As a result, the research of higher education branding, in particular the relationship between brand image and brand identity becomes increasingly necessary.. In particular, the higher e
Trang 11
PREAMBLE
a Reasons for choosing the topic
Brand identity are created by businesses, while brand image is perceived by
customers A brand is only strong when the brand identity approach or even coincide
with the brand image In practice, however, there is always a gap between the brand
identity and brand image Therefore, the important task of brand managers is to
prioritize identification and measurement, so that measures can be taken to narrow
such gap
Despite the increasing importance, specific empirical research related to
branding in higher education is relatively scarce As a result, the research of higher
education branding, in particular the relationship between brand image and brand
identity becomes increasingly necessary
With a transition economy like Vietnam, the issue of branding in general and
branding for universities in particular has only been mentioned in recent years
Therefore, studying the relationship between brand identity and brand image,
especially measuring the gap between them in the context of higher education, is
essential
b Purposes of study
The general purpose is to study the relationship between brand identity and
brand image of universities The study will answer the question of whether brand
identity really affect brand image, or whether there is a gap between them, and for
each different audience, whether such gap is different
The study focuses on a typical case, the National Economics University
c Object and scope of study
Object of study: The object of study of the thesis is the relationship between
brand identity and brand image
2
Scope of study: The study is carried out in the field of higher education, of
which typical research is conducted at the National Economics University Data for the study base were gathered in the period from 2013 – 2017 The survey was conducted from July 15th, 2017 to October 10th, 2017
d New contributions of the thesis
The thesis systematically re-rebuilds typical models of brand identity and outlines limitations of such models
Several previous studies, when determining the gap between brand identity and brand image, often rely on qualitative research, while this study uses quantitative methods to quantify those factors
The previous studies, when examining this relationship, paid little attention to the two perspectives of enterprise and customer to study; or if so, they are primarily qualitative studies In this thesis, the author uses the technique of combining two independent samples (lecturers' and students' samples are designed to have similar scales of measurement) into a single sample, using classification variables to differentiate the observations of lecturers’ sample against those of students’ Quantitative methods, namely SEM model, are also used to quantify concept variables (latent variables) and examine the research hypotheses of the thesis
On the other hand, Kapferer's brand identity prism model, rarely applied in the service industry but in this study, shows that if there is a reasonable adjustment, this model is fully applicable in the service industry, particularly in higher education
In particular, the higher education sector in Vietnam has a diversity of subjects and forms of training, so with the study of the perception of different learners on the brand of the University of Economics Nationally, the thesis has helped administrators
to come up with solutions to suit each of them
Trang 23
e Structure of the thesis
The thesis consists of four chapters which are structured as follows:
Chapter 1: Theoretical basis of and research overview
Chapter 2: Research methods
Chapter 3: Research results
Chapter 4: Conclusion and implication of administration
CHAPTER 1
THEORETICAL BASIS AND RESEARCH OVERVIEW
1.1 Theoretical basis
1.1.1 Brand
In recent years, the term "brand" has become popular In Vietnam, although
mentioned a lot, many people still do not have a correct and comprehensive view of
this issue Most of these concepts still come from the perspective of product brands
When researching service brands, due to the intangible nature of the services, the
category of organizational brand is very important The organizational brand will
help enterprises provide a clear image, and personalize the values of such
organizations (De Chernatony&McDonald, 2005)
In this study, the brand term is associated with the category of organizational
brand
1.1.2 Brand identity
Brand identity originating from the company itself are important factors to
distinguish such company from its competitors Several researchers identify brand
identity as an emotional structure and originating from brand managers
4
