month response to all the longer term issues facing the supply chain
in compliance and security (C-TPAT, creation of SOPs, training of operations
personnel, etc.) This strategy incorporates a new position and, if not an
“inde-pendent” job, then certainly another “hat” for someone to wear: Import/Export
Compliance Officer
The Mind-Set of the United States Government
Atno point can I possibly make that statement that I speak for the government of
the United States and more specifically any of the various departments and
agen-cies involved with terrorism or homeland security/compliance Nor can I make an
absolute representation of what the government is thinking Why?
1 The events of 9/11 have set a chain of events in motion that still is a “work
in progress.”
2 As the political landscape changes, so do compliance and security issues
3 Various government agencies such as the Departments of Commerce, State,
and Treasury are taking a different approach to terrorism Although the
“ulti-mate goals” may be similar, their approaches can be very different
4 Different individuals in “power positions” are interpreting laws, regulations,
and initiatives differently
Figure 1.4
Trang 29What I can do is offer an intelligent, informed opinion of what the government is
thinking, as a result of significant analysis and in-depth review of Web sites, media,
presentations, and contacts with various personnel “in the know.”
The Big Picture
The government felt very naked, vulnerable, and exposed as the result of the
terror-ism of 9/11 All areas of government purview were now under scrutiny:
How was our intelligence gathering mechanism working?
More questions, then answers The government had both immediate, intermediate,
and long-term issues to deal with Some of the critical issues:
Ensure 9/11 does not happen again
impact our interests overseas
Improve government interagency coordination and cooperation
◾
Reorganize the government to deal with terrorist issues effectively
◾
So what is the government thinking, and how does it affect my supply chain?
The government believes the following:
Figure 1.5 The DOJ prosecutes compliance claims in Federal Courts.
Trang 30The Events of 9/11 and How They Affect Global Supply Chains ◾ 9
The borders had to be better secured from persons and cargoes
lutely necessary, but would improve opportunities for success
The mind-set of the government followed these thoughts that ultimately led to
actions, laws, regulations, reorganization, and military action Just to name some
that had an effect on global supply chains:
USA Patriot Act
Trang 31Automated Targeting System (ATS) and Automated Export System (AES)
◾
used to assess cargo
Student and Exchange Visitor System (SEVIS)
These acts, changes, and new directional headings can be summarized as follows:
The U.S government is going to be proactive in fighting terrorism at the
◾
source and not wait for it to hit our shores
Individuals and corporate America will be enlisted in providing various levels
◾
of cooperation in these new initiatives
Additionally, individuals and corporate America will trade off and
compro-◾
mise certain liberties, freedoms, and privileges in this effort
The government will enforce very strict guidelines on receiving prior
infor-◾
mation on inbound freight and people
This book examines in great detail all the new regulations, laws, and procedures
that affect supply chains and, more importantly, how one needs to manage the
import and export business with the least amount of disruption
The U.S government agencies that are peripherally involved in compliance and
security and their user-friendly Web sites are listed in Table 1.1
Table 1.1 Government Websites
California Intelligence and Terrorism Alert
Network
http://www.catitan.org/
Infragard: Guarding the Nation’s Infrastructure http://www.infragard.net/
International Association of Chiefs of Police http://www.theiacp.org/
Internet Fraud Complaint Center http://www.ifccfbi.gov/index.asp
National Center for Missing and Exploited
Children
http://www.missingkids.com/
National Executive Institute Associates, Major
Cities Chiefs’ Association & Major County
Sheriffs’ Association
http://www.neiassociates.org/
Trang 32The Events of 9/11 and How They Affect Global Supply Chains ◾ 11
Regional Computer Forensic Laboratory,
National Program Office
http://www.rcfl.gov/
Texas Coastal Region Advisory System http://www.tcras.org/
The Risks of Global Trade: Now, Add
Compliance and Security
There has always been a certain amount of risk in buying and selling in foreign
markets Risks can be classified as follows:
Dealing with foreign cultures
Trang 33The key to successful global trade has always been to mitigate these risks and
exposures One can rarely eliminate the risks; but one can make sure that everything
is being done proactively to ensure the opportunity for occurrence is significantly
diminished and, if these risks should occur, there has been a risk management
ini-tiative put in place to limit disruption to the supply chain
The risks and exposures in global trade are too vast and too opportunistic for
any one individual or company to secure a 100-percent effective loss control
pro-gram There are too many potential exposures and risks over which we can only
exercise “influence” and have little control
The most successful global enterprises have learned a three-step process in
eval-uating risks in their supply chains and then developing cost-effective initiatives to
manage them The three steps are covered in Chapter 4: risk assessment, setting up
personnel who are responsible and accountable, and then developing a risk
manage-ment action plan Personnel who are held accountable and responsible develop
the “skill sets” of global trade. They become experts, professionals in:
Evaluating risk and exposure
finance and insurance
Mastering technology solutions
◾
Choosing the right providers for banking, accounting, logistics, legal, consulting
◾
Although all these skill sets hold water in today’s global markets, the events
of 9/11 have created a new “skill set” necessary for achieving supply chain
excel-lence: compliance and security management, learning how the new regulations
specifically affect your import or export supply lines, and developing capabilities to
mitigate their effects and structuring initiatives to afford the best opportunities for
