This studyemploys the commitmcnt-involvcmcnt theory, involvement theory and perceived trustbased on the hierarchy-of-effects model to create a three-stage model assessing howproduct cogn
Trang 1VIETNAMESE CONSUMERS
Thuộc nhóm chuyên ngành : Kinh tế
TP Hồ Chí Minh, tháng 02/2024
Trang 2Cross-border E-commerce (CBEC) has thrived and grown in recent years Due to the
more complicated interaction processes compared to domestic e-commerce, consumers experience more significant uncertainty Despite the rapid development and expansion
of CBEC into Vietnam, research on consumers’ intentions remains scarce This studyemploys the commitmcnt-involvcmcnt theory, involvement theory and perceived trustbased on the hierarchy-of-effects model to create a three-stage model assessing howproduct cognition affects purchase intention in CBEC Data was collected fromShopee platform users The analysis reveals that a high-quality product descriptionsignificantly positively affects product involvement, platform involvement, and
perceived trust (integrity and ability) Platform enduring involvement positivelyinfluences perceived trust (benevolence and ability), and platform situationalinvolvement affects all three indicators of perceived trust Interestingly, product
involvement does not significantly impact purchase intention, but platforminvolvement does Regarding perceived trust, ability and integrity do not significantly
affect purchase intention, while benevolence does This study highlights that althoughproduct descriptions may not directly influence purchase intention and perceived trust (benevolence), high-quality product descriptions play a vital role in attracting consumers and shaping their decisions on CBEC platforms Therefore, optimizing
descriptions can increase consumer engagement and trust
Keywords: Cross-border E-commerce, Product Descriptions, Shopee, Purchase intention.
Trang 32.2.2 The commitment-involvement theory 15
CHAPTER 3 RESEARCH MODEL AND HYPOTHESES DEVELOPMENT 18
1 Impact ofproduct cognition on behavior intention 19
3.1.1 Product description and purchase intention 193.2 Impacts of product cognition on variables ofthe affective stage 20
3.2.1 Product description and product involvement 20
3.2.2 Product description and platform involvement 213.2.3 Product description and perceived trust 22
3.3 Impacts among internal variables of the affective stage 23
3.3.1 Platform enduring involvement and perceived trust 23
3.3.2 Platform situational involvement and perceived trust 23
3.4 Impacts of variables of the affective stage on behavior intention 24
Trang 43.4.1 Product Involvement and purchase intention 24
3.4.2 Platform Involvement and purchase intention 25
3.4.3 Perceived Trust and purchase intention 26
4.1 Research Approach 27
4.3 Data collection 32
CHAPTER 5 DATA ANALYSIS AND RESULTS 34
5.1 Demographic descriptive statistics 34
5.2 Measurement model results: 35
6.2.2 Building Trust through Enduring Involvement 57
6.2.3 Focusing on Benevolence towards situational Purchase Intention 57
6.2.4 Resource Allocation for Cognitive and Affective Involvement 58
6.2.5 Considering Resource Allocation for Integrity 59
Trang 56.3 Limitations and Future Research
APPENDIX
REFERENCES
59
62 64
Trang 6LIST OF FIGURE
Figure 4 Structural model andresults of PLS-SEM 46
Trang 7LIST OF TABLE
Table 1 Observed variables using measurement ofresearch concepts 29
Table 3 Results of scale reliability and convergent validity analysis 37
Table 4 Results of discriminant validity analysis (Fornell & Larcker criterion) 40
Table 5 Results of discriminant validity analysis (HTMT) 41
Table 7 Collinearity statistics: variance inflation factor (VIF) result 43
Table 8 The f - Square index and the corresponding impact level 45
Table 10 R - Square and R - Square adjusted results 49
Table 11 Descriptive statistics of all measurement items 62
Trang 915 PT1 Perceived Trust Integrity
Trang 10CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION
The rapidly advancing processes of economic integration and technological progress
have made the world smaller and more interconnected, creating a variety of opportunities for international trade and service It increases consumers’ awareness of both online purchasing and shopping destinations, which promotes the growth of CBEC According to an Accenture report in 2019, the CBEC market is developing at
twice the rate compared to the domestic e-commerce market The number of consumers using the CBEC platform is continuously increasing; by 2020, the number
of cross-border orders is expected to reach 9.3 billion (McKinsey, 2022), and the
global CBEC will be forecasted to account for 17% of the global e-commerce market
share by 2023 (Forrester, 2023) CBEC booms all over the world (Stoklosa et al.,
2018), and it is an inevitable development that no country can stand aside from
Vietnam is one of them The demand for cross-border shopping by Vietnamese consumers via e-commerce sites is growing, notwithstanding the fact that the method
of cross-border sales via e-commerce in Vietnam is still relatively new The proportion
of consumers who purchase products directly from foreign websites rises considerably from 49% in 2020 to 56% in 2021 (IDEA, 2022) Seeing the high demand and potential, Vietnamese e-commerce platforms have been developing internationalpurchasing capabilities; consumers buy goods from foreign sellers on Vietnamese e-commerce platforms, with that percentage having risen from 41% in 2020 to 57% in
2021 (IDEA, 2022)
However, in a CBEC environment, interaction processes are more complex, and
consumers may experience more uncertainly (Mou et al., 2017) as a result of the geographical distance barrier between buyers and sellers, causing differences in
cultures, languages, customs, and history (Zhu ct al., 2019) Product information
cognition represents a problem in CBEC that cannot be overlooked In this situation,the product description serves as a connection between the two sides (Kim et al.,
