BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016 CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1 INTRODUCTION In recent years, seafood export is one of the strengths of Viet Nam, contributting from 3.5 % to 4% of
Trang 1
GRIGGS UNIVERSITY GLOBAL ADVANCED MASTER OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT
BUSNINESS STRTEGY FOR ANVIFISH
Trang 2
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016 CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
- 1 -
LIST OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION 4
CHAPTER 1: OVERVIEW OF THEORIES RELATED TO STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT 6
1.1 An overview of strategic management theory 6
1.1.1 The concept of strategic management 6
1.1.3 Process of Strategic management 8
1.1.4 Tools for strategy formulation and seclection 12
1.2 Overview of pangasius processing and exporting in Vietnam: 15
1.3 The necessary of planning strategy for the Company 21
CHAPTER 2: BUSINESS SITUATION OF ANVIFISH 23
2.1 Overview of Enterprise 23
2.1.1 Foundation and development 24
2.1.2 Organizational structure and Management 27
2.1.3 Main business activities of AVF 29
2.1.4 Technology Capacity 31
2.1.5 Business performance and financial status from 2008 to first half of 2011 33
2.2 Internal Environment 37
2.2.1 Management activities 37
2.2.2 Marketing 40
2.2.3 Finance and Accountant 41
2.2.4 Operation management 44
2.2.5 Research and Development of product (R & D) 45
2.2.6 Information system in the company 46
2.2.7 Core competitive advantages of the company 46
2.3 External environment factors 47
2.3.1 Macro Environment 47
Trang 3
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016 CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
- 2 -
2.2.1 Competitors 52
2.2.2 Competitors analysis 54
2.2.3 Advantages and disadvantages from macro factors impact on processing and exporting pangas us 59
CHAPTER 3: BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR VIET AN JSC 2012 -2016 62
3.1 Strategy formulation for AVF 62
3.1.1 Defining strategic targets 62
3.1.2 Strategy implementation schedule 2012 – 2016 62
3.1.3 Formulating and choosing business strategies 63
3.2 Organization solutions to implement selected strategies 75
3.2.1 Financial solutions 75
3.2.2 Solution to operation management 75
3.2.3 Marketing solution 76
3.2.4 Human resources solution 78
PROPOSITION 79
CONCLUSION 80
REFERENCES 81
LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1.1: The process of strategic management……… 9
Figure 1.2: Factors affecting the macro environment……… …11
Figure 1.3: Model of five competitive forces M Porter………11
Figure 1.4 - Structure of production of aquatic products for export in 2011………17
Figure 2.1: Organizational structure and management of AVF……….28
Figure 2.2: Some main products of Anvifish……….31
Figure 2.3: Manufacturing process of frozen pangasius fillet in block/IQF……….….33
Figure 2.4 Chart of quatity and sales of AVF to markets……… 36
Figure 3.1: Illustration of selected strategy of AVF through SPACE Matrix……… 70
Trang 4
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016 CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
- 3 -
LIST OF TABLES Table 1.1: Process of strategy formulation………13
Table 1.2 : Internal – External Matrix……… 14
Table 1.3 : Competitive Image Matrix……… 15
Table 1.4: SWOT Matrix……… 15
Table 1.5 - Statistical pangasius export value in markets 2009-2011……… 18
Table 1.6 - Top 20 importing markets in 2011 in term of growth……… 19
Table 1.7 - Top 20 importers of pangasius in 2011……… 20
Table 2.1: List of some certificates and awards of AVF……… 26
Table 2.2: Sales of AVF from 2008 to 2011 ……… 30
Table 2.3 - AVF’s performance during period of 2009 - 2011……… ……… 34
Table 2.4 - VAF’s business performance changes over years……… 34
Table 2.5 - AVF’s Expense/net revenue changes over years……… 35
Table 2.6 – export sales in markets……… 36
Table 2.7 - List of some members of AVF’s Board of Directors……….…38
Table 2.8 - Labor resource by qualification of AVF (2009-2011)……… 41
Table 2.9: Cash flows in brief of AVF 2008 – 2010……… 42
Table 2.10: Typical financial ratios of AVF ……… 43
Table 3.1: The strategy implementation schedule of AVF 2012 – 2016……….63
Table 3.2: External Factors Evaluation matrix ………63
Table 3.3: Image competition matrix for AVF……….65
Table 3.4: Internal Factors Evaluation matrix for AVF ……… 65
Table 3.5: SWOT Matrix for AVF……… 66
Table 3.6: SPACE matrix of Anvifish……….69
Table 3.7: Internal – Extenal Factor Matrix……….70
Table 3.8: alternative strategies conclusion……….71
Table 3.9 : QSPM matrix – Group of centralized strategies………71
Trang 5
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
INTRODUCTION
In recent years, seafood export is one of the strengths of Viet Nam, contributting
from 3.5 % to 4% of GDP, creating jobs for over three million people and is one of
three largest export industries in term of value, just following crude oil and
garments
In the period from 2006 to 2011, fishery was one of highest growing industries of
Vietnam, at about 15% In 2010, marine foods export value of Vietnam was over of
$ 5 billion and that is expected to reach about $ 6 billion in 2011
For exported seafood products, pangasius fillets could be seen as one of the staples,
accounting for about 28 % to 30 % of total seafood export value, being exported to
about 136 countries in the world This product is considered as potential field that
opens up many opportunities for the fishery exporting companies
Besides these achievements, the companies processing and exporting pangasius has
been facing to many difficulties and challenges from the subjective and objective
factors such as: the volatility of raw materials due to environmental pollution,
disease outbreaks; workers are not stable due to competitiveness of internal
industrial enterprises; increase in barriers from foreign markets, especially the U.S
and EU; competition among the peers and so on…
As a fishery processing and exporting company, ranked in the top 10 fishery
exporters of Vietnam in term of export value, Viet An Joint Stock Company is
headed for many opportunities and challenges Therefore, formulating "business
strategy period 2012 - 2016" is very necessary to promote the strengths and limit
weakness, seize opportunities and avoid threats from the external factors in the
future
- Objectives and methods of the study
Based on the theories from Strategic Management subjects that will be applied in
practice to analyze and evaluate internal and external factors and competitive
