1. Trang chủ
  2. » Luận Văn - Báo Cáo

towards solving the hard problem of consciousness the varieties of brain resonances and the conscious experiences that they support

187 1 0
Tài liệu đã được kiểm tra trùng lặp

Đang tải... (xem toàn văn)

Tài liệu hạn chế xem trước, để xem đầy đủ mời bạn chọn Tải xuống

THÔNG TIN TÀI LIỆU

Thông tin cơ bản

Tiêu đề Towards Solving the Hard Problem of Consciousness: The Varieties of Brain Resonances and the Conscious Experiences That They Support
Tác giả Stephen Grossberg
Trường học Neural Networks Research Institute
Chuyên ngành Neuroscience
Thể loại journal article
Năm xuất bản 2016
Thành phố Unknown
Định dạng
Số trang 187
Dung lượng 14,69 MB

Các công cụ chuyển đổi và chỉnh sửa cho tài liệu này

Nội dung

Towards solving the hard problem of consciousness: The varieties of brain resonances and the conscious experiences that they support.. Neural This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript

Trang 1

Stephen Grossberg

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.neunet.2016.11.003

Received date: 2 August 2016

Accepted date: 20 November 2016

Please cite this article as: Grossberg, S Towards solving the hard problem of consciousness: The varieties of brain resonances and the conscious experiences that they support Neural

This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.

Trang 4

 ".1'3##0-,,!#&#-/6*',)0/#0-,,1"6,+'!0'-!(',"(.,&"'444444

&#1 '*'16#*+""+/ "#$$%'")%"% !)&, !&,+"00000000

 &$'#$%+)/)&**"% +)$*&))'+"&% & %"+"&%%' +"&%0000

('(%(+,)+"' ' ),''.-,4444444444444444444 '+.*#%%,'!"++!"%+,(%.-"('(.'+-"'-2444444444444444 ( '"3"' 0"-!(.-,"' (&)%1%%,"&)%2-!-%%(.'+",+"'/","%4444 (.'+2(&)%-"(''")(% +(.)"' %%,444444444444444444

'!"++!"%+,(%.-"('(.'+-"'-244444444444444444444  &6/#0-,,!#

 ++%+"&%-*)"%+"% ,)"%  + &)/)%"% 00000000000000000

 (#!111#,1'-, 61-."-4,+-"2*1-/6-,!#,1#/-$$,.++(.''-0(+$444444 &6.-1&#0'01#01',%,"*#/,',%-$./#"'!1'3#/#!( '"-"('- (+244444444

,(%/,,2&(% +(.'"' 444444444444444444444444444  #12/#- (+2+,('',,.))(+-(#- '-"('%+'"' '+( '"-"('4444

Trang 6

%./0 3$0 %/ 0$! &   %'%,! %

$+3/!*/0%+*/-1%.!$.0!.%/0%//1$/+(+./* 0/0!/'2% $()!./3$+%*0.+ 1! 0$! ()!   "  ($)#  $ 

!4,(*0%+*+"3$00$%*# +!/$+3%0$*#!/+2!.0%)!* $+3%0%/,100+#!0$!.10!2!*"0!.3!$2!!4,(%*! 0$!"1*0%+*( 5*)%(* /0.101.(,.+,!.0%!/+"0$!+*/%+1/)%* 3!*

+"+*/%+1/*!//3%(($2!0+#+!5+* 0$!1/1()!0$+ /+"/%!*!+*/%+1/*!//0$!.!"+.!,.!/!*0/

$ ,.+(!)"+./%!*!+.,!.$,/%0).'/0$!(%)%0/+"3$0/%!*!*!4,(%*4,(%*%*#3$5

+*/%+1/*!// +1./ 0 (( * ! +*0./0!  3%0$ /+ &$ '  !  0$!

