Advanced concrete technology3 curing

Advanced concrete technology3 curing Advanced concrete technology3 curing Advanced concrete technology3 curing Advanced concrete technology3 curing Advanced concrete technology3 curing Advanced concrete technology3 curing Advanced concrete technology3 curing Advanced concrete technology3 curing Advanced concrete technology3 curing Advanced concrete technology3 curing Advanced concrete technology3 curing Advanced concrete technology3 curing Advanced concrete technology3 curing

Curing

Bryan Marsh

~ ~i~i~i~ ~ i i i ¸¸ The aim of this chapter is to examine when and why curing of in-situ concrete is necessary and what effect curing has on its hardened properties

A typical definition of curing (BS 8110, 1997) is 'the process of preventing the loss of moisture from the concrete whilst maintaining a satisfactory temperature regime' This particular definition adds that the curing regime should prevent the development of high- temperature gradients within the concrete

Many other definitions exist which include references to hydration, durability and cost but there are three basic elements to consider:

• Moisture

• Heat

• Time

According to the British Standard for the structural use of concrete, BS 8110 (1997), the intention of curing is to protect concrete against:

• premature drying out, particularly by solar radiation and wind (plastic shrinkage)

• leaching out by rain and flowing water

• rapid cooling during the first few days after placing

• high intemal thermal gradients

• low temperature or frost

• vibration and impact which may disrupt the concrete and interfere with bond to reinforcement

Adequate curing will facilitate, but not necessarily ensure, the optimal development of the surface zone of fresh, newly cast concrete into strong, impermeable, crack-free and durable-hardened concrete The objective is to keep the concrete saturated, or as near saturated as possible, for sufficient time for the original water-filled space to become filled to the desired extent by cement hydration products According to the research reviewed in CIRIA (1997), the depth of the surface zone directly affected by curing can

be up to 20 mm in temperate climatic conditions, and up to 50 mm in more extreme arid conditions Properties of the concrete beyond this zone are unlikely to be affected significantly

by normal curing

It is, however, this surface zone that is often relied upon to provide many of the essential requisites of a concrete structure or element such as abrasion and chemical resistance and protection of embedded reinforcement Figure 3.1 shows the relative depths from the surface at which various properties will be affected by inadequate curing The importance of appropriate curing must therefore not be overlooked

Concrete surface , / z~

,4

,4

A z~

z~

Reinforcement

z~

,4

</

Weathering

Abrasion

Corrosion

,d

Strength The arrows indicate the region of concrete influencing the deterioration

mechanisms in question

The rate of evaporation of water from the surface, taking into account the combined influences of the ambient temperature and relative humidity, the concrete temperature, and the wind velocity can be estimated from Figure 3.2 taken from ACI 308 (1992) This

standard requires that curing measures are taken if the predicted rate of evaporation exceeds 1.0 kg/m2/h, to prevent plastic shrinkage cracking, but also recommends that such measures may be needed if the rate exceeds 0.5 kg/m2/h

°C

5 15 25 35

0.8

Relative

humidity 100% / , ~ 0 / ~ A I , / " ~ Oo%,,o

40 50 60 70 80 90 130 ~ ,,t.~l,/¢~

Air temperature (°F)

-

0.7

To use this chart:

1 Enter with air temperature, '~ 0.6

move up to relative humidity

t -

O 0.5

2 Move right to concrete "~

temperature o

ca 0.4

3 Move down to wind velocity >

"6 0.3

4 Move/eft;, read approx, rate o

of evaporation

rr 0.2

0.1

I

I

',

2.0

"

~ _ ~ ~'~_, J ~ ,

Figure 3.2 The effect of concrete and air temperatures, relative humidity, and wind velocity on the rate of

evaporation of surface moisture from concrete (ACI 308, 1992)

In the absence of any deliberate curing measures the rate of water loss during the first few hours is similar to that of any wet surface Nevertheless, once the concrete has set, the rate of evaporation of water from the near surface of concrete in temperate climates is relatively slow (depending upon the concrete composition, actual weather conditions, etc.) and hydration of concrete in the outer zone will be able to proceed to a certain degree Research has shown that in the absence of any curing (laboratory air storage) the

time taken for the relative humidity in 0.59 water/cement ratio Portland cement concrete

to fall to 95 per cent is 4 days at a depth of 7.5 mm, 18 days at 11.5 mm, and 111 days

at 33.5 mm (Parrott, 1988) These times will be greater for lower w/c concretes and higher for blended cements These figures, however, relate to controlled laboratory conditions and will be affected in practice by ambient relative humidity, air temperature, wind speed and concrete temperature