environment among the peers, our group formulated the business strategy as well as
measures to implement the strategy for the company during the period from 2012 to
Trang 6
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
2016 with the expectation it will be a useful reference document for AVF in
formulating it’s business strategy in coming years
- Research Methods:
We use two methods of qualitative and quantitative, based on internal documents,
financial statements provided by the AVF, market research, forecast of fishery
development potential by experts as well as local and foreign organizations For this
report, we also use the documents from websites publishing by General Statistics
Office, General Administration of Customs, and Seafood Association of
Vietnamese
- The structure of this thesis includes 03 chapters
Chapter 1: An overview of theories related to strategic management
Chapter 2: Business situation of Viet An Joint Stock Company (AVF)
Chapter 3: Strategic business formulation for AVF 2012 to 2016
Trang 7
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
CHAPTER 1: OVERVIEW OF THEORIES RELATED TO
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
1.1 An overview of strategic management theory
1.1.1 The concept of strategic management
Strategic management is concerned with providing a purpose in order to establish
the way forward for the organization It involves creating a sustainable competitive
advantage for the organization
1.1.2 Classification strategy
1.1.2.1 Classification of specific strategies
According to Fred R.David, it is possible to divide strategies into 14 types of typical
strategies and 04 groups as follows:
Integration strategy group
- Forward integration: this type is related to the increase of ownership or control
to distributors or retailers An effective method to implement this combination
strategy is transfer of right The enterprises can develop rapidly through transfer
of right since the cost and opportunity are divided to many individuals;
- Backward integration: this type is related to the search for ownership or control
of company’s suppliers This strategy is especially suitable when the current
suppliers of the company are not reliable, expensive or fail to satisfy the
requirements of the Company;
- Horizontal integration: this strategy is related to the discovery of ownership or
control to rivals The merging, acquisition helps to improve the effectiveness of
the scope, and increase the exchange of resources and capacity
Intensive strategy group
- Market Penetration refers to the search for additional market shares for current
products and services in the existing markets through marketing efforts Market
penetration includes the increase of sales staff, advertisement cost, production
products or advertisement efforts;
Trang 8
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
- Market Development refers to the launching of existing products and services to
new sectors;
- Product Development refers to the increase of turnover by the improvement or
adjustment of existing products or services Product development requires high
research and development cost
Expansion strategy Group
- Diversification of concentric activities means the addition of new but interacted
products or services;
- Diversification of activities in horizontal manner means the addition of new
products and services those have not relation for existing customers;
- Diversification of activities in combined manner means the addition of new
products or services without interaction
Other Strategy Group
- Joint venture: two or more companies form an independent company for
cooperative purposes;
- Operation contraction refers to the consolidation through cost and property cut to
save the dropping revenue and profit;
- Activity cut-down refers to the selling of a branch or a part of the company;
- Liquidation means the selling of all the properties, partially, with tangible
values;
- Combination pursues two or many strategies at the same time
1.1.2.2 Michael Porter 's perspective on the typical strategy
According to Porter, typical strategies enable company to get competitive
advantages from three different aspects:
- Cost strategy refers to the manufacturing of standardized products at low unit
price for price-sensitive customers;
- Differentiation refers to the strategy aiming at the production of service
products considered as specific in the sector for customers those are not
sensitive to the price;
- Focus on the main point refers to the production of products and services to
meet the demands of small groups of customers;
One reason for pursuing forward strategy, backward strategy or horizontal strategy
is to gain the benefits of price orientation
Trang 9
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
Product development is a typical strategy with many advantages for the product
distinction (differentiation strategy) The successful product distinction means the
higher product flexibility, greater combination ability, lower cost, improved
services, fewer maintenance, more comfortableness, or more specific traits
The strategies such as market penetration, market development provide much
advantage
1.1.3 Process of Strategic management
Figure 1.1: The process of strategic management
1.1.3.1 Strategy formulation
Feedback information
Thiết lập mục tiêu dài hạn
Lựa chọn các chiến lược để theo đuổi
Xét lại mục tiêu kinh doanh
Thực hiện kiểm soát nội
bộ để nhận diện những điểm mạnh yếu
Phân phối các nguồn tài nguyên
Đo lường
và đánh giá thành tích
Thiết lập những mục tiêu hàng năm
Đề ra các chính sách
Thông tin phản hồi
Feedback
Establish term objectives
long-Select the strategies to pursue
to identify the main opportunities and threats
Review business objective
Implement internal control to identify the strength and weakness
Distribute natural resources
Measure and evaluate achievement
s
Establish annual objectives
Propose policies
Feedback Strategy
development
Strategy implementation
Strategy evaluation
Trang 10
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
Strategy formulation is a process that includes defining the tasks, the current
strategic objectives, analyzing the context of the internal & external elements of the
business and then making plan a strategy for the company appropriate to the context
analyzed The result of this process will show the company decided to participate/
not participate in the field of business/geographical area, how to allocate their
resources; should extend/ shrink operation; associated or not associated with a
partner ?