!4,(%*! 1/%*#0$!1/1()!0$+ /+"/%!*!100$0(!2!/0$!-1!/0%+*+"3$50$!.!%//+)!0$%*#%0

Trang 7

!) ($  &" &#"'  &(  ')!!&.' '#! # ( )""( ,$&!"(  *" ((  

#"'#)''(('&&'#""('(('#( &"-"!'&&'#""("()'#"'#)'"'''

"#()'(+&#"#&!(#"$&#''"

   "#+#&"(&'#""('(('')$$#&(&"("'##"'#)'%) #(&'#(#"'%) -!$#&("("#'&'#""('(( (#!#-#"'#)',$&"

" #&& (# $&#* *" $&(  "'+&' (# (' %)'(#"' ( (#&- +   )' (# ,$ " #+

*&#)'*# )(#"&- "'((*"&"'"#&&(#$((#"""*&#"!"('"

& (!*"!(+($&() &#"'#)''(('"#+('#"'#)''(('#&!$&(# &&$(**#& $ ('"('&&((#&-&)'(()!"'&"#(#"'#)'

(#((&$((#(+#& '""!"'# )'(&((' !'((#&-$&#$#''#+(

&""&('&'#""'((')$$#&($&() &#"'#)',$&"'#'"&" ""

"#+""'##"(')'('#+&'#""'#&#"'#)''" $(#"')&(*&"

&'#""'#&#"'#)'&" $(#"')&(*'$""&'#""'#&#"'#)' "

Trang 8

/%.(#-0'%,($'(0,(&-!"' ,(.-"-'!/))+()+"-%"' ,-!-+"+--(0+,"-

&"++(+"'  )+()+-", ( ,.#-"/ +)(+-, ( -!, *.%" '+- (,+/% - (.- -!,

1)+"', -!- + (%%- "' ),2!(%( "% ' '('"'/,"/ '.+("(%( "% 1)+"&'-, ('

!.&', ' + (',",-'- 0"-! ),2!(%( "% &.%-")%%-+( '.+()!2,"(%( "% - ' (-!+-2), ( '.+("(%( "% - -!- + (%%- +(& &('$2, 0!( 1)+"' -! ,& ,-"&.%.,

('"-"(',

"/',.!-"%(++,)('',0"-!1)+"'*.%"'&.%-")%-2),(-"-'

-!-&(2 "'"/".% (',"(., 1)+"', (' -! ),2!(%( "% %/%  ,.!  (++,)(''

-0' -"% +"' +)+,'--"(', ' -"% )+()+-", ( (',"(., *.%" (.+, (+ ,.""'-%2 %+  (2 ( ),2!(%( "% - -!' "- 0(.% )+(/" ,-+('  /"' -!- -!, +"'+)+,'--"(', +- ' ,.))(+- -!, (',"(., 1)+"',   -!(+2 ( -!", $"' 0(.% !/

Trang 9

#&,""&'&!!(%"""&'&%" )!''',)$(%!')(!%&'!!"

(%%!' %'&( %-&'"%, #')&"!!"%,"% ''+#!&!(% !& &!#&,""(!'"!&",! %!&''&*"&#%"#%'&   &(')

#%"#%'& " !)( "!&"(& +#%!& )! & ', +#! #% '% #%"#%'& " !,

#&,"" ' "(' '& +#%!& !(! '% &#'"' #"% ,! &  &"

#%"#"&&!*'%!%"!&'&,! &''& ,"(%!"*'&,! &''& ,

%&%" (!&'"&%!(% !& &)!*!',%%,"('%!'(!'"!

%"&!#'))"%&(&!%!'#%'&"'%!



