BAI BAO KHOA HOC LlfA CHON TIEU CHUAN VA TIEU CHJ DANH GlA CHAT LlTlfNG 6IA0 V | £ N GlAO DUC THE CHAT THEO HlTOfNG D A P (fNG NHU CAU XA H D I DIflfC D A D T A O T A I TRirtfNG CAO DANG TUYEN QUANG •[.]
Trang 1LlfA CHON TIEU CHUAN VA TIEU CHJ DANH GlA CHAT LlTlfNG 6IA0 V | £ N
GlAO DUC THE CHAT THEO HlTOfNG D A P (fNG NHU CAU XA HDI
DIflfC DAD TAO T A I TRirtfNG CAO DANG TUYEN QUANG
• • >
Tran Vu PhiFong *
g i n h G ^ ^
Tdmtlt:
Nhim xic djnh ndi dung djnh huwng cho vide dii mdi chuwng trinh dio tgo chuydn nginh (
trinh dd cao ding tgi Tnidng Cao dang Tuydn Quang de t i i da nghidn cdu lya chpn du'pc cic tifiiT
chuin, tieu chi dinh gii chit li/png giio vidn GDTC theo hu-dng d i p dng nhu d u x i hdi dfi qua
dio tgo tgi tnrdng Cao ding Tuydn Quang
TCr khda: Chuang trinh dio tgo, Cao ding Tuyen quang, cic tidu chuin, tidu chi, chit lirpng
giio vidn GDTC
Selecting criteria and standards for teachers' quality assessment in College of Tuyen Quang
in the direction of social needs Summary:
To determine the oriented contents for the renewal of specialized training program of Physical
Education course of college degree in the College of Tuyen Quang the research have selectecj
several standards and criteria for evaluating the quality of Physical Education educated in the school
under the direction of social needs
Keyword: Training pnsgram College of Tuyen Quang, criteria, standards, qualities of physical
education teachers » _
PHl/dNG PHAP NGHIEN CUfU
Qui trinh nghifn ciiu sii dyng cic phuong phip: Phuang phip phan tich vi ting hpp tii lifu; phuang phip phdng van tpa dim; phucmg phap toin hpc thing ke
KET QUA NGHigN CUfU VA BAN LUAN
1 K h i i q u i t c i c tidu c h u i n , t l l u chi dinh
g i i c h i t lu-Q-ng gi^o vidn cua m$t s6 n u ^ trdn t h l gid"!
Qua nghien ciiu vi tim hilu cac tieu chuin, tieu chi dinh gia giao vien d mpt so nude v4 virng lanh thi nhu My, Anh, Uc, Hong Kdng va Dan Mgch, dl tii nhgn thiy vifc xay dyng bp tieu chuan danh gii ehit lupng giio vien deu dupe quan tam vi coi dd li mdt trong nhihig nhifm vy quan trpng frong vifc dii mdi vi phit trien giao dye 6 moi quic gia bp tifu chuin dinh gia chit lupng giio vien Igi dupe xay dyng theo cic tifu chuin, tieu chi khic nhau phu hpp
vdi vai nen van hda vi miic dp phit triln kinh
O^T VAN DE
De dinh gii dupe chat lupng giio vien
GDTC Trudng Cao dang Tuyen ()uang dio tao
cd dip ling dupe yeu ciu frong thyc tien cdng
tic hay khdng tnrdc hit phii xic dinh dupe
nhiing tieu chuan vi tieu ehi dinh gii Trong
tfiyc tien hifn nay, dpi ngu giio vien GDTC ciia
cic hirdng phd tfidng diu ap dyng bp tieu chuin,
tieu chi dinh gii chung dii vdi tit ci cic giio
vien chinh dieu dd da dan din vifc kit qua dinh
gii khdng phin inh dupe chinh xic vi toan difn
cic mgt dgc tfiu frong hogt dpng chuyen mdn
cua giio vien GDTC frong tfiyc tien cdng tic
Vi \ay \ iec lya chpn dupe cic tifu chuin, tifu
chi dinh gii chit luijmg giio vien GDTC theo
hudng dip ling nhu eiu cua xa hpi dupe dio tgo
tgi Trudng Cao ding Tuyen Quang li vin dl
mang tinh cip thilt, li co sd khoa hpe quan
trpng gdp phin nang cao chit lupng dio tao cua
Nha ttirdng
Trang 2N- a « o cnat ii^tmg gia?TidI?GDTCIi?l6f?SI5
nhtmg ylu to quan trpng giup nang cao hidu qua
GDTC trong t n , d ^ g hpc cac d p (Anh minh hpa)
te - xa hpi cua mdi nude, hiy nhien frong dd ludn
xac dinh cic diem chung li cac tieu chuin quan
hjpng nhat cua mpt giio vien, gim: Phim chit
^ H d u c , ning lyc chuyen mdn, nang luc giao
• P ^ ( n a n g lyc su phgm), ning lyc phit ttiin
chuyen mdn
2 C i c tieu chuin, tieu chi danh gia giao
vidn trong hf th6ng giio dye qud^ d i n
d-Vigt Nam
Dl tii da tim hilu cic bp tieu chuin, tieu chi
dinh gii giio vien, gim:
+ Chuan nghl nghifp giio vien Mim non
(Ban hinh kem tfieo quylt dinh s i 02/200S/QD
BGDDT ngiy 22 1/ 2008 cua Bp ttirdng Bp
Giao dye vi Dio tap)
+ Chuan nghl nghifp giio vien Tilu hpc
(Ban hinh tfieo quylt dinh s i
05/2007/QD-BGDDT ngiy 8 3 '2007 ciia Bp frudng Bd Giio
dye vi Dio tgo)
+ Chuan nghl nghifp giio \ ien frimg hpc ca
sa, giio vien hung hpc phi thdng (Ban hinh
kem tfieo Thdng hr s i 30 2009 /TT-BGDDT
ngiy 22 thing 10 nam 2009 ciia Bd frirdng Bd
Giio dye vi Dio tgo)
+ Chuan nghl nghifp giio vien day nghl
(Ban hinh tfieo thdng tu s i 30/2010
TT-BLDTBXH nga> 29 tfiang 9 nam 2010 cua Bd
fruong Bp Lao dpng - Thuong bmh vi Xa hdi)
, + Chuin nghifp vu su phgm giio vien frung
cap chuyen nghifp (Ban hinh kdm flieo Thdne hr
sd 08 /2012 TT-BGDDT ngiy 05 tfiing 3 n L
2012 cua Bp frudng Bp Giio dye vi Dao tao)
WTiiWIitTOIlintW - s d 2 g B 1 5 Qua nghien ciiu cic bp tieu chuan, tieu chi dinh gii giao vien chiing tdi nhgn ra ring, d Vift Nam, khi xay dyng cac quy dinh chuin giao vien, giing vien cic bac hpc
Bd Giio due v i Dio tao da cd sy tham khao, ITnh hdi, kl thiia vi phat huy cac tieu chuin, tieu chi dinh gii giio vien d cac nude cd nen giio due phit ttiin fren thl gidi \ i phu hop vdi die dilm xa hpi, phong tyc tap quan cua nude
ta Tuy nhien cd thl nhan thiy, frong bd tieu ehi danh cho cip Tieu hpe vi mam non vifc diing hi cdn gay khd hieu cho ngudi dpc hoac ngudi dinh gia nhu nhiing tfiuat ngu: "Tieu chi cua chuan", "Yeu ciu ciia chuin" dii vdi cip phd flidiig va day nghl cd sy khdng thing nhit quan diem ve dung tur "tieu chuin" vi "tieu chi" Vi dy d cip phi thdng, frong mpt tieu ehuin cd nhieu tieu chi, cdn trudng day nghl tfii frong mdt tieu chi cd nhilu tieu chu^ Sau khi nghien ciiu cic bd tieu chuin quy dinh chuan giio \ ien cic bic hpc luan in nhan tfiiy cic bd tieu chuin quy dinh chuin giio vien da phu hop vdi rtmg bgc hpc, hiy nhien luan in nhan thay bp "Chuin nghl nghifp giio'vien hung hpc ca sd, giio \ ien trung hoc phi tfidng" vdi 06 tieu chuin, 25 tieu chi da dinh gia dupe toan bp cic mat hogt ddng cua mpt ngudi giio \ ien
3 Lira chon cdc tieu chuan, tieu chi dinh gia giao vien GDTC theo huvng d i p i>na nhu d u xa hdi
Qua nghifn ciiu cic bp tieu chuin quy dinh chuin giio vien cic bgc hpc trong va ngoai nude, luin in da lya chpn bd "chuin nghl nghifp giao vien frung hpc ca sd, giio vien trung hpc phd tfidng" lim ca sd ban diu dl xay
xay dyng bp tieu chuin, tieu chi rieng di dinh gii giio % ien GDTC Tuy nhien, xuit phit tii
muc dich ban hinh bd chuin nghl nghifp diing
de dinh gii chung dii vdi cac giio vien hung
hoc ca sa giio vien frimg hpc phi tfidng, vi v|y
da dan den vifc khi ip dung dl dinh gii ehuin giao Men GDTC se khdng phin anh dupe chinh xac va toin dien cic mat mang tinh die thu
Trang 3BAIBAOKHOAWN:
u
»-o
o
u
o-£
« h
>^
n-•o
c
c
>
o
•<0
>
£
3
«
^
• »
II
•a
o-:5 c JS
•.J _
Ui—->
:Ki
BO
^
• ^
JZ
c
O
c
CJ
*«« Q^
3
•m
>
c
a
3
u
• «
u
o:
;^
r/1
s?