1.1.3.1.1 Identify strategic objectives
Identifying strategic objectives is to analyze and point out the mission - the vision
and long-term goal of offering the business To build strategic objectives and tasks
of the planners of the business strategy must answer the question: Our enterprise
operate in what, our business bring and benefits to whom, how we can satisfy the
interests of the people involved and what we will become in the future These issues
are critical and considered as guidlines for all activities of the business in the future
1.1.3.1.2 Analysis of external environment
Analyzing the external environment is to focus on the identification and evaluation
of external factors to find out what opportunities and threats from these factors to
the operation of the business in order to devise appropriate strategies for the
enterprise to respond to the changes of these factors The analysis of the external
environment can be done by analyzing the macro environment and industry
environment
Macro environment analysis
The changes in the macro environment possibly impact on any certain forces in
the industry and alter the attractiveness of an industry Macro environment
consists of 6 segments: economy, social culture, demography, political law,
technology and global
Trang 11
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
Figure 1.2: Factors affecting the macro environment
Analyzing the industry environment (micro-environment)
According to Michael Porter , there are five competitive forces oriented within
the sector are: (1 ) the risk of entry of new companies , (2 ) the degree of
competition among existing companies in the industry , (3) bargaining power of
buyers , (4) bargaining power of sellers ; (5) threat of substitutes
Figure 1.3: Model of five competitive forces M Porter
Competitive pressures of the suppliers with the basic elements:
Trang 12
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
The quantity and scale of suppliers;
Product substituting ability of suppliers;
Information about suppliers
Competitive pressure from customers
Customers are classified into 2 groups as other retail and distributors Both
groups put pressure on companies on price, product quality and service come
and it is they who control the industry through competition in the purchase
decision
Competitive pressure from potential rivals
According to M-Porter, the implicit rivals of the enterprises have not appeared in
the sector market but can influence the sector in the future
Competitive pressure from substitute products
Substitute products and services refer to those can satisfy the similar demand of
customers for products and services in the sector
Competitive pressures of the industry internal
The enterprises in the sector will compete directly with each other to create the
pressure on the sector and form the competition intensity Following factors of
the sector will increase pressure on the rivals:
Sector situation;
Sector structure
1.1.3.1.3 Analysis of internal company environment
This is a process of evaluation of all the main functional operations of a company
such as administration activity, marketing, finance – accounting, product research
and development, etc… in comparison to the peers of the company The purpose of
that is finding out the strengths and weaknesses of the company in combination with
the results of external analysis to formulate business strategy for the company
1.1.3.1.4 Strategy formulation and selection
In regarding to build up long term objectives of the company, formulate transferable
strategies, and pick up the reasonable business strategies to follow All the process
Trang 13
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
is implemented with the tools of analysis, evaluation and selection and the point of
views of strategy maker included
1.1.3.2 Strategy implementation
The process of specifying the selected strategies, defining appropriate policies for
strategies implementation, allocating all necessary resources to ensure that strategic
objectives are achieved
1.1.3.3 Evaluation and adjustment of strategy
In fact business environment is always changing; our forecast of internal and
external factors impacting on the process of formulation strategy is possibly not
accurate Accordingly, Once the selected strategies are implemented, the
performance of that should be measured and evaluated In needed the strategy
adjustment must be done in the way that fit to the changes in business environment
1.1.4 Tools for strategy formulation and selection
According to Fred R David, the strategy formation includes 3 stages including
penetration, combination and decision:
Boston consulting group (BCG)
Internal – External matrix (IE)
Grand strategy matrix
Stage 3: Decision
Quantitative strategy planning matrix (QSPM)
Table 1.1: Process of strategy FOemulation
1.1.4.1 Internal factor evaluation Matrix (IFE)
Trang 14
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
External Factor Evaluation enables strategists to summarize and evaluate economic,
cultural, social, demographic, geological, political, government, technological and
competing information
1.1.4.2 External factor evaluation Matrix (EFE)
External factor evaluation Matrix (EFE) allow summarizing and evaluating of
economic information, social, cultural, demographic, take reasonable, politics,
government, law, technology and competition, how to impact to business, aims to
establish the appropriate business strategy for enterprise
1.1.4.3 Internal - External Matrix (IE)
IE Matrix (Internal – External Matrix) set the difference SBU (Strategic Business
Unit) of company into the table with 9 cells IE Matrix is based on two main aspects
as follows:
- Total significant scores of IFE matrix is shown on the X axis , and
- Total significant scores of EFE matrix is shown on the Y axis
Each SBU must to establish IFE and EFE matrix, thereby setting IE matrix of the
business On the X axis of the matrix IE, showing the total number of critical points
IFE matrix Similarly, on the Y axis of the matrix IE, showing the total number of
