1. Trang chủ
  2. » Khoa Học Tự Nhiên

Green analytical chemistry past, present and perspectives

460 3 0

Đang tải... (xem toàn văn)

Tài liệu hạn chế xem trước, để xem đầy đủ mời bạn chọn Tải xuống

THÔNG TIN TÀI LIỆU

Thông tin cơ bản

Tiêu đề Green Analytical Chemistry Past, Present and Perspectives
Tác giả Justyna Płotka-Wasylka, Jacek Namieśnik
Trường học Gdańsk University of Technology
Chuyên ngành Analytical Chemistry
Thể loại book
Năm xuất bản 2019
Thành phố Gdańsk
Định dạng
Số trang 460
Dung lượng 13,09 MB

Các công cụ chuyển đổi và chỉnh sửa cho tài liệu này

Nội dung

Emphasis hasbeen put on the beginnings of green chemistry awareness and on the possibilities of increasing and evaluating the greenness of both currently used and designed lytical chemis

Trang 1

Green Chemistry and Sustainable Technology

Green Analytical Chemistry

Justyna Płotka-Wasylka

Jacek Namieśnik Editors

Past, Present and Perspectives

Trang 2

University of Venice, Venice, Italy

Z Conrad Zhang

Dalian Institute of Chemical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Dalian,China

Trang 3

The series Green Chemistry and Sustainable Technology aims to presentcutting-edge research and important advances in green chemistry, green chemicalengineering and sustainable industrial technology The scope of coverage includes(but is not limited to):

– Environmentally benign chemical synthesis and processes (green catalysis,green solvents and reagents, atom-economy synthetic methods etc.)

– Green chemicals and energy produced from renewable resources (biomass,carbon dioxide etc.)

– Novel materials and technologies for energy production and storage (bio-fuelsand bioenergies, hydrogen, fuel cells, solar cells, lithium-ion batteries etc.)– Green chemical engineering processes (process integration, materials diversity,

– Green technologies for environmental sustainability (carbon dioxide capture,waste and harmful chemicals treatment, pollution prevention, environmentalredemption etc.)

The series Green Chemistry and Sustainable Technology is intended to provide anaccessible reference resource for postgraduate students, academic researchers andindustrial professionals who are interested in green chemistry and technologies forsustainable development

Trang 4

Justyna P łotka-Wasylka • Jacek Namie śnik

Editors

Green Analytical Chemistry Past, Present and Perspectives

123

Trang 5

Justyna Płotka-Wasylka

Department of Analytical Chemistry

Gdańsk University of Technology

Gdańsk, Poland

Jacek Namieśnik (Deceased)Department of Analytical ChemistryGdańsk University of TechnologyGdańsk, Poland

ISSN 2196-6982 ISSN 2196-6990 (electronic)

Green Chemistry and Sustainable Technology

ISBN 978-981-13-9104-0 ISBN 978-981-13-9105-7 (eBook)

https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-9105-7

© Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd 2019

This work is subject to copyright All rights are reserved by the Publisher, whether the whole or part

of the material is concerned, speci fically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on micro films or in any other physical way, and transmission

or information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed.

The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a speci fic statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use.

The publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and information in this book are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication Neither the publisher nor the authors or the editors give a warranty, expressed or implied, with respect to the material contained herein or for any errors or omissions that may have been made The publisher remains neutral with regard

to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional af filiations.

This Springer imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd The registered company address is: 152 Beach Road, #21-01/04 Gateway East, Singapore 189721, Singapore

Trang 6

of Prof Jacek Namieśnik (10 December 1949–14 April 2019), a visionary analytical chemistry leader and a mentor to so many You will be missed.

Trang 7

Care about global climate change, pollution of environment and hazards to human

field of chemistry science and chemists’ action including those that are connectedwith chemical analysis Analytical chemistry is a central science that provides the

essential role to play in environmental protection through monitoring of pollutants

in air, water or soil On the other hand, analytical activities involve the use of manyreagents and solvents, thus generating toxic residues For these reasons, GreenAnalytical Chemistry (GAC) was introduced in 2000 to reduce or remove the sideeffects of analytical practices on operators and the environment

This idea has attracted a great deal of interest among chemists, particularly thoseconcerned with making laboratory practices in analytical chemistry environmen-tally friendly As it is a great challenge to reach an acceptable compromise betweenincreasing the quality of results and improving environmental friendliness of ana-lytical methods, it is important to follow the guidelines and principles of GreenAnalytical Chemistry which have been introduced, and provide a framework forGAC

not only in academia but also in industrial and governmental laboratories Thisbook starts by introducing the history of Green Analytical Chemistry as well aslaws and principles that are based on the GAC ideology Another important issuethat will determine the future of Green Analytical Chemistry is education of thisconcept in the society; thus, the subject connecting with teaching of GAC based onseveral examples is also discussed It then goes on to present the trends and futureperspectives of the analytical laboratories Developments and new achievements in

extraction of trace constituents, and nature of the derivatization process and greenchromatographic techniques are widely discussed Flow injection analysis towardsGreen Analytical Chemistry as well as remote monitoring of environmental pol-lutants is presented The book also contains chapters which are focused on the smart

vii

Trang 8

sorption materials and new types of solvents used in the field of analyticalchemistry.

As the greenness of analytical procedure is multivariable aspect, many greennesscriteria should be taken into consideration From the other side, modern analyticalchemistry offers dozens of analytical methodologies, based on different methodsand techniques, which are used for determination of analytes in a given matrix Due

to such complex decision-making processes, multi-criteria decision analysis toolsare applied as systematic approach to deal with complex decisions In this book, the

multi-criteria decision analysis tools as Green Analytical Chemistry systems Inaddition, several tools that can be applied to evaluate the developed analyticalprocedures are presented

The book concludes with a discussion of how GAC is both possible and

perspectives of Green Analytical Chemistry Green Analytical Chemistry is aimed

at managers of analytical laboratories but will also interest teachers of analyticalchemistry and green public policy-makers

This book aims to celebrate the advancements in Green Analytical Chemistry,which encompasses all measurement techniques for all types of applications thatminimize or eliminate the generation of chemical waste We believe that this bookwill allow the reader to identify that GAC can operate in all contexts, not only inenvironmental application but also in the industrial and the sanitary We hope thatthis book contributes to move from the theory to the practice; therefore, editors andauthors are convinced of the necessity of this book

