Executing SQL over Encrypted Data in the
Database-Service-Provider Model
Hakan Hacıg ¨um ¨us¸
Bala Iyer
Chen Li
Department of Information and Computer Science, University of California, Irvine, CA 92697, USA
hakanh@acm.org, chenli,sharad @ics.uci.edu
IBM Silicon Valley Lab., San Jose, CA 95141, USA, balaiyer@us.ibm.com
ABSTRACT
45 026$.789"$&! 4 $.;:<= 4 4 "
=
45 0F,G (890'
="$V 2!"
$.9! "$0-OZ (;0 &R [$.H\.) 23S =;$ ]$.P*%$,"$2C^*N
5 W 4
$.g (/ h[$ RJVb =
"$c$. (;$.g (/ hQ$ "$2c d$.
4$ 4"$ 8
4"$ 8
=" 5 4 L 5 9 m$.b= m/.) (00&C
5 $ ^GD 5 $SEo+pqn 5 U3,"B"=HD$2b U/ DC?r
/.g
$.'n
"=H
4 ("] (00B 89 5 $,"$P$
6
\$.;=
Q="=HLC6*+.)
! ?V"
$. "'! ? (?*Qx!y\C
Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for
personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are
not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies
bear this notice and the full citation on the first page To copy otherwise, to
republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific
permission and/or a fee.
ACM SIGMOD ’2002 June 4-6, Madison, Wisconsin, USA
Copyright 2002 ACM 1-58113-497-5/02/06 5.00.
> ("$
$ &j U3"b$.R*<L$"$2O+ ()t.) (g02
$ ^ S~2 U$& ("=Hj
5 Q$ 89"$@$.
5 4
<> U"$= 0
5 4 = 4<! ("$^"$ % 5 $O 4 (" 4 5
5 8[JV"@ 4-5 ="$O
$,"
a!.B) (
"/ 0|n
8XM JV"S 4
4> ("$9= (M
(/ (J) (=^"$ 4 5
"/ (Q="
4 5 IU2
4 "$89 Q! 4 5 ?
3 )d D/
"$!$ X&
4"$ 8$. 4X 4 QM
$ 89,"' U/
"=> U"/R= (M
0 5 5 9,. 00&Cfa|"/ DMN -X2d$ \JV
5 + ()g$.[ U/ 9&"/ 5
+ (&V5 8\5|WW (0C
U
CP*> ( 4 5 )h$.) (6. ("/%> ("$9"=HDM
J 0#b"$2
) "$ 4 4 "7n 5 4"$ 8i$.>a>zZ¡7MN JV,.8P ("$#
I¢(
Trang 25 4"$ 8$.@ (/ (J) (=
("=> ("/ (M
5 4"$ 8i$.
=,"$3"
()XGD
$!$.?n
& ($' (089 Q>"=H9 L/ &B 4
"6 P0 ("$&;
8;JV"?
]JV 89
r 5 5 "$X ()^ M
5 "$
4 $."$ 45 M
V =g$.Rn
5 &89L$2
L;
"9 U;$.P="$"
UP$.]="$"2C
N3N^4 "P="/ (QM
="?n
=,"$3"2O )6V"4 5 ,"=H+"$5 0I$C
"=HP U3,"
" P P$.?="$3"2O
5 "=H 4
"$
0I$]
$.R="$3,"^n
4"/ 89,! "$# 4 "]n 5
("$8P
"FQ="/ ($&(H6 ("1
89,"$
n
"|"$
0I$|=. 2u$.) U
$.B89 %0C
5 ">! "$#VCZED ("$/.g b,"=HD$2S (/
2
I( 5
,"/ ( 5 45
a!.9"$QW 4 4
D"$=L$P. 2
=='. 2
5 5 "=HLOL5 ,.9$. (Z$.B 8XM
5 "'GDV"=M
0I$> gn
5 4
"$ 8 $.+a>z7¡7MNJV,.8P ("$#VCj
05
STOR-AGE MODEL
x7 4 5 5 4 ("!n 5
,"=HD$2^ U/ DOV0 5 5 =B. U
Q$ ("$2] U?$.+="$3,"2C
,O!_Q$ "$_ +$.@="$"
!#"%$'&)(+*-,.0/21*43 *5(76)"98:*<;>=?(7@A6"9B)*A(DCE(F8+1?"%G*E8FG&(7*'H
0I
JKMLON'P9J
$
J KQLON'P%JR JKMLON'P9J
¢
"$=V )?$ g X 5
5 $
("=M
4 5 $
5 =2
("n
JUVN
4 5 F890 2HLC
WYX[Z WY\O] ^0W _M] `a] bdc ] ZOZOb ZOX[Z ef g'h
^ i jk lm] nO`[W o7j pq
j lm] bdc
jk lm] X[\
fe
j r hs
\ tjk uvXw7WYb tj
i t r7Wxbdbdc ttk y n5W>zWx`[` {{Yj
a!.
