AALDEF Amicus Brief Fisher v. UT-Austin

!

+E`KD!#B!/IAF#?@A@DH!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!@@@

*=AD?DHA!#B!AFD!/_@L@!CI?@ED!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!%5I E?^!#B!AFD!/?YI_D=A!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!'/?YI_D=A!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!]

*$ 9+a5!/ON*55*3"!\63C-55!O3-5!"3+!

O*5C6*N*"/+-!/1/*"5+!36!

O*5/O:/"+/1-!/5*/"!/N-6*C/"!

/\\2*C/"+5$!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!]/$!9+!O#DH!"#A!+?DEA!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=H!EH!38D??DJ?DHD=ADG$!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!U0$ 9+!,EH!"#A!2@_@ADG!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=!

/G_@HH@#=H!A#!NEALF!AFD!6EL@EK!

OD_#Y?EJF@LH!#B!+DbEH$!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!%%C$ +FD?D!*H!"#!-8@GD=LD!#B!"DYEA@8D!/LA@#=!/YE@=HA!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=H!EA!9+$!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!%(

%$ "E??#RK^!AE@K#?DG!EBB@?_EA@8D!ELA@#=!J?#Y?E_H!G#!=#A!L#=HA@AIAD!=DYEA@8D!ELA@#=!EYE@=HA!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=!

EJJK@LE=AH$!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!%(Q$ 5/+!HL#?D!GEAE!EA!9+!G#!=#A!HF#R!

+?D_D=G#IH!O@8D?H@A^!>@AF@=!AFD!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=!E=G!\EL@B@L!*HKE=GD?!

C# I=@A^$!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!Q)

0$ +FD!O@BBD?D=A!* @Y?EA@#=!,@HA#?@DH!#B!

/H@E=!/_D?@LE=!E=G!\EL@B@L!*HKE=GD?!

5I`Y?#IJH!,E8D!5FEJDG!+FD@?!

5#L@#DL#=#_@L!-bJD?@D=LDH!@=!AFD!9=@ADG!5AEADH$!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!Q]C$ 5I`HAE=A@EK!-L#=#_@L!E=G!-GILEA@#=EK!

O@HJE?@A@DH!-b@HA!/_#=Y!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=!5I`Y?#IJH!@=!+DbEH$!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!'%O$ ND_`D?H!#B!O@HEG8E=AEYDG!/H@E=!

/_D?@LE=!E=G!\EL@B@L!*HKE=GD?!5I`Y?#IJH!0D=DB@A!B?#_!9+aH!*=G@8@GIEK@fDG!E=G!

"E??#RK^!+E@K#?DG!/G_@HH@#=H!\?#LDHH$!$$$$$!'(

***$+,-!-O9C/+*3"/2!0-"-4*+5!34!

5+9O-"+!O*:-65*+;!/CC69-!+3!/22!

5+9O-"+5$!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!']C#=LKIH@#=!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!'P/JJD=G@b!

!

(*!/$&'%&*2()'"#(#$+&

.;<=<&

3'4#5(6-(7%00$&8"'7!)'P!9$5$!Q((!VQTT'W!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!%)! 3'/##"'(6-(7%00$&8"'7!)'P!9$5$!'TX!VQTT'W!!$$$$$$!+4**$9! :%+;%%,(6-(<"=4*7!]U!4$'G!P'Q!V)AF!C@?$!%PPXW!$$$$!%Q!

%PU%W!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!'(&

+>;>?>=&

* @Y?EA@#=!/LA!#B!%PPT7!\I`$!2$!%T%&X(P7!%T(!5AEA$!(P]U!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!QU&

5@YEK!/K#=!g!NE?AE!+@D=GE7!B$6"'*$#?P(

S++%'#/&$#?P(4&,(#A"(@A$1#$&8(T"'$#%2'42?($&( :$8A"'(U,/24#$%&7!]Q!/_$!5#L$!6D8$!(U]!

VQTT]W!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!QQ!

/=YDK#!"$!/=LFDAE7!)42"P()$8A#*P(4&,(#A"(L*$4&(

L9"'$24&(U=+"'$"&2"!V%PPUW!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!Q]!

0D=!0ELSDH7!B%(L11$'94#$6"(L2#$%&(74&*(H%;"'( T$&%'$#?(.%00"8"(U&'%009"&#(4&,(

4E_@K@DH7!:$,,"&($&(!04$&(I$";R(L&(S6"'6$";(

%1(#A"(C"",*(%1(L*$4&(L9"'$24&(@#/,"&#*($&(

#A"(!/Y0$2(@2A%%0(@?*#"9!VQTT(W7!464$04Y0"(4#(

FAAJhiiRRR$LELB$#?YiLK@LS.A?ELSiLK@LS.A?ELS$JFJjB@KDHk)%!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!'%!

!

!

C#KKDYD!0#E?G7!.%00"8"V7%/&,(@"&$%'*(<%#40(

3'%/+(!'%1$0"()"+%'#!V[IK^!QT%TW7!464$04Y0"( 4#(FAAJhiiJ?#BDHH@#=EKH$L#KKDYD`#E?G$L#_iJ?#BG!

#R=K#EGiQT%T&A#AEK&Y?#IJ&J?#B@KD&?DJ#?A&

L`H$JGB$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!Q(!C#=H#K@GEADG!0?@DB!#B!2A$!1D=$![IK@IH!>$!0DLA#=7!

*=GIH$!6DK$!''%!V%PPPW!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!%P!

NE?S!-$!-=Y`D?Y!g!5^K8@E!,I?AEG#7!B"6"0%+$&8(

!0/'40$*#$2(@F$00*(4&,(B$*+%*$#$%&*($&(.%00"8"R( U=49$&$&8()42$40]U#A&$2(3'%/+(B$11"'"&2"*7!

UQ![$!,@YFD?!-GIL$!(%X!VQT%%W!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!'U!+F#_EH![$!-HJD=HFEGD!g!/KDbE=G?@E!>EKA#=!

!

VQTTQW7!464$04Y0"(4#!FAAJhiiRRR$LD=HIH$Y#8iJ#!

JIKEA@#=iRRRiG#LI_D=AEA@#=iARJHTT)XiAE`)U$JGB!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!%%&%Q!

\EA?@L@E!1I?@=!DA!EK$7!B$6"'*$#?(4&,(:$8A"'(

U,/24#$%&R(<A"%'?(4&,(>9+42#(%&(U,/24#$%&40( S/#2%9"*7!]Q!,E?8$!-GIL$!6D8$!''T!VQTTQW!$$$$$$$$!'U!

>@KK@E_!C$!M@GGD?7!C"84#$6"(L2#$%&(I"'*/*(

L11$'94#$6"(L2#$%&R(L*$4&(!42$1$2(L9"'$24&*( 4'"(@#$00(.4/8A#($&(#A"(.'%**1$'"7!%%!N@LF$![$!

NE?@E!:D?#=@LE!5E=ADK@LDH!g!NE?S!>@KH#=7!

E&14$'(<'"4#9"&#NR(<A"(.4*"(%1(J'"",0"P(#A"(

@L<P(4&,(#A"(@#4&,4',$54#$%&(L++'%42A(#%( B$11"'"&#$40(>#"9(J/&2#$%&$&87!UT!,E?8$!

-GIL$!6D8$!%TX!VQT%TW!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!%P!

6#`D?A!+$!+D?E=@HF@7!L*$4&*(>&(#A"(>6%'?(<%;"'R(

B$0"994*(%1()42$40(>&"W/40$#?($&(L9"'$24&( :$8A"'(U,/24#$%&!VQT%TW!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!QX7!QU&'T!

9$5$!CD=HIH!0I?DEI7![\\dV[\D\(L9"'$24&(

.%99/&$#?(@/'6"?(eVZ"4'(U*#$94#"*7!

464$04Y0"(4#!FAAJhiiBELAB@=GD?Q$LD=HIH$Y#8i`S!

_SiAE`KDi%$TiD=i/C5i%T.';6iO\T'iT(TTTTT95(Uo%XTTTTT95(UT(TTTo%XTTTTT95(U%XX%Q!!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!'Q!

9$5$!CD=HIH!0I?DEI7![\D\(L9"'$24&(

.%99/&$#?(@/'6"?(DVZ"4'(U*#$94#"*7!

464$04Y0"(4#!FAAJhiiBELAB@=GD?Q$LD=HIH$Y#8i`S!

_SiAE`KDi%$TiD=i/C5i%T.%;6i5TQT%iiJ#JY?#IJpT%QoT%)oTQToTQ(oTQPoT)To(TT!!$$$$$$$$$$!QP&'T!