Relative humidity within concrete can be measured using electronic probes inserted into pre-drilled holes of the required depth These probes typically work by dew-point sensing on a chilled plate or by use of a humidity-sensing film sensor that produces an electrical change such as capacitance or resistance (Dill, 2000) They are best suited to laboratory studies and are unlikely to be encountered on site

The most common methods of site curing of in-situ concrete are:

• formwork retention

• suspension of covering above the surface before the concrete has set (horizontal surfaces)

• spraying with water

• ponding with water

• covering with wet sand, earth, sawdust, straw, or periodically wetted hessian or cotton mats, or the use of an absorbent covering with access to water

• application of a curing membrane

• waterproof reinforced paper or plastic sheeting

• tenting or other shelter against drying winds

• sunshields

• covering with an insulating layer or heated enclosure

No specific measures are needed when the ambient conditions of moisture, humidity and temperature are sufficiently favourable to provide adequate curing by themselves But great caution should be exercised in making such a j u d g e m e n t - general assumptions about climate can be dangerous, particularly in temperate climates such as the UK For

example, the annual average relative humidity, which may be approximately 80 per cent,

is of absolutely no relevance on a hot dry summer day when the relative humidity may be

as low as 50 per cent or less

In theory the amount of free water in most concretes is more than sufficient for complete hydration Preventing loss of moisture has thus traditionally been believed to provide adequate curing Nevertheless, the rate of hydration is considerably slowed by a drop in

the relative humidity level within the pore structure of the concrete Below 95 per cent

relative humidity it is believed that the rate of hydration will be slowed to the extent that

no further reduction in large porosity will occur even though hydration itself will not

actually cease until about 80 per cent relative humidity This is significant as both strength

and durability are related to porosity, with large porosity having a particularly large influence on durability Sealed concretes of w/c below about 0.5 will experience self- desiccation (Neville, 1995), i.e the water consumed by hydration will reduce the relative humidity level in the pore space such that further hydration will not occur Thus, in theory

at least, optimum properties will only be obtained by use of curing methods which allow ingress of water into concrete (ponding, spraying) rather than those that just prevent or reduce loss of moisture Consideration must, however, be given to the potential problems

of using direct application of free water outlined in the following sections

In reality the best curing method is the one that actually gets done, and gets done properly!

3.5.1 Retention of formwork

Where the constraints of the construction programme allow, curing can be provided by retention of the formwork Enhanced curing may be obtained by loosening the formwork, once the concrete has hardened sufficiently to allow this (the next day, for example), to allow water to be introduced into the gap between the formwork and the concrete surface Care must be taken to avoid the risk of thermal shock from using water that is too cold (see section 3.5.4) and to ensure the concrete is kept moist

3.5.2 Impermeable coverings

Impermeable material in contact with a concrete surface will prevent loss of moisture In the form of thin sheet materials such as polythene, it has the advantage of being very lightweight and flexible so it can be applied in most locations and on complicated shape elements Sheeting on formed surfaces (i.e cast against formwork) should be in intimate contact with the surface, and securely fixed at the edges to form an effective moisture seal This can, however, result in a mottled surface appearance and thus should not be used where appearance is a critical factor Sheeting on fresh unformed (horizontal) surfaces should preferably be suspended above but sealed at the sides and ends to prevent through- passage of air, and to form an effective high relative humidity curing chamber Thus in this application a small amount of evaporation from the surface is inevitable but should

be small provided the enclosure is effectively sealed

In practice, suspension of sheeting above the fresh concrete surface is often considered impractical and, instead, it is placed directly on the concrete In this case it is essential that the surface is allowed to stiffen sufficiently to prevent damage from contact with the cover White sheeting will help control surface temperature of the concrete by reflecting the sun's rays; black will have the opposite effect and should be avoided for outdoor applications in warm conditions Clear sheeting will have little effect on heat absorption The surface of the concrete should be moistened by spraying with water prior to application of the coveting to minimize the effect of any initial loss of water into the air space between the concrete and the coveting