Trang 112017) In general, when consumers conduct online product searches, a brief
description of the product is shown The description is an important indicator for the consumer in determining whether or not it is of high quality (Gabriella & Agus, 2020)and making further decisions (Resatsch et al., 2008) If consumers are unaware of a
product, they will not express any desire or interest in it, thus ensuring that no purchase will occur From the perspective of a product seller on CBEC platforms, it is
critical to understand consumer behavior during online purchasing to properly targetthem and deliver information based on their request (Demangeot & Broderick, 2007)
Given the aforementioned considerations and previously released data, the purpose of
this study is to evaluate and investigate the role of the product description on purchase intention within the CBEC platform Thus far, the success ofdomestic e-commerce has
been thoroughly researched, whereas CBEC has received less attention to our
knowledge (Mou et al., 2017) In-depth studies in this area have mainly concentrated
on B2B strategics that encourage and foster cross-border trade, yet there are many limitations for B2C, with only exploratory aspects of the relationship between satisfaction with logistics quality and price (Do et al., 2023), the formation of consumer intentions in cross-border trade (Phuong & Tung, 2021), and CBECplatform selection (Cuong & Chau, 2021) Thus, this study can be incorporated intothe research system on consumer behavioral intents in CBEC with the goal of effectively exploiting the market potential In addition, the HOE model is used in the research to systematically forecast purchase intention, reflect the entirety of the processing response procedure performed by consumers as well as systematically
forecast purchase intention on the CBEC platform (Zhu et al., 2019)
Accordingly, Shopee, with a 63% market share, is one of the typical examples inVietnam's e-commerce, the largest market share in the entire country's e-commerce sector (Momentum Works, 2023) and right in the first quarter of In 2022, the platformrecorded the most impressive monthly visitation total of 84.520.000, followed by
Trang 12Lazada, with only 16.970.000 visits (Iprice, 2022) This fact supports the choice of
Shopee as the study’s case so that the performance of the CBEC may be seen and studied in the context of Vietnam
While there are no statistics on the number of Internet users by age, it is thought that young people in Vietnam make up the majority of Internet users, with older individuals
using the Internet less frequently than younger ones According to a survey published
in 2023 by We Are Social, 54.1% of social network users in Vietnam were in the
18-34 age range In addition, Shopee’s most frequent user demographic is 18-34 years
old, who account for 81.63% of all desktop usage (Similarweb, 2023) As a result, for
the purpose of ensuring study efficacy, the research objectives are Vietnamese consumers aged 18 to 34 who have previously shopped on the Shopee platform
The study investigates a variety of points of view, including both the direct and indirect impacts of the integration of the two theories, and takes into account perceived
trust to figure out whether or not product descriptions influence consumers’ purchase
intentions in the CBEC environment The potential contribution of this research would
be to provide insight for suppliers and sellers, a guide to improve product awareness,
and optimize every stage of the journey, thereby driving buying behavior of
cross-border consumers This research collected data from 353 subjects and analyzedthe data using SmartPLS software to assess the given hypotheses
The theoretical basis of the research is expanded on in the following section After
describing the connections between the constructs and hypotheses, the paper moves on
to describe the study methodology and measurement techniques Based on the study's
results and limitations, the current article examines pertinent applications and possiblefuture research paths
Trang 13CHAPTER 2 LITERATURE REVIEW 2.1 Conceptual Background
2.1.1 Cross-Border E-commerce (CBEC)
Cross-border E-commerce (CBEC) is a form of transaction that takes place between
different countries or customs areas, facilitated by an e-commerce platform and
cross-border logistics (Tmogroup, 2015) This trend has become increasingly prevalent
in the modern e-commerce landscape, particularly for small and medium enterprises
(SMEs), as it offers the potential to reduce trade barriers and stimulate growth in
otherwise limited marketplaces (Terzi, 2011)
While the advent of the internet and digital technology has significantly reduced the
impact of geographical distance on trade costs, other factors have emerged assignificant in the context of CBEC These include language and cultural differences,the quality of legal institutions, and the efficiency of payment and parcel delivery
systems These factors can significantly influence the cost and feasibility of online
trade (Blum & Goldfarb, 2006; European Commission, 2012)
In essence, CBEC is a complex concept that encapsulates various aspects of
international trade, digital technology, and logistics Its definition and implications can vary across different studies, reflecting the evolving nature of e-commerce and the
diverse perspectives of researchers in this field
Trang 14Consumers often make reasonable decisions and rely on factors such as product
information, prices, benefits, and promotions to evaluate the quality of a product
(Gentry et al., 2006) Toulmin (1958) claimed that information sources that lead tostrong statements in purchase intention with the framework and well-organized content
arc likely to be more appealing and arc seen as more credible The persuasive power of quality in product description has been discovered in a variety of contexts