 # ! &,!%"!- *! ', !'%' ) %#%" +''"%,  &!& (%!  '!#%"&&''"(%&'*!"''" (#!'"#"*!#'*,&'!'')'&"'&

&,!%"!- & "&' ! #& *' "! !"'% &"!'!  ')'& &" "(& ''!'"!(#"!&(&'"&'%,%,!"*'%!!" "!&"(&"''!)!'& '&

#') %&"!! *! ' "(%& ! %!' &#- !'" & '' %) %!'',#& "

Trang 10

+*/') %*)# 

&+####*++*,*+ %%'+ -)*&%%$0)')*%+&%* &,*&%+%+*&%/') %

/'# %*.0&%#0##*++)*%* + -+&+" %*&'*0&#& # *) $ %+ &%*&#&)

)++)$&  + %+&%* &,*/') %%&+ *%.0+* *) $ %+ &%*%

&,) &%#0 + ')*)  *+* & ) % ')&** % ,)&'0* &#& # + &,+ ')'+,#

/') %* # "  %&,#) ) -#)0 ##,*+)+ + * +  &&++ *   % %,)# $&#* -



%)# +% ++ & &%* &,*%** +% *,  +&)0 %* +& /'# % 0 ++ * *& % &.

&%* &,* *++* ) * )&$ ++ $&) %)# ,%+ &% ) % 0%$ * % #*& &,) ++ & %&+ %#,%0'&**  # +0&)*&%%%&+#0,) %+%)+ &%&*'+ #%$&+&))')*%++ &%*

%+,*$0%&+*,''&)+%0&%* &,*/') %*+ &% 

 ,))%+ )+ # ')&'&** %*.)* +& +* (,*+ &%* %  + &% 0 /'# % % %,)#

$% *$* % '*0&#& # ,%+ &%* & '+ - )*&%%* % *' 0 % + ,%+ &%#

%+&$ # % %,)&'0* &#& #  )%* +.% )*&%%* ++ % *,''&)+ &%* &,*

/') %*&* %) % # %%"%& % ')&- **%&+ &-  , +&&.

$%0  )%+ " %* & ,+,) /') $%+* $0  * % +& ')&-  $&) %&)$+ &% &,+ +

) %)*&%%*++*,''&)+&%* &,*/') %*&(,# 

&)/'# % %&.%#) 0+) %*,*+)+*&&%* &,*/') %* + *,*,#+&)# 1++.*%&+-#&'+&/'# %&%* &,*%**+) +.*-#&'+&/'# %%') + #) '*0&#& # %%,)& &#& # +** &,+ #)% % ')'+ &% &% + &% %

$&+ &%%&))+& -*#&%+ %/'&* + &%%&+#0+&%#%.+/'#%+ &%*%') + &%* +&  ,%)*+&& &,+  + * +)&) %**)0 +& )- . *'+* & &. 

/'# %*+.&*')&')+ *%+,)##0#+&%,)#)')*%++ &%*&&%* &,*(,# +#*&%*+&  $'* 1 ++ + ,))%+ )+ # /'# %* $, $&) + &,+ &%* &,*%** +% *')- &,*#0%&%,* %&)%0&+)+&)0+/+%*)+)+%!,*+)-  % +

)+ ##*&,%  *')###*+)$*&$&# %+ - +0++-%*')+#0-#&',+.&*+**')+$&# %*+)$*+,*%+&)- .*&+++ )*0%+* *%*)  %

Trang 11

3/%*0.+ 1! 0+

!4,(%* $+3 .%*/ /+(2! 0$! /0%(%05,(/0%%05 %(!)) %*! %0/ %*0.+ 10%+* %* .+//!.#       $/ !!* %*.!)!*0((5 !2!(+,!  %*0+  +#*%0%2! *  *!1.( 0$!+.5 +" $+3 0$! .%*

%* %2% 1( +*/%+1/ !4,!.%!*!/ / !)+ %!  3%0$%* 0$! /,0%+0!),+.( ,00!.*%*# +" !(( 0%2%0%!/1*%0/+"/$+.00!.) )!)+.5 * (+*#0!.) )!)+.5,.+2! 0$00$!"1*0%+*( 1*%0/+"

/00!/ 0$0 "+1/ 00!*0%+* 1,+* 0$! .%0%( "!01.!/ 0$0 !,.!/!*0 ,.! %0%2! *!1.( %*"+.)0%+*