3.5.3 Absorptive coverings

~ ~ ~: ~ ~ ~.~: ,~:~.~ ~ ~ : ~ :: :::.: :::: :: ::::: :: ::

Absorptive materials, such as hessian or sand, will keep the surface of the concrete damp for as long as they are in place and are themselves kept wet Use of such materials may not be appropriate in large sections where it is necessary to insulate the outer surfaces to prevent the risk of cracking through excessive temperature across the section

Materials should not contain harmful amounts of substances, such as sugars or nitrate fertilizers, that could damage the surface of the concrete Where appearance is important, these materials should also be free of substances that could stain or discolour the surface

At the end of the required period of curing, subsequent drying of the concrete will be beneficially slowed if the absorptive material is allowed to dry thoroughly before its removal

3.5.4 Water addition

~ ~ ~ ~:~ ~ ~ ~,~ ~.~ :~ ~ ~.:~ :~ ~::::: ::::::.:::: :

Ponding is easily achieved on flat surfaces by building a small bund around the perimeter and keeping the enclosed area flooded Where spraying or misting is to be used there is

a need to consider factors such as continuity of water supply, clogging of nozzles, wind direction and strength, and drainage paths for the surplus water The risk of thermal shock and excessive temperature differences across sections should also be considered ACI 308-92 (1992) recommends that the curing water should not be more than about l l ° C cooler than the concrete as rapid cooling and contraction of the surface, restrained by the warmer layer below, could result in the development of sufficient stress to cause cracking The use of free water should also be avoided where the possibility of freezing of the concrete surface exists during curing

Water used for curing should generally be of the same quality as that used as mix water In particular, if the concrete is reinforced, or if it contains any other embedded metal, the water should not contain significant levels of chloride that could enter the concrete and increase the risk of premature corrosion of reinforcement Where the appearance

of the concrete surface is important, the water should not contain harmful amounts of any substances that could stain, attack or discolour the surface

3.5.5 Curing membranes

Curing membranes are hand- or spray-applied sealing compounds applied in liquid form after free water has disappeared from the concrete surface (for horizontal surfaces) or upon removal of formwork (for formed surfaces) Such materials typically include natural and synthetic resins, waxes and solvents that are highly volatile at normal ambient temperatures They work by greatly reducing the rate of evaporation of water from the surface When the rate of evaporation exceeds the rate of bleed, it is advisable to wet the surface of the concrete and wait for bleeding to cease before applying a curing membrane

If bleeding continues below the membrane a layer of water may form below the upper layer of matrix which has adhered to the membrane; this layer will be very prone to later damage in service Map-cracking of the membrane, requiting reapplication, is another possible result

Opaque compounds have the additional effect of shading concrete; light colours reduce absorption of solar heat It is difficult to tell by eye whether clear membranes have been applied properly Curing membranes are generally less effective than properly applied wet curing - but properly applied wet curing is rare so membranes are very worthy of consideration They have an additional advantage that once they have been applied no further actions or access are required unlike most other Curing methods In some cases, however, it may be necessary to physically remove traces of the curing membrane prior

to application of a finish to the concrete surface

Curing membranes are available in a number of different qualities, expressed in some countries (UK) as 'efficiency' and in others as water retention (USA) The greater the efficiency the greater their effect is likely to be Products with efficiencies as low as 80 per cent are unlikely to provide the required benefit

Curing efficiency, according to BS 7542, is measured by comparing the water loss from a treated standard mortar sample in a warm, dry atmosphere (approximately 38°C and 32-35 per cent RH for 72 hours) with the water loss from an untreated but otherwise identical control specimen The ASTM C156 water-retention value is simply the weight loss recorded without reference to a control specimen