2.1.3 Perceived Trust
The presence of perceived trust significantly influences alleviating the uncertaintiesthat consumers typically encounter while going through the online shopping process.According to Lemire et al.‘s (2008) evaluation of the trustworthiness of onlineretailers' product descriptions, this study considered perceived trust as a composite construct comprising specific dimensions, especially the integrity, benevolence, and
ability of the product supplier (McKnight et al., 2002) On a CBEC platform,
consumers will engage in buying behavior and increase their perceived trust in a product seller ifthey believe that the seller has integrity, benevolence, and ability
Investigating the perceived trust on CBEC platforms, benevolence is the aim for companies to conduct themselves in a way that benefits their consumers whilebehaving with an egotistical economic goal (Mayer Ct al., 1995) Integrity expresses consumer expectations that sellers will perform their commitments ethically,
consistently, and in fulfillment of accepted standards and principles (McKnight, 2002).According to Mayer el al (1995), the ability is a collection of capabilities, competencies, and behavioral traits that enable a seller to impact the process of providing a product
2 1.4 Purchase Intention in CBEC
Following a consumer's overall assessment of a product, certain exchange behaviorsare referred to as buying interest This is a perception based on how someone feels
Trang 15about a certain object As a result, opinions about items or altitudes towards brands,
along with the stimulation of outside stimuli, help to shape consumer purchasing
desires The propensity of clients to make online transactions is refeiTed to as buy interest in CBEC (Lu, 2016) Purchase intentions are formed under the assumption of a
pending transaction and, consequently, are often considered an important indicator of actual purchases (Chang Ct al., 1994)
2.2 Theoretical Background
2.2.1 The involvement theory'
The involvement theory introduced by Zaichkowsky (1986) relates to an individual's perceived relevance regarding an object according to instinctual needs, values, and
interests Zaichkowsky (1986) posits that involvement acts as a motivating force andthat ego involvement is utilized to forecast individuals' attitudes When individuals arestimulated or find themselves in a particular situation, they will establish a connection
between the stimulus and themselves, leading to heightened interest (Sherif & Cantril,1947) Numerous researchers have since investigated the validity ofthe participation
hypothesis through empirical investigations in the framework of traditionale-commerce For example, studies by Herrero & San Martin (2012) and Huang et al
(2010) contribute to the involvement theory, indicating that the amount of engagementhas a substantial impact on how consumers perceive information about the product(Zhu et al., 2019)
Consumers select products on CBEC platforms depending on their engagement and assess whether rational or emotional aspects are most crucial in the decision-making process and the development of behavioral intentions, claim Zhu et al (2019) Thus,
we distinguish between cognitive involvement and affective involvement when
describing product involvement Affective involvement describes how relevant an item
is to consumers based on their feelings, moods, and thoughts, whereas cognitiveinvolvement relates to how consumers assess the item's usefulness and functionality
Trang 16(Drossos et al., 2014) So reasoning and factual knowledge are related to cognitive
involvement, but emotions and mood slates are related to affective involvement
2.2.2 The commitment-involvement theory ’
According to Zhu et al (2019), the commitment-involvement theory is an integration
of both the involvement theory and commitment theory It posits that when individuals perceive a connection or relevance to a stimulus or activity, they develop interest and commitment toward it (Sherif & Cantril, 1947; Hornback, 1971) Mou et al (2020) argue that platform involvement can be defined as an individual's perception of thesignificance of a platform stimulus or situation When consumers purchase on an e-commerce website, their level of platform involvement is reflected in how they
evaluate the importance of factors such as user interface, payment system reliability,
consumer service quality, etc Consumers’ level of involvement and value interaction
on that platform will be high if they consider these factors important and significantly
affect their buying experience
According to the commitment-involvement theory, Zhu et al (2019) categorize platform involvement into two types: platform enduring involvement and platformsituational involvement Platform enduring involvement signifies a continued interest
or sustained concern with the platform (Keusch, 2015), while platform situational
involvement pertains to temporary feelings evoked by specific platform situations (Havitz & Mannell, 2005) Enduring involvement is characterized by a consumer'slong-term interest in a platform This form of involvement is often associated with a
deep psychological bond between the consumer and the platform, which is cultivated
over time through repeated interactions and experiences (Beatty et al., 1988) Situational involvement, on the other hand, indicates a temporary interest in a
platform This form of involvement is often triggered by specific situations or events
and is not as enduring as enduring involvement (Zaichkowsky, 1985)
Trang 172.2.3 Hierarchy of Effects model (HOE)
The HOE model is a response hierarchy model that analyzes consumers, evaluateshow consumers respond to information, and systematically demonstrates the
progression from consumers' ignorance regarding a product to their actual buying
behavior (Smith et al., 2008) including three stages: cognition, affective and behavior
Consumers understand or interpret details about products in the cognitive stage, andthey also associate products and services with themselves (Barry & Howard, 1990) The effect stage could show the consumers' fervent preferences, including their desire,belief, and so on (Barry & Howard, 1990) Finally, in the action stage, consumers'
desire to make a purchase is piqued, and their strongly held preference prompts them
to make a decision on the products in question (Zhu el al., 2019)
Similarly, this study is to operationalize a logical procedure with three stages (sec inFigure 1), which sequence corresponds to how consumers process and respond in the
setting of CBEC
Trang 18Figure 1 Conceptual Framework
According to Barry & Howard (1990), cognition is defined as a mental process that expresses itself in the form of consumer opinions, convictions, or product knowledge.Initially, consumers are unaware of the product on a CBEC platform In this situation,
a particular product description may pique consumers' interest, and sustain it for
enough time to develop the link between the product description and consumer's
product cognition (Smith el al., 2008) Since this link is made, the consumer becomes
conscious of the product and takes it into account when making a decision (Smith &
Swinyard, 1988) Wc refer to this stage as known as product cognition The team
research, therefore, proposes product description as an analytical variable at theproduct cognitive stage in the HOE model
In the affective stage, consumer attitudes and feelings for products and platforms areprogressively fostered, and consumers develop a positive view and a level of
Trang 19preference for them (BaiTy & Howard, 1990) The consumer’s comprehension ofthe
product description gradually improves, on the one hand, leading to a higher level of perceived relevance to the consumer based on individual perceptions or emotions
(Mou et al., 2020) On the other hand, consumers get more engaged with the platform
where these products are displayed (Celsi & Olson, 1988), and as a result, they give their feelings greater consideration and devote more time to digesting or responding on
this platform Consumers can steadily build their trust in the product sellers in the
involvement process (Zhu et al., 2019) Thus, during the affective stage, we suggest product involvement, platform involvement, and perceived trust as analytical variables
The conation stage shows the intention to conduct an action (e.g., buy) or the activity
itself (Egan, 2007) on the CBEC platform The team research refers to this stage asknown as behavior intention After the affective phase, purchasing desire of consumers
is stimulated to elicit potential consumer actions We recommend purchase intention asthe analytical variable during the behavior intention stage
CHAPTER 3 RESEARCH MODEL AND HYPOTHESES DEVELOPMENT
The research team proposed a model with three stages in order to assess the both relationship direct and indirect between product description and purchasing intention within a CBEC context depending on the HOE model, the involvement and commitment-involvement theory, along with possible mediating impacts of perceived trust
Trang 20Figure 2 Research Model
3.1 Impact of product cognition on behavior intention
3 1.1 Product description and purchase intention
An online product description serves as a means of showcasing a product’s
functionality and performance (Yao & Shao, 2021) as well as an essential variable that
sellers utilize to assist consumers in their product evaluation and purchasing choices(Khare & Rakesh, 2011) All of these factors of product descriptions impact potential consumers' purchasing decisions (Benlian et al., 2012) When consumers buy a product online, Park et al (2005) claim that the product description may elicit an
emotional reaction A high-quality product description fulfills or surpasses the
consumer's expectations (Kahn et al., 2002) This can lead to increased confidence inpurchasing decisions Alternatively put, product description plays a crucial role inreducing consumers’ doubts and uncertainties regarding the product The more detailed
the product description, the more positive the psychological response from consumers
Trang 21approaching the product As a result, consumers become more inclined to participate
in various psychological activities associated with the product, such as making a purchase
Hl: Product description positively affects purchase intention.
3.2 Impacts of product cognition on variables of the affective stage
3.2.1 Product description and product involvement
According to Kitchen et al (2014), a person's information processing can go either a
"central route" or a "peripheral route” In “central route” circumstances, consumers will use extra cognitive effort to analyze the problem (Mou Ct al., 2019) Consumersare more likely to use the "central route" when the product description's quality is higher and tend to concentrate more on viewing product information (Nkwocha et al.,
2005)
A high-quality product description not only enhances the product's image but alsopositively impacts consumers' emotions about it, unlike an inadequate productdescription (Krishna & Ahluwalia, 2008) Al this moment, consumers hold a positive psychological concern for the product In addition, the involvement theory slates that
an effective product description can somewhat raise a product's potential worth and
strengthen its interaction with consumers This encourages consumer involvement inthe products and moves them from a state of disinterest to one of cognitivesclf-idcntification and successful full investment (Huang Ct al., 2010) Based on the explanation above, we propose the following hypothesis:
H2a: Product description positively affects cognitive involvement.
H2b: Product description positively affects affective involvement.
