Phan Thj Mai Huong lim chd nhidm.. Td Thuy Hanh Phd Trudng phong Phdng Tdm ly hgc ing dung.. Ihdi dp vd cdm trongphgm vtgia dinh cua cdc em cd dnh hudng Id, hdnh vl thuc hiin viic nhd I
Trang 1MOT s o MO HINH Da BAO
SL/THAY OOI HANH VI
THL/C HIEN VIEC N H A
VA H A N H VI GIUP DO NGUOI K H A C
CUA TRE V! T H A N H NIEN
thanhnientio Vidn Tam ly hoc chil tri, PGS.TS Phan Thj Mai Huong lim chd nhidm '
ThS Td Thuy Hanh
Phd Trudng phong Phdng Tdm ly hgc ing dung
T6M TAT
17 song,a Ha Ngi va thanhphd Hd Chi Minh cho thdy Ihdi dp vd cdm trongphgm vtgia dinh cua cdc em cd dnh hudng Id, hdnh vl thuc hiin viic nhd IdZhvTgZ danprat khac cua chmh cdc em Nghiin citu cing lim ra md, si md hinhdu bdofd the tdng cuang cdc hdnh vi lich cue agio dinh vd xa h0l cita tre vi thdnh niin
Tii- khoa: Thai do vd cam: Gia dinh: Vi thdnh niin
Ngdy nhdn bdi: I4/6/20I6; Ngdy duyil ddng bdi: 25/8/2016
1 Mff d i u
h., ,-^^' dp thudng duac hiiu la phin flng mang tinh chit dinh gii tