This lecture argues that through inclusive finance, companies can make money and help solve the global problem of poverty. By inclusive finance we mean opening access to high-quality financial services to everyone who needs them, especially low-income and previously excluded people. We also discuss how microfinance—until recently a small, close-knit community of institutions offering microloans—is evolving into an essential part of global financial systems and engaging with new private-sector players.
Trang 1Micro Financing & Micro
Leasing
An Introduction
Trang 2Summary of last Lecture
• Microfinance Background and
Introduction.
Trang 3• Xavier sells frozen fish and a few
groceries at a dusty intersection on the outskirts of Maputo, Mozambique
• Wearing a crisp white shirt and tie, he
poses before an electric typewriter in his kiosk Everything about the picture,
including the pride in his face as he looks
at the camera, reflects his striving to
become a successful businessman
Trang 4• Big institutions of society had either failed
or ignored him, except for the Coca-Cola distributor that brought him cases of soft drinks to sell Xavier was putting the
pieces of prosperity together for his family
on his own by building his business He
had a loan from a microfinance
cooperative, but it was small, suitable only for financing a little extra stock
Trang 5• Xavier could be a loyal customer for many other financial services—savings accounts
to help him build for the future, a
home-improvement or fixed asset loan, health
insurance, and remittance services to
send money to his relatives in South Africa
Trang 6• Xavier could be a loyal customer for many other financial services—savings accounts
to help him build for the future, a
home-improvement or fixed asset loan, health
insurance, and remittance services to
send money to his relatives in South
Africa
Trang 7• The success of microfinance institutions in making small loans to people like Xavier has begun a revolution in financial sectors around the world
Trang 8• The consequent media attention to
microfinance is leading the business
community to consider what their roles might be in bringing financial services to population groups that have long been marginalized
Trang 9• The gaps we see in Xavier’s financial needs point toward many opportunities that await entrepreneurial companies prepared to engage the low-income
market
Trang 10• Imagine a world in which a farm couple in the highlands of Nicaragua saves enough money to provide for their old age, a slum dweller in Mumbai who falls ill gets
medical treatment without sacrificing her
life savings, and a snack vendor in
Uganda borrows money and builds a small restaurant
Trang 11• Imagine that these examples are not
special cases, but are multiplied hundreds
of millions of times across the world
Trang 12• Now imagine that these fortunate events are made possible by financial services provided by private companies These
companies are touted in the highest
business circles as savvy and successful
—and valued and trusted by their
low-income customers Finally, imagine that for these companies, reducing global
poverty goes hand in hand with profitable business operations and strong market valuation
Trang 13• This course argues that through inclusive finance, companies can make money and help solve the global problem of poverty
By inclusive finance we mean opening
access to high-quality financial services to everyone who needs them, especially low-income and previously excluded people
Trang 14• We also discuss how microfinance—until recently a small, close-knit community of institutions offering microloans—is
evolving into an essential part of global financial systems and engaging with new private-sector players
Trang 15• Today, perhaps only a fraction of
low-income people around the world have
such life-supporting financial services But many of the building blocks for universal access to financial services are now in
place Profitable models of financial
service delivery exist, and private
companies can emulate them and bring
them to scale
Trang 16• Ten years ago, when people first started to talk with major corporations about their
role in inclusive finance, the only people
who would listen were from corporate
philanthropy departments The Citibank
Foundation, one of the most prescient,
began working with microfinance
organizations, in the 1980s
Trang 17• As valuable as this support was to the
growth of microfinance, it did not come
close to tapping the real potential of
Citibank to contribute to financial inclusion
Trang 18• And, while the foundation work contributed
to Citi’s reputation for corporate
citizenship, it made no direct contribution
to Citi’s bottom line Citibank knew this
and did something about it But that’s a
story for later
Trang 19What Has Changed?
• New technologies and delivery channels improve the cost equation for handling the small transactions of the poor And leading microfinance institutions not only prove
that low-income people can be loyal
customers, they also show how to serve
these customers profitably
Trang 20What Has Changed?
• An increasing number of countries have
an environment favorable for inclusive
finance: political and economic stability, an improved regulatory framework, and a
growing domestic market with increasing spending power
Trang 21What Has Changed?
• University of Michigan Business professor
C K Prahalad and Stuart L Hart
summarize the benefits to business and society when businesses operate at what they call the “bottom of the pyramid.”
