Kiểm định hiệu lực ngang giá sức mua PPP giữa Việt Nam với Thái Lan và Malaysia

Bài viết tiến hành kiểm định hiệu lực ngang giá sức mua PPP giữa Việt Nam với Thái Lan và Malaysia. Với cách tiếp cận chuỗi tỷ giá hối đoái và chỉ số giá là phi tuyến và sử dụng mô hình hồi quy bán tham số, bài viết đã tìm thấy sự tồn tại của PPP giữa Việt Nam và Thái Lan, nhưng không tìm thấy sự tồn tại PPP giữa Việt Nam và Malaysia.

*,Ӳ$9,ӊ71$09Ӟ,7+È,/$19¬0$/$<6,$

7+(385&+$6,1*32:(53$5,7<$021*9,(71$07+$,/$1'$1'0$-/$<6,$

+͛7Kͯ\7LrQ 1 +͛7KX+RjL 1 1J{9ăQ7RjQ 1

1Jj\QKұQ  1Jj\QKұQEҧQVӱD1Jj\ÿăQJ

7yPWҳW

%jLEiRWLӃQKjQKNLӇPÿӏQKKLӋXOӵFQJDQJJLiVӭFPXD333JLӳD9LӋW1DPYӟL7KiL/DQYj0D-OD\VLD9ӟLFiFKWLӃSFұQFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLYjFKӍVӕJLiOjSKLWX\ӃQYjVӱGөQJP{KuQKKӗLTX\ EiQWKDPVӕFK~QJW{LÿmWuPWKҩ\VӵWӗQWҥLFӫD333JLӳD9LӋW1DPYj7KiL/DQQKѭQJNK{QJWuP WKҩ\VӵWӗQWҥL333JLӳD9LӋW1DPYj0DOD\VLD.ӃWTXҧQJKLrQFӭXFKRWKҩ\FKtQKViFKWӹJLiҧQK KѭӣQJUҩWOӟQYjRVӵWӗQWҥL333JLӳD9LӋW1DPYӟL7KiL/DQYj0DOD\VLD.ӃWTXҧQJKLrQFӭX còn

SKiWKLӋQPӝWÿLӇPTXDQWUӑQJÿyQJJySWKrPYjROêWKX\ӃW333ÿyOjW͛QW̩LKD\NK{QJW͛QW̩L333 NK{QJFK͑FͱQJQK̷F[HP[pWÿ͡O͏FKFͯDP͡WÿL͋PVRYͣLÿ˱ͥQJ333PjWK{QJWK˱ͥQJFyÿ͡O͏FK WURQJP͡WSK̩PYLQK̭Wÿ͓QKVRYͣLÿ˱ͥQJ333ÿ͋OêJL̫LFKRFiFFKLSKtWURQJJLDRG͓FKWK˱˯QJP̩L TX͙FW͇YjFiF\͇XW͙NKiFWiFÿ͡QJ.ӃWTXҧQJKLrQFӭXFKRWKҩ\SKҥPYLQj\Oj1ӃXÿӝOӋFKUD

NKӓLÿѭӡQJ333QKӓKѫQWKuYүQÿѭӧF[HPOjWӗQWҥLQJDQJJLiVӭFPXDWUѭӡQJKӧS9LӋW1DP Yj7KiL/DQQӃXÿӝOӋFKYѭӧWTXiWKuNӃWOXұQOjNK{QJWӗQWҥLQJDQJJLiVӭFPXD333WUѭӡQJ KӧS9LӋW1DPYj0DOD\VLD

7ӯNKyDKLӋXOӵFQJDQJJLiVӭFPXDFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLFKӍVӕJLiSKLWX\ӃQKӗLTX\EiQWKDPVӕ

$EVWUDFW

7KHSDSHUH[DPLQHVWKHSXUFKDVLQJSRZHUSDULW\333DPRQJ9LHWQDP7KDLODQGDQG0DOD\VLD:LWK WKHDSSURDFKXVLQJWKHH[FKDQJHUDWHVHULHVDQGWKHQRQOLQHDUSULFHLQGH[DQGXVLQJWKHVHPLSDUDPHW-ULFUHJUHVVLRQPRGHOZHKDYHIRXQGWKHH[LVWHQFHRI333VEHWZHHQ9LHWQDPDQG7KDLODQGEXWIRXQG QRH[LVWHQFHDW333EHWZHHQ9LHWQDPDQG0DOD\VLD7KHUHVXOWVRIWKHVWXG\VKRZWKDWH[FKDQJHUDWH SROLF\KDVDJUHDWLQÀXHQFHRQWKHH[LVWHQFHRI333VDPRQJ9LHWQDP7KDLODQGDQG0DOD\VLD7KH

¿QGLQJVDOVRUHYHDODQLPSRUWDQWSRLQWFRQWULEXWLQJWRWKH333WKHRU\WKDWH[LVWVRUGRHVQRWH[LVW PPP is not only rigidly considering the deviation of one point compared to the PPP curve but there is usually a deviation in a certain range of PPP lines to account for costs in international trade transac-WLRQVDQGRWKHUIDFWRUVLPSDFW5HVHDUFKVKRZVWKDWWKLVUDQJHLV,IWKHGHYLDWLRQRXWRIWKH333LV OHVVWKDQLWLVVWLOOFRQVLGHUHG333LQWKHFDVHRI9LHWQDPDQG7KDLODQGLIWKHGHYLDWLRQH[FHHGV

WKHFRQFOXVLRQLVWKDW333GRHVQRWH[LVWLQWKHFDVHRI9LHWQDPDQG0DOD\VLD

.H\ZRUGVSXUFKDVLQJSRZHUSDULW\H[FKDQJHUDWHVHULHVQRQOLQHDUSULFHLQGH[VHPLSDUDPHWULF

regression model

1 Trường Đại học Tài chính – Marketing

*LӟLWKLӋX

/ҥPSKiWYjWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLFyTXDQKӋYӟL

QKDXWK{QJTXDOêWKX\ӃW1JDQJJLiVӭFPXD

7KHR Oê WKX\ӃW Qj\ JLi Fҧ FӫD FQJ PӝW ORҥL

KjQJKyDOjJLӕQJQKDXFKRGEiQӣEҩWNǤTXӕF

JLDQjR1ӃXFyPӝWVӵFKrQKOӋFKWURQJJLiFҧ KjQJKyDJLӳDTXӕFJLDWKuNLQKGRDQKFKrQK OӋFKJLiVӁ[ҧ\UDKӋTXҧOjWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLVӁ ÿLӅXFKӍQKÿӇOjPFkQEҵQJPӭFJLiKjQJKyD ӇWӯNKLOêWKX\ӃWQj\ÿѭӧFSKiWELӇXYjRQăP

