aeneid agent emergent network intrusion detection

This microform edition is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code.. ProQuest Information and Learning Company 300 North Zeeb Road P.O.

89 8 >EDGFH:I

Y >@P]QX<NbacN\I@PMN\Nb> Y ac>2d\QM>@P]> Yfe <F9>@BM>@V<46Cg

8 PMA K TWA)QXNbjdS<>2> 9 > Yqp >@?`VTQMN PmAC: Kr : >@PO?#A)QXFH>C:sjd FnN :d\N B

UMI Number: 3223031

3223031 2006

UMI Microform Copyright

All rights reserved This microform edition is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code.

ProQuest Information and Learning Company

300 North Zeeb Road P.O Box 1346 Ann Arbor, MI 48106-1346

by ProQuest Information and Learning Company

d >C: Y>@PM?`B QM> ACd d\N VQXAC5 9NBRQSAC: K ACP K BGAC: K FHB Y 9H9 K N _4TWA+QMNFH: BMd\>@VxN^AC: K _4TWA 9FUQo6 QX> Y 9n[9H9

p <WACFnPMVxN POBM>@:> Y acFHBMBON PRQSA+QMFH>@: p >@?`?`FnQMQMN N

FH: e ACPOQMF A 9
T 9n[W9n9?`N :7Q]> Y Y >CP]QX<NbacN ICPMN N> Y ac>2d\QX>CP]> Yfe <F9>CBM>@V<76

dkA+: NVx>@BMN]BON :BOFnQMFni@N K A+QXA >@P BMFH?`V 9 K N :76 BMN\POi2FHd\N QX> 9N ICFnQXFn?#A)QXN-TBON PMB\g p TPOPMN :7Q-Fn:7QXPMTBMFH>C:

K QXN\dS<:> 9>@I@FnN B TQXF9F\N`BOFHI@:A+QXTPON#5WA+BMN B QX<WA+Q A 9H9>ED QX<N\? QM>PXA+VFK 96AC: K A+d d T

;=<NVPO>@VZ>CBMN K PMN BONkACPOdS< VPMN\BMN :7QMB A+:A K ACVQXFniCN ACICN :7Q 5WACBMN K FH:7QXPOTBMFn>@: K

BMd A 9N Y PON N#VxN N\P QX> VZN\N P :N\QoD >@P  v N ?`N POI@N :7Q5xN <WAki2FH>CP FnB YACd\F 9FUQSA+QMN K 576 A 9n9>EDGFH:IsBOFH?`V 9

A+QOQSACd 4B AC: K QM>cQX<N 9>@BMBf> Y ACI@N\:4QMB v2AC: K d AC: DGFnQM<BOQXAC: K QX<N 9 >@BOBq> Y TV QM>bwL> Y FnQXBfACI@N\:4QMB

FnQXB Y T:d\QMFH>@:WA 9FnQo6Cg

;=<FHB d >@? 5FH:WA)QXFH>C: > FH::>Ei+A+QMFH>@:BPON VPON BMN\:7QXB A BOFHI@:F [ d AC:7QqA

iCA+:d N]Fn:bQM<N=ACVV 9FndkA+QMFH>@:

> ACPOQMF[ d\FA FH:7QXN 9H9FHI@N\:d N QMN dS<:FH_4TN BGQX> Fn:4QMPMTBOFH>@: K

N _4TWA 9 K 576<FnBcN :7QM<2TBMFA+BM? Y >@P QM<NPMN\BMN ACPMdS<vDGFnQM<>@TQ DG<FHdS<QX<FHBcD >@T 9

ACP K T>@TBb>@P K NkA 9 QM>5xN N : K TPMN K g r :BRQXNkA K FnQD ACB AC:Nd FUQXFH:I AC: K N\: O>E67AC5 9N#A K i@N\:4QMTPMN+g

acP g 8 PMN\IbjFH?`d >^A+:

?`N ? 5xN POBAC: K QX<PM>@TIC< <AEi2Fn:I 5ZN\N : FH:BRQXPOTd\QM>@PMB Y >@P#d >@TPOBMN\BQM<WA+Q r QX>2>  K TPMFn:I ? 6

BOQMT K FnN B g ;=<N\FHPGI@TFK AC:d\N^AC: K FH:BRQXPOTd\QMFH>@: D N PMN^Fn:4i+A 9TWAC5 9 K TPOFH:IQM<FHB]D >@P  g

s6sQoDGFH:5PO>CQX<N P
sFHdS<WACN 9 VPM>Ei2F

TBOFH:I <FHB dkAC5 9 ?`> K N ?sgmNA 9BO> VPM>Ei2FK N N ?`>CQXFn>@:WA 9 BOTVVx>@POQ QX<PO>@TI@<>CTQ QM<FHB VPM>2d N\BMB\v

>@VVx>@PRQXT:FUQo6 Y >@P=?`NcQX>`VTPOBMTN^QX<FHB K N\I@PMN\NCg ;=<WAC:  6C>@T Y>@P=5ZN 9

FH:A 9H96@v=? 6DGF Y t FH: A+: K >@TP Y>@TP#dS<F9 PMN\:'j2F >@:v >EDGPMF/v  PR62:vcAC: K ; PMN Y >@P g

jF>@:B N :7QM<2TBMFA+BM? QM>ED]ACP K ? 6PMN\BMNkA+PMdS< PMFUiCA 9 K acP g p AC::WA K 6B\v A+: K <FHB FH:BOFHI@<7QMB FH:7QM>

? 6 PON BONkACPOdS<D N PMN  Fn:I 9 K N N V$vxN\BMVxN d\FA 9n96 Y >@PGAEw  6CNkACPo> 9 g

;=<N >CPO6sAC: K GN BMN ACPMdS< FnQXN\PXA+QMTPMNbj2VZN\d F[ d^QM>QX<N^; >@VFHd H@u

 J I@N\:7Q e >@VT 9A+QXFn>@:B]>@:  >CBOQ K TPMFn:I e FH:I f9>> K w?

p >@?`VTQXN\P :N\QoD >@P 4Bqd\>@:7QXFH:4TN QX>m5ZN QX<N > :4T?`N PO>@TBQo6VxN B > A+QOQSACd 4B\gf;=<N\BMN

A+QOQSACd 4B dkAC:`5ZNGFn:FnQMFA+QMN K QM> I7A+FH: ACd\d N BOB QM>bBON :BOFnQMFni@N K A+QXAv4A 9QXN P K A+QSAv K N\BOQMPM>E6 K A+QXAv7I7ACFn:

F 9n9Fnd FnQ ACd\d N BOB`QM> d\>@?`VTQXFn:IAC:

:N\QoD >@P  PON BO>@TPMd\N B Y>@P >CQX<N P VTPOVZ>@BON B\v]>@P 9 QM>

AVx>CQXN\:7QXFA 99>@BOB]QX> QX<N^>EDG:N\Pm> Y QM<NQSACPOI@N\QMN K BO62BOQMN ?sg

ACVVPM>@VPOFA+QMN PON BMVx>@:BONCg J : A+VVPM>CVPMFHA+QXN PMN BOVZ>C:BMNd AC::>CQc5ZN 9ACT:dS<N K T:7QXF9 QM<NA+QOQSACd 

Y PM>C? QX<N^AEi+ACF9 AC5 9NmBMFHIC:WA+QXTPMN [W9NcVPM> [W9N\B v>@PGA)QMQSA+d 2B=QM<WA+QmACPONcT: 4:>EDG:QM>QX<NBON d TPMFnQo6

T:FnQo6Cgq;=<4TB vQM<N PONFHB]A VxN POFH>

DG<N\:FUQXB=dS<WACPMACd\QMN POFHBOQMFHd\B=dkAC:s5ZNFnBM> 9A+QXN K FH: >@P K N P]QM> d PMN A+QXNQM<NBMFnI@:WA+QMTPMN [W9NCvQM<N :QX<N

PMN\d N\FHVQ AC: K Fn:BOQXA 9H9A+QXFn>@: > QX<NmBOFHI@:A+QXTPON [W9N+g-jFnI@:F[ dkAC:7Q K dkAC:`5ZNGd ACTBMN K#K TPMFH:I

QX<N N N\:QM<N [ PMBRQ=A+QOQSACd `AC: K QX<N FH:BRQSA 9n9A+QMFH>@:> Y QX<N :N\D BOFHI@:WA)QXTPON [W9NCgq;=<4TB\v

QX<NGA+QMQXACd CN\PMB <WAki@N=QX<NGA K i+AC:7QSACICN=FH::>Ei@N 9 A+QMQXACd 4B ACBfD N 9H9 ACB-FH: i+ACPOFA+QMFH>@:B > 9

4:>EDG:A+QOQSACd 4B\g

J K A+VQXFUi@NFH:7QMPMTBOFH>@: K N\QXN\d\QMFH>@:BO62BRQXN ?`BG<WAki@N5xN N\: K N ?`>@:BOQMPXA+QMN K FH: PON BONkACPOdS<sQM>VPM>

QXN\d\QMN K :N\QoD >@P  i2T 9:N PMAC5 9NcQM> >CQX<N\PmA+QMQXACd 4B g

FnBOQMFH:I PMN BONkACPOdS< FH: K FHBRQXPMFn5TQMN K Fn:7QXPMTBMFH>C: K BO62BRQXN ?`B]<WA+B VPON BMN\:7QXN K i+ACPOFH>@TB

N POB

QX<Nbd\>@?`VPM>@?`FHBONc> Y APMN 9A+QXFUi@N 9 BO?#A 9H9 :4T? 5ZN\Pm> Y d\PMFnQMFHd A 9

e A+VWA K >@Vx>@T 9 96`AC: K ACd\d TPMA+QXN K N\QMN d\QMFH>@: K F 9 AC: K N TBOFniCN

>@:NDG<>FHB`ACTQM<>@POF N K QM> <AEiCNBO>@?`NA+d d N\BMB`QX> QX<NsBO62BOQMN ?sv]FHB VWA+POQXFnd T 9ACP 9 K F `d T 9Qkg

N\:F A > BON PRiFnd N A+QMQXACd  g

;=<N PON^ACPMNmQoD >5PM>7A K A+VVPM>@ACdS<N B QX<WA+Q]ACPMN I@N :N\PXA 9n96`ACVV 9FnN K QM> K A+QOQSACd 

QX<A+Q K N\i2FA+QMN Y PO>@? QX<N TBMTA 9 5xN <AEi2Fn>@P > QX<N BO62BOQMN ? AC: K FUQXB TBMN\PMB\g r 9n9Fnd FnQqTBMN > A 9N I@FUQ

TBON P BmACd d\N BOBmQM> A d >@?`VTQMN P=BO62BRQXN ? FHBGA Vx>D N P Y 9 ?`N\QX<> K 576#DG<FHdS<sAC:sA+QMQXACd CN\P

<WAki@NmACd\d N\BMB g  N\dkACTBMN=QX<NmACd\d N\BMB FHBq>2d d\TPMPOFH:IT: K N P AC:>+QX<N\P-FK N\:4QMFnQo6Cv@QX<FnB A BO>VPM>Ei2FK N\B

<WAki2FH>@POB=QX<WA+Q K N\i2FA+QMN YPM>@? QX<Nb:>@PO?#A 9 ACd\QMFni2FnQMFHN\B=> Y QM<N^TBMN\PG5ZN\FH:I FH?`VxN PMBO>@:WA+QMN K vBMTdS<

ACB T:4TBMTWA 9 >@Pm>CQM<N P ACd\QMFni2FnQMFHN BGQX<A+Q QM<N TBON P K >N\Bc:>CQ :>@PO?#A 9H96 VZN\P Y>@PO?g

?#A+FH:7QSACFn:FH:I VPO> [W9N\B Y >@PNkA+dS<TBON P\v

V 9ACd Fn:I ABMFHIC:F[ d AC:7QG5TP K N :>@: QX<N r a^j QX> VZN\P Y>@PO? QM<N BON Y T:d\QXFn>@:BGd >CPMPMN\d\Q 96@g

FHBOTBMN K N\QXN\d\QMFH>@: ACVVPM>7A+dS<N B QX<N QSACB  Y PO>@? QX<N>CQM<N P#BMFK NFH: QM<WA+Q FUQ

Y >@PO? > PMN\VZ>@BOFnQM>@PO6#FH: DG<FndS<sQM<NbA+QMQXACd  VPO> [W9N\BGACPMN^BRQX>@PON K AC: K QX>DG<FndS<

;=<N BON K N BMd\PMFnVQXFn>@:BqPON _4TFHPONGA K N\QXACF 9 K T: K N POBOQSA+: K FH:Ib> Y QM<NGA+QOQSACd  AC: K dkAC:>C: 9

BMFnI@:WA 9 AbVx>CQXN\:7QXFA A+QMQXACd  DG<N\: AcQX<PMN BO<> 9 <WA+B 5xN N\:#VWA+BMBMN

v2FH:

FndkA+QMFH:I^A+d\QXFUi2FnQo6 QM<WA+Q FnB

BMT 96T:2TBMTWA 9 QM<WA+QbA KK FnQMFH>@:WA 9 Fn:4iCN BRQXFHI@A+QXFn>@:FHBcD ACPOPXAC:7QXN K g
FnBMTBON K N\QMN d\QMFH>@:$v A+B

BM<>DG: AC5x>iCNCvW> YQMN :sPMN 9FHN\B=>@:sA`POT 9No5WA+BMN K ACVVPM>7A+dS<g ;=<FHBGN\i+A 9TWA+QMN BmACd\QMFni2FnQMFHN\B=ACI7ACFn:BOQ

4:>EDG: A+QMQXACd  BMd\N :WACPOFH>@B#AC:

Fn:

K N\BMFHIC:N K AC: K ACBGd >@?`VPON <N\:BMFUi@NbACBGVZ>CBMBMFn5 9NFn:>@P K N\P=QX> VPM>Ei2FK FH? T? VPM>CQMN d\QMFH>@:$g

;=<N O>@POFnQo6 > QM<N PON BONkACPOdS< FH:bFH:7QXPOTBMFn>@: K BO62BRQXN ?`Bf<ACB Fn:7i@> 9i@N K PMT 9N 5WACBMN K

QX> VPMN\i2Fn>@TB 96sT: 4:>EDG: A)QMQSA+d 2B\g

J K

ACVQXFniCNFH:7QXPOTBMFn>@:

>@TB 96T:BMN N\:A+QOQSACd 4B B 4FH:N\Q A gUvZwCy@y@y(g J POQXF[ d FHA 9 Fn:4QMN 9n9FHICN :d\NcQXN dS<:FH_4TN\BACPMNb5xN FH:I

ACVV 9FHN

QM>#Fn:4QMPMTBOFH>@:

QX<NbFH:<N PMN\:7QAC5F9FUQo6 > :N TPMA 9 :N\QoD >@P 4B QM>#d 9ACBMBOF Y

;=<NcTBON> Y ACICN :7Q=5WACBON K NV 9>@PON K ACPOiCN P\v  F9H9 v2j2TP K T$v  e >2>dS<$v

dS<WA 9 BRQXPOTd\QMTPMNbFHB=VPON K N :N K 576 d PONkA+QMFH:I BOVZN\d FA F\N K ACICN :7QXB\vWBM>@?`N^5ZN\FH:I>@5BMN PRi@N\PMBcA+: K

>CQM<N POBACB K FnPMN\d\QX>CPMB FHBO<>@VvwCy@y7w2v$VgB<WH7u(g ;=<N\BMN VPMFn>@PGD >@P 4B vACBmD N 9H9

:N\>@TBbACI@N\:4QMBcQX<WA)Q^? TBOQ^d\>@?`? T:FndkA+QMN TVQX<N<FHN PMACPMdS<76QM>A d N :7QMPXA 9F N K VZ>@Fn:7QcDG<N PON

N\QMN PM?`FH:A+QXFn>@: > F QX<N\PMN=FHBqAC: A+QMQXACd  Fn: VPO>@I@PMN\BMB-FnB

K NCgf;=<FHB d N\:7QXPXA 9F\N K ACVVPO>7ACdS< 9N AEiCN B QX<N\BMNmBO62BOQMN ?`B i2T 9 :N PXA+5 9N]QM> YACF9TPONCv@576`A+QOQSACd 

>@P >CQX<N P ?`NkA+:B v> Y QX<A+Q]d\N :7QXPMA 9 d\>@?`VZ>@:N :7Q AC:BMN\: N\Q]A 9 gUvwCy@y@y(g FnQM<>@TQ QX<N d N\:7QXPXA 9

;=<N>@5 ON\d\QMFni@N> Y QM<FHBmD >CP D ACBcQM> K N\iCN 9>CV AC: K QXN\BOQbA VPO>> Yo> Y d >@:d\N VQ VPO>CQX>CQo62VxN

VxN N P QM>oVxN N\P K FHBRQXPMFn5TQMN K ACI@N\:7Q^5WACBMN K Fn:7QXPMTBMFH>C: K N\QMN d\QMFH>@:BO62BRQXN ? QX<WA+Q v576QX<N :WA)QXTPON

FH:7QMPMTBOFH>@: K N\QMN d\QMFH>@: A+: K QX> BMN PRi@NACB A Y >@T: K A+QXFn>@: Y >@P A KK FnQXFn>@:WA 9 PON BMN ACPMdS< Fn:

QX<N A+VV 9FndkA+QMFH>@:#> Y QM<N BON d\>@:d\N VQMBmQM>`Fn: Y>@PO?#A+QMFH>@:#BO62BOQMN ?`B BON d TPMFnQo6Cg

 ;$&

;=<N PON <WA+B 5xN N\: A BOFHI@:F[ d AC:7Q > PMN\BMNkA+PMdS< Fn:`QM<N [ 9 > FH:7QXPOTBMFn>@: K N\QXN\d\QMFH>@:v

DGFnQM< i+ACPOFH>@TB 9N\i@N 9 > BOTd d\N BOB g-;=<N ACVV 9FHdkA)QXFH>C:b> Y ACI@N\:7Qo5ACBMN K QXN\dS<:> 9>@I@FHN\BQX> Fn:7QXPMTBMFH>C:

VPO>@5 9N\?g e ACBOQ PMN BONkACPOdS< Fn: ACICN :7Q 5WACBMN K FH:I@N :N PXA 9 <ACB Y>2d TBMN K >@:sd N :7QMPXA 9F N K

N<Fn5FnQMN

d N\:7QXPXA 9F\N

A+:WA 4FHPMAC?#A+:N\Q A gnvw+y@y@u(g 9ACP 96CvxPON BONkACPOdS< FH:7QM>

K FH:7QXPOTBMFn>@: K N\QMN d\QMFH>@:BO62BOQMN ?`B <WACB`TQMF9  N K A+:4Q 9 CN

T:FHd A+QXFn>@: 5xN\QoD N N :ACI@N :7QMB g

FH:d PMN ACBMN K <ACP K D K K QM<N 5WACPMPOFHN\PMB> Y QX>2> 94FnQcAkiCA+F9A+5F9FnQo6sAC: K A 

N _4TWA)QXN#VPM>2d N BOBMFn:I Vx>ED N\P QX>A

:F[ dkAC:7Q FHBMBOTN F  <WAC>v  >@TvwCy@y@u(gqlm:4QMF9 QX<N K N\iCN 9>@V?`N :7Q=> Y QM<N J h N aLBR6BRQXN\?