JUVN
="$3,"2
JUVN
J KQLONP9J
J|}
J~5UJ
EPA+
5}<}<
}<|} I'
4 !
0RJV[ bn
$
5}<}<
5 5 [0 =; 4
!b =
$P
5 $
4 "?2 (,
$
4 05
$
T
N
O)
,.g$. (
Q
45
N57KQ|KQ|+~
( 4 00 2'
N57KQ|KQ|+~v
v
NF
N
5 $
J7|}
$.
JUVN
/ J0
JV U3C7E
V =B$.+ 0
>
::U
C!?=
$'$.) UZ!?
(
Trang 3:
:F(
N5+KM|KM|F~vJUVN
J|}
+:(
FF
¢::(
¢OF
F:(
F:
:(
:
:F(
$
U
OB 5 0JV 5 =2
4 5
$CR*<u$.S,G (890
=2
5 "XQ="/ U$&HLO 4 5 89S$.
n 5 4 "?Q="/ ($&(H]$ 9 $."
"=! ("/O%$.
,G (890O 5 5 5
0J
/#3$C@r
89!$.) U'2 /.g 0
B8P !$
$.2n
($
"BQ="/ U$&H
">$.
n
*S$.+ (JV (+G 890OD gn 5 5 QM
="/ U$2C
4 5 $9 "="$M
C&DCO
5 5 ?"/ (&C u 5 =
P
()
$ P $+$.
0 2!,"+ ()
V"'JV
("=HS
45
|}5J~'K [N
5 $
5 "$
$ b$.
$
JU2N
J7|}
|}5J~'K
T
= FF(
O%
|}5J~'K
T
>
F
::U
#$" %!! &"" ' !"
"
!#"%$&(7*+*.-, CE(+G "%G"%@/ C0.B "9B*1.G"32v8FC G"%@0.54d&6.?8FG"%@/.?3 @04
JU2N
J7|}
a!.
|}5J~'K 45 5 4 5 5
|}5J~'K [N
87
|}5J~'K [N/9 4;:
"$V =O
4"$9.) (= 45 5 4 $.
5 =29 Z
|}5J~K 45
$..) (= 45 5 =+$.Q/ ("=B )=<( ("Bg 05 ' 4
"/ (&C
45 7N
$.) U?8P ' [ (0
4 5 $
+N 6C
@A
|}5J~K [N
,O'."$
*$.jG (890u (JV (O+$. 4
05 6 4 45 4 5 $
J7U2N
J|}
Cbe ("
+N
TD
O
OE?
7N TD
:
O! )
7N/
TD
5 P U"$
MONP
TDQ KR
o i o
u 45 4Hb<Z ;<HDV> 4 45
CTS = ^ , 45
2 002XW Q , 4K4 "B LHb! 9 05 B@
()Y@
4 @ T[Z
@ O|$.O?
@ ]\
@ ,C
CB^ 45 = WF 4
"/ ()D 8 45 5
45
5 "=H
4 "bJV $.m<HDV9 4 8P M 45
u
.0 5 5
45
$OL$.?0 (=$"!! 6. 0
;_a`
O"$
"$[?
b_a`
05
O"$ 5 "$e?
+N 6
,C p|,Ef\JVB 6
J=Z
(0
$
X@uJVg h 05 jgD`)S$. 4
45
7N fvv
|}5J~K [N
hg
N ci f-7kj
@A
[N
hg N
P%m+n
?
@Av
[N
hg N
\p@
7N
"$5 0F 4
7N
5 ' _0=@$.) (r@)C
+N
o6
5 6 (B&("$2 ($,"
$.) (Y@)C
ub 2{.) 23b 5 4Hf. 2 $ jQ$ "$
q$.^="$"2C e ("g /.q5 0
ts
0u
0
J~v+ +NEK
E
xw:
7N y
7N z u
'.,"$
J~v+ 7N K
45 5 =2k$ u"=HDb \5 0^ 4
J7U2N
Q$ ("$2g b$.+="$"2
{|$}m~a{ { { 1aA{ h3 aha h
aa h
a
aa a
a!.'`"$QZ 05 89
JKMLON'P9J
$ b$.;"=HD$2^ 5
JUVN
Trang 4$ P:
:F:F::F:FD%
C%CC=A]n 5 0$
J~v+ 7N K
:
5+
:
5|~
I,
O!+ED
O'xZ0 2>`)=
I7U
O>T+ZE
$COZ2 mJV 5 =2c$
"=HD>$.B
0C
a!.;= )h 0
5 4 5 $
J7|}
+:(
O7ZgQ$ "$b$.S (0
k:
Aj
4 $.