!

9$5$!CD=HIH!0I?DEI7!<"=4*(!'%1$0"(%1(3"&"'40(

B"9%8'4+A$2(.A4'42#"'$*#$2*R([\\\7!464$04Y0"( 4#(FAAJhiiBELAB@=GD?Q$LD=HIH$Y#8i`S_SiAE`KDi%$!

TiD=iO-CiTT.54%iO\%iT(TTTTT95(U!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!%Q!

9$5$!CD=HIH!0I?DEI7!<"=4*(!'%1$0"(%1(3"&"'40(

B"9%8'4+A$2(.A4'42#"'$*#$2*R([\D\7!464$04Y0"( 4#!FAAJhiiBELAB@=GD?Q$LD=HIH$Y#8i`S_SiAE`KDi%$!

TiD=iO-Ci%T.O\iO\O\%iT(TTTTT95(U!$$$$!%Q7!'%!

9+!/IHA@=7!D \VD D(@#4#$*#$240(:4&,Y%%Ff

@#/,"&#*7!464$04Y0"(4#!FAAJhiiRRR$IADbEH$DGI!

iELEGD_@Li@_EiH@ADHiGDBEIKAiB@KDHi5,0PT&P%5A!IGD=AH$JGB!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!%Q!

9+!/IHA@=7![\\_V[\D\(@#4#$*#$240(:4&,Y%%Ff

@#/,"&#*7!464$04Y0"(4#!FAAJhiiRRR$IADbEH$DGI!

iELEGD_@Li@_EiH@ADHiGDBEIKAiB@KDHi5,0TP&%T5A!IGD=AH$JGB!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!%Q!

9+!/IHA@=7!>9+0"9"&#4#$%&(4&,()"*/0#*(%1(#A"(

<"=4*(L/#%94#$2(L,9$**$%&*(H4;7!3LA$!QP7!

QTTP7!464$04Y0"(4#!FAAJhiiRRR$IADbEH$DGIiHAI!

GD=AiEG_@HH@#=Hi?DHDE?LFi,0)UU&6DJ#?A%Q$!JGB!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!QQ&Q'!

7042F(4&,(GA$#"!VQTT'W!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!Q]!

N@=!cF#I!g!CE?K!0E=SHA#=7!@#'4,,0$&8(<;%(

@%2$40(G%'0,*R(<A"(U=+"'$"&2"(%1(I$"#&49"*"( )"1/8""(.A$0,'"&($&(#A"(E&$#",(@#4#"*7!9?`E=!

O@8D?H@A^!5D?@DH!"#$!%%%!VQTTTW7!464$04Y0"(4#(

FAAJhiiRRR$D?@L$DG$Y#8i\O45i-O('P%UT$JGB!$$$!QP!

!

#,($"$+(&'%&()$&*-#.#&.2"#*$ D &

+FD! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=! 2DYEK! ODBD=HD! E=G!-GILEA@#=! 4I=G! Vd//2O-4eW7! %U! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=!E=G! \EL@B@L! *HKE=GD?! DGILEA@#=! E=G! ^#IAF&HD?8@=Y!

#?YE=@fEA@#=H7! E=G! )Q! F@YFD?! DGILEA@#=! BELIKA^! E=G!

#BB@L@EKH! VK@HADG! @=! BIKK! @=! AFD! /JJD=G@bW! HI`_@A! AF@H!

`?@DB! EH! E_@L@! LI?@ED! @=! HIJJ#?A! #B! 6DHJ#=GD=AH! @=!AF@H! LEHD$! ! /_@L@! L#_J?@HD! E! `?#EG! ?E=YD! #B!

#?YE=@fEA@#=H! E=G! @=G@8@GIEKH! R#?S@=Y! #=! @HHIDH!EBBDLA@=Y! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! E=G! \EL@B@L! *HKE=GD?H! @=!S@=GD?YE?AD=! AF?#IYF! %QAF! Y?EGD! E=G! F@YFD?!DGILEA@#=$!

//2O-47! FDEGqIE?AD?DG! @=! "DR! ;#?S! C@A^! E=G!B#I=GDG! @=! %P](7! @H! E! =EA@#=EK! #?YE=@fEA@#=! AFEA!J?#ADLAH! E=G! J?#_#ADH! AFD! L@8@K! ?@YFAH! #B! /H@E=!/_D?@LE=H$!! 0^! L#_`@=@=Y! K@A@YEA@#=7! EG8#LEL^7!DGILEA@#=7! E=G! #?YE=@f@=Y7! //2O-4aH! -GILEA@#=EK!-qI@A^! \?#Y?E_! J?#_#ADH! AFD! ?@YFAH! #B! /H@E=!/_D?@LE=!E=G!\EL@B@L!*HKE=GD?!HAIGD=AH!@=!M&%Q!E=G!F@YFD?! DGILEA@#=$!! //2O-4! FEH! E=! @=AD?DHA! @=! AF@H!K@A@YEA@#=! `DLEIHD! @AH! R#?S! R@AF! L# I=@A^&`EHDG!

^#IAF! EG8#LEADH! EL?#HH! AFD! L#I=A?^! ?D8DEKH! AFEA!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

% ! *=! ELL#?GE=LD! R@AF! 5IJ?D_D! C#I?A! 6IKD! ']$'VEW7! EKK! JE?A@DH! FE8D!L#=HD=ADG!A#!AFD!B@K@=Y!#B!E_@LIH!`?@DBH7!E=G!L#J@DH!#B!AFD! KDAAD?H! #B! YD=D?EK! L#=HD=A! FE8D! `DD=! B@KDG! R@AF! AFD! CKD?S$!!

\I?HIE=A!A#!5IJ?D_D!C#I?A!6IKD!']$X7!L#I=HDK!B#?!E_@L@!HAEAD! AFEA!AF@H!`?@DB!REH!=#A!EIAF#?DG7!@=!RF#KD!#?!@=!JE?A7!`^!L#I=HDK! A#!E!JE?A^7!E=G!=#!_#=DAE?^!L#=A?@`IA@#=!A#!AFD!J?DJE?EA@#=!#?! HI`_@HH@#=!#B!AF@H!`?@DB!REH!_EGD!`^!E=^!JD?H#=!#?!D=A@A^!#AFD?! AFE=!E_@L@!#?!AFD@?!L#I=HDK$!

/H@E=! /_D?@LE=! E=G! \EL@B@L! *HKE=GD?! HAIGD=AH!

`D=DB@A! B?#_! @=G@8@GIEK@fDG! ?ELD&L#=HL@#IH!EG_@HH@#=H! J#K@L@DH! EH! RDKK! EH! B?#_! G@8D?HD!DGILEA@#=EK!HDAA@=YH$!

+R#! E_@L@! E?D! #?YE=@fEA@#=H! R@AF! AFD! DbJ?DHH!JI?J#HD! #B! HIJJ#?A@=Y! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=! E=G! \EL@B@L!

*HKE=GD?! HAEBB! E=G! HAIGD=AH! EA! AFD! 9=@8D?H@A^! #B!+DbEH!EA!/IHA@=!Vd9+eW$!!+FD!/H@E=i/H@E=!/_D?@LE=!4ELIKA^! E=G! 5AEBB! /HH#L@EA@#=! E@_H! A#! I=@AD! /H@E=!E=G! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=! BELIKA^! E=G! HAEBB! EA! 9+! E=G!J?#_#ADH! =DAR#?S@=Y! E=G! HIJJ#?A! B#?! DqIEK!

#JJ#?AI=@A^7! Y?#RAF7! E=G! _IAIEK! `D=DB@A! E_#=Y! @AH!L#=HA@AID=AH$! ! +FD! /H@E=! ODH@! \EL@B@L! *HKE=GD?!/_D?@LE=! C#KKDLA@8D! @H! E! HAIGD=A! #?YE=@fEA@#=!GDG@LEADG!A#!D_J#RD?@=Y!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=!E=G!\EL@B@L!

\EL@B@L! *HKE=GD?! F@YFD?! DGILEA@#=! J?#BDHH@#=EKH! R@AF!B@?HAFE=G! S=#RKDGYD! #B! AFD! `D=DB@AH! #B! G@8D?H@A^! EA!AFD@?!JKELDH!#B!D_JK#^_D=A$!