critical points of the matrix EFE:
Medium 2,0 – 2,99
Low 1,0 – 1,99 Strong
Table 1.2 : Internal – External Matrix
Based on IE Matrix, we can be divided into three major sections; each section
includes the following different strategies:
- SBU located in the cells I, II and IV that suggests the grow and build strategy
Trang 15
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
- SBU located in the boxes III, V and VII, that suggests hold and maintain
strategy, market penetration and product development are two appropriate
strategies in this case
- SBU located in cells VI , VIII and IX: suggested strategies are harvest and
divest
1.1.4.4 Competitive image Matrix
Competitive image matrix helps a company to identify the competitors, and their
strengths, and weakness in comparison with its self in the process of strategy
formulation
Strategy 1 Strategy 2 Strategy 3
Rating Score Rating Score Rating Score
List the
factors
Total scores
Table 1.3: Competitive Image Matrix
1.1.4.5 Strengths - Weaknesses - Opportunities – Threats Matrix (SWOT)
SWOT Matrix is a tool that combines the strengths (S), weaknesses (W),
Opportunities (O) and threats (T) to give the following four strategic:
List all Threats Combination of S-T Combination of W-T
Table 1.4: SWOT Matrix
1.1.4.6 Strategic position and action evaluation Matrix (SPACE)
Strategy position and action evaluation matrix is used to evaluate the operation of
the business, and determine the location of the business in the market The axis of
Trang 16
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
this matrix represents the two aspects within the organization: financial strength
(FS) and competitive advantage (CA) and two outside business aspects:
environmental stability (ES) and strength of the sector (IS)
1.1.4.7 Quantitative strategic planning matrix (QSPM)
QSPM aims at evaluating and ranking of strategic options that help to select the
most reasonable strategies for the enterprise QSPM uses the outputs in relation to
each other from EFE matrix, Competitive image matrix, IFE matrix, SWOT matrix,
Space matrix, IE matrix This is the tool to carry out objective evaluation of
alternative strategies, which is firstly based on the internal and external factors to
success
1.2 Overview of pangasius processing and exporting in Viet Nam:
Vietnam is considered as one of nations having the fastest fishery export growth in
the world, with an average growth rate of the period 2001- 2010 was 15%
According to FAO, Vietnam was ranked the fifth in the list of the seafood exporter
in the world and was the third on aquaculture production Fishery is one of the key
export sectors of Vietnam, contributing 3.5% to 4% GDP, next only to crude oil,
coal, textiles, reached 3.74% GDP in 2010
The revenue of exported seafood of Vietnam in 2011 reached 6.1 billion USD, up to
21% compared with that of 2010 and more three times than 2002 In which the
value of exported pangasius reached 1.805 billion USD, increased nearly 26.5% and
With export volume of over 600,000 tons
Trang 17
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
Figure 1.4 - Structure of production of aquatic products for export in 2011
According to VASEP, currently there are more than 200 enterprises engaged in
processing and exporting pangasius However, 10 leading enterprises in Vietnam
has occupied 40% of the total seafood export value in which Vinh Hoan Seafood
Joint stock company accounts for 8%, Hung Vuong Seafood Company is over 7.2%,
AGF is about 4.55%, AVF is 4.13% and other companies are from 2.2% to 2.8%
Most of these companies have their own aquaculture areas and factories in the
Mekong Delta Besides focusing and concerned in quality of product, process from
aquaculture to processing and packaging to meet the stern requirements of strict
markets of the US and Europe, they also have paid attention to quality control in
response to non-tariff barriers from the market However, among 200 enterprises
engaged in processing and exporting seafood, there are over 100 enterprises operate
with capacity from 40% to 50% of the design capacity The main reason stems from
unstable input resources and strong increase in input price that make them difficult
for manufacturing In addition to the weak financial capacity, inadequate working
capital for production has led them to much more using borrowing capital from
credit institution causing their high risk of finance
Exported seafood structure in 2011
(GT)
Mollusc 10,0%
Other crustaceans
1,8%
Shrimp 39,8%
Catfish 30,0%
Tunny 6,3%
Others 12,1%
Source: Pangasius-vietnam.com
Trang 18
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
Major products of most Vietnam pangasius export companies are fillets with various
types These companies still haven’t had the differentiation in their products, even
for some leading firms such as HVG, AGF However, in recent years, some
companies have initially implemented product diversification by producing
value-added products such as rolled fillets, breaded pangasius slice, skewered fish But
the contributions to revenue and profit from the products are still low
Table 1.5 - Statistical pangasius export value in markets 2009-2011
Trang 19
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
Table 1.6 - Top 20 importing markets in 2011 in term of growth
Trang 20
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
Table 1.7 - Top 20 importers of pangasius in 2011
No Markets Value (USD) Proportion (%)
For importing markets, The EU is the largest importer of pangasius of Vietnam
However, the value of pangasius exports to this market is saturated In 2011, the
value of exports to this market virtually increased in comparison to that of 2010,
reached nearly 514 million USD The US market is the next, value export to this
market was up to nearly 332 million USD in 2011, with growth of over 88% yoy
We suppose that in the near future, the US will remain the potential for pangasius
exporter of Viet Nam's
Trang 21
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
