Luận án tiến sĩ Kinh tế: Nghiên cứu ảnh hưởng của quản trị công ty tới giá phí kiểm toán báo cáo tài chính của các doanh nghiệp niêm yết tại Việt Nam

Luận văn Nghiên cứu ảnh hưởng của quản trị công ty tới giá phí kiểm toán báo cáo tài chính của các doanh nghiệp niêm yết tại Việt Nam được nghiên cứu với mục tiêu nhằm mục đích kiểm định mối quan hệ giữa quản trị công ty và giá trị kiểm toán báo cáo tài chính.

2

2 7 32

!"2 #32 7 32

2 2 2 2

34"2 9$2 %2 &32 9'#2 2

%2 9)32 3452 ,-2 4./2 2

0562 9562 9-2 9'#2 9592 76#2 340,2

4"/2 #/ 2

2 2

2

2 2

!12 52 232 32 2

4

2

2

2

2

2

2 142 5 6789:

 2

2

2

!2 " 2 !2 "32 7#3 2 32 7#32 2

2 2 2 2

34!2 9$2 %2 &32 9'"2 2

%2 9)32 3452 ,-2 4./2 2

0562 9562 9-2 9'"2 9592 76"2 340,2

4!/2 "/ 2

9123452 567518 2 92 : ;<5= 2 > ?@2 : ;<52 A72 ,1B52 : D12

/E2 FG8 2 HIJKIKL2

2 2 2

M2 52 NO2 2

PQRST U VRWXQU YZXU [V\]U V^_` U U

,3Na 2 623b52 2 ,1de562 ;f2

2 2 2 2

2

2

2 142 g hKLHi

6

000020000202000"00#"00$ % 0

&0'( 0)*"0+&0+00,0!*"00"2-0.0/0+#020002000'"020

0/-01000"00#"00$ %

0

23456789:3;444=>9:4449?@4ABCD4

6 6 EFGHI6JKL6MGIF6

6 6 3H6NLOIE6PQIE6 6

6

6

00  0!"0#$0%&02

(0)0*0+,0

-%./001020220(0032052067080!09$0:2702 0<2;0=0>0 0@10<2;0A00A2700%.50=>20@0A200 >0!2

2;0 4F20!020004 0,0

-20220320452 -?, 0H.80L$0.520

./0DM0$0@0#$04 10!E00N02 020 $0)'0P20 020

+0)0 .80  02 >0!P040R002 02000

4 0,0

0T1020220(00320452067080!02$0!U10N0.520

!+0!V0 #0P10!P0)2002$0W00X0)/2020%0 05202$0@0 0 )0200 0

-20220(006708Y0

7896 61

7896536 1

3456745661

3456696661

3456 1

3456 1

69 969!"6 5$"61

1%&6'()6*+,*6'-.6)/+0)6'1261

3134'6*026)/+0)6'12651

67876719:;0<=>0<?@A0B>C<07777777777777777777777777777777771

67878719:;0<=>0;:0<EF77777777777777777777777777777777777701

515G26+H6)/+0)6'1261

I1J6KL)/6M6N+OP66)/+0)6'12651

67Q7671RS20TU@A0@AE2=@0;V>0777777777777777777777777777777771

67Q7871WEXY0Z20@AE2=@0;V>0777777777777777777777777777777777Q1

[1\+K])/6N+^N6)/+0)6'12661

_13`6+a)+6)/+0)6'126M6'^'6/b6*+2c,*_1

d1eP6*f*6g,*6h2b6)/+0)6'1261

i1j,*6'k26'-.6l2m)6^)61

36 p656%q67r6"s6t1

31u)/6h2.)6v6h2b)6*wx6'`)/6*c661

8767671yC;0zEC20@2{Y0Z|0B>}@0<;€@A0<0777777777777777777777777661

8767871yC;0Y€0E‚@E0B>}@0<;€@A0<0<=@0<Eƒ0A2„207777777777777777777681

8767D71yC;0…†0<E>ƒ<0Z|0B>}@0<~0;€@A0<0Z‡0<Eˆ@A0‰Š0B>}@0<~0;€@A0<07777777861

331u)/6h2.)6v6/^6N+‹6gŒP6*^)663I1

8787671R@E0@AEŽˆ0Z|0A2C0E0z2FY0<ŠC@0Z‡0<Eˆ@A0‰Š07777777777777777778Q1

8787871‘†0<E>ƒ<0Z|0A2C0E0z2FY0<ŠC@0777777777777777777777777778Q1

351u)/6h2.)6v6PJ60)6+’6/“.6h2b)6*wx6'`)/6*c6M6/^6N+‹6gŒP6*^)63d1

87D76719S20B>ˆ@0E{0A2”ˆ0B>}@0<~0;€@A0<0Z‡0A2C0E0z2FY0<ŠC@0…‡0YS20B>ˆ@0E{0