J|}
:
Cq*m$.
5 45 4 "6$. O
EPA+
5}<}<
O> ()
}<|}
5 $P ("$^ (P=. 2'|O!J 5 ;$.Hm U"$h QM
*^&"/ 0OVZ
:A
:Q@,"=HD$A<Z$ P8P
J KMLON'P9J
I ,CP*<\$.P JV U3X,G (890O
JU2N JU2N
5 DM
I # [C+*<^$.WG%M (890> (JV (O JU2N
v J7U2N
8 5
4 tM
0IF
s
JKMLON'P9J
JKMLON'P9J
I
I I
I
I I
()D"=HD$
J KQL:N'P9J
J KMLON'P9J
5 "=HDD$2
5 $ 05 C
?Z (9G 890OL =
U |}
}<|}
U 5
U 5
J KQL:N'P9J
|}
}<|}
,CRE
V =9!9!"$P$ ^ 89
$
J7U2N
I
U 5
I
}<|}
I (=M
5 $C;a!.;"$5
KQJ7U2N
5 $s
JUVN
J KQL:N'P9J
J|}
7
AP%5+
5}<}<
JU2N
}<|}
U 5
J KQLONP9J
U |}
U 5
}<|}
I C*
Zc ("$u$ qDM
,"=HDB$.
KQJUVN
5 V"/ U$ "$ P 89 5 $
9KQJUVN
5 $
J|}
x
AP%5F
A}<}<
JUVN
}<|}
U|}
5
}<|}
9KQJUVN
:9 5 89
K>JUVN
()hD"$ ^$.[
7N
%Hj. U
"=H
5 ,
. 2
n ,"=HS="$? ("$+="/ =0 ($2-C
45
U/ > JV
"=H
4 5 0
$
N
0
:
5 $
N
5 $:
!
("
YN 5
#"0
5 5 =?$. 4
$&%(')$+*-,/.$0(12%3$.5416178/.1-,,7/.9,(*:,/.;'<*-,<=
%<>7/)?%*-,/.9,(*-,.%(0(1#%<$<=
'+7A@BC)!'<*-,/.'0A1#%3$.9,(*:,/.;DE+,>+$F3=
G G G (+"IH?&G *KJML0CN9&*'.SE 5
00 U'
+N3
@AO
I -?
+N0C
@A
DO 45 ? 7N/ 8P @\$ h$.
5 @)CPe (" J7U2N
/ J06 JV U3OD!. U
7N J|}
F J|}
ID
J|}
5 $C
G G G (+"IH?&G *
L0CN9&)*.bE
5 $98 5 Q6. U9 g!00Z`2R "/,"=M
5 V 45 7N/ 5
$
("=> U"/
+N3
@AO
I \ ?
+N
@A
4 5 $S 05
4 $.
r@+Q7'."$ @+Q
@)CSe ("=M
+N
@AO
I TR
+N oC
@A
? 7N J|}
SO J|} I
+:(
FF
¢OF(
C
P $ $.) UmZ { 0I! 2HD
= D`)2
$.\"/ )D 8
$C
>Z001 !$.n 5
Trang 55 4
45
00 2'
7N
@AO
7N/
@A
B () 8]?
+N3
@AO
7N l
@A,C
7N J|}
F
SO J7|}
¢
3+
¢
G GG (+"IH&G *',J G G G(F"H&G *d*.[E 5
5 $B2 (RJV 4"$ 8 J0O% "
"$ 8
5 $B RJV
4"$ 8 $.B$ 89+/ J0C_a!. 4
7N
O
|}5J~K [N
|}5J~'K<[N 9
N
N A7KQ|KM|+~v
T
9 N5+KM|KM|F~vc N'
N 7
()
,OK!P.) 23X
I
|}5J~'K[N
S
@
()
;
$. (_2
;
dX
\O_ HF
T
] bdXMX
\:_ HF
T
j[{Yjj
j
jj
{Yjj
jj o
jjo7jj
jj
jj
jjo7jj {
45 4 5 $
JUVN
}<|}
U 5
}<|}
JUVN
}<|}
U 5
}<|} 4
0IM
JU2N
}<|}
U 5
}<|}
JU2N
}<|}
U 5
}<|}
JU2N
}<|}
U 5
}<|}
J7U2N
}<|}
U 5
}<|}
,C
G GG (+"IH&G *',
5 6 = 5 89[$.) U
T Z
C! 5
DV)D
45 4 5 $
;
"$|C
Z 00
;
$.) U
(
00 2'
7N
TZ
;
O
#"h_$&%
('D*)
|}5J~'K [N
7N/<[N
P%
7N/
+N3
TZ
c
O
#"m_$&%
+'D,)
I
|}5J~K<[N
I \ ?