We would like to express our thanks to the personnel of Springer who haveoffered all the time their support, especially June Tang and Sunny Guo for their help

to make this book possible The generosity, patience and good work of all theauthors are acknowledged We are convinced that this book is the starting point forfuture cooperation in a new analytical chemistry

Trang 9

1 History and Milestones of Green Analytical Chemistry 1

2 Teaching Green Analytical Chemistry on the Example

of Bioindication and Biomonitoring (B & B) Technologies 19

John Hillman, Jean-Bernard Diatta, Susanta Lahiri, Ivan Suchara,

Marina Frontasyeva, Adnan Badran, Alexander Lux,

3 Teaching Green Analytical and Synthesis Chemistry:

Performing Laboratory Experiments in a Greener Way 45Arabinda Kumar Das, Ruma Chakraborty and Miguel de la Guardia

4 Mass Spectrometry-Based Direct Analytical Techniques 75

5 New Achievements in the Field of Extraction of Trace Analytes

from Samples Characterized by Complex Composition

of the Matrix 103

6 Greening the Derivatization Step in Analytical Extractions:

Recent Strategies and Future Directions 151Muhammad Sajid

ix

Trang 10

7 Smart Sorption Materials in Green Analytical Chemistry 167Francesc A Esteve-Turrillas, Sergio Armenta, Salvador Garrigues

and Miguel de la Guardia

8 Ionic Liquids and Deep Eutectic Solvents in the Field

of Environmental Monitoring 203

and Mara G Freire

9 Green Chromatography and Related Techniques 241

10 Flow Injection Analysis Toward Green Analytical Chemistry 299

11 Remote Monitoring of Environmental Pollutants 325

12 Comparative Greenness Evaluation 353

13 Quantitative Assessment 379

14 QuEChERS—A Green Alternative Approach

for the Determination of Pharmaceuticals and Personal Care

Products in Environmental and Food Samples 395Christina Nannou, Anna Ofrydopoulou, David Heath, Ester Heath

and Dimitra Lambropoulou

15 Green Analytical Chemistry: Summary of Existing Knowledge

and Future Trends 431

Trang 11

Education, University of Mostar, Mostar, Bosnia and Herzegovina

University of Aveiro, Aveiro, Portugal

Valencia, Spain

Valencia, Valencia, Spain

xi

Trang 12

Francesc A Esteve-Turrillas Department of Analytical Chemistry, University ofValencia, Valencia, Spain

of Dresden, Zittau, Germany

University of Aveiro, Aveiro, Portugal

for Nuclear Research, Dubna, Russia

Chemistry, Jan Kochanowski University, Kielce, Poland

Valencia, Spain

Canada

University, Tula, Russia

Valencia, Valencia, Spain

University London, London, UK

Mostar, Mostar, Bosnia and Herzegovina

Trang 13

Eun-Shik Kim Department of Forestry Environment and Systems, College ofForest Science, Kookmin University, Seoul, South Korea

Opole, Poland

River National Laboratory, Aiken, USA

Nuclear Physics, Kolkata, India

Thessaloniki, Thessaloniki, Greece

Bratislava, Slovakia

Universidad Nacional de Mar del Plata, Mar del Plata, Argentina

Germany

Ghent, Ghent, Belgium

Thessaloniki, Thessaloniki, Greece

Development, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA

Thessaloniki, Thessaloniki, Greece

Trang 14

Katarzyna Owczarek Department of Analytical Chemistry, Faculty of Chemistry,

Technology, Krakow, Poland

Department, University of Aveiro, Aveiro, Portugal

Wuppertal, Wuppertal, Germany

Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals, Dhahran, Saudi Arabia

Department, University of Aveiro, Aveiro, Portugal

Gdansk, Poland

Poland

University, Ghent, Belgium

Stanislava Talić Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Science and Education,University of Mostar, Mostar, Bosnia and Herzegovina

University, Opole, Poland

Trang 15

Meie Wang Research Center for Eco-Environmental Sciences, Chinese Academy

of Sciences, Beijing, China

Haren-Erika, Germany

Trang 16

History and Milestones of Green

Analytical Chemistry

Justyna Płotka-Wasylka, Magdalena Fabjanowicz, Kaja Kalinowska

and Jacek Namie´snik

Abstract Due to the increased environmental consciousness, Green Analytical

Chemistry (GAC) is an important concept steadily gaining popularity, as its mentation facilitates the decrease the detrimental effect analytical chemistry method-ologies may have on the environment In this chapter, a brief overview of the history

imple-of Green Analytical Chemistry (GAC) and its milestone was given Emphasis hasbeen put on the beginnings of green chemistry awareness and on the possibilities

of increasing and evaluating the greenness of both currently used and designed lytical chemistry methodologies In addition, the prospects of implementation of 12principles of Green Analytical Chemistry have been briefly described

Concern and interest for the state of the environment are constantly increasing;therefore, it becomes significant to examine those chemists and chemical engineers’activities which may impact on the environment state, on both the laboratory and

the dissemination of the principles of sustainable development and the highly ble tendency to the implementation of these principles in laboratories and chemicalplant In fact, principles of green chemistry have been adopted in the specific fields

visi-of chemistry However, in the literature, it can be observed that before the ization of the green chemistry concept, there was a consciousness among analyticalchemists of the need to develop sustainable methodologies, in order to save solventsand reagents, as well as to replace the most toxic solvents by other innocuous or

may commit damage to the environment and serious risks for operators; therefore,for these reasons, it is essential to think about the effects as well as consequences

J Płotka-Wasylka · M Fabjanowicz (B) · K Kalinowska · J Namie´snik

Department of Analytical Chemistry, Faculty of Chemistry, Gda´nsk University of Technology, 11/12 G Narutowicza Street, 80-233 Gda´nsk, Poland

e-mail: magfabja@student.pg.edu.pl

© Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd 2019

J Płotka-Wasylka and J Namie´snik (eds.), Green Analytical Chemistry,

Green Chemistry and Sustainable Technology,

https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-9105-7_1

1

Trang 17

2 J Płotka-Wasylka et al.

of action as researchers/users of analytical methods Hence, from the viewpoint ofpeople who take care of the environment and themselves as well as part of eco-nomic aspects of analytical methodologies, the special attention should be paid onthe inherent risk of some samples type, aliquot of reagents and solvents used, theconsumption of energy related to more and more modern instrumentation and, with-out a doubt, produced laboratory wasted and emissions coming from the numerous

In this chapter, we will shortly describe the history and milestones of Green lytical Chemistry (GAC) In addition, the facts which made possible the tremendousinterest in Green Analytical Chemistry exist today, and the origin of many of terms