UҩWQKLӅXFiFQJKLrQFӭXWKӵFKLӋQÿӇNLӇPÿӏQK

OêWKX\ӃWQj\WURQJWKӵFWӃ&iFQJKLrQFӭXFKR

ÿӃQQD\FKLDUDOjPWUѭӡQJSKiL7UѭӡQJSKiL

ÿҫXWLrQNKҷQJÿӏQKWӗQWҥLQJDQJJLiVӭFPXD

YjWUѭӡQJSKiLFzQOҥLWKuNK{QJ.ӃWTXҧQJKLrQ

FӭXFyFKtQK[iFKD\NK{QJSKөWKXӝFUҩWOӟQ

YjRSKѭѫQJSKiSVӱGөQJYjTXDQÿLӇPYӅPӕL

TXDQKӋJLӳDFKXӛLGӳOLӋXOҥPSKiWYjWӹJLi

KӕLÿRiL%jLEiRQj\ӫQJKӝTXDQÿLӇPTXDQ

KӋSKLWX\ӃQJLӳDFKXӛLGӳOLӋXWUrQ9uYұ\

P{ KuQK Yj SKѭѫQJ SKiS QJKLrQ FӭX VӁ WKLrQ

YӅTXDQÿLӇPQj\NKLNLӇPÿӏQKFyKD\NK{QJ

WӗQWҥL333JLӳD9LӋW1DPYjÿӕLWiFFyJLDR

GӏFKWKѭѫQJPҥLOӟQQKҩWWURQJ$6($1Oj7KiL

/DQYj0DOD\VLDWURQJJLDLÿRҥQQJKLrQFӭXWӯ

WKiQJÿӃQWKiQJ

7әQJTXDQFiFQJKLrQFӭXWUѭӟFÿk\

1KuQ FKXQJ FiF FKXӛL WKӡL JLDQ trong kinh

WӃWKѭӡQJÿѭӧFFKROjSKLWX\ӃQ7RQJ

(QJOH  %ROOHUVOHY  Yj FiF QKj

NLQK WӃ WKѭӡQJ [k\ GӵQJ WtQK SKL WX\ӃQ Qj\

WKHRPӝWWURQJKDLFiFKVDXL[k\GӵQJP{

KuQK SKL WX\ӃQ ÿӝQJ FKR PӝW FKXӛL WKӡL JLDQ

Fө WKӇ +DQQDQ  )DQ DQG <DR 

*DR KRһFLL[HP[pWPӕLTXDQKӋSKL

WX\ӃQJLӳDKDLFKXӛLWKӡLJLDQ*UDQJHU

&KHQ &iFEjLQJKLrQFӭXYӅVӵWӗQWҥL

FӫD 333 ÿѭӧF WKӵF KLӋQ WUrQ QKLӅX TXӕF JLD

YjWѭѫQJӭQJYӟLKDLFiFK[k\GӵQJWUrQWKuFy

KDL KѭӟQJ ÿӇ NLӇP ÿӏQK ÿy Oj  NLӇP ÿӏQK

QJKLӋPÿѫQYӏFӫDFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLWKӵFYj

NLӇPÿӏQKWtQKÿӗQJOLrQNӃWWURQJPӕLTXDQ

KӋJLӳDWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLGDQKQJKƭDYjFKӍVӕJLi

WLrXGQJJLӳDKDLTXӕFJLDFҫQNLӇPÿӏQK&iF

SKѭѫQJSKiSNLӇPÿӏQKQJKLӋPÿѫQYӏYjÿӗQJ

OLrQNӃWWUX\ӅQWKӕQJOjSKѭѫQJSKiSÿѭӧFVӱ

GөQJUӝQJUmLWURQJFiFQJKLrQFӭXWKӵFQJKLӋP

FӫD 333 QKѭQJ FiF SKѭѫQJ SKiS Qj\ WKѭӡQJ

NK{QJ WuP WKҩ\ EҵQJ FKӭQJ FKR WKҩ\ Vӵ WӗQ

WҥL FӫD 333 1KӳQJ WKҩW EҥL Qj\ GүQ ÿӃQ YLӋF

Vӱ GөQJ QKLӅX SKѭѫQJ SKiS PӟL ÿӇ WuP NLӃP

EҵQJFKӭQJYӅ333EDRJӗPVӱGөQJEӝGӳOLӋX

YӟLWKӡLJLDQGjLKѫQ7D\ORU VӱGөQJ

SKѭѫQJ SKiS NLӇP ÿӏQK QJKLӋP ÿѫQ Yӏ GҥQJ

EҧQJ7D\ORU YjVӱGөQJFiFP{KuQK

SKLWX\ӃQ+DLSKѭѫQJSKiSÿҫXWLrQOLrQTXDQ

ÿӃQYLӋFVӱGөQJFiFEӝGӳOLӋXNKiFQKDXÿӇ

FҧLWKLӋQYLӋFNLӇPWUD333WX\QKLrQFyQKѭӧF ÿLӇPOjEӓTXDVӵSKөWKXӝFFӫDFiFTXӕFJLD 2¶&RQQHOO 7URQJNKLÿySKѭѫQJSKiS VӱGөQJP{KuQKSKLWX\ӃQFyWtQKÿӃQFiF\ӃX WӕNLQKWӃNKiFFyWiFÿӝQJÿӃQWӹJLiKӕLÿRiL FKLSKtJLDRGӏFKYҩQÿӅVWLFN\SULFHVӁFKR NӃWTXҧÿiQJWLQFұ\KѫQ

é WѭӣQJ YӅ P{ KuQK Wӹ JLi KӕL ÿRiL SKL WX\ӃQ ÿҫX WLrQ ÿѭӧF SKiW KLӋQ EӣL +HFNVFKHU  ÐQJ FKR UҵQJ FKtQK FKL SKt JLDR GӏFK TXӕF WӃ JLӳD WKӏ WUѭӡQJ KDL TXӕF JLD GR NKiF ELӋWYӅNK{QJJLDQOjQJX\rQQKkQGүQÿӃQVӵ SKLWX\ӃQ6DXÿyPӝWORҥWFiFQJKLrQFӭXWKӵF QJKLӋPÿѭӧFWKӵFKLӋQQKҵPSKiWWULӇQP{KuQK Oê WKX\ӃW YӅ Wӹ JLi WKӵF SKL WX\ӃQ Yj Vӱ GөQJ FiF P{ KuQK Qj\ ÿӇ NLӇP WUD JLҧ WKX\ӃW 333

%DXP HW DO 2¶&RQQHOO DQG :HL ÿm NӃ WKӯD QJKLrQ FӭX FӫD +HFNVFKHU  [HP[pWP{KuQKWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLSKLWX\ӃQGѭӟL JyFÿӝFKLSKtJLDRGӏFK1JRjLUDYӟLJLҧÿӏQK FiFF{QJW\FyVӵSKkQELӋWJLiӣFiFTXӕFJLD NKiFQKDXQJKLrQFӭXFӫD&DUYDOKRYj1HFKLR FKRWKҩ\YҩQÿӅVWLFN\±SULFHOjQJX\rQ QKkQ OjP FKR WKӏ WUѭӡQJ KjQJ KyD ÿLӅX FKӍQK FKұPKѫQWKӏWUѭӡQJWjLVҧQNKLFyF~VӕF[ҧ\UD ĈLӅXQj\QJөêPӕLTXDQKӋSKLWX\ӃQJLӳDWӹ JLiKӕLÿRiLYjFKӍVӕJLiFӫDQӅQNLQKWӃ7KrP YjRÿyYҩQÿӅOӧLWKӃQăQJVXҩWWѭѫQJÿӕLJLӳD FiF TXӕF JLD FNJQJ Oj PӝW WURQJ QKӳQJ \ӃX Wӕ ӫQJKӝFKRP{KuQKWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLSKLWX\ӃQ &KRQJHWDO 

9ӟL FiFK WLӃS FұQ ÿҫX WLrQ PӝW Vӕ QKj QJKLrQFӭXWLӃQKjQKNLӇPÿӏQKQJKLӋPÿѫQYӏ WUrQ FKXӛL Wӹ JLi KӕL ÿRiL WKӵF 0LFKDHO HW DO VӱGөQJGӳOLӋXKjQJWKiQJFӫDEӕQTXӕF JLD0ӻ$QK3KiSYjĈӭFÿӇP{WҧTXiWUuQK ÿLӅXFKӍQKSKLWX\ӃQVӱGөQJ6PRRWK7UDQVLWLRQ

$XWRUHJUHVVLYH 0RGHO YӟL WӕF ÿӝ ÿLӅX FKӍQK WKD\ ÿәL +ӑ WKҩ\ UҵQJ QӃX GӵD WUrQ P{ KuQK WX\ӃQWtQKNKҧQăQJEiFEӓVӵWәQWҥLFӫD333 UҩWFDRPһFGWURQJGjLKҥQYүQFyVӵWӗQWҥL FӫD333&iFWiFJLҧWuPWKҩ\FKXӛLWӹJLiKӕL ÿRiL WKӵF Fy [X KѭӟQJ KӝL Wө YӅ JLi WUӏ WUXQJ EuQK+D\QyLFiFKNKiFFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiL WKӵFOjFKXӛLGӯQJFKRWKҩ\VӵWӗQWҥLFӫD333