+N0C [N
|$
xZ $ ?
7N/
() ?
7N/
$.B JV U3B! [8P M
00 2'
+N3
TZ
c
O
7N [N P
L\ ?
7N [N/9
N5+KM|KQ|F~v
T N/9
N A7KQ|KM|+~v
,C
x7 $.8?
7N/
Y?
0IM
+N3
T Z
O
I
|}5J~'K [N
I
|}5J~K<[N 9
N
N57KQ|KQ|+~
T
9 N5+KM|KM|F~vc
N
()
c
$.) U@ 5 4
J7U2N
}<|}
U 5
}<|}
0 ($2S$
JUVN
}<|}
U 5
}<|}
JUVN
}<|}
U 5
}<|}
JUVN
}<|}
I
U 5
}<|}
I
JUVN
}<|}
U 5
}<|}
JUVN
}<|}
I
U 5
}<|}
I
JUVN
}<|}
U 5
}<|}
,C
JUVN
}<|}
U 5
}<|}
5 2-O
Q :
F:U
4 5 $
JUVN
}<|}
FF
¢::( 4 5
$
U 5
}<|} 4
0
JUVN
}<|}
U 5
}<|}
#KMKMF|*/LEK>J3
K>J+
O$.b?
+N 8P M
4 KdKQ+|*/L KQJF
#KMKMF|*/LEK>J3
OD (
$>"$"$=2C
@/.B?"%G"%@0.,
@/.?B"%G"%@/.6*21
@/.B?"%G"%@0.,
@/.?B"%G"%@/.6*
4 00 2'
+N +~}<|KM|F~K
3
+~}<|KM|+~)
SO
+N3
+~}<|KM|F~K
CY?
+N3
+~}<|KM|F~)
+N3
+~}<|KM|F~K
3
+~}<|KM|+~)
SO
+N3 +~}<|KM|F~K
CY?
+N3 +~}<|KM|F~)
4 7N !
F~}<|KQ|+~
2 (]JV
4 5 U
rBV"/ U$ "A\ 4
b V"/ ($ ("
Trang 64 IMPLEMENTING RELATIONAL
OPER-ATORS OVER ENCRYPTED RELATIONS
"$CBr
5 $] j5 V"$=,b 4 Q!"$S&"=M U$2dJLHj$.P V"/ ($ ("
5 S"$5
5 /.h
"$h b8
/.k
5
B WS$ ;Q$ ("$
$.8 ,C@a!.
,"/ ($ "$72 9JV'
"/ 89Z "$#
4 5 4 "9$.g 5 "$V =b 4
n "=HS 89
$&%('/)$A*-,/.9,A*-,3= %<>7/)?%*-,.9,(*-,3=
7N 45 4 JU2N
J7|}
JUVN
}<|}
O|
U 5
}<|}
5 89
$. (W$. ?
+N 45 4 U 5
JU2N
J7|} 5 "$ 5 = ()
¢(
"!$#%&
"!# &
!#"%$&(7*)( , CE(+G "%G"%@/ C=.?B "9B)*d.G"328:C G"@/ 4M&6.8:G"%@/.3 4@(
4@'&( C GG (+"IH&G *A3:H
/1*+**<N*E8FG"%@/.-, =v*5(7C G @
`2X 9 ? "789 "$'
$
[C@
"$ 8{$.6="$"
0
. 2!3,"2OV 5 4
4"$ 8
V"/ ($ ("+ U'$.="$3,"
5 [O 5 =.$.7"$5
D"=HD$K$.!"$ 5 0I$7 )6`)0I$"$_ 5 _ 5 4
4 00 2'
$.
R$.) Uh$.d=0\ V,"/ ($ "jGD
$R (h$.d="$"2C
892m$ u,G
$g (P$.
$
J KMLON'P9J
O- ()^D"$ R 00F$.W $."