Ana-is currently used

Chemistry

Nowadays, GAC is the concept which every chemist analyst should know Therefore,

it is not surprising that analytical chemistry studies in the frame of chemistry degreesaround the world have evolved in different ways However, a responsibility among theanalytical chemists’ society appeared long before the introduction of the GAC term.Many innovative advances in the area of sample preparation, measurement as well

as data handling associated with microwave-assisted flow injection analysis (FIA),sample digestion and extraction (MAE), and chemometrics were represented in the

which were invented to increase the green character of the analytical protocols were

to introduce the GAC idea was concept developed in 1993 regarding the possibilityoffered by the combination of the processes of photo-assisted degradation linked toFIA manifolds carried out in the spectrometric determination of phenolic compounds

of word “waste”, suggesting an alternative method which includes an additionalchemical effort to reduce the environmental impact of FIA determinations That wasthe beginning of the clean analytical chemistry concept In 1995, the potentialityproposed by the degradation processes’ contribution and FIA to enhance analyticalmethods was confirmed

In the same year, the article entitled “Towards environmentally conscientiousAnalytical Chemistry through miniaturization containment and reagent replacement”was published, and it is obvious that this was the first declaration of the principles

term “waste minimization” was proposed and recommended to analytical practice.Although the term Green Analytical Chemistry was not applied in this manuscript,

Trang 18

Fig 1.1 Milestones of Green Analytical Chemistry

Trang 19

4 J Płotka-Wasylka et al.

Fig 1.2 Basic ideas for an integrated eco-friendly approach of Analytical Chemistry

it is allotted as the precursor works of GAC because the green idea was inherentlypresent Since this time, green idea development in analytical practice was goingvery quickly Thus, more and more improvements, in both procedures and instru-

the basic ideas for an integrated environmentally friendly approach of analytical

In 1973, an important work entitled “Trends in the Teaching of Analytical istry in American Universities” was published In this work, a well-known sentence

Chem-“the usual approach to predict the future is to project past trends” has been cited

surmount any crises by a correct projection of the past to the future, making adequatebehavioural changes to avoid errors made in the past and to incorporate new ideas into

under the title “Changes of paradigms in Analytical Chemistry” In this presentation,

Trang 20

Fig 1.3 Steps of the analytical process to be considered in the frame of the Ecological Paradigm

the term paradigm was used not only as a pattern and a syntax-like scheme but also as

a guide for new friends in our academic society to give them novel tools for solving

six successive paradigms in the evolution of Analytical Chemistry—from chemistry to alchemy, iatrochemistry, chemiology, chemiurgy and finally ecologicalchemistry—were identified In this presentation, it has been presented that Analyt-ical Chemistry today must be closely associated with environmental protection Inaddition, all analytical activities must consider the different aspects connected to thepreservation of our ecosystem Therefore, we must be conscious that in our profes-sional activity, it is required to take care of the operator’s safety and the environmentpreservation Although there is no clear transition between the archaeological periodand the different paradigms, nowadays the ecological mentality must inform the work

archeo-of the analyst and relationship with society Thus, taking into account the analyticalprocess, the attention should be paid not only to the problems, samples and data to

be obtained, but also to the nature and amounts of the reagents to be applied, theemissions and wastes generated during the whole process, the energy requirements

Without a doubt, the analytical activity increase on the environmental samples and

on the undesirable environmental constituents had the knock-on effect of increasingthe number of analytical wastes and provided notable changes in the laboratories’mentality about the impact of their residues Evolution of the ecological mentality

the bad conscience about the side effects of the increase of reagent consumptionand waste generation This is hard evidence that the new opportunities proposed bychemistry at the end of the last century were closely associated with the ecologi-cal mentality, and here, the idea of GAC offered excellent opportunities from theacademic as well as business points of view

Trang 21

6 J Płotka-Wasylka et al.

Fig 1.4 Steps of the evolution of the ecological mentality within analytical laboratories

Analytical Chemistry to Green Analytical Chemistry

In the 1990s, Paul Anastas edited a series of texts concerning the need for the ment towards environmentally benign chemistry, about Green Analytical Chemistry

empha-sized its twofold role in the environmental protection, caused by the fact that variousanalytical chemistry methodologies could not only contribute themselves to detec-tion of potentially undesirable environmental constituents but possibly also take part

in the increase of pollution’s amount and further ecological problems Because ofthat it is important to work on greening the analytical methods, while taking theiraccuracy, sensitivity and precision under consideration

How-ever, since they were coined in order to be applied in the field of synthetic chemistry,only some of them could be employed to the analytical chemistry Because of thatthere was a need to adapt the rules in a way that would make their implementation

Trang 22

Fig 1.5 Goals of the Green

Analytical Chemistry

in the field of analytical chemistry possible Thus, 12 undermentioned principles of

1 If possible, sample treatment should be avoided by the use of direct methods

2 The number and size of the samples should be as small as possible

3 Measurement should be performed in situ

4 Processes and operations should be integrated

5 If possible, automation and miniaturization of analytical methods should beselected

6 Derivatization should be avoided

7 The number of wastes generated should be as little as possible, and it should bemanaged accordingly

8 Multi-analyte and multi-parameter methods should be applied wherever it ispossible

9 Use of the energy should be minimal

10 Reagents from renewable sources should be preferred

11 Toxic reagents and solvents should be eliminated or replaced

12 Safety of the operators should be improved

Based on the principles of both green chemistry and Green Analytical Chemistry,

Trang 23

8 J Płotka-Wasylka et al.

Fig 1.6 Types of factors

evaluated during greenness

assessment

has been coined in order to speak about methods in which additional effort wasmade in order to decrease the negative impact the analysis has on the environment,

aforementioned priorities and principles of GAC, an ideally clean analytical methodwould be direct, nondestructive, reagentless procedure that requires only a minimalenergy, while at the same time is also fast and capable multiple parameters andanalytes in a single run

However, in case of many analytical problems, it is not possible to use a so-calledideal method that would be in accordance with all principles of Green AnalyticalChemistry, since not many analytes and parameters can be determined simultaneously

or from an untreated sample Because of that, it is important to evaluate all aspects ofanalytical methods that affect their sustainability and that may be improved withoutaffecting their basic analytical characteristics

In order to minimize the negative environmental impact of already existing ods, each step of analytical procedure (i.e sampling collection, sampling preparation,analysis and the evaluation of the results) should be evaluated based on their influ-

