Wood quality: resource to end-use "You can't make a Silk Purse out of a Sow's Ear.“ Jonathan Swift 1667 - 1745 Content • Definition • The link between resource quality and end use
Trang 1Wood quality: resource to end-use
"You can't make a Silk Purse
out of a Sow's Ear.“
Jonathan Swift (1667 - 1745)
Content
• Definition
• The link between resource quality and end use
• Growth manipulation and wood quality
• Genetic improvement and wood quality
• Measuring wood quality
Art work, MONA
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Definition of wood quality
• Wood quality is the combination of
characteristics of the log and
properties of its wood that affect:
– the recovery of useful products and
– their value and serviceability in
intended applications (Hillis 2000)
• The characteristics are not consistent
For any log, they vary with:
– the species of the source tree,
– its growing conditions and age at
harvest,
– the section of the tree that the log
comes from, and
– the part of the log sampled
• While generally applied to the log, the
term can be applied at other stages
during production and use
Veneer at DEEDI, Qld
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
The link between resource quality and
end use
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Resource to end-use market: sawn wood
Patterns like this demonstrate that differences exist in the value and serviceability
in the applications of sawn material drawn from different resources
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Limits on the function of timber products
• Timber product functionality is limited by:
– The form of the log
• Its shape, length and diameter
• Its primary wood properties
– Size constraints on recovered pieces – The directionality of its key properties – Its structural consistency
Trang 2Wood quality: resource to end-use
Table of resultant primary wood elements
Long grain
elements Poles Timber Scantling Veneer <2.4mm thick
Veneer
>2.4mm thick
Veneer Strips
Short grain
elements
Chips or
flakes Strands Splinters Shavings Sawdust
Wood flour
Fiberal
Elements Fibre bundles Whole fibers Macerated fibers Fibrils
Chemical
Decreasing width and/or thickness
Increasing formability, decreasing strength/weight ratio, reducing dependence on log quality, increasing homogeneity and isotropy
From Marra, 1972, Wood products into the future
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Log resources obviously differ
What are desirable log and wood characteristics?
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Desirable wood properties
• Different wood properties can be loosely
grouped under four headings, namely:
– Visual character;
– Wood properties - Usage;
– Wood properties - Processing; and
– Log Characteristic - Form
• The groupings are not exclusive and
assessment of their importance varies at
the production stage and point of sale
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Visual Character
Clear wood - present 2.3 4.1 2.4 Grain - even 2.0 4.2 2.3 Colour consistency
Colour - pale - present 2.0 2.9 2.2 Gum Vein -kino -present 2.3 1.2 2.0
Insect feature- present 1.8 1.4 1.8 Knots - present 1.5 1.2 1.7
Source: Nolan et al 2005 Eucalypt Plantations for Solid Wood Products in Australia FWPRDC project PN04.3002
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Wood Properties -Usage
Wood Properties -Usage Rounds Appearance Structural
Source: Nolan et al 2005 Eucalypt Plantations for Solid Wood Products in Australia FWPRDC project PN04.3002
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Wood Properties-Processing
Tension wood - low 3.8 4.7 4.5
Growth strain - low 3.8 4.4 3.9
Internal checking - low 2.5 4.7 3.4
Surface checking - low 3.0 4.6 2.9
Collapse - low 2.3 4.4 3.6
Shrinkage - low 2.5 4.0 3.5
Shrinkage ratio -tangential/radial 2.5 3.1 2.4
Source: Nolan et al 2005 Eucalypt Plantations for Solid Wood Products in Australia FWPRDC project PN04.3002
Trang 3Wood quality: resource to end-use
Log characteristic - Form
branch frequency - low 4.0 4.7 3.9
End split - low 4.3 4.0 4.0
Knotty core diameter -small 3.0 4.9 4.2
Log form - taper - low 3.3 4.0 3.8
Heartwood content - high 3.0 3.6 3.3
Sapwood thickness - low 2.8 3.5 3.2
Heart / corewood diameter - low 3.0 3.1 2.9
Source: Nolan et al 2005 Eucalypt Plantations for Solid Wood Products in Australia FWPRDC project PN04.3002
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Log diameter and value recovery
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Log small end diameter (cm)
r = 0.68
Plot of log diameter and recovery for pruned eucalypts processed
with standard industry practice (Washusen and Clark, in prep)
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Log quality and value recovery
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Growth manipulation and wood
quality
Silviculture is day-to-day forestry techniques used to modify growth
and wood quality
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Forestry for wood quality
• Wood quality correlates
strongly with:
– The genetic characteristics
of the resource and
– Growth manipulation
through silvicultural
practice
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Limits on manipulation
• Forest management objectives limit silvicultural options and the potential for manipulation
• Manipulation is constrained with native forestry:
– wood production is only one
objective in broad multi-use forestry
• Manipulation is encouraged with plantation forestry:
– wood production for a given
target market is a primary objective
Trang 4Wood quality: resource to end-use
Variables for manipulation
• Trees for harvest may differ
through being:
– Different genetic background
(between or within species),
– Grown to different ages
– Grown in different environments
– Managed differently over their
growing life
• Even with all these factors
being constant, grown trees
still differ from tree to tree
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Different genetic background
• For native forests, trees from a site generally provide the seeds used
to regenerate a site
– Genetic selection is generally not an option
• For plantation forestry, trees with desirable characteristics are selected from growth trials, and propagated in seed orchards
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Genetic assessment and selection
Selecting preferred genetic material
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Managed differently: silvicultural approaches
For a given site and species, the major silvicultural options for plantations are:
• Thinning
– Reducing the stocking levels of trees to give each tree more space and resources
– The result is bigger trees and larger logs
• Pruning
– Removing branches to encourage the growth of clear wood
– The result is more consistent, high value wood in the logs
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Managed differently: unthinned, unpruned
Landscape view
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Managed differently: unthinned, unpruned
Close up view
Trang 5Wood quality: resource to end-use
Managed differently: thinned
Relation between crown width and dbh in E globulus grown in Galicia, Spain.