$C
G 890
TD
A@CBAD
TD>E
PAF
J7U2N
7N
0
587
I5G
JUVN
I >=KO'."$$.
-?
+N3
0v
J7|}
}<|}
I
f!C
0
"$5
JV U3 4 00 2'
L035
0I
_:&;
z$<
' ) I
"$OV$. fk "$89L' ]$.
4 ($.) U+$. 5 $2R (+$.;="$"2C
JUVN
TDE
TD
U 5
="/ =0 ($2b$ D
035?7&
J7U2N
U 5
I( =
D`)2
/1*NM (7@'&)=" $ C=.?B G $$ (+*5$CEG"%@/.O,V=*5(7C G@(.QPR27
&"$ 5
,O
'.,"$WV VYX/Z[V
C\VYX"$
$;
5 4 ("$892O? ()-V "="$=V )DS$ u=b 4
5 5R^`_ acb 'ed )gf?h
09892 S$. (S!\"$2 ($R&"$
5 5 $3 WO! () 4 "P /.k&("$ 5 k 8XM $B$.
vFL ~Ki
45
OV ()WV
Ik?lm
i
cnpo
CKa!.@"$
$ qo;C@f
4 5 ? 4 [O% ;$.' 5 8;JV,"@ 4 5
&"$
$"o;C'*
4
jDOV 0IH]&("$
V"
"$892-C
4 $.g&"$ 5
0[2 (fJV
4 00 U'
PUT
-PUT 7
PIT
0I >=
JFJ
V
V X
5 b$."=HD$2P 5 0'J =2
5 $W 4 V V,"4 "$8 (LH
0
Cta!.]"$
0$P
("$
\
ITsG
&("$ 5 R 89 5 $]J%Hg$.W="$3"2CW? P"$5 0I2O
&"$ 5
'.X 89
T C_r
"$=O 45
5 $2
5 5 5 0@JV
Trang 7T
^c_ja b 'D )f8h
JU2N
8;JV,"+
D) U"=$89L2Cp8Vt $\:
}<|}
Ik?lm
J|}
n o;CAa!.
PUTK7&
PI
TD
JU2N
I
}<|}
5 $+ S$.
=,"$3"2C? 4$"?$.6&"$ 5 V2g5 5
Z',"=HDK$.> (/ %OL [V"
"$8i$.!&"$
$. }<|} 5
$.B5
}<|}
.) 23+ 0I"$2 %HgJVg&("$ 5 VbJLH
"$8
v+L~'K J|}
$ ; 5 %>$. 5 8;JV,"! 4 4 }<|} C
/1*]*@(7G" $ ,V=v*5(+CEG @(]
27.R
0
00 2'
0
PIT
0I =
$C
9$.?"=HD$2
5 $ VQ 4 V'C * 45 4
CK 4$"F$._"$ 5 0I$K ("$_"$ 5
45
gO ()+V"
"$8 $.
5 5 $ V'C
$+$. ('$.6 (89 5 L' 4
$
5 V S'.$."! "> !$.
$.
"$, 5 "$mJLHd$.g="$3"S U"$]"$= ("=$2 5
5 = 45 0!$ R 89 5 $qP
(X$.
=,"$3"Z$ "$2
L7
0
. 23bJVk&("$
V2mJLH\$.g=,"$3"2O
T
JUVN 089L$2S
00 2'
T
7&
PI
TD
JUVN
'."$rV
J|}
4 ("$8 9&"$ 5
TD
]$.
JUVN
D"=HD$_$.?"$
"$2;
/1* &=/N9"98FC G *<; N9" " )C G"%@0.S,V=v*A(7CEG @(r 27._a!.Z
5 DM
0v 7
PUT
0I =
$
I '."$
$
5 5 0> S$.B="$"
JUVN
="/ =0 ($2b$ D
7&
TD
T
JU2N
I =
5 0W 4 ~ (0= g (V2 U"$
5 45 00IHW"$2 5 Z$.' (89 5 %1 4 ! ("$#;D ' (@$.
$
() i
i 4 00 2>M
5 0@2 (WJV 5
xw
z?
Qjb
dxw
d/z?
Q
PIT 0I I
_ :&;
z<
w
z
I
'.,"$8V-
(] u
$.^0
=M
$
5 Q="/ U$X$.X (JV U3["5 0
$."$
& j (\G (890C;E
V =W!;! L+$ S 89
$ JUVN
U 5
8P &"$C7a!.6n 5 4 5 ,"=H
TD
TD
Q
TD
TD
Q
PI
T
TD
TD
TD
JU2N
I I
U 5
I
7N
JUVN
J|}
U 5
|}
'.,"$
DC
5 $
>=M
$
2 (=7
$.X"$
B$.+ 89
5 X$ g$.9&"$ 5 00B$.]5 0S$. (b.) 23h
pFp 05 4 "
5 $
V2]$ &,$."2C#t.]$."$
$.