Trang 22What Has Changed?
• This is a time for multinational
corporations (MNCs) to look at
globalization strategies through a new lens
of inclusive capitalism For companies with the resources and persistence to compete
at the bottom of the world economic
pyramid, the prospective rewards include growth, profits, and incalculable
contributions to humankind
Trang 23What Has Changed?
• Until fairly recently, barriers to entry kept most private actors out of inclusive
finance These barriers were both real—
like the high cost of processing small
transactions—and imagined—like the idea that low-income people would be
unreliable customers What has changed?
Trang 24What Has Changed?
• MNC investment at “the bottom of the
pyramid” [BOP] means lifting billions of
people out of poverty and desperation,
averting the social decay, political chaos, terrorism, and environmental meltdown
that is certain to continue if the gap
between rich and poor countries continues
to widen
Trang 25What Has Changed?
• The acronym BOP has become a popular way to refer to this market of 4 billion
people who live on less than $3,000 per year and the economic opportunities they represent
Trang 26What Has Changed?
• We use the term here as a convenient
shorthand for the people inclusive finance targets In fact, we are indebted to
Prahalad for alerting business leaders to the BOP market opportunity Prahalad
focuses on multinationals
Trang 27What Has Changed?
• We note that this increasingly includes
businesses from developing countries, like CEMEX of Mexico and ICICI Bank of
India, which are becoming regional or
global players And we highlight the
importance of smaller, local companies
serving their own markets
Trang 28The Benefits of Private-Sector
Engagement in Inclusive Finance
• Benefits to the Private Sector
• Today, the business executives are hoping
to achieve through inclusive finance the
following:
Trang 29The Benefits of Private-Sector
Engagement in Inclusive Finance
• Short-term profits Low-income people
are good clients They will pay for quality financial services The success of Mexican retailer Grupo Elektra in launching Banco Azteca demonstrates that companies can tap existing know-how to create profitable business lines for this sector
Trang 30The Benefits of Private-Sector
Engagement in Inclusive Finance
• Long-term growth and market share
Phone maker Nokia assumes that the
majority of the world’s next billion mobile
subscribers will come from emerging
markets
Trang 31The Benefits of Private-Sector
Engagement in Inclusive Finance
• This may also hold for the next billion
banking customers Companies that
connect with the broad base of the world’s population will have a much stronger
foundation for the future
Trang 32The Benefits of Private-Sector
Engagement in Inclusive Finance
• Learning for innovation Creative
solutions to reach low-income clients may
be relevant for other lines of business
Trang 33The Benefits of Private-Sector
Engagement in Inclusive Finance
• For example, some companies are
learning from the dynamics of group
lending and peer pressure in microfinance
to resolve payment issues in other areas.Akhuwat Foundation
Trang 34The Benefits of Private-Sector
Engagement in Inclusive Finance
• These points suggest the untapped
market opportunity that inclusive finance
presents, a “blue ocean” opportunity Kim
and Mauborgne, in their influential Harvard
Business Review article, “Blue Ocean
Strategy,” write, “Blue oceans denote all
the industries not in existence today—the unknown market space, untainted by
competition.”
