c-Type cytochromes are almost always characterized by covalent attachment of heme to protein through two thioether bonds between the heme vinyl groups and the thiols of cyste-ine residue
Trang 1cytochrome c with heme attached via only one thioether bond and implications for the substrate recognition
requirements of heme lyase
Vilmos Fu¨lo¨p1, Katharine A Sam2, Stuart J Ferguson2, Michael L Ginger3and James W A Allen2
1 Department of Biological Sciences, University of Warwick, Coventry, UK
2 Department of Biochemistry, University of Oxford, UK
3 School of Health and Medicine, Division of Biomedical and Life Sciences, Lancaster University, UK
The principal physiological role of mitochondrial
cyto-chrome c is electron transfer from the cytocyto-chrome bc1
complex to cytochrome aa3 oxidase during oxidative
phosphorylation c-Type cytochromes form a large
family in bacteria, archaea, mitochondria and
chlorop-lasts, in which the iron cofactor heme is covalently
bound to the polypeptide chain Such cytochromes have many distinct folds (often unrelated to that of mitochondrial cytochrome c); bacterial c-type cyto-chromes frequently have many hemes [1] Despite this variety, the covalent heme attachment to protein is highly stereospecific and regiospecific, and is almost
Keywords
Cytochrome c; heme lyase; intermembrane
space; thioether bond; trypanosome
Correspondence
J W A Allen, Department of Biochemistry,
University of Oxford, South Parks Road,
Oxford, OX1 3QU, UK
Fax: +44 0 1865 613201
Tel: +44 0 1865 613330
E-mail: james.allen@bioch.ox.ac.uk
Database
X-ray structure coordinates for Crithidia
fasciculata cytochrome c have been
deposited in the Protein Data Bank under
the accession code 2w9k
(Received 23 December 2008, revised 19
February 2009, accepted 13 March 2009)
doi:10.1111/j.1742-4658.2009.07005.x
The principal physiological role of mitochondrial cytochrome c is electron transfer during oxidative phosphorylation c-Type cytochromes are almost always characterized by covalent attachment of heme to protein through two thioether bonds between the heme vinyl groups and the thiols of cyste-ine residues in a Cys-Xxx-Xxx-Cys-His motif Uniquely, however, members
of the evolutionarily divergent protist phylum Euglenozoa, which includes Trypanosoma and Leishmania species, have mitochondrial cytochromes c with heme attached through only one thioether bond [to an (A⁄ F)XXCH motif]; the implications of this for the cytochrome structures are unclear Here we present the 1.55 A˚ resolution X-ray crystal structure of cyto-chrome c from the trypanosomatid Crithidia fasciculata Despite the funda-mental difference in heme attachment and in the cytochrome c biogenesis machinery of the Euglenozoa, the structure is remarkably similar to that of typical (CXXCH) mitochondrial cytochromes c, both in overall fold and, other than the missing thioether bond, in the details of the heme attach-ment Notably, this similarity includes the stereochemistry of the covalent heme attachment to the protein The structure has implications for the maturation of c-type cytochromes in the Euglenozoa; it also hints at a dis-tinctive redox environment in the mitochondrial intermembrane space of trypanosomes Surprisingly, Saccharomyces cerevisiae cytochrome c heme lyase (the yeast cytochrome c biogenesis system) cannot efficiently mature Trypanosoma bruceicytochrome c or a CXXCH variant when expressed in the cytoplasm of Escherichia coli, despite their great structural similarity to yeast cytochrome c, suggesting that heme lyase requires specific recognition features in the apocytochrome
Abbreviations
Ccm, cytochrome c maturation; IMS, intermembrane space; NCS, noncrystallographic symmetry; SHAM, salicylhydroxamic acid.
Trang 2always through two thioether bonds between the vinyl
groups of heme and the thiols of cysteine residues that
occur in a CXXCH amino acid motif; the histidine
serves as the proximal ligand to the heme iron atom
[2–4] However, in one group of eukaryotes, the
mem-bers of the protist phylum Euglenozoa, biochemical,
spectroscopic and genetic evidence suggests that,
uniquely, the mitochondrial c-type cytochromes (c and
c1) both have heme covalently bound to the polypeptide
chain through only a single thioether bond [to an
(F⁄ A)XXCH motif] [5–10] The Euglenozoa include
ubiquitous, free-living phagotrophic flagellates (e.g
Bodo saltans), photosynthetic algae (e.g Euglena
graci-lis), and parasitic trypanosomatids [e.g the causal
agents of the tropical diseases African sleeping sickness
(Trypanosoma brucei), Chagas disease (Trypanosoma
cruzi), and leishmaniasis (Leishmania species)] Note
that some euglenozoans, such as E gracilis, also contain
a chloroplast with typical CXXCH cytochromes c [11]
Covalent attachment of heme to cytochromes c is a
catalyzed post-translational modification Remarkably,
at least five completely distinct biogenesis systems have
evolved to achieve this heme attachment in different
organisms and organelles Some eukaryotes (land
plants and various protists) use the multicomponent
System I [also called the cytochrome c maturation
(Ccm) system], and others (animals, fungi, and many
evolutionarily diverse protozoa and algae) use System
III, the enzyme heme lyase, for maturation of their
mitochondrial cytochromes c [10] Surprisingly little is
known about the mechanism and substrate recognition
features of heme lyase-dependent heme attachment to
apocytochrome c, and the origins of this critical
eukaryote-specific enzyme are obscure [10] Strikingly,
none of the known cytochrome c biogenesis proteins
are present in the several trypanosomatid species for
which complete genome sequences are available
[9,10,12] The presence throughout the Euglenozoa of
unique single cysteine mitochondrial cytochromes c,
coupled with the absence from trypanosomatids of any
known cytochrome c biogenesis proteins, points
towards a novel maturation apparatus for all
eugleno-zoan mitochondrial cytochromes c [9,10]
The reason for the loss of one thioether bond from
the mitochondrial cytochromes c of euglenozoans is a
longstanding puzzle It could be a means of altering
the structure of these cytochromes c and⁄ or a
conse-quence of some biosynthetic demand A
high-resolu-tion structural comparison between a euglenozoan
mitochondrial cytochrome c and a typical
cyto-chrome c (with heme bound by two thioether bonds) is
therefore important Moreover, in all the available,
diverse structures of c-type cytochromes, there is an
invariant stereospecific arrangement of the heme [1,13]; there is no a priori reason to expect this to be the same
in the single thioether bond euglenozoan cytochromes Finally, it is likely that (at least for cytochrome c bio-genesis Systems I and II) folding of holocytochromes c mainly takes place after covalent attachment of heme to the polypeptide chain Thus, it is not axiom-atic that anchoring the heme to protein through only a single thioether bond would result in the same local structure that is characteristic of heme attachment to a CXXCH motif Therefore, we have determined the X-ray crystal structure of mitochondrial cytochrome c from the trypanosomatid C fasciculata; we have also investigated the maturation of trypanosome cyto-chrome c by the poorly understood yeast cytocyto-chrome c heme lyase
Results
Cytochrome-dependent respiration in
C fasciculata For determination of a euglenozoan cytochrome c structure, we isolated holocytochrome from C fascicu-lata, a monogenetic insect parasite that is not patho-genic to humans Some trypanosomatids (e.g Leishmania spp and T cruzi) possess a classic mito-chondrial respiratory chain [14–16] In others (e.g the life cycle stage of T brucei found in the midgut of the tsetse fly), the mitochondrial respiratory chain is branched, and electrons can be transferred from ubiqu-inol to either the cytochrome bc1 complex, or to the enzyme alternative oxidase, which reduces oxygen to water but is not coupled to ATP production by oxida-tive phosphorylation because proton translocation is absent [17,18] In other cases, such as pathogenic forms of T brucei found in the mammalian blood-stream, cytochrome-dependent respiration is repressed, and alternative oxidase is the essential sole terminal oxidase in mitochondrial electron transport [16,19] Thus, before solving the X-ray structure of C fascicu-latacytochrome c, we first confirmed its importance in mitochondrial electron transport in that organism The presence of 200 lm salicylhydroxamic acid (SHAM), a specific inhibitor of alternative oxidase, had little effect
on the growth rate of C fasciculata when compared with control cultures Addition of 2 lgÆmL)1antimycin
A (a cytochrome bc1 complex inhibitor), however, resulted in no growth over 72 h (from a starting inocu-lum of 105cellsÆmL)1) Similarly, addition of SHAM
to a concentration of 3 mm exerted no effect on oxygen consumption by C fasciculata as measured using a Clark oxygen electrode, whereas following
Trang 3addition of antimycin to 2 lgÆmL)1, oxygen
consump-tion by C fasciculata effectively ceased within a few
seconds (Fig 1) A very similar result was obtained if
2 mm KCN was added instead of antimycin A; cyanide
inhibits the cytochrome aa3 oxidase of the classic
respiratory chain, but not alternative oxidase Thus,
cytochrome-dependent respiration is essential in
C fasciculata
The structure of C fasciculata mitochondrial
cytochrome c
The overall structure of oxidized C fasciculata
cyto-chrome c, determined by X-ray crystallography to a
resolution of 1.55 A˚, is shown in Fig 2 The
asymmet-ric unit is a trimer The structure is ordered for
resi-dues 5–114 of the 114 amino acid polypeptide chain
The fold is typical for a class I c-type cytochrome (e.g
mitochondrial cytochrome c and bacterial
cyto-chromes c2) [20] The structure unequivocally confirms
the earlier conclusion that trypanosomatid
cyto-chromes c contain only one thioether bond between
heme and protein; there are no other compensatory
covalent bonds to the heme cofactor The heme is (as
expected [21]) covalently attached to the protein through its (original) 4-vinyl group (also called the C8 vinyl), as is observed for the C-terminal cysteine of the typical CXXCH c-type cytochrome heme-binding motif [1,13] The heme iron is coordinated by the Ne
of the histidine of the ‘AXXCH’ (actually AAQCH) heme-binding motif, and the sulfur of Met91 The heme iron–ligand distances were restrained to 2 A˚ (his-tidine) and 2.3 A˚ (methionine), and the model fits well with these values The vinyl a-carbon–Cys28 distances were restrained to 1.8 A˚, but these refined to consider-ably longer bond lengths: 2.25, 1.98 and 2.00 A˚, respectively, for the three subunits of the asymmetric unit Residue 83 is a trimethyllysine [5]; a moderate fit
to the electron density suggests that the trimethyl group is flexible
The structure of C fasciculata cytochrome c (in red)
is overlaid with that of S cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c (in blue) in Fig 3 The two cytochromes have 48% amino acid identity and 72% similarity The structures are remarkably similar overall, and in the details of the heme attachment and heme position The rmsd between the structure of C fasciculata cytochrome c and S cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c is 0.94 A˚ for the
104 a-carbon atoms fitted The positions and stereo-chemistries of both axial heme ligands are essentially
Time (s)
+ SHAM
+ Antimycin
55 nmol O 2
Fig 1 Oxygen consumption by C fasciculata in the presence of
respiratory inhibitors C fasciculata cells (3–7 · 10 7 cells in 0.66 mL
of culture medium taken directly from a growing culture and diluted
to 2 mL with water) were placed in the chamber of a Clark oxygen
electrode, and the oxygen consumption of the cells was measured
at room temperature Inhibitors of alternative oxidase (SHAM) and
the cytochrome bc1 complex (antimycin A) were added at the
points indicated to final concentrations of 3 mM and 2 lgÆmL)1,
respectively The electrode was calibrated using a saturated
solu-tion of air in water, and water treated with disodium dithionite to
remove all of the oxygen One representative experiment (of
seven) is shown.
Fig 2 The X-ray crystal structure of C fasciculata cytochrome c to 1.55 A ˚ resolution The molecule is shown rainbow colored, from the N-terminus (residue 5) in blue to the C-terminus (residue 114)
in red The heme cofactor is shown in ball and stick representation,
as are the methionine and histidine side chains that coordinate the heme iron, and the cysteine side chain that forms a thioether bond between heme and protein Also shown is the methyl group of the alanine of the AXXCH heme-binding motif, which is found in place
of the first cysteine of a typical c-type cytochrome CXXCH heme-binding motif.
Trang 4identical between the two structures These
observa-tions concur with those of Wuthrich et al., who used
proton NMR to investigate the heme environment in
cytochrome c from another trypanosomatid species in
the 1970s, and concluded that the heme crevice and
heme electronic structure were very similar to those in
mammalian (CXXCH) mitochondrial cytochrome c
[21,22] (Notably, these authors also correctly predicted
the overall structure of the trypanosomatid
cyto-chrome.) The stereochemistry of heme attachment
through the thioether bond is conserved in C
fascicu-lata cytochrome c (Figs 3 and 4); it therefore remains
the same (i.e S-stereochemistry) as in all known c-type
cytochrome structures [1,13] Strikingly, the methyl
group of Ala25 in C fasciculata cytochrome c (the
equivalent residue of the first cysteine of the CXXCH
motif of S cerevisiae cytochrome c) overlays almost
perfectly with the CH2 group of the equivalent
cyste-ine Thus, the position of the polypeptide chain around
the cysteine(s) is very similar in the two structures,
even though one has attachment through two thioether
bonds and the other through only a single bond As
discussed in a recent review [23], ‘the backbone
struc-ture of the CXXCH motif [of typical c-type
cyto-chromes] shows little variation, even among proteins in
which the variable ‘‘XX’’ residues have very different
properties’ The observation that this remains true in natural single thioether cytochrome c is a notable finding
Details of the heme attachment in C fasciculata cytochrome c are shown in Fig 4 The methyl group
Fig 3 Comparison between the structures of C fasciculata
cyto-chrome c (protein main chain in red) and S cerevisiae
iso-1-cyto-chrome c (Protein Data Bank entry: 1YCC) (in blue) Also shown are
the heme ligands (histidine and methionine in each case), the
cysteines that form thioether bonds to the heme, and the methyl
group of the alanine of the C fasciculata AXXCH heme-binding
motif, which is found in place of the first cysteine of the S
cerevi-siae CXXCH heme-binding motif The rmsd between the structure
of C fasciculata cytochrome c and S cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c
is 0.94 A ˚ for the 104 a-carbon atoms fitted.
Fig 4 Detail of the heme-binding site in C fasciculata cyto-chrome c from two angles The SIGMAA [50] weighted 2mFo)DF c
electron density, using phases from the final model of the half-reduced form, is contoured at the 1.5r level, where r represents the rms electron density for the unit cell Contours more than 1.5 A ˚ from any of the displayed atoms have been removed for clarity Thin lines indicate heme axial ligand coordination and hydrogen bonds Sulfur atoms (in methionine and cysteine) are colored yellow, nitrogen blue, oxygen red, and iron purple The methyl group of the alanine of the AXXCH heme-binding motif is green, and the unsaturated vinyl group of heme is cyan Pro41 is conserved in class I c-type cyto-chromes, and its main chain carbonyl is hydrogen bonded to the N d
atom of the heme axial histidine side chain; this interaction main-tains the correct orientation of the histidine ring to the heme iron.
Trang 5of the alanine of the AXXCH motif (Ala25) (in
green) and the unsaturated vinyl group of the heme
(cyan) are separated by 3.41 A˚ (as compared with a
typical thioether bond length of 1.8 A˚) As the
posi-tion of the polypeptide chains in this region is
essen-tially the same in the two structures (Fig 3), this
means that in the C fasciculata cytochrome the
heme moves away from the polypeptide relative to
its position in the S cerevisiae protein The
unsatu-rated 2-vinyl group of C fasciculata cytochrome c
remains almost coplanar with the porphyrin ring
The conserved residue Pro41 is hydrogen bonded
through its carbonyl group to the Nd of the
proxi-mal heme histidine ligand [20] The electron density
shows no additional modifications (e.g oxidation) to
the sulfurs of the heme-binding methionine or
cyste-ine residues
Maturation of trypanosome cytochrome c by
yeast cytochrome c heme lyase
Given the remarkable overall structural similarity
between the mitochondrial cytochromes c from C
fas-ciculata and S cerevisiae (Fig 3), we also investigated
whether the poorly understood enzyme responsible for
heme attachment to cytochrome c in yeast, heme lyase,
can mature a trypanosomatid cytochrome c Heme
lyases can mature AXXCH variants of yeast or human
cytochrome c, albeit at a lower level than the CXXCH
wild-type [24,25] Thus, we coexpressed S cerevisiae
cytochrome c heme lyase with either T brucei
cyto-chrome c or a CXXCH variant in the cytoplasm of
E coli (the cytochromes c from C fasciculata and
T brucei have 84% sequence identity and 92%
simi-larity, and both have an AAQCH heme-binding
motif) As a control, we also coexpressed heme lyase
with S cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c Cells expressing
the yeast cytochrome were bright red, and were shown
by absorption spectroscopy to have produced
1.4 mg of cytochrome c per gram of wet cells
(assuming a reduced Soret band extinction coefficient
of 130 000 m)1Æcm)1 [20]) However, neither wild-type
T brucei cytochrome c nor the CXXCH variant was
matured at levels immediately detectable by
spectros-copy or by staining of SDS⁄ PAGE gels for proteins
with covalently bound heme Expression of the protein
was, however, readily confirmed by western blotting of
the E coli cytoplasmic extracts using a polyclonal
antibody raised against recombinant T brucei
CXXCH holocytochrome c (Fig 5A), the latter
matured by the E coli Ccm system [9]; this antibody
is sensitive to both T brucei holocytochrome c and
T brucei apocytochrome c (J W A Allen,
unpub-lished observation) Following concentration of the
E coli cytoplasmic extracts, both T brucei wild-type holocytochrome c and T brucei CXXCH holocyto-chrome c could be observed on heme-stained SDS⁄ PAGE gels, and ran at the same molecular mass as purified recombinant T brucei CXXCH cytochrome c matured by the E coli Ccm system
A
B
14 kDa
14 kDa
400 450 500 550 600 0.00
0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08
0.10
C
1 2 3 4
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Wavelength (nm)
Fig 5 Maturation of T brucei cytochrome c and a CXXCH variant
by S cerevisiae cytochrome c heme lyase (A) Western blot of cytoplasmic extracts from E coli coexpressing heme lyase and cytochrome c, using a primary antibody raised against the CXXCH variant of T brucei holocytochrome c (the latter matured in the periplasm of E coli by the E coli Ccm apparatus [9]) Lane 1: molecular mass markers Lanes 2–5: four independent cultures expressing wild-type T brucei cytochrome c Lanes 6–9: four inde-pendent cultures expressing the CXXCH variant of T brucei cyto-chrome c Lane 10: as the positive control, purified CXXCH variant
T brucei holocytochrome c matured in the periplasm of E coli by the E coli Ccm apparatus (B) SDS ⁄ PAGE gel of concentrated plasmic extracts from E coli coexpressing heme lyase and cyto-chrome c, stained for proteins containing covalently bound heme Lane 1: molecular mass markers Lane 2: wild-type T brucei cyto-chrome c Lane 3: the CXXCH variant of T brucei cytocyto-chrome c Lane 4: as the positive control, purified CXXCH variant T brucei holocytochrome c matured in the periplasm of E coli by the E coli Ccm apparatus (C) Absorption spectra of concentrated cytoplasmic extracts from E coli coexpressing heme lyase and cytochrome c Wild-type T brucei cytochrome c (black line) and the CXXCH variant (gray line) A few grains of disodium dithionite were added to the samples to reduce the cytochromes As no extinction coefficients are available, the spectra were normalized by intensity of the Soret band The spectra were also corrected for light scattering by sub-traction of a wavelength to the power four curve.
Trang 6(Fig 5B) Yields of heme lyase-matured T brucei
holocytochrome were calculated from absorption
spectra of the concentrated cytochromes (Fig 5C) as
3.1 lg (wild-type) and 3.2 lg (CXXCH) of
holocyto-chrome c per gram of wet cells, assuming in each
case a reduced Soret band extinction coefficient of
130 000 m)1Æcm)1 This cytochrome maturation was
heme lyase-dependent, because virtually no
holocyto-chrome was observed if expressed in the absence of
heme lyase We previously investigated maturation of
T brucei cytochrome c in E coli by the Ccm system,
which produced approximately 1.6 mg of CXXCH
variant holocytochrome per gram of wet cells [9];
hence, the low yields of heme lyase-matured
holo-cytochrome in the present work are not due to, for
example, poor expression of the apoprotein or
T brucei codon usage We conclude that both
wild-type and CXXCH T brucei cytochrome c are
matured by heme lyase, to similar extents, but,
sur-prisingly, at only approximately 0.25% of the level
of maturation of S cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c,
even though the various cytochromes are structurally
extremely similar
Discussion
Euglenozoan cytochrome c – evolution and
maturation
We report here the first high-resolution structure of
mitochondrial cytochrome c from a euglenozoan
organism The mitochondrial cytochromes c and c1
from this evolutionarily divergent protist group are
unique because they contain heme covalently bound
through only one cysteine residue to an (A⁄ F)XXCH
heme-binding motif, rather than through two thioether
bonds to CXXCH, as in all other eukaryotes No
apparatus for the post-translational attachment of
heme to apocytochrome c has yet been identified in
any euglenozoan, and, in contrast to all other
eukary-otes possessing mitochondrial cytochromes c, no
appa-ratus is evident from the analysis of multiple
completely sequenced trypanosomatid genomes
[9,10,12] Identification of the novel biogenesis system
for cytochrome c in trypanosomes is a demanding
task Remarkably, despite these fundamental
differ-ences in heme attachment and cytochrome biogenesis,
the structure of C fasciculata cytochrome c is very
similar to the structures of typical mitochondrial
cyto-chromes c, e.g from S cerevisiae (Fig 3) This
simi-larity was also observed, other than the missing
thioether bond, in the details of the heme attachment
and around the heme-binding site (Figs 3 and 4) [21]
Different c-type cytochromes have very different folds [1], but the structural arrangement of the heme-bind-ing motif around the thioether linkages is absolutely conserved The present work extends this observation
to a cytochrome with a natural single cysteine heme-binding motif Moreover, as illustrated with E gracilis cytochrome c558, single thioether attachment of heme does not significantly affect the reaction between the cytochrome c and (mammalian) cytochrome bc1 or cytochrome aa3 oxidase (when compared with horse heart cytochrome c) [26] The biophysical properties
of euglenozoan and typical mitochondrial cyto-chromes c are also similar [8] Priest and Hajduk [6] speculated that single thioether heme attachment in both cytochromes c and c1 (rather than just in one) might be mutually compensatory, allowing efficient interaction between them for respiratory electron transfer in spite of their distinctive mode of heme binding However, our data (Fig 3) suggest that the unique mode of heme attachment is probably unre-lated to the interaction between cytochrome c and its redox partners There is no apparent structural com-pensation for the presence of only one thioether bond
in C fasciculata cytochrome c, although properties such as the reduction potential may be subtly fine-tuned by the protein
There is no obvious reason from the protein struc-ture or functional data why one group of protists has evolved a unique type of cytochrome c and a corre-sponding novel biogenesis pathway However, it is clear from our data that euglenozoan cytochrome c could structurally accommodate two cysteines in a typical CXXCH heme-binding motif (Fig 3) So, how might the occurrence of these single cysteine cyto-chromes c be explained? Considerable evidence points
to catalyzed formation and subsequent reduction of
an intramolecular disulfide bond in the CXXCH motif during cytochrome c biogenesis in bacteria [3]; this may also happen in yeast [27] It therefore seems plausible that evolution of the euglenozoan single cys-teine heme-binding motif, while the protein structure was otherwise retained (Fig 3), relates to the redox environment of the euglenozoan mitochondrial inter-membrane space (IMS) (the location of the cyto-chrome c) Loss of one cysteine from the cytochrome c heme-binding motif could: (a) signifi-cantly affect the interactions between the apocyto-chrome and other thiol proteins in the IMS; and⁄ or (b) prevent the formation of an undesirable intramo-lecular disulfide bond in the apocytochrome for which no suitable reductant would be available in the IMS; and⁄ or (c) provide a selective advantage by alle-viating a constraint on other IMS redox proteins
Trang 7Our structure thus adds to other recent evidence [28]
hinting that the redox environment of the
mitochon-drial IMS in trypanosomatids may be different from
that in animals and yeast
Notably, the stereochemistry of heme attachment
remains conserved in all cytochromes c, including
that from C fasciculata (Figs 3 and 4) Heme is not
symmetrical; to date, it has always been observed to
be attached to cytochromes c with S-stereochemistry
[1], although the physiological advantage of such
ste-reospecific attachment is not known It was therefore
not clear a priori whether euglenozoan cytochromes c
with heme attached through a single cysteine would
have the same attachment stereochemistry as
cyto-chromes c with two thioether linkages [13] The fact
that they do must be reflected in stereospecific
con-trol of the heme attachment by the euglenozoan
cyto-chrome c biogenesis machinery If heme is not
inserted into cytochromes in a controlled orientation,
it enters initially in a mixed, roughly equal
popula-tion, and equilibrates slowly until one orientation
dominates (as observed for b-type cytochromes and
globins) [29–31] This implies that there may be a
heme-handling chaperone in the trypanosomatid
cytochrome c biogenesis machinery (as there is in
biogenesis System I [32])
One surprising difference in the structure of C
fas-ciculata cytochrome c relative to ‘normal’ CXXCH
c-type cytochromes is that the thioether bond between
heme and protein is longer than is typical (1.98–
2.25 A˚ as compared with 1.8 A˚) Our structure was
refined with a nonredundant first part of the dataset,
which showed similar bond lengths, as did refinement
against a lower-resolution dataset collected at a much
less intense beamline (ESRF, BM16) Therefore, this
observation cannot be interpreted as a result of
X-ray-induced radiation damage; rather, it is an
intrinsic feature of the structure In single thioether
cytochrome c, the heme is less constrained than in a
normal (CXXCH) c-type cytochrome, because it is
covalently anchored to the protein only once rather
than twice This leads to greater conformational
flexi-bility of the heme, which is reflected, for example, in
broadening of the peaks in the absorption spectrum
[9,24] Moreover, when heme is attached to a
CXXCH motif, the (quite significant) strain of
con-straining the heme position is spread over two
thioe-ther bonds plus the histidine ligand to the iron,
whereas in the euglenozoan mitochondrial
cyto-chromes, the load must be borne by only one
thioe-ther bond plus the histidine Togethioe-ther, these factors
presumably lead to a weaker, and hence longer,
thioe-ther bond
Cytochrome c maturation by other biogenesis systems
The structure reported here is also informative in the context of the failure of the E coli Ccm apparatus to effectively mature wild-type (AXXCH) T brucei cyto-chrome c [9]; the system can mature both a CXXCH variant [9] and the structurally very similar (Fig 3) yeast (CXXCH) mitochondrial cytochrome c [33] Hence, we can now conclude with a high degree of confidence that the inability of the Ccm system to mature the single cysteine trypanosomatid cyto-chrome c was due to the Ccm apparatus itself, and not
to some (previously unidentified) structural feature of the substrate cytochrome It has been argued that cyto-chrome c biogenesis System II can catalyze single cysteine heme attachment within the four-heme c-type cytochrome NrfH from Wolinella succinogenes which is unrelated to mitochondrial cytochrome c [34] The present work suggests that such single cysteine attach-ment could be structurally accommodated within that protein as a variant of the wild-type double cysteine attachment The bioinformatic implications are clear;
an XXXCH sequence could be indicative of a c-type cytochrome in genomes of bacterial species that use System II [34] (Note also that the cytochrome b6f complex of cyanobacteria and chloroplasts contains a heme covalently bound to protein via a single thioether bond; this heme attachment is dependent on the recently described biogenesis System IV [12].)
Our data further show, unexpectedly, that S cerevi-siae heme lyase (System III) matures a CXXCH vari-ant of T brucei cytochrome c very poorly, in spite of the great structural homology between the trypanoso-matid and yeast cytochromes There are two extreme possibilities for how the scarcely understood heme lyase recognizes its target apocytochrome The first, by analogy with the Ccm system [35], is that it recognizes little more than the CXXCH heme-binding motif The second is that it recognizes as yet undefined features of the apoprotein, leading to a productive complex within which heme is attached Our results here suggest the second possibility, and that the recognition features in the apocytochrome are not related to the overall struc-ture of the cytochrome This complements the previous observation that heme lyase is unable to mature a bacterial class I c-type cytochrome, Paracoccus denitrif-icans cytochrome c550 [33] Moreover, many taxa that have heme lyase apparently have separate heme lyases for the maturation of cytochromes c and c1 [10]; this has been demonstrated biochemically for S cerevisiae, where only very limited overlap of substrate specificity was observed [36] Again, ‘simple’ interaction between
Trang 8heme lyase and the apocytochrome CXXCH motif
would appear to be unlikely if separate heme lyases are
required to mature cytochromes c and c1 Bernard et al
[36] identified point mutations in S cerevisiae
cyto-chrome c1 that enhanced the activity of cytochrome c
heme lyase towards the former protein The
identifica-tion of such residues both within and upstream of the
CXXCH heme-binding motif supports our conclusion
that heme lyase recognizes specific features in its
apocy-tochrome substrate, rather than just the heme-binding
motif or the overall fold of the protein
Experimental procedures
C fasciculata choanomastigotes were cultured at 27C in
media containing 37 gÆL)1 heart–brain infusion, 10 mgÆL)1
hemin, 10 mgÆL)1folic acid and 5% (v⁄ v) heat-inactivated
fetal bovine serum Cells inoculated at 104
cellsÆmL)1 in
500 mL tissue culture flasks containing 100 mL of medium
were grown for 60–72 h Harvested cells were washed twice
in NaCl⁄ Pi (8 gÆL)1 NaCl, 0.2 gÆL)1 KCl, 1.42 gÆL)1
Na2HPO4 and 0.27 gÆL)1 KH2PO4, pH 7.2) and stored at
)80 C until required Growth assays for C fasciculata
were conducted by the addition of respiratory inhibitors as
described in the text; growth was assessed either by counts
using a hemocytometer, or by measurement of D600 nm
val-ues Respiration of C fasciculata was also investigated
using an oxygen electrode (Rank Brothers, Bottisham,
UK), which was calibrated and used according to the
man-ufacturer’s directions Cells were placed in the electrode
chamber in their growth medium, and respiratory inhibitors
were added as required
Purification of cytochrome c
Extracts of C fasciculata were prepared by disrupting the
cells from 20 L of culture twice in buffer containing
1.42 gÆL)1 Na2HPO4, 0.27 gÆL)1 KH2PO4, 1 mm
Na2EDTA, 2 mm EGTA, 5 lm 2-mercaptoethanol, 0.25
mm phenylmethanesulfonyl fluoride, four ‘Complete’
prote-ase inhibitor tablets (Roche) for every 50 mL of buffer
(containing 2 · 1011cells), and 2% (v⁄ v) Nonidet P40
Substitute detergent (Igepal CA-630; USB Corporation,
Cleveland, OH, USA) Cell debris was removed by
centrifu-gation at 17 000 g for 15 mins, and the soluble cell extracts
were diluted five-fold with 50 mm Tris⁄ HCl buffer (pH
8.0), and then applied to an XK26⁄ 20 column containing
SP-Sepharose fast-flow resin (GE Healthcare, Amersham,
UK) at room temperature The column was washed with
the same buffer, and then with 50 mL of 2 mm K3Fe(CN)6
dissolved in the buffer to ensure that the C fasciculata
cytochrome c (sometimes called cytochrome c555[5]) was all
oxidized The protein was eluted from the column with a
500 mL gradient of 0–500 mm NaCl in 50 mm Tris⁄ HCl
buffer (pH 8.0), with a flow rate of 10 mLÆmin)1; 8 mL fractions were collected Fractions were assessed by their red color, and those with maximum Soret band absorbance more than one-third that of the best fraction were retained The pooled fractions were diluted five-fold in 50 mm Tris⁄ HCl (pH 8.0), and applied to an XK26 ⁄ 20 column containing CM-Sepharose fast-flow resin (GE Healthcare)
at room temperature The protein was eluted as described above Retained fractions containing the purest cytochrome were concentrated to a volume of 1.5 mL, and applied to
a Sephacryl S-200 column (2.6 cm diameter, 1 m length), pre-equilibrated with 50 mm potassium phosphate buffer (pH 7.0) This chromatography step was conducted at 4C The cytochrome was eluted in the same buffer at a flow rate of 15 mLÆh)1; 5 mL fractions were collected and assessed for purity by absorption spectroscopy and SDS⁄ PAGE Those with ASoret (oxidized)⁄ A280 nm (oxi-dized) > 3.8 were regarded as pure, and were concentrated
to 16 mgÆmL)1( 1.3 mm) for crystallography
Crystallization, structure determination, and model refinement
Redox homogeneity of the purified C fasciculata cyto-chrome c was ensured by the addition of 5 mm K3Fe(CN)6 Crystals initially formed in sitting drops made by mixing the protein 1 : 1 with a solution containing 2.7 m (NH4)2SO4, 0.1 m Hepes (pH 6.5) and 0.1 m LiCl at 19C (all crystallographic reagents purchased from Hampton Research, Aliso Viejo, CA, USA) These crystals were of poor quality, but they were used for seeding Diffraction-quality crystals were produced in hanging drops by mixing the protein 1 : 1 with 2.45 m (NH4)2SO4 and 0.1 m Hepes (pH 6.5); these drops were seeded with microcrystals after equilibration for 48 h Crystals grew, and were harvested, within 1 week Crystals were then picked up from the mother liquor containing 15% glycerol using a cryoloop, placed in a nitrogen stream at 100 K, and stored in liquid nitrogen until data collection Initial diffraction data were collected at beamline BM16 (European Synchrotron Radia-tion Facility), but the final dataset used for structure deter-mination and refinement was collected at the Diamond Light Source, UK Integration and scaling were performed using denzo and scalepack [37] Subsequent data handling was carried out using the ccp4 software package [38] Molecular replacement was carried out using the coordi-nates of S cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c (Protein Data Bank code: 1YCC) as a search model with the phaser pro-gram [39] Refinement of the structure was carried out by alternate cycles of refmac [40], using noncrystallographic symmetry restraints and manual rebuilding in o [41] Water molecules were added to the atomic model automatically
by arp⁄ warp [42], and in the last steps of refinement all the noncrystallographic symmetry restraints were released
Trang 9A summary of the data collection and refinement statistics
is given in Table 1 Figures were drawn using molscript
[43,44] and rendered with raster 3d [45]
Heme lyase maturation assays
Maturation of T brucei cytochrome c by heme lyase was
investigated in the cytoplasm of E coli BL21-DE3 cells
Plasmids for T brucei cytochrome c (pKK223–Tbcytc), its
CXXCH variant (pKK223–TbcytcCXXCH), S cerevisiae
cytochrome c heme lyase (pACcyc3) and iso-1-cytochrome c
(pScyc1) were as previously described [9,33] Cells were
cotransformed with the heme lyase plasmid and the plasmid for each of the cytochromes, respectively Cells were grown overnight at 37C with vigorous shaking, in 50 mL of 2·
TY medium (16 gÆL)1 peptone, 10 gÆL)1 yeast extract,
5 gÆL)1 NaCl) supplemented with 100 lgÆmL)1 ampicillin,
34 lgÆmL)1 chloramphenicol and 1 mm isopropyl-thio-b-d-galactoside Nine separate cultures were grown for each combination of heme lyase and cytochrome The E coli periplasmic fraction was prepared as previously described [46], and discarded The spheroplast pellet was resuspended
by vigorous vortexing in 50 mm Tris⁄ HCl plus 150 mm NaCl (pH 7.3), and broken by six freeze–thaw cycles (at )78 and 37 C); this was followed by centrifugation at
25 000 g for 1 h to remove the cell debris The soluble cyto-plasmic fraction was initially assayed by running the pro-teins on SDS⁄ PAGE gels that were stained for proteins containing covalently bound heme [47] Subsequently, the extracts from multiple cultures were pooled and applied to a
5 mL Hi-Trap column containing SP-Sepharose (GE Healthcare) The bound protein was batch eluted using
500 mm NaCl, concentrated, and then assessed using absorption spectroscopy and heme-stained SDS⁄ PAGE gels Western blotting was performed using a polyclonal primary antibody raised against purified, recombinant, Ccm system-matured CXXCH variant T brucei holocyto-chrome c (protein as described in [9]; antibody raised by Covalab, Villeurbanne, France) Unconcentrated E coli soluble cytoplasmic extracts were resolved by SDS⁄ PAGE and blotted onto Hybond-C Extra nitrocellulose membrane (GE Healthcare) The membrane was blocked for 1 h in 5% (w⁄ v) milk powder dissolved in NaCl ⁄ Tris [50 mm Tris ⁄ HCl,
pH 7.5, 120 mm NaCl, 1% (v⁄ v) Tween-20] It was then incubated for 1 h with primary antibody diluted 200-fold in
10 mL of 5% milk⁄ NaCl ⁄ Tris solution; the primary anti-body was used as crude (unpurified) serum The membrane was washed four times (1· 15 min, 3 · 5 min) in 10 mL of NaCl⁄ Tris, and then incubated with the secondary antibody for 1 h in 30 mL of 5% milk⁄ NaCl ⁄ Tris; the secondary anti-body was affinity purified anti-rabbit IgG whole molecule alkaline phosphatase conjugate (purchased from Sigma, Poole, UK), and was used at 6000-fold dilution The mem-brane was then washed three times in NaCl⁄ Tris (each wash for 5 min), and stained by incubation in 10 mL of H2O containing a dissolved FAST 5-bromo-4-chloroindol-2-yl phosphate⁄ Nitro Blue tetrazolium tablet (Sigma)
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council [grant numbers
BB⁄ C508118 ⁄ 1 and BB ⁄ D019753 ⁄ 1] J W A Allen is
a BBSRC David Phillips Fellow, and M L Ginger is
a Royal Society University Research Fellow KAS is the William R Miller Junior Research Fellow,
Table 1 Summary of crystallographic data collection and
refine-ment statistics Numbers in parentheses refer to values in the
high-est-resolution shell Rsym¼ P
j
P
h Ih;j hI h ij P
j
P
h hI h i, where
Ih,jis the jth observation of reflection h, and <Ih> is the mean
inten-sity of that reflection R cryst ¼ P
F obs
j j F j calc j
F obs j, where
F obs and F calc are the observed and calculated structure factor
amplitudes, respectively Rfreeis equivalent to Rcrystfor a 4%
sub-set of reflections not used in the refinement [48] DPI, diffraction
component precision index [49].
Data collection
Synchrotron radiation,
detector and
wavelength (A ˚ )
Diamond, IO2, ADSC Q315 CCD 0.9511
c = 60.93, b = 131.2
Refinement
Nonhydrogen atoms 3199 (including three c-type
hemes, seven sulfates and
563 waters)
Rcryst(all data) 0.212
Average temperature
factor (A˚2)
24.4
Rmsds from ideal values
DPI coordinate error (A ˚ ) 0.09
Ramachandran plot
Trang 10St Edmund Hall, Oxford We thank N Brown for very
helpful crystallographic discussions, A Holehouse for
preliminary experiments, and H Lill for the gift of
plasmids encoding the S cerevisiae proteins used in
this work Crystallographic data were collected at
beamline IO2 at Diamond Light Source, UK, and we
acknowledge the support of T Sorensen at Diamond
and A Labrador at the ESRF, France
References
1 Barker PD & Ferguson SJ (1999) Still a puzzle: why is
haem covalently attached in c-type cytochromes?
Struc-ture 7, R281–R290
2 Stevens JM, Daltrop O, Allen JWA & Ferguson SJ
(2004) C-type cytochrome formation; chemical and
biological enigmas Acc Chem Res 37, 999–1007
3 Allen JWA, Daltrop O, Stevens JM & Ferguson SJ
(2003) C-type cytochromes: diverse structures and
bio-genesis systems pose evolutionary problems Philos
Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 358, 255–266
4 Kranz R, Lill R, Goldman B, Bonnard G & Merchant S
(1998) Molecular mechanisms of cytochrome c biogenesis:
three distinct systems Mol Microbiol 29, 383–396
5 Hill GC & Pettigrew GW (1975) Evidence for the
amino-acid sequence of Crithidia fasciculata cytochrome
c555 Eur J Biochem 57, 265–271
6 Priest JW & Hajduk SL (1992) Cytochrome c reductase
purified from Crithidia fasciculata contains an atypical
cytochrome c1 J Biol Chem 267, 20188–20195
7 Pettigrew GW, Leaver JL, Meyer TE & Ryle AP
(1975) Purification, properties and amino acid
sequence of atypical cytochrome c from two protozoa,
Euglena gracilis and Crithidia oncopelti Biochem J
147, 291–302
8 Pettigrew GW, Aviram I & Schejter A (1975)
Physico-chemical properties of two atypical cytochromes c,
Crithidiacytochrome c557and Euglena cytochrome c558
Biochem J 149, 155–167
9 Allen JWA, Ginger ML & Ferguson SJ (2004)
Matura-tion of the unusual single cysteine (XXXCH)
mitochon-drial c-type cytochromes found in trypanosomatids
must occur through a novel biogenesis pathway
Biochem J 383, 537–542
10 Allen JWA, Jackson AP, Rigden DJ, Willis AC,
Ferguson SJ, Willis AC, Ferguson SJ & Ginger ML
(2008) Order within a mosaic distribution of
mitochon-drial c-type cytochrome biogenesis systems? FEBS J
275, 2385–2402
11 Pettigrew GW (1974) The purification and amino acid
sequence of cytochrome c552from Euglena gracilis
Bio-chem J 139, 449–459
12 Kuras R, Saint-Marcoux D, Wollman FA & de Vitry C
(2007) A specific c-type cytochrome maturation system
is required for oxygenic photosynthesis Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 104, 9906–9910
13 Hamel P, Corvest V, Giege P & Bonnard G (2008) Bio-chemical requirements for the maturation of mitochon-drial c-type cytochromes Biochim Biophys Acta 1793, 125–138
14 van Hellemond JJ, Hoek A, Schreur PW, Chupin V, Ozdirekcan S, Geysen D, van Grinsven KW, Koets AP, Van den Bossche P, Geerts S et al (2007) Energy metabolism of bloodstream form Trypanosoma theileri Eukaryot Cell 6, 1693–1696
15 Guerra DG, Decottignies A, Bakker BM & Michels PA (2006) The mitochondrial FAD-dependent glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase of Trypanosomatidae and the glycosomal redox balance of insect stages of
Trypanoso-ma bruceiand Leishmania spp Mol Biochem Parasitol
149, 155–169
16 van Hellemond JJ, Simons B, Millenaar FF & Tielens AG (1998) A gene encoding the plant-like alternative oxidase is present in Phytomonas but absent in Leishmania spp J Eukaryot Microbiol 45, 426–430
17 Chaudhuri M, Ord RD & Hill GC (2006) Trypanosome alternative oxidase: from molecule to function Trends Parasitol 22, 484–491
18 Lamour N, Riviere L, Coustou V, Coombs GH, Barrett
MP et al (2005) Proline metabolism in procyclic Try-panosoma bruceiis down-regulated in the presence of glucose J Biol Chem 280, 11902–11910
19 Helfert S, Estevez AM, Bakker B, Michels P & Clayton
C (2001) Roles of triosephosphate isomerase and aero-bic metabolism in Trypanosoma brucei Biochem J 357, 117–125
20 Moore GR & Pettigrew GW (1990) Cytochromes c: Evolutionary, Structural, and Physicochemical Aspects Springer-Verlag, New York, NY
21 Keller RM, Picot D & Wuthrich K (1979) Individual assignments of the heme resonances in the 360 MHz1H NMR spectra of cytochrome c557from Crithidia onco-pelti Biochim Biophys Acta 580, 259–265
22 Keller RM, Pettigrew GW & Wuthrich K (1973) Struc-tural studies by proton NMR of cytochrome c557from Crithidia oncopelti FEBS Lett 36, 151–156
23 Bowman SEJ & Bren KL (2008) The chemistry and bio-chemistry of heme c: functional bases for covalent attachment Nat Prod Rep 25, 1118–1130
24 Rosell FI & Mauk AG (2002) Spectroscopic properties
of a mitochondrial cytochrome c with a single thioether bond to the heme prosthetic group Biochemistry 41, 7811–7818
25 Tanaka Y, Kubota I, Amachi T, Yoshizumi H & Matsubara H (1990) Site-directedly mutated human cytochrome c which retains heme c via only one thioether bond J Biochem 108, 7–8