Brand identity may be influenced by different notions (Balmer and Thompson, 2009) The importance of brand identity is also mentioned by many researchers However, the environment is increasingly dynamic and the market often happens with sudden changes and unpredictable developments Such challenges open
a new perspective on concepts related to brand identity Popularly, there are two perspectives on brand identity coexisting: (1) static, fixed, and unchanged over time, independent of the environmental context, and (2) dynamic, where the core value maintains consistent over time, but a part may be adjusted to suit the changing environment
This study of the author also agrees that "brand identity" need to be dynamic Thus, in addition to the core identity, enterprises may add new identity to match the fluctuations in market demand Such view will help the brand grow in a volatile market and environment, while retaining its core identity to maintain brand stability
In 1986, Kapferer first mentioned the concept of "brand identity" and since then there have been many discussions about its definition and models (Janonis et al., 2007) The thesis systematizes a number of typical models of brand identity and points out the basic limitations of these models as follows:
Limitation 1: Most models have not been tested empirically, leading to difficulties in checking the actual meaning of the factors that constitute these models Limitation 2: There is very little research focused on measuring brand identity Limitation 3: Current models of brand identity mostly come from a commodity point of view, leaving room for application in service context
Limitation 4: Researching brand identity depends very much on the views of managers, while there are few studies standing on the perspective of consumers
1.1.3 Brand image
If brand identity are considered as a message originating from the enterprise,
Trang 35
brand image is considered as a reflection of consumer awareness The concept of
brand image has evolved over time Brand image can be defined as links that brands
suggest in the minds of consumers (Keller, 1993) Therefore, customer behavior will
be affected and determined by brand image (Burmann et al., 2008)
Some studies have shown that brand image can be considered from two
perspectives The first is that brand image associated with the image of a company or
store is related to the quality and attributes of the organization The second identifies
that brand image can also be defined as related to people in the organization
In this study, the author also analyzes brand image from the perspective as
"Brand image is the subjective feeling of customers on the brand" (De Chernatony
and McDonald, 2003); Keller, 2008 and Reizebos, 2003)
1.2 Overview and gap in research on the relationship between brand
identity and brand image
1.2.1 Overview of research on the relationship between brand identity and
brand image
The study has made several judgments on the relationship between brand
identity and brand image by some authors, such as Davies (2002), Nandan, (2005),
Vytautas et al (2007); and re-enumerate the perspectives that previous studies have
addressed the relationship between brand identity and brand image
The thesis also mentions the study by Roy and Banerjee (2014) The authors
analyzed Kapferer's brand identity lens (2008) and proposed a method to narrow
down the gap between brand identity and brand image To create the minimum gap
between brand identity and brand image, integration must be done in Kapferer lens,
between six aspects, from sender and receiver
1.2.2 Research on the relationship between brand identity and brand image
in universities
6
Building and maintaining a strong brand is a challenge in all areas, and higher education is no exception
For a training institution like a university, the brand is conceived as a brand of
an organization Customers of higher education include many subjects, however, due
to limited resources, this study focuses only on students and alumni of different training systems
Currently, very few studies focus on studying the relationship between brand identity and brand image in universities In particular, the criteria for determining brand identity and brand image of universities have not been mentioned and tested in many ways in Vietnam
1.2.3 Identity of higher education services in Vietnam
So far, we almost still have not conceived that higher education is a kind of goods and services, so most of the higher education institutions are not interested in building and developing their brands
A higher education platform is no longer solely for a "quintessential" part but has become a mass one With such a change, learners have more ways to get a college degree, such as regular training, in-service training, and even distance learning
1.2.4 Introducing the research context
Introduction to National Economics University