In an effort to diversify in order to limit risks from the EU and US markets,
recently, the exporters in Vietnam have made their efforts to develop importing
markets, especially South America markets such as Brazil, Mexico In 2011, the
value of exports to the two markets were 84 million USD and 109 million USD
respectively According to experts, these markets will be considered as the potential
of pangasius processing and exporting in Viet Nam in the future
Production and export value of pangasius have had significant growth over the
years, with growth in the period from 2006 – 2010 were respectively of 14% and
15% Due to the forecast of experts, fishery industry in general and pangasius
processing and exporting will remain the development potential in coming years
with some reasons as followings:
• The worldwide demand for seafood consumption is expected to continue
increasing It is stemmed from decrease in substitute’s resources supply caused
by the disease of poultry and cattle, particularly tendency of fishing limitation to
protect the ecological environment of countries all over the world
The Government is continuing to offer preferential policies for developing
fishery industry The activeness of the marine associations such as VASEP,
Vietnam Pangasius Association will support enterprises, especially give the
options to promote cooperation among enterprises to limit the competitive price
as before
The economic growth in new developed countries like China and India will
increase long-term demand for seafood products in general and pangasius in
particular
Vietnam’s pangasius products haven’t been diversified, great demand of value
added products in the global market are not met that will bring in many
opportunities for fishery companies in the future
Besides the opportunities, the companies of Vietnam have continued to face
enormous challenges from many different causes:
Trang 22
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
In recent years, the very fast growth of the fishery industry, the lack of
aquaculture planning have poisoned the ecological environment These facts
have been negatively impacting on the fishery development of Vietnam
The increase in the price of raw materials, borrowing cost, financial difficulties,
limit of loans from banks… have pushed many families feeding pangasius into
giving up their business Accordingly the competition among the peers in
acquiring the inputs for their production likely make the price increase
The unstable status of labor forces has badly affected the activities of fishery
processing companies
The increase in the market barriers such as anti-dumping tax, technical barriers,
sanitary and food safety, especially policies to protect the ecological
environment throughout the world are commonly applied that will make many
challenges for exporters of Vietnam
The risks from the importing markets: Recently, the pangasius exported to EU
and US has accounted for about 48% of that of Vietnam in term of value as well
as quantity However, the governments of these countries often issue new
barriers to limit the import of fishery products in general and pangasius products
in particular from Vietnam Therefore, all exporters of the markets are always in
the state to deal with these risks
From the above analysis, it shows that in the coming years, processing and
exporting pangasius products will have much potential to develop However, the
companies in this field will continue to face many risks from many factors
Therefore, to succeed, it is required all the companies must have appropriate
strategies to capture new opportunities as well as to cope with negative
influences arising from their business activities
1.3 The necessary of planning strategy for the Company
Trang 23
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
Viet An Joint Stock Company (AVF) is one of the 04 leading pangasius exporters in
Vietnam Its export value accounts for over 4% of export value of the national
pangasius export value
As many companies operating in fishery, in addition to the impact of the internal
factors, AVF has been also facing the opportunities and challenges under the
influence of macro factors, the weaknesses from the marine products industry in
general and pangasius in particular
So, to cope with changes from markets, to promote the strengths as well as to limit
weaknesses to increase the business efficiency in the coming years, formulating the
business strategy is essential It allows orienting enterprises as well as giving clear
solutions so as to make companies develop sustainably
Trang 24
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
CHAPTER 2: BUSINESS SITUATION OF ANVIFISH
2.1 Overview of Enterprise
Company name: Anvifish Joint-Stock Company
Abbreviated: Anvifish Co
Logo :
Address: National Road 91, Thanh An Village, My Thoi Ward, Long Xuyen
City, An Giang Province
Tel: (0763) 932 545 - Fax : (0763) 932 554
Website : www.anvifish.com - Email : info@anvifish.com.vn
Business Registration Certificate No.: 1600720555, first registration dated
27/02/2007 issued by An Giang Department of Planning and Investment, and
the second dated 21/12/2009 and the third dated 26/08/2010
Tax code : 1600 720 555
Chartered capital : VND 225.000.000.000
Scope of business: Specialized in processing and exporting frozen
aqua-cultural products The main products of the company are Pangasius section
such as pangasius fillet, pangasius fish slice, slice fillet many other kinds of
product
Branch in HCMC:
Address: 34 Phan Dinh Giot, Ward.2, Tan Binh District, HCMC
Tel: (84-8) 3848 7358 - Fax: (84-8) 3848 7357
Main function: Marketing, widening Europe, America, Russia and Mid-West
markets It is organized with 3 functions including marketing, documentation
for export and goods delivery
Trang 25
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
Subsidiary Company:
ANPHA-AG is only subsidiary of the company being in charge of managing
and exploiting frozen storage system including 06 storages with capacity of