:> Y 9H96 K FnBOQMPMFH5TQXN K VxN N\P QM>oVxN N\PmACI@N :7Q V 9A)Q Y>@PO? BMVxN d\F[ d A 9H96 K Y >@PGBMN\d TPOFnQo6ACV 

V 9FHdkA)QXFH>C:B]<WACB=5xN N\:Aki+ACF9AC5 9 Y >@P K 9>@V?`N :7Q g

QXPOFH5TQXN K VxN N P QM>oVxN N\Ps?`>@5F9 ACICN :7QsV 9A+Q Y>@PM? FH: FH:7QXPOTBMFn>@: K N\QMN d\QMFH>@:$g ;=<NVPMFn?#A+PO6

<762VZ>CQM<N BOFHB QM<WA+QmD]A+B FH:7iCN BOQMFHI7A)QXN K D]ACBmQX<WA)Q 5ZN\<WAki2FH>@Pm5WACBON K TVx>@:A Y >@PXA+I@FH:I

?`N\QSA+V<>@P Fn: AC: <>@?`>@I@N\:N >CTB BM>2d FnN\Qo6 > ACTQX>C:>@?`>@TB ?`>@5F9N`BM> Y QoD ACPMNA+I@N :7QXB DG<FHdS<

ACPON VxN PM?`FnQOQXN K QM> d >@?`? T:FHdkA)QXNQX<N\FHP [ : K QX>#d\N PRQSACFn:> Y QM<N FnP VxN N\PMB D >@T 9 5xN dkA+VWAC5 9

> K N\QXN\d\QMFH:I 5x>CQM< 4:>EDG: AC: K T: 4:>EDG: A+QMQXACd 4B ACI7A+FH:BRQ#A d >@?`VTQMN P`:N\QoD >@P  g ;=<N

Y ACI@N\:7QXBmFH:A`BOdkA 9NY PON N^BM>2d FHA 9 >@P VZN\PM?`FnQMQMN

A PXACVF

d >@?`? T:FndkA+QMFH>@:

ACI@N\:7QXB=QX> d >C:4QMFH:4TNQX<N FHP BMNkA+PMdS< Y 9>CTB VWA+d CN\QMB >@:>CQM<N P=<>@BOQMBmFn: >CP  g

QqD ACB-A 9BM>c<762VZ>+QX<N\BMF\N

QX<A+QfQM<N]BMd A 9N Y PON N]BO>d\FA :N\QoD >@P  FH:bDG<FHdS<QM<N]ACICN :7QXB-BON 9nY

N :7QMFHPMN ACI@N\:4Q]<>@BOQ D >@T

5xN BOTKK

DGFnQM<>@TQ FH:7QMN PMPOTVQMFH>@:ACBGQX<N\PMN D >@T 9 BRQXF9n9 5xN A`PMN 9A+QXFUi@N 9 BO<>@POQ VWA+QM< 5xN\QoD N N\: A+:46 QoD >

PMN\?#A+FH:Fn:IACI@N\:7QXB g

!+Z.
4 $
$(
L& !+X
 $



 
 !

QX<NAC5F9FnQo6 > QX<N BO62BOQMN ? QM> PMN\d >@IC:F\N QX<>@BMN Qo62VxN B> Y A)QMQSA+d 2BcAC:

KK

F :>CQ :N d\N BOBXACPOF9

QX<N TBON > BOFH? T A+QMN

TBON> Y BRQXPO>@:Id > K N?`FHI@PMA+QXFn>@:g ;=<FHB=PON _4TFnPMN K QM<WA+Q]QM<N^ACI@N\:4QMB=5ZN^A+5 9 QM> QXPOTBOQ=QM<N<>@BRQ

BO62BRQXN ?`BGQX>DG<FHdS<QX<N\6 D N PON 5xN K N V 9>E6@N K g J 9BM>vQX<NbACICN :7QXB=D N PMNbd >C:4QXACFH:N K DGFnQM<FH: QX<N

<>@BRQ  NN\d TQMFH>@: VPO>d\N BMB\v-BM>QM<WA+Q AC: A+QMQXACd  A+I7ACFH:BOQbQX<N <>@BOQ A BM> K FHPON d\Q 9 K

QX<N A+I@N :7QXB\g

d > 9H9N\d\QMFH>@: ?`N dS<AC:FHBO? d >CT 9 VPON\i@N\:7Q A t AkiCA o5WACBON K BM> 9TQXFn>@: Y PM>C? 5xN FH:I YN ACBMFn5 9 Fn: A

BMN\POiCN >@: 9 A+B A VPO>> Y > od\>@:d\N VQ=VPM>CQM>CQo62VZN+g

;=<N K N BMFnI@: > QM<N BR62BOQXN\? AC: K FnQXBTBON > A Y >CPXACI@Fn:I ?`N\QSA+V<>@Pd >CT 9 PMN\: K N PsFnQ

FH:BMN :BMFnQMFniCN QX> 9>@:Iv K PXAkDG: o>CTQ^A+QOQSACd 4Bc>@PmBMd AC:BFn:DG<FndS<QX<N\PMN FnBcA#BOFHI@:F[ d AC:7Q VxN POFH> K

> QMFH?`N#5xN\QoD N N :AC:>C?#A 9>@TBbVWACd +N\QXB\g ;=<FHB

;=<NBO62BRQXN ? D]A+B K N BOFHI@:N K ACBA#VPM>2> Yo> Y d >@:d N VQcVPO>CQX>CQo62VxNCvA+: K QX<N PMN Y>@PMN:> d >@:

5xN]iCA 9 K d >@:d N PO:B FH: AcVPO> K Td\QMFH>@:BR6BRQXN\?v7QX<N\6 D N PONGFHI@:>CPMN K FH: QX<FHBqVPO>CQX>+Qo6VxN=FH:>CP K N\P

QX> d\>@:BOQMPXACFn: QX<N^BMd\>@VxN > QX<NbPON BONkACPOdS<g

J 9BM>vQX<N`BO62BRQXN ? D ACB :>+Q K N BMFnI@:N K QX>DGFnQM<BOQXAC: K A+:46>CQM<N P Y>@PO? > A+QOQSACd >+QX<N\P

QX<AC: Ac<>@BRQ 5ZN\FH:IcPON ?`>Ei@N K g-;=<N PON]D]ACB-:>bd\>@:BOF K N\PXA+QMFH>@: ICFni@N\: QX>^A KK PMN\BMBMFn:I^<FMA+d 2Fn:Iv

BMVx>2> [ :Ivf?#AC:oFH: QX<No?`FKK 9NA)QMQSA+d 2B\v >@P AC:76 >CQX<N P A)QMQSA+d  >@: QX<N J

K FnBMd TBMBMN K Fn: QM<N d TPOPMN\:4Q 9FUQXN\PXA+QMTPMNA+PMN i2T 9:N PXA+5 9 QM> A+QOQSACd A+Q^d N\POQSA+FH: VZ>CFH:7QXB K TN QM>

;=<NGPMN\BMNkA+PMdS<#VPMN BON :7QXN K FH: QM<FHB K FHBMBON PRQSA+QMFH>@:PON BMT 9QXN K Fn: QX<N K N\BMFnI@:`AC: K FH?`V 9 

QXFn>@: > A+: FH::>Ei+A+QMFni@N ACVVPO>7ACdS< QX> FH:7QXPOTBMFn>@: K FH: A d\>@?`VTQXN\P >CP #QM<PM>@TI@<

p <WACVQMN P w

Y QX<N FnQMN PXA)QXTPON

9  #($; 

r Y>@PO?#A+QMFH>@:bBMN\d TPOFnQo6b<WACB 5ZN\d >@?`N A d POTd FHA 9 ACPMN A > PON BONkACPOdS<FH: 9FHIC<4Q > QX<N FH:d\PMNkA+BMFH:I

i2FHPOTBMN\B]FH:#QM<N @D<Cy  5PO>@TI@<7QGA+5Z>@TQ QM<N DGFK NoBOVPMN A K PMN\d >@IC:FnQMFH>@:`> Y QX<N QX<PONkA+Q]ACI7ACFn:BOQ

@?@y B g ;=<FHBGdS<WACVQXN PmVPON BMN\:7QXBcA Y QM<N^PMN 9 N\i+AC:7QmPMN\BMN ACPMdS<

QXF[ d FHA 9 r :4QMN 9n9FHICN :d\N#QX<WA)QBMTVVZ>@PRQQX<N QM<N >CPO6 A+: K K N BOFHI@: > QM<FHB PON BONkACPOdS<  dS<WAC>@B A+: K

9NFnQo6QM<N >CPMFHN\B v2N ?`N POI@N :7Q]5xN <AEi2Fn>@P v2BMN 9nYo>CPMI7AC:FkA)QXFH>C:v@BM>2d FHA 9 :N\QoD >@P 2B\vWAC: K A ACV 

  6 R

-&-*D% 2*& M
$( C &
4W62 / 5
4;*

   


A+Q 9NkACBRQqBOFH:d\N]QX<N 9A+QXN @@z@y Bq576 N\BOQXFn: r :QX<WA)QfD >@P bQX<NGACTQX<>@PfVPMN\BMN :7QMB A+PMI@T 

Y >@P QX<N QSACB #A+Q QX<N J ?`N POFHdkA+: p >@:BRQXFUQXTQMFH>@:`D]ACB Y PXAC?`N K QX<WA+Q BXAC?`N YPMAC?`N\D >@P 

Y TPRQX<N\P 5ZN\<FH: K FH: QM<N ??@y  DGFnQM< QX<N#FH:7i@N\:4QMFH>@: > 9N V<>@:NCg J KK FUQXFH>C:WA 9 QXN\dS< 

$>@PRQXBQX>A KK PMN\BMB^QX<NFnBMBOTN B\v 5x>CQX<QM<PM>CTI@< 9N\I7A 9 AC: K QMN dS<:FHdkA 9 N PON VPMN

?`>@:AC: K ?`>@PON <FnI@< 96bFn:4QMN I@PMA+QXN K FH:7QX> K ACF9 9 YNCv+QM<N=ACTQX<>@PfPMN Vx>@PRQXBfQM<WA+QfQM<N]QXN\dS<:> 9>@IC6

5xN A KK PMN\BMBON K 576sAd >C? 5FH:A+QXFn>@: > QXN dS<:FHd A 9 A i+AC:d\N BmAC: K TV K A+QMN K 9N I@A 9 VPO>CQXN\d\QXFn>@:g

FH:d PMN ACBMN K TBMN^> Y 9 K A)QSA PMN\_4TFHPONcFH:d\PMN ACBMN K N$>@PRQXB QM>

$RM#3$ 
A 4Fn:I QM<N d\>@:7QXN\:4QMB]> Y A [W9NmT:Fn:7QXN 9n9FnI@FH5 9 QM> AC:76`5TQ ACTQM<>@PMF N K TBON PMB\g

acN ::FH:I @R?D< 9FnBOQMB N\FHI@<7Q Y>CPM?`B > 9 5ZN\<WAki2FH>@P FH: A d\>@?`VTQXN\P]BO62BRQXN ? QX<WA)Q

d >CT 9 5xN 9FH: +N K QX>`A BMN\d TPOFnQo6 i2FH> 9 A+QMFH>@: 

9 FnBOQMB QX<PMN N d A+BMBMN\B qK FHBMd 9>@BOTPMN QX<PONkA+Q v7FH:7QXN\I@PMFUQo6^QX<PONkA+Q v7AC: KK N\:FA o> YoBMN\POi2FHd\N QM<PMN A+Qkv4A+: K