%DXPYjFӝQJVӵVӱGөQJGӳOLӋXWURQJ WKӡLNǤKұX%UHWWRQ:RRGVYjVӱGөQJ6PRRWK 7UDQVLWLRQ$XWRUHJUHVVLYH0RGHOÿmPӝWOҫQQӳD

NKҷQJ ÿӏQK NӃW TXҧ FӫD 0LFKDHO HW DO 

7LӃSÿyEjLQJKLrQFӭXFӫD%DKPDQL2VNRRHH

WKD\YuVӱGөQJNLӇPÿӏQK$')FKXҭQ

Kӑ Vӱ GөQJ NLӇP ÿӏQK PӟL NӃW KӧS SKL WX\ӃQ

WURQJ FKXӛL Wӹ JLi WKӵF FӫD  TXӕF JLD F{QJ

QJKLӋS ӃW TXҧ FKR WKҩ\ SKѭѫQJ SKiS NLӇP

ÿӏQKPӟLӫQJKӝVӵWӗQWҥL333ӣQKLӅXTXӕF

JLDKѫQSKѭѫQJSKiS$')WK{QJWKѭӡQJ*ҫQ

ÿk\*LUDLWLVYjFӝQJVӵÿӅ[XҩWVӱGөQJ

FiFP{KuQKKӋVӕELӃQÿәLWKHRWKӡLJLDQQJүX

QKLrQÿӇNLӇPWUDJLҧWKX\ӃW333+ӑVӱGөQJGӳ

OLӋXWӹJLiWKӵFÿӇSKKӧSYӟLP{KuQKWӵKӗL

TX\YjWұSWUXQJYjRYLӋFSKkQWtFKVӵKӝLWөYӅ

JLiWUӏWUXQJEuQKFӫDFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLWKӵF

.ӃWTXҧFKRWKҩ\VӵWӗQWҥLFӫD333

9ӟL FiFK WLӃS FұQ WKӭ KDL FiF QKj QJKLrQ

FӭXWLӃQKjQKNLӇPÿӏQKWtQKÿӗQJOLrQNӃWJLӳD

FKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLGDQKQJKƭDYjFKXӛLFKӍVӕ

JLi7UѭӟFÿk\FiFNLӇPÿӏQKÿӗQJOLrQNӃWFKӫ

\ӃXÿѭӧFWKӵFKLӋQӣGҥQJÿӗQJOLrQNӃWWX\ӃQ

WtQK WX\ QKLrQ NLӇP ÿӏQK WX\ӃQ WtQK WKѭӡQJ

WKҩWEҥLNKLWuPUDPӕLTXDQKӋJLӳDFiFFKXӛL

WKӡLJLDQNK{QJGӯQJQӃXFK~QJFyPӕLTXDQ

KӋSKLWX\ӃQ*UDQJHU +RQJYj3KLOOLSV

OұSOXұQUҵQJFiFFKXӛLWKӡLJLDQNK{QJ

GӯQJFyNKX\QKKѭӟQJOjFiFFKXӛLFyEѭӟFÿL

QJүXQKLrQUDQGRPZDONFKRQrQQӃXVӱGөQJ

FiFѭӟFOѭӧQJWX\ӃQWtQKFKRFiFNӃWKӧSSKL

WX\ӃQFyWKӇGүQÿӃQNӃWTXҧVDLOӋFKWURQJGjL

KҥQ'RÿyFiFWiFJLҧQj\WKӵFKLӋQNLӇPÿӏQK

5HJUHVVLRQ (UURU 6SHFL¿FDWLRQ 7HVW 5(6(7

VӱGөQJFKXӛLGӳOLӋXWKӡLJLDQNK{QJGӯQJÿӇ

NLӇPÿӏQKWUӵFWLӃSFKRPӕLTXDQKӋÿӗQJOLrQ

NӃWWX\ӃQWtQKYjKӑWuQKWKҩ\UҩWtWEҵQJFKӭQJ

ӫQJKӝVӵSKKӧSFӫDÿһFWtQKÿӗQJOLrQNӃW

WX\ӃQWtQK1KѭYұ\YӟLFKXӛLWKӡLJLDQNK{QJ

GӯQJYjSKLWX\ӃQVӱGөQJFiFKNӃWKӧSWX\ӃQ

WtQKVӁGүQÿӃQNӃWTXҧVDLOӋFK&iFQJKLrQFӭX

VDXQj\WұSWUXQJVӱGөQJP{KuQKSKLWX\ӃQ

ÿӇ [HP [pW Vӵ WӗQ WҥL FӫD 333 ÿLӇQ KuQK EjL

QJKLrQFӭXFӫD/L/LQYj+VLDRVӱGөQJ

P{KuQKEiQWKDPVӕYӟLKӋVӕKӗLTX\WKD\ÿәL

QKҵPNLӇPÿӏQKVӵWӗQWҥLFӫD333JLӳD0ӻ

$QK 0ӻ  1KұW Yj 0ӻ  &DQDGD %jL QJKLrQ

FӭX Qj\ WKӵF KLӋQ ÿӗQJ WKӡL Fҧ SKѭѫQJ SKiS

WUX\ӅQWKӕQJYjSKѭѫQJSKiSPӟLKӑWKҩ\UҵQJ

NKLVӱGөQJSKѭѫQJSKiSEiQWKDPVӕNӃWTXҧ

ӫQJKӝVӵWӗQWҥLFӫD333FyӣFҧEDFһSTXӕF

gia

'R ÿy YӟL FiF FKXӛL Wӹ JLi KӕL ÿRiL GDQK QJKƭDYjFKXӛLFKӍVӕJLiNK{QJGӯQJNKLNLӇP ÿӏQKÿӗQJOLrQNӃWWURQJPӕLTXDQKӋJLӳDFiF FKXӛL Qj\ Vӱ GөQJ P{ KuQK SKL WX\ӃQ VӁ SK KӧSYjFKRNӃWTXҧFKtQK[iFKѫQ%jLEiRQj\ QKyPWiFJLҧNӃWKӯDP{KuQKEiQWKDPVӕYӟL KӋVӕKӗLTX\WKD\ÿәLFӫD;LDRÿӇWLӃQ KjQK NLӇP ÿӏQK Vӵ WӗQ WҥL FӫD 333 JLӳD 9LӋW 1DP±7KiL/DQYj9LӋW1DP±0DOD\VLD

3KѭѫQJSKiSQJKLrQFӭX

'ӳOLӋXWURQJQJKLrQFӭXQj\ÿѭӧFQKyPWiF JLҧWKXWKұSWKHRWKiQJYӅWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLGDQK QJKƭDFӫD91'7+%0<5YӟL86'FKӍVӕ JLiWLrXGQJ&3,FӫD9LӋW1DP7KiL/DQYj 0DOD\VLDWURQJJLDLÿRҥQWӯQăPÿӃQ QăP1JXӗQGӳOLӋXÿѭӧFOҩ\Wӯ4Xӻ 7LӅQWӋTXӕFWӃ,QWHUQDWLRQDO0RQHWDU\)XQG± ,0)Yj7KRPVRQ5HXWHU

%jLEiRVӱGөQJP{KuQKEiQWKDPVӕYӟLKӋ VӕKӗLTX\WKD\ÿәLQKѭVDX

࢙࢚= ࢼ૙(ࢠ࢚) + ࢼ૚(ࢠ࢚)࢖࢚+ ࢼ૚(ࢠ࢚)࢖࢚כ + ࣆ࢚ 



7URQJÿy

stWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLGDQKQJKƭDJLӳD9LӋW 1DP Yj TXӕF JLD L L OҫQ OѭӧW Oj 7KiL /DQ 0DOD\VLD

pt FKӍ Vӕ JLi WLrX GQJ FӫD 9LӋW 1DP 9,(

p*

tFKӍVӕJLiWLrXGQJOҫQOѭӧWFӫD7KiL /DQ7+$0DOD\VLD0$/

ztOjELӃQVӕFӕÿӏQKҧQKKѭӣQJÿӃQPӕL TXDQKӋJLӳDVt, pt t7URQJEjLQJKLrQFӭX Qj\QKyPWiFJLҧOӵDFKӑQ]tOjFKrQKOӋFKOmL VXҩWJLӳDKDLTXӕFJLDPөFWLrXEӣLYuPӕLTXDQ KӋJLӳDPӭFJLiYjWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLVRQJSKѭѫQJ WKѭӡQJ Eӏ ҧQK KѭӣQJ EӣL FKrQK OӋFK OmL VXҩW JLӳDKDLTXӕFJLDĈӇWtQKFKӍVӕ]tEjLQJKLrQ FӭXWKXWKұSGӳOLӋXOmLVXҩWWtQSKLӃXNKREҥF NǤKҥQWKiQJYjOmLVXҩWWUiLSKLӃXNKREҥFNǤ KҥQQăP]tÿѭӧFWtQKQKѭVDX

