TAP CHi KHOA HOC DHSP TPHCM sS 7(85) nim 201d* T H V C TR4JSG QUAN LI CONG TAC KIEM TRA HQC KI CUA HIEU TRlTdNG CAC TRl/OfNG TRUNG HQC CO Sd d Q U A N TAN BINH THANH PHO HO CHI MINH PHAN VAN QUANG'''' TO[.]
Trang 1T H V C TR4JSG QUAN LI CONG TAC KIEM TRA HQC KI CUA HIEU TRlTdNG
CAC TRl/OfNG TRUNG HQC CO S d d Q U A N TAN BINH
THANH PHO HO CHI MINH
PHAN V A N QUANG'
TOM TAT
Cdng tdc kiim tra hoc ki (KTHK) nhung ndm gdn ddy tai cdc trudng tnmg hoc ca sd (THCS) duac Id chirc thuc hien mdt cdch bdi bdn, khoa hoc dd gdp phin ndng cao chdt luang gido due ciia nhd hTtdng Bi Idm tdt cdng tdc ndy, hieu trudng (HT) phdi van dung cdc chdc ndng qudn li h-ong viec lap ki hoach: Id chiic thuc hien, chi dao vd kiim tra, ddnh gid edng tdc KTHK Bdi viit ndy trinh bdy kit qud khdo sdt thuc trang viee qudn li cdng tdc KTHK cua HT tgi mot sd h-udng THCS d Thdnh phd Hd Chi Minh (TPHCM), ddng thai di xudt cdc bien phdp ndng cao hieu qud qudn li cdng tdc KTHK tai cdc hnrang THCS
Tie khoa: quan li giio due, hieu trudng, kiim tta hpe ki, trung hpc co sd
ABSTRACT
The reality of term-testing management of principals in junior high schools
In Tan Binh district of Ho Chi Minh City
Term Testing has been organized properly and professionally in Junior High schools
in the recent years, which has improved the quality of education To make this work principles have to manipulate all managing fiinctions in planning, performing, leading, checking and judging term testing administration This report shows the result of a survey about the principals' term testing management in some junior high schools in Ho Chi Minh city as well as proposes a number of solutions to improve this management
Keywords; educational management, principal, term testing, the junior high school
1 D^t vin d i Hieu trudng quin li tdt cdng tac
Cdng tie KTHK cho hpc sinh li KTHK khdng chi giiip nha trudng dinh mdt cdng doan quan trpng ttong qui trinh gia dung nang lire, trinh dp cua hpc sinh, giio due v i dio tao d trudng phd thdng giiip giao vien (GV) xiy dung v i diSu ndi chung v i trudng THCS ndi rieng chinh ke hoach giing day, mi cdn la co
Theo Quy chi ddnh gid, xip loai hoc sinh sd di HT danh gii chit lupng giing day THCS va hoc sinh trung hoe phd Ihdng, cua GV, viec thuc hiSn chuong ttinh, ke
t^ Khoin 2, Diiu 7, Chucmg 3 da quy hoach giang day cua td, nhdm chuyen
djnh cy thi vi cae bii kiim ten thudng mdn, danh gii chit lupng giio due cua
xuyen, kiim tta dinh ki v i KTHK [1] nhi Uirdng, tir dd cd ki ho^ch diiu chinh
• HVCH, Trudng B?l hpc Su ph?m TPHCM; Email: quang_196901@yahoo.com