Trang 223.2.2 Product description and platform involvement
According to Ferns & Walls (2012), enduring involvement refers to a continuous
interest in a product A greater degree of enduring involvement will arise from thisresonance’s gradual alteration of consumers’ ideas, feelings, and psychologies
regarding the platform Consumers may develop a positive attitude toward a CBECplatform after reading a high-quality product description on it, strengthening their
relationship with it and increasing the platform's capacity for enduring involvement
(Mou et al., 2020)
Giving consumers highly relevant product descriptions might improve their situationalinvolvement on online platforms (Hsia et al., 2020) Additionally, Mou et al (2020) noted that an excellent product description on CBEC platforms can improve thepurchase experience for consumers Duc to the enjoyable nature of the purchasing
experience, consumers' hedonic gains will be increased in this instance As a result,
situational involvement may rise to a higher level
rhe commitment-involvement theory claims: high-quality product descriptions on a
CBEC platform can lead to an attitude of optimism and strengthen the relationship
between consumers and the platform, consequently enhancing enduring involvement;
Additionally, the product descriptions on the platform can influence situationalinvolvement by motivating a particular buying environment On this platform,
consumers may be placed in a particular buying circumstance by reading high-quality product descriptions We hence hypothesize
H3a: Product description positively affects enduring involvement.
H3b: Product description positively affects situational involvement.
Trang 233.2.3 Product description and perceived trust
Sunnafrank (1986) uncertainty reduction theory suggests that the duration and depth of communication during initial interactions can effectively decrease uncertainty and
foster trust between parlies This theory is particularly relevant in the context of
product descriptions in e-commerce Racherla et al (2012) emphasized the significantrole of product description quality in affecting consumers' evaluations of a product's
attributes
Detailed and accurate product descriptions make consumers feel cared for and belter informed about the product, creating a sense of benevolence from the seller This alsodemonstrates the seller's care and respect for consumers, enhancing their trust (Kim et al., 2017; Mavlanova & Benbunan-Fich, 2010)
When product descriptions are honest and unambiguous, the seller exhibits integrity in
their business practices This generates trust from consumers, who believe they arc not being deceived and that the product they purchase will meet their expectations (Kim et al., 2017; Mavlanova & Benbunan-Fich, 2010)
A high-quality product description not only provides information about the product but
also demonstrates the seller's ability to understand its product This creates trust from
consumers, who believe the seller has the ability to provide good products and services
(Kim ct al., 2017; Mavlanova & Bcnbunan-Fich, 2010).Thcrcforc, we hypothesize
that:
H4a: Product description positively affects benevolence.
H4b: Product description positively affects integrity.
H4c: Product description positively affects ability.
Trang 243.3 Impacts among internal variables of the affective stage
3.3.1 Platform enduring involvement and perceived trust
According to the Social Judgment Theory, individuals with higher levels of enduringinvolvement are capable of assessing a broader range of outcomes and are lesssusceptible to persuasion (Sherif et al., 1965; Hong, 2015) This suggests that consumers with higher enduring involvement are less likely to be influenced by other
platforms and tend to have stronger trust in their chosen platform and its products
Furthermore, enduring involvement can lead to a stronger perception of benevolence,
integrity, and ability This is because consumers with a long-term interest in a platformare more likely to develop trust in the platform's intentions, honesty, and competence (Hsia et al., 2020)
This is further supported by studies such as Điyang & Agus (2020), who found a
positive connection between enduring involvement and trust Based on the abovediscussion and the supporting literature, we propose the following hypotheses:
H5a: Enduring involvement positively affects benevolence.
H5b: Enduring involvement positively affects integrity.
H5c: Enduring involvement positively affects ability.
3.3.2 Platform situational involvement and perceived trust
According to Mou el al (2020), situational involvement can be enhanced by providing
consumers with highly relevant product descriptions, which can improve theirpurchase experience on online platforms This enjoyable purchasing experience can increase consumers' hedonic gains, leading to a higher level of trust in the platform's benevolence, integrity, and ability
Trang 25Moreover, research findings by Hsia et al (2020) suggest that providing consumers with highly relevant product descriptions can improve their situational involvement on
online platforms This, in turn, can lead to a higher level of perceived trust Based on
the above discussion and the supporting literature, we propose the followinghypotheses:
H6a: Situational involvement positively affects benevolence.
H6b: Situational involvement positively affects integrity.
H6c: Situational involvement positively affects ability.
3.4 Impacts of variables of the affective stage on behavior intention
3.4.1 Product Involvement and purchase intention
According to Wang et al (2009), product involvement significantly affects consumer
behavior Especially in the context of online shopping, the level of involvement with
products may impact consumer attitudes and behaviors (Bian & Moutinho, 2011)
Consumers who are highly involved with the product are more likely to perceive it positively, giving rise to a greater feeling of personal pleasure and excitement As a result, this increased product involvement is related to an increased degree of purchaseintention According to the involvement theory developed by Drossos el al (2014), a substantial level of product involvement can affect consumers' altitudes about products, fostering the development of consumers' attitudes and behaviors
The concept of product involvement is categorized into two types: cognitiveinvolvement and affective involvement Product cognitive involvement is reflected in
consumers' engagement with a product's functional and utilitarian characteristics,
resulting in them seeking relevant knowledge while formulating their intentions about
a particular product (Drossos et al., 2014) On the other hand, affective involvement
Trang 26greatly influences consumers' emotional connection to the product (Drossos et al.,
2014) Similar to cognitive involvement, a positive psychological response resulting
from this type of involvement can also contribute to the formation of purchaseintentions (Drossos et al., 2014)
H7a: Cognitive involvement positively affects purchase intention.