/.^
0B2
c 5
0Z
$. (7
0P
$.=' 5 0_ 4 5 J=2n 5 L
0
0
pFp@C
c ]fb ()B$.@5 J=2n 5
5 4 ("$892
L7&"$
0
"$ 8 $.,"Z&("$
C a!
OV"
=$ ("=HLO% 5 5 '$.? 89 5
$.6="$"B=. 5 0l]JV 5
Trang 8$.>
5 00IHR R 89 5 =M
=2
DV
V 6$._ L$LF
9 Q=MNJ) =Rn
/1*Y."%@/ ,V=*5(7C 4
"$L
4 $. 5
"=> U"/
Z
0I?ZI I
$'$.
5 5
5 $g 4 00 U'
Z
I I Z I >=
4 5 $
'."$
5 $
$.
I I I
"$ 8
"
O($ BJVZ J0!$
45
$.9"$
0IP
$.
4 $.X5 0
4"$ 8
("
5 5 5 4 ("+$.W ("="$
45 4 $.X) (V" U
5 Q="/ U$>$.B2 4 5 $
()k$.]"$
()]D30 V2g (0&J"/ %C
/1*T, (+@ *A8:G"@/ ,V=v*A(7CEG @(
J KQLONP9J
5 $6 4
0I2O)$ X 89
$ T
0,O
'."$ 4 5
0v T I
TD
JU2N
TD
JUVN
C
SPLITTING
> 5
"=H
OL
"7
5 4
("$ =W$.9="$"
89
$? Z8
/.;
$.?n
4 $._ 89 5 5
89 5 5 "=HB0 4 ("
*<rq X¡!z
"=HX ("!$.
JUVN
$.' 23,"/ &?$ 0 U"=H9
JLH }<|}
0(1#%3$K$&%('
416178 ) )4161783=
$&%A'
,(*-,=
!"$#%"'& ( )+*-, )+*-, 798:/;0'1<4=/$6
>@?BA /$C
DFE
CHGJI45/'6LKM/;0$1;4=/$6
: n "=H
="$C
NO$P%O'Q R
T+U-VMW
_a`bY;Z'[<]=Y$^
c@dBe Y;f
T+U-V W
hFi
fHjJk]=Y$^%lmY$Z$[;]5Y'^
J' M
o5pHqJr
s+tvuaw5xyLtaz{|}tauawBy~t9z
JL
ta
yLtazJtvuawByLtaz
J9a
J
t9 =F5=x
aa
o=pq r
=0M
=
La Jv¡9¢BLa
£=¤H¥J¦
§©¨9ª¨a«¬
§©
~=®¯F°=±5²
¨9ª¨a«¬L³
£=¤H¥J¦
v¡a¢=²L9
v¡a¢BL9
La Ja¡a¢BLa
L¹$a@
º¼»
º¼»
y 5
!#"%$'&(7*¾½.:¿ * =/N%@À'*5*E3ÃÂm1@ CMÄ* R@(7* G1C= C56'*5(+CE$*3 C3N%C (ÁÀ @04 * N@@À'*5*A3ÅÂ 1@SC (7*4" B?"9BJ4,
ÆÇvÈ
Ë~ÌÍ<ÎÏvÐ ÏvÐÏ ÕÖÁ×vØLÖJÙ
ÙÖ©Ú9ÛÚLÜÝ%Þ'Ú~ßFàáFÛ Ý
Ú~×vØLÖJÙÞ;ãÝLÜäåLÝ%ßFÜæLÙã
Ø%çè$éêFê%ë ì5ÈFívî ï~Æì
5 "=HP="$C
óLôõ'ö÷9ø÷ùHôúvû~ö÷9ø÷ üJý©þ9ÿFý
ÿ
õ=û óLôõ
ôúvû
þ9ÿ%ý
JF 4
!#"%$'&(7*#". 6EC3N9&CEG"%@/ @04 C @'".%$)&)*A(ÁÀH
"=H9="$ S= 89+
$.B 0
5 5 "$
:W$
,Cca!.b`"$Q
Q="/ ($&H
5 "$
/ UM
Trang 9
702$/8:9+;<=<=>
$=!3@BADCFEGH!3#I$%J'2) *,/.-021,/4=.6'*-K $5!F@LADCFEMG02$/8:9+;<=</> K
N O7
:>
SUT VWOXZY[I\[]^W`_NaY
W`_Nab
c+d egf5hFiLjDkFlMmHh3nIf&o(pq+r-s/t
dvu s/w5txpr-y c+d egf5hFiBjBklm
f&z:{}|2~5~/(y
XaMNb VFWOX7b
SUT VWOXZY X\[
h3nIf&o(pq rs/t
d2u s/w=tUxp r-
f/z:{}|2~=~=
J!