Trang 12

+0%.7&+0) 6*15' ('#674' 2#66'405 6*#6 '/$1&; 6*' 2#4#/'64+% 2412'46+'5 1( +0&+8+&7#. %105%+175':2'4+'0%'5 +)74'  7%* &+5%18'4+'5 4'2'#6'& /7.6+2.' 6+/'5 18'4 # 2'4+1& 1( &'%#&'5 '& 61 #

&4+8+0) (#56 '#40+0) 6*#6 +0%14214#6'5 6*' #66'0&'& %4+6+%#. ('#674' 2#66'40 +061 $16* 6*' $1661/72

#&#26+8'(+.6'456*#6#%6+8#6'4'%1)0+6+10%#6')14+'5#0&6*'612&190':2'%6#6+1056*#6#4'4'#&176$;6*'/

%#75'&%#6#56412*+%(14)'66+0)

!*' 241%'55'5 6*#6 #4' 57//#4+<'& $; 6*'   /0'/10+% #4' 4'.#6'& 61 10' #016*'4 +052'%+(+%9#;56*#625;%*1.1)+%#. #0&0'741$+1.1)+%#.&#6#*#8'5722146'&14':#/2.'#66'06+10#0&.'#40+0)#4'.+0-'&+0#/#00'4%105+56'069+6*!24'&+%6+105#$1768+57#.2'4%'267#..'#40+0)')

#7&+614;.'#40+0)')#1#0& 7)# #0&51/#615'0514;.'#40+0)')472#*#<#0(#4#0&9*'0 #0& *19 2'4%'267#. '#40+0) %#0 1%%74 9+6*176 (1%75'& #66'06+10 14 %105%+175 #9#4'0'55 ')

$'69''0 #66'06+10 #0& 5;0%*410175 15%+ #6+105 6*#6 9'4' 57$5'37'06.; ':2'4+/'06# ; 4'2146'& ')

Trang 13

*,)*)-  &#(%! .1( -3(",)()/- )-#&&.#)(- ( )(-#)/-(  1#.")/.  .#&

)'*/..#)(&."),3.)&#(%'"(#-.#*,)*,.#-) ,-)((.,#(-..-.)*,'.,#&*,)*,.#-) 

#(#0#/&)(-#)/-*-3")&)!#&2*,#(-((2*&(.#)() 1",(1"3*,.#/&,%#(-) ,-)((-)/,#(.",#(.)-/**),.# ,(.-/$.#02*,#(-."#-*,)*)-&)-().,#-.)." &0& )   ,/ "),3 )  )(-#)/- 1,( .#)(  *,)0#-  )'*,.#0 #-/ #)( ) -0,&**,)"-.)2*&#(#(!)(-#)/-( 

2*&#((*,#.#(,-#(!&3&,!"0#),& ((/,)#)&)!#&.--,(!#(! ,)'(),'&

( (),'& -*.- )  "/'( ( (#'& *,*.#)( ( )!(#.#)( ) " -*#%#(! ( )-#&&.),3

3('#-) "#,,"#&&3),!(#4&'#(, "&')),.#& (),.#)),.#& (.1),%-#( '/&.#*&')&#.#- ( -)'  ')&- #(#0#/&&3 2*&#( -#'/&. ( *,#. "0#),&

(.)'#& (/,)*"3-#)&)!#& #)*"3-#& ( 0( #)"'#& .  /,,(.&3 *,)0#- /(.#)(& ( '"(#-.# 2*&(.#)(- )  . )(,(#(! -/" #0,- )*#- - &'#(, ),.#&

#,/#.,3 #(0,#(. )$. ( -(# !#-. &,(#(! ( ,)!(#.#)( *,).).3* -/,  ( )/(,3

 (.#)( !'' ( . )-#&&.#)(- &,(#(! )  (.),"#(&!,# &&- ( "#**)'*& *& &&-

)'*/..#)( )  ")')&)!)/- -*.#& ( '*),& '"(#-'- #( " (.),"#(&"#**)'*& -3-.'0#!#&(,%)1(-/,#(!/.#-'('#&.'*),&'(-#)!(#.#0').#)(&#(.,.#)(-.". )/- (.#)()(0&/)$.-#((*.#0&3.#'13.',,(%1),%#(!''),#-(