H7h: Affective involvement positively affects purchase intention.
3.4.2 Platform Involvement and purchase intention
Previous studies have found that involvement influences factors such as brand
attitudes, purchase intention, advertising attitudes, and online shopping behaviors
(Bosnjak et al., 2007; Huang et al., 2010; Yang, 2012) According to Zaichkowsky
(1986), the leading indicators of involvement are personal factors, stimulus factors,
and situational factors (i.e., brand familiarity) Bosnjak et al (2007) studied online
purchase intention and found that effective involvement was a significant indicator of
online purchase intention Platform involvement is likely to be experience-based and
remains unchanged; however, the situation changes (Patanasiri et al., 2018)
Additionally, Huang (2012) suggested that involvement is classified as a motivation
state that affects the extent and focus of the attention of consumers as well as overt behaviors, i.e., shopping and consumption activities Specifically, for the context of
online shopping or online retailing, Jiang Ct al (2010) noted that effective involvement
is associated with emotional, hedonism, and is derived from value-expressive oraffective motives
Regarding the two types of platform involvement in this study, sustained engagement
with platform products may be defined as the degree to which a platform is ingrained
in and motivated by a person's value structure (Ferns & Walls, 2012) When platform enduring involvement is strong, consumers feel psychologically more secure when
making decisions depending on product knowledge because they tend to be more
Trang 27certain in their ability based on their knowledge (Alba & Hutchinson, 1987), or their
previous purchasing experience (Laaksonen, 1994) On the other hand, to some extent,
increased situational participation can minimize customers' uncertainties and lowertheir expenses and social hazards throughout the purchase process (Zhu et al., 2019).According to the commitment-involvement theory, high platform involvement
encourages consumers to dedicate more time and energy to the platform, which increases their propensity to engage in a range of purchase intentions and behavior (Im
& Ha, 2011) Asa result, we aim to verify both of the hypotheses that follow:
H8a: Enduring involvement positively affects purchase intention.
H8h: Situational involvement positively affects purchase intention.
3.4.3 Perceived Trust and purchase intention
According to Gefen et al (2003), taking part in online shopping necessitates consumers dealing with the social complexities involved with sellers' opportunistictendencies The perceived trust of consumers in product sellers affects their
dependence on their information and behaviors (Hajli et al., 2017) According toresearch on online shopping by Lim et al (2006) and Faqih (2013), consumers' trust
has a positive and considerable influence on their intention to purchase online Mayer
et al (1995) and McKnight (2002) posit that the trust of an individual is measured by perceived trust including benevolence, integrity, and ability These characteristics have
been mentioned as significant indicators that strengthen consumers' reliance, reduce
uncertainty during transactions, and foster longer-term relationships with online
product sellers (Suh & Han, 2003; Beldad el al., 2010; Blut el al., 2015) This
demonstrates that perceived trust will increase their engagement in "behavior related totrust" in online shopping, such as purchasing Therefore, we believe that perceived
trust will have a comparable favorable impact on purchase intention
H9a: Benevolence positively affects purchase intention.
Trang 28H9b: Integrity positively affects purchase intention.
H9c: Ability positively affects purchase intention.