(1)

%LӃQ 0{Wҧ &iFKWtQK

st 7ӹJLiKӕLÿRiLJLӳD

7+%91'Yj0<5

91'

pt &3,FӫD9LӋW1DP OQ&3,91'

p*t &3,FӫDQѭӟFFzQOҥL OQ&3,7+%0<5

zt &KӋQKOӋFKOmLVXҩWJLӳD

KDLFһSTXӕFJLD

7\WL±73m,t,i±7\W91'±7PW91'

zt 7\WL±73m,t,i±7\W91'±7PW91'

YӟLL 7+%0<5

1KyPWiFJLҧWұSWUXQJYjRNLӇPÿӏQKÿӗQJ

OLrQNӃWFӫDP{KuQKÿӇNLӇPÿӏQKJLҧWKX\ӃW

PPP

.êKLӋX

ݔݐ= (1, ݌ݐ, ݌ݐכ)ܶ, ߚ(ݖ) = (ߚ0(ݖ), ߚ1(ݖ), ߚ2(ݖ))ܶ

0{KuQKÿѭӧFYLӃWOҥLQKѭVDX

࢙࢚ = ࢚࢞Ԣࢼ(ࢠ) + ࢛࢚

&iFKӋVӕKӗLTX\WURQJP{KuQKÿѭӧFWtQK

QKѭVDX

ߚመݐ(ݖ) = ൥෍ ݔݐݔݐܶ ܭ݄(ݖݐെ ݖ)

ܶ

ݐ=1

൩

െ1

෍ ݔݐݏݐܭ݄(ݖݐെ ݖ)

ܶ

ݐ=1

9ӟL

ܭ݄(ݖݐെ ݖ) = ݄െ1ܭ ቀݖݐ െ ݖ

݄ ቁ

OjKjP.HUQHOYjKOjWKDPVӕEDQGZLGWK 1KyPWiFJLҧVӱGөQJѭӟFOѭӧQJ*DXVVLDQNHU-QHOYjFKӑQEDQGZLGWKWӕLѭXEҵQJFiFKVӱGөQJ SKѭѫQJSKiS/6&9/HDVW6TXDUH&URVV9DOL-GDWLRQPHWKRG

ĈӇ NLӇP ÿӏQK ÿӗQJ OLrQ NӃW QKyP WiF JLҧ WLӃQ KjQK JLӳ OҥL SKҫQ Gѭ FӫD P{ KuQK  Yj WKӵFKLӋQNLӇPÿӏQKWKHRSKѭѫQJSKiSFӫD;LDR %jLEiRWLӃQKjQKNLӇPÿӏQKKӋVӕ]HUR FӫDELӃQ[XKѭӟQJWKӡLJLDQWURQJP{KuQK

࢛ෝ࢚૛ = ࢇ + ࢈࢚ + ࢋ࢚

*L̫WKX\͇W+ 0 :0{KuQKNK{QJFy[XKѭӟQJ

WKӡL JLDQ WӭF Oj FKXӛL Xt Oj FKXӛL GӯQJ WUXQJ EuQK+D\QyLFiFKNKiFFyPӕLTXDQKӋÿӗQJ OLrQNӃWJLӳDFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLYjFKXӛLJLi 1KѭYұ\ӫQJKӝJLҧWKX\ӃW333

%jLEiRÿѭӧFWLӃQKjQKWKHRWUuQKWӵQKѭVDX

- LӇP ÿӏQK QJKLӋP ÿѫQ Yӏ EҵQJ $')

')*/6Yj33ÿӕLYӟLFiFFKXӛLWӹJLi

KӕL ÿRiL FKXӛL &3, Yj FKXӛL ]t 9ӟL

FKXӛL Wӹ JLi KӕL ÿRiL Yj &3, QӃX FiF

FKXӛLQj\NK{QJGӯQJYjOj,NKLÿy

YLӋFiSGөQJP{KuQKEiQWKDPVӕWKӇ

KLӋQPӕLTXDQKӋJLӳDWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLYj

FKӍVӕJLiOjSKKӧS+RQJYj3KLOOLSV

 9ӟLFKXӛL]tWKHR;LDR ÿk\SKҧLOjFKXӛLGӯQJ

- +ӗL TX\ P{ KuQK  Vӱ GөQJ SKѭѫQJ SKiS/6&9/HDVWVTXDUHFURVV±YDO-LGDWLRQFӫD6XQYj/LÿӇWuPUD WKDPVӕEDQGZLGWKWӕLѭX

- ӃWKӯDSKѭѫQJSKiSFӫD;LDR NLӇPÿӏQKVӵWӗQWҥLFӫDOêWKX\ӃWQJDQJ

(2)

(3)

%ҧQJ%LӃQQJKLrQFӭX

&һSTXӕFJLD 9,(7+$ 9,(0$/

JLiVӭFPXDEҵQJP{KuQKKӗLTX\EiQ

WKDPVӕFyWKDPVӕWKD\ÿәLEҵQJFiFK

NLӇPWUDWtQKGӯQJFӫDSKҫQGѭ

.ӃWTXҧQJKLrQFӭX

ĈӇNLӇPÿӏQKFyWӗQWҥL333JLӳD9LӋW1DP

YjTXӕFJLDFzQOҥLQKyPWiFJLҧWLӃQKjQKFiF

NLӇPÿӏQKQKҵPWuPUDWtQKÿӗQJOLrQNӃWJLӳDWӹ

JLiKӕLÿRiLYj&3,FӫDFiFFһSTXӕFJLD ĈҫXWLrQQKyPWiFJLҧWKӵFKLӋQNLӇPÿӏQK WtQKGӯQJFӫDFiFFKXӛLWKӡLJLDQVӱGөQJWURQJ EjL QJKLrQ FӭX EDR JӗP FiF FKXӛL YӅ Wӹ JLi KӕLÿRiLYjFKXӛLFKӍVӕ&3,/ҫQOѭӧWVӱGөQJ SKѭѫQJ SKiS $') ')*/6 Yj 33 NӃW TXҧ ÿѭӧFWKӇKLӋQӣ%ҧQJ

