Tác động của quản lý tài chính đến chất lượng giáo dục đại học_Nghiên cứu điển hình tại các trường đại học thuộc Bộ Công Thương

^_GHF`aPMQGbcdeJFIfGIdgJFIhVSijGHklmn^ F†GI‡GHGI{RSˆ‰VS^]RZSX]S\OFEFw„dPMQF`aFEFGHIJKGFLŠS^‹S^ijFdIqFIJrGy ŒŒŒŽ‘Ž’“Ž”•–—˜š›œŽžŸŽ ¡¢˜¢š£¡¤˜¥œŽ”•–—˜š›œŽ¦§¨©Ž ªJrRSR«¬­S®¯RSY]YSY~S°

1234 56784 39:4 3;784 1234 <=>74 ?@4 1AB 4 3CD 7C4 4 5E74 3CF14 ?GH784 8B 2I4 JK34 5LB 4 CM34 N 4

bc%Zde%fghij

1234 56784 39:4 3;784 1234 <=>74 ?@4 1AB 4 3CD 7C4 4 5E74 3CF14 ?GH784 8B 2I4 JK34 5LB 4 CM34 N 4

4 !m(n<8(omp8(Eq8(Ers l

^c9I; ^#'a1d=7"#$bLB$AG

 ^#e"$fg>&$"&@$"'h5

3456 656   



3         !"#

$%&'()*)+,-.%&'0'1&.3'3456,7&8& 9

$%&'():);',&<=>?@ABD>ABEDAFG&<345H,I@AJKABLMAD>C@>AFN&3'OBAPQ@RASTUV *(

VW@>AXYZYA[\ADO,'].'^&<<18_`a3H,^3`1& b9

$%&':):);',&<6_<130cSTUV bd

$%&':)b)+,I&6e.f13'2&'.'g_h1ijAFMc,h'1i&0k&<6l0 mn

VW@>AXYoYA[\ADO,3O=ApM@>A=>CAD>qASTUVArs1].t5u v(

$%&'b)*)wGu8-.x3'y334zADEDABP|@RAF}1'~3.',G3w€ n:

3‚ƒ

wI&<:)*)„^JPQ@RABP|@R…A†M@>A‡Mˆ@AF}1'~3rs1].t5u b‰

wI&<:):)„^<1I@RA‡Mˆ@AF}1'~3rDEDABP|@RAF}1'~3s1].t5u b‰

wI@RAXYŠYA[\ADOjADEDABP|@RAF}1'~3rs1].t5u bn

wI&<:)m)‹G.Œ^'%&'.'y33,&<y&<`3'0aSTUVAD>MzAB>ŽqA@RP|13,&<3O0 m(

wI&<:)v)833&<.'y33O=ApM@>A=>CAD>qASTUV v*

wI&<b)*)+,-u<1I&<01&34zADEDABP|@RAF}1'~3.',G3w€ nv

wI&<b):)‘1]&.3''~3.703'_Œ1&'01&34zADEDABP|@RAF}1'~3.',G3w€ n‰

wI&<b)b)€x@RAD>MA@R?@A†ED>AD>qADEDAF\@A‡Œ’&<'1]0345w€ nn

wI&<b)m)€x&<3'1&<1&Œ83'3'_<18_`a3345w€ n9

wI&<b)“YA”M@>A=>CAF•jABPAD\A†r07.3'O.3'_<18_`a3345w€ nd

wI&<b)‰);1&'0'2',Œ’&<'1]034zADEDAD\A†r<18_`a3.',G3w€ nd

wI&<b)n)€x&<.',34zADEDABP|@RAF}1'~3.',GDA–[—ARMzMAFq}&:((d˜:(*b 9(

wI&<b)™YA[\ADO,383h'_I@AD>MARMzMAFq}&:((d˜:(*b34zADEDAB{P|@RAF}1'~3

wI&<b)šYA[\ADO,3'1&<1&Œ83'3'_383-N,.^FIu›I_3'OBAJPQ&<345383

wI&<b)*()‹y33'13'_&<'1&3y,h'_5'~334zADEDABP|@RAF}1'~3.',G3w€œ9n

wI&<b)**)€',&'70›%&'H,1&345s.}MADEDABP|@RAF}1'~3.',G3w€<151

wI&<b)*:)‹yDAFGF•jABPABLMAD>C@>AD>qAD>P\@RABW@>AFLqAB}_34zADEDABP|&<

wI&<b)*b);N.H,I'~3.70žŸ&6,-]&34zA ¡ADEDABP|@RAF}1'~3.',G3w€ d*

wI&<b)*m)‹yDAFGF•jABPABLMAD>C@>AD>qAFGMA@R¢AS¡AD4zADEDAB{P|@RAF}1'~3

wI&<b)*v)‹yDAFGF•jABPABLMAD>C@>AD>qAD\A†r07.3'O.34zADEDABP|@RAF}1'~3

31s97898,t!1!16141G"#156#u56Ev!1!1EK56!1 %33+, .6

31s97858Z6Y5E4!\ 0w5695#!EK56!1 %& xX6141G"#!3+, 6-

31s9789-8@A1<5%345y74500I0318Œ%3O56#47450#w1!„5!01015Y5631!\U2^_S` 9-:

gUnU
_S_
SŒb
RSUV
Q~g
RQ
mn
…
RbU
QSaS
Rs\ŽOƒou\NU
S„Q
SY
`g
QiŒ
QStj\pOPg
gUŒ
ZQ‘
’XU
YZ[\N][^\jŽ“oz
gŒbU
_S”
Y•
N”
Wb
deR
…z
…

