WTG and Solar Dynamic Models• WTG Overview • Model Structure Generator/Converter with Voltage Protection Electrical Control Turbine and Turbine Control for WTG Wind Power or Irra
Trang 1Power Systems & Energy Course: Wind and Solar Plant Modeling
Jason MacDowell
Trang 22 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
Alphabet Soup: Software
There are several software programs used by the
electric power industry for planning studies:
• “PSLF” by GE EA&SE (us: Energy Consulting, EC, PSEC, PSED,
EUSED, etc…)
• Other regional, specialty s/w:
Trang 3Utilities represent their entire system in a simulation model
(using software such as GE PSLF or Siemens PSS/E ®)
This model is a mathematical representation of all
components in the network, such as:
• Generation (Thermal, Renewables, etc…)
• Transmission (Lines, Transformers, FACTS, etc…)
• Loads
What is a ‘model’?
‘model’ to an EXCEL spreadsheet ‘model’
Trang 44 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
EXCEL
To solve problems in EXCEL (or Lotus 123) , one needs:
give it input data to produce output.
on capital equipment in Elbonia) User’s need the structure (code) of the macro AND input data.
PSLF and PSS/E ®
generators), IEEEST1 (for one standard type of excitation system), GGOV1 (simple governor for gas
turbines)… There may be thousands of these models in the grid model.
e.g HVDC, special relays, and some wind turbine generators…)
functions and MACROs don’t work Thus, the data is part of the ‘model’.
Trang 66 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
Time-Scale of Dynamic Performance
Switching Transients
Electro-Mechanical Interactions Transient Stability Oscillatory Stability
Long-term Dynamic Stability
Trang 7Wind Farm Steady-State Model
Trang 88 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
Modeling a Wind Power Plant?
Trang 9Equivalent Model for System Level Studies
Substation Transformer
High Side Bus (collector, e.g
34.5kV)
Substation transformers usually
have FOA rating roughly equal to
total MVA of WTGs
For most systems of N machines,
model an equivalent transformer
and machine as N times one
Represent entire farm capability
in power factor range, voltage regulation, etc.
Trang 1010 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
Equivalent Model for Plant Application Studies
High Side Bus (collector, e.g
Point of Interconnection (POI) Bus
Substation Transformer
CollectorEquivalentImpedance
Unit Transformers are normally 1.75 MVA, 5.8% leakage reactance delta-wye connected padmounts
For most systems of N machines,
model an equivalent transformer
and machine as N times one
The collector system may cover several miles, and have different topologies.
Provide an approximate equivalent R & X.
Include charging, particularly for cable collector systems.
Substation transformers usually
have FOA rating roughly equal to
total MVA of WTGs Substation
collector bus may have additional
shunt reactive compensation to
augment machine var capability
Trang 11High Side Bus (collector, e.g
Point of Interconnection (POI) Bus
Substation Transformer
CollectorEquivalentImpedance
GE 1.5 MW machines offered in a range of steady-state reactive power capabilities at their terminals
A common range:
• 0.90 pf overexcited (delivering 730 kVARs to the system)
• 0.90 pf underexcited (drawing 730 kVARs from system)
Frequently provides +/- 0.95 pf at POI
The supervisory control will
instruct individual machines