&,( &#-. "/(%- ), " *&((#(! ( )(.,)& )  -+/(- )  &#(!/#-.# -*.#& ( ').),

#( ),'.#)()(-#)/--*"*,*.-.".,#( &/(3 /./,)(.2./#.),3-.,'#(!#(()#-

Trang 14

!2/&+$ 0,2/ " 0"$/"$1&,+ +! 0-"("/ +,/*)&71&,+ /&+ /"$&,+0 4%,0" #2+ 1&,+0 /" )/&#&"! 6

 &+ )2!" 3&02) +! 2!&1,/6 +", ,/1"5 0-" &#&  +! +,+0-" &#&  1%)*&  +2 )"& &+#"/,1"*-,/)-/&"1) -/"#/,+1) "+1,/%&+) %& , *-) -/%& , *-) -"/&/%&+) +! *,1,/ ,/1& "0 #/,+1)

"6" #&")!0 02 )"*"+1/6 "6" #&")!0 *6$!) 0) $+$)& "/""))2* +! 02-"/&,/ ,))& 2)20

%"0" 2+&#&"! "5-)+1&,+0 ,# *+6 !&##"/"+1 16-"0 ,# !1 &+ /"0"! ,+#&!"+ " &+ 1%" "*"/$&+$ )00&#& 1&,+,#/"0,++ "0

%"/1& )"#&/01!"0 /&"0/"0,++ "01%102 ,/1)" 3&02)0""&+$(+,4&+$+!/" %&+$

"*,1&,+)#"")&+$(+,4&+$+! 1&+$" 1&,+ 4%&)")0,-/,-,0&+$%,41%"0"3/&,20(&+!0,#/"0,++ "0*6&+1"/ 1 1,$"1%"/ ,*-/1&3"!&0 200&,+,#0,*",1%"/-/,*&+"+1 ,+1/&21&,+01,

/&+0-/, "00&+$,#3&02)2!&1,/6 ,$+&1&3"+!##" 1&3"0&$+)0%&0&+ )2!"0#/,+1)11 (,+4,/(0 &+3,)3"0 )&+("! -/, "00"0 ,# ,+0 &,20+"00 "/+&+$ 5-" 11&,+ 11"+1&,+ "0,++ " +!

2!&1,/6 ,$+&1&3"+!##" 1&3"/"-/"0"+11&,+0/"1%1"*"/$"#/,*1%"0"-/, "00"0" 20"&#,+"

!,"0 +,1 2+!"/01+!  ),1 ,21 %,4 3&0&,+ 2!&1&,+ ##" 1 +! /" ,$+&1&,+  12))6 4,/( 1%"+ ,+" ++,1 06 +61%&+$ !""- ,21 %,4 4%"+ +! 4%6 1%"&/ /"-/"0"+11&,+0 ,# &+!&3&!2) "5-"/&"+ "0

Trang 16

0)'4.'+&'4#0&#%-1   *' 8'064#. 564'#/ ':*+$+65 2412'46+'56*#6 #4'1(6'0%1/276#6+10# ;

%1/2.'/'06#4; 61 6*15' 1( 6*' &145#. 14 "*'4' #0& 19 %146+%#. 241%'55+0) 56'#/ (14 52#6+#.

