Khdng rieng gi chung cu vffa bi chiy, nhieu chung cff khic cOng thiet ke va xay dffng khong dung quy djnh ve phdng chiy chffa chiy.. Nhieu nha chung cff thiet ke cau thang bp ma khong [r]
Trang 1[Chuyen de]
Nhd cao nhung chdi
12
> THAIVO
Thap thoang, nhln nhung khu do thj moi voi tung day nha cao tang hien dai, ngudi ta hlnh dung rang
nhOng nguui dan sdng a do se
hanh phuc lam, nhung tiec rang nguoi trong cupc khong cam thay thoai mai, blnh an vl qua nhieu chuyen phai lo au va buc bpi
NOI LO CHAY DO LAM SAI THIET KE
Sau khi xay ra vu chiy nhi cao 18 tang d Le Van Lffdng, du chi mdi
chiy tff dng din ric d i khien hai ngffdi tff vong, Cdng an Ha N6i d i vio
cu6c de bm nguyen nhin Ket qui dieu tra ban dau lam cho bat ky ai
di dau tff mua nhi chung cd Iim ndi sinh sdng deu cim thay ngao
ngin Nha dau tU da lam sai thiet ke de giim chi phi, dng xi ric ding le
phii lam bing thep thi dddc thay bang nhffa compozit kem chat Iffpng
Vj tri dat dng xi ric lai dit gan cffa thoit hiem Trang thiet ke, dng xi
ric cd he thdng phun nude Iff dpng, nham tddi am ric nhung thffc te thi
nd khdng dupe lip dat, thay vao dd la he thdng phun nddc bing tay VI
the, nhan vien van banh cd phun hay khdng, phun nhieu hay it l i viec
khdng ai kiem soit dffpc
Khdng rieng gi chung cu vffa bi chiy, nhieu chung cff khic cOng thiet
ke va xay dffng khong dung quy djnh ve phdng chiy chffa chiy Nhieu
nha chung cff thiet ke cau thang bp ma khong cd cffa bu6ng thang d
tffng tang, la trii quy djnh, da bien nhdng chd nay thanh cic dddng
dan khdi tff cac tang dddi len khi xiy ra chiy Sff bat cap nay thay rd
'' qua vu chiy ham thu ric chung cff 1SC34; chiy chung cff CT4-1 khu
dd thj Me Tri Ha, huyen Tff Liem v i vu chiy chung cU 25 Vu Ngpc Phan,
quan Dong Oa
Diem bat hpp ly thff 2 d cic chung cff hien nay, cffa ra vio budng thang
thoat nan khdng Iff ddng, budng thang khdng lap quat dieu ip (quat
giup i p suat khi dff trong cau thang ludn cao hdn cic khu vffc xung
quanh khien khdi khdng Ipt dffdc vao cau thang)
Tiep den, cau thang thoit nan trong cic chung cff dang bj chiem dung
lam ndi dit cic hop ky thuat, tham chi ci budng xi rac Mat khic,
trang h6p ky thuat cd dddng cdng nghe nhd day dien, cip thdng bn
cd chat lieu vd cao su, nhffa n§n khi chiy se toi khdi d6c gay nguy
hiem cho ngddi dan Neu trong khdi cd nhieu thanh phan dpc td do
vat lieu tdng hpp tdi da 3 phut la ngddi dan d i bi choang, ngat va mat
TAP CHI PHAP LY< s o c I UI I U,\.N(, 4/2010
di khi ning di chuyen ra khdi vung nguy hiem Chdng tu khdi tai cac Chung cu quan trpng la vay, tuy nhien thdc te, ty le cdng trinh, nhi cao tang khdng dip ffng dffpc he thdng chdng tu khdi la khi nhieu 6 tang ham de dtd, xe miy - nai cd nguy cd xiy ra chiy cao, theo mpt dieu tra mdi ddpc cdng bd, cd tdi tren 60% tang ham chung cff chffa dip ffng dffpc tieu chuan niy, chu yeu do khdng lip dat he thdng quat hut khoi