>@P#QX<FHB K FnBMd\TBMBOFH>@:vGQX<N ACTQX<>@P BM<WA 9H9 d A+QXN\I@>@POF NQX<PONkA+QMB FH:7QX> >@:N> Y QX<N Y 9H9>ED 

FH:I I@PM>CTVB mK FnBMPMTVQXFn>@:v K FHBMd 9>@BOTPMN+v K N\d N VQXFH>C:vFH:7QMN I@POFnQo6@v$AC: K TBMTPOVWA+QXFn>@:g;=<N A+TQX<>CP

5xN 9 FnN\iCN B QX<A+Q QX<FHB FnBACVVPM>@VPOFA+QMN#Fn: >@P

QX<N 9FHBOQ g J 9BO>v DG<F9 J @R@Hv Vg u@z K N\BMd POFH5xN B#AC: A)QMQSA+d  QSA >@:>C? 6 

acFHBOPMTVQMFH>@:$v@FH:QX<FHB-d >C:4QMN2Qkv2FH: K FHd A+QXN\B AC:76N\iCN :7Q QM<WA+Q VPON\iCN :7QXB >@P->CQX<N PODGFnBMNGFH?`VWACFnPMB

dkA 9

FHBOPMTVQXFH>C:QX<PONkA+QMB A+PMN AC:76 QM<PMN A+QQX<A+QD >CT 9 5xN QX<N PMN\BMT 9Q^> Y BM>@?`N +N :

<>@BRQcQX<A+QdkA+:VPM>Ei2F K QX<NBON POi2Fnd N B> Y QM<N K FnBMPOTVQXN K BMN\POi@N\PDG<N : :N\N K N g j2FH?`F9A+P 9 A

5WACd 4TVBMN\POi2FHd\NbVPM>Ei2FK N\P=?#Ak6 5xN^ACVVPM>@VPOF A+QMNFY QX<N PMNFnB=BMT! `d\FHN :7Qm5xN 9 FnN Y

I@N\:N PMA+QX>@POB v ?#A+P 4FH:I V 9ACd\N BDG<N PON`QM<N`dkAC5 9N B^PMT: T: K N POI@PM>@T: K QM>PON K Td N QX<N dS<WAC:d N

d PON\D D >CT 9 A+d d FK N :7QXA 9H96 d\TQ QM<N dkA+5 9N+v-AC: K PON BRQXPMFnd\QMFH:IV<462BOFHdkA 9

<>@TBMFH:IbQM<NGBO62BOQMN ? BM<>@T 9 5ZNmACVVPM>@VPOFA+QMN 9 K AC: K V<762BMFndkA 9 BMN\d TPOFnQo6 ?`NkACBOTPMN\B

<F9 N\iCN PR6d >@?`VTQMN PFn:QX<N D >@P 9 FHBNVx>@BON K QX> QX<FHB Qo62VxN`> Y QM<PMN A+Qkv:>CQ^A 9n9 ACPON

NVx>@BMN K QM>QM<NFn:7QXN :7QMFH>@:WA 9 d PONkA+QMFH>@: > QX<FnB Qo6VxNs> Y QM<PMN A+Qkg

9 CN 96sQX> 5xN`BOT5 ON\d\Q^QX> QX<FHB Qo62VxN`> Y QM<PMN A+Q^FH:d 9 K 5TBOFH:N\BMB^BO62BOQMN ?`B A+: K I@>Ei@N PO:?`N :7Q

BO62BRQXN ?`B g

: FH:7QXN\:4QMFH>@:A 9 QSACPOI@N\QMN

A)QMQSA+d A+I7ACFH:BOQ`QX<NsN :7QXFUQo6 d >@:7QXPO> 9H9 FH:IQM<N BR6BRQXN\?

> BM>@?`N^>CQX<N P]Qo62VZNb> Y V<762BMFHd A 9 QX<PMNkA)QkvWBMTdS<ACBmA [ PMN+vi+AC: K A FHBO?v>@P]QX<N YQkg

N ?`V 9>6CN K QX<N BMN QX<PMNkA)QXB g J d\>@?`VTQXN\P BXA Y [ PON NQMFH:ICTFHBO<FH:IGBR6BRQXN\?1BO<>@T 9

5xNsFn:BOQXA 9H9 N Fn: QM<NsBMN PRi@N\P#PM>2>@? AC:

BO62BRQXN ?B V<462BOFHdkA 9 BMFnQMTWA+QMFH>@: 576 iFnBMTWA 9 FH:BOVZN\d\QMFH>@:vCVWA+QXPO> 9H9FH:I I@TWACP K B v4A+: K A QXN ?`VxN PXA)QXTPON

?`>@:FnQM>@P]Fn:QM<N^PM>2>@? QM>D]ACPO:> Y

N> Y QX<N^BO62BRQXN ?B >@VxN PMA+QXFn:I  >C:N

dkA+: A BM> 5xN N ?`V 9>E6@N K g;=<N 5WACd 4TV BO62BOQMN ?`BbAC: K PMN ?`>CQMN Y 9H9o5WACd <>CBOQXFn:IsACPMN A+5Z>@TQ

;=<N PON 9 ?`N\QX<> K BQM<WA+Q AC:bA+QOQSACd +N PdkA+:bTBMN-QX>GFH:7QMN P Y N\PMN-DGFnQM<cQX<N Aki+ACF9AC5F 9FnQo6

>@P  g J BNV 9ACFH:N K AC5Z>EiCNCv+QM<N A+QMQXACd 4B d\>@T 9 5xN K 576^5TBOFH:N\BMB d >@?`VxN\QXFUQXFn>@:v

VPO>CQXN\BOQXB^> Y A B^>@Pc>@POI7AC:FkA+QMFH>@:B Vx> 9FHd FnN B >@P^ACd\QMFH>@:B vVx> 9FUQXFHd A 9 VPM>+QXN BRQkv>@P^A+B

QX<N PMN`FHB^A 9BM> QM<N Y QM<PMF9H9 BMN\N CN\PMBDG<>D]A+:4QbQX>BO<>ED QX<N FHP^A+5F9FnQXFnN B 546

?`N PMd\N :WA+PMFHN\B > BM>@PRQXB\v$VxN P Y >CPM?`FH:IQX<N FHP > d\625xN POi+AC:

dkA+TBMFn:I QX<N]BO62BOQMN ? QM>cPMT:>@TQq> Y PM>2>@?LQX>cBRQX>@PON QX<N ?#ACF9 vQX<4TB-A)QfQX<N i@N\PO6 9NkACBRQ K N\:76Fn:I