@ATU;0;E2|>707777777777777777777777777777777777777778•1

87D78719S20B>ˆ@0E{0A2”ˆ0B>}@0<;€@A0<0Z‡0A2C0E0z2FY0<ŠC@0…‡0YS20B>ˆ@0E{0<E>–@0

;E2|>7077777777777777777777777777777777777777777708—1

87D7D71˜EŠ}@A0<S@A0@AE2=@0;V>077777777777777777777777777770D™1

45651  999998999 9 !"9#9

$%&%955555555555555555555555555555555555555555559'41

45(51%99 9 *9+955555555555555555555555555555''1

%,-./09'192,-./092,329/0,45/9%67955555555555555555559'81

'5951  :95555555555555555555555555555555555559'81

'5451 <=9 9 *9+95555555555555555555555555555'>1

'5'51    955555555555555555555555556A1

BCBCDC1EFGHIJ0KFLK0MFN0MFOK0MFPIJ0MI0MFQ0RSK0CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCTU1

BCBCUC1EFGHIJ0KFLK0MFN0MFOK0MFPIJ0MI0VH0RSK0CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0TU1

'5651  WX9<Y9 <?Z955555555555555555596[1

'5(517\9 *9+99<:995555555555555555555555555559(91

BC]CDC1^_IJ0MF`0IJF2aI0RQN0CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC]D1

BC]CUC1bFcI0deN0IJF2aI0RQN0CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0]D1

%,-./096192,f/9&g%,9&,h%9&ij/097k49l7m/9,n904om9l7p/9&iq9

%r/09&s9tu904392,g9;4v79&w3/9$3w9%3w9&u49%,g/,9%xm9%3%9 ywm/,9/0,4n29/4579sz&9&j49t4n&9/m759555555555555555555(41

65951   |999899|99 *"9)9555(41

TCDCDC1b_0}PIJ03~0}20F€20}IJ0R_0}PIJC0CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0]U1

TCDCUC1‚€20}IJ0ƒN„I0M†CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC]B1

TCDCBC1‡ˆI0‰2`d0VŠLM0CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0]]1

65451 |99 9 !"9#9$%&%999899 *"9)9555555555555555555555555555555555555555559(81

TCUCDC1ŒN0MŽIF0LR0}†IF0J2L0KF0‰2`d0MŠLI0‘LŠ0RLŠ0M~20RFIF0CCCCCCCCCCCC0]’1

TCUCUC1“”0‰FLR0‘2•M0…ŠIJ032•R03OI0–—IJ0ƒN0MŽIF0MIF0KF0CCCCCCCCCCCCCC]˜1

65'51  "™99 X999899š›99 9 !"9#9$%&%9|9 tY9/"95555555555555555555555555555555555555555558'1

TCBCDC1EFœI0MRF0}†IF0MIF0CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0’B1

TCBCUC1EFœI0MRF0}†IF0GžIJ0CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0’Ÿ1

%,-./09(19/, /9¡¢&9tu9;,7sz/9/0,q955555555555555555559>'1

(5951 ‹£9555555555555555555555555555555555555559>'1

]CDCDC1¤LIF0J2L0dP0FŽIF0ƒN„I0M†RPIJ0M0M20RLR0–ŠˆIF0IJF2•K0I2ad0¥M0CCCCC0˜B1

]CDCUC1¦FOI0§M03¨0MF”R0MIJ0œ0–”IJ0J2L0KF0‰2`d0MŠLI0M20©2•M0¦ˆd0CCCCCC0˜T1

]CDCBC1¦FOI0§M03¨0dª20ƒNˆI0F•0J2«ˆ0ƒN„I0M†RPIJ0M03~0J2L0KF0‰2`d0MŠLI0CCCCC˜]1

(5451 95555555555555555555555555555555555559>[1

]CUCDC1¤ª203¬20RH0ƒNˆI0IF~0IG¬R0CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0˜Ÿ1

]CUCUC1¤ª203¬20‚€20‰2`d0MŠLI032aI0F~IF0IJF¨0©­bE­0CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0˜˜1

