The activities of the enzymes lysine 2-oxo-glutate reductase and saccharopine dehydrogenase, both involved in lysine degradation in the maize endosperm were also determined and shown to
Trang 1Regulation of maize lysine metabolism and endosperm protein
synthesis by opaque and floury mutations
Ricardo A Azevedo1, Catherine Damerval2, Jacques Landry3, Peter J Lea4, Cla´udia M Bellato5,
Lyndel W Meinhardt6, Martine Le Guilloux2, Sonia Delhaye3, Alejandro A Toro1, Salete A Gaziola1 and Bertha D A Berdejo1
1
Departamento de Gene´tica, Escola Superior de Agricultura Luiz de Queiroz, Universidade de Sa˜o Paulo, Sa˜o Paulo, Brazil;
2
Station de Ge´ne´tique Ve´ge´tale INRA/UPS/INA-PG/CNRS UMR 8120, La Ferme du Moulon, Gif-sur-Yvette;3INRA, Laboratoire
de Chimie Biologique, INA-PG, F78850 Thiverval-Grignon, France;4Department of Biological Sciences, University of Lancaster, Lancaster, UK;5Centro de Energia Nuclear na Agricultura, Universidade de Sa˜o Paulo, Sa˜o Paulo, Brazil; and6Departamento de Gene´tica e Evoluc¸a˜o, Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Campinas, Brazil
The capacity of two maize opaque endosperm mutants
(o1 and o2) and two floury (fl1 and fl2) to accumulate lysine
in the seed in relation to their wild type counterparts
Oh43+was examined The highest total lysine content was
3.78% in the o2 mutant and the lowest 1.87% in fl1, as
compared with the wild type (1.49%) For soluble lysine, o2
exhibited over a 700% increase, whilst for fl3 a 28% decrease
was encountered, as compared with the wild type In order to
understand the mechanisms causing these large variations in
both total and soluble lysine content, a quantitative and
qualitative study of the N constituents of the endosperm has
been carried out and data obtained for the total protein,
nonprotein N, soluble amino acids, albumins/globulins,
zeins and glutelins present in the seed of the mutants
Fol-lowing two-dimensional PAGE separation, a total of 35
different forms of zein polypeptides were detected and con-siderable differences were noted between the five different lines In addition, two enzymes of the aspartate biosynthetic pathway, aspartate kinase and homoserine dehydrogenase were analyzed with respect to feedback inhibition by lysine and threonine The activities of the enzymes lysine 2-oxo-glutate reductase and saccharopine dehydrogenase, both involved in lysine degradation in the maize endosperm were also determined and shown to be reduced several fold with the introduction of the o2, fl1 and fl2 mutations in the Oh43+inbred line, whereas wild-type activity levels were verified in the Oh43o1 mutant
Keywords: lysine metabolism; maize; storage proteins
Maize production is the highest of all crop plants and serves
as an important source of dietary protein for human and
livestock consumption However, the nutritional quality is
not adequate, due to the lack of the essential amino acids
lysine and tryptophan in the seed proteins [1]
Zeins, which account for 50–70% of the endosperm
proteins in maize seeds, have a characteristic amino acid
composition, being rich in glutamine and hydrophobic
amino acids, whilst being very poor in lysine and tryptophan
[2] Based on their solubility, genetic properties, and the
apparent molecular masses, zeins have been classified into a- (22 and 19 kDa), the most abundant, b- (14 kDa), c- (27 and 16 kDa) and d-zein (10 kDa) [3]
Four main strategies have been attempted in order to obtain plants with a high lysine seed content: plant breeding, characterization of naturally occurring mutants, induction
of biochemical mutants and the production of transgenic plants [4,5] Perhaps the most exciting result obtained during this research was the identification of the high-lysine opaque 2 (o2) maize mutant [6] Unfortunately, the high-lysine trait was negatively correlated with other agronomic characteristics, such as resistance to plant pathogens and yield [1] More recently, quality protein maize (QPM) varieties have been produced which maintain the high-lysine and high-tryptophan characteristics conditioned by the o2 mutation in a modified-vitreous endosperm, with favorable agronomic characteristics [7–9]
The amino acid lysine is derived from aspartate and the biosynthetic pathway involves the action of several strongly regulated enzymes [10] The enzyme aspartate kinase (AK;
EC 2.7.2.4), which converts aspartic acid into b-aspartyl phosphate, can exist in at least two distinct isoforms, one (or two) sensitive to lysine feedback inhibition and the other sensitive to threonine feedback inhibition, the latter being a bifunctional polypeptide with the threonine-sensitive homo-serine dehydrogenase isoenzyme (HSDH; EC 1.1.1.3) [11]
Correspondence to R A Azevedo, Departamento de Gene´tica, Escola
Superior de Agricultura Luiz de Queiroz, Universidade de Sa˜o Paulo,
Piracicaba CEP 13418–900, SP, Brazil.
Fax: +55 19 3433 6706, Tel.: +55 19 3429 4475,
E-mail: raazeved@esalq.usp.br
Abbreviations: AK, aspartate kinase; DHDPS, dihydrodipicolinate
synthase; HSDH, homoserine dehydrogenase; LOR, lysine
2-oxo-glutarate reductase; N, nitrogen; NPN, nonprotein nitrogen; PVPP,
insoluble polyvynylpyrrolidone; SDH, saccharopine dehydrogenase;
SAA, soluble amino acids.
Enzymes: AK (EC 2.7.2.4); HSDH (EC 1.1.1.3); LOR (EC 1.5.1.8);
SDH (EC 1.5.1.9); DHDPS (EC 4.2.1.52).
(Received 2 September 2003, accepted 22 October 2003)
Trang 2The AK isoenzymes have been characterized at both the
biochemical and molecular level in several plant species
[4,5,10,12], and shown to be a major factor in the regulation
of the carbon flux through the aspartate pathway [4,10]
HSDH catalyses the conversion of aspartate semialdehyde
to homoserine in the presence of the coenzymes NADH or
NADPH and is present in plant species in two isoforms,
resistant and sensitive to threonine inhibition [10] The
first enzyme unique to lysine synthesis,
dihydrodipicoli-nate synthase (DHDPS; EC 4.2.1.52) has also been
exten-sively studied and characterized in plants catalyzing the
condensation of pyruvate and aspartate semialdehyde
into dihydrodipicolinic acid [4] DHDPS is also subject
to feedback inhibition by micromolar concentrations of
lysine [4]
Several mutants that overproduce and accumulate
threo-nine have been obtained by selection on media containing
amino acids or their analogues and this phenomenon has
been shown to be due to alteration in the feedback pattern of
the lysine-sensitive AK isoenzyme [4] However, in the case of
cereal seeds, the mutants failed to accumulate lysine in higher
concentration [10,13,14] The development of plant
formation techniques has allowed the production of
trans-genic plants expressing the enzymes of lysine biosynthesis
that are insensitive to feedback regulation analogous to the
biochemical mutants Again, most of the plants did not
exhibit significant accumulation of lysine in the seed [4,12]
Positive results were however, obtained with barley, canola
and soybean transgenic seeds in which dramatic increases in
the lysine content were observed [5,15]
Very little was known about lysine catabolism in plant
until recently [5,12,16] The first two enzymatic steps are
catalyzed by the bifunctional protein lysine 2-oxoglutarate
reductase–saccharopine dehydrogenase (LOR–SDH; EC
1.5.1.8 and EC 1.5.1.9, respectively) LOR–SDH protein
has been studied in some plant species [17–21] where the
activity was particularly high in the endosperm tissue in
cereal crops [17,18] The regulation of the LOR activity has
been shown to be complex, involving several distinct
mechanisms [5,12,16]
Recent studies have confirmed that in order to obtain
lysine overproduction in cereal seeds, manipulation of lysine
degradation is needed [5,12,16] This suggestion is supported
by five main points [5]: (a) The cereal mutants or transgenic
plants do not exhibit significant accumulation of lysine in
the seeds; (b) LOR–SDH activities are endosperm specific in
cereal crops only; (c) LOR–SDH activities are drastically
reduced in the high-lysine o2 maize mutant as compared
with the wild-type; (d) lysine catabolism intermediates
accumulate in the seeds of lysine overproducing plants of
soybean and canola, indicating reduced LOR–SDH
acti-vities; and (e) LOR–SDH activities are lower in legume
plants and rice, which is the cereal crop with the highest
concentration of lysine in the seed
The product of the o2 gene is specifically expressed in the
endosperm and the protein was shown to activate the
transcription of the 22 kDa a-zein [22] and 14 kDa b-zein
genes [23], together with the b-32 [24] and cyPPDK1 (one of
two cytosolic isoforms of pyruvate orthophosphate
dikin-ase) genes [25] Other possible direct or indirect target genes
of the o2 factor have been shown to belong to various
metabolic pathways [26–28] In the o2 mutant, LOR–SDH
mRNA and protein quantities were severely reduced (about 90%), and the expression pattern during grain development was markedly modified [29] The genomic sequence of the gene and its 5¢ regulatory regions revealed the presence of o2 boxes in the upstream promoter, confirming the hypothesis
of a transcriptional control of the Lor/Sdh gene by the o2 protein [16] These large effects suggest that o2 protein may play an important role in the developing grain, as a coordinator of the expression of storage protein, and nitrogen and carbon metabolism genes [30]
Although there is now plenty of information available about o2, information related to lysine metabolism for several other similar mutants that have been classified as high-lysine and exhibit the opaque phenotype are very scarce A comprehensive investigation into these mutants was initiated, with the aim of obtaining new insights into the regulation of lysine metabolism in maize During the course
of this work Hunter et al [31] published an analysis of some
of these mutants Our work now extends the studies of Hunter et al [31] and provides further insights into the complex but critical regulation of lysine accumulation within the maize seed, reporting for the first time the biochemical characterization of these mutants using pro-teomic and enzymological approaches
Experimental procedures
Maize mutants Seeds of the mutant genotypes opaque (o1 and o2) and floury (fl1 and fl2) and the respective wild type, Oh43 +, were kindly provided by the Maize Genetics Cooperation Seed Stock Center (Urbana, IL, USA) Plants of all genotypes were grown in the glasshouse at ESALQ-USP, Brazil and self-pollinated Maize ears were harvested
20 days after pollination (DAP) directly into liquid nitrogen and stored at) 80 C until used for enzyme extraction The experiments were repeated over three summer seasons (1999–2000, 2000–01 and 2001–02)
Preparation of endosperm samples Endosperms were isolated from mature grains previously soaked in water for 30 min by peeling off the outer tegument and excising the germ After freeze drying, the endosperms were ground to a powder using a ball mill
Fractionation of nitrogen (N) constituents The isolation of endosperm N constituents was undertaken
in duplicate as previously described by Landry et al [32]
Quantitation of N constituents For an accurate quantitation, the nonprotein nitrogen (NPN) and protein content were determined by the ninhydrin assay of a-amino N released after alkaline digestion (3MNaOH, 130C, 45 min) for the TCA, E1,2, E4 extracts [32] or acid digestion (6MHCl, 110C, 18 h) for the E3 extract and residues, according to Landry et al [33] Soluble amino acids (SAA) were quantitated by ninhydrin without previous digestion of the TCA extracts [32]
Trang 3Amino acids analysis
Soluble amino acids from mature seeds were extracted and
analyzed exactly as described by Gaziola et al [9] As the
OPA-lysine derivative is rapidly degraded, a second analysis
was performed using a 15-min elution time Four replicates
were analyzed
Protein extraction and two-dimensional polyacrylamide
gel electrophoresis of zein polypeptides
The procedure for two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel
electrophoresis (2D-PAGE) analysis of zein isoforms
followed that published previously by Consoli and
Damer-val [34] Briefly, three sets of three mature kernels were
combined for each genotype and individually analyzed,
generating three independent replicates Embryos and
pericarp were manually excised, and the endosperms were
crushed in liquid nitrogen for each genotype The proteins
were resuspended in a urea-Triton X-100–2 ME buffer
Isoelectric focusing was performed in 10-cm long rod gels in
a pH gradient ranging from 5.5 to 8.5 Approximately
40 mg of total proteins were loaded on each gel The SDS
dimension was separated using a 14% acrylamide slab gel,
and staining was adapted from the colloidal Coomassie blue
method of Neuhoff et al [35] Images of the 2D patterns
were recorded and image analysis and spot detection were
carried out as described by Consoli and Damerval [34]
Specific zein protein extraction was previously used to
confirm the zein identity of the polypeptide spots visualized
in 2D gels [34]
Statistical analyses of zein isoform amounts
A previous analysis of colloidal Coomassie blue staining
intensity as a function of protein loading was carried out for
zein spots and it was demonstrated that for 86% of the
isoforms, a linear relationship was obtained [34] Differences
in total zein amounts loaded onto the gels were
compen-sated by scaling the raw integrated optical density of every
spot i in each gel j according to Consoli and Damerval [34]
One-way analysis of variance with the genotype as the
factor, were then performed for each spot on their scaled
integrated optical density, and a significant effect was
retained at P < 0.05
Enzymes partial purification and assays
All procedures were carried out at 4C unless stated
otherwise Four replicates each composed of five selected
maize ears, which were harvested (20 DAP), combined, and
mixed, were used for enzyme analysis
For the extraction of AK, frozen seeds were extracted in
five volumes of buffer A [50 mM Tris/HCl, 200 mMKCl,
0.1 mM phenylmethanesulfonyl fluoride, 0.1 mM EDTA,
1 mMdithiothreitol, 2 mM L-lysine, 2 mM L-threonine, 10%
(v/v) glycerol and 5% (w/v) insoluble polyvynylpyrrolidone
(PVPP), pH 7.4] The extract was filtered through three
layers of miracloth, and centrifuged at 16 000 g for 30 min
to remove the cellular debris Solid ammonium sulfate was
added slowly to 30% saturation with gently stirring for at
least 30 min The suspension was centrifuged at 16 000 g for
30 min and the supernatant subjected to a second ammo-nium sulfate precipitation at 60% saturation for 30 min with continuous stirring Precipitated protein was recovered
by centrifugation at 16 000 g for 30 min and the protein pellets were dissolved in a small volume of buffer B [25 mM Tris/HCl, 1 mM dithiothreitol, 0.1 mM L-lysine, 0.1 mM
L-threonine and 10% (v/v) glycerol, pH 7.4] The sample was loaded onto a Sephadex G25 column (2.5· 20 cm) equilibrated with five column volumes of buffer B and run under gravity The desalted sample was collected and assayed for AK activity
AK activity was assayed routinely in a final volume of
500 mL as described by Brennecke et al [28] Controls containing lysine and threonine were included to identify the isoenzymes sensitive to lysine and threonine Activity was expressed as nmolÆmin)1Æmg)1protein Four replications were carried out for each assay
For the extraction of HSDH, frozen seeds were extracted
in five volumes of buffer C [50 mMTris/HCl, 200 mMKCl, 0.1 mM phenylmethanesulfonyl fluoride, 1 mM EDTA,
3 mMdithiothreitol, 5 mM L-threonine, 10% (v/v) glycerol and 5% (w/v) PVPP, pH 7.5] The extract was filtered through three layers of miracloth, and centrifuged at
16 000 g for 30 min to remove completely cellular debris from the extract Solid ammonium sulfate was added slowly
to 30% saturation with gently stirring for at least 30 min The suspension was centrifuged at 16 000 g for 30 min and the supernatant subjected to a second ammonium sulfate precipitation at 60% saturation for 30 min with continuous stirring Precipitated protein was recovered by centrifuga-tion at 16 000 g for 30 min and the protein pellets were dissolved in a small volume of buffer D [25 mMTris/HCl,
1 mMEDTA, 1 mMdithiothreitol, 0.1 mM L-threonine and 10% (v/v) glycerol, pH 7.5] The sample was loaded onto a Sephadex G25 column (2.5· 20 cm) equilibrated with five column volumes of buffer D and run under gravity The desalted sample was collected and assayed for HSDH activity
HSDH activity was assayed routinely spectrophotomet-rically at 340 nm in a final volume of 1.1 mL at 30C as described by Azevedo et al [11] The effect of threonine on the HSDH activity was determined by the addition (10 mL
of a 1Msolution) of the amino acid to the assay mixture Activity was expressed as nmolÆmin)1Æmg)1protein Four replications were carried out for each assay
For the extraction of LOR–SDH, frozen seeds were extracted in five volumes of buffer E [100 mMpotassium phosphate, 50 mMKCl, 1 mMEDTA, 1 mMdithiothreitol, 0.1 mMphenylmethanesulfonyl fluoride, 10% (w/v) glycerol and 5% (w/v) PVPP, pH 7.0] The homogenate was first filtered through three layers of miracloth and then centri-fuged at 15 000 g for 30 min to remove cellular debris The supernatant was adjusted to 30% ammonium sulfate saturation by gently stirring for at least 30 min The suspension was centrifuged at 15 000 g for 30 min and the supernatant subjected to a second ammonium sulfate precipitation at 55% saturation for 30 min with continuous stirring After centrifugation at 15 000 g for 30 min, the sedimented proteins were dissolved in 10 mL of buffer E (minus phenylmethanesulfonyl fluoride and PVPP) The sample was then loaded onto a Sephadex G50 column (2.6· 20 cm) previously equilibrated with buffer F
Trang 4[100 mMTris/HCl, 1 mMdithiothreitol, 1 mMEDTA and
10% (v/v) glycerol, pH 7.4] and run under gravity The
desalted sample was collected and assayed for LOR and
SDH activities
LOR activity was routinely assayed
spectrophotometri-cally in a 1 mL cuvette at 30C by following the change in
absorbance at 340 nm over a 15-min period, with
appro-priate adjustments for a lysine-free blank as described by
Gaziola et al [18] Activity was expressed as nmol NADPH
oxidizedÆmin)1Æmg)1protein Four replications were carried
out for each assay
SDH activity was measured spectrophometrically in a
1 mL cuvette by following the rate of substrate-dependent
reduction of NAD+to NADH monitored at 340 nm at
30C over a 15-min period, with appropriate adjustments
for a saccharopine-free blank as described by Gaziola
et al [18] Activity was expressed as nmol NAD+reducedÆ
min)1Æmg)1protein Four replications were carried out for
each assay
Protein determination
Protein concentrations of the samples were determined as
described by Bradford [36] using bovine serum albumin as
a standard
Results
Distribution patterns of N constituents
Table 1 provides data concerning the percentage
contri-bution of the main N constituents present in opaque (o),
floury (fl) and wild-type (+) endosperms The amounts of
SAA and NPN were of the same magnitude for the
wild-type inbred line and all mutants The albumins and
globulins of the mutants exhibited variable amounts,
ranging from a value similar to that of the wild-type
inbred line (Oh43fl1), to a value 3.5-fold higher (Oh43o2)
The same mutant genotypes also marked the boundaries
of variation of zein for the mutants, with the Oh43o2
endosperm being the poorest in zeins, whereas Oh43fl1
exhibited the highest amounts of zeins, but still lower than
that of the wild-type Oh43+ In general, the mutants had
protein distribution patterns varying between that of
Oh43fl1, similar to that of the wild type, and that of
Oh43o2 From these results it was possible to assess the importance of lysine-rich nonzeins with accuracy, because
of the quantitation of nonprotein N and the exhaustive extraction of zeins Thus, the ratio of the nonzein content
of the mutants compared with that of Oh43+varied from 1.2 to 1.5 for most mutants, whereas for Oh43o2, a ratio
of 2.6 was calculated
Soluble lysine concentration The Oh43o2 mutant exhibited the highest relative concen-tration of soluble lysine followed by the Oh43fl2 mutant, whereas the Oh43o1 mutant exhibited the lowest relative concentration of soluble lysine, but still higher than that of the wild-type counterpart (Table 1) The Oh43o2 mutant also exhibited the highest absolute concentration of soluble lysine (7.35 nmolÆmg)1dry weight) followed by the Oh43fl2 mutant (5.29 nmolÆmg)1dry weight), whereas the Oh43o1 mutant exhibited the lowest absolute concentration of soluble lysine (1.65 nmolÆmg)1dry weight), but still higher than that of the wild-type counterpart (0.82 nmolÆmg)1dry weight) However, the total SAA pool also varied among the genotypes, indicating clear differences between the mutations The total SAA pool was increased slightly following the introduction of the mutations o2, fl1 and fl2, but was reduced by 20% by the o1 mutation (Table 1), however, the relative soluble lysine concentrations were increased considerably following the introduction of each mutation (Table 1)
2D-page Thirty-five zein polypeptides were detected in wild type Oh43+and Oh43o1, Oh43o2, Oh43fl1 and Oh43fl2 mutants Four polypeptides were identified as c27 kDa zeins, 10 as a22 kDa zeins, 15 as a19 kDa zeins, two as b14 kDa zeins, two as c16 kDa zeins and two as d10 kDa zeins, according to their apparent molecular masses in the SDS dimension (Fig 1)
Between 20 and 31 zein isoforms were detected according
to the genotype (Table 2) The mutations decreased the number of zein isoforms detected on the 2D gels as compared with the wild-type, indicating a decrease in zein amount and diversity (Fig 2) The effect of each mutation
on the amount of every isoform was tested using analyses of
Table 1 Quantitation of N constituents Percentage contribution of N constituents present in opaque (o), floury (fl) and wild-type (Oh43+) endosperms Data expressed as percentage (± standard deviation) of endosperm total N N constituents: SAA, soluble amino acids; NPN, nonprotein N; A +G, albumins +globulins corresponding to E1,2 – NPN; non- zeins corresponding to glutelins (Glu) +albumins +globulins;
P, endosperm total proteins expressed as percentage of dry matter Soluble lysine is expressed as percentage of total soluble amino acids pool (± standard deviation) followed by the percentage increase in soluble lysine in relation to the wild type.
Genotypes
N constituents
Lysine % increase SAA NPN A+G Zeins Glu Non-zeins P% DM
Oh43+0.75 (0.07) 1.6 3.2 (0.28) 77.4 (1.8) 17.8 (1.0) 21.0 (0.6) 10.8 0.33 (0.02) –
Oh43o1 0.60 (0.07) 2.4 4.0 (0.20) 68.6 (0.4) 25.0 (0.7) 29.0 (0.5) 11.6 0.53 (0.02) 61 Oh43o2 0.95 (0.00) 2.9 11.1 (0.35) 41.5 (1.2) 44.5 (1.6) 55.6 (1.2) 8.7 2.70 (0.07) 718 Oh43fl1 0.82 (0.07) 1.9 3.7 (0.28) 71.9 (0.8) 22.5 (1.1) 26.2 (0.8) 12.8 0.83 (0.02) 151 Oh43fl2 0.94 (0.14) 2.7 6.7 (0.35) 64.8 (0.2) 25.8 (0.6) 32.5 (0.2) 11.2 1.46 (0.10) 342
Trang 5variance on standardized spot volumes (see Methods) The
o2and fl2 mutations had large effects, as about 60% of the
isoforms differed in amount as compared with the wild type
Conversely, Oh43o1 and Oh43fl1 mutants exhibited zein
patterns and contents similar to those of their wild-type
counterpart, in agreement with the data of Table 1
The pattern of c27 kDa isoforms was the most strongly
affected by the fl2 mutation, as all the polypeptides
disappeared, in contrast, fl1 had little effect Among the
10 a22 kDa zein class isoforms, only one appeared in a
similar amount in all of the mutants and wild type (a22z2,
Fig 1, 2) The mutations generally decreased the amount of
the isoforms as compared with the wild type Among the 15
a19 kDa zein class isoforms, five were unaffected in the
mutants The Oh43fl2 mutant exhibited the strongest effect
on this zein class, altering the amount of nine isoforms,
amongst which, two occurred specifically in this mutant (e.g
a19z114, Fig 1, 2) The mutations fl2 and o2 had a parallel
effect on b14 kDa and d10 kDa zein isoforms, but the effect
of fl2 was less pronounced than that of o2 In all, the o2
mutation markedly altered the pattern of low molecular
mass zeins, as compared with the wild type
Lysine metabolism
In this study, the enzymes AK, HSDH, LOR and SDH
were extracted initially from the developing seeds (16, 20
and 24 DAP) of the wild type, which indicated that the
main peak of activity of AK (4.32, 7.91 and
3.10 nmolÆmin)1Æmg)1protein at 16, 20 and 24 DAP,
res-pectively), HSDH (5.24, 16.31 and 6.16 nmolÆmin)1Æmg)1
protein at 16, 20 and 24 DAP, respectively), LOR (2.05,
3.53 and 2.18 nmolÆmin)1Æmg)1protein at 16, 20 and 24 DAP, respectively) and SDH (2.37, 3.51 and 2.08 nmolÆ min)1Æmg)1protein at 16, 20 and 24 DAP, respectively) was
at 20 DAP The activities of the enzymes involved in lysine metabolism have been studied in maize endosperm, exhi-biting a peak of activity between 16 and 24 DAP depending
on the enzyme [9,28] In this study, the activities of the enzymes AK, HSDH, LOR and SDH were determined in extracts isolated from the wild-type 16, 20 and 24 DAP and the maximum activity for all enzymes was confirmed as 20 DAP Based on this peak of enzyme activity, all genotypes were subsequently analyzed at 20 DAP
The activity of AK varied considerably among all genotypes, ranging from 2.78 nmolÆmin)1Æmg)1protein in Oh43fl1)15.29 nmolÆmin)1Æmg)1protein in the Oh43fl2 (Table 3) The Oh43o1 and Oh43fl2 mutants exhibited higher activities (12 and 85%, respectively) when compared with the wild type, whereas the mutants Oh43o2 and Oh43fl1 exhibited lower activities (40 and 66%, respect-ively) The inhibition by lysine was shown to be reduced in all four mutants when compared with the wild type (60.8% inhibition), ranging from 28.9% in the Oh43fl1 mutant to 55.6% in the Oh43o1 mutant The inhibitory effect of threonine on AK activity was much lower when compared with the effect of lysine, resulting in 11.1% inhibition of AK activity in the wild type, 15.6% in the Oh43fl2 mutant and 3.34% in the Oh43fl1 mutant, whereas a slight stimulation
of AK activity was induced by threonine in the Oh43o2 mutant When both amino acids were added together, a more intense inhibitory effect was observed, with the wild-type Oh43+exhibiting the highest inhibitory effect (92.5%) and the Oh43fl1 the lowest (41.8%) (Table 3)
Fig 1 Two-dimensional separation of zein isoforms isolated from the endosperms of maize seeds in the Oh43 background, using isoelectric focusing and SDS/PAGE Wild-type Oh43+ key isoforms are indicated with black arrows The white arrow points to an isoform appearing specifically in the fl2 mutant Molecular masses and pH range are indicated along the gel.
Trang 6The activity of HSDH varied considerably among all
genotypes, ranging from 17.4 nmolÆmin)1Æmg)1protein
in Oh43+to 38.4 nmolÆmin)1Æmg)1protein in Oh43o2
(Table 3) All mutants exhibited higher activities when
compared with the wild-type, with the Oh43o2 mutant
exhibiting a 2.2-fold higher HSDH activity The effect of
threonine was tested on HSDH activity, exhibiting an
inhibitory effect in the wild-type and Oh43o2, Oh43fl1 and
Oh43fl2 mutants, but stimulating HSDH activity in the
Oh43o1 mutant (Table 3)
Table 3 shows the activities of the enzymes LOR and
SDH, both involved in lysine degradation, which were also
measured for all genotypes Large variations were observed
for LOR activity, varying from 0.49 nmol NADPH
oxi-dized min)1Æmg)1protein in Oh43fl2)3.83 nmol NADPH
oxidized min)1Æmg)1protein in Oh43o1, which was even
higher than the activity in the wild type (3.50 nmol NADPH
oxidized min)1Æmg)1protein) (Table 3) The Oh43o2
mutant exhibited a sixfold reduction of LOR activity, a
reduction that was even higher (7.1-fold) in the Oh43fl2
mutant Reduction of LOR activity was also observed in the Oh43fl1 mutant (40% lower) when compared with the wild type, whereas in the Oh43o1 mutant the activity was slightly higher than the wild type Similar reductions in SDH activity along with LOR, were also induced by the o2, fl1 and fl2 mutations and thus the LOR/SDH ratio did not exhibit major variations
Discussion
The opaque and floury mutations and their respective wild-type (Oh43+) were obtained from the Maize Genetics Cooperation Seed Stock Center (USA) and cultivated in Brazil for three successive summer seasons Very little variation among the genotypes was observed for time of flowering indicating a similar developmental behavior, which would be expected as all mutants are in the same genetic background This also allowed the self-pollination and production of seeds for all genotypes The content of the various N constituents in the endosperm is dependent on
Table 2 Two dimensional separation of zeins isolated from maize endosperms Thirty-five zein isoforms were revealed Mean values of spot volumes are indicated Each isoform number is prefixed by the name of the zein class Statistical analyses were performed to test for significant differences in isoform amounts, and genotypes sharing a same letter did not differ significantly (a indicates an amount significantly greater than b).
c27z28 7009.92(a) 8712.80(a) 8342.94(a) 8406.33(a) 0 c27z21 29520.46(a) 10278.86(b) 0 16517.54(ab) 0 a22z4 51353.85(a) 50168.37(a) 41558.61(a) 60342.63(a) 0
a22z31 7140.23(a) 4266.46(a) 0 5461.84(a) 0 a22z3 26824.27(a) 24194.50(a) 4797.66(b) 24681.31(a) 25758.31(a) a22z2 26413.60(a) 32646.71(a) 26387.42(a) 32919.48(a) 28709.67(a) a22z18 9363.84(a) 6607.25(a) 0 7301.23(a) 0 a22z12 18884.57(a) 19780.78(a) 13033.15(a) 25436.17(a) 0
a22z11 23365.92(a) 18853.00(a) 0 23972.68(a) 19571.06(a) a22z1 81282.15(a) 73752.64(ab) 44042.71(b) 101923.68(a) 88989.89(a)
a19z9 51483.41(a) 43735.68(a) 50534.32(a) 42954.38(a) 52618.48(a) a19z8 25934.51(c) 18027.17(c) 72930.41(a) 33846.97(bc) 47679.73(b) a19z7 65109.57(a) 50561.34(a) 70261.18(a) 50230.13(a) 46370.74(a) a19z6 65917.49(a) 78276.12(a) 79297.66(a) 75690.34(a) 62619.74(a) a19z5 92886.09(a) 99287.19(a) 79080.27(a) 63968.14(a) 61067.52(a)
a19z30 7646.58(b) 0 17683.49(a) 6122.26(b) 0 a19z23 10831.41(b) 22279.91(a) 8024.70(b) 8822.52(b) 27136.28(a) a19z20 16394.55(a) 19023.76(a) 2706.90(b) 12926.97(a) 15690.45(a)
a19z17 19406.44(a) 20261.95(a) 10550.99(b) 19055.38(ab) 18178.69(ab)
a19z10 45064.00(a) 43462.53(a) 51245.73(a) 51198.85(a) 46990.69(a)
c16z13 31426.21(b) 37841.49(b) 118849.72(a) 44790.63(b) 23034.16(b) b14z33 7480.22(a) 7535.85(a) 0 6828.42(a) 0 b14z14 71467.31(ab) 83184.64(a) 39052.79(c) 73327.86(ab) 51025.04(bc) d10z16 43782.08(bc) 52390.91(bc) 109105.04(a) 27284.15(c) 75793.39(ab)
Trang 7genetic and environmental factors With the view of
dissociating these two factors, the present results were
compared with data taken from the literature and
concern-ing the same genotypes, but cultivated at diverse locations:
Bergamo, Italy [37]; Orsay, France [32]; LaFayette, USA [38]; and Tucson, USA [31] Furthermore, for a better comparison, the genotypes were ranked according to an increasing content of zeins (Table 4): (a) Zein percentages
Fig 2 Mutants Oh43o1, Oh4 3o2, Oh4 3fl1 and Oh43fl2 The arrows point to the isoforms indicated on the wild-type gel (Fig 1).
Table 3 Determination of activity of enzymes involved in lysine metabolism AK specific activity (nmolÆmin)1Æmg protein)1), HSDH specific activity (nmolÆmin)1Æmg protein)1), LOR specific activity (nmol NADPH oxidizedÆmin)1Æmg protein)1) and SDH specific activity (nmol NAD + reducedÆmin)1Æmg protein)1) were determined in extracts of 20 DAP maize endosperms and following the addition of lysine (L) and/or threonine (T) Standard deviation (SD) values were all below 5% for the L, T and LT treatments.
Enzyme
Genotypes Oh43 +Oh43o1 Oh43o2 Oh43fl1 Oh43fl2 AK
Control (SD) 8.282 (0.314) 9.240 (0.371) 4.956 (0.121) 2.783 (0.120) 15.290 (0.414)
% inhibition by +5 m M L 60.8 55.6 42.2 28.9 37.5
% inhibition by +5 m M T 11.1 13.5 +4.73 a 3.34 15.6
% inhibition by +5 m M LT 92.5 78.3 83.2 41.8 49.5
HSDH
Control (SD) 17.4 (0.71) 27.6 (0.88) 38.4 (1.43) 19.8 (0.57) 21.0 (0.57)
% inhibition by +5 m M T 31.0 +26.1 25.0 6.1 17.1
LOR (SD) 3.505 (0.121) 3.830 (0.133) 0.590 (0.016) 2.115 (0.030) 0.490 (0.013) SDH (SD) 3.490 (0124) 3.050 (0.090) 0.705 (0.071) 1.870 (0.097) 0.890 (0.033)
a
Indicates activation of enzyme activity.
Trang 8ranged from 28.7% (W64Ao2) to 77.5% (Oh43+) The
difference between the minimum and maximum percentages
was almost the same as that found by Balconi et al [39]
between Illinois low protein (40%) and Illinois high protein
(74.5%) genotypes, taking into account that these values are
slightly (5%) underestimated as E4 proteins were excluded
from zeins by the authors (b) The effect of environmental
conditions upon the content of zeins for a given genotype
can result in a discrepancy of 8–9% in the case of Oh43o2,
W22o2 and W22 +or be negligible in the case of Oh43fl2
or Oh43+ (c) For a given mutant gene the genetic
background can have a considerable impact upon the zein
content, however, this is not always the case as can be seen
with W64Ao1 and Oh43o1 (d) More generally, the gradual
increase in zein content would indicate a progressive change
in the relative proportions of soft and hard endosperms,
respectively, poor and rich in zeins Therefore, the effect of
one gene upon the distribution pattern of protein fractions
cannot be generalized from that found for only one genetic
background
The opaque and floury mutants used in this study have
been classified as high-lysine endosperm mutants, however,
such higher concentrations of lysine can be due to
altera-tions in the storage protein fracaltera-tions and/or in the
concen-tration of soluble lysine in the endosperm In previous
studies, the soluble lysine concentration has been shown to
be increased in the o2 maize mutant when compared with
the wild-type maize [9,30,31] Estimating the percentage of
lysine in true proteins by assuming the lysine content of
nonzeins is independent of genotype and equal to 7 g per
100 g of proteins, and based on the distribution of the
endosperm proteins, the mutants exhibited higher
concentrations of total lysine when compared with their
wild-type counterpart We have also observed a significant
variability in the absolute and relative soluble lysine
concentrations among the mutants analyzed The o2
mutation led to an increase in the total SAA pool and in
the soluble lysine concentration in the endosperm, confirm-ing the previous reports for this mutant [2,13,30,31], although such increases may vary depending on the genetic background to which the gene is introduced [30,31] In the other mutants, distinct responses were observed in relation
to lysine concentration, showing that the mutants Oh43fl1 and Oh43fl2, exhibited increases in total SAA and soluble lysine concentration, in a similar way to the Oh43o2 mutant, leading to higher lysine concentrations in the endosperm, but not to the same extent However the Oh43o1 mutant, exhibited a lower concentration of total SAA, but an increased concentration of relative and absolute contents of soluble lysine, which on balance indicates that the Oh43o1 mutant has a small significant increase (101%) in soluble lysine The results observed for the o1 mutation are similar
to that reported by Hunter et al [31], who observed an amino acid composition similar to the wild-type counter-part On the other hand, Balconi et al [39] reported an increased concentration of total lysine in the o1 mutant to the same extent as that for the o2 mutant In general, all mutants can be classified as high-lysine mutants, but the increases in lysine observed were not as great as that observed for the o2 mutation
Hunter et al [31] used one dimensional SDS/PAGE to compare qualitative and quantitative differences in zein patterns among a range of opaque mutants Except for o2, little effect of the mutations was observed The analysis was refined by immunoblotting with specific antisera, which demonstrated that in o2 there was a decreased amount a22 kDa, b14 kDa and d10 kDa isoforms, whereas in fl2 the a22 kDa zeins were reduced Using 2D electrophoresis,
we were able to observe complex patterns of alterations in the mutants as compared with the wild type The various isoforms detected are not due to artifacts during protein isolation and/or fractionation, but to genetic differences in charge and amino acid content [40] A given mutation can increase or decrease the relative amount of different isoforms belonging to the same class of zein, indicating very specific effects In the Oh43 background fl1 and o1 mutations had very little effect A similar low effect was also observed for o1 in the W64A background [31] The mutations o2 and fl2 had their largest effects on the a22 kDa and c27 kDa zeins, mostly decreasing the amount
of the isoforms present The effect of o2 on b14 kDa isoforms was consistent with a regulatory role of this transcriptional activator on these zein genes [23] In contrast
to Hunter et al [31], we found that o2 increased rather than decreased the relative amount of the d10 kDa isoforms This may be due to a specific effect of the background, as we used Oh43 while Hunter et al [31] used W64A A large background effect on the range of o2 effects had already been observed (e.g [34])
The enzymes of lysine metabolism have been studied and characterized in several plant species [10] As wild-type maize and the o2 mutant were the only sources of information in the literature as far as lysine metabolism is concerned, we have used them as controls for our analysis of the other mutants The data in Table 3 provide evidence that there is a wide variation in terms of AK activity, with several-fold variation in AK activity among the genotypes studied, which, in the case of the low rates in the Oh43o2 mutant, agreed with previous results published by other
Table 4 Zein and lysine determinations in distinct studies Percentage
of zein and protein lysine in maize seeds References: PS: present study;
Misra et al [38]; Di Fonzo et al [37]; Landry et al [32]; Hunter et al.
[31] Lysine percentage true proteins (estimated), values in parentheses
correspond to lysine percentage crude proteins (assayed).
Genotype Zeins Lysine percentage [Reference]
W64Ao2 28.7 3.8 31
Oh43o2 41.5 3.78 PS
Oh43o2 47.1 3.14 32
Oh43o2 49.3 (3.5) 38
W64Afl2 50.0 2.8 31
Oh43fl2 64.8 2.34 PS
W64Ao1 66.4 1.7 31
Oh43fl2 65.7 (2.3) 38
Oh43o1 68.6 2.08 PS
Oh43fl1 71.9 1.87 PS
Oh43+77.5 (1.6) 38
Trang 9authors [9,28] Two mutants, Oh43o1 and Oh43fl2 exhibited
increases in AK activity, whereas the mutants Oh43o2
and Oh43fl1 exhibited a reduction in AK activity when
compared with their wild type, Oh43+ AK activity has
been shown to be determined by the action of at least two
separate isoenzymes, one that is sensitive to lysine inhibition
and the other sensitive to threonine inhibition [10]
Fur-thermore, in higher plants, the lysine-sensitive isoenzyme
normally accounts for 50–80% of the total AK activity,
with the exception of AK activity in coix endosperm, in
which the threonine-sensitive isoenzyme predominates [41]
Independent of the mutation, in the Oh43 genetic
back-ground, lysine produced the stronger inhibition of AK
activity, suggesting that the lysine-sensitive isoenzyme is
predominant in this genetic background and that such
distribution of isoenzymes activities is not affected by any of
the introduced mutations
Threonine inhibition of AK was low in all the lines, but
there was evidence of a further reduction, caused by the o2
and fl1 mutations However, lysine inhibition was reduced
in all the mutants when compared with the wild-type,
particularly in fl1 and fl2 The presence of AK activity more
insensitive to lysine and threonine inhibition was confirmed
when both amino acids were tested together, resulting in less
than 50% inhibition of the total AK activity in fl1 and fl2,
with lesser reductions being detected in the opaque mutants
Stimulation of HSDH activity by threonine was observed
for the Oh43o1 mutant, however, no major effects on AK
activity were observed in this mutant, which might indicate
a specific effect of the o1 gene on the HSDH domain of the
bifunctional polypeptide Apart from these results, HSDH
activity does not appear to be under any particular influence
from the mutations analyzed All the genotypes tested
exhibited variations for threonine inhibition, suggesting the
presence of both HSDH isoenzymes It has been suggested
that HSDH does not have a regulatory role in the
biosynthesis of lysine, although this enzyme shares the
same substrate (aspartate semialdehyde) with DHDPS,
which could eventually be a key point in determining
the flux of carbon through the pathway, leading to
threonine or lysine biosynthesis [10] Although a recent
study using transgenic Arabidopsis thaliana expressing
bacterial DHDPS and having knockout mutation for lysine
catabolism produced high increases in soluble lysine and
methionine [42], no evidence of an increase in soluble
methionine was detected in the opaque and floury mutants
analyzed in this work (data not shown)
Evidence has been obtained from biochemical and
molecular analyses that AK activity is possibly regulated
by the o2 gene [13], intensifying its effect on the total pool of
SAA and free threonine accumulation in maize endosperm
[13] Moreover, one of the genes encoding a lysine-sensitive
AK isoenzyme was linked to the o2 gene in chromosome 7
[13] Wang et al [43] also observed that AK activity varied
in its sensitivity to lysine inhibition, even between distinct
lines in which the o2 was introduced Furthermore, several
quantitative trait loci for SAA content have been identified,
one of them linked to another AK-HSDH encoding gene
[43] The analysis of o2 mutants has indicated that the
lysine-sensitive AK isoenzyme, but not the bifunctional
threonine-sensitive AK-HSDH isoenzyme, is affected by the
mutation [43]
The enzymes of lysine catabolism, LOR and SDH, were also analyzed in all genotypes and exhibited significant alteration in activity depending on the mutant LOR and SDH were initially identified as one bifunctional enzyme containing both enzyme domains [12,17,18], whilst later monofunctional LOR and SDH enzymes were identified [12] The results reported in the literature generally indicated that SDH activity is more stable than LOR activity [5] The dramatic sixfold reduction of LOR activity in the mutant Oh43o2 also confirmed the results observed for the effect of the o2 gene on LOR activity [9], which is due to a decreased mRNA and enzyme protein synthesis [29] SDH activity was also influenced by the o2 gene, exhibiting a 4.9-fold decrease in enzyme activity, which is a greater reduction when compared with previous work with this mutant [9] The reduction in LOR and SDH activities observed for the Oh43o2 mutant was also observed in Oh43fl1 and Oh43fl2 mutants, with the latter exhibiting a LOR activity even lower that of the Oh43o2 mutant (7.1-fold)
Our results suggest that the catabolism of lysine catalyzed
by the enzyme LOR, may be under the regulation of the opaque and floury mutations This is in addition to the biosynthetic enzymes AK and to a lesser extent HSDH discussed previously The way this pleiotropic regulation can take place may be different according to the mutation It has been shown in previous studies in which the LOR and SDH enzymes were isolated and characterized, that the LOR has an essential role in the regulation of lysine catabolism, as this enzyme is modulated by Ca2+, ionic strength and protein phosphorylation/dephosphorylation in several plant species [19,29,44,45], however, such modula-tion effects do not appear to influence SDH activity Pleiotropic regulation is also supported by the effect of the mutations on the storage proteins analyzed by 2D-PAGE
In parallel with their considerable effect on LOR and SDH activity, both o2 and fl2 induced large alterations in the synthesis pattern of a22 kDa and c27 kDa zeins Further-more, the Oh43o2 and Oh43fl2 mutants also exhibited higher concentrations of soluble lysine in the endosperm, not only based on its concentration, but accompanying the effect of each mutation on the concentration of the total pool of SAA
Curiously, the Oh43o1 mutant, which has been classi-fied as high-lysine, did not exhibit major effects on the catabolism of lysine in the endosperm, which suggests that the high lysine concentration cannot be explained by an altered lysine catabolism in this mutant Although there was a slight increase in the concentration of soluble lysine
in the Oh43o1 mutant when compared with the other mutants, the lysine degradation enzyme pattern as well as the AK activity, was shown to be at the same level of the wild-type counterpart Furthermore, Hunter et al [31] who also analyzed this mutant, but in a different genetic background, could not find any important effect of this mutation The mutants Oh43o1 and Oh43fl1 exhibited little effect either on the zein polypeptides or on LOR and SDH activities
The analysis of other mutations in the same phenotypic class as the o2 gene indicates that the mutations may strongly influence lysine metabolism and storage protein synthesis and accumulation in maize Many of the zein polypeptides have been shown to vary in these mutants and
Trang 10a new range of studies must be carried out to determine the
precise molecular regulation of the synthesis of these
polypeptides by such mutations It is also clear that future
studies on the effect of these mutations should also be
carried out on the activity of the DHDPS enzyme, which has
been shown to be a key regulatory step in lysine biosynthesis
[5,10], but has only been tested in the o2 mutant so far [43]
Acknowledgements
This work was financed by grants to RAA from Fundac¸a˜o de Amparo
a` Pesquisa do Estado de Sa˜o Paulo, Brazil (FAPESP 98/12461–0 and
01/13904–8) and the British Council (RAA and PJL) The authors also
wish to thank the Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Cientı´fico e
Tecnolo´gico (CNPq, Brazil) and FAPESP for the scholarships and
fellowships received, Professor L Sodek (UNICAMP) for the critical
reading of the manuscript, J Carmezzini for the growth of the
mutants, A Karime, M Garcia and F Mestrinelli for technical
assistance.
References
1 Vasal, S.K (1994) High quality protein corn In: Specialty Corns
(Hallauer, A.R., ed.), pp 79–121 CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL.
2 Sodek, L & Wilson, C.M (1971) Amino acid composition of
proteins isolated from normal, opaque-2, and floury-2 corn
endosperms by a modified Osborne procedure J Agric Food
Chem 19, 1144–1149.
3 Wilson, C.M (1991) Multiple zeins from maize endosperms
characterized by reverse- phase high performance liquid
chroma-tography Plant Physiol 95, 777–786.
4 Azevedo, R.A & Lea, P.J (2001) Lysine metabolism in higher
plants Amino Acids 20, 261–279.
5 Azevedo, R.A (2002) Analysis of the aspartic acid metabolic
pathway using mutant genes Amino Acids 22, 217–230.
6 Mertz, E.T., Bates, L.S & Nelson, O.E (1964) Mutant gene that
changes protein composition and increase lysine content of maize
endosperm Science 145, 279–280.
7 Pixley, K.V & Bjarnason, M.S (1993) Combining ability for yield
and protein quality among modified-endosperm opaque-2 tropical
maize inbreds Crop Sci 33, 1229–1234.
8 Moro, G.L., Lopes, M.A., Habben, J.E., Hamaker, B.R &
Larkins, B.A (1995) Phenotypic effects of opaque2 modifier genes
in normal maize endosperm Cereal Chem 72, 94–99.
9 Gaziola, S.A., Alessi, E.S., Guimara˜es, P.E.O., Damerval, C &
Azevedo, R.A (1999) Quality protein maize: a biochemical study
of enzymes involved in lysine metabolism J Agric Food Chem.
47, 1268–1275.
10 Azevedo, R.A., Arruda, P., Turner, W.L & Lea, P.J (1997) The
biosynthesis and metabolism of the aspartate derived amino acids
in higher plants Phytochemistry 46, 395–419.
11 Azevedo, R.A., Smith, R.J & Lea, P.J (1992) Aspects of aspartate
kinase regulation in maize: co-purification of aspartate kinase and
homoserine dehydrogenase sensitive to threonine Phytochemistry
31, 3731–3734.
12 Galili, G (2002) New insights into the regulation and functional
significance of lysine metabolism in plants Annu Rev Plant Biol.
53, 27–43.
13 Azevedo, R.A., Arana, J.L & Arruda, P (1990) Biochemical
genetics of the interaction of the lysine plus threonine resistant
mutant Ltr*19 with opaque-2 maize mutant Plant Sci 70, 81–90.
14 Muehlbauer, G.J., Gengenbach, B.G., Somers, D.A & Donovan,
C.M (1994) Genetic and amino acid analysis of two maize
threonine-overproducing, lysine-insensitive aspartate kinase
mutants Theor Appl Genet 89, 767–774.
15 BrinchPedersen, H., Galili, G., Knudsen, S & Holm, P.B (1996) Engineering of the aspartate family biosynthetic pathway in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) by transformation with heterologous genes encoding feed-back-insensitive aspartate kinase and dihydro-dipicolinate synthase Plant Mol Biol 32, 611–620.
16 Arruda, P., Kemper, E.L., Papes, F & Leite, A (2000) Regulation
of lysine catabolism in higher plants Trends Plant Sci 5, 324–330.
17 Gonc¸alves-Butruille, M., Szajner, P., Torigoi, E., Leite, A & Arruda, P (1996) Purification and characterization of the bifunctional enzyme lysine-ketoglutarate reductase-saccharopine dehydrogenase from maize Plant Physiol 110, 765–771.
18 Gaziola, S.A., Teixeira, C.M.G., Lugli, J., Sodek, L & Azevedo, R.A (1997) The enzymology of lysine catabolism in rice seeds Isolation, characterization, and regulatory properties of a lysine 2-oxoglutarate reductase/saccharopine dehydrogenase bifunctional polypeptide Eur J Biochem 247, 364–371.
19 Miron, D., Ben-Yaacov, S., Karchi, H & Galili, G (1997) In vitro dephosphorylation inhibits the activity of soybean lysine-oxoglutarate reductase in a lysine-regulated manner Plant J 12, 1453–1458.
20 Cunha-Lima, S.T., Azevedo, R.A., Santoro, L.G., Gaziola, S.A.
& Lea, P.J (2003) Isolation of the bifunctional enzyme lysine 2-oxoglutarate reductase-saccharopine dehydrogenase from Phaseolus vulgaris Amino Acids 24, 179–186.
21 Cunha-Lima,S.T.,Azevedo,R.A.&Santoro,L.G.(2003)Improved procedures for extraction of lysine 2-oxoglutarate reductase/sac-charopine dehydrogenase (LOR/SDH) enzyme from Phaseolus vulgaris cultivars New Zeal J Crop Hort Sci 31, 261–268.
22 Schmidt, R.J., Ketudat, M., Aukerman, M.J & Hoschek, G (1992) Opaque-2 is a transcriptional activator that recognizes a specific target site in 22-kD zein genes Plant Cell 4, 689–700.
23 Neto, G.C., Yunes, J.A., DaSilva, J., Vettore, A.L., Arruda, P & Leite, A (1995) The involvement of opaque-2 on beta-prolamin gene regulation in maize and coix suggests a more general role for this transcriptional activator Plant Mol Biol 27, 1015–1029.
24 Lohmer, S., Maddaloni, M., Motto, M., DiFonzo, N., Hartings, H., Salamini, F & Thompson, R.D (1991) The maize regulatory locus opaque-2 encodes a DNA binding protein which activates the transcription of the B-32 gene EMBO J 10, 617–624.
25 Maddaloni, M., Donini, G., Balconi, C., Rizzi, E., Gallusci., P., Forlani, F., Lohmer, S., Thompson, R., Salamini, F & Motto, M (1996) The transcriptional activator Opaque-2 controls the expression of a cytosolic form of pyruvate orthophosphate dikinase-1 in maize endosperms Mol Gen Genet 250, 647–654.
26 Habben, J.E., Moro, G.L., Hunter, B.G., Hamaker, B.R & Larkins, B.A (1995) Elongation factor 1 alpha concentration is highly correlated with the lysine content of maize endosperm Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 92, 8640–8644.
27 Damerval, C & Le Guilloux, M (1998) Characterization of novel target proteins of the o2 mutation expressed during maize endosperm development Mol Gen Genet 257, 354–361.
28 Brennecke, K., Souza-Neto, A.J., Lugli, J., Lea, P.J & Azevedo, R.A (1996) Aspartate kinase in the maize mutants Ask1-LT19 and opaque-2 Phytochemistry 41, 707–712.
29 Kemper, E.L., Cord-Neto, G., Papes, F., Martine Z., Moraes, K.C., Leite, A & Arruda, P (1999) The role of opaque-2 on the control of lysine degrading activities in developing maize endosperm Plant Cell 11, 1981–1994.
30 Wang, X & Larkins, B.A (2001) Genetic analysis of amino acid accumulation in opaque-2 maize endosperm Plant Physiol 125, 1766–1777.
31 Hunter, B.G., Beatty, M.K., Singletary, G.W., Hamaker, B.R., Dilkes, B.P., Larkins, B.A & Jung, R (2002) Maize opaque endosperm mutations create extensive changes in patters of gene expression Plant Cell 14, 2591–2612.