On January 25th, 1956, the Prime Minister issued Decree No.678/TTg on theestablishment of the Central Financial and Economic School (now the National Economics University) Over 60 years of existence and development, the University has gained many proud achievements
As of September 2017, the National Economics University has 811 organic lecturers, including 16 professors, 130 associate professors, 198 doctors, 445 masters, and 22 lecturers with university degrees The University currently has 89 visiting
Trang 47
lecturers
It can be affirmed that the University is one of the leading units on the
implementation of measures to improve the quality of training and organization of
testing and evaluation of training quality
Reasons for choosing National Economics University as a subject of
study
Many public universities in Vietnam still have the concept of "natural scent of
incense", without much attention to brand issues Therefore, the selection of the
National Economics University, a public university, with more than 60 years
existence as typical a subject of study is perfectly reasonable in this situation
When the Government introduced regulations on autonomy of public service
units, many universities were no longer supported with tuition fees The loss of
tuition advantages has forced them to pay more attention to the branding work The
National Economics University is one of the first public universities to implement
such autonomy regime
Scale: The National Economics University is fully qualified for research
Along with that, the University has a full range of training forms from graduate to
post-graduate, so it will be suitable in helping to assess the diverse views of different
subjects on brand issues
1.2.3.3 Proposal of research model
To be able to provide a suitable research model to measure the gap between
brand identity and brand image, the author derives the thesis from the model of
defining brand identity
To discuss a possible gap in the thesis and how to shorten such gap, thereby,
strengthening the relationship between brand identity and brand image, Kapferer's
theory on band lens (2008) will be applied
8
Based on the theoretical framework and conceptual model derived from Kapferer's brand identity lens, along with the proposal of B.Hosseini et al., the author introduces the conceptual model of this study
In this model, on the left, the brand identity are sent by the organization and consist of six dimensions: physique, personality, culture, relationship, reflection, and self-image On the right is brand image which is perceived by and imprinted in the minds of customers Any difference between brand identity and image will be considered as the information gap (the gap between brand identity and brand image), and that is the same concept that forms the theoretical basis for the study
Figure 1.12: Model of researching the gap between brand identity
and brand image
Source: Author's synthesis
Based on the model, the following hypotheses are given:
H1: There exists a significant gap between brand identity and brand image of
Physique
BRRAND IDENTITY Relationship
Character
Self-image Reflection
Culture
Gap
Character
BRAND IMAGE
Self-image
Physique
Relationship
Reflection
Culture
ORGANIZATION
CUSTOMER
Trang 59
the National Economics University
H2: The feeling of staff and lecturers of the National Economics University
culture will affect their perception of other factors that make up the brand identity of
the University
H3: The perception of students and learners of the National Economics
University will affect their perception of other factors that make up the brand image
of the University
Conclusion of Chapter 1
Chapter 1 presents a theoretical overview of the relationship between brand
identity and brand image, development process, and the results of researchers'
contributions to this relationship On that basis, a gap in researching the relationship
in the field of higher education has been discovered and research hypotheses as well
as theoretical models have been formed to measure the gap between brand identity
and brand image
CHAPTER 2
RESEARCH METHODS
2.1 Process of building and processing questionnaires and scales
This section introduces the process of developing and processing
questionnaires and the scales in use and research sample
Research sample: For the University's lecturers, the study is directed to an
expanded group of key officials and lecturers (those who have doctoral and higher
degrees and those who hold management position) For alumni, students and learners,
the study is directed to alumni and current students at the University (regular training,
in-service training, or transitional training, etc), post graduate students, and doctorate
researchers The sample size used for key officials and lecturers is 350, of which 191
notes of questionnaires have been collected, accounting for 54.6% of the expected
10
number The sample size for alumni and students is 900, of which 799 notes of questionnaires have been collected, accounting for 88.8%