Con sd nay ddi vdi cau thang bp thoit nan an toin l i tren 90%
M6t thdc te khic, hien nhieu chu dau tff qui chu trpng tdi viec xiy nha
de bin, nen hp "qu§n" mat viec xay ddng va khdp ndi cic cong trinh
ha tang ben trang va bdn ngoii chung cff, die biet l i giao th6ng chda chiy Trang vu chiy chung cff 1SC34, phai rat vat v i , Iffc Iffpng Cinh sit PCCC mdi cd the dda dffdc xe thang 52 met, cic xe chffa chiy bep can hien trffdng dp dffdng vip chung cff niy qui hep Nhffng bat hpp
ly cua he thdng giao thdng tinh d nhieu chung cff tai Ha Npi cOng dang khdng dip ffng dffdc nhu cau thdc te Old cua ngffdi dan v i khich de
Trang 2[Chuyen de]
irgng s6ng khdng cao
chat kin Idng dddng, vay quanh cic tda nha
tao ra cac hing rao cin trd cic xe chffa chiy
tiep can hien trffdng
Theo thdng ke chffa diy du, trang 5 nam qua,
tren dja bin thanh phd Hi Npi xiy ra gan 10
vu chiy, sff cd chay tai cic chung cff, nha cao
tang Trffdc vu chiy lam chet 2 ngffdi d chung
cff 18 tang tren dddng Le Van Lddng, Hi Npi
di CO vu chiy tang ham de xe 6t6 khu nhi A,
chung cff My Dinh 1, huyen Tff Liem thing
7-2008, thieu rui 3 chiec 616 va lam hff hdng
mpt sd xe khic; vu chiy tai phdng 806, tang
8, toa nha 34T, khu dd thj Trung Hoi - Nhin
Chinh
Theo bio cio mdi day cua CATP Hi Npi ve
ket qui kiem tra an toan PCCC tai cic nha
cao tang, chung cd tren dja bin thanh phd:
Tinh den thing 1-2010, Hi Npi cd 364 nha
cao tang (cao tff 10 tang trd len), trang dd
cd 247 nhi chung cff; 34 toi nha vffa Iim
chung cff, vffa Iim van phdng; 47 vin phdng;
17 khich san Qua kiem tra, Iffc Iffpng cdng
an phit hien, nhieu chung cff, nhi cao tang
du dffpc trang bj he thdng PCCC, nhffng do lau
ngiy khdng van hinh d i bdng hdc Ding chu
y, 43/364 nha chung cff he thdng den chieu
sing v i 17/364 nhi he thdng den chi dan
thoit nan khdng bio dim quy djnh Nhieu
ngudi dan vi pham cic quy dinh PCCC
Ve phia Idc Idpng PCCC, mdt lanh dao cho
hay: Cic nddc cd ci miy bay de chffa chiy
nhi cao tang, nhffng ddn vj hien mdi cd mpt
xe thang loai 52 m (dp vffdn cao khoing tang
16 nhi cao tang) v i 2 xe thang loai 32 m Ve
nang Iffc chffa chiy, vdi cic xe chuyen dung
v i phffdng tien hien cd, Iffc Iffpng PCCC mdi
chi dip ffng chffa chiy hieu qui tff tang 10
trd xudng Neu cao bdn, ip Iffc nffdc se giim,
viec chffa chiy se khdng dem lai hieu qui
Do dd, cac toa nhi cao tang phii cd he
thdng chOa chay tff dpng hoac bin Iff dpng
tai chd Khi xiy chiy, Iffc Iffdng PCCC tai chd
AH T6NG RA SOAT LAI HE THONG THANG BO TAI CAC
TOA NHA CAO TANG
Theo TS Tran Chung, Trffdng Ban Chat Iffpng (Tong hpi Xay ddng Viet Nam), cong tic PCCC tai cic tda nhi phii dddc xem la nhiem vu s6 mpt, tuy nhien thuc te hien nay lai khong phai nhu vay
Oing ra, tff khau thiet ke ky thuat, yeu td PCCC phii dddc cd quan chffc nang tham dinh