Characteristics of reagents and solvents used in the analytical process are one ofthe key factors affecting its greenness, since they may be detrimental to the environ-ment, as well as human health and safety On many occasions, these compounds areflammable, toxic or otherwise potentially harmful to the biota Moreover, the use ofthe nongreen reagents at each step of analytical methodology may result in the neces-

Trang 24

sity of the implementation of expensive and time-consuming waste treatment [13].Due to the aforementioned reasons, one of the aims of Green Analytical Chemistry

is to identify reagents to be replaced and substitute them with nontoxic, harmless

Out of all steps of the analytical procedure, samples’ preparation is usually themost polluting part, since techniques such as extraction or mineralization are oftenenergy-consuming and require the use of various nongreen solvents Because ofthat the greenest approach would be to use direct analytical methods, in which thewhole step of sample preparation is negligible However, in many cases, isolation andpreconcentration of analytes are unavoidable and direct analysis cannot be performed.Thus, the emphasis should be put on the automation and miniaturization of theprocess, as well as the use of the least harmful compounds and novel techniquesthat require much smaller amounts of organic solvent Reduction and, if possible,elimination of the use of a nongreen solvent in samples preparation should be apriority not only due to being detrimental to the environment but also because it

Samples’ collection is usually not associated with being harmful to the ecosystem;nevertheless, transportation, storage and the collection itself involve money, materialand energy Moreover, in the case of environmental or biological samples whosephysical or chemical composition changes during storage Notwithstanding, in thecase of the measurements that can be performed directly in the flow system, it isrecommended to avoid the sample collection step by using greener in-line system

When neither in-line analysis nor direct methods can be used, the emphasis should

be put on choosing the greenest approach The factors such as the amount of wastegenerated and energy used, as well as the occupational hazard of using the instrument

in question, should be taken under consideration

Since analytical procedures are usually complex and consist of several steps, it might

be difficult to assess the overall impact it has on the environment Moreover, parison of different methodologies based on their accordance with GAC principles

evaluation tools have been proposed in order to facilitate the evaluation of analyticalprocedures

National Environmental Methods Index (NEMI) is a tool in which the proceduresare assessed based on their greenness profiles In order to evaluate a particular method,four main criteria are taken under consideration: toxicity and corrosivity of usedchemicals, hazard and waste amount The procedure in question is seen as greenwhen:

• the chemical used is not hazardous or listed as persistent, bioaccumulative or toxic,

• pH during the analysis is in the 2–12 range,

Trang 25

10 J Płotka-Wasylka et al.

Fig 1.7 Exemplary pictogram of NEMI

The results of the evaluation are presented in the form of the profile’s symbol

greenness of the method in relation to a different criterion NEMI pictograms areeasy to read by potential users; however, its use is time-consuming since it requiressearching each of the used chemicals on various lists of harmful substances More-over, application of NEMI in comparison of different procedures may be difficult,since it provides neither quantitative nor semi-quantitative information Therefore, inorder to increase NEMI applicability in collating multiple analytical methodologies,Guardia et al proposed the use of a three-coloured scale in order to evaluate the

procedures are evaluated based on five criteria: potential environmental, health andsafety risk, amount of generated waste and energy consumption As can be seen in

them marked green, yellow or red based on category’s environmental impact Withthe use of the visual representation of this tool, it is possible to compare two or moredifferent procedures based on their greenness

An alternative approach is to use the Analytical Eco-Scale proposed by Namie´snik

reagents used or waste generated, are assessed For each parameter that differs fromthe principles of GAC, penalty points are assigned and then subtracted from 100.Based on the obtained result, it is possible to evaluate greenness of the method inquestion: the higher the final score is, the greener the suggested method is AnalyticalEco-Scale can be used in order to evaluate new analytical methods, as well as tocompare them with already existing techniques since it enables quick assessmentand appraises many aspects of environmental impact in an efficient manner.The newest tool is the Green Analytical Procedure Index (GAPI) In this approach,greenness evaluation of each step of the analytical procedure is presented in a form

of pictogram comprised of five pentagrams that provide information on the

Trang 26

Environmental

Hazard

If less than 50 g of environmental hazards used

If more than 50 g but less than 250 g used If more than 250 g used

little solvent evaporation

An instrumental method such as GC, HPLC;

moderate solvent evaporation

An instrumental method such as GC-MS; high volume of solvent evaporated

50 g.

Total waste ≤ 250 g Total waste > 250 g

Health Hazard

Slightly toxic, slight irritant; NFPA health hazard score is 0 or 1

Moderately toxic; could cause temporary incapacitation; NFPA = 2

or 3

A serious injury on term exposure; known or suspected small animal carcinogen; NFPA = 4

short-Safety Hazard

Highest NFPA flammability,

instability score of 0 or 1

No special hazards.

Highest NFPA flammability or

instability score is 2 or 3,

or a special hazard is used.

Highest NFPA flammability or

preparation, reagents used, instrumentation as well as a general method are assessed

well-defined criteria of assessment and simplicity of its application, GAPI is a good toolfor semi-quantitative for greenness comparison and appraisal

Trang 27

12 J Płotka-Wasylka et al.

Approach of Analytical Chemistry

An integrated environmentally friendly approach of analytical chemistry stronglyrefers to the review paper published in 1999 by M de la Guardia in Journal ofBrazilian Chemical Society In the publication, ten keywords were pointed out, whichstand for the main problems and challenges of analytical chemistry at the end of thetwentieth century, including:

I traceability

II chemometrics

III flow analysis and robotics

IV in-field sampling

The most preliminary step, at the beginning of each analysis, is obtaining thematerial for a given research Common practice is to collect the samples, transportthem to the appropriate laboratory/research institute and store until the moment ofanalysis Given process is adjusted to many problems like difficulties of the repre-sentative sample collection, loss of analytes, sample contamination and time con-sumption The goal of the concept of an integrated approach of analytical chemistry

is to reduce the size of the laboratory samples and implement enhanced technologyfor in-field sampling with the use of chemometric models and screening techniques.Moreover, to carry on direct analysis with the on-line preconcentration in order toavoid sample transport and storage and to reduce the time of sample pretreatmentprocess by the implementation of developed sonochemistry, which suggests the use

of the microwave—assisted digestion and extraction or ultrasounds Both techniques