2.2 Methods of data collection and analysis 2.2.1 Methods of data collection
- Secondary information is collected from theses, articles, books, textbooks, etc related to brand identity and brand image
- Primary information is collected via in-depth interviews or surveys through questionnaires for multi-dimensional information and different perspectives and views of each individual on brand identity and brand image of the National Economics University
2.2.2 Methods of data analysis
After using the descriptive statistical method to get an initial look at the variables, the thesis uses EFA verification to remove variables that are not sufficiently discriminatory and then applies Cronbach Alpha to verify conformity for scales The thesis also explains how to combine two independent samples into a single one to have a data base to analyze observed variables and statistical relationships and define concept variables, thereby to provide a way to examine whether there is a gap between brand identity and brand image
The thesis uses SEM model with AMOS software to identify conceptual variables of level 1 and level 2 with tests on the suitability of the model and Bootstrap test for the analysis model On that basis, it is used to verify differences between target groups (lecturers and students) as well as using regression models on SEM to answer the research questions
Conclusion of Chapter 2
Chapter 2 has presented research methods including steps: Research design; process of building and processing questionnaires and scales; introduction of research
Trang 611
sample; and methods of analysis and research In particular, as the thesis research two
different samples, the author has used the technique of two independent samples
(lecturers and students' samples which are designed with similar scales) into a single
sample, using categorical variables to distinguish which observations belong to the
lecturers’ and students’ samples; and using SEM model to quantify concept variables
(latent variables) and test the hypotheses of the thesis
CHAPTER 3
RESEARCH RESULTS
3.1 Description of research samples
The survey for official research was conducted from July 15th, 2017 to October
10th, 2017
• For alumni and student survey samples: With 799 respondents and a range
of score from 1 to 5, the assessment of alumni and students about the factors
that make up the brand image of the University ranged from 3.389 to 4.272
• For key staff and lecturer extended survey sample: With 191 respondents,
the assessment scores for components ranged from 3.450262 to 4.455497
3.2 Analysis results
3.2.1 Analysis of discovery factors
The results of exploratory factor analysis based on the combined data between
two groups of key officials and lecturers and students and learners showed that the
data used for factor analysis are perfectly appropriate
After that, the author used the factor rotation matrix and focused the
observations on the five representative factors A number of factors that were not
sufficiently discriminatory were also removed
• In factor F: Components F6, F7, F8, and F9 - the "invisible physique"
12
component were eliminated In this study, although these factors are reliable enough, they are not sufficiently differentiated from other components Therefore, these factors need to be considered in other contexts
• Two components P4 and SI6 were not retained This is also quite consistent with the analysis described above These two components have a low rating in both the target group and high standard deviation
3.2.2 Results of Cronbach’s alpha reliability analysis
In this study, to ensure good reliability, scales with Cronbach’s Alpha coefficient of 0.6 or higher were retained for use in subsequent analysis steps The results in this step show that the total correlation coefficients of the observed variables in the scales are greater than 0.4, and the scale used for variables studying factors F - "physiques", R - "relationship", RC - "reflection", SI - "self image", P - "personality" is reasonable All observed variables are accepted and will
be used in analysis of the next factor
3.2.3 Results of analysis and verification of research hypotheses
- The results of analysis of CFA scale for building brand identity and brand image show that a number of indicators reflect the relevance of the model,
however, GFI index = 0.881 <0.9 should be concluded CFA results from this model are not really good (See Appendix 1, for more details of the tests)
Therefore, the thesis uses MI index to improve the suitability of the model Then, SEM model is used to test the research hypotheses
- SEM model
To test the hypotheses: There exists a difference between brand identity and brand image The thesis will use the variable "phanbiet", a variable used to
Trang 713
distinguish brand identity and brand image The value of variable "phanbiet" is
defined at 1 for "brand image", or 0 for "brand identity."