3.500 tons per storage The company has plan of raising total storage
capacity up to 40.000 tons in upcoming time
Associated company:
Viet An associates with loyal customers in America and Europe to establish
Anvifish-Australia, Anvifish-Europe in order to penetrate these markets
2.1.1 Foundation and development
Precursor of Viet An JSC was AN GIANG – BASA Co, Ltd, established in August
2004 In Feb 2007, the company was transferred into formation of Joint Stock
Company with the name of Viet An Joint – Stock Company
After 7 years operation and development, the company has been defining its
position on the export market and becoming one of the biggest companies in Viet
Nam in the field of exporting frozen aqua – culture products Its proportion of
exported pangasius value has been accounting for more than 4% of Vietnam
pangasius export with annual revenue estimated at USD 60 million and 25.000 tons
in term of volume
Some highlight achievements of AVF
In 2008, AVF was imposed anti-dumping duty of 0% on American market while
many other fishery companies had to bear the rate of 63.88%
AVF has distribution networks with more than 100 big clients, especially some
of them own supermarket and agency system in Europe and America
AVF is one of the biggest enterprises in Viet Nam in the field of proccessing and
exporting Pangasius, it has 02 factories with total capacity of 250 tons/day and
aqua-culture areas of 123 hectares (01 area of AVF and 05 associated areas)
Recently, AVF has invested in new area of 100 hectares in order to be active in
Trang 26
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
input materials Beside, AVF has completed a system of frozen storage of
capacity of 20.000 tons at Long Hau Industrial Park
The company has increasingly developed, with revenue of USD 32 million from
2007 up to USD 62 million in 2010, growing to 100% after 4 years
During the time of operation, AVF has gained many certificates and merits from
the governments, associations and organizations:
Table 2.1: List of some certificates and awards of AVF
No Certificates and Merits Issued date Issued place
1 ISO golden cup in 2007 04/09/2007 Ministry of Science
4 Vietnamese Typical Business Person
Business Person cultural center
5 Gold award for safe food brand 21/05/2008 Viet foods Safety
Network
6 Top 100 trusted brand 2008 15/08/2008 VN Enterprise
7 Certificate of trustful supplier in Viet
Nam
VN Enterprise
8 Contribution to program of “Looking
forward beloved countryside” in 2007
Trang 27
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
11
Certificate for achievement of
social-economic development in An Giang in
2007
01/02/2008 An Giang People’s
Committee
12 Certificate of prestigious export
enterprise in Viet Nam in 2007
14 Certificate of prestigious export
enterprise in Viet Nam in 2008
16/04/2009 Ministry of Trade
and Industry
Trang 28
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
2.1.2 Organizational structure and Management
Figure 2.1: Organizational structure and management of AVF
Vice General Director of Materials
Vice General Director of producing Inspection Commitee
Dept
of IT
Dept
of Techni
que
Dept
of Constr uction
HR F&A Materi
al area Dept
QC Center
Dept
of produc ing control
Dept of quality maneg
Dept
of planni
ng
Wareh ouse
An Thinh
factory
Viet Thang factory
Trang 29
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
- General Meeting of Shareholder (GMS) is the most powerful one of Viet An
JSC; GMS has the rights of highest decision making authority of the company
- Board of Management is voted by General Meeting of Shareholders, is
responsible for implementation related matters set in resolution of General
Meeting of Shareholders as well as The charter of the company
- Inspection Committee is voted by General Meeting of Shareholders, is
responsible for monitoring, supervising Board of Directors’ as well as
company’s business activities in order to ensure benefits for all shareholders
- Board of Directors includes General Director and 04 Vice General Directors
who are under duty of operating daily company’s activities as well as
implementing company’s strategies
- Dept of IT is responsible for managing and maintaining the system of
Company’s IT such as office equipments, softwares and company’s website
- Dept of technique concerns about periodic maintenance (monthly, quarterly,
and annual) equipments, electric devices…to ensure smoothly operation of those
ones This Dept also takes care of changing, installing new machines and
equipments along Projects as well as filling technical guide
- Dept of Construction is responsible for managing, repairing and constructing
new fix assets of the company
- Dept of Admin and HR is responsible for HR matters like labour, insurance,
fire fighting, work safety, hygiene…and other tasks of admin such as manage
files and other missions relate to other Dept(s)
- F & A is in charge of planning and mobilizing financial resource for AVF as
well as collection, processing, examination, analysis and supply of financial
information according to the requirements of the Board of Directors and other
relevant subjects and have responsibilities of making financial statement, and
also internally auditing operation of the company
- Quality control center of aquatic: precursor is laboratory with its major
functions are to ensure food hygiene for material of fish, standardize
measurement tools and devices under criteria of trustful, objective, and honest
Trang 30
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
Technical management activities of Laboratory are ruled in ISO/IEC
17025:2005
- Dept of planning cares about annual plans, produces as orders, co-ordinates
with F & A to form prices, co-ordinates with factories of production schedule
and economic norms, forms and supervises investment projects along producing
needs, supplies safety clothing, tool, chemical, manages material storage, checks
and reports plan condition
- Quality Control Dept: checks whether factories follow quality requirements or
not and ensures quality of products at each stage of producing