NOPQ
R‚S
–b—
R‚Œg
˜0™
R‚ig
š–iŒ
gY
Qn
RbU
…UV
RSiY
dSnŒ
Wb
QQ
_SZ
…ZQ›z

jœou\N|
ž^OŸou\ 
š˜˜
Rig›
_
Rg
_S`
RQSz
b
ŠŒR
QQ
gSU†
Qf
RŒg
Wb
ouœrs\oOXQ
W€
jk[\Nlg
Qhi
mn
…
RbU
QSaS
Ne
QStj\pOPou\vwxy\N¡
¢k[\N£S
dSŒng
R‚‹g
Qhi
QQ
gSU†
Qf‡\or¤\pr¥\[Ÿ\¦•
N€
‰tR
QQ
YZQ
RU†
gSU†
Qf‘

ž^OŸou\§
š¨©
Rig›
_
Rg
WbŒ
…
gUnU
ls\^r¥ª\[Ÿ\¦•
…
Qhi
Q~g
RQ
mn
…

RbU
QSaS
Rs\[k[\jOƒou\NU
S„Qz
QStj\OPg
gUŒ
Z[\NU
S„Q
ˆr\jk[\Nlg
Qhi
mn
…

jrs\[^]o^\Ne
QStj\vwxy‘
ž^OŸou\«
š©¬
Rig›
_
Rg
_S`
RQS
RSTQ
Rg
mn
…

RbU
QSaS
Qh­\[k[\jŽOƒou\NU
S„Q
RSl[\®ž¯ª\jŽœou\N|\°^±o\j][^\¦±‡\ˆrœ\[Ÿ\[t
Š²

Zg
g
…TQ
RbU
QSaS
QSŒ
QQ
—e
R‹
no^\^O•ou\Ne
QStj\pOPg
gUŒ
ZQ³
Y‹U
mi
SV
gU´i
QQ
—e
R‹
no^\^O•g
RXU
QStj\OPg
gUŒ
ZQ
Wb
RSbS
RQS
S„Q
R_z
µ
…—V
Qh­\¶·¸\Ng
RSƒU
_S`
RQS
_Sn
SU
Qhi
¹’z
º’
W€
WUVQ
Š²
Zg
g
…TQ

RbU
QSaS
QSŒ
QQ
—e
R‹
no^\^O•ou\Ne
QStj\OPg
gUŒ
ZQz
_Sn
Ss\ouOƒs\­œ\Nlg
W€
QStj\OPg
gUŒ
ZQ
Qh­\[k[\jOƒou\NU
S„Q
RSlQ
»¼½‘
ž^OŸou\¾
š˜¬
Rig›
N€
Q_

RXU
QQ
gUnU
_S_
Wb
dS—e
gS£
N‹U
WXU
QQ
–†
…†
mi
SY
SŒb
RSUV
Q~g
RQ
mno\pq\jrs\[^]o^\^OXg
RXU
`g
QiŒ
QStj\OPg
gUŒ
Z[\jœou\[k[\jOƒou\NU
S„Q‘

o\ko\N¿\°^±o\j[^\ˆr\¢k[\N£o^\NOPQ
jk[\Nlg
Qhi
mn
…
RbU
QSaS
Ne
QStR

pOPg
¹ÀxÁ
mi
QQ
YUS
QSfg
–g
QQ
Š‹
…V
RS‹ou\“\ˆr\Ns€
Ri
dSnŒ
ŠR
U
ÃÄ\jOƒou\NU
S„Q
RSl[\®ž¯\ˆr\N€
‰tR
YlR
Š‹
gUnU
_S_
•
Qt°\ˆÅ\¥Æ\Ço^r\oOXQ
Wb
[Ÿ\ȇ­o\ȇno\pq\o^r\oOX[ɪˆs\¥Æ\ǎOƒou\NU
S„Q›
W€
[Ÿ\[^e
[Êou\o^O\°^OŸou\j^fQ

^‡¤\Nlgz
Š²
Zg
g
…T[\jrs\[^]o^\N¡
`g
QiŒ
QStj\OPou\vwxy‘

235678  9


 !"#$%&'()*&+,-
./0
12
130
405
16

1
407
18
-09:;.
<2
=71
:
/
>.
1?@
AB1


09C
D
405
16
E=
=
<2
12
13FGHIJIKL$MNOPHQLLN&*@
R.7
SP-
QLLN

1*
T
UV.
WX-
6-
-E
UB1
<5.
Y
Z&[I"\NG]^_`
a2
UB1
>D0
16
9?0b

cU
X
de
U%ILN&*
0f
D
a3HHG&gIB
-5
1*
B
a3HHIN&

&+T
<2
=71
:
>.
1?
-h(Z&+i-b
Z&L&N$($N*
-j
.%=
7b

.%*$INMk^NG"]^_`
a0j
a0j
a2
UB&+F&lmF(&6&NHI+n&gI

=71
1:
>.
1?
op
B.
-h5
UV.
40q-
.5
<8
E
+,-
orU
a2
UB&F&+Qi.
a,.