The cultural identity defined at 1 for "traditional" and 0 for "modern" group
Figure 3.3: Standard SEM model results
Source: Author's research
Figure 3.3 results show that the model is consistent with the data collected
Specifically, a number of indicators are as follows: Chi-square = 11056,648 (p =
0,000); Chi-square/df = 3.37 <5; GFI, TLI and CFI are 0.923 respectively; 0.959 and
0.965 RMSEA = 0.049 <0.05
Combined with the table of non-standardized regression coefficients of the
theoretical model, the study has come to the conclusion as follows:
+ There exists a meaningful gap between brand identity and brand image
14
+ There are differences in brand identity and brand image between two traditional and modern cultural groups
- To assess the reliability of the estimates in the model, the thesis uses algorithm bootstrap algorithm with the number of repeated samples N = 1000 Since then, the study has come to the conclusion as follows:
+ There is a difference (or gap) of statistical significance and reliability between brand identity and brand image (coefficient -0.416 implies lower brand image than brand identity)
+ Index of brand identity and brand image in traditional cultural group is lower than that of modern culture group (coefficient -0.594)
In addition, the thesis also verifies the role of component factors to concept variables (latent variables) as brand identity and brand image, and has come to the conclusion as follows:
+ RC factor plays the biggest role in forming the concept of brand identity and brand image
+ Physiques (F) contribute to the potential variables of brand identity and brand image
+ Personality (P) contributes to a positive direction to potential variables of brand identity and brand image
+ Reflection (RC) contributes to the positive and the largest (because the standardized coefficient is 1.354) to the potential variables of brand identity and brand image
+ Self-image (SI) contributes to a positive direction to potential variables of brand identity and brand image
+ Relationship (R) contributes to a positive direction to potential variables of brand identity and brand image
Trang 815
After that, the thesis continues to use SEM model in multi-group structure
analysis: group of officials and lecturers (lecturer) and student groups (student)
In general, both models for the student group and the official and lecturer
group provide the acceptable values of GFI, TLI, CFI, and RMSEA, so these models
are quite suitable for analysis To better assess the reliability of the estimated
coefficients, the thesis uses Bootstrap testing method with the number of sampling
times of 1000
The results of the test below show that there are statistically significant
differences between the two groups of students and lecturers, in other words, there
are different impacts from variables to variables "brand" between student group and
lecturer group
Table 3.13: Differences between the two study samples
Parameter SE SE-SE Mean Bias SE-Bias
A - B 117 004 000 -.010 005
Source: Author's research
Analysis for the student group: The RC factor has the strongest contribution
to the "thuonghieu" variable (in this case, brand image), as this variable has the
highest standardized load factor (1.168)
The thesis also analyzes the average value according to the training system of
the student group, and draws the results: Between different education groups, the
perception of brand image is different The distance-learning group has the lowest
sense of brand image, so this is a group to which the University needs to pay special
attention The postgraduate group has the next low sense, while this is considered a
16
group with high education and social position, so the underestimation of this group of brand image is a sign that the University should take into consideration
Analysis of the lecturer group:
Auditing with Bootstrap, N = 1000, shows that most indicators CR> 1.96, so the estimates in the model for the lecturer group independently will be unreliable (see Appendix 7.2 for details) This can also be explained by the limited samples of this group
The following model will help to consider the gap between brand identity and brand image more intuitively
Figure 3.8: Gap between brand identity and brand image
Source: Author's research
As shown in Figure 3.8, in all the factors, the next range of noteworthy factor
is R - relationship, and this factor also has the lowest score in the group of distance-learning group, and graduate group
SI factor - self-image is a highly unifying factor between brand identity and
Trang 917
brand image
RC factor - reflection, as analyzed above, is the factor that has the greatest
impact on the relationship between brand identity and brand image
These analysis and syntheses will be an important basis, helping the University
to know what factors need to be considered to build a strong brand of the National
University
Conclusion of Chapter 3
Chapter 3 has produced the research results to prove the hypotheses given in
Chapter 2 Through determining the role of each factor in the formation of brand
identity and brand image, the thesis has shown that: Between brand identity and
brand image, there exists a significant gap, and cultural variable plays an important
role, affecting this gap The author also gives a visual model of the gap between
brand identity and brand image to help readers have a clear view of this gap, from
which, determine what factors to be taken into consideration to shorten the gap
between the brand identity and brand image of the National Economics University
CHAPTER 4
CONCLUSION AND IMPLICATION OF ADMINISTRATION