- Material management area Center: ensure to supply standard fish with right
quantity and suitable price, deliver on time, maintain good relationship with
suppliers, ensure long term competitive position for the company, look for and
develop material resources
- Producing control Dept: manages producing activities of the company, is
responsible for managing warehouse, An Thinh and Viet Thang Factories
2.1.3 Main business activities of AVF
AVF is specialized in processing and exporting frozen aqua-culture products such
as pangasius in fillet, pieces, of which pangasius fillet account for 90% annual
revenue of the company Pangasius fillet products are diversified and classified
following different standards (color, size, weight…) depend on customer and export
market’s requests Waste products from processing such as head, fat, bone, skin…
are sold directly to feed processing companies for their production inputs
Table 2.2: Sales of AVF from 2008 to 2011
Ton for quantity and 1.000 USD for value
Trang 31
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
Figure 2.2: Some main products of Anvifish
Pangasius fillet T1
Product: Well – Trimmed
Latin name: Pangasius
Product : Half - Trimmed
Latin name : Pangasius
Trang 32
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
2.1.4 Technology Capacity
Producing capacity
- An Thinh Factory owns capacity of 100 tons of raw fish/day, frozen system of
04 rapid freezing conveyers of IQF 500kgs/h, 04 frozen boxes of 2.000 kgs/h/1
- Viet Thang Factory owns capacity of 150 tons of raw fish/day, frozen system
of 04 rapid freezing conveyers of IQF 500kgs/h, 06 frozen boxes of 2.000
kgs/h/1
- Warehouse with capacity of 3.500 tons of products
The company has invested in advanced production line such as: rapid freezing
conveyers and boxes, compressors (Mycom-Japan), grading machines (Denmark)
and some other accessories (Europe)
Trang 33
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
Manufacturing process of frozen pangasius fillet in block/IQF
Figure 2.3: Manufacturing process of frozen pangasius fillet in block/IQF
Freeze IQF
Freeze block
Receiving materials
Cutting fauces Fillet Washing 1 Slicing skin
Repairing fish
Checking fish
Checking parasite*
Washing 2 Supportive substance
Grading
Weigh
Putting into moulds
Waiting for frozen
Rapid freezing
Weigh,
Rapid freezing Splitting moulds Pouring into PE, Closing
Packing, labeling
Preserving
Distributing
CCP B2 CCP C1
Trang 34
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
1 Rate of increasing revenues
on sales and services supply
(%)
2 Rate of increasing gross
profits on sales and services
supply (%)
3 Rate of increasing gross
profits on business activities
(%)
4 Rate of increasing net profit
after corporate income
tax (%)
(Source: AVF)
Trang 35
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
Table 2.5 - AVF’s Expense/net revenue changes over years
Cost of goods sold /Net revenue 83.8% 81.7% 81.1% 80.3% 82.8%
Gross profit/ Net revenue 16.2% 18.3% 18.9% 19.7% 17.2%
Financial profit/ Net revenue -3.5% -5.4% -2.4% -4.6% -3.4%
Selling expense / Net revenue 6.9% 10.6% 8.0% 7.2% 7.3%
Administrative expense/ Net revenue 2.4% 1.3% 1.7% 2.1% 1.9%
Net profit / Net revenue
3.3% 0.8% 6.8% 5.7% 4.8%
(Source: AVF)
In general, AVF’s business result during period of 2008-2011 was fairly good;
although seafood export companies faced to many difficulties in output market and
income materials, AVF’s revenue still reached growth rate of 2 numbers or more
than 34%
Growth of net profit growth during this period was very high, nearly 45% However,
in recent years, it has signaled the decrease with the pace of 2011 was only 4.8%
caused by increase in cost of goods sold Even so that would be encouraged in the
the condition of strongly increasing price of inputs in this year
Cost of goods sold: in order to reach the above achievement, AVF was active in
controlling price, quality and income materials, improving capacity of factories and
applying advanced production procedures…then decreasing rate of cost/net revenue
This rate was decreased from 86% in 2006 to 82.8% in 2011 On the other hand,
gross profit rate in 2006 was increased from 14% to 17.2% in 2011, higher than
average number of the same companies (about 15%) and AVF is at the top group of
companies which have the highest gross profit rate
Other expenses: AVF has well-controlled operation expenses such as selling,
administrative expenses Selling expense/net revenue was decreased from 10.6% in
2009 to 7.3% in 2011 Administrative expense/net revenue was from 1.7% - 2.1%
Trang 36
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
in the period 2009 – 2011 and downed from 2.1% in 2010 to 1.9% in 2011 that
showed the efforts of the company in managing and controlling these kinds of
expense
2.1.5.2 The situation of product export and distribution
Table 2.6 – export sales in markets
Unit: ton for quantity, $ 1000 for value
No Market
Y 2008 Y 2009 Y 2010 Y 2011 Quantity Value Quantity Value Quantity Value Quantity Value
Source: AVF
Trang 37
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
Recently, AVF’ products have been mainly exported to America, EU and Russia
(accounted for more than 91% and 93% respect in term of sales and volume)
EU Market: is the traditional market of pangasius export companies in general
and AVF in particular However; this market is saturation to aqua-culture
exporting companies of Vietnam Moreover, the fierce competition of selling
price among the exporters in fishery has been hurting all participants Therefore,
AVF has restructured its markets in the way of reducing product export to this
market and focusing on America’s one This is proved by showing that, the
proportion of export revenue to EU reduced from 53% in 2008 to 29.2% in 2011
Russian Market: in 2008, Russian’s demand pangasius increased The export
sales to this market reached nearly USD 120 million Along this trend, AVF also
focused on this market with the output was 7.100 tons, accounted for nearly