CHAPTER 4 METHODOLOGY 4.1 Research Approach
The authors have reached research questions and data collection by using quantitative
methods with the objective of focusing on the impact of the items listed in the model
on consumers’ purchasing intentions In particular, this type of research method is
suitable for our research topic because of the following reasons:
First, this method of research relates to the work of measuring variables, reviewing
and investigating relationships between variables to explore patterns, correlations, or
causal relationships between variables (Leavy, n.d.) In evaluating the influence of
product description on consumers purchasing intention, this objective is perfectly
aligned with the topic of this study
Second, the measurability of the method is a crucial point to help determine the reliability and suitability of the relationship in the research topic (Bryman & Cramer,
2012) When applying the quantitative method, the researcher will have a clearer view
of delecting the people's differences in a trait that is mentioned and studied (Bryman &
Cramer, 2012)
Finally, objectivity is also an appropriate value of quantitative research methods, reflected in transparency in research procedures (Bryman & Cramer, 2012) As a result, the authors are free to expand upon earlier research without being concerned
about any particular bias or expectations from the earlier researcher
Trang 294.2 Research design
Figure 3 Research process
The 5-lcvcl Likert scale, with the scale descriptions "Strongly Disagree," "Disagree,"
"Normal," "Agree," and "Strongly Agree," is the one that has been used in this study Respondents are asked to rate how much they agree or disagree with a series of comments made regarding a certain topic on the scale The Likert scale is also one of
the most precise tools for determining people's preferences, attitudes, and views regarding particular behaviors (Hair cl al., 2010; Leung, 2011)
This study uses a Likert scale to evaluate how Vietnamese consumers' attitudes toward purchase intention are measured through an online survey Besides, Hair et al (2010) argue that there is no absolute rule about which level of scale is the best choice
Trang 30However, the number of levels on the rating scale should typically not exceed 5, as this
will make it challenging for respondents to make a decision The author claims that the
greater the number of levels the study employs, the greater the change in the data,
which is a crucial factor in data analysis As a result, the research paper’s use of a
5-level scale will make it simpler and more consistent for respondents to make their
decisions, especially minimizing the possibility ofresearch data being so
There are 5 research concepts used in this study, which are built on the theoretical
foundations from previous studies which are respectively:
Table I Observed variables using measurement of research concepts
The products’ descriptions were easy to understand
rhe products' descriptions are objective
The products* descriptions are credible
The products' descriptions are clear
Park et al
(2007)
2 Product Involvement
Trang 31CU (Cognitive involvement) Shopping on Shopee is a very
important decision
Drossos et al.(2014)
CI2 (Cognitive involvement) Shopping on Shopee requires
thoughtful consideration
C13 (Cognitive involvement) There is a lot to lose if you select
the wrong products on Shopee
CM (Cognitive involvement) Shopee shopping is not primarily
logical or objective (*)
CI5 (Cognitive involvement) Shopping on Shopcc is based
mainly on functional facts (Search, browse, view, etc.)
All (Affective involvement) Shopping on Shopee expresses Drossos et al
SH (Situational involvement) Shopping activities on Shopee Mou et al
caught my attention (2020); Zhu et
SI2 (Situational involvement) I really enjoy the shopping
process on Shopee
(Situational involvement) Shopping on Shopee is an
al (2019);Havitz &
Mannell (2005)
SI3
activity that suits my current needs
Trang 32SI4 (Situational involvement) Shopping on Shopee gives an
overview of my needs
SI5 (Situational involvement) I will feel disturbed if shopping
activities on Shopee are found to be not good
Ell (Enduring involvement) I enjoy shopping on Shopee even
if I don’ buy anything
Fems & Walls (2012)
EI2 (Enduring involvement) I consider shopping on Shopee to
be a relevant part of my life
EI3
(Enduring involvement) I am interested in shopping on
Shopee rather than other e-commerce platforms
4 Perceived Trust (PT)
PTB1 (Benevolence) I expect this Shopee’s product seller to have
good intentions toward me
Buttner &Goritz (2008)
PTB2 (Benevolence) I expect this Shopee's product seller puts
consumers' interests before their own
PTB3
(Benevolence) Ifproblems arise, I expect Shopee’s product
seller to be ready and willing to assist and support me
PTI1 (Integrity) I am happy with the standards by which
Shopee’s product seller is operating
Biittner &Goritz (2008)
PTI2 (Integrity) Shopee’s product seller operates scrupulously
PTI3 (Integrity) I can believe the statements of Shopee's product
seller
Trang 33PTA2
PTA3
(Ability) Shopee’s product seller is very competent
(Ability) Shopee’s product seller is able to fully satisfy its consumers
(Ability) One can expect good advice from Shopee’s
product seller
Buttner &Goritz (2008)
5 Purchase Intention (PI)
PIl
PI2
PI3
I am interested in buying products on Shopee
In the future, I would buy products from Shopee
I am inclined to purchase products on Shopee in the future
Mou et al.(2020); Zhu et
al (2019); Hsu
Ct al (2016)
4.3 Data collection
4.3 1 Data sampling and collection
In order to ensure the representativeness of the data, this study uses a random survey method to collect samples The survey of this study is for Vietnamese consumers whoare individuals aged 18 to 34, currently residing and working in Viet Nam The data were collected over a week through an online survey using Google Forms According
to (Raykov & Widaman, 1995), SEM requires a large sample size based on the theory
of sample distribution Furthermore, Hair el al (2017) argued that a minimum sample
size of 300 is required to conduct SEM, and a good sample size should be 500 ormore In this study, 336 forms from respondents who had passed the filter stage wereused as the official sample size, ensuring compliance with the mentioned sample size requirements