  0' 4'#510 (14 6*+5 "*#6"*'4' %1/2.'/'06#4+6; +5 6*#6 6*' "*#6 564'#/ '#405 1$,'%64'%1)0+6+10 %#6')14+'5 6*#6 #4' 57$56#06+# ; +08#4+#06 70&'4 %*#0)'5 +0 #0 1$,'%65 8+'9 5+<' #0&

9+6*176':2'4+'0%+0)#%1/$+0#614+#.':2.15+10*';%#0016*19'8'4.1%#6'#0&#%67210#&'5+4'&1$,'%6+052#%'"*'4'564'#/52#6+#.#0&/16144'24'5'06#6+105%#0 1%#6'1$,'%65#0&64+))'4#%6+105619#4&5 6*'/ $76 %#0016 4'%1)0+<' 6*'/ ; +06'4#%6+0) 61)'6*'4 6*' "*#6 #0& "*'4' 564'#/5 %#0

&11%%741.'55+/2146#06+56*'(#%66*#6)11&'017)*/#6%*'5$'69''0':2'%6'&#0&#%67#.'8'06564+))'4 4'510#06 56#6'5 6*#6 %#0 5722146 '#40+0) 1( 0'9 4'%1)0+6+10 %#6')14+'5 #0& 4'(+0'/'06 1( 1.&10'59*+.'#.5164+))'4+0)%105%+1754'%1)0+6+101(6*'%4+6+%#.('#674'2#66'4056*#6#4'#66'0&'&#52#46

Trang 17

40&78.(.8= ).0*11& 278*&) 74&8.&0 1&47 &2) 13836 ,&.27 *<4*6.*2(* (&8&78634-.( +36,*88.2, &7 8-*=0*&62 -3; 83 &((96&8*0= (328630 396 (-&2,.2, '3).*7 8-639,-398 0.+* "3,*8-*6 8-*7* (3140*1*28&6=463(*77*7(6*&8*&7*0+78&'.0.>.2,4*6(*489&0(3,2.8.:*+6328*2).28-*$-&8786*&1+360*&62.2,&'3988-* ;360) &2) '*(31.2, (327(.397 3+ 8 ;-.0* 8 28*00.,*280= (311&2)7 136* 0&'.0* 74&8.&013836463(*77*7.28-*$-*6*786*&18-&8(328630396(-&2,.2,'3).*7

1&8(-.2,(&2238,*2*6&8*(327(.397.28*62&06*46*7*28&8.327

"-*7*(32)(31498&8.32&04&6&).,1.7(&00*)&1.2&631498.2,&1.2&631498.2,)*7(6.'*7-3;8-* (*6*'6&0 (368*< 7 36,&2.>*) 283 0&=*6*) (.6(9.87 ;-37* 74*(.&0.>&8.327 7944368 &00 -.,-*636)*6'.303,.(&0 28*00.,*2(* 2)**) 8-* 0&1.2&6 (.6(9.87 3+ (*6*'6&0 (368*< 7**1 83 6*&0.>* & 6*:3098.32&6=(31498&8.32&0 7=28-*7.7 3+ 8-* '*78 4634*68.*7 3+ +**)+36;&6) &2) +**)'&(/ 463(*77.2, ).,.8&0 &2)

&2&03, 463(*77.2, &2) )&8&)6.:*2 '3883194 463(*77.2, &2) -=438-*7.7)6.:*2 834)3;2 463(*77.2,(368.(&013)*073+:.7.3274**(-&2)(3,2.8.3274*(.+.(&00=.28-*  "13)*03+ :.7.32

&)).8.32&0 27.,-87 283 -3; 74*(.&0.>*) 6*732&2(*7 97* 7.1.0&6 8=4*7 3+ (.6(9.87 83 7944368 ).++*6*28(327(.397*<4*6.*2(*7

.,96* 

236)*683 92)*678&2)-3;&796+&(*7-639)6*732&2(*(&27944368 (327(.3977**.2,3+:.79&059&0.&

*<40&2&8.327 ;.00 (0&6.+= ;-= 796+&(*7-639) 6*732&2(*7 &6* 46*).(8*) 83 '* 86.,,*6*) '= 28*6&(8.327'*8;**2 46*786.&8* :.79&0 (368.(&0 &6*& #

Ngày đăng: 26/07/2023, 07:40

TỪ KHÓA LIÊN QUAN

TÀI LIỆU CÙNG NGƯỜI DÙNG

TÀI LIỆU LIÊN QUAN

🧩 Sản phẩm bạn có thể quan tâm

w