3AFD?! E_@L@! E?D! =#=J?#B@A! #?YE=@fEA@#=H! AFEA!EG8#LEAD! #=! `DFEKB! #B! #?! J?#8@GD! H#L@EK! HD?8@LDH! A#!/H@E=! /_D?@LE=! E=G! \EL@B@L! *HKE=GD?! F@YF! HLF##K&EYDG!^#IAF!EL?#HH!AFD!9=@ADG!5AEADH$!!NE=^!#B!AFDHD!

^#IAF&HD?8@=Y! #?YE=@fEA@#=H! E?D! _D_`D?H! #B! AFD!

"EA@#=EK! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=! -GILEA@#=! /G8#LEADH!

"DAR#?S7! E! M&%Q! DGILEA@#=! EG8#LEL^! L#=H#?A@I_$!!

+FDHD! E_@L@! FE8D! E! I=@qID! I=GD?HAE=G@=Y! #B! AFD!

=DDGH! E=G! DbJD?@D=LDH! #B! I=GD?HD?8DG! /H@E=!/_D?@LE=! E=G! \EL@B@L! *HKE=GD?! ^#IAF! RF#! E?D!J?DJE?@=Y!B#?!L#KKDYD$!!

4@=EKK^7! _E=^! I=GD?H@Y=DG! E_@L@! E?D! @=G@8@GIEK!BELIKA^! _D_`D?H! E=G! #BB@L@EKH! EA! @=HA@AIA@#=H! #B!F@YFD?!DGILEA@#=$!!+D=!E?D!D_JK#^DG!EA!9+!@AHDKB$!!/!

=I_`D?! #B! AFDHD! E_@L@! E?D! DGILEA@#=7! KDYEK7! E=G!H#L@EK! HL@D=LD! HLF#KE?H! RF#HD! R#?S! DbE_@=DH! AFD!G@8D?HD! DGILEA@#=EK! DbJD?@D=LDH! #B! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=!E=G! \EL@B@L! *HKE=GD?! L# I=@A@DH$! ! NE=^! FE8D!AEIYFA!@=!F@YFD?!DGILEA@#=!E=G!J?#GILDG!HLF#KE?HF@J!E`#IA! AFD! @_JELA! #B! DGILEA@#=EK! EG_@HH@#=H! J#K@L@DH!

#=!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=!E=G!\EL@B@L!*HKE=GD?!HAIGD=AH$!0EHDG! #=! AFDHD! L#KKDLA@8D! DbJD?@D=LDH7! E_@L@! E?D!RDKK! qIEK@B@DG! A#! E=HRD?! E! SD^! qIDHA@#=! `DB#?D! AFD!C#I?Ah! ! F#R! =E??#RK^&AE@K#?DG7! @=G@8@GIEK@fDG7! ?ELD&L#=HL@#IH! EG_@HH@#=H! J#K@L@DH! @_JELA! /H@E=!/_D?@LE=! E=G! \EL@B@L! *HKE=GD?! HAIGD=AH! @=! F@YFD?!DGILEA@#=$!

+2 *"5&'%&()$&*"02-$,(&

+FD! EG_@HH@#=! #B! HAIGD=AH! R@AF! E! d`?#EGrs! E??E^!

#B! qIEK@B@LEA@#=H! E=G! LFE?ELAD?@HA@LHe! EG8E=LDH! AFD!L#_JDKK@=Y! @=AD?DHA! #B! L#KKDYDH! E=G! I=@8D?H@A@DH! @=!EAAE@=@=Y!E!G@8D?HD!HAIGD=A!`#G^!E=G!AFD!DGILEA@#=EK!

`D=DB@AH! AFEA! B#KK#R$! ! 3'/##"'( 6-( 7%00$&8"'7! )'P! 9$5$! 'TX7!'Q)!VQTT'W!VqI#A@=Y!)"8"&#*(%1(#A"(E&$6-(%1(.40-(

6-(74FF"7!('U!9$5$!QX)7!'%)!V%P]UW!V#J@=@#=!#B!\#RDKK7!

[$WW$! ! 0^! L#=H@GD?@=Y! AFD! ELF@D8D_D=AH! #B!I=GD?Y?EGIEAD! EJJK@LE=AH! @=! AFD! L#=ADbA! #B! AFD!EAA?@`IADH! E=G! #`HAELKDH! AFEA! FE8D! @=BKID=LDG! AFD_7!

@=HA@AIA@#=H! K@SD! 9+! =#A! #=K^! D=?@LF! ELEGD_@L!G@HL#I?HD!E=G!LKEHH?##_!KDE?=@=Y7!`IA!EKH#!#JD=!=DR!JEAFRE^H!B#?!HILLDHH$!

6EL@EK!E=G!DAF=@L!#?@Y@=!@H!`IA!d#=D!_#GDHA!BELA#?!E_#=Y! _E=^! #AFD?He! L#=H@GD?DG! @=! AFD! KE?YD?!ELF@D8D_D=A! _EA?@b! AFEA! 9+! IHDH! @=! @AH!

@=G@8@GIEK@fDG! ?D8@DR! #B! EJJK@LE=AH! RF#! E?D! =#A!D=A@AKDG! A#! EIA#_EA@L! EG_@HH@#=! I=GD?! +DbEHaH! +#J!

+D=!\D?LD=A!2ER!Vd+#J!%Tm!2EReW$!!@""(3'/##"'7!)'P!

9$5$!EA!'P'!VMD==DG^7![$7!G@HHD=A@=YW$!!*A!J?#8@GDH!E=!

@_J#?AE=A! ADbAI?D! A#! E=! EJJK@LE=AaH! J?#B@KD! R@AF#IA!J?DG#_@=EA@=Y! #8D?! #AFD?! GDB@=@=Y! qIEK@A@DH! E=G!BELA#?H$! ! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! E=G! \EL@B@L! *HKE=GD?HtE!I=@qID! L?#HH&HDLA@#=! #B! @GD=A@A@DH! E=G! DbJD?@D=LDH!AFEA! HJE=H! E! ?E=YD! #B! L#_JE?EA@8D! J?@8@KDYD! E=G!G@HEG8E=AEYDt`D=DB@A! B?#_! AF@H! @=G@8@GIEK@fDG!EJJ?#ELF! A#! EG_@HH@#=H7! EH! G#! /B?@LE=H! /_D?@LE=H7!2EA@=#H7!E=G!>F@ADH$!

\DA@A@#=D?!E=G!H#_D!#B!AFD!E_@L@!RF#!HIJJ#?A!FD?!J#H@A@#=! D??#=D#IHK^! EHHD?A! AFEA! /B?@LE=! /_D?@LE=H!E=G! 2EA@=#H! E?D! AFD! #=K^! `D=DB@L@E?@DH! #B! 9+aH!EG_@HH@#=H! J#K@L^$! ! ! 4?#_! AF@H! BEIKA^! J?D_@HD7! AFD^!

@=L#??DLAK^! L#=AD=G! AFEA! 9+! FEH! DbJE=GDG!EG_@HH@#=H!#JJ#?AI=@A@DH!B#?!/B?@LE=!/_D?@LE=H!E=G!2EA@=#H! EA! AFD! DbJD=HD! #B! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! E=G!

>F@ADH$!

*=!?DEK@A^7!E!=E??#RK^!AE@K#?DG7!3'/##"'&L#_JK@E=A!

EG_@HH@#=H! J?#Y?E_! K@SD! 9+aH! HA?#=YK^! `D=DB@AH! AFD!/H@E=! /_D?@LE=! E=G! \EL@B@L! *HKE=GD?! L# I=@A^$!!9+aH! @=G@8@GIEK@fDG! ?D8@DR! EKK#RH! B#?! AFD!L#=H@GD?EA@#=! #B! DGILEA@#=EK! @=DqI@A@DH! BELDG! `^!

HAIGD=AH!B?#_!LD?AE@=!HI`Y?#IJH!AFEA!E?D!B?DqID=AK^!F@GGD=! `^! AFD! EYY?DYEA@#=! #B! GEAE! @=A#! E! H@=YKD!d/H@E=e! LEADY#?^$! ! 5AIGD=AH! `DK#=Y@=Y! A#! AFDHD!HI`Y?#IJH! @=! +DbEH! E=G! DKHDRFD?D! FE8D! BELDG!JD?8EH@8D!H#L@EK!E=G!DL#=#_@L!G@HEG8E=AEYDH!ES@=!A#!AFEA! DbJD?@D=LDG! `^! _E=^! /B?@LE=! /_D?@LE=H! E=G!2EA@=#H7! DGILEA@#=EK! EAAE@=_D=A! KD8DKH! AFEA! E?D!E_#=Y!AFD!K#RDHA!#B!EKK!DAF=@L!E=G!?EL@EK!Y?#IJH7!E=G!D8D=! ?EL@EK! @=A@_@GEA@#=! E=G! FE?EHH_D=A$! ! NE=^! #B!AFD@?!JE?D=AH!V@B!=#A!AFD!HAIGD=AH!AFD_HDK8DHW!_EGD!E!G@BB@LIKA!A?E=H@A@#=!A#!AFD!9=@ADG!5AEADH!EH!?DBIYDDH7!E=G! #AFD?H! L#_D! B?#_! L# I=@A@DH! AFEA! FE8D! `DD=!HI`nDLADG! A#! L#K#=@fEA@#=! #=! AFD@?! #R=! =EA@8D! KE=G$!!0^! L#=H@GD?@=Y! AFD! ?#KD! AFEA! AFDHD! HAIGD=AHa! ?EL@EK!E=G!DAF=@L!#?@Y@=!FE8D!FEG!#=!AFD@?!DbJD?@D=LDH!E=G!ELF@D8D_D=AH7! 9+aH! EG_@HH@#=H! J?#LDHH! D=L#I?EYDH!

?EL@EK! G@HEYY?DYEA@#=! E=G! @=G@8@GIEK@fDG! A?DEA_D=A!E=G!AFRE?AH!AFD!FE?_BIK!d_#GDK!_@=#?@A^e!_^AF!AFEA!_EHSH! A?D_D=G#IH! G@8D?H@A^! R@AF@=! AFD! /H@E=!/_D?@LE=!E=G!\EL@B@L!*HKE=GD?!L# I=@A^$!

5D8D?EK! SD^! E?YI_D=AH! J?DHD=ADG! `^! \DA@A@#=D?!E=G! FD?! E_@L@! ?DK^! #=! BELAIEK! G@HA#?A@#=H! E=G! AFD!

@_J?#JD?! A?DEA_D=A! #B! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! EH! E!_#=#K@AF@L! Y?#IJ$! ! 4@?HA7! AFD^! EHHD?A! AFEA! 9+! FEH!GDD_DG!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=H!A#!`D!d#8D??DJ?DHD=ADGe!#=!

@AH! LE_JIH$! ! +FEA! LKE@_! @H! L#_JKDADK^! I=A?ID$!!5DL#=G7!AFD^!EHHD?A!AFEA!9+!FEH!K@_@ADG!EG_@HH@#=!#B!/H@E=! /_D?@LE=! HAIGD=AH! @=! #?GD?! A#! _EALF! AFD!

?EL@EK!GD_#Y?EJF@LH!#B!+DbEH$!!5@=LD!9+!EG#JADG!@AH!

?ELD&L#=HL@#IH! J#K@L^7! F#RD8D?7! AFD! JD?LD=AEYD! #B!/H@E=! /_D?@LE=! HAIGD=AH! D=?#KKDG! EA! 9+! FEH!

?ELD! #B! EJJK@LE=AH! #=! E=! @=G@8@GIEK@fDG! `EH@H! E=G!D=?#KK! HAIGD=AH! B?#_! G@8D?HD! `ELSY?#I=GH$! ! +F@H! @H!D=A@?DK^! G@HA@=LA! B?#_! =DYEA@8D! ELA@#=7! RFD?D`^! E!I=@8D?H@A^! G@HL?@_@=EADH! EYE@=HA! E! ?EL@EK! Y?#IJ! @=!

#?GD?! A#! HIJJ?DHH! AFD@?! KD8DKH! #B! D=?#KK_D=A$! ! +FD!I=GD?H@Y=DG!E_@L@!R#IKG!8@Y#?#IHK^!#JJ#HD!E=^!B#?_!

#B! =DYEA@8D! ELA@#=7! B#?_EK! #?! @=B#?_EK7! EBBDLA@=Y!/H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! #?! E=^! #AFD?! Y?#IJt`IA! AFD?D! @H!H@_JK^! =#! D8@GD=LD! #B! @A! EA! 9+$! ! \DA@A@#=D?aH! E_@L@!EKH#! EAAD_JA! A#! J?#8D! G@HL?@_@=EA@#=! `EHDG! #=!G@BBD?D=A@EK!HAE=GE?G@fDG!ADHA!HL#?DH7!`IA!AFD^!@Y=#?D!AFD! HA?#=Y! L#=HD=HIH! #B! H#L@EK! HL@D=A@HAH! AFEA! HILF!G@BBD?D=LDH!?DBKDLA!G@HJE?@A@DH!EK?DEG^!J?DHD=A!@=!AFD!EJJK@LE=A! J##K! E=G7! @=GDDG7! FE8D! Db@HADG! B#?! _E=^!

^DE?H! @=! 9+aH! +#J! %Tm! JKE=! E=G! #AFD?! ?ELD&=DIA?EK!EG_@HH@#=!J?#Y?E_H$!

*=! AFD! D=G7! GDHJ@AD! LKE@_H! `^! \DA@A@#=D?! E=G! FD?!E_@L@! AFEA! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! E=G! \EL@B@L! *HKE=GD?H!E?D! J#@HDG! A#! ?DLKE@_! #JJ#?AI=@A@DH! K#HA! A#! G@8D?H@A^!

@=@A@EA@8DH! HF#IKG! AF@H! C#I?A! ?IKD! EYE@=HA! 9+aH!EG_@HH@#=H! J?#Y?E_7! AFD! #8D?RFDK_@=Y! D8@GD=LD!

@=G@LEADH! AFD! #JJ#H@AD$! ! NE=^! /H@E=! EJJK@LE=AH! @=!L# I=@A@DH! HA?IYYK@=Y! R@AF! K#R! DGILEA@#=EK!EAAE@=_D=A! R@KK! HIBBD?! @B! EG_@HH@#=H! J?#Y?E_H! HILF!EH!9+aH!E?D!G@H_E=AKDG$!

-qIEKK^! @_J#?AE=A7! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! E=G! \EL@B@L!

*HKE=GD?HtEK#=Y! R@AF! HAIGD=AH! #B! #AFD?! ?ELDHtR@KK!

=#A! DbJD?@D=LD! AFD! S@=G! #B! G@8D?H@A^! AFEA! D=?@LFDH!AFD@?!DGILEA@#=!E=G!J?DJE?DH!AFD_!B#?!LE?DD?H!@=!E=!

@=L?DEH@=YK^! @=AD?LIKAI?EK! E=G! YK#`EK! R#?SJKELD$!!

\DA@A@#=D?aH! LFEKKD=YD! D=GE=YD?H! dr`s?#EG! ELLDHH! A#!AFD!DGILEA@#=!AFEA!KDEGH!A#!KDEGD?HF@J!?#KDH!rE=G!AFEA!

@Hs!DHHD=A@EK!A#!JI`K@L!L#=B@GD=LD!@=!AFD!BE@?=DHH!E=G!

@=ADY?@A^! #B! JI`K@L! @=HA@AIA@#=H$e! ! C#=H#K@GEADG! 0?@DB!

#B! 2A$! 1D=$! [IK@IH! >$! 0DLA#=7! [?$! DA! EK$! EH! L9$2$(

./'$4"! @=! 5IJJ#?A! #B! 6DHJ#=GD=AH! EA! P7! 3'/##"'( 6-( 7%00$&8"'7!)'P!9$5$!'TX7!'Q)!VQTT'W!V"#$!TQ&Q(%W$!

4#?!AFDHD!?DEH#=H!E=G!AF#HD!GDHL?@`DG!`DK#R7!AF@H!C#I?A!HF#IKG!IJF#KG!9+aH!EG_@HH@#=H!J#K@L^!E=G!AFD!

+FD! ?DL#?G! `DK#R! DHAE`K@HFDH! AFEA! @=! @AH! DBB#?A! A#!

#`AE@=! AFD! DGILEA@#=EK! `D=DB@AH! AFEA! ?DHIKA! B?#_!HAIGD=A!G@8D?H@A^7!9+!IHDH!?ELD!R@AF@=!AFD!L#=ADbA!#B!dE! F@YFK^! @=G@8@GIEK@fDG7! F#K@HA@L! ?D8@DRe! AFEA! Y@8DH!dHD?@#IH! L#=H@GD?EA@#=! A#! EKK! AFD! RE^H! E=! EJJK@LE=A!_@YFA! L#=A?@`IAD! A#! E! G@8D?HD! DGILEA@#=EK!

D=8@?#=_D=A$e! ! @""( 3'/##"'7! )'P! 9$5$! EA! '']$! ! /H!

\DA@A@#=D?! FEH! EG_@AADG7! 9+! FEH! =#A! DHAE`K@HFDG! E!dY#EK7!AE?YDA7!#?!#AFD?!qIE=A@AEA@8D!#`nDLA@8De!B#?!AFD!

EG_@HH@#=! #B! E=^! JE?A@LIKE?! Y?#IJ$! ! @""( [/! %'%E$!!

*=HADEG7! @A! EKK#RH! EJJK@LE=AH! #B! EKK! ?ELDH7! @=LKIG@=Y!/H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! E=G! \EL@B@L! *HKE=GD?H7! A#! `D=DB@A!B?#_!AFD!L#=H@GD?EA@#=!#B!AFD@?!?ELD!@=!AFD!G@HA@=LA@8D!L#=ADbA! #B! AFD@?! `ELSY?#I=G! E=G! DbJD?@D=LD$! ! /H!G@HLIHHDG! `DK#R7! AFD! E?YI_D=AH! `^! \DA@A@#=D?! E=G!FD?! E_@L@! AFEA! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! E?D! H#_DF#R!8@LA@_@fDG!`^!AF@H!J#K@L^!#B!@=G@8@GIEK@fDG!?D8@DR!E?D!D=A@?DK^!I=B#I=GDG!@=!KER!E=G!BELA$Q!

*E&& 2(&1B=<&,B>&(A=;>&*<C;G&*H=ACI;G<&;<& 'J=AA=KA=<=G>=LE&

\DA@A@#=D?! E=G! FD?! HIJJ#?A@=Y! E_@L@! ?DJDEADGK^!LKE@_! AFEA! 9+! FEH! GDD_DG! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! A#! `D!

d#8D??DJ?DHD=ADGe!@=!@AH!HAIGD=A!J#JIKEA@#=$!!@""!\DA$! 0?$! EA! ! ]7! %P7! QU! =$! ]g( *""( 40*%( 0?@DB! B#?! AFD! /H@E=!

/_D?@LE=! 2DYEK! 4#I=GEA@#=! E=G! AFD! [IG@L@EK!

-GILEA@#=! \?#nDLA! EH! /_@L@! CI?@ED( @=! 5IJJ#?A! #B!

\DA@A@#=D?H!Vd//24!0?$eW!EA!Q7!P7!%Q&%'!=$]7!QQ$!!4?#_!AF@H! J?D_@HD! EK#=D7! 4@HFD?! L#=LKIGDH! AFEA! 9+!dD_JK#^H! ?ELD! @=! EG_@HH@#=H! GDL@H@#=H! A#! AFD!GDA?@_D=A!#B!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=H$e!!\DA$!0?$!EA!]$!!/_@L@!//24!H@_@KE?K^!EHHD?AH!AFEA!drAsFD!8D?^!BELA!AFEA!9+!LI??D=AK^! GDD_H! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! #8D??DJ?DHD=ADG!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Q ! \DA@A@#=D?! E=G! FD?! E_@L@! G#! =#A! EKKDYD! JE?A@LIKE?! FE?_! A#!

\EL@B@L!*HKE=GD?H!?DHIKA@=Y!B?#_!9+aH!@=G@8@GIEK@fDG!EG_@HH@#=H! J?#LDHH$!

$!$!$!HF#RH!AFEA!AFD!IHD!#B!?ELD!@=!EG_@HH@#=H!R@KK!E@_!A#! ?DGILD! AFD! ?DJ?DHD=AEA@#=! #B! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H!RF@KD!@=L?DEH@=Y!AFD!?DJ?DHD=AEA@#=!#B!,@HJE=@LH!E=G!/B?@LE=!/_D?@LE=H$e!!//24!0?$!EA!Q$!

G#LI_D=A! @H! AFD! R#?G! d#8D??DJ?DHD=ADGe! IHDG$!!

*=HADEG7! 9+! GDHL?@`DG! /B?@LE=! /_D?@LE=! E=G!,@HJE=@L! HAIGD=AH! EH! I=GD??DJ?DHD=ADG! `EHDG! #=!AFD@?! #8D?EKK! D=?#KK_D=A! E=G! LKEHH?##_! J?DHD=LD! EA!AFD!I=@8D?H@A^$!!9+!G@G!=#A!B@=G7!E=G!AFD?D!@H!=#!`EH@H!B#?! L#=LKIG@=Y7! AFEA! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! #?! E=^! #AFD?!Y?#IJ!FEH!`DD=!GDD_DG!#8D??DJ?DHD=ADG$!

\DA@A@#=D?! EKH#! ?DBD?H! A#! AFD! O@HA?@LA! C#I?A!

#J@=@#=!@=!AF@H!LEHD$!!@""!\DA$!0?$!EA!%P!VL@A@=Y!/JJ$!

%)(EW$! ! +FD?D7! @=! B@=G@=Y! AFEA! I=GD?! 3'/##"'7! 9+!

L#IKG!L#=H@GD?!+DbEH!J#JIKEA@#=!GEAE!@=!GDAD?_@=@=Y!dRF@LF!_@=#?@A^!Y?#IJH!qIEK@B^!EH!I=GD??DJ?DHD=ADG!E=G!RF@LF!#=DH!G#!=#A7e![IGYD!5JE?SH!#`HD?8DG!AFEA!dL#_JE?DG! A#! AFD@?! JD?LD=AEYD! #B! +DbEHa! J#JIKEA@#=!EH! E! RF#KD7! ,@HJE=@LH! ?D_E@=! I=GD??DJ?DHD=ADGe!

RF@KD!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=H!dE?D!KE?YDK^!%6"'!?DJ?DHD=ADG!

L#_JE?DG! A#! AFD@?! JD?LD=AEYD! #B! +DbEHa! J#JIKEA@#=$e!!

@""! /JJ$! %)(E&%))E! VD_JFEH@H! @=! #?@Y@=EKW$! ! +FD!

L#I?AaH! D_J@?@LEK! #`HD?8EA@#=! E`#IA! AFD! G@BBD?D=LDH!

`DARDD=! AFD! 9+! HAIGD=A! J#JIKEA@#=! E=G! +DbEH!GD_#Y?EJF@LH! G#DH! =#A! HIJJ#?A! \DA@A@#=D?aH! LKE@_!E`#IA! 9+aH! EG_@HH@#=! J#K@L@DH$! ! +#! AFD! L#=A?E?^7! EH!AFD! O@HA?@LA! C#I?A! #`HD?8DG7! AFD! BELA! AFEA! AFD!JD?LD=AEYD!#B!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=!HAIGD=AH!EA!9+!@H!B@8D!A@_DH!KE?YD?!AFE=!AFD!JD?LD=AEYD!#B!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=H!

@=! +DbEH! @H! L#_JDKK@=Y! D8@GD=LD! AFEA! =#! LD@K@=Y! FEH!

`DD=!@_J#HDG$!!@""!/JJ$!%)XE7!=$%%$!!*=!#AFD?!R#?GH7! EH! G@HLIHHDG! @=! 5DLA@#=! **$07! $&1'47! AFD! GEAE! #=K^!

=DYEAD!\DA@A@#=D?aH!LKE@_!AFEA!9+!FEH!K@_@ADG!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=!EG_@HH@#=H!A#!_@??#?!+DbEH!GD_#Y?EJF^$!

4#?!AF@H!?DEH#=7!EG_@HH@#=!J#K@L@DH!EA!9+!LE==#A!

?DEH#=E`K^!`D!L#_JE?DG!A#!AFD!E`F#??D=A!qI#AEH!E=G!

?DHA?@LA@8D! J#K@LDH! @_J#HDG! EYE@=HA! [DRH! AF?#IYF#IA!

AFD! JEHA! LD=AI?^$! ! @""! //24! 0?$! EA! %U&%Pv! 0?@DB! /_@LIH! CI?@ED( #B! AFD! 2#I@H! O$! 0?E=GD@H! CD=AD?! B#?!

,I_E=! 6@YFAH! 9=GD?! 2ER7! +FD! UT&QT! "EA@#=EK!/H@E=&/_D?@LE=! -GILEA@#=EK! 4#I=GEA@#=7! DA! EK$7! @=!5IJJ#?A!#B!\DA@A@#=D?!VdUT&QT!0?$eW!EA!QT&'($!!>@AF#IA!qIDHA@#=7! AFD?D! @H! E! G@HAI?`@=Y! F@HA#?^! #B!G@HL?@_@=EA#?^! EG_@HH@#=! J#K@L@DH7! JE?A@LIKE?K^! EA!DK@AD! J?@8EAD! I=@8D?H@A@DH7! EBBDLA@=Y! [DRH7! /B?@LE=!/_D?@LE=H7! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H7! R#_D=7! E=G! #AFD?H$!!

@""! [D?#_D! ME?E`DK7! <A"( A%*"&R( <A"( :$,,"&( :$*#%'?( %1( L,9$**$%&( 4&,( U=20/*$%&( 4#( :4'64',P( Z40"P( 4&,( !'$&2"#%&! VQTT)W$! ! "#?! G#! E_@L@! GD=^! AFD!

J#HH@`@K@A^! AFEA! H#_D! @=HA@AIA@#=H! _E^! EJJK^!DbLKIH@#=E?^! J#K@L@DH! EYE@=HA! _@=#?@A^! EJJK@LE=AH7!

@=LKIG@=Y! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H7! A#GE^$! ! /H! G@HLIHHDG!

`DK#R7!E_@L@!R#IKG!8@Y#?#IHK^!#JJ#HD!E=^!LEJ7!qI#AE7!

#?!#AFD?!S@=G!#B!=DYEA@8D!ELA@#=7!B#?_EK!#?!@=B#?_EK7!

EYE@=HA! E=^! ?EL@EK! Y?#IJ$! ! "D8D?AFDKDHH7! AFD?D! @H! =#!D8@GD=LD! AFEA! 9+! FEH! HIJJ?DHHDG! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=!EG_@HH@#=H!@=!E=^!_E==D?$!!*=GDDG7!EKK!D8@GD=LD!@H!A#!AFD!L#=A?E?^$!

\DA$! 0?$! EA! %Pg( *""( 40*%( $,-( EA! QU! V?DBD??@=Y! A#! d9+aH!

G@BBD?@=Y! A?DEA_D=A! #B! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! E=G! #AFD?!_@=#?@A@DH! `EHDG! #=! DELF! Y?#IJaH! J?#J#?A@#=! #B!+DbEHaH! J#JIKEA@#=eWv! //24! 0?$! EA! Q! VEHHD?A@=Y! AFEA!d9+! LI??D=AK^! GDD_H! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H!

#8D??DJ?DHD=ADG! E=G! HDDSH! A#! ?DGILD! GD_#Y?EJF@L!G@BBD?D=LDH! `DARDD=! @AH! HAIGD=A! J#JIKEA@#=! E=G! AFD!5AEAD!EH!RF#KDeW$!!+F@H!LKE@_!@H!EKH#!`EHDKDHH$!

/! H@_JKD! L#_JE?@H#=! #B! AFD! =I_`D?H! #B! /H@E=!/_D?@LE=H! AFEA! 9+! EG_@AADG! E=G! D=?#KKDG! E=G! AFD!JD?LD=AEYD!#B!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=H!@=!+DbEH!HF#RH!AFEA!9+! FEH! =#A! A?@DG! A#! _EALF! AFD! AR#$! ! +FD! /H@E=!/_D?@LE=!J#JIKEA@#=!@=!+DbEH!FEH!?EJ@GK^!DbJE=GDG!

#8D?! AFD! KEHA! 'T! ^DE?H7! ?DELF@=Y! '$Um! #B! AFD! HAEAD!J#JIKEA@#=! @=! QT%T$'! ! "D8D?AFDKDHH7! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

' !*=!%PUT7!%QT7TTT!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=H!K@8DG!@=!+DbEH7!_ES@=Y!IJ!

#=K^!T$Um!#B!AFD!#8D?EKK!HAEAD!J#JIKEA@#=$!!@""(CE_J`DKK!1@`H#=! g!ME^![I=Y7!9$5$!CD=HIH!0I?DEI7!:$*#%'$240(."&*/*(@#4#$*#$2*(

%&( !%+/04#$%&( <%#40*( Y?( )42"P( D^_\( #%( D \P( 4&,( Y?( :$*+4&$2( S'$8$&P( D_^\( #%( D \( 1%'( #A"( E&$#",( @#4#"*P( )"8$%&*P( B$6$*$%&*(

!

D=?#KK_D=A! EA! 9+! FEH! @=L?DEHDG! EA! E=! D8D=! BEHAD?!

?EAD$! ! 4?#_! %PUX! A#! QTT%7! D=?#KK_D=A! #B! /H@E=!

/_D?@LE=H!EA!9+!@=L?DEHDG!B?#_!Xm!A#!%Pm$!!@""(9+! /IHA@=7! D cVD b( @#4#$*#$240( :4&,Y%%Ff@#/,"&#*!

Q%Q& 9+! /IHA@=7! [\\DV[\\[( @#4#$*#$240( :4&,Y%%Ff

@#/,"&#*! EA! Q)$(! ! 4?#_! %PPP! A#! QT%T7! D=?#KK_D=A! #B!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=H!B?#_!+DbEH!?D_E@=DG!@=!AFD!?E=YD!

#B! %]m! A#! QTm$! ! @""( 5[/! %)]Ev! 9+! /IHA@=7!

>9+0"9"&#4#$%&( 4&,( )"*/0#*( %1( #A"( <"=4*( L/#%94#$2( L,9$**$%&*( H4;7! ODL$! Q'7! QT%T! VdQT%T! +#J! %Tm!

6DJ#?AeW! EA! U$! ! +FD! KEAAD?! JD?@#G! D=L#_JEHHDH! `#AF!H@b! ^DE?H! #B! ?ELD&=DIA?EK! EG_@HH@#=H! VB#KK#R@=Y!

:%+;%%,(6-(<"=4*7!]U!4$'G!P'Q!V)AF!C@?$!%PPXWW!E=G!

H@b! ^DE?H! #B! ?ELD&L#=HL@#IH! EG_@HH@#=H! VB#KK#R@=Y!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

4&,(@#4#"*7!A`K$)U!VQTTQW$!!0^!%PPT7!AFEA!=I_`D?!FEG!Y?#R=!A#! '%P7TTT7! #?! %$Pm! #B! AFD! HAEAD! J#JIKEA@#=7! $,-7! E=G! `^! QTTT! @A!

?DELFDG! )XQ7TTT! #?! Q$Um! #B! AFD! #8D?EKK! HAEAD! J#JIKEA@#=7! *""( 9$5$! CD=HIH! 0I?DEI7! <"=4*( !'%1$0"( %1( 3"&"'40( B"9%8'4+A$2( A4'42#"'$*#$2*R([\\\$!!4?#_!QTTT!A#!QT%T7!AFD!/H@E=!/_D?@LE=!

J#JIKEA@#=! @=! +DbEH! DbJE=GDG! A#! PX)7TTT! #?! '$Um! #B! AFD! HAEAD!

J#JIKEA@#=$!!@""(9$5$!CD=HIH!0I?DEI7!<"=4*(!'%1$0"(%1(3"&"'40( B"9%8'4+A$2( A4'42#"'$*#$2*R( [\D\$! ! +F@H! ]Qm! @=L?DEHD!

#IAJELDG! D8D=! AFD! ,@HJE=@L! #?! 2EA@=#! J#JIKEA@#=7! RF@LF!

5AEA@HA@LEK! ,E=G`##SH! L#=H#K@GEAD! GEAE! #=! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=! EG_@AADDH! B?#_! R@AF@=! E=G! #IAH@GD! +DbEH$! ! 9+aH! +#J! %Tm! 6DJ#?AH!G@HA@=YI@HF!`DARDD=!AFDHD!Y?#IJH$

/LS=#RKDGY@=Y! AFEA! dAFD! A#AEK! =I_`D?! E=G!JD?LD=AEYD! #B! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! FE8D! @=! BELA!

@=L?DEHDG!EA!9+!@=!AFD!KEHA!AD=!^DE?H7e!E_@LIH!//24!RDESK^!J#H@AH!AFEA!9+aH!dDBB#?AH!EA!?EL@EK!`EKE=L@=Ye!FE8D!`DD=!dKDHH!DBBDLA@8D!AFE=!@A!R#IKG!K@SD$e!!//24!0?$!EA!%Q&%'!=$]$!!0IA!AFD?D!@H!=#!`EH@H!@=!AFD!?DL#?G!A#! HIYYDHA! AFEA! 9+! FEH! H#IYFA! AF@H! Y#EK$! ! +#! AFD!L#=A?E?^7!AFD!?DL#?G!HF#RH!AFEA!AFD!L#=H@GD?EA@#=!#B!

?ELD! @=! 9+aH! EG_@HH@#=H! J?#LDHH! LE=! J#H@A@8DK^!