Trang 2kjp thdi nhim ning cao chit lupng giao
due vi dao tap
Chinh vi tim quan trpng dd, ttong
bai viet nay, chiing tdi sS phin tich thuc
trang HT quan U cdng tie KTHK t£ii mdt
si ttirdng THCS d TPHCM lim ea sd
thuc tiSn de dS xuat eae bien phap giiip
HT trudng THCS quin li cdng tic niy
mpt cich hieu qui
2 T h i ^ trang quan Ii cong tic
KTHK tai mot so tru-dng THCS d
TPHCM hifn nay
2.1 MifC lieu nghien ciiu
Nghien cuu nham khio sat thuc
trang quan li cua HT trudng THCS vi
cdng tie KTHK theo cic chiic nang quan
h: xdy difng ke hoach, td chiic, lanh dao
vd kiem tra cdng tdc KTHK cua HT nhd trucmg
2.2 Dja bin vi khdch thi nghiin ciru
Khio sit dupc tiin hinh tji 12 ttTrdng THCS cdng l^ip cda qujn Tin Binh, TPHCM, gdm eic trudng: NguySn Gia Thiiu, Huing Hoa Thim, Trudng Chinh, Ngd Quyin, Quang Trung, Tin Binh, Ngd ST LiSn, Au Ljc, Ly Thudng KiSt, Pham Ngpc Thjich, Vd Vin Tin, Trin Van Dang Khich thi khio sit li 35 ein bp quin II (CBQL) ttordng THCS (HT, phd HT), 120 GV vi nhin vien (NV) cua cac trudng dupc lua chpn ngiu nhiSn Miu nghiSn ciiu thi hien cu thi ttong bing sau:
Bang 1 Khdi qudt ve khdch the khdo sdt
Khach thS khio sat
Hieu trudng
Phd hieu trudng
Td trudng chuyen mdn
GV
Nhin vien
Solirgng
11
24
36
59
25
Tong C9ng
35
120
Z3 Phirong phap nghien ciiu
Phuang phip chinh dupe sii dyng l i
phuong phip diiu tra bing bing hdi
Thang diem dinh gia thuc ttang quan li
edng tic KTHK cua HT tai 12 trudng
THCS dupc quy udc nhu sau: 4 diim
-Rit tdt, 3 diim - Tdt, 2 diim - Trung
btah, 1 diim - Chua tit, 0 diim - Rit
chua tdt
Diim ttomg bmh (DTB) dupe chia
ra eic mirc dO:
0 diim - 0,8 diim: Rit chua tdt;
0,9 diim - 1,7 diSm: Chua tit;
1,8 diim - 2,6 diim: Trung binh;
2,7 diSm - 3,5 diim: Tdt;
3,6 diSm - 4 diSm: Rit tdt
2.4 Kel qud nghien ciiu 2.4.1 Thuc trang viec lap ke hogeh cdng tdc KTHK tai 12 trucmg THCS dufc khdo sdt
Xiy dung ki hojch l i chiie nang diu tien vi eo bin ciia nha quin li Trong quin li cdng tic KTHK ciing viy, HT xiy dung ke hoach, chi d^o cac
bp ph|in v i c i nhin lien quan lim tit viSc xiy dipig ki hojch li mdt yiu td quan ttpng, dam bao thinh edng eda cdng tic KTHK tai trudng THCS Viec
Trang 3xiy dung kS hoach phai bao him diy dii
cac ndi dung edng viec cua mdt dpt
KTHK: ra di vd duyet de kiem tra,
chudn bi ca sd vat chdt, chudn hi dn
phdm, sao in de, coi kiem tra, chdm
kiem tra, chdm xdc sudt kiem tra lgi, nhgp diem vd xu li ket qud
Kit qua khio sit thuc tt?ng vi|c lip
ki hoach cic cdng viec ciia mdt te KTHK tjj 12 ttudng THCS ciia qu|n Tin Bmh dupc the hien d bing 2 sau diy;
Bang 2 Bdnh gid eua CBQL, GVvd NVve viec
Lap ke hoaeh cac cong vi^c
eiia mgt dfft KTHK
1 Lip ki hoach ra dS, duyet de KTHK
2 Lap kS hoach chuin bj co sd vat chit td chiie
KTHK
3 Lap kS hoaeh ehuan bj an pham, phuong tien
sao in di KTHK
4 Lap ke hoach sao in de KTHK
5 Lap ke hoaeh td chire coi KTHK
6 Lip kS hoach chim bai KTHK
7 Lip kS hoach chim xic suit bai KTHK
8 Lip kS hoach nhip diSm, xir Ii kSt qui bai
KTHK
Igp ke hoach cong tdc KTHK
Danh gia ciia CBQL
DTB 3,60 3,71 3,60 3,60 3,66 3,49 3,31 3,54
DLC 0,497 0,458 0,497 0,497 0,482 0,507 0,471 0,505
Thil bic
3
1
3
3
2
7
8
6
Banh gia cAa GV, ]
NV i
DTB 3,62 3,61 3,58 3,58 3,57 3,46 3,35 3,54
DLC 0,522 0,490 0,495 0,496 0,546 0,500 0,513 0,500
Thd bic ,
1 L
2 i
3
3
5
7 i
8
6
Khi khao sat lap ke hogeh cdc cong
viec cua mgt dot KTHK, chung toi ghi
nhan viec lap ke hoach cua HT, Pho HT
dirge danh gia vai DTB rat cao (deu tren
3,31), chung to co sir quan tam r4t lon
cua HT, GV va NV ve cac noi dung nay
Bang 2 cung cho thay sir thong nhat ciia
CBQL, GV va NV khi danh gia viec Lap
ke hogeh chudn hi ca sa vgt chdt td chiec
KTHK; Lap ki hogeh td chuc coi KTHK;
Lgp ki hogeh ra di, duyet di KTHK; Lap
ke hogeh sao in di KTHK vd Lap ki
hogeh chudn bi dn phdm, phuang tien
sao in de KTHK dat miic diem cao nhlt
(3,57-3,71); Lap ke hogeh chdm bdi
KTHK; Lap ke hogeh chdm xdc sudt bdi
KTHK ; Lap ke hogeh nhdp diem, xu li kit qud bdi KTHK dat mirc dilm (3,31-3,54) Tit ca cac npi dung tren dhu dugc danh gia a mure ''Tdt" Dieu nay phSn nao
dg phan anh thirc trang HT cac trucmg da
CO quan tam, chii y den viec xay dung ke hoach cho cong tac KTHK
Vay viec lap ke hoach cua moi dau eong viec trong mgt dot KTHK cua HT, Pho HT dugc danh gia "Rit t6t" va
"T6t" Didu nay cho thiy HT quan li cong tac KTHK tai cac tnrcmg THCS la rit t6t, CO ke hoach va quan li tot ke hoach de ra
2.4.2 Thuc trgng viec to chirc cdng tdc
Trang 4Chiic nang td chirc d nhi trudng
dupc thi Men thdng qua viec bifu trudng
phin phdi v i sap xip cic ngudn lire theo
nhirng cich thire nhit djnh dS dim bio
thue hien tit ki hoach di ra
Kit qui khio sit CBQL vi GV, NV
vS viec HT td chuc eac cdng viec ciia mdt dot KTHK tai 12 trudng THCS cua quin Tin Binh duac thi hien d bang 3 sau diy:
Bang 3 Banh gia cua CBQL, GVvdNV vi viec td chirc cdng tdc KTHK
To chirc cac cdng viec
cua mSt dot KTHK
V
1 To chitc ra de, duyet dS KTHK
2 To chirc chuin bj co sd vat chat td chire KTHK
3 To chiic chuin bj in phim, phuong tien sao in di
KTHK
4 T6 chirc sao in dS KTHK
5 To chitc coi KTHK
6 Td chirc chim bai KTHK
7 Td chire chim xic suit bii KTHK
8 Td chirc nhap diSm, xu li kSt qui bii KTHK
Danh gia eua CBQL
DTB 3.60 3.60 3,60 3,66 3,77 3,49 3,26 3,43
DLC 0.497 0.497 0,497 0,482 0,426 0,507 0,561 0,502
Thd bic
3
3
3
2
1
6
8
7
Dinh gia cua GV, NV DTB 3.57 3.60 3,58 3,64 3,69 3,50 3,33 3,52
DLC 0.530 0.492 0,495 0,482 0,464 0,502 0,568 0,502
Thir bic
5
3
4
2
1
7
8
6 Khao sat thuc trang to chuc cac
cong viec cua mpt dgt KTHK, chiing toi
ghi n h ^ viec to chuc cua HT, Pho HT
dugc danh gia vai DTB rat cao (deu tren
3,26) Ket qua khao sat CBQL, GV va
NV deu cho rang to chiec coi KTHK (xep
haig 1), to chuc sao in de KTHK (xep
hang 1) la 2 npi dung dugc danh gia cao
nhat Trong khi do to chuc chdm bdi
KTHK; to chuc chdm xdc sudt bdi
KTHK; to chuc nhdp diem, xu li kit qud
bdi KTHK dugc CBQL, GV va NV co
cung nhan dinh la "Tot" nhung l^i xep
h£ing thip nhit (3,26-3,52)
K^t qua khao sat cho thiy cong tac
t6 chijrc cac cong viec ciia mgt dgt KTHK
dugc HT phan cong va t6 chuc thuc hien
tot, hieu qua, gop phan vao viec nang cao chat lugng giao due tai cae tnrong THCS
2.4.3, Thuc trgng lanh dgo cdng tdc KTHK
Theo Tran Kiem, chiic nang lanh dao "thl hien nang lire cua nguai quan li Nguai CBQL phai dieu khien cho he thong hoat dgng nham thuc hien muc tieu
da de ra Day la qua trinh su dung quyen lire quan li dS tac dgng din cac d6i tugng
bj quan li (con nguai, cac bg phan) mgt each CO chii dich nhim phat huy hit tilm nang cua hg huong vao viee dat mue tieu ehung ciia he thong" [2, tr.68]
Ket qua khao sat thuc trang viec lanh dao cac cong viec eua mpt dpt KTHK tai 12 truang THCS quan Tan Binh dugc the hien a bang 4 sau d§y:
Trang 5Bang 4 Ddnh gid cua CBQL, GV vd NV vi vi^c lanh dgo cdng tdc KTHK
Chi d^o cic cdng vi^c
cua mgt dft KTHK
1 Chi dao ra di, duyet di KTHK
2 Chi dao chuin bj co sd v^t chit td chirc KTHK
3 Chi dao chuan bj an phim, phuong ti^n sao in di
KTHK
4 Chi dao sao in dS KTHK
5 Chi dao eoi KTHK
6 Chi d?io eham bii KTHK
7 Chi dao chim xae suit bai KTHK
8 Chi dao nhip diSm, xit li ket qui bii KTHK
Binh gii cfia CBQL
DTB 3,71 3,71 3,71 3,60 3,66 3,71 3,37 3,54
DLC 0,458 0,458 0,458 0,497 0,482 0,458 0,598 0,505
Thir hie
1
1
1
6
5
1
8
7
Dinh gii cnaGV.NV
DTB 3,59 3,63 3,67 3,63 3,63 3,58 3,46 3,62
DLC 0,527 0,486 0,473 0,484 0,486 0,496 0,548 0,488
Thii bic
6
2
1
2
2
7
8
5
B ^ g 4 cho thay viSc d§nh gid thii
b$c cao nhat, miic '''Rdt tdf d cac ngi
dung chi dgo cdc cdng vi$c cua mgt dot
KTHK: CBQL danh gia cac n^i dung chi
dgo ra de, duyet di KTHK; chi dgo chdm
bdi KTHK; chi dgo chudn b{ ca sa vgt
chdt; chi dgo chudn bi dn phdm, phuang
ti$n sao in di KTHK (3,71, xip h ^ g 1)
GV va NV thi danh gid chi dgo chudn bi
dn phdm, phuang ti^n sao in di KTHK;
chi dgo chudn bi ca sa vgt chdt to chuc
KTHK; chi dgo sao in di KTHK; chi dgo
coi KTHK (dgt 3,63-3,71) Tuy nhidn co
si; ddnh gid rit khac bi?t trong vi?c chi
dgo chdm bdi KTHK, CBQL xip h ^ g 1;
trong khi do GV va NV xip hang 7 Co
sir thong nhit trong vi^c danh gia chi dgo
chdm xdc sudt bdi KTHK dugc xip hang
8 (3,75-3,46) v^ dugc ddnh gid "T6t"
Nhu vay HT da chi dao th\rc hien tot cong tac to chiic KTHK tren co sa cdc van ban phap li, xay dung ke hoach va ra quySt dinh thuc hien Npi dung nay da dupc danh gid 6 miic "Rit tot" va "Tot"
2.4.4 JhiiCC trgng kiem tra, ddnh gid cdng tdc KTHK
Kiem tra, ddnh gid la mpt npi dung quan trgng, la nhiem vu thuong xuyen va
la khau cuoi cung ciia cong tac quan li Trong cong tac KTHK cf trudng, c6ng tdc kiem tra, ddnh gid giiip HT don dfic va thuc diy GV, NV va hpc sinh thuc hien nghiem tiic, co chat lugng trong dgt KTHK Chiing toi tiln hanh khdo sat c6ng tac kiSm tra, ddnh gid trong vi^e to
chijc KTHK va thu dugc kit qua nhu a
Bdng 5 sau day:
Trang 6Phan Vin Quang
^BangS Ddnh gid ciia CBQL, GVvdNV vi viec HT kiim tra cong tae KTHK
Kiem tra va dinh gia cac cdng viec
cua mpt a<ft KTHK
1 Kiim tta vi danh gii viec ra di, duySt di KTHK
2 Kiem tta vi dinh gii viec chuin bi co sd vit chit
ti chile KTHK
3 KiSm tra vi dinh gii viec chuin bj in phim,
phuong tien sao in di KTHK
4 Kiem tra vi danh gia viec sao in di KTHK
5 KiSm tta va dinh gii viee eoi KTHK
6 Kiim tta vi dinh gii viee chim bii KTHK
7 KiSm tra vi danh gii viec chim xac suit bii
KTHK
8 Kiem tra va dinh gii viee nhip diim, xir Ii kit
qua bai KTHK
Dinh gia eua CBQL DTB 3,71 3,71 3,71 3,60 3,66 3,71 3,37 3,60
DLC 0,458 0,458 0,458 0,497 0,482 0,458 0,598 0,497
Thil bac
1
1
1
6
5
1
8
6
Danh gia cua GV, NV DTB 3,53 3,61 3,67 3,59 3,53 3,44 3,38 3,54
DLC 0,501 0,490 0,473 0,494 0,501 0,499 0,486 0,500
Thii bae
5
2
1
3
5
8
7
4 KSt qui khio sit CBQL vi ndi
dung kiem tra, ddnh gid cdc cdng viec
cua mot dot KTHK duac dinh gia "Rit
tdt" va dupc xip theo thii bic tir cao din
thap nhu sau: Kiem tra, ddnh gid viec
chudn bi ca sd vgt chdt; Kiim tra, ddnh
gjd viec chudn bi dn phdm, phucmg tien
sao in di KTHK (3,71) Kiim tra, ddnh
gid viec coi KTHK (3,66) Kiim tra, ddnh
gid viec ra de, duyet de vd sao in di
KTHK chdm bai KTHK (3,60) RiSng npi
dung kiem tra, ddnh gid viec chdm xdc
sudt bdi KTHK (3,37) dupc danh gii d
mure "Tdt"
Bing 5 cho thiy viee kiim tra vi
dinh gii cie cdng viec ciia mdt dpt
KTHK d cic trudng THCS dupc GV vi
NV danh gii d miic "Tdt", "Rit tdt" vi
dupc xip theo thil bac tir cao xudng thip