9 QX> QX<N A+d d >CT:7Q >CP^ACd d\>@T:7QXBQX> DG<FndS<QM<N 9 D ACB A KK PMN\BMBON K g ;=<FnB

?`N\QX<> K PON _4TFHPON B :>^?`>@PMN]QMN dS<:FndkA 9 4F9n9 QX<WA+: QM<NGAC5F9FUQo6bQM>^BMN : K A 9A+PMI@N]N\?#A+F9

>@P-QX>bBMN\: K A 9A+PMI@N]iC> 9T?`NG> Y 9 ?`N BOBXACICN B g h A+QXTPXA 9n96@v@Ab?`>@PMNGBO>@V<FnBOQXFndkA+QMN K A+QMQXACd CN\P

D >@T 9 N2QMN : K QX<NGNZ>@PRQ :N N K N QM>^d >@:d\NkA 9 QM<N=QXPMTNm>CPMFHICFH:Bq> Y QM<NmA+QMQXACd  v25TQ Ab5 9A+QSA+:4Q

;=<FnB Qo62VZN> Y A+QMQXACd d >@T 9KK N\:46 9 QM> A 9H9 TBON POBFY QM<N BO62BRQXN ? FHB d >@: [ I@TPMN K FH:BMTdS<

A D]Ak6 QX<WA)Q ABM<ACPMN K ACPONkAFnB^TBMN K Y >@PbA 9n9 FH:d\>@?`FH:I N\?#ACF9 9ACP 96@vZFY QX<N`BO62BRQXN ? FnB

:>CQmVPO>@VxN P 9 d >C: [ I@TPON

>@POQMT:WA+QMN 96CvQM<FHB Qo6VxN> Y QX<PMNkA)Q=dkAC: 5xNc?`FnQMFHI7A+QMN K 9 BOFH?`V 9 BOQXN\VB g e-9A+d FH:I

<>@?`N K FHPMN\d\QM>@PMFnN Bf>C:A K F
ZN PON :7QqVACPOQMFnQXFn>@: Y PO>@?LQX<N PM>2>CQ [9N BR62BOQXN\? AC: K QX<N]BR62BOQXN\? [W9N B g

;=<FnB D >@T 9 [W9H9FH:I QX<NG<>@?`N [W9NoBR62BOQXN\? Y PM>C? FH:7QMN P YN\PMFn:IcDGFnQM<`>+QX<N\P >CVZN\PXA+QMFH>@:B

> QX<N BO62BOQMN ?sg G Y d >@TPOBMN+v >@:N D >@T 9 :N\N K QX>V 9ACd N#QM<N PM>2>CQTBMN PB K FHPMN\d\QM>@PO6

9o5x>@? 5 A+QOQSACd  v N BMVxN d\F A 9n96 F QM<NsA+QMQXACd CN\PMB#A 9BO> 9>E6 K N d\N VQMFH>@:AC: K BMVx>> Y QX<N

PM>CTQXFn:IVWA+QM<B A+: K >@PMFnI@FH:WA)QXFH:I A KK PMN BOBMN\B g

;=<N PONGACPMN >CQX<N\P Y > A+QMQXACd ^QX<WA+QqACPMN 5WACBMN K TVZ>C: dS<WACPMACd\QMN PMFnBOQMFHd Bf> Y QX<N ; p]e
r

QXFn>@:B\g

i+ACPMFHA+QXFn>@: >@: QX<N=QM<N ?`NG> Y QM<NG?#A+F95x>@? 5 A+QMQXACd  FHBqQM<N e FH:I^> Y acNkA+QM< PMT?`NCv

wCy@yCyv7Vg Ez@y(gq;=<FnB A)QMQSA+d FH:7i@> 9i@N\B BON : K Fn:I A e FH:IbVWACd +N\Q <FUQXNCvwCyCy@y
e >@BRQXN 9 v@R?@u

@R?  (g;=<FHBA)QMQSA+d  BMN\: K B^:4T?`N PM>CTB^j h PMN _4TN\BOQMB vPMN\_2TN BOQMFH:I QM<WA+Q^A#d\>@::N\d\QMFH>@: 5xN

QXFn>@:B=QX<PON N D]Ak6s<WAC: K BM<WA CN 576A 9QXN POFH:IQM<N j h VWACd +N\Q QM>#Vx>@FH:7Q=QM>#A`:>@:NFnBOQMN :7Q r

A+QOQSACd  ACI7ACFn:BOQ
sFHd PO>@BM> Y  ACTQX>C?#A+QMFHd`TV

>@TQ >@:A#d\>@::N\d\QMFH>@:PON _4TN BRQ^AC: K Fn:d PONkACBOFH:I`QX<N :2T? 5ZN\Pc> Y d\>@::N\d\QMFH>@:B BMTVVx>@PRQXN K QM>

DGFnQM<>@TQfAC: Nd N\BMBMFUi@N=:4T? 5xN P > YYA BMN Vx>@BMFUQXFUi@N B\gf;=<N ACTQM<>@P PMN Vx>@PRQXB BMTd\d N BOB-FH:bVZN\P Y>@PO? 

AC: K K FHBOQMPMFn5TQXN K QX<PO>@TI@< QM<N r Y >@P#QX<FHB VTPMVx>@BMN PMT?`NCv wCy@yCyvGVg=wCuv

A 9 Fnd FH>CTB TBMN^ACPOFHBON B YPM>C? d\PMNkA)QXFH:IA <FHIC<#i@> 9T?`Nc> Y VFH:I PMN\_2TN BOQMB g ;=<NVWACd +N\QMB d AC:

> QMN :s5ZNbA KK PMN BOBMN K QX>`AC: r A KK PMN\BMBmN : K Fn:I`FH:w >@PGy QX>`dkA+TBMNQX<N VFn:IPMN\_4TN BRQXB QM>

5xNb5PM>7A

ACPON=d >@: [ I@TPMN K QM> 9ACT:dS<`BOFH? T 9QSA+:N >@TB-A+QMQXACd 4B ACI7ACFn:BOQqQM<N=QSACPOI@N\Q gf;=<FnB K FHBRQXPMFn5TQMN BqQX<N