@_JELA! EJJK@LE=AH! #B! E=^! ?ELD7! E=G! AFD! I=@8D?H@A^!_ESDH!=#!DBB#?A!A#!_#=@A#?!AFD!=I_`D?!#B!EJJK@LE=AH!EG_@AADG! @=! E=^! JE?A@LIKE?! Y?#IJ! A#! D=HI?D! AFEA! E!

JE?A@LIKE?! AF?DHF#KG! @H! _DA$! ! @""( [/! QTXE! V*HF#J!

*=! ?DEK@A^7! AFD! GEAE! HF#R! AFEA! B?#_! QTT(! A#! QT%T! E!F@YFD?! JD?LD=AEYD! #B! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=! HAIGD=AH!EG_@AADG! `^! 9+! FE8D! `DD=! EG_@AADG! AF?#IYF!

?D8@DR!#B!DELF!EJJK@LE=AaH!JD?B#?_E=LD!E=G!JD?H#=EK!L@?LI_HAE=LDH$!

.E& (@=A=&#<&,B&$JCL=GI=&BO&,=N;>CJ=&*I>CBG&

*N;CG<>&*<C;G&*H=ACI;G<&;>&2(E&&

DE& ,;AABRMS&>;CMBA=L&;OOCAH;>CJ=&;I>CBG& KABNA;H<&LB&GB>&IBG<>C>?>=&G=N;>CJ=&

dEYE@=HA!/H@E=&/_D?@LE=!EJJK@LE=AH$e!!@""(4@HFD?!0?$! EA! QU7! ))v( *""( 40*%( //24! 0?$! EA! Q7! P7! %Q&%'! =$]7! QQ$!!

/YE@=7!AFDHD!E?YI_D=AH!E?D!D=A@?DK^!I=HIJJ#?ADG!`^!D8@GD=LD! @=! AFD! ?DL#?G! #?! D_J@?@LEK! GEAE$!!

4I?AFD?_#?D7! AFD^! L#=BKEAD! AR#! G@HA@=LA! L#=LDJAHtEBB@?_EA@8D!ELA@#=!E=G!=DYEA@8D!ELA@#=tJ?#GIL@=Y!E!_IGGKDG! E=G! F@YFK^! _@HKDEG@=Y! J@LAI?D! #B!EG_@HH@#=H!EA!9+!E=G!#AFD?!HDKDLA@8D!I=@8D?H@A@DH$!

9=GD?!AF@H!C#I?AaH!F#KG@=YH!@=!3'4#5(6-(7%00$&8"'7! )'P! 9$5$! Q((! VQTT'W7! E=G! 3'/##"'7! I=@8D?H@A@DH! _E^!

JI?HID! DGILEA@#=EK! G@8D?H@A^! V#B! RF@LF! ?EL@EK!G@8D?H@A^!@H!#=D!DKD_D=AW!`^!AES@=Y!@=A#!ELL#I=A!AFD!

?ELD! #B! EJJK@LE=AH! @=! E! =E??#RK^! AE@K#?DG! _E==D?! A#!D=?#KK! HAIGD=AH! B?#_! G@8D?HD! `ELSY?#I=GH$! ! /=!

@=G@8@GIEK@fDG! EBB@?_EA@8D! ELA@#=! J?#Y?E_! @H!L#_JKDADK^! G@HA@=LA! B?#_! =DYEA@8D! ELA@#=7! RF@LF!

@=8#K8DH! G@HL?@_@=EA@#=! `^! E! I=@8D?H@A^! A#! HIJJ?DHH!D=?#KK_D=A! #B! E! JE?A@LIKE?! ?EL@EK! Y?#IJ7! HILF! EH!

/H@E=!/_D?@LE=H$!!@""!>@KK@E_!C$!M@GGD?7!@$#/4#$&8(

L*$4&( !42$1$2( L9"'$24&*( $&( #A"( H4;( @2A%%0( L11$'94#$6"( L2#$%&( B"Y4#"R( U9+$'$240( J42#*( LY%/#(

<A"'&*#'%9K*()A"#%'$240(L2#*7!]!/H@E=!2$[$!QP7!''7!XT!

VQTTTWv! [D??^! ME=Y7! C"84#$6"( L2#$%&( L84$&*#( L*$4&(

L9"'$24&*R( <A"( >&#"'&40( >&*#4Y$0$#?( %1( B;%'F$&K*( B"1"&*"( %1( L11$'94#$6"( L2#$%&7! '%! ,E?8$! C$6$&C$2$! 2$!

6D8$!%7!'&(!V%PPXW$!!+#!EKKDYD!?EL@EK!G@HL?@_@=EA@#=!`^!L#_JE?@=Y! EG_@HH@#=H! B#?! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H!DbLKIH@8DK^!R@AF!#AFD?!_@=#?@A@DHtEH!\DA@A@#=D?!E=G!FD?!E_@L@!G#t@H!A#!BEKK!8@LA@_!A#!E!LEIHEA@#=!BEKKEL^!EHHI_@=Y!dE!B@=@AD!=I_`D?!#B!_@=#?@A@DH!AFEA!LE=!`D!EG_@AADG!rA#!E!I=@8D?H@A^!E=Gs!AFEA!HJ#AH!B#?!LD?AE@=!_@=#?@A@DH! _IHA! L#_D! EA! AFD! DbJD=HD! #B! #AFD?!

_@=#?@A@DH$e! ! @""! /G?@E=! 2@I7! L11$'94#$6"( L2#$%&( `(

C"84#$6"( L2#$%&R( :%;( X$4&( H$K*( 4*"( 4&( 7"&"1$#( L*$4&( L9"'$24&*7! %'! N@LF$! [$! 6ELD! g! 2$! 'P%7! (Q%!

VQTTUW$! ! *=! #AFD?! R#?GH7! @A! EHHI_DH! AFEA! L#KKDYD!

@=HA@AIA@#=H! R@AF! E! ?ELD&L#=HL@#IH! EG_@HH@#=H! J#K@L^!

L#_JK^@=Y! R@AF! 3'4#5! E=G! 3'/##"'! L#_JDAD! @=! E!

H@=YKD! J##K7! ?DYE?GKDHH! #B! ?ELD$! ! -8D=! AF#IYF! ?EL@EK!qI#AEH!FE8D!`DD=!@KKDYEK!H@=LD!AF@H!C#I?AaH!?IK@=Y!@=!

74FF"7!\DA@A@#=D?aH!E_@L@!A?DEA!L#KKDY@EAD!EG_@HH@#=H!

EH! @B! E! qI#AE! B#?! >F@ADH! SDDJH! AFD@?! =I_`D?H!L#=HAE=A!E=G!LEJH!AFD!A#AEK!=I_`D?!#B!_@=#?@A@DH$!!*=!BELA7!_E=^!#B!AFD!HJ#AH!AFD#?DA@LEKK^!_EGD!E8E@KE`KD!

`^!D=G@=Y!EBB@?_EA@8D!ELA@#=!R#IKG!Y#!A#!>F@ADH7!RF#!L#_J?@HD!E!_ILF!KE?YD?!JD?LD=AEYD!#B!AFD!J#JIKEA@#=!

AFE=! /H@E=H$! ! @""P( "-8-7! 0D=! 0ELSDH7! B%( L11$'94#$6"( L2#$%&(74&*(H%;"'(T$&%'$#?(.%00"8"(U&'%009"&#(4&,( L##4$&9"&#N( U6$,"&2"( 1'%9( @#4#";$,"( 74&*7! (]![$!,I_$!6DH#I?LDH!(')7!((U&)T!VQT%QW$!!+F@H!BELA!`?DESH!AFD! LEIHEK! K@=S! AFEA! \DA@A@#=D?aH! E_@L@! ?DJDEADGK^!LKE@_!`DARDD=!?ELD&L#=HL@#IH!EG_@HH@#=H!E=G!EKKDYDG!G@HL?@_@=EA@#=! EYE@=HA! /H@E=H$]! ! +FD?DB#?D7! E=^!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

6 !*A!EKH#!@Y=#?DH!AFD!?DEK@A^!AFEA!H#_D!I=@8D?H@A@DH!V`IA!=#A!9+W! Y@8D!J?DBD?D=LD!@=!EG_@HH@#=!A#!LF@KG?D=!#B!EKI_=@7!E!J#K@L^!AFEA!

G@HJ?#J#?A@#=EADK^! `D=DB@AH! >F@AD! EJJK@LE=AH$! ! @""( L11$'94#$6"( L2#$%&( 1%'( #A"( )$2AR( H"842?( !'"1"'"&2"*( $&( %00"8"( L,9$**$%&!