34546417890 0 0 090044444444444444444444444441

3454417890 0 00909004444444444444444444441

3454341 !00"090#$02%0 90#$00'0444444444451

()*+,-./+00000000000000000000000000000000000000001231

45/6+789+9:/;+*<=/6+/;6>?/+9@-+(6A5+6B9++9C5+*D9+;>E+9F+ ,>?/+G-5/+H)/+4I+*J>+,-./+D/+00000000000000000000000012K1

45/6+789+*J>+,>L-+*657+(6EA00000000000000000000000012M1

N68+,89+0000000000000000000000000000000000000000011O+ NPQ+RQS+1T+NPUVW+XPYZ+[\]+XU^_+]Z\`+aUb`+000000000000000000000011O1

NPQ+RQS+OT+NPUVW+XPYZ+[\]+cZd`P+`ePUfg+0000000000000000000000011h1

+

45678 88

0 00300

0 0 !0"#$0&'(0)0

*++,0 *-0(3./03010)20

340 30/0536100

0 30&(3-07(0

89:0 8;30<=(0"#$0&

4>0

:0

4361002300 :#$0&'(0)0

9?@A0 B(0(310<!0

40 &0%CD(0E(050

>F3F0 8;3043610023000(G0>3.0+-10

00000 !0"0#1

000$0%&0 ' 0(3)0*3+,0-'00.1

0#0!002/0&010&'&002&0!00341

0#05' 0(3)0 60,!070380 9003:1

03000&;0*3+,0'0550<:1

030$0%&0 !0"038,0")0=0>,0/0.?1

03#0@0*80,!00 ' 0 A0800?41

0330B02001003C0 ' 0(3)00,!070?#1

03<0D3+,000 E0")0?<1

03.0D)00,!070FGH0330I0440J040?:1

03?0D)00,!070FGH0330I04#0J04.0:<1

8

0

45678 7678

00003001

00003001

000 03000!1

00"0#$0%&03000'1

0(0)%00*+0,-03+0./0031203+04+30+30530/0061

0(07800900020:00;1

8 8 8

34567899 497847939

9999 !9"#9

$%&'0()*+)0,-.0/*0.)0(012+0+3*+)04%250(60+078'0,-.03%9058(0/:%01;01<(0=>:+0 (?+30(6+30+@+04%+)0(A0()B01CD+30/*07E'0F%&(0'G+0()%A(0')60+)9+30=>H'03%:07:+30.)0(0 (%2+0(6+30FH%0'I+)0)8%0+)-.0=>H'0(AJ0K)L+30()20.)M0+)-+01N+30.)O04%250(60+0,*058(0 (6+30+)9+30+3>P+0,Q'0=>:+0(?+30+)<(07R+303R.0/*60SQ0(P+0(T%0/*0.)0(012+0'M:0'0'0 UL+30(V04%250(60+078'0,-.J0W)O04%250(60+07CX'0Y0'07B+)0Z05['0780)X.0,\03%].04%250 (60+0/%^+0_K`$a0/*0'L+30(V04%250(60+0()Q'0)%&+04%250(60+0'R0')<(0CX+3J0`>V0+)%^+b0 )%&+0+:V0'L+30(V04%250(60+0Z0$%&(0c:50'R0Y>0)Cd+30'T+)0(:+)03%00.)Ob(e07R0(T601:0 I+)0)CZ+30(^>0'Q'07A+0')<(0CX+304%250(60+J0U0'0/f0/%&'0+g%0'8507H%0/d%0'0'0h6:+)0 +3)%&.0+%^50VA(0iccja0/*058(0/*%07k+0/B04%250(60+0()D%03%:+0=>:07CX'07l+30(I%01^+0 '0'0.)Ck+30(&+0()L+30(+07T%0')]+3b07%2+0)m+)0,*0'0'0'>8'04%250(60+0iCX'0$%n+0oL+3b0 3p0`1CD+30`)*+)b0')60()<V0'G+0.)I%0'R0)*+)078+30(e0'0'0F^+0,^+0=>:+0720'R0+)9+30 ':+0()%&.04B.0()D%b3%].0()B01CD+304%250(60+0.)0(012+0F@+0/9+3q0)Q'0SQ0,*0+k%01:60 3r%0+%@50(+0'M:0'0'07H%0CX+30Sr0hf+30(Q'0(A.0/*03%0+0(A.0hB')0/f0+*VJ0`)Q'0(A0')60 ()<V0'0'0'k0=>:+0')['0+l+30+)C0s80`*%0')O+)b0tV0F:+0U)[+304)60+b0u8%04%250(60+0 /%^+0)*+)0+3)@07v0+)%@>0+l50=>:+0(w50/*0()I60,>-+0+)C+30/<+07@0Y0'07B+)03%00.)O0 4%250(60+0/*0'0'0+)w+0(H0I+)0)CZ+30/x+0';+0')C:07CX'03%I%0=>VA(J