33% total export volume The competition price among exporters caused the
fraud of increasing ice-glazing rate from 20% to 30% making decrease in
product quality As a result, at the end of 2008, Russia closed market to all
fishery exporters from Vietnam and reopened in April 2009 In this year, total
revenue of pangasius export to this market of USD 64 million decreased nearly
50% in comparison to 2008 Right after the market was reopened, with the
advantage of having a position as a member of the board of exporting seafood to
Russian market; AVF took the chance to boost export to this market making
revenue up to USD 11.5 million, increase by 6% in comparison to 2008 In
recent years, AVF’s strategy for this market is restructuring products to this
market on the way of increasing deep-processing products such as catfish fillet
T1, T2 instead of exporting the whole fish, fillet T3 Looking at the Figure 2.3,
we can see that, in 2010, quantity and value proportions of export to this market
were 13.2% and 8.5% respectively and in 2011, they were 15.6% and 16.2% in
turn
American market: it is hard to enter this market because of anti-dumping duty
tax and other regulations In 2007 and 2008, export value of AVF to this market
Trang 38
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
was only accounted for 4% to less than 5% However, the efforts of penetration
into this market helped AVF to benefit anti-dumping duty of less than 0.52% in
2009 Because of the profitability from US market, AVF focused on exporting to
America As a result, export revenue to this market in 2009 was 6 times more
than 2008 and increased 38% YoY in 2010 and 19% YoY in 2011 According to
the result of final review on anti-damping tax in the period of August 1st 2009 to
July 31st 2010 of U.S Department of Commerce, AVF will be applied
anti-dumping duty of 0.03 USD/kg while the many rivals of AVF possibly imposed
of 2.11 USD/kg So that US market will be considered as advantageous market
of AVF in upcoming times
Other markets: Stemming from the target of diversifying markets, AVF has
been recently implementing trade promotion activities to shift its products to
some other markets in which Australian market was the most focused market
This is approved by the revenue structure of the company in this market has
increased from 1% in 2010 to nearly 6% in 2011
2.2 Internal Environment
2.2.1 Management activities
- Board of directors
Table 2.7 - List of some members of AVF’s Board of Directors
General management 47 Civil Engineer 07 years
Trang 39
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
AVF’s BOM includes 05 members, owns more than 30% of shares of the company
These members own education background of University and Postgraduate, many
years of managing, aquaculture, producing and exporting experiences Most of them
have worked for AVF at least 3 years, especially since 2004 (Chairman cum
General Director) They are not only AVF’s BOD members but also hold high
positions of institutions that support company’s activities In detail, Chairman –
CEO is member of BOM of seafood export companies to Russia Other member of
BOM is a big shareholder who owns 11% of the shares and simultaneously is D &
T General Director of Foods Corp – U.S and Far East Ventures LLC USA This is
one of the key advantages of AVF in exporting its products to US
Most of members in Board of Directors own education background of University
and Postgraduate, with 7 to 20 years of experiences in managing and executing in
the field of aqua-culturing, producing and exporting AVF’s BOD positions are
suitable, based on qualification and capacity of each member
We think that AVF’s BOM and BOD was the key for the company’s success; these
ones will lead AVF to plan and implement effective business strategies in future
- Organization and management structure
Organization and management structure of the company is organized in functional
mechanism It means that each Department undertakes certain functions during
business operation General Director has rights to give out strongest decisions for
raised matters in the company 4 Vice General Directors support General Director:
Vice General Director of Technique, Vice General Director of Finance, Vice
General Director of Materials, and Vice General Director of Producing Each Vice
Trang 40
BUSINESS STRATEGY FOR AVF 2012 2016
CAPSTONE PROJECT REPORT GROUP 1
General Director is responsible to manage some departments and plays the role of
connecting the departments that he is in charge of
Vice General Director of Technique undertakes activities of Dept of IT,
Technique and Construction
Vice General Director of Finance undertakes activities of Dept of HR, F & A
Vice General Director of Materials undertakes activities of quality control
centre and material areas
Vice General Director of Producing undertakes activities of Dept of Planning,
Quality management and Production
Head of department is responsible for specific department operation that regulated
in the business management regulation of the company, but in some cases, the
combination among departments has been facing some difficulties due to not clearly
decentralization management This is one of the problems that AVF have to resolve
in near future
- Human Resource
Total number of employees is 2.927 in which 72 people own education background
of University and Postgraduate, mainly care about management and highly
specialized works
Frozen pangasius export companies in general and AVF in particular employ many
unskilled workers, mainly in factories, this number accounts for 93% to 96% of
total employees Having widened its scale in recent years that push AVF up into the
needs of hiring more and more workers and that is why the number of workers of
AVF has increased so fast In the end of 2009, the number of unskilled workers is
1.988, but this one increases to 2.800 as now These employees are not well
educated; therefore, it is hard and complex to manage them Therefore, AVF
occasionally faces to condition of quitting jobs of those ones However, with the