$"?
5 5
+
g5FBBH3I&(Z/
2
/=U2
+
g5FLDF
/:+==(
¡¢£¤ ¥¦ §¤
¨©
¦®N¡¤
JI&(
¨©3°
g5FLDFF-±M²3-/73=³´5²3-/
3I&( /
2
/=U:µ
&:}25/
±²-/73/³´=²-
7!
¸+¹ ºO»=¼3½B¾D¿FÀÁH¼3ÂI»ÃJÄ2Å+ÆÇ/È
¹2É Ç/Ê=ÈËÄÆ-Ì
¸+¹ ºg»5¼F½L¾D¿FÀMÁ
»/Í:Î+ÏÐ=Ð/Ñ(Ì
ÒÓÔÕNÖ ×ØÒ§Ö
Ø`ÙNÓÖ
ÜÝ3Þ ºO»=¼3½B¾D¿FÀÁÄ2Ãß¼àÇ/È-Ç/Å+Ãâá&ÊvàÇ/È-Ç/Ì
ÜUÝ3Þ ºO»=¼3½B¾D¿FÀÁÄ2Ãß¼à¼3È-Ç/Å7¼3Ê=ãä5à¼3È-Ç/Ì
ÃJÂI»ÃJÄ
¼3ÂI»&Ã(ÄÅ ÆÇ/È
¹2É Ç/Ê=ÈUËÄÆ-æ
»/Í:Î}Ï2Ð=Ð=Ñ æ ¼3Ê/ãä=à¼È-Ç/ÅZÄñ¼à¼3ÈÇ æ Ä2Ãß¼àÇ/È-Ç/Å+Ãâá&ÊvàÇ/È-Ç
!a!.+`) 0|n
"=H9="$C
! "$'&(7*ç.¾¿ &*5(ÁÀ (7* (+"%G" )$ 1*A&(+"93 G"9884@( @'".%$)&)*A(+"%*A3
Q="/ U$&H
5 "$
¢E
5 $') ("=! 4 5 "=H
07 "=M
? 7N }<|} ,Cga!.9="$3"W=$ g$.
4 $.
J7U2N
CO JU2N
$.+='
4 5 0
$ R 05 4 $.gn 5 ,"=HLCè7; ($."XV QM
5
"$
"=Hj (6$.
}<|}
Cba!.X"$5 0I$[ U"$
0; ()j 8XM
5 $
$. 5 0I$+ U"$;D"=HD$2^ U
*N6=.
V QM
"/ 89Z "$#VO| )
$.hG ,]n 5 ,"=Hq0 (t=. 5 0qJVR Q
V,"2C r
& ($2$ 45
$.) U> (00 2 4 5
$.@="$"1 ("=
"$
"="$2+$ ?
I V$. (1,G
$| (|$._="$3"
"$4"="$[$
|$.) (_GD 5 $@ U
5 0I$! 4 $.Bn 5 "=H; (05 ($b U!$.
="$3,"2CWr
5 5 "=H[="$O
/.^$.) U+89 QB 4 $.W- "=B 4 (05 5 "=Hg L 5 "$
L>
Z "$#VC
Q="/ ($7
4 5 "=H6$. (@ 89 5 $1$.! 89K 4 $. 8P &"$@
FFé
%(0(1#%<$
$&%('.%(>7/.;'+7+@B
'0(1#%3$ëê,(*4&ì+,7(*3í+$7î
ïMð
'<*-,
ïMð
416&ñMñFò
ïMð
5 5 0 ($9$.bn 5 "=Hj="$9$
I
5 "$
A
:Z=. 2'>$.Bn 5 "=HX="$
5 =.2b 2'b$ ;"$0l UM
Trang 10C?a!.6"$5
"$
A
J,C
"="$LSn
,"=Hd="$]"$2n
N F
: O
J7U2N
O7 ()
U 5
U$S$.]n
,"=HLC j
5 5 5 "=H[="$
"$
E
:,C
$.>! 6=0M
5 4 "$8 (8 5 /
_hc
E T
T
() 0
_a9
FAF
TD>E
$ T
(0&JD"/
C^a!.9 n 5 "$
A
J',C
j+2 (] 2 5 5
/.f$.) U
TD>E
TD
"$
A
7!=. 2'
$.;n 5 "=Hb="$; 4 5 00|$.<Z
0 _a;
E T
T
_h9
FAF
() 0
TE
TD
TD>E
TD
C a!.kZ]"$0 (
$.