The choice of membrane is especially important when the concrete is to receive further treatment such as plastering or painting Some compounds, if not physically removed, will prevent subsequently applied materials from adhering Acrylic-based curing membranes are available that are intended to double up as a permanent surface sealer

ii i¸¸¸i~¸ ~ ~ iiii ~i~ 5 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i i~ ~i ~ i ~ ¸ ~i ~ i i ~ i ~ i~i ~ ~ i~ii ~ ~i~ ~ ~ i i ~ i ~ ~i i~ i i~iii~ i ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~i~ i~i ~ ~!~ i li i~ i ~ i i ! i ~ ! i i i ~ I i ~ ~ i i i i i~i i!i ~ii~ i~iil iii !~i i~ i~il i i ~ii i li ¸ ii!iiii~ ~ i i i~ ¸ !i ¸ ~i ~ i!ii ¸ iii~ii ~i~i~ i~il ¸ i i ¸ ~ ~ i ¸ili ¸ i~ !~i ~ii~iii~ ~ i i i i ~ i i l ~i ii~ii!i ¸ i~ i i !iiili iiii i flail i i li ill i~ ~ !i~iiiill ii!il ~ ii i!ii i i iiii!ii

Excessive vibration of immature concrete (from sources such as blasting, piling or very close road or rail traffic) once initial set has taken place can result in decreased strength and reduced bond to reinforcement Concrete should thus be protected from damaging vibration in the initial period from approximately 4 hours to approximately one day Information is sparse on the level at which vibration becomes damaging but an indication

of risk is given by the peak particle velocity (ppv) Theoretical calculation of ppv is, however, difficult and it may be necessary to use results from actual measurements The following limits have been suggested (CIRIA, 1992):

Less than one day 5 mm/s

One to seven days 50 mrn/s

Well-proportioned concrete mixes are tolerant of low-amplitude, low-frequency vibrations during setting and early strength development High-slump concrete has been shown, in the laboratory, to be more susceptible to damage traffic-induced vibrations (Highways Agency, 2000) Bleeding of freshly cast concrete can be increased by intermittent vibration

It may be possible to provide the necessary protection by ensuring the formwork is isolated from the vibration source In the case of traffic-induced vibration, a minimum distance of 600 mm should be provided between the vehicle wheels and the concrete A speed limit of 50 mph is also advised (Highways Agency, 2000)

The commonly encountered method of covering loosely with plastic sheeting can sometimes

be ineffective, if not fixed properly, as water still evaporates from the surface of the concrete, condenses on the sheeting and may drain away Placing the coveting directly on the unformed surface will necessitate delay until the concrete has stiffened sufficiently for no damage to the surface This delay could negate the effect of curing for some purposes, such as avoidance of plastic shrinkage cracking

An absorbent material which is allowed to dry out can conceivably draw moisture from the surface of the fresh concrete, the effect of which could be worse than applying

no curing

A delay between finishing the concrete surface or striking formwork and applying curing can reduce or eliminate the effectiveness of the curing Intermittent curing within the first two or three days may have the same effect Under these conditions, calcium hydroxide that is deposited in the surface capillaries by evaporating pore water becomes carbonated The resultant calcium carbonate then partially blocks the capillaries making

it difficult to get water back into the concrete Intermittent early curing may also result in surface cracks (ACI 308, 1992) After two or three days of effective continuous curing, intermittent curing may allow continued hydration albeit to a reduced degree

There is currently no practical on-site test capable of measuring the effectiveness of curing By definition, the part of the concrete affected by curing is restricted to the outer layers and most in-situ techniques rely on properties measured as an average over a depth generally greater than the affected zone

This depends upon:

• the reason for curing (plastic shrinkage, temperature control, strength, durability, etc.)

• the size of the element

• the type of concrete (especially rate of hardening)

• the ambient conditions during curing

• the exposure conditions to be expected after curing

• the requirements of the specification

3.8.1 The effect of cement type

Cements, or combinations, containing fly ash (pfa), blast furnace slag (ggbs), limestone filler (>5 per cent), or condensed silica fume react more slowly than plain Portland cement, particularly in cold weather Concretes containing blended cements should therefore

be cured thoroughly and for a longer period than for PC concrete, particularly if the potential durability benefits are to be obtained in the near-surface and cover zone Concrete containing condensed silica fume or metakaolin exhibits only minimal bleeding and thus requires early protection to prevent plastic shrinkage cracking

The following circumstances warrant particular consideration of curing needs:

• horizontal surfaces

• dry, hot, windy conditions (one or more of these)

• wear-resistant floors

• high-strength concrete (initial curing is especially important)

This list is not exhaustive and curing may still be of great importance in other conditions Abrasion resistance is particularly dependent on good curing but also relies upon other factors including materials and surface finishing