Sampling,

transport and

storage

Selection of the most appropriate technique

Hyphenation between analytical techniques

Data mining Decontamination of waste

Trang 28

Finally, it is important to increase awareness not only about the inputs (such asreagents and energy sources) but also about the outputs together with waste treatment.From year to year, the treatment of waste generated during the chemical analysis is ofhigher and higher importance Nowadays, the law regulates the carefulness regardingthe side effect of each chemical process, and it is said to choose methods generatingless amount of waste as well as decontaminate waste generated by the entity engaged

The graphical representation of the integrated approach of green analytical

necessary analytical steps and creation of the flow analysis process, which enables

At the same time, when the need of the integration physical, chemical and tional data, important for sample description, has appeared, researchers started tolook for the advanced statistical and computational tool able to treat a large amount

addi-of data Chemometrics, a new discipline, turned out to be a promising tool for theimprovement of experimental design and the process of optimization Chemomet-rics help among the others to determine the size of analytical data population, to findfunction of variables that could affect data, to optimize of analytical parameters, to

Trang 29

14 J Płotka-Wasylka et al.

combine data from different sources, etc Currently, given tool places a significant

and the Main Analytical Figures of Merit

The key point of the green chemistry assumptions is to increase the safety of both theenvironment and the operator All of the green chemistry principles are designed inorder to protect the environment and what is more the health and safety of workingpeople The difficulties in the case of greening the analytical chemistry rely on findingthe balance between the compatibility of the green chemistry principles and the mainanalytical figures of merit Principles of green chemistry, among the other, stronglyinfluence the type of reagent used in the analytical process in order to replace toxic andhazardous reagents to reduce the risk Moreover, it pays attention to reduce energyand reagent consumption and to decrease the amount of generated waste However,analytical chemistry is looking for the best accuracy, traceability, representativeness,

way how to satisfy the assessment of green chemistry and characteristic of analytical

Fig 1.12 Characteristic of

the compatibility of green

chemistry principles and the

main analytical figures of

Trang 30

Amount

of sample

Quantity of reagent and solvent used per sample

Quantity of reagents required and their stability

Quantity of cleaning solutions

Total amount

of waste

While greening the method of analytical chemistry, one should pay special tion how implemented changes of one factor may influence following ones Actually,using different reagent than originally dedicated for the analytical analysis may affectthe accuracy and selectivity At the same time, treatment of sample in a differentmanner should be done such a way to keep similar extraction recovery Additionally,representativeness of samples can be affected by the sample miniaturization even

atten-if it entails a number of advantages Once the volume of the sample is smaller, theanalysis consumes less energy and less amount of reagent and generates less amount

of waste Amount of the sample used for analysis contributes to the following factors

The amount of waste can be calculated as a waste generation per hour regardingthe flow system or per 100 analysis Automation and in-field methods as a way tomake the analysis greener have several advantages However, there are no opportu-nities for building in the checks It creates the need for the improvement in order toincrease the reliability, which may be achieved by designing the procedure in which

it will be possible to run standards between analysed samples or implement any othercalibration methods Obviously, automation strongly helps in greening the methodand at the same time lowers the cost Since the handling is reduced, the traceabilityand precision are enhanced as well The only thing one should be aware of is losing

Principles of green chemistry help significantly to preserve the environment andincrease the safety of employees, which is very important The only thing is to find theoptimal way to satisfy both the analytical characteristics quality and the evaluation

of green chemistry Each analysis should be focused to maximize the information atminimal cost and risk Analytical chemists during the design stage of green analytical

Trang 31

16 J Płotka-Wasylka et al.

The use of GAC methods is increasing since it was proven to be a smart strategy thatcan be both environmentally friendly and economically beneficial The development

of new greener sample preparation methods, the replacement of potentially harmfulreagents with less toxic alternatives, the miniaturization or automatization are only

a few out of many ways of improving the analytical process to be cost-effectiveand in accordance with principles of Green Analytical Chemistry There are manyarticles pertaining to the general aspects of GAC, as well as different new method-ologies described as sustainable, green or clean However, it is somewhat difficult

to determinate the exact number of studies concerning GAC, since there is no monly used term that would group a wide variety of actions taken to make analyticalmethodologies greener

com-In order to increase the popularity of Green Analytical Chemistry and to assist inits further implementation, there is a need for emphasis to be put on the importance ofso-called green mentality both in the scientific publications concerning new method-

contribute to the changing of social perception of analytical chemistry and chemistry

in general, but also to the integration of efforts made in the field of green chemistry

References

1 Namie´snik J (2001) Green analytical chemistry—some remarks J Sep Sci 24(2):151–153

2 de la Guardia M, Armenta S (2011) Origins of green analytical chemistry Compr Anal Chem 57(11):1–23

3 de la Guardia M, Garrigues S (2011) An ethical commitment and an economic opportunity In:

de la Guardia M, Garrigues S (eds) Challenges in green analytical chemistry Royal Society of Chemistry, pp 1–12

4 de la Guardia M, Ruzicka J (1995) Towards environmentally conscientious analytical chemistry through miniaturization, containment and reagent replacement Analyst 120(2):17N

5 Green DW et al (1995) Waste minimization in analytical methods In: DOE pollution prevention conference XI, pp 16–18

6 Laitinen HA (1973) Trends in the teaching of analytical chemistry in American universities Fresen Z Anal Chem 263(4):307–313

7 Malissa H, Roth E (eds) (1987) Reviews on analytical chemistry In: Euroanalysis VI Les Ules: Les editions de physique

8 Anastas PT, Warner JC (1998) 12 principles of green chemistry In: Green chemistry: theory and practice Oxford University Press, New York, p 30

9 Gałuszka A, Migaszewski Z, Namie´snik J (2013) The 12 principles of green analytical istry and the SIGNIFICANCE mnemonic of green analytical practices Trends Anal Chem 50:78–84

chem-10 Armenta S, Garrigues S, de la Guardia M (2008) Green analytical chemistry Trends Anal Chem 27(6):497–511

11 Tobiszewski M, Mechli´nska A, Zygmunt B, Namie´snik J (2009) Green analytical chemistry

in sample preparation for determination of trace organic pollutants TrAC Trends Anal Chem 28(8):943–951

Trang 32

12 Płotka-Wasylka J (2018) A new tool for the evaluation of the analytical procedure: green analytical procedure index Talanta 181:204–209

13 de la Guardia M, Armenta S (2011) A green evaluation of existing analytical methods Compr Anal Chem 57(11):39–57