to adjust their reactive
power output in order to
regulate system voltage;
normally at the
point-of-interconnection
Volt/Var Control for Application Studies
Trang 1212 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
Typical Dynamic Model Development
Trang 13Excitation System Structure
Power, Frequency
orOther Signals
VoltageSensingManualVoltageRegulatorAutomaticVoltageRegulator
ExcitationPowerSource
Generator
Turbine-meter
Tacho-PowerTransformer
Field CurrentLimiterOverexcitationLimiter (OEL)
Voltage Sensingand Compensation
UnderexcitationLimiter (UEL)
Generator Flux(Volts/Hertz)Limiter
PowerSystemStabilizer
De-excitation
ProtectiveRelays
Rotor Speed
TerminalVoltage
& Current
– Modeling depends on nature
and time scale of study
– Transient Stability
– AVR
– Excitation power source
– V sensing & compensation
Trang 1414 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
Excitation System Model
Exciter AVR
V ref
Ka 1+sTa
+ –
–
1 Ke+sTe –
Trang 15WTG and Solar Dynamic Models
• WTG Overview
• Model Structure
Generator/Converter with Voltage Protection
Electrical Control
Turbine and Turbine Control (for WTG)
Wind Power (or Irradiance)
Trang 1634.5kV bus)
… and Solar PV
Trang 17PSLF WTG Dynamic Model Structure
Generator/
Converter Model
Electrical Control Model
I
p (P) Command
Turbine &
Turbine Control Model
Wind Speed Wind Profile
Model
(User-written)
Power Order
Trang 1818 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
DFG Generator/Converter
• Generator flux dynamics neglected
• Rotor inertia dynamics included in turbine model
• Injects P & Q currents based on Electrical Control command
From exwtge
From exwtge
V term
High VoltageReactive CurrentManagement
Low VoltageActive CurrentManagement
I sorc -1
1 1+ 0.02s
Low Voltage Power Logic
V
LVPL
brkpt (0.90)
1.11
zerox (0.50)
Trang 21DFG Generator Protection
• Over and under-voltage settings vary by project
• Low voltage trip data may be critical to performance so confirm with
Trang 22WindCONTROL Emulator
Pord
From Wind Turbine Model
To Generator Model
QrefPower Factor Regulator PFAref
Reactive Power Control
Pelec
Vreg
Plant-Level Controller
WTG Controller
Trang 231 1+ sTr
1 1+ sTpwr
0
pfaflg 1
Qref
(vref)
0
varflg 1
+ +
DFG Reactive Power Control
From User Model Power Factor Controller
Plant Voltage Control
Trang 25DFG Electrical Control
+
From Wind Turbine Model
s0
s1
XI Qmin
.
K Qi / s
(efd)
(ladifd) (vsig)
-
-+
( model[@index].sigval[0] )
Auxiliary Test Signal
Trang 26DFG voltage control, via
reactive power control at
zero real power, is
available with reduced
VAR range.
Wind Power Model
Wind Speed
Blade Pitch
Torque Control X
Pitch Control
rotor
+
+
+ +
Pset
Pord
Power Response Rate Limit
Pinp
Pitch Compensation
Pitch Actuation
Speed Reference Function
err
Power Control
Active Power Control (optional)
(from generator model)
Trip Signal (to generator model)
(to electrical control model)
Trang 271 1+ sTp
Wind Power Model
Wind Speed
Blade Pitch
Torque Control
X
Anti-windup on Power Limits
Under Speed Trip
To getwg
Anti-windup on Pitch Limits
Anti-windup on Pitch Limits
Kptrq + Kitrq/ s
s4 s2
s1 s0
s3
P elec
Rotor Model
(elimt)
+ +
Active Power Control (optional)
Auxiliary Signal
(psig)
WTG Terminal Bus Frequency
fbus
pstl
sTw
1 + sTw s10
P setAPC
Power Response Rate Limit pinp
plim
perr
wsho
+ +
+ +
s6 s9
1 + 60s
dpwi +
- 0.75P 2 elec + 1.59P elec + 0.63
WindINERTIA Control (optional)
P min
P max
1.