maintaining competitive advantage
So what we are saying is that all the old skill set requirements have been
main-tained and a new one has been added Either the company hires an experienced
individual to tackle these responsibilities or it trains existing personnel Either the
company creates this new skill as its own independent position or it places the
burden on an individual as another “hat” to wear It really depends upon the
vol-ume of global trade, the intricacies and complexities of the supply chain, and the
overall commitment of senior management to determine which is the best option
to exercise Either way a company goes, the real point here is to acknowledge that
compliance and security is a necessary “skill set” that the company must acquire if
it is to tackle post 9/11 issues seriously
Trang 34The Events of 9/11 and How They Affect Global Supply Chains ◾ 13
The Security Concern in Our
Transportation Infrastructure
With all the concern about safety and security, it is time to ask just how safe
trans-portation and logistics truly are these days That’s exactly what consulting firm
Deloitte Services (www.deloitte.com) undertook when it hired the U.S Chamber of
Commerce’s Statistics and Research Center (www.uschamber.com) to survey more
than 100 senior executives employed by transportation providers The major
con-clusion was that the transportation industry recognizes the serious security threats
it faces, and is concerned that not enough is being done to counter those threats
Among those surveyed, maritime (84 percent) and air cargo (70 percent) are the
two sectors at highest risk, as reported by various industry experts Highest cargo
risk areas for the industry are perceived to be when goods are in transit (55 percent)
and during dock operations (44 percent) While ten different security measures
were cited as being important, not one of them was found to be used effectively
Background checks of employees was seen as most important (62 percent), but
was perceived as being effective by only 14 percent of survey respondents Physical
security measures are also thought to be important (57 percent), but only 9 percent
of respondents believe they are effective
Although air and maritime executives expect to give high priority to Homeland
Security issues during the next 12 months, just 60 percent of rail executives say they will
be doing the same Homeland Security will be a priority during the same time frame for
just 26 percent of truckload carriers and 25 percent of less-than-truckload companies
In seeking funding for new security measures, 55 percent of respondents expect
to take money from their profit and reserves, while 47 percent will increase rates
to meet requirements Of all respondents, 48 percent plan to use outside services
to implement their Homeland Security strategy The maritime sector will be the
heaviest user of these services (76 percent), followed by rail (50 percent) and air (50
percent) Physical security (49 percent) and training (47 percent) are the two areas
most expected to be outsourced
Figure 1.6
Trang 35According to the survey, 41 percent are Customs-Trade Partnership Against
Terrorism (C-TPAT) certified, and an additional 18 percent have certification
action in process
One of the eye-catching things about the study was that respondents thought
they were doing a good job in compliance, but the industry as whole had a long way
to go Not all regulations are finalized right now, so the respondents did not want
to make a major financial investment until they can be sure they are investing in
the right thing at the right time
Industry experts predict a shift from federal mandates to shipper mandates in
the supply chain
Operation Safe Commerce (OSC)
Operation Safe Commerce (OSC) is a program to fund business initiatives designed
to enhance security for container cargo moving throughout the international
trans-portation system and was the predecessor to many of the new programs since 2002
in cargo security
OSC will provide a test-bed for new security techniques that have the potential
to increase the security of container shipments DOT and Customs will use the
pro-gram to identify existing vulnerabilities in the supply chain and develop improved
methods for ensuring the security of cargo entering and leaving the United States
Those security techniques that prove successful under the program will then be
recommended for implementation systemwide
Congress, through the 2002 Supplemental Appropriations Act, provided $28
million in funding for OSC to improve the security of container shipments through
pilot projects involving the United States’ three largest container ports of entry
In a Federal Register notice issued previously, DOT’s Transportation Security
Administration (TSA) solicited proposals from the ports of Los Angeles/Long
Beach, New York/New Jersey, and Seattle/Tacoma for projects that included
rep-resentation from all components of the supply chain, including major and minor
ports and their feeder locations, overseas customers and port partners, and the
shipping lines serving these locations The notice invited comments on the proposal
from interested parties no later than December 4, 2002
An Executive Steering Committee (ESC) co-chaired by DOT and Customs
will select projects for funding and provide oversight for the program The ESC also
includes representatives from TSA, the U.S Coast Guard, the Departments of State,
Justice, and Commerce, and the White House Office of Homeland Security
“Securing America’s ports is essential for protecting our homeland, which is
why I developed Operation Safe Commerce and pushed it through Congress,” said
Sen Patty Murray, Chair of the Senate Transportation Appropriations
Subcom-mittee “Container traffic is critical to the health of our economy, but we do not
know enough about what is in the more than six million containers that enter
Trang 36The Events of 9/11 and How They Affect Global Supply Chains ◾ 15
our nation each year This initiative will ensure the security of the containers that
will pass through our ports and onto America’s highways and railways TSA and
Customs should be commended for taking this important step and I look forward
to continuing to work with them on this and other initiatives.”