14 Welch CJ et al (2010) Greening analytical chromatography Trends Anal Chem 29(7):667–680

15 Bonastre A, Ors R, Capella JV, Fabra MJ, Peris M (2005) In-line chemical analysis of ater: present and future trends Trends Anal Chem 24(2):128–137

wastew-16 Tickner JA, Becker M (2016) Mainstreaming green chemistry: the need for metrics Curr Opin Green Sustain Chem 1:1–4

17 Keith LH, Gron LU, Young JL (2007) Green analytical methodologies Chem Rev 107(6):2695–2708

18 Raynie D, Driver J (2009) Green assessment of chemical methods In: 13th annual green chemistry and engineering conference, p 34

19 Gałuszka A, Konieczka P, Migaszewski Z, Namie´snik J (2012) Analytical eco-scale for ing the greenness of analytical procedures Trends Anal Chem 37:61–72

assess-20 Płotka-Wasylka J (2018) A new tool for the evaluation of the analytical procedure: green analytical procedure index Talanta 181(January):204–209

21 de la Guardia M (1999) An integrated approach of analytical chemistry J Braz Chem Soc 10(6):429–437 (Brazilian Chemical Society)

22 de la Guardia M, Armenta S (2011) Practical consequences of green analytical chemistry In: Comprehensive analytical chemistry 57, 219–232

Trang 33

Chapter 2

Teaching Green Analytical Chemistry

on the Example of Bioindication

and Biomonitoring (B & B) Technologies

Bernd Markert, Eun-Shik Kim, Stefan Fränzle, Simone Wünschmann, Meie Wang, Rumy Djingova, Mira Aniˇci´c Uroševi´c, Shirong Liu,

John Hillman, Jean-Bernard Diatta, Susanta Lahiri, Ivan Suchara,

Piotr Szefer, Guntis Tabors, Jörg Rinklebe, Stefano Loppi, Harry Harmens, Peter Hooda, Maria Wacławek, Filipe Tack, Svetlana Gorelova, Anna Knox, Józef Pacyna, Elias Baydoun, Marina Frontasyeva, Adnan Badran,

Alexander Lux, Silvia De Marco, Erik Meers, Andrzej Kłos

and Jerome Nriagu

This book chapter is dedicated to our colleagues Dr Rebecca R Sharitz and Dr Jean-Paul

Schwitzguébel who passed away in 2018 Rebecca Sharitz worked at the University of Georgia

in Aiken, SC, USA, where she mainly researched highest successful on ecological processes in wetlands For many years, Becky has been working very effectively in our International Association for Ecology (INTECOL) She was the very first woman to work with INTECOL over such a long period of time to put her scientific interests into practice together with her friends and colleagues, but fought fairly and serenely for equal rights for women in the environmental and natural sciences Jean-Paul Schwitzguébel worked successfully at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Lau- sanne, Switzerland, especially in the context of his phytotechnological studies Particularly, note- worthy is his extraordinary ability in the framework of different European Cooperations in Science and Technology (EU-COST) over many years to bring together scientifically and practically dif- ferent European and global schools of thought Jean-Paul had as a francophile Swiss a heart and a feeling for all kinds of “everyday” problems, which we as scientists, whether young or old, private

or professional have to deal with Many young scientists owe it personally to him that they have found their successful way into the future.

B Markert (B) · S Wünschmann

Environmental Institute of Scientific Networks, Fliederweg 17, 49733 Haren-Erika, Germany e-mail: markert@EISN-institute.de

E.-S Kim

Department of Forestry Environment and Systems, College of Forest Science, Kookmin

University, Seoul, South Korea

S Fränzle

Department of Biological and Environmental Sciences, University of Dresden, Zittau, Germany

M Wang

Research Center for Eco-Environmental Sciences, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China

© Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd 2019

J Płotka-Wasylka and J Namie´snik (eds.), Green Analytical Chemistry,

Green Chemistry and Sustainable Technology,

https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-9105-7_2

19

Trang 34

Abstract Teaching of Green Analytical Chemistry (GAC) requires a not

inconsid-erable willingness on the part of the lecturer to familiarize himself with a relativelynew field in analytical chemistry Although there is much that can be derived fromGreen and Sustainable Chemistry, the GAC’s forward-looking perspectives in partic-ular are independent approaches that must not be neglected In the first chapter of thisarticle, approaches are pursued “how (teachers) learn to learn,” ultimately based on aconsensus on ethics, which allows dealing with people, society and the environment

to become an interdisciplinary unit The end of all this is a smart method of conflictmanagement which provides solutions of problems Available tools include– Regions concerned with education (learn how to learn)

– Think tanks (to define integrative solutions for problems) and

– Turbodemogracy (to get faster results)

In the second part of the chapter, GAC and nature merge completely, in whichmechanical sample collectors are replaced by mosses within the framework ofbioindication and biomonitoring (B & B) technologies during atmospheric depositionmeasurement of chemical elements Definitions of bioindicators and biomonitors,active and passive B & B technologies and interdisciplinary connections betweenbioindicative sampling and scientific interpretations of natural systems are given

Department of Agricultural Chemistry and Environmental Biogeochemistry,

Poznan University of Life Sciences, Pozna´n, Poland

Trang 35

2 Teaching Green Analytical Chemistry on the Example … 21

Mosses are distinguished by a rather large resistance toward enhanced levels of ious anthropogenic air pollutions permitting their use also in polluted areas

var-Keywords Green analytical chemistry·Education·

Analytical Chemistry moved—at least in parts—to Green Analytical Chemistry asshown in chapter one of the book by Justyna Plotka-Warsylka et al on “History andmilestones of green analytical chemistry.”

In order to introduce Green Analytical Chemistry (GAC) in universities, technicalcolleges and other higher educational institutions on the teaching side, a high degree

of high quality and quantitative prerequisites are required, which are particularlyplaced on teaching staff, i.e., professors and other persons actively involved in thetraining of students

Trang 36

Thus, it is first of all the task of the respective professor and trainer to familiarizethemselves with the overall topic of the GAC Learning how to learn in the sense of

a consensus on ethics will be the subject of the first part of this article

In addition, excellent textbooks have been published on this subject, whichdescribes essential findings from previous years At the same time, reference ismade to some publications which are far from complete and the selection of which

Analytical Chemistry will no longer do in the future use of technocratic pieces ofknowledge to obtain these integrative approaches to overcome the present problems,since:

• Increasing dynamics and complexities of problems need a better, more reflectedarguing on the pros and cons of some strategy;

• Crucial (or better: all future) decisions can (ought to) be done exclusively based

on provable, objectively stable pieces of information, data and knowledge, while;

• Sufficient transparency must be provided to all the stakeholders

With “performance being the personal ability of an individual to change andadapt,” it takes “education providing the ability to be open and ready, able to learn

on all levels.”