0 1
apcflg
Trang 2828 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
Wind Power Model
( 2
Trang 29From ewtgfc
From ewtgfc
Vterm
High Voltage Reactive Current Management
Low Voltage Active Current Management
Isorc -1
(efd)
IPcmd
(ladifd)
1 1+ 0.02s
1 1+ 0.02s
s0
s1 LVPL & rrpwr
1 1+ 0.02s LVPL
IQcmd
IPlv
s2 V
Low Voltage Power Logic
V
LVPL
brkpt (0.90)
1.22
zerox (0.40)
Full Converter (FC) Generator/Converter
Current commands from Electrical Control
Representation of fast regulator/PLL action similar to DFG
Applies to Full Converter WTG and PV Solar
Similar generator protection
Was 1/X”
for DFAG
Trang 3030 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
Option for user-written model
Qcmd
IPcmd
WindCONTROL Emulation
Vref
Qgen
Vterm
Electrical Controller
Pord
(from wind turbine model)
(to generator model)
Qref
Power Factor Regulator PFAref
Reactive Power Control
Trang 31FC Electrical Control
+ +
KQi/ s
IPcmd
(ladifd)
to Wind Generator Model
(efd)
to Wind Generator Model
+
(elimt)
to Wind Turbine Model
Trang 3232 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
FC Converter Current Limit
-1
P Priority
1 0
1.0
Vt
Trang 33P mech
Wind Power Model
Wind Speed
Blade Pitch
Torque
Pitch Control
rotor
+
+
+ +
Pset Power Response
Rate Limit
Pinp
Pitch Compensation
Pitch Actuation
Speed Reference Function
err
Power Control
Active Power Control (optional)
(from generator model)
Trip Signal (to generator model) 1.0
WindINERTIA
+ +
FC Turbine &
Turbine Control
Functional
Overview
FC voltage control, via
reactive power control at
zero real power, is
available with full VAR
range
Trang 34Wind Speed
Blade Pitch
Torque Control
X
Anti-windup on Power Limits
Anti-windup on Pitch Limits
Anti-windup on Pitch Limits
Kptrq + Kitrq/ s
s4 s2
s1 s0
s3
P elec
Rotor Model
s5
1
1 + s5 - 0.67P
2 elec + 1.42P elec + 0.51
(elimt)
+ +
Frequency Response Curve
1 1+sTpav
Auxiliary Signal
(psig)
WTG Terminal Bus Frequency
P min
s11
P max
Release Pmax
P setAPC
Power Response Rate Limit pinp
Trang 35Model Validation
Trang 3636 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
Why Model Validation?
• Good models of wind plants are more important as wind
penetration increases
• Development of stability models is on-going
> Grid codes are driving increased functionality in wind plants
> Continuously evolving equipment and models create on-going need for
Trang 37Faulted Bus
DFG Model Validation
Test system:
Disturbance: 3-phase, 150msec bus fault with impedance at POI (bus 2)
Compare PSLF positive sequence dynamic response to EMTP based
cycle-by-cycle response
Strong
Network
Wind Plant Substation Aggregate Wind Turbine and Transformer
Trang 39DFG Model Validation
1.5 MW DFAG PSLF and WindTrap (EMTP) Real Power Response
-1.0 0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0
Trang 41Full Converter (FC) Model Validation
Similar test system, similar disturbance…
Trang 43FC Model Validation
2.5 MW FC PSLF and Windtrap (EMTP) Real Power Response
0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0
Trang 45Field Test Results
Trang 470
pfaflg 1
(vref)
0
varflg 1
+ +
Slower Plant-Level Control
s0
s1
XI Qmin
.
K Qi / s
(efd)
(ladifd) (vsig)
-
-+
( model[@index].sigval[0] )
Auxiliary Test Signal
Slower WTG Q Control Fast WTG V Control
Trang 4848 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
Individual WTG Test
+
From Wind Turbine Model
s0
s1
XI Qmin
.
K Qi / s
(efd)
(ladifd) (vsig)
-
-+
( model[@index].sigval[0] )
Auxiliary Test Signal
Voltage Step Stimulus
Trang 49Unit Internal Voltage Reference Step Test
Trang 5050 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
Unit Internal Voltage Reference Step Test
Unit Internal Voltage Reference Step Test
10x expanded time scale
Trang 51Vt PSLF Vref PSLF
Trang 5252 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
Plant Level Volt/Var Test
Trang 53s1
XI Qmin
.