0X
>.
1?
-
-c
-7
D
<2
op
B.@

Wq.
-c
/
>.
1?
1
1e-
.%

59b
Z1
-c
HMH+i-
(Hq
s
1U
-.?
K+,-
<2
-7-
1e-
=t
,u:
1r
>[=

<i.
d3
-*
15
29
-2
59
s1

=71
:
/
>.
1?
vw5b
0xxxyb0
-0
]^_`
ONGL!
-2
=71
:
1C
12
1?
.i$QLz-
W.%1
2
T
HMH+i-

(uIM&\:b
./0
-{
=h
=c$q.
Uz1
<i.
<Z/
S09
18Ue-
12.
,
-j
-
]^_`
v|5U5b
}~~~y@Ă.
8
a*.
[-
d€
=71
:
-h5
]^_`
1C
12
1?

.i.b
)HGI$/FHI+n&\II[
d3
+(\(HMHHnHI?
12.
-{
-
]^_`b

Âd1r
v}~~‚y
-
Ê
:
.cU
7=
a3H&L$HIJIHINHMH&+Ô*.
6-
-Ơ
-E

1:
D
-5
-Z&+,
.7
SP-b
D
-5
S5
1?
-h5
&+Ô
:
10
†1
Ưˆ
.
S5
1r
6H"z-
W.%1
2
-7-
Ưˆ
+i-
2.‰Uz&ÀIMHHMH&+Ô
-
=c.
*
5
-7-
Uq.
405
%
<i.
XuNL"H‹&!:
6
V
1,
-7-
1.?1
W[

6-
1X=
<2
GHŒa2
HnT
KŽ&+T
-
Ưˆ
13-
1X=@

'0xxb
D
2
?
.i.
v‘’y
109C
Wq“”]^_`
)K QLN&gI

1*
>h
c
1C
12
1?
.i$•kẢIJIQgQX9b
-c.
-7-
]^_`
HŒ)&\T

12
UB1
.%&+,
=;
W.?
T
0
?&HMH+i-
1
d0q1
}—mF(k#Lz-

W.%1
HŒ&IĐN‘’
-7-
-0B-
-c$HMHIL!/0
-E
UB&”HI+n&\II[
d3•

™ÃĐO(›Hnœc
>7
.qI(F"I+HG”0
dq
HIF•T
0
?&HMH+i-
a2
1X=

10
<2
5.
Uc
</
žăÁâđêôơê
<2
ẶưẨơâẪàẬâđêÈẺẼÉ°ẸơỀ"HINOỂHMH+i-
-E
d3

>7-
50
>7
ai
</
1:
-?
-{
1[
</
&gIB
=71
:
>.
1?@
09C
D
-h5
ỄFI+i
E.
C
-E
Z1
./F"I+Q/
Uz1
2.
-{
-h
9?0
<2
=;
W.?
a2

234
67
89





9


3
!"#
$
%&'(&)*+,'-.'/0

2322
3
0
45/
6

&'(78
99
:9
;
=
8>
1
3?

5@7
A9
BC 30
1%(E.FGH+I')J&+K&LM(NO-PQ(+%

7S%E(GIT(,U%(&V(&F(&V(&&M(%WX1


Y

/
?
07

I7=0
03
2Z
/0
;
R[
G+V%E(G(&+SP\
B

$
^X(78XV(GK&^%,7_

63
9a
0b(cdN
!"#
$
/eK(M+%,T(%&
085 

f

96
g

f
30
hiij
%&7k0
4

23
`(GlSV(+
/

9
Y
9
BA
A
9_
m

3*X&O(&X&L(&n^X&V(G
99
o4p

5]9
09
9q
(&'(78X(T(r(GGrKsVt(&+TSX&t !"#0`
`(Gu+o+V(GX*

v
9
503
2Z
%&w(GFX&E.nrXnp
/ox
1(Gy05


03
0
0
105

9
p
/
`7

09
9q
9W
0

3
]9

p
5]
Rz
2Z0
09
R
YVX^X%7k(G*
H
;
]9
96
/0
{
]XbS%7%'+X&L(&XYVX^X%7k0
3

 9
W
6(&&7$(G 
U%7=(G

bdY

/O k+X&7V|(&`(GbS%7
Y

%7k0
3

 D&6y*4$ 76''*$@264 6'>&66'WL4( G6''*$@8 B8 m- 644,4\ 

 az[H4$#6 B8 { TFF7|3=64}$6'86'1Zz[42W#6'&A66'561*4(Q 4"64LY /9 9a ~Y 4@

€ 9a Y8