Dealing with conflicts smartly and searching for integrative problem solutions aremore closely linked to each other than hitherto used to be assumed Hence, lifelonglearning, achievement of quality and competences will get an ever larger relevanceboth to secure our common future in the society and for personal lives in the spheres

of work and profession, family, leisure time, culture and politics likewise

The individual has to develop his ability to learn for this purpose and keep onlearning as the way to obtain personal competence with regards to social, occupational

Trang 37

2 Teaching Green Analytical Chemistry on the Example … 23

become crucial factors for innovation and capability of social self-structuring in order

to compete successfully on an international level, rather than losing contact withrecent social and cultural developments

We now need a broad movement to promote lifelong learning, both to develop and

the future with regards to its economic, ecological, cultural and social perspectives

of further development The system of education must provide the basis to achieve

Lifelong learning does not just mean to involve as many citizens as possible allover their life phases (at least until retirement) but has qualitative drawbacks on edu-cation policy also Lifelong learning requires to change the attitude toward learning,making learning a process that individual must pursue and shape all along lifetimeresponsible for himself or herself With economic innovations and changes in societyoccurring ever faster, there is responsibility to autonomously adapt one’s kinds ofqualification A new cultural sense is required which integrates learning into the pro-cesses of everyday life, acknowledging this and fairly estimates outcomes against

offered by schools, professional training, university or secondary occupational cation will not lose their significance, but must be corroborated by a new key feature

edu-of informal learning, which takes place in the “school edu-of life,” in social networks,everyday life, at workbench, in family and leisure time This is really a new princi-ple of learning which must be developed, focused on one’s own responsibility and

With a high degree of individual responsibility and autonomy being required,motivation and support of hitherto less advantaged groups must not be disregarded;these guys otherwise would not be capable of fulfilling such a task of self-motivationand structuring, as a rule Education politics and practical education rather must beconcerned and aware that nobody is taken off his educational and career chances

to avoid producing new obstacles in obtaining education and training The present

1In the German original: “soziale Demokratie” This term does refer/allude to “soziale

Mark-twirtschaft,” the concept put forward by later Federal chancellor Ludwig Erhard (1897–1977), sometimes also dubbed “the Rhineland way of doing capitalism” rather than, for example, “Archiv der sozialen Demokratie” which is the central part of the party archives of the German Social Democratic Party (SPD) Anyway, in Germany the link between democracy/federal structuring of state and social norms is part of the constitution and even officially protected against any change

(Grundgesetz articles 20, 79, 116).

2 In Germany, this really became a popular term: “bildungsferne Schichten” (people who live in utmost avoidance of education) The Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) studies revealed Germany to be the one country in the developed world where educational and thereafter occupational chances depend mostly on the educational status (and income levels) of the parents, more so than even in many developing countries So a vicious circle can be established (parental poverty precludes education of the children to a level now required even to obtain a reasonable apprenticeship position) which is avoided only by more active measures pointing to the corresponding milieus and urban neighbourhoods.

Trang 38

serious level and extent of exclusion of people and groups can be reduced in thenear future only if the array of educational contents and kinds becomes more closelyrelated to ongoing economic, cultural changes and those in society, while the offers

With lifelong learning becoming the paradigm of education, tasks and structures ofclassical agents of education must also adapt A culture of learning which conforms

to recent demands takes more and novel kinds of coaching and services, but alsoneeds an enhanced degree of flexibility, self-responsibility and communication.These in turn require novel kinds of partnership with “consumers” and users of thisbroadened array of education Institutions of education and culture, those concernedwith social and youth welfare, clubs and enterprises, single persons and the activities

of all of these must be pushed and motivated to investigate novel ways of learning

Border transgressing regions of education which provide the chances of lifelonglearning working, and education to all children and youngsters but also parents,teachers and other adults, must be promoted better than before and get (placed)into the focus of public interest Of course, diverging interests of political powersand parties, regional and national particular notions and interests will persist oneither side of the border, but there are also local commons which are a topic of(transcultural) education as such and itself can and must reshape the present topic—focussed into ability—focused curricula of education A higher level of education

becomes more attractive when people notice in remote border regions also: tua res agitur; it is your (local) matters that matter, rather than (just) the views and issues

of some far away metropolitan region, far away in both topographical and mentalterms Besides better ways of overcoming local problems, this will enhance the wishand positive feelings on lifelong learning, producing competences, self-confidenceand thus finally increases occupational chances in border regions also By the way,

a kind of education defined and constructed like this is going to both catalyze andpay itself in the long term mainly

There are plenty and more of historical burdens and present deviating interests;hence, the first step must be constructing an integrative mode of conflict management

on the very site which there gains support by some democratic majority

Rely on trust rather than treaty—this will work only if the above attitude is given.Diversities of opinions and religious faiths will only become a bonus and a chance

to achieve more stability if we become aware of some ethical consensus which can

be learnt and which is going to link us, including Muslim or agnostic fellow citizens

beliefs and likewise solidaristic acts toward the weaker

Trang 39

2 Teaching Green Analytical Chemistry on the Example … 25

Fig 2.1 Trust, variety and solidarity provide an indispensable blueprint for solving problems in

the regions of education, think tanks and the approaches of “turbodemocracy” [72]

Handling and Identify Integrative Solutions

for Problems of Society

Problems and questions which recently arise in society are distinguished by disciplinary and international ranges; hence, highly specific expert knowledge andcorresponding skills will not solve or even characterize and define such problems,but it takes the readiness of everyone who is involved to mitigate among the oftenmost diverse individual interests and wishes Hence, the crucial feature of an inte-grative problem solution rests not so much with technology or funding but with theactual “ability of everybody to honestly and convincingly achieve a solution which

multi-is acceptable to all stakeholders.”

There are many features of conflicting double binds in modern societies: cians and the parties which “made” and support them, officials including universityprofessors in public service domains and authorities, physicians and their medicalresponsibility and ethos, TV producers and TV watching quotas, mothers and fatherswho want both to perform and progress in occupation and responsibly, sincerely risetheir children, they all are faced with conflicts which cannot be resolved and block

Trang 40

politi-potentials for overcoming these and yet other conflicts even though all are convincedthat it takes genuine professional ethics, genuine convictions and their active real-ization in everyday life to ensure a sustainable and justly motivated structure ofsociety!