Khi be thdng, phddng tien PCCC phai dddc lap dat hoin chinh va ddpc cP quan chffc nang kiem tra v i phe chuan thi tda nha mdi dffpc dffa vip van hinh
COng theo dng Iran Chung, ddi vdi cic tda nhi cao tang, he thdng cau thang thoat hiem co the Iim d trang hoac ngoii tda nhi Tuy nhien, diem quan trpng l i phii dupe thiet ke, xay dffng de tao ldi thoit chff khdng phii la dng hut khdi "giam giff" con ngudi Tdi kien nghi can cd dpi kiem tra, r i soit lai toan bp he thdng thang dp cic tda nha"- Ong Chung ndi
se bat he thdng chffa chiy td d6ng hoac ban
Id dpng, nffdc se Iran xudng cic tang tff cic hpng vdi chffa chiy
TRANH CHAP VOI CHU DAUTU
Ci nffdc hien cd hdn 300 chung cff vdi gan 1 trieu cff dan sinh sdng, nhffng cd che quin ly khu vuc niy cdn rat thieu VI the tranh chap dan sff tai cic tda nhi lien tuc nd ra v i phan thua thiet cudi cung thffdng thupc ve khich hing Nhieu khu chung cff bau ra Ban quin tri cua minh nhung Ban quan rtri lai khdng
cd tff cich phip nhan nen rat khd thffc hien chffc nang cua minh v i chffa cd chu dau tff dff i n nio ip dung quy djnh ve Ban quin ly
The l i quyen ldi chinh ding khd dddc bio ve, nhieu khu khdng cd trudng hpc cdng lap, thieu ndi sinh boat c6ng ddng nhd trong thiet ke nhdng ngffdi dan khd tranh cai
Trang dd lai cd sd hOu rieng cua ngddi mua,
sd hffu rieng cua chu dau tff the nhffng cd
sd phip ly de chffng minh, xic djnh rd quyen
sd hffu chung, sd hffu rieng v i quyen sff dung chung chffa rd
Binh luan ve sff lung tung trong viec tim cP che quin ly nha chung cff, dng Odng Minh Sdn - Hdi Xiy ddng Hi Npi cho rang, hau het
nha dau tU dd bio sai hoac khdng quan tam xay dung dien tich chung du dap ffng nhu cau cua nhan din, trong khi cd quan quin ly dja phffdng chffa hudng dan, giim sit chat che dan den bnh trang thieu cho de xe, nay sinh mau thuan, tranh chap
Hang loat mau thuan phffc tap, khd giii quyet hien nay nhU ai se t r i tien sff dung dat khi lam thu tuc cap giay chffng nhan quyen sff dung dat, quyen sd hffu nha d va tai sin khac gan lien vdi dat? Ai l i ngddi sd hffu tang
1, tang ham va tang thUdng cua nha chung cu? Ai cd trich nhiem cham sdc vudn hoa, cay cinh trong khuon vien khu chung cff? Hdn nffa, khi chung cff khdng chi dung de d mi cdn dung lam van phdng cho thue, va ci cac boat dpng djch vu thddng mai, ngan hing, tii chinh thi viec quin ly, sff dung cing phffc tap hdn
Neu kh5ng dffdc xff ly kip thdi, van de se ngiy cang trd nen bffc xuc, dd dan den nhffng bat
dn trang xi h6i, mau thuan trien mien giffa nha dau td vdi ngffdi sd hffu sff dung cin
hp chung CU; gay cin trd cho viec trien khai chinh sich nhi d xi hdi, nhi d gia thap;
khdng kiem soit ddpc nan dau cd bit d6ng sin nha d Nhieu chuyen gia cho rang can
cd "Luat Chung cff" ^
,so Cl 6 i T H i M 4/2010 »• TAP CHf P H A P LY
13