DTB cic ndi dung djt tir 3,38 din 3,67;
ttong dd, ndi dung kiem fi-a, ddnh gid viec chudn bi dn phdm, phuong tien sao
in di KTHK (3,67); kiim tra, ddnh gid viec chudn bi ca sd vat chdt Id chirc KTHK (3,61) dupc danh gii "Rit tit" Cic npi dung kiem tra, ddnh gid sao in di KTHK: kiim tra, ddnh gid coi KTHK: kiem tra, ddnh gid ra de, duyet di KTHK; Nligp diem, xd li ket qud bdi KTHK; kiim tra, ddnh gid chdm bdi KTHK; kiim tra, ddnh gid viec chdm xdc sudt bdi KTHK
ed DTB dat tir 3,38 din 3,59 vi dupc dinh gii "Tdt"
Tuy nhiSn, cd sir khic biet ttong
Kiem tra vd ddnh gid viec chdm bdi KTHK, CBQL xip hang 1 edn GV vi NV
lai xip hang 8, nhimg ci CBQL, GV va
NV dSu dinh gia "Tdt" Nhu viy, viec
kiem tra, ddnh gid cdc cdng viec cua mot dot KTHK dupc HT kiim tta, dinh gii vi
Trang 7TAP CHl KHOA HOC DHSP TPHCM
thuc hien mdt each bii bin dua tten vipc
lap kS hoach
3 Kit luan
Kit qui khio sat thuc ti tir CBQL,
GV va NV tai 12 trudng THCS d quan
Tin Binh TPHCM cho thiy mdi ndi dung
ttong qua ttinh td chiic KTHK diu gdp
phin quan ttpng ttong viee td chiic thinh
cdng mpt dpt KTHK Cac cdng tdc chudn
bi ca sd vgt chdt, cdng tdc coi kiem tra,
viec chudn bi dn phdm, phuang tien sao
in di KTHK diu dupc CBQL, GV, NV
dinh gii xip b^ng tir "Tdt" ttd len
Nhin ehung, cic chile nang quin li
cua HT dupc dinh gii tir tdt trd ISn Tuy
nhien, DTB cua eae ndi dung xip hang
(cao nhit, thip nhit) chua cd su thing
nhit ttong dinh gii, cdn cd su ehSnh
lech Vi vay, HT ein tip trung vi cd
TAI LIfU THAM KHAO
1 BS Giio due vi Dao tao (2011), Quy chi ddnh gid, xip loai hoc sinh h-ung hoe ca sd
vd trung hoc phd thdng (Ban hinh kem theo Thdng tu sd 58/2011/TT-BGDDT ngiy
12/12/2011 cua Bp ttudng Bp Giio due vi Dio tao)
2 Trin Kiim (2014), Nhirng vdn di ca bdn ciia khoa hoe qudn li gido due, Nxb Dai
hpc Su pham Hi Npi
(Ngiy Tda so^n nhin duvc bii: 16-4-2016: ngiy phin biin dinh gii: 29-6-2016:
ngiy chip nhin ding: 23-7-2016)
nhimg giii phap cu thi, ddng bd it cic ndi dung: chdm xdc sudt bdi KTHK-, chdm bdi KTHK-, nhgp diim, xir II kit qud bdi KTHK
Thuc ttang ttSn ciing cho thiy vai trd quan U cdng tic KTHK d ttuftng THCS la mpt ttong nhthig nhi§m vu qi«i ttpng, gdp phin dim bio chit lupng giao due vi dao t£io cua trudng Vi viy, di cdng tac KTHK tai cac ttruang dugc td, ehiic mdt cich cd hieu qua thi HT can phai vjn dung tdt cic ehiic nang cua mpt nhi quin li Kit qua khio sat dupc trinh biy ttpng bii viit nay li ca sd thuc tien quan ttpng, cd the giiip cho HT cae ttirdng THCS xem xet, nit kmh nghiem, nhim tim ra cic bien phap quin H tdt hem nira ttong edng tic KTHK