%Q]!V6@LFE?G!O$!MEFKD=`D?Y!DG$!QT%TW$

] ! \DA@A@#=D?aH! E_@L@! ?DK^! FDE8@K^! #=! ?DHDE?LFD?! +F#_EH! -HJD=HFEGDaH! R#?S! A#! HF#R! F#R! G@BBD?D=LDH! `DARDD=! 5/+! HL#?DH! #B! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! E=G! #AFD?! Y?#IJH! GD_#=HA?EAD! E!

dJD=EKA^e! #=! /H@E=H$! @""! //24! 0?$! EA! P&%Tv! UT&QT! 0?$! EA! )&X$!!

-HJD=HFEGDaH! DHA@_EADH7! F#RD8D?7! JD?AE@=! A#! %PP]! GEAE! B#?!

!

HIJJ?DHH@#=! @=! AFD! EG_@HH@#=! #B! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!AF?DD!DK@AD!J?@8EAD!I=@8D?H@A@DH!E=G!E?D!AFD?DB#?D!@=EJJK@LE`KD!A#! AF@H! LEHD$! ! 4I?AFD?_#?D7! RF@KD! @A! @H! A?ID! AFEA! -HJD=HFEGD! H#IYFA! A#! dqIE=A@B^! AFD! DBBDLAH! #B! ?ELD&L#=HL@#IH! EG_@HH@#=H!

J#K@L@DH7e!*""!//24!0?$!EA!P7!E_@L@!G#!=#A!_ESD!LKDE?!AFEA!d?ELD&

L#=HL@#IH! EG_@HH@#=He! B#?! -HJD=HFEGD! @=LKIGD! =#A! #=K^! EBB@?_EA@8D! ELA@#=! `IA! EKH#! =DYEA@8D! ELA@#=! EYE@=HA! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H$! ! *=! #AFD?! R#?GH7! RFD=! -HJD=HFEGD! HIYYDHAH! AFEA! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! R#IKG! `D=DB@A! B?#_! AFD! DK@_@=EA@#=! #B! ?ELD& L#=HL@#IH!EG_@HH@#=H7!FD!@=LKIGDH!@=!F@H!E=EK^H@H!AFD!?D_#8EK!#B! E!)T&5/+&J#@=A!EG8E=AEYD!AFEA!>F@AD!EJJK@LE=AH!?DLD@8DG!#8D?!

/H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! V$-"-7! =DYEA@8D! ELA@#=W$!! @""( +F#_EH! [$! -HJD=HFEGD! g! CFE=Y! ;$! CFI=Y7! <A"( S++%'#/&$#?( %*#( %1( L,9$**$%&(!'"1"'"&2"*(4#(U0$#"(E&$6"'*$#$"*7!UX!5#L$!5L@$!l$!QP'7!

QPU! VQTT)W! VEHHDHH@=Y! ?D_#8EK! #B! dG@HEG8E=AEYD! @=! EG_@HH@#=e! DbJD?@D=LDG! `^! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=H! EH! RDKK! EH! J?DBD?D=LDH! B#?!

#AFD?! Y?#IJHWv! $,-! EA! 'T%! V?DBD??@=Y! A#! dRFEA! H#_D! _@YFA! AD?_!

wG@HEBB@?_EA@8D! ELA@#=a! B#?! /H@E=HeW$! +FD! HE_D! GEAE! @=! -HJD=HFEGDaH! _#?D! ?DLD=A! `##S! L#=B@?_! AFEA! @=! F@H! _#GDK7! @=! AD?_H! #B! AFD! #8D?EKK! @_JELA! #=! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=! EG_@HH@#=!

#BBD?H7! D=G@=Y! =DYEA@8D! ELA@#=! REH! DHA@_EADG! A#! FE8D!E=! DBBDLA! _#?D! AFE=! B@8D! A@_DH! Y?DEAD?! AFE=! AFD! DBBDLA! #B! D=G@=Y! EBB@?_EA@8D! ELA@#=! B#?! /B?@LE=! /_D?@LE=! E=G! 2EA@=#! HAIGD=AH$!!

@""! +F#_EH! [$! -HJD=HFEGD! g! /KDbE=G?@E! >EKA#=! 6EGB#?G7! C%( H%&8"'(@"+4'4#"P(C%#(Z"#(UW/40R()42"(4&,(.04**($&(U0$#"(.%00"8"( L,9$**$%&(4&,(.49+/*(H$1"!''(!A`K$P$%7!/JJ$!A`K$C$P$%!VQTTPW$!!

3AFD?! ELEGD_@LH! FE8D! LFEKKD=YDG! -HJD=HFEGDaH! R#?S! EH! _@HKDEG@=Y! #?! d@=AD?=EKK^! L#=A?EG@LA#?^e! `DLEIHD! @A! dL#=B#I=GH! AFD! ?#KD! #B! =DYEA@8D! ELA@#=! $! $! $! R@AF! AFD! ?#KD! #B! EBB@?_EA@8D! ELA@#=7e! E=G! FE8D! GDHL?@`DG! F@H! L#=LKIH@#=H! EH! dI=AD=E`KDe!

`DLEIHD! AFD^! EHHI_D! AFEA! dAFD! ?#KD! #B! =DYEA@8D! ELA@#=! @H! A?IK^! GD! _@=@_@H$e ! !@""P( "-8-7! >@KK@E_! C$! M@GGD?7! C"84#$6"( L2#$%&( I"'*/*( L11$'94#$6"( L2#$%&R( L*$4&( !42$1$2( L9"'$24&*( L'"( @#$00( 4/8A#( $&( #A"( '%**1$'"7! %%! N@LF$! [$! 6ELD! g! 2$! XT)7! X%(&%)!

VQTTXW$!

_IHA! `D! LEIHDG! `^! H#_DAF@=Y! #AFD?! AFE=! ?ELD&L#=HL@#IH!EBB@?_EA@8D!ELA@#=$!!+F@H!@H!RFD?D!=DYEA@8D!ELA@#=!L#_DH!@=$!

"DYEA@8D! ELA@#=! L?DEADH! E! GD! BELA#! LEJ! #=!EG_@HH@#=H! B#?! /H@E=! /_D?@LE=! HAIGD=AH$! ! *A! LE=! `D!

@_JKD_D=ADG! `^! @=BKDb@`KD7! =I_D?@LEK! qI#AEH! #?! `^!E=! I=qIE=A@B@DG! EG_@HH@#=H! LEKLIKEA@#=$! ! ME=Y7!

`IA! @A! @H! E! JFD=#_D=#=! I=?DKEADG! A#! EBB@?_EA@8D!ELA@#=$! ! +FD! Db@HAD=LD! #B! E! =E??#RK^! AE@K#?DG7! ?ELD&L#=HL@#IH! EG_@HH@#=H! JKE=! FEH! =#! `DE?@=Y! #=!RFDAFD?!E!I=@8D?H@A^!D=YEYDH!@=!=DYEA@8D!ELA@#=$!

TE& +*(&<IBA=&L;>;&;>&2(&LB&GB>&<@BR& G=N;>CJ=&;I>CBG&;N;CG<>&*<C;G&

*H=ACI;G<E&

CKE@_H!E`#IA!G@BBD?D=A@EK!HAE=GE?G@fDG!ADHA!HL#?DH!

`^! ?ELD! E?D! #BAD=! F@YFK^! _@HKDEG@=Y7! @B! =#A!GD_#=HA?E`K^! BEKHD$! ! O@BBD?D=LDH! @=! E8D?EYD! HL#?DH!E_#=Y!?EL@EK!#?!DAF=@L!Y?#IJH!EA!@=HA@AIA@#=H!HILF!EH!9+! ?DBKDLA! AFD! ?EL@EKiDAF=@L! ADHA! HL#?D! G@HJE?@A@DH!EK?DEG^!J?DHD=A!@=!AFD!EJJK@LE=A!J##K7!?DHIKA@=Y!B?#_!H#L@#DL#=#_@L!G@BBD?D=LDH7!DGILEA@#=EK!J?ELA@LDH7!E=G!

#AFD?!D=8@?#=_D=AEK!BELA#?H$!!@""! CKEIGD! 5$! 4@HLFD?! DA!EK$7!>&"W/40$#?(Y?(B"*$8&R(.'42F$&8(#A"(7"00(./'6"(

T?#A!(X!V%PPXWv!>@KK@E_!1$!0#RD=!g!OD?DS!0#S7!<A"(

@A4+"( %1( #A"( )$6"'R( H%&8V<"'9( %&*"W/"&2"*( %1(