Chapter 4, to summarize the main results and draw conclusions from the study,
the content of Chapter 4 consists of three parts: (1) Summary of key results and
theoretical and methodological contributions and the meaning of research for
administrators and researchers; (2) Proposal of a number of solutions to shorten the
gap between brand identity and brand image of the National Economics University in
particular and higher education in Vietnam in general; and (3) Limitations and
directions for further research
4.1 Main results and contributions of the thesis
The research results are presented in two main parts: (1) Measurement model
18
and (2) theoretical model
4.1.1 Measurement model
The results of testing the measurement model for the gap between brand identity and brand image in the context of higher education in Vietnam, particularly
at the National Economics University show that, after adjusting, all scales gain reliability
The meaning of the above results
In terms of research methods, this study contributes to the specialization of the scale of characterization and brand image in higher education in a transitional economy of Vietnam
On the scale of the factors that make up brand identity and brand image, this study shows that these factors depend greatly on the identity of the sector Therefore, when setting the scales of these factors to apply to different sectors, in addition to referring to the existing scales, the use of qualitative research to build a specialized scale of the sector is extremely necessary
4.1.2 Theoretical model
The testing results show the relevance of the theoretical model with the collected data In addition, this study also shows that learners (training system) is one
of the factors that greatly affect customers' perception of brands of universities This
is something that brand strategy makers in higher education should pay attention to
4.1.2.1 Contributions to the concept of brand identity and brand image
In this study, the author uses the brand identity model of Kapferer, saying that brand identity are constituted by 6 factors: culture, physiques, self-image, reflection, relationship, and personality The theories of brand identity are the basis for a research model on the gap between brand identity and brand image
In the research results, it shows that RC factor - reflection (expressing social
Trang 1019
evaluation of students of the University) plays the biggest role in forming the concept
of brand identity and brand image
The research results also show that brand identity and brand image in higher
education in a transitional economy like that in Vietnam also include some basic
components as confirmed in the developed economies However, as shown above, the
basic components of brand identity should be rearranged to match the identity in
Vietnam In addition, when considering this issue in other contexts, particularly in the
service sector, more research on the "invisible physique" component is needed
4.1.2.2 Contributions to research methods
This research opens up a suggestion when considering relationships -
specifically measuring the gap between brand identity and brand image The previous
studies, when examining this relationship, paid little attention to the two perspectives
of enterprise and customer to study; or if so, they are primarily qualitative studies
4.2 Implications of administration for the University administrators
This thesis has affirmed the role of culture variable to brand identity and brand
image, and culture in a modern way will help develop the brand stand out from the
organizations with traditional culture
The thesis also specifies the role of other components, including: "Reflection",
"Physiques", "Relationship", "Self-image", and "Personality" to the brand of The
National Economics University, and suggest a number of solutions to help shorten the
gap between brand identity and brand image of the University
The impact of the training system on the perception of brand image is also
mentioned in this thesis, and the author has suggested points to which the University
should pay attention to improve the students' perception about brand image of the
University
4.3 Limitations of the study and further research directions
20
This study has its own limitations as follows:
- The thesis only considers the gap between brand identity and brand image based on a model that is considered the most typical
- The second limitation relates to the scope of the study: The thesis only considers this issue in the field of higher education and measures specific results at the National Economics University
Regarding the samples of research: Due to the limitation of resources, this study focuses only on students and alumni of the training system - the main and most important customers of a higher education institution
- In addition, the study was conducted in Vietnam, leading to separate cultural issues Therefore, researching issue in different service sectors and other cultural contexts will help clarify the marginal conditions for different theoretical generalizations
Conclusion of Chapter 4
Based on the analysis results in the previous chapters, Chapter 4 summarizes the contributions of the research on both theoretical and practical aspects and then propose a number of suggestions for administrators Although only case studies are conducted at the National Economics University, the conclusions in Chapter 4 are quite relevant and partly show the current situation of the brand issue of Vietnamese education Chapter 4 also outlines limitations and suggests further research directions