_ i
^
tt^
J
X
• ^
=
o
o
o
o
c
c
r-• »
>
O
ot
s
•jo
i
'O
o
.c
~<S8 x:
u
E
oa s
a
U
•
3
TT
==
O
=
O
o
o -s
1 ^
•»
BO
c
Q
2 '.J
U )
p
• 3
1
- C
c:
-C3
c C
•J
1
c
>- c
n
JZ o
- c —
o c
— -ca
~ i 3 CL
a , -c
+ ~
o
T T
—
^
=
o
o
o
£
r^
• ^
~2
BO
I
E
-a
"5
r 3
-.^
JZ
u
E
J =
•o c
= 0
c
3
•1>
>-c
BO
c
= 0
c
u -a
n
Q =
^ ^ sfl
T- O
O
• ^
—
o
o
o
o
o
o
r^
• *
c
in
o
>
B O
B
KO
Sl
ao
c
• o
o
- b
X
•io
ra
ab
c
g-c
3 *
>^
BO
C
6
•s
fl
• 5
>
•3
•n
BO
+
o
T
^
o
o
o
o
o
:x
r-T r-T
O
•2-BO
§
• a
•to
' O
c
BO
c
«o
>
c -a -S o
o S
, & !
i d y S>E
s =
1 ^
= 0 B 3 - 3
• D "
•.-J
•¥ - 5
o
•*
^'
o
==
o
o
o
g
r^
• *
E
3
E
c
o
Q
c
1
>
JZ
c
C3-P
JZ
c :2 5JJ
C
tA
'12
- o
'da
c
o c
- o
'J
iS E
^
^-o
o
c
o
o
o
r-• *
a-• o
o
• «
'So
eo
1
E .98
>
eo
• < o
" O
3
E
i
e i
e
>a
Z
u
•
3 ^
O N
m
o
'—
o
o
•*^
M
^
0 0
v^
rr
c
E
E
• < w
r j
.^
ra
1
rs
«o u
IE
• 3 • < «
-1- o
vo
O N
f*^
O
o
o
o
vn
>o
Ov
t N
rr
ao
1
J 3
cd
ra
• 3 BO
" 8
J = D
s >
E Z
3 ( 8
J -E S
o
• *
o
o
o
o
o
c
o
o
1 ^
rr
m
•a
s
ec
B
z
f '
o
•
-^
^,
• ^
o
o
—
o
=
o
o
r-r r-r
•o
E
•o-j o
cd
• 3 U
- 3
Kd
rs
>
gr
JZ
JZ
a
o -ra 'wj
c 5'
-.r
JZ
O
ra-o
•:)«
0 0
§ u
• O 3
>> "
(Cd J =
BO
-E -J
Kd O
E c
3 ^
-^ -a
; 0 - 0
^ 1
f— 5
ov
ov
r^
O
o
o
—
r^
Ov
vo
• »
-o
•a
X x:
c
u o e
>>
Cd
BO
E
3
rs
c
o o
E -cd
rs
O
Q
CJ
O
-J S
E
• O
E
•3
• 3 x:
a -5
^ -s
^
^^
r^
O
o
o
oo vo"
o
< N
Ov
r^
U
Q
o
J =
•o
E
• i
•E
ao
1
Si
Cd
• 3
<o-rs
E
•flj
9 0
E
• 3
rs
o
• 5
>^
»•
•o
BA
C -ea
o
r n +
^^
o
• »
—
o
o
o
o
o
o
s
• »
eo
1
o
Q
O
B
• O f=
- 3
4i
rs
8
§:
• o
a
X
a
BO
g
3 x:
Q
u
-«
CJ
• o
00
%
rs
> ?