Source: Nutto and Touza (2004), Figure 2
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Managed differently: thinned
heavier thinning = higher basic density
Basic density versus final stocking in 33-year-old E grandis in South Africa
(Malan and Hoon 1992) – All treatments established at 6,850 stems per
hectare, multiple thinning operations
0.500 0.520 0.540 0.560 0.580 0.600 0.620 0.640 0.660 0.680 0.700
final stocking (sph)
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Managed differently: prune
(a) The stem cross-section highlighting the defect knotty core The knotty core is a product
of the diameter over-pruned branch stubs (DOS); plus the additional growth before clear
wood is produced to give the DOO, and (b) the tapering characteristic of the knotty core
within the tree Source: Montagu et al (2003a), Figure 2
While the branches are still green
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Managed differently: thin, prune, wait
10 year old unthinned, unpruned E.nitens 28 year old thinned, pruned E nitens
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Measuring and sorting for wood
quality
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Grading for forest products
Harvested trees yield logs of different quality and characteristics up the stem
These are graded (and separated) at the harvesting site, and checked in the log yard
Trang 6Wood quality: resource to end-use
Log grade definitions
Sweep
Grain
tight kino <3mm width : length % of diameter 25 200
tight kino >3mm width : length% of diameter 25 100
loose kino/kino pockets/shakes : length % of diameter 100
stain
allowable defective quarters
GRADE
<20% of diameter over 2.4 m length
<1:8 ul
<1:10
ul 200 dark 25
light
Grades 1, 2, 3 and 4 are equivalent to Victorian A, B, C and D grades
Grades 5 & 6 are research grades devised for plantations
Source: Innes et al 2008 Determining the Economics of Processing Plantation Eucalypts for Solid Timber Products, FWPRDC project PN04.3007
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Defective quarters
Logs to be graded Defective quarter of the log
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Log grade and value recovery
$0
$50
$100
$150
$200
$250
$300
$350
$400
log grade 1 log grade 2 log grade 3 log grade 4 log grade 5 log grade 6
sawlog grade
E nitens 26yo - thinned, pruned butt log - ITC Newood
E nitens 26yo - thinned, pruned upper log (unpruned) - ITC Newood
E nitens 26yo - fibre - ITC Newood
,E globulus 19yo - thinned pruned butt log - ITC Newood
Total product value per cubic metre of sawlog, by log-grade and log
type - logs processed by ITC Newood
Source: Innes et al 2008 Determining the Economics of Processing Plantation Eucalypts for Solid Timber Products, FWPRDC project PN04.3007
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Log grades
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Log grades & merchandising
Modern harvesting heads measure and can access other properties
using NDE tools, such as near infrared spectroscopy (NIR)
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Grades are confirmed in the log yard
Trang 7Wood quality: resource to end-use
Non-destructive evaluation (NDE) AWV
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Non-destructive evaluation (NDE) AWV
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Summary
• There is a link between resource quality,
production value and end use
• Wood quality can be manipulated by
– Genetic improvement
– Silvicultural action
• Forestry objectives limit the potential for
manipulation
• Logs are generally visually graded for
quality NDE processes are being
introduced
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use
Thanks to Patrick Cook
www.csaw.utas.edu.au
KDA503/335 Timber, its origin and characteristics
Wood quality: resource to end-use