In many different societies, psychological obstacles to adhere to these rules areposed by many citizens who already became solidly mistrusted and alienated byactions and premises put forward by politics itself This alienation is just a symptombut it can block a real, honest dialog in society which is devoted to solving prob-lems by innovative modes of thinking up to the point that it becomes impossible

informed about the situation before even starting a public discussion on how to dealwith it, including the side effects which would arise if the actual situation is neglectedany longer This will be the first rate of a “pound (weight) of honesty”: politicians andothers in charge of decisions pertinent to society must be courageous enough to be(recklessly and fully) honest Viable data on the situation and complete transparencytoward all ones who are or could become involved are self-evident conditions to getany reasonable acting which can make a meaningful future

of and Integrating the Present Problems?

Realistic estimates of the time left to mankind to tackle problems in an integrativemanner on global scales, implement and complete them, range from 500 to 1000 years

this kind of global change Maybe by 3000, there will be some merger between human

the inputs and outputs among all the existing biocoenoses for common and mutualbenefit which to plan and realize must be the priority and aim of all human activitiesthen To achieve this end, it will take 1000 years of global education, which must ofcourse be developed, discussed and effectively implemented for gaining acceptanceamong all mankind The practical result which is inevitable is to agree on a globallycommon criterion of completely just distribution of material and non-material goodsand items among all people living on Earth Before this can be reached, constantglobal peace must be achieved, which will be about 500 years in the future Inaddition, this will be the period of time until the downfall of the last dictatorship onEarth This is another precondition for the era of stable global peace predicted by anumber of colleagues, which in turn is indispensable for justice in the above sense,namely, the just and balanced distribution of all the essential goods

neces-sary changes in a “turbodemocracy” once there is common acceptance of educationbeing most urgent: until 2030 This is the period of time it will take to harmonize andequalize in rank intercultural and intracultural activities regarding the many diverse

Ngày đăng: 10/05/2022, 14:43

Nguồn tham khảo

Tài liệu tham khảo Loại Chi tiết
57. European Commission, Opinion of the Scientific Committee on Food on the Risks to Human Health of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons in food (expressed on 4 December 2002) Docu- ment SCF/CS/CNTM/PAH/29 Final, 2002. Available from: http://europa.eu.int/comm/food/fs/sc/scf/index_en.html Link
1. Koel M, Kaljurand M (2006) Application of the principles of green chemistry in analytical chemistry. Pure and Appl Chem 78(11):1993–2002 Khác
2. Keith LH, Gron LU, Young JL (2007) Green analytical methodologies. Chemical Rev 107(6):2695–2708 Khác
6. Tobiszewski M, Tsakovski S, Simeonov V, Namie´snik J (2013) Application of multivariate statistics in assessment of green analytical chemistry parameters of analytical methodologies.Green Chem 15(6):1615–1623 Khác
7. Bystrzanowska M, Tobiszewski M (2018) How can analysts use multicriteria decision analysis?.TrAC Trends in Anal Chem 105:98–105 Khác
8. Lahdelma R, Salminen P, Hokkanen J (2000) Using multicriteria methods in environmental planning and management. Environ Manag 26(6):595–605 Khác
9. Mardani A, Jusoh A, MD Nor K, Khalifah Z, Zakwan N, Valipour A (2015) Multiple criteria decision-making techniques and their applications—a review of the literature from 2000 to 2014. Econ Res (Ekonomska Istraživanja) 28(1):16–571 Khác
10. Huang IB, Keisler J, Linkov I (2011) Multi-criteria decision analysis in environmental sciences:ten years of applications and trends. Sci Total Environ 409:3578–3594 Khác
11. Smilde AK, Knevelman A, Coenegracht PMJ (1986) Introduction of multi-criteria decision making to optimization procedures for high-performance liquid chromatographic separations.J Chromatogr 369:1–10 Khác
12. Smilde AK, Bruins CHP, Doornbos DA (1987) Optimization of the reversed-phase high- performance liquid chromatographic separation of synthetic estrogenic and progestogenic steroids using the multi-criteria decision making method. J Chromatogr 410:1–12 Khác
13. Eagan P, Weinberg L (1999) Application of analytic hierarchy process techniques to streamlined life-cycle analysis of two anodizing processes. Environ Sci Technol 33(9):1495–1500 14. Khan FI, Sadiq R (2005) Risk-based prioritization of air pollution monitoring using fuzzysynthetic evaluation technique. Environ Monit Assess 105(1–3):261–283 Khác
17. Tobiszewski M, Tsakovski S, Simeonov V, Namie´snik J, Pena-Pereira F (2015) A solvent selection guide based on chemometrics and multicriteria decision analysis. Green Chem 17(10):4773–4785 Khác
18. Tobiszewski M, Orłowski A (2015) Multicriteria decision analysis in ranking of analytical procedures for aldrin determination in water. J Chromatogr A 1387:116–122 Khác
19. Bigus P, Namie´snik J, Tobiszewski M (2016) Application of multicriteria decision analysis in solvent type optimization for chlorophenols determination with a dispersive liquid–liquid microextraction. J Chromatogr A 1446:21–26 Khác
20. Serna J, Martinez END, Rincón PCN, Camargo M, Gálvez D (2016) Multi-criteria decision analysis for the selection of sustainable chemical process routes during early design stages.Chem Eng Res Des 113:28–49 Khác
21. J˛edrkiewicz R, Orłowski A, Namie´snik J, Tobiszewski M (2016) Green analytical chemistry introduction to chloropropanols determination at no economic and analytical performance costs? Talanta 147:282–288 Khác
25. Hicks AL (2017) Using multi criteria decision analysis to evaluate nanotechnology: nAg enabled textiles as a case study. Environ Sci: Nano 4(8):1647–1655 Khác
26. Xu D, Lv L, Ren J, Shen W, Wei SA, Dong L (2017) Life cycle sustainability assessment of chemical processes: a vector-based three-dimensional algorithm coupled with AHP. Ind Eng Chem Res 56(39):11216–11227 Khác
27. Gadge PA, Waghmare AC (2017) A topsis-based Taguchi optimization to determine the reverse osmosis process parameter for distillery effluent in ZLD. IJARIIT 3(1):521–529 Khác
28. Cinelli M, Coles SR, Nadagouda MN, Błaszczy´nski J, Słowi´nski R, Varma RS, Kirwan K (2017) Robustness analysis of a green chemistry-based model for the classification of silver nanoparticles synthesis processes. J Clean Prod 162:938–948 Khác