y>I+0(B'L+30(V07CX'0'6%0*0+)w+0(H0I+)0)CZ+30,d+07A+0+8%0h>+3b0)D%03%:+0/*0 3%00.)O04%250(60+J0o%@>0+*V07v07CX'04)z+307B+)0Z0+)%@>0+3)%^+0'[>0(1Cd'07wV0 _{%|S')>(}0/*0'8+30SQ0_~2aq€:):F0/*0'8+30SQ0_~22aq€>0_~2~aqu>S+%+0/*0'8+30 SQ0_~2aJ`>V0+)%^+b0h60(+)0.)['0(T.0'M:0=>I+0(B'L+30(V0hx+07A+0'0')0()['070+)03%00 'M:0'0'0'L+30(V04%250(60+0720Y0'07B+)03%00.)O0';+0Sk0,CX'0/*0')C:0()H+30+)<(0T%0$%&(0 c:5J0$m0/-V0/%&'04%2507B+)05H%0=>:+0)&03%9:0=>I+0(B'L+30(V0/*03%00.)O04%250(60+0 sU`U0()L+30=>:0/%&'0.)w+0(')0h90,&>0'M:0'0'0h6:+)0+3)%&.0+%^50VA(0T%0$%&(0c:50,*0

1<(0'G+0()%A(J

`)B01CD+30')[+304)60+0_``UKa0$%&(0c:50(6+30+)9+30+l503G+07wV07v0'R0SQ0 F%A+07g%05T+)05‚0'I0/@0SH0,CX+30/*0')<(0CX+3J0`)ƒ60tV0F:+0U)[+304)60+0c)*0+Cd'0 _~2„ab0=>V05L0()B0(1CD+30'g0.)%A>0+l50~2…0')%A50††‡0ˆiWb0+l50~2‰0,*0‰†‡0

ˆiWJ0o20'R07CX'0SQ0.)0(012+0F@+0/9+30'M:0``UKb05%+)0FT')0)R:0()L+30(+0(*%0')O+)0 'M:0'0'0iccj07:+30,*0V^>0'G>0'<>0F0')J0o203R.0.)G+07I50FI60(+)0(>+30()Q'b0)X.0 ,\0/*0)X.0.)0.0'M:0()L+30(+07CX'0'L+30FH0FZ%0'0'0iccj0(^+0``UKb0tV0F:+0U)[+30 4)60+0c)*0+Cd'0$%&(0c:50V^>0'G>0'0'0iccj0(1^+0``UK0$%&(0c:50.)I%0FŠ(0F>8'0

3450673809 09030038430093030380403000930

030 38!000940"30#70$73038%03 05&906'(0)*0$+380380,0 -.003406/09'093800,0!190'(38009300$060/306'(0620-20 03070609050%04206/09'0530#700,0!503 360%303750673800

90)5000930600930 304073809500930'704309430 6033806'(05 0/603806(0#7038'80)*0$+3809738093090190'(380093!0 :90380)50385 303;30$<306&309309 345040)30>09080"0093!00

738095009300190'(380$?0+0738095906738040"00930@080190

9106006'(004386038000738095006?30'@3809030$40 0

9A0938040%03;38070190'(380093008B01903900C309038D30

0609&09+0$509=6?30'@380$0738006#0'(3800438!0E08F0 4730 4230G607380950093040HIIJ00)906'(0190'(38009360%0 38 30309080"00930#700HIIJ040190/309&9!

KA30306'(090%30943073808F0-L0)380404309%30 ).0G0A3090 4230907380956080"0093040504730%08M7042309073809504080"0

093!0KA3030N3808F0$73038%00930006?306F38080"6-20620 190'(380093093800<30$509=6'(0930 973!0 30 6600 47304230G0070N3800 ).0604230G080"0093060-206200 )9040$5090190'(38009360603380390930#700,0!0+09O0KA3030 8F0 4730303C3803'0040"360P50-7303380360Q00930 30

4303890920806'(090)50;0R04230GO0

STK409&0340600738095009303R07380080"00930

040230'.3809@0190'(380093040=30230380#703890

093U0

STI 3075073803 305 0/00$73038%009302073807080

"00930#709V3800438U0

07380950093060A0N380090920806'(00;0R04230G0 3'04O0

STK409&034060-&906'(080"009300;50$38009V38004380 0W0(0738U0

STK409&03406095&90+004380X38080"00930040W0

(UY

03'0A5600$73038%09 00930N380090920806'(0 0;0RO