4.3.2 Data Analysis Technique
We used a quantitative research method through the data obtained from the survey questionnaire Excel 2019 software was employed to filler and encode the raw data from the survey For the reversed scale (CI4: Cognitive Involvement - Shopee
Trang 34shopping is not primarily logical or objective), we conducted data encoding and
altered the measurement direction of the scale (where value 1 would be transformed
into 5, value 2 into 4, and value 3 would be retained unchanged) to ensure that theindices are not disrupted during the model validation process due to the presence of a scale in the opposite direction compared to other measurement scales
SEM was used to examine the proposed model SEM is regarded as a modern andwidely used data analysis method, employed by numerous researchers worldwide totest research models in various fields The hypothesis testing and research model
examination using SEM have advantages over traditional methods like multiple regression, as it not only accounts for measurement errors but also allows the
integration of latent concepts with their measurements into a theoretical modelsimultaneously (Hulland Ct al., 1996)
From a technical perspective, there are two approaches to implementing SEM:
Covariance-Based SEM (CB-SEM) and Partial Least Squares SEM (PLS-SEM) Concerning data requirements, CB-SEM requires data to follow a normal distribution
or have a large sample size Therefore, PLS-SEM becomes a more attractive option in
this case, but it still necessitates considering how to handle outliers in the data.According to Xiao Ct al (2019), PLS-SEM is more flexible regarding data requirements, model complexity, and the specification of relationships to validate themodel compared to the CB-SEM technique
All statistical indicators and criteria in the measurement model arc conducted using
PLS-SEM through the SmartPLS software, which includes automated calculations This is also an advantage of PLS-SEM, as the integrated statistical indicators in the software help researchers save time by providing the necessary statistical indices For
the aforementioned reasons, we opt to use PLS-SEM in conjunction with the
Smart-PLS 4 software to examine the SEM model
Trang 35CHAPTER 5 DATA ANALYSIS AND RESULTS 5.1 Demographic descriptive statistics
We conducted an online survey with 353 people and received 336 valid responses The collected data was encoded and categorized for further analysis The statistical results
are displayed in the table below:
Table 2 Respondent Demographics
Sample Information Frequency Percentage (%)
Trang 36Source: Authors analysis survey data
According to the respondent's profile, the majority of CBEC Shopee users are female,
accounting for 65.8% Respondents between the ages of 18 and 24 made up 87.2% of
CBEC Shopee users Moreover, respondents who are studying and living in big cities
in Vietnam: Ho Chi Minh City, Da Nang, Ha Noi have 40.2%, 22.6% and 16.4% respectively The remaining 20.8% came from other provinces and cities Concerning their experience in Shopee's CBEC, 310 respondents have participated in CBECshopping through Shopee, accounting for 92.3% The remaining 7.7% have never shopped CBEC on Shopee since they feel that the product descriptions are not persuasive enough
The descriptive statistics of each observed variable is shown in the Appendix part
5.2 Measurement model results:
To test the measurement scales, we assess scale reliability, convergent validity, and
discriminant validity since it is the most important measurement model metrics for
PLS-SEM (Hair el al., 2017) We use Cronbach's Alpha and composite reliability (CR)
to evaluate scale reliability Convergent validity is examined by analyzing outer loadings and average variance extracted (AVE) from the measures Finally, the Fornelland Larcker criteria (as known as the Square root of the AVE (SQRTAVE)) and
Heterotrail-Monotrait Ratio (HTMT) are chosen to assess the discriminant validity
5.2.1 Scale reliability
According to Hair et al (2017), it is advisable to consider and report both Cronbach’s
Alpha and CR (as true reliability usually lies between Cronbach’s Alpha - representing
the lower bound and the CR - representing the upper bound)
Trang 37The Cronbach's Alpha and CR varies between 0 and 1, with higher values indicating higher levels of reliability With a reliable scale, the obtained Cronbach’s Alpha should
be greater than or equal to 0.7 (Nunnally, 1978; Hair et al., 2009; DeVellis, 2012) In
terms of CR, Hair et al (2017) argued that in more advanced stages of research, CR values between 0.70 and 0.90 can be regarded as satisfactory Values above 0.90
(definitely above 0.95) arc not desirable because that means all the indicator variables
are measuring the same phenomenon and are therefore not likely to be a valid measure
of the construct Furthermore, CR values lower than 0.60 suggest inadequate internal consistency reliability
All Cronbach's Alpha and CR values (as shown in Table 3) of this model are wellabove the critical threshold of 0.70 It can be observed that the measurement modelmeets the requirement for reliability
Trang 38loadings below 0.4 should be removed from the model When the values fall between
0.4 and below 0.7, the decision to keep or remove them depends on the researcher's
evaluation along with other indices like CR and AVE of that factor If both CR andAVE meet the recommended thresholds, observed variables with outer loadingsbetween 0.4 and below 0.7 may still be considered for retention in the research model.Regarding the aspect of evaluating the AVE, Hock & Ringlc (2010) proposed that a measurement scale achieves convergence ifAVE is 0.5 or higher This threshold of 0.5(50%) implies that the average latent construct accounts for at least 50% of the variance in each observed variable
Table 3 has shown that all outer loadings of the reflective constructs are above the
threshold value of0.70, which suggests sufficient levels of indicator reliability (except CI3: 0.651 and PD3: 0.678) Since all the AVE values arc higher than 0.5 (Hock &
Ringle, 2010) and CR met the recommended thresholds, we have decided not to
remove CI3 and PD3 (based on the arguments of Hair et al., 2017)
Table 3 Results of scale reliability and convergent validity analysis.
Composite Reliability
(CR)
Average
Variance Extracted