The hardening of concrete is a chemical reaction- the rate of this reaction increases with temperature but so does the rate of evaporation from an exposed concrete surface The rate of reaction at 35°C is about twice that at 20°C which is, in itself, about twice that at 10°C

The ultimate strength of concrete cured at low temperature (e.g in winter) is generally greater than that of concrete cured at a higher temperature (e.g in summer); but extremes

of temperature generally have a negative effect The slow rate of reaction at low temperatures means the concrete must be cured for a longer period to achieve the desired degree of reaction The fast rate of reaction at high temperatures gives relatively high early strengths but the long-term strength and durability are generally reduced

The optimum temperature required to produce the maximum 28-day strength, based

on small laboratory specimens, is said to be approximately 13°C (Neville and Brooks, 1987) and ambient temperatures of 15-25°C are generally considered to be most suitable for concreting operations

Hydration will proceed, to some extent, at temperatures down to as low a s - 1 0 ° C Nevertheless, little strength will develop below 0°C, and below 5°C the early strength development is greatly retarded (ACI 308, 1992) Even in the temperature range 5-10°C conditions are unfavourable for the development of early strength These effects will be most prevalent in thin sections, in the near surface of larger sections, and in concrete made with slow hydrating cements The bulk strength of larger sections will be less affected because, generally, the internal temperature will be elevated by the heat of hydration

Concrete should not be allowed to freeze before it has gained sufficient strength to resist damage According to AC1308 (1992) this strength is approximately 3.5 MPa Air- entrained concrete should not be allowed to undergo any freeze-thaw cycles until it has reached a strength of approximately 25 MPa Non air-entrained concrete should, of course, never be allowed to undergo freezing and thawing while saturated

The temperature of concrete during curing depends on:

• the dimensions of the element

• the weather (ambient conditions)

• cement type

• cement content

• admixtures (accelerators, retarders)

• the fresh concrete temperature

• formwork type/insulation

• formwork stripping time

Mostly, temperature control of in-situ concrete during hardening is only attempted at

temperature extremes where, for example, there is:

• a risk of freezing

• a risk of an excessive peak temperature or an excessive temperature difference across

the section

The peak temperature in a section should generally be kept below about 65-70°C to

minimize the effect on compressive strength and to minimize the risk of delayed ettringite

formation (DEF) Measures to reduce peak temperatures are beyond the scope of normal

curing techniques and may include cooling of the fresh concrete by various means or

cooling of the placed concrete by means of cooling pipes within the section

Concrete allowed to freeze before a certain minimum degree of hardening has been

achieved will be permanently damaged by the disruption from the expansion of the water

within the concrete as it freezes This will result in irretrievable strength loss Excessive

evaporation from an exposed horizontal surface within the first approximately 24 hours

after casting will result in plastic shrinkage cracking and a weak, dusty surface An

excessive temperature difference through the cross-section of an element will result in

early thermal cracking due to restraint to contraction of the cooling outer layers from the

warmer inner concrete Inadequate curing will result in the properties of the surface layer

of concrete, up to 30-50 mm, not meeting the intentions of the designer in terms of

durability, strength and abrasion resistance

~ii~i~ili~i~i~i~ii~i~i~ii~i~i~i~i~iiii~iiiiiiiii~iiiiii~iiiii ¸ ~ ~ i i ~ i ~ i ~ i~iiiii~ i iiiil i~iiii~ii~ii~iii~~iiii~iiiii~i!~i~i!~i~iiiiii~i~iiiii~iii~i~iiiiii~i~i~i~iiii!ii~iiiiii!i~iiiii~ii~iiiiii~iiiiiiiiiiiii~ii~iiii!i~!ii!i~

The effect of curing on strength development is limited to the near-surface of concrete so

its effect on strength will depend on the element size and type of loading that will be

applied The effect on large elements loaded in compression will be much less than on

slender elements loaded in flexure It is unlikely that the structural capacity of most

elements would be significantly reduced by poor curing Attempts to assess the effect of

poor curing on strength development on small specimens such as cubes or cylinders are

likely to give pessimistic results (Marsh and Ali, 1994)

The effect of reduced strength in the surface zone on the structural performance can be

calculated by making assumptions about the actual reduction in strength and the depth of

the effect Using a strength reduction of 25 per cent in the outer 25 mm predicts the

following overall effects (CIRIA, 1997):