OSC demonstrates the government’s resolve to make cargo traffic safe and has
provided direct funding for a variety of issues to study and provide specific
solu-tions to a complex transportation infrastructure on cargo moving to and from the
United States
Executives in global supply chain management need to pay attention to OSC,
as its efforts will set standards that carriers and principal shippers will need to
fol-low It will challenge the efficiencies of international logistics
Free and Secure Trade (FAST)
What Is the FAST program?
The Free and Secure Trade (FAST) program is a joint Canada–U.S initiative
involving the Canada Border Services Agency, Citizenship and Immigration
Can-ada, and the United States Bureau of Customs and Border Protection (CBP) FAST
supports moving pre-approved eligible goods across the border quickly and
verify-ing trade compliance away from the border It is a harmonized commercial process
offered to pre-approved importers, carriers, and registered drivers Shipments for
approved companies, transported by approved carriers using registered drivers, will
be cleared into either country with greater speed and certainty, and at a reduced
cost of compliance
In Canada, FAST builds on the Customs Self-Assessment (CSA) program and
its principles of pre-approval and self-assessment, as well as increased security
mea-sures under the Partners in Protection (PIP) program FAST includes aligning the
requirements of Canada’s PIP program and the U.S Customs-Trade Partnership
Against Terrorism (C-TPAT) program As part of these programs, companies will
have to adopt and implement security procedures to be compatible with guidelines
set by both customs agencies
What Are the Benefits of the FAST Program?
FAST, based on sound risk management techniques, focuses on greater speed and
certainty at the border and reduces the cost of compliance by:
Reducing the information requirements for customs clearance
Trang 37Reducing the rate of border examinations
approved importers (Canada only)
Who Is Eligible to Apply?
There are three major participant groups who are eligible for FAST: importers,
carriers, and drivers FAST will be available to those who have a demonstrated
his-tory of compliance with all relevant legislation and regulations and have acceptable
books, records, and audit trails
Importers
◾
Importer Application Process for Importing into Canada
−Carriers
◾
Highway Carrier Application Process
−Drivers
◾
FAST Commercial Driver Information Guide
−FAST Commercial Driver Application Form
−Tips for Completing the FAST Commercial Driver Application
−FAST Commercial Driver Program — Participant’s Guide
−Information on Citizenship and Immigration Canada’s Criminal Reha-
−bilitation Program (FAST Applicants Only)
Where Is FAST Available?
Currently, Canada and the United States jointly offer expedited Customs
clear-ance processes to pre-authorized drivers, carriers, and importers at the following 12
major border crossings:
Stanstead (55), Quebec / Derby Line, Vermont
Trang 38The Events of 9/11 and How They Affect Global Supply Chains ◾ 17
Coutts, Alberta / Sweetgrass, Montana
◾
Pacific Highway, British Columbia / Blaine, Washington
◾
In addition, plans were developed to have all major commercial crossings FAST
capable by the end of 2006 or the beginning of 2007 Companies with significant
trade activity with Canada would benefit in time and cost with access to the FAST
program This should be considered a serious option by all supply chain managers
Trang 40Chapter 2
Compliance and Security
Import Supply Chains
This chapter reviews all the issues that the import manager will have to face
on their inbound supply chain and provides comprehensive considerations
for the purchasing manager who is sourcing from foreign manufacturers.
The more knowledge one has about the history and infrastructure of Customs, the
better one will be able to import successfully The United States Customs Service,
formerly under the direction of the Department of the Treasury since its creation
in 1789, was transferred to the Department of Homeland Security in March 2003
This was a significant amendment to process as a message was sent to the
inter-national trade community that Customs’ focus would be more concentrated on
enforcement of global security rather than a primary focus of protecting the
rev-enue of the United States through commercial operations actions of collection
Effectively in March 2003, Customs implemented a name change to the Bureau of
Customs and Border Protection, and its mission statement was updated to reflect
this new focus:
Vigilance is how we ensure the safety of all Americans We are continuously
watchful and alert to deter, detect, and prevent threats to our nation We
demonstrate courage and valor in the protection of our nation