Writing your doctoral dissertation - part 23 pdf

For instance, when there is a careful match among the theory being tested, the data collected, and the research question, there is construct validity—one important type of affirmation th

Writing your dissertation proposal

and Goetz, 1982; Howe, 1998; Howe and Eisenhart, 1990; Richardson, forthcoming; and Wittrock, 1986) For instance, when there is a careful match among the theory being tested, the data collected, and the research question, there is construct validity—one important type of affirmation that your study has been carefully designed and implemented Since one of your major concerns in conducting this study is to convince experienced researchers that this is quality research, you will want to provide clear evidence of the validity

of the decisions you made in planning and conducting it You want to provide assurance that you have complied with accepted research practices, discussing, for example, the reliability and validity or the truthfulness of all the procedures you followed in designing your study

Another way to establish the validity of your methodology is to seek expert evaluation You will want to respond to suggested revisions, either following the advice offered, or rejecting it Your correspondence is frequently included

in an appendix to your proposal An explanation of all the steps you create to validate your study promotes respect for the quality of your research

Steps Toward Approval of Your Proposal

There are numerous steps which mark you progress toward approval of your proposal You will probably want to include each of these in your personal checklist and note when each has been fulfilled (see Appendix E)

Once your committee has confidence in your proposal, there is likely to

be a formal proposal hearing With an approved proposal in hand, you are ready for two things:

1 Celebrate your major accomplishment One outcome of this review is a

written approval which you should preserve in a safe place This statement certifies the acceptance of your proposal by university reviewers The approval theoretically signifies a commitment between the university and the student to support the completion of your project, providing you adhere

to all the university’s rules, such as registering each semester But there are no guarantees Complete your degree requirements as rapidly as possible to avoid new rules and expectations which inevitably accompany new administrations or faculty changes Celebrate your progress—and…

2 Get on with the next phase of your work—conducting your study!

By thinking of it as small parts—theoretical rationale, research design, etc —I was able to divide the project into smaller, more manageable units and thereby was able to reduce the pressure on myself, and make it possible to see progress

on this immense project

One thing the dissertation forced me to do was to reflect on what I was doing This time to reflect was a gift

With your committee’s approval, you are now ready to “do your study.” This is a most exhilarating time in the research process It is at this point that you are able to use your unique talents, experiences, and knowledge Your organizational skills ease your way as you both orchestrate this large-scale study and insure that you have the documentation you need to write it

up Now is the time when you discover the answer(s) to your research questions

Being mindful that you are responsible for establishing your own schedule, you will create a time line, noting all the activities which need to be done, and giving adequate time for each step As you make this list you will identify several activities which may be accomplished simultaneously For example, when you send out questionnaires to one group of participants, you may schedule and conduct interviews with other participants There is always something that can be done Do not allow one day to go by without doing

something Your schedule keeps you in focus, as long as you revise it to

reflect the real progress you are making and the added elements which need

to be completed in your study Expect that your initial projections will be revised Don’t allow any curve balls to stop you They may cause you to take

a new perspective, but keep a positive attitude, finding ways to succeed.

Conducting your study

• collecting and storing your data;

• analyzing your data; and

• interpreting your findings

Although we will discuss these separately, these are interdependent components of your study as noted in Figure 11.1 There are times, for example, when you may analyze some of your data while you are still collecting further data

Collecting and Storing Your Data

In your proposal you identified data which you expected to collect and use in conducting your study Your data may take many forms Depending on the focus of your study, you may collect a range of materials For example: census reports unpublished documents

statistical tables test results

interview questions handwritten journals

transcripts published articles and letters

personal letters parental approvals

You will need to establish systematic procedures for collecting and storing these data so that you can find them when you need them

Collecting your Data

As you start your study you need access to all the materials which you have identified The collection process may take the form of visiting libraries and/

or identifying human participants If you are planning to enlist the cooperation of others in your data collection (through interviews, responses

Figure 11.1 Conducting your study: a cyclical process

to surveys, or the like), you need to find effective ways to accomplish this.

Remember that the people who are your participants are helping you There’s

probably nothing “in it” for them except for the feeling that they are helping you, and/or the research community Your recognition that your study is dependent on getting good data from these respondents will be evident in the ways in which you accommodate your respondents’ priorities Some suggestions for encouraging participation in your study are noted below

Ultimately you must find a way to get people to respond Without data, your study cannot go forward If you run into problems, your committee and your program colleagues are excellent resources for addressing these concerns

If you need to develop a questionnaire for a survey or interviews, you may find useful resources in other dissertations, published reports of related studies, conference presentations, or the like There are also books written

on interview strategies (see Appendix D for suggestions) Your study will be enhanced by pilot-testing your materials It is also useful to audio-tape and then critically review your potential questions Try to simplify your

Suggested strategies for gathering responses

• Keep the time needed to a minimum

• Inform people of the time this is likely to take

• Arrange a time that is convenient for your participants

• Provide instructions which are easily understood

• Insure anonymity and confidentiality where possible

• Invite assistance from those concerned with the same issue you are studying, such as members of your professional organization

• Note in your invitation the names of people on your committee who are respected by your potential informants

• Expect that only about 50 per cent of the group of potential participants may respond

• Limit the number of participants needed

• Seek assistance from people you have helped

• Provide a stamped, self-addressed envelope, when appropriate

• Follow up on the telephone, by snail mail, or by e-mail

Conducting your study

find it easier to clarify seemingly chaotic data than if many months have elapsed or if you are absent from the taping experience The video-tape and

field notes are “raw” data, whereas the transcript is derived from your initial

data Each transcript represents a specific perspective As you create your transcripts and decide what to include, be conscious of your selections and exclusions, and be ready to explain these decisions in your dissertation and

at your oral examination

While you are collecting all your data, you want to be as cautious as possible about restricting your influence on the activities You want to maintain a neutral, explorer’s stance, seeking to discover something new as you collect your data

Storing Materials

Establish one place to store all your materials, a place no one else will disturb As you engage in your data collection and analysis, you are likely

to create numerous stacks of papers You may have books and journal articles from the library, blank questionnaires, responses to surveys, new and recorded audio-and video-tapes, field notes, essays written in classes, pre-publication articles, email from experts across the nation, conference papers, and equipment The more cautiously you store these materials, the more likely it is that you will be able to retrieve them when you want them

You will also need to find ways to categorize the materials you are accumulating You might place all your completed questionnaires in one box, and the names and addresses of people surveyed in a second box Your computer diskettes may be organized chronologically, noting the data collected in the first three months of your study on Diskette #1 and that collected in the second three months on Diskette #2 One set of back-up diskettes may be stored near your computer, a second set placed on your living-room bookshelves, a third back-up in the form of your zip drive may

be carried in your backpack And of course, keep hard copies as well Be paranoid: store your data in many places.

Conducting the actual study can be exciting, as well as frustrating It can

be exciting if the researcher has organized the procedures for conducting the study and has enlisted the help of persons to assist in collecting the data Even the most organized and well-planned study does not always

go as anticipated, but good organization can help things move smoothly

It is very important that the researcher set deadlines for receiving data There must be some contingency for retrieving data that are not received

by that deadline Some researchers may have a telephone committee to remind people to return data Others may send out letters as reminders

Of course, much of this will depend on the type of research being conducted When experimental research is done, the experimenter has