%ҧQJ.LӇPÿӏQKWtQKGӯQJFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLYj&3,

   9ӟL JLҧ WKX\ӃW + FiF FKXӛL WKӡL JLDQ Fy

QJKLӋPÿѫQYӏ.ӃWTXҧӣFiFFӝW,ӣFҧED

NLӇP ÿӏQK ÿӅX FKҩS QKұQ JLҧ WKX\ӃW +, hay

QyLFiFKNKiFFiFFKXӛLQj\ÿӅXNK{QJGӯQJ

1KyP WiF JLҧ WLӃQ KjQK Oҩ\ VDL SKkQ FӫD FiF

FKXӛLWKӡLJLDQYjWKӵFKLӋQOҥLFiFNLӇPÿӏQK

NӃWTXҧFiFFӝW,FKRWKҩ\FiFFKXӛLWKӡLJLDQ

Qj\ÿӅXGӯQJ1KѭYұ\FiFFKXӛLWKӡLJLDQWӹ

JLiYjFKӍVӕ&3,OjFiFFKXӛLEұFQKҩWa, 

1Kѭ Yұ\ YLӋF Vӱ GөQJ P{ KuQK KӗL TX\ EiQ WKDPVӕYӟLKӋVӕKӗLTX\WKD\ÿәLOjSKKӧS +RQJYj3KLOOLSV 

7KHR &DL HW DO  Yj ;LDR  FKӍ Vӕ]tÿҥLGLӋQEӣLFKrQKOӋFKOmLVXҩWJLӳDFiF FһSTXӕFJLDYjSKҧLGӯQJ'RÿyQKyPWiFJLҧ WLӃQKjQKNLӇPÿӏQKWtQKGӯQJFӫDFKXӛL]tEҵQJ NLӇPÿӏQK$')Yj33.ӃWTXҧWKӇKLӋQWURQJ

%ҧQJ

%ҧQJ.LӇPÿӏQKWtQKGӯQJFKXӛL] W VӱGөQJNLӇPÿӏQK$')Yj33

ZTHA-VIE

Z0$/9,(

9ӟLJLҧWKX\ӃW+FiFFKXӛL]tFyQJKLӋPÿѫQ

YӏVӱGөQJNLӇPÿӏQK$')Yj33ÿӅXEiFEӓJLҧ

WKX\ӃW+ӣPӭFêQJKƭDYjĈLӅX

Qj\ FKR WKҩ\ FiF FKXӛL ]t ÿӅX Oj FKXӛL GӯQJ

a, .ӃWTXҧQj\WKӓDÿLӅXNLӋQEDQÿҫXFӫD

P{KuQK

0ӝWWURQJQKӳQJQJKӋWKXұWNKLVӱGөQJP{ KuQK EiQ WKDP Vӕ Oj SKҧL FKӑQ WKDP Vӕ EDQG-ZLGWKSKKӧS7LӃSWKHRQKyPWiFJLҧVӱGөQJ SKѭѫQJSKiS/6&9/HDVWVTXDUHFURVV±YDO-LGDWLRQFӫD6XQYj/LÿӇWuPUDWKDPVӕ EDQGZLGWKWӕLѭX

   %ѭӟF FXӕL FQJ QKyP QJKLrQ FӭX NӃ WKӯD

SKѭѫQJSKiSFӫD;LDRNLӇPÿӏQKVӵWӗQ

WҥL FӫD Oê WKX\ӃW QJDQJ JLi VӭF PXD EҵQJ P{ KuQKKӗLTX\EiQWKDPVӕFyKӋVӕWKD\ÿәLEҵQJ

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

FiFKNLӇPWUDWtQKGӯQJFӫDSKҫQGѭ

%ҧQJ.LӇPÿӏQKSKҫQGѭ

&һSTXӕFJLD 9,(7+$ 9,(0$/

9ӟLFһSTXӕFJLD9LӋW1DP±7KiL/DQKӋVӕ

SYDOXHOҫQOѭӧWOj.ӃWTXҧQj\ÿmWKҩW

EҥLWURQJYLӋFEiFEӓJLҧWKX\ӃW+WӭFOjEuQK

SKѭѫQJSKҫQGѭNK{QJELӃQÿәLWKHRWKӡLJLDQ

+D\QyLFiFKNKiFFKXӛLXtOjFKXӛLGӯQJWUXQJ

EuQK'RÿyӣFһSTXӕFJLDQj\QKyPWiFJLҧ

WuPWKҩ\WtQKÿӗQJOLrQNӃWJLӳDFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕL

ÿRiLYjFKXӛLJLi1KѭYұ\ӫQJKӝJLҧWKX\ӃW

PPP.7X\QKLrQÿӕLYӟLFһSTXӕFJLD9LӋW1DP

Yj0DOD\VLDNӃWTXҧOҥLQJѭӧFOҥL9ӟLSYDOXH 

ÿmFKRWKҩ\VӵELӃQÿәLWKHRWKӡLJLDQFӫD

SKҫQGѭWӭFXtNK{QJGӯQJĈLӅXQj\FKRWKҩ\

OêWKX\ӃWQJDQJJLiVӭFPXDNK{QJÿѭӧFGX\WUu

JLӳDFһSTXӕFJLDQj\

;iFÿӏQKÿӝOӋFKNKӓLÿѭӡQJQJDQJJLiVӭF

PXD333

7ӯVӕOLӋXYӅWӹJLiYjOҥPSKiWFӫDWӯQJTXӕF

JLDWURQJPүXQJKLrQFӭXQKyPWiFJLҧQKұQ WKҩ\FyVӵFKrQKOӋFKWURQJWKD\ÿәLOҥPSKiW JLӳD  TXӕF JLD YӟL WKD\ ÿәL Wӹ JLi ÿӗQJ WLӅQ JLӳDTXӕFJLDĈLӅXQj\FKRWKҩ\VӁFyPӝWÿӝ OӋFKFӫDFiFÿLӇPWKӇKLӋQTXDQKӋWURQJWKD\ ÿәLOҥPSKiWYjWӹJLiVRYӟLÿѭӡQJQJDQJJLi VӭFPXDĈӇ[iFÿӏQKÿӝOӋFKQj\QKyPWiFJLҧ Vӱ GөQJ SKѭѫQJ SKiS ÿӗ WKӏ NӃW KӧS YӟL YLӋF [iFÿӏQKNKRҧQJFiFKFӫDWӯQJÿLӇPÿӃQÿѭӡQJ PPP