Trang 35The Benefits of Private-Sector
Engagement in Inclusive Finance
• They argue that when new demand is
created, with few contestants for market
share, profitable and rapid growth
becomes possible
Trang 36The Benefits of Private-Sector
Engagement in Inclusive Finance
• Blue ocean opportunities arise most often when the boundaries of an existing
industry change, and inclusive finance
involves just this kind of radical shift in the boundaries of the financial system, to
include the previously excluded
Trang 37The Benefits of Private-Sector
Engagement in Inclusive Finance
• Additional benefits can accrue to
companies from the social value
associated with inclusive finance
• Goodwill Creating social value enhances
a company’s brand and reputation It
builds goodwill with increasingly socially
minded stakeholders—shareholders,
governments, and community leaders
Trang 38The Benefits of Private-Sector
Engagement in Inclusive Finance
• Employee loyalty and satisfaction
Employees take pride in being part of a
business that is making a difference
Trang 39The Benefits of Private-Sector
Engagement in Inclusive Finance
• Of course, companies may also find other benefits specific to their own situations
• For example, Banco Pichincha of Ecuador initiated microlending in part to leverage
its underused bank branches and earn
more revenue from its excess liquidity
Trang 40The Benefits of Private-Sector
Engagement in Inclusive Finance
• Building a business case for inclusive
finance requires delving into the
challenges each company will encounter
on the road
Trang 41The Benefits of Private-Sector
Engagement in Inclusive Finance
• The challenges are at least as important to consider as the benefits, and we will
explore them thoroughly throughout the
course
Trang 42The Benefits of Private-Sector
Engagement in Inclusive Finance
• Serving low-income markets with financial services requires good solutions—and
often new solutions—to familiar business elements, like marketing, product design, technology, finance, and alliances We do not claim that inclusive finance is easy; but then, few successful new business efforts are
Trang 43Benefits from the Private
Sector
• Private involvement in inclusive finance brings a number of benefits to society,
starting with the direct and obvious
benefits of making a difference to
customers’ lives When people become valued financial-services customers, they come one step closer to social and
economic enfranchisement
Trang 44Benefits from the Private
Sector
• Many of them use financial services to
move their families out of poverty or to
build their businesses
• The human impact of financial services
can be an enormous source of motivation for businesspeople to get involved, as
long as it is coupled with business
success
Trang 45Benefits from the Private
Sector
• But can’t the nonprofit or government
sectors do this just as well? In fact, many nonprofits and governments do an
excellent job of providing financial
services, especially (as we will see) in
reaching out to ever more difficult market segments
Trang 46Benefits from the Private
Sector
• Yet there are tremendous economic
benefits when the private sector gets
involved, starting with the greater potential
of private markets to reach all those who need services
Trang 47Benefits from the Private
Sector
• Moreover, as commercial scale becomes the driver of inclusive finance, it frees
philanthropic and public resources to
tackle still unsolved problems in other
sectors
Trang 48Benefits from the Private
Sector
• Equally important, the dynamics of
competitive markets stimulate innovation and reward efficiency The result is better service quality and lower costs, as has
already become evident in some highly
competitive microlending markets like
Bolivia and Peru, where interest rates
have fallen and product range has grown
Trang 49Benefits from the Private
Sector
• The close interaction that is emerging
between business and nonprofits in
microfinance may also have the indirect effect of introducing proven business
methods and models to help nonprofits become more effective, accountable, and sustainable
Trang 50The Road to Inclusive Finance
• This course provides a road map for
business executives and investors
thinking about greater involvement in
inclusive finance The map looks
something like this
Trang 51The Road to Inclusive Finance
• We start, in Part 1, with the market,
beginning up close with portraits of three clients from different continents and then stepping back to the scale and purchasing power of the global market We describe who is serving the market today—and who
is not
Trang 52The Road to Inclusive Finance
• This sketch sets up the next topic: how to take advantage of the opportunities Then
we will examine the unique challenges of providing financial services for low-income people and how companies can solve
these challenges in designing products
like microleasing, housing finance,
microinsurance, and remittances
Trang 53The Road to Inclusive Finance
• Part 2 asks about strategic entry points
We highlight three main business models that companies are using to get involved: banks launching their own microfinance
operations (“downscaling”), partnerships between banks and retail networks to get services closer to customers, and
investors putting debt and equity into
microfinance institutions
Trang 54The Road to Inclusive Finance
• Part 3 discusses the building blocks of an inclusive financial system, where some of the most exciting new developments are taking place, like the penetration of card-based payments, mobile phone banking, and credit scoring
Trang 55The Road to Inclusive Finance
• Part 3 discusses the building blocks of an inclusive financial system, where some of the most exciting new developments are taking place, like the penetration of card-based payments, mobile phone banking, and credit scoring This section also looks
at the supporting role played by capital
markets and governments
Trang 56The Road to Inclusive Finance
• In Part 4 we turn to social responsibility
We argue that inclusive finance gives
companies a great opportunity to align
social value with long-run business
success if they incorporate social issues creatively into strategy
Trang 57The Road to Inclusive Finance
• The explicit incorporation of social aims
into business strategy has been one of the distinguishing features of microfinance
and can become a hallmark of successful inclusive finance as well
Trang 58The Road to Inclusive Finance
• In this part we also discuss the downside risk—for customers, providers, and the
industry—of failing to protect customers
from harm The section ends with the
challenge of measuring the social bottom line