5 "$
E
,C
4 5 "$
E
,O8 5 ,.W 4 $.!! ("$#[ 4
)
V)D2S
$.Bn 5 "=H[="$:D
JV_
00
$.7n
n 4 890 2HL?'. ]D b Z "$#
4 "]$.\8P () (&"^ 892Y:<xZ JCA
$0A1#%3$ $&%('
$A*:,
ï &ï
$A*-, K$#%('.%<>7
$A*-, %*-,
FïMð
$0(12%3$ëî A@-D+î =
"$V
4
ZW ("$$ 9GD 5 $+$.6n 5 5 5 "$V
O,O
JU2N
OZ
Z00! (6$.X"=HD$2R Q!"$W&"/ ($jJLH^$.qJ I V"/ (M
5 002k (JV U3b$.
=MN
$"
0
$.Xn 5 5 "$D
J,C uW2 R 2 00F$.
"!#
$ ('*)+-,.)
012
"!#
3/
:3'
&;$
&%
'<)+-,.)
Oo
89
>:?A@B
><C(@B
EGFHI
KLMNOP"Q"RCSL?TCU*VW-X3YV
[\]
K9LMN P"QR C@B3U*?A@B3Z
>:?T@B C@B3U*?A@B
J:C@B3U*?A@B&abCS
?TCU VW-XYV
V"/ ($ ("
5 5
c-dfeg ciheg
c-h3eglkdmeg
oqp rtsvuwxyzl{
h3|
d6h}~Tv~
t
h3eg"}dmeg
oh3eg}qdfeg"<h|
dmh3}~T~
l
rtsvuwxyzl{h3eg"}dmeg
7
$"7
-m
i
t-
tl ¡¢£¤
3¥
63¦q§¨T©ª§«
¯°l±
t ¡¢£ ¤
3"¦m«
²v ¡¢£ ¤3"¦qm"«
3¦qm ³<¥
63¦§¨T©ª§
-3l´m
t µ¶
"=H9="$C
!#"%$'&(7*¸· ¿ &*5(ÁÀR(7*Â (+"%G".$ 4d@(C 3 *5G;xB?"*5(7*d.8:* $)&)*A(ÁÀH
"$ ,CSa!.X`)) (0_="$XV"
("$8968
/.R
$.Xn
"=HR 8XM
5 0$P U"$]D"=HD$2c ()
uB.) 23B ) 5
0$C
uu"/ ($.\$Q$\JLH 5 a>z7¡7MN JV/.8P U"$#
¢
4 $ ("
D
"="$26$ + (1$.
y]xd
: y]x
,$2^
<Z g*<x>y*<L$0IMNJ) (=2RV,"$= ) (07 89 5 5 *=*=*
y]xuBBy\CrB7
$.Z 89
=M
"$+V,"
"$89R (B$.[="$3"2O ()h $." ;V"
"$892h (
5 5 "$CP?0IM
LX= 4> ("$^ 89V L$ 5 =dZ"$]*<x>y Tx
E%C
()
4 FF:
¹m*(N%C 5 D8 5 0M
DH ("$P$.
6*:0A$A*-F$&%
Oº E<4-FA@2%3$7
OZ
@7,+$7
4 5 $ 4
*:0A$A*:F+$&%¼»96½4*¾<*:'+,+1F+$ 6½-,(*4
@:E0+F/.56½-¿E(1-0+F(*:F8
7,+$7A4 »9@½@7,+$7,A1F+$.@½
E<4:FFì($8/.@½+4*¾<*&''+7(*@7A*-F8
E<4-FA@2%3$7À»
º º E<4-FFìA$8
! 5
I72
... commercial advantage and that copiesbear this notice and the full citation on the first page To copy otherwise, to
republish, to post on servers or to redistribute...
I¢(
Trang 25 4"$ 8$.@ (/ (J) (=
("=> ("/ (M
5...
permission and/or a fee.
ACM SIGMOD ’2002 June 4-6, Madison, Wisconsin, USA
Copyright 2002 ACM 1-58113-497-5/02/06 5.00.
> ("$