^1
1
1
1
1
;
Trang 4MlWWlmWI 11 HM -sfl2/2015
37
Trang 5BAI BAo KHOA H W
trong hoat dpng chuyen mdn eua giio \'ien TAI LIEU THAM KHAO
GDTC Ddng thdi vdi muc dich ban dau ciia Tieng Viet
lugn an la xay dyng bd tieu chuan, tieu chi 1 Bd Giio dye va dio tgo (2007), Quvei djnh khdng chi dinh gii dupe ning lyc chuyen mdn Sd: 05 2007/QD-BGDDTngdy tV '3/2007 re \-iec
mi cdn phii phan inh dupe muc dp dip ung nhu ban hdnh quy dinh ve chudn nghe nghifp gido
eiu xa hpi ciia ngudi giio vien GDTC frong
thye tien cdng tic tgi dia bin viing nui phia Bic
Tren ca sd bd "chuin nghe nghiep giio vien
trung hpc ca sd, giio vien trung hpc pho thdng",
vdi nhimg yeu ciu dupe dit ra luin an da giir
nguyen 6 tieu chuan nhu da ban hanh, ddng thdi
tien hinh nghien cuu difu chinh, thay thl mdt
so tieu chi vi cich dien dgt frong hinh van dl
eic tieu chi bam sat vdi thyc tiln cdng tic cua
ngudi giio vien GDTC va phan inh dupe miic
dp dip ling nhu ciu xi hpi Tir nhimg ea sd neu
fren lugn in bude dau di xay dyng dupe bp tieu
ehuin, tieu chi (gim: 6 tieu chuin vi 25 tieu chi)
dl dinh gii chuin giio \ ien GDTC
Df bp bp tieu chuan, tieu chi dinh gia chuin
giao vien GDTC dim bio dupe tinh khoa hpc
vi tinh khich quan, lugn an da tiln hinh phdng
van bing philu hdi tdi 147 nhi quan ly giio dye
vi giio vien dang frvc tilp giang dgy GDTC d
cac trudng THCS, Tilu hpc tren loan tinh vdi
thang dilm dinh gii nhu sau: 4= Rit can thilt;
3 = Can thilt; 2 = Binh thudng; 1 = Khdng can
thift Kit qua thu dupe sau khi su ly dupe thl
hifn d bing 1
Ket qui thing ke fren bing cho thiy: 6 tieu
chuan (TC) vi 25 tieu chi (tc) mi dl tii lya chpn
deu dupe cic nha quan ly giio dye vi cac giio
vien dang fryc lilp giing dgy GDTC d cic frudng
Tieu hpc vi THCS cho ring rit can thilt vi cin
vien Tieu hpc
2 Bd Giao dye vi dao tgo (200S),Quyei djnh
sd 02'2008/QD-BGDDT ngdy 22/1/ 2008 ve ban hdnh chudn gido viin Mdm non
3 Bp Giio dye va dio tgo (2Q09),Chudn
nghe nghiip gido viin trung hpc ca sd, gido viin trung hpc pho thdng (Ban hdnh kem theo Thdng tu sd 30 /2009 /TT-BGDDT ngdy 22 ihdng 10 ndm 2009 cua Bp trudng Bp Gido dgc
vd Ddo tao)
4 Bp Lao dpng, Thuomg binh vi Xa hpi
(2QlO),Chudn nghe nghifp gido viin dpy nghi (Ban hdnh theo thong tir So: 30/2010/TT-BLDTBXH ngdy 29 thdng 9 ndm 2010 ctia Bp trudng Bp Lao dpng - Thuang binh vd Xd hpi)
5 Bp Giao dye vi dio tgo (20l2).Chudn nghifp vg suphgm gido viin trung edp chuyen nghifp (Ban hdnh kem theo Thdng tu sd 08 2012/TT-BGDDTngdy 05 thdng 3 ndm 2012 cua Bp trudng Bp Gido due vd Ddo tpo)
Tling Anh
6 Owen J M., Rogers P J (1999) Program Evaluation: Forms and Approaches 2nd edition
Allen & Unwin
7 Australian Universities Quality Agency (2002) AUQA Glossary Refrieved October 17,
2000 from the World Wide Web: http:// www.auqa.edu.au/tools/glossary/index.shfrnl Burrows, A & Harvey, L (1993) thiet vdi sy nhat ehl cao (fren 95% cho ting rat Defining quality in higher education - the can thiet) Xet v e diem so, cic tieu chuan vi freu stakeholder approach In M Shaw & E Roper chi deu dgt diem sd frung binh d muc rat cin thilt (Eds.) Quality in Education and Training (pp
nr 3,94 den 4,00 Day ehinh li nhimg tieu ehuin 44-50) London: Kogan Page.Harvey vu Green
va tieu chi can thiet mi lugn an se sir dyng dl (1993)
dinh gii chit lupng giao vien GDTC da dupe
tnrdng Cao ding Tuyen Quang dio tgo
KjT LUAN
Ket qua nghien ciiu da lya ehpn vi xiy dyng
dupe 06 tieu chuin vdi 25 tieu chi la nhimg tieu
chuan, tieu chi can thilt dl danh gia chit lupng
„•: I. •- J 5 uap ung nhu cau ">-'».".»iJiiiciuuicurncuium-Daseami
d i o t o ' " " ^ ^ "" ' " " ^ '""^'" ^ " ^ S ' ' - ^ « ' « " 8 School Failure, fr 5-10
(Bai ttfp ngay 1/3/2015, Phan bl?n ngdy 23/3/2015 duy^t In ngiy 2/4/2015)
9 Len M R (2005) Capacity Buiding in Higher Education and Quality Assurance in the Asia Pacific Region Paper presented on Asia Pacific Quality Network Meeting, I February
2005 in Hongkong
10 Deno, S L (1992), The nature and development of cuniculum-based measurement
«