K Qi / s
(efd)
(ladifd) (vsig)
-
-+
( model[@index].sigval[0] )
Auxiliary Test Signal
1 1+ sT r
1 1+ sT pwr
0
pfaflg 1
Q ref
(vref)
0
varflg 1
+ +
V qd -
Slower Plant-Level Control
Slower WTG Q Control Fast WTG V Control
Trang 5454 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
WTG and Plant Reactive Power Response
Multi-modal response is grid friendly
Trang 55Model closely replicates field response
Field Test vs Simulation – Reactive Power
Q_TURBINES - TEST
Qg - MODEL
Cap Bank Switched Offline
Trang 5656 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
Cap Switching Test vs Model – (100 MW Plant)
Second s
0.98 5
0.9 9
0.99 5 1
1.00 5
-20 -10 0 10
-6 -3 0 3 6 9
W43: Q POI (Blue = Measured Green = Simulated) [(W14)|overplot(W46)]
POI Voltage Response
POI Q Response
Plant Qcmd BLUE = MEASURED GREEN = SIMULATED
Trang 57Field Test - Voltage Regulation
Trang 5858 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
Wind Turbine-Generator Technology – Primary Alternatives
3
3
GEAR BOX
WOUND ROTOR INDUCTION GENERATOR TRANSFORMER
GRID
IGBT R Control Rectifier
GRID Rectifier
3 3
IGBT Inverter
Fixed Speed System
• NEG-Micon, Bonus, traditional Nordex
Variable Slip System
Trang 59Plant reactive coordination problems and solutions
Trang 6060 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
WTG terminal Voltage with Uncoordinated
PI regulators with PT error
WTG Terminal Voltage Plant Reactive Power
Trang 61Wind Plant Voltage Control
Wind Plant Voltage Control
interconnection voltage
Trang 62Dynamic Models & Simulation Results
Trang 63Plant and WTG Electrical Control
1 1+ sTr
-+
Test Signal
Slow Plant Level Voltage Regulator (WindCONTROL Emulation)
Fast Turbine Level Voltage Regulator
Intermediate Turbine Level Reactive Power Regulator
Converter Current Limit
P,Q priority flag
+
Doubly Fed
Full Converter
to generator / converter model
+
KVis
Test Signal
Doubly Fed
Full Converter
Trang 641 1+ sTr
-+
Test Signal
Slow Plant Level Voltage Regulator (WindCONTROL Emulation)
Fast Turbine Level Voltage Regulator
Intermediate Turbine Level Reactive Power Regulator
Converter Current Limit
P,Q priority flag
+
Doubly Fed
Full Converter
to generator / converter model
+
KVis
Test Signal
Doubly Fed
Full Converter
* Ipmx is fixed for the doubly fed model, or calculated by the converter current limit
function for the full converter model
Plant and WTG Electrical Control
Trang 651 1+ sTr
-+
Test Signal
Slow Plant Level Voltage Regulator (WindCONTROL Emulation)
Fast Turbine Level Voltage Regulator
Intermediate Turbine Level Reactive Power Regulator
Converter Current Limit
P,Q priority flag
+
Doubly Fed
Full Converter
to generator / converter model
+
KVis
Test Signal
Doubly Fed
Full Converter
Plant and WTG Electrical Control
Trang 6666 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
Response of One Plant
to a major line outage
Reactive Power Output
Point-of-regulation Voltage
Terminal Voltage Behavior
Trang 67Wind Plant Droops Field and Tuned Gains
(on plant MVAr base)
Proportional
Gain
Integral Gain
Trang 68Field test results
Trang 69Voltage Behavior – 5 Uncoordinated Wind Plants
System conditions moving
System conditions moving
Grid capacitor switching
Voltage Limit overrides power factor control
Trang 7070 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
System conditions moving
System conditions moving Grid capacitor switching
Trang 71Dynamic Behavior and Field Validation
of Simulation Model
Trang 7272 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
No Droop - Simulation
Trang 73No Droop – Field Measurement
Trang 7474 /
© 2016 General Electric International, Inc All rights reserved Not for distribution without permission.
With Droop - Simulation