62Fn:IcQX<Nm:4T? 5xN P > A+QOQSACd 4Fn:I

BO62BRQXN ?`B g-;=<FHB K FHBMPOTVQMFni@N VZ>ED N Pq> Y QM<FHB Qo62VZN]> Y A+QMQXACd bD ACBqd 9N ACP 9 K N ?`>@:BOQMPXA+QMN KK TPMFH:I

J VFH:I >2> K FH:AC: K > FnQXBON 9UY FHBGN ACBO6 QM> K >vx5TQcA K FnBOQXPOFH5TQXN K A+QOQSACd  FnBm? TdS< ?`>@PMN

A+QOQSACd  V 9A+Q Y>CPM? >@Pmd PONkA+QMN A i2FHPMTB >@P=D >@PM? QM<WA+QGDGF9n9 V 9AC:7QGQX<N A+QOQSACd BO> YQoD]A+PMN >C:QX<N

PMN\BM>@TPMd N\B`QM> ?#AC:ACI@N#QM<NA+QMQXACd  FHBO<>@Vv wCy@y@wv Vg lm: Y >@POQMT:WA+QMN 9 >@:Nsd AC::>+Q

N\QMN

6VPO>CQXN\d\Q A BO62BOQMN ? ACI7A+FH:BRQQX<FnBcQo6VxN > A+QMQXACd  FHBO<>@Vv wCy@y@wvVg$<@WH

>@:N dkAC: PON K Td\NcQX<N FH?`VWACd\Q > QM<NA+QOQSACd `QX<PO>@TI@< VACd 9N\iCN 9[ PON\D A 9H9B /acN\::FnB vWw+y@y7wv

Vgfu7wR<(v-BMVxN d FHA 9H96 d >@: [ I@TPON K PM>@TQXN POB QX>?`> K N PXA)QXN#N\BOQXAC5 9FnBM<Fn:I d\>@::N\d\QMFH>@:B FHBO<>@Vv

QX<A+QGFHB K N\BMFnI@:N K QX> VPO>CQXN\d\Q ABO62BOQMN ? ACI7ACFn:BOQ QX<N\BMN A+QMQXACd 4B g

QXFn>@:WA 9 VPON\iCN :7QSA+QMFniCNs?`NkA+BMTPON B NFnBOQ g

:7QXF i2FHPOTB BO> YQoD ACPMNAC:

FH:IsN\?#A+F9 <AC: K FH:I BO<>@T 9 PON K Td N QX<N BMVPMNkA K > D >@PM?`BbAC: K i2FHPMTBMN B\g J :    

POT?`NCvZwCy@y@yvVg Ez7w =d AC:s5ZNbN ?`V 9>E6CN K QX> [W9QMN P=BMTBMVFnd FH>CTBmQMPXA `d 9

>@P=PO>@TQXN\P g

J B BRQSA+QMN K A+5Z>Ei@N+v K FHBOd 9>CBMTPONQX<PMNkA)QXB Fn:4iC> 9iCN T:ACTQX<>@PMF N K ACd d\N BMB QM> Fn: Y

FHBM<>@Vv=w+y@y7wv Vg <AC: K dkAC: 5xN ACd\d >@?`V 9FHBM<N K QX<PO>@TI@< i+ACPMFn>@TBQXN\dS<:FndkA 9 AC: K :>@:

K QX<A+Q QM<N BO62BOQMN ? D]ACB i2FH> 9A+QXN K Fn: >@P K N PQX> N2QX>CPOQ Y PM>C? A d >CPMVx>@PXA+QMFH>@:

G PMI7A+:F A+QXFn>@:Bfd AC: Y >@PfVTPMVx>@BON B > N ? 5WA+PMPXA+BMBM?`N :7Q v2N2QX>@PRQXFH>C:v@>@P->CQM<N P-IC>7A 9

Y >@P BMFH?`F9ACPGPMN ACBM>@:B^AC: K A BM> Fn:>@P K N P QM> I7ACFH: 9FnQXACPO6#FH:7QXN 9H9FHI@N\:d N+g r QFHBcA 9BO> VZ>CBMBMFn5 9

NVx>@BMN K K TN^QM>#Ad\>@: [ I@TPXA+QMFH>@:N POPM>@P=>C: AC:N p

>> 4Fn:I BfBO<>@T 9 N P DG<N : QM<WA+QfVZN\PMBM>C: FHB Qo6VFH:I A VWACBOBOD >@P K >@P PMN A K FH:I

d >C:4iCN POBXA+QMFH>@:v=N\:WAC5 9

> K A+QSA K FHPON d\Q 96Cv >@P`> Y VWA+BMBOD >@P K B 576 DG<FHdS< A+: A+QOQSACd +N P d AC: K N\d N\Fni@NQX<NBO62BOQMN ? 546

ACTQM<>@POFnQo6@g i@N : A BMd\PXACV> Y VACVZN\P`DGFUQX<AVACBMBRD >@P K DGPMFUQMQXN\:>C: FnQQM<WA+Q`D]A+B`QM<PM>EDG:

FHB BMT! `d FnN :7Q 96?`>CQXFUi+A+QXN K QX> BONkACPOdS< Y >CPcFnQ QX<N\PMNCg acFHBOd 9>CBMTPON d >CT 9 A BM> 5xNACdS<FnN\iCN K 546

QMN dS<:> 9>@ICFHN BmBMTdS< ACB QX<N

QX<N\6 +N\625Z>@ACP

VPM>

Td\N B ACBGVWACPOQG> Y FUQXB=:>@PO?#A 9 >@VxN PXA)QXFH>C:g

K FnBMd 9>@BMTPMNCg ;=<N [ POBOQ AC: K BOFH?`V 9N\BOQFnBN K Td A+QXFn>@:g;=<FnB d AC:^FH:d 9 K N-ACVVPO>@VPOF A+QMNqd >@POVZ>CPXA+QMN

BOQMPMFnd\QGVx> 9 9>E6@N N\BmACPMN^:>CQmA 9H9>ED N QX> I@FUi@NcQM<N^:WAC?`N BG>@P]QXN 9N\V<>@:N^:4T? 5xN POB

62BMFnB> Y i+A 9TN QX<WA+: A 5PMTQMNY >CPMd NBON _4TN\:4QMFA ICTN BOBMFH:IA)QMQSA+d  j2dS<:N FnN P\v @R@@zv

N :d\PO62VQXFn>@: BO62BOQMN ?`B>@TQcQM<N PONCg jdS<:N FHN\P