9ӟLÿѭӡQJ333YjÿLӇP0[;y KRҧQJFiFKWӯÿLӇP0ÿӃQÿѭӡQJ333ÿѭӧF WtQKEҵQJF{QJWKӭFVDX

݀(ܯ݋, ܲܲܲ) =|ܽݔ0+ ܾݕ0+ ܿ|

ξܽ2+ ܾ2

DOjKӋVӕFӫD[YjEOjKӋVӕFӫD\WURQJSKѭѫQJ WUuQK333

VӭFPXD333WDWKҩ\WURQJFҧJLDLÿRҥQQJKLrQ

FӭXTXӕFJLD0DOD\VLDFyÿӝOӋFKUDNKӓLÿѭӡQJ

333OjOӟQQKҩWYӟLÿӝOӋFKOjWURQJNKL

7KiL/DQFyÿӝOӋFKUDNKӓLQJDQJJLiVӭFPXD

QKӓ KѫQ  1KuQ YjR ÿӗ WKӏ FiF ÿLӇP SKkQ

WiQWұSWUXQJErQWUiLÿѭӡQJ333FKӭQJWӓOҥP

SKiW FӫD 9LӋW 1DP FDR KѫQ QKLӅX VR YӟL OҥP

SKiW FӫD 0DOD\VLD QKѭQJ ÿLӅX FKӍQK WURQJ Wӹ

JLi0<591'NK{QJÿiQJNӇĈk\OjQJX\rQ

QKkQ FKӫ \ӃX GҭQ ÿӃQ ÿӝ OӋFK UD NKӓL ÿѭӡQJ

333 FӫD 0DOD\VLD FDR WURQJ JLDL ÿRҥQ QJKLrQ

FӭX7ӯEҧQJWtQKÿӝOӋFKUDNKӓLÿѭӡQJ333

QKyPWiFJLҧFNJQJFyQKұQÿӏQKPһFGNӃWTXҧ

NLӇPÿӏQKFKRWKҩ\WӗQWҥL333JLӳD9LӋW1DP

Yj7KiL/DQQKѭQJÿӝOӋFKUDNKӓLÿѭӡQJ333

FӫDTXӕFJLDQj\QKӓKѫQ9ұ\FyWKӇNӃW

OXұQ YQJ WӗQ WҥL 333 NK{QJ FKӍ Oj QҵP WUrQ

ÿѭӡQJ333PjQҵPWURQJELrQÿӝQKӓKѫQKRһF

EҵQJ1JKƭDOjQӃXÿӝOӋFKUDNKӓLÿѭӡQJ

333WURQJSKҥPYLQKӓKѫQWKuYүQNӃWOXұQ

OjWӗQWҥL333OjGRWӗQWҥLFiFFKLSKtYұQWҧL

EҧRKLӇPWKXӃ«WURQJWKѭѫQJPҥLTXӕFWӃ

.ӃWOXұQ

%jL EiR WKӵF KLӋQ QKҵP NLӇP ÿӏQK Vӵ WӗQ WҥL QJDQJ JLi VӭF PXD 333 JLӳD 7KiL /DQ 0DOD\VLDYj9LӋW1DP9ӟLFiFKWLӃSFұQNKiF VRYӟLFiFQJKLrQFӭXWUѭӟFQJKLrQFӭXQj\WuP WKҩ\ Vӵ WӗQ WҥL QJDQJ JLi VӭF PXD 333 WURQJ GjLKҥQJLӳD9LӋW1DPYj7KiL/DQWURQJYQJ ÿѭӡQJ333YӟLSKҥPYLQKӓKѫQQKѭQJOҥL NӃWTXҧQJKLrQFӭXNK{QJFKRWKҩ\VӵWӗQWҥL 333JLӳD9LӋW1DPYj0DOD\VLDYӟLÿӝOӋFKUD NKӓLÿѭӡQJ333OjWUrQ

/êGRJLҧLWKtFKFKRVӵWӗQWҥLKD\NK{QJWӗQ WҥLFӫDOêWKX\ӃW333[XҩWSKiWWӯQKLӅXQJX\rQ QKkQ ĈӕL YӟL7KiL /DQ PһF G OҥP SKiW FӫD TXӕFJLDQj\WKҩSKѫQQKLӅXVRYӟL9LӋW1DPYj FKӍEҵQJVRYӟLOҥPSKiWFӫD9LӋW1DPWURQJ VXӕWJLDLÿRҥQQJKLrQFӭXQKѭQJGR7KiL/DQ WKӵFKLӋQFKtQKViFKWӹJLiWӯFӕÿӏQKVDQJOLQK KRҥWWLӃQÿӃQWKҧQәLWӯVDXNKӫQJKRҧQJQăP

ÿmOjPJLiWUӏ7+%ÿLӅXFKӍQKOLQKKRҥW KѫQVRYӟLTXӕFJLDFyTXDQKӋWKѭѫQJPҥLĈӕL YӟL 0DOD\VLD Oj ÿӕL WiF WKѭѫQJ PҥL OӟQ WKӭ  VDX7KiL/DQYjOjTXӕFJLDNK{QJWӗQWҥL333

+uQK 3KkQEӕÿӝOӋFKUDNKӓLÿѭӡQJ

QJDQJJLiVӭFPXD333

Bahmani2VNRRHHDQG5DWKD7KH%LODWHUDO-&XUYH6ZHGHQYHUVXVKHU0DMRU Trading Partners ,QWHUQDWLRQDO-RXUQDORI$SSOLHG(FRQRPLF

%DXP&)%DUNRXODV-7&DJOD\DQ01RQOLQHDUDGMXVWPHQWWRSXUFKDVLQJSRZHU

SDULW\LQWKHSRVW%UHWWRQ:RRGVHUD-RXUQDO,QWHUQDWLRQDO0RQH\DQG)LQDQFH±

%ROOHUVOHY7*HQHUDOL]HG$XWRUHJUHVVLYH&RQGLWLRQDO+HWHURVNHGDVWLFLW\-RXUQDO

RI(FRQRPHWULF

&DUYDOKR & 1HFKLR ) $JJUHJDWLRQ DQG WKH 333 SX]]OH LQ D VWLFN\SULFH PRGHO

$PHULFDQ(FRQRPLF5HYLHZ±

&KHQ:$QDO\]LQJPXOWLSOHQRQOLQHDUWLPHVHULHVZLWKH[WHQGHG*UDQJHUFDXVDOLW\

3K\VLFV/HWWHUV$±

*LUDLWLV/.DSHWDQLRV*<DWHV7,QIHUHQFHRQVWRFKDVWLFWLPHYDU\LQJFRHI¿FLHQW

models.-RXUQDORI(FRQRPHWULFV±

&KRQJ< -RUGi Ï7D\ORU$0 7KH +DUURG±%DODVVD±6DPXHOVRQ K\SRWKHVLV UHDO

H[FKDQJHUDWHVDQGWKHLUORQJUXQHTXLOLEULXP,QWHUQDWLRQDO(FRQRPLF5HYLHZ±

(QJOH5$XWRUHJUHVVLYH&RQGLWLRQDO+HWHURVFHGDVWLFLW\ZLWK(VWLPDWHVRI9DULDQFH

RI8QLWHG.LQJGRP,QÀDWLRQ(FRQRPHWULFD

*DR -  1RQOLQHDU 7LPH 6HULHV 6HPLSDUDPHWULF DQG 1RQSDUDPHWULF 0HWK

RGV/RQGRQ&KDSPDQDQG+DOO&5&

*UDQJHU&:-6WUDWHJLHVIRU0RGHOOLQJ1RQOLQHDU7LPH6HULHV5HODWLRQVKLSV(FR

QRPLF5HFRUG

+DQQDQ(-7KHDV\PSWRWLFWKHRU\RIOLQHDUWLPHVHULHVPRGHOV-RXUQDORI$SSOLH

3UREDELOLW\

+HFNVFKHU ()  9l[HONXUVHQV JUXQGYDO YLG SDSSHUVP\QWIRW(NRQRPLVN 7LGVNULIW

±

+RQJ6+3KLOOLSV3&%7HVWLQJOLQHDULW\LQFRLQWHJUDWLQJUHODWLRQVZLWKDQDSSOLFD-tion to purchasing power parity.-RXUQDORI%XVLQHVV(FRQRPLF6WDWLVWLFV±

/L H./LQ Z.Yj+VLDR C.,  Testing purchasing power parity hypothesis: a

semipara-PHWULFYDU\LQJFRHI¿FLHQWDSSURDFK(PSLULFDO(FRQRPLFV

0LFKDHO:0(GHU36DQG'UH\IXVV*7KH.QXFOHDUVKXWWOLQJGRPDLQ$QRY-HOVLJQDOIRUQXFOHDULPSRUWDQGQXFOHDUH[SRUWLQWKHKQ513.SURWHLQ(0%2-±

YӟL9LӋW1DPWURQJJLDLÿRҥQQJKLrQFӭXOjGR

FKrQKOӋFKOҥPSKiW9LӋW1DPYj0DOD\VLDNKi

FDRPӭFWUXQJEuQKWUrQWѭѫQJWӵQKѭ7KiL

/DQQKѭQJFKtQKViFKWӹJLiFӫD0DOD\VLDNKi

FӭQJQKҳFQHRFӕÿӏQKYjR86'WURQJWKӡLJLDQ

GjLÿӃQQăPEҳWÿҫXÿLӅXFKӍQKOLQKKRҥW

KѫQ1KѭYұ\NKL[iFÿӏQKWӹJLiFKpR0<5

91' WKu ÿѭѫQJ QKLrQ 0<5 OrQ JLi VR YӟL 91'/ҥPSKiW9LӋW1DPFDRKѫQ0DOD\VLDOӁ UD91'SKҧLJLҧPJLiQKѭQJNKL0<5JLҧPJLi VkXKѫQVRYӟL86'WKu91'OҥLWLӃSWөFOrQJLi Yjÿk\OjQJX\rQQKkQFKӫ\ӃXJLҧLWKtFKFKRVӵ NK{QJWӗQWҥL333JLӳD9LӋW1DPYj0DOD\VLD YӟLÿӝOӋFKUDNKӓLÿѭӡQJ333Oj

differences across US cities -RXUQDORI,QWHUQDWLRQDO(FRQRPLFV±

3HVDUDQ0+6PLWK5RQ3<DPDJDWD7DQG+YR]G\N/3DLUZLVHWHVWVRISXU-chasing power parity, (FRQRPHWULF5HYLHZVSS,661

6XQ < /L 4 'DWDGULYHQ EDQGZLGWK VHOHFWLRQ IRU QRQVWDWLRQDU\ VHPLSDUDPHWULF

models.-RXUQDORI%XVLQHVVDQG(FRQRPLFV6WDWLVWLFV±

7D\ORU037KH(FRQRPLFVRI([FKDQJH5DWHV-RXUQDORI(FRQRPLF/LWHUDWXUH, 33:



7D\ORU033HHO'$6DUQR/1RQOLQHDUPHDQUHYHUVLRQLQUHDOH[FKDQJHUDWHVWR-ward a solution to the purchasing power parity puzzles ,QWHUQDWLRQDO(FRQRPLF5HYLHZ±



7D\ORU$0$&HQWXU\RI3XUFKDVLQJ3RZHU3DULW\7KH5HYLHZRI(FRQRPLFVDQG

6WDWLVWLFV

7RQJ+1RQOLQHDU7LPH6HULHV$'\QDPLFDO6\VWHP$SSURDFK2[IRUG2[IRUG

University Press

;LDR =  )XQFWLRQDOFRHI¿FLHQW FRLQWHJUDWLQJ UHJUHVVLRQ -RXUQDO RI (FRQRPLFV

±

¿QGLQJVDOVRUHYHDODQLPSRUWDQWSRLQWFRQWULEXWLQJWRWKH333WKHRU\WKDWH[LVWVRUGRHVQRWH[LVW PPP is not only rigidly considering the deviation of one point compared to the PPP curve but there is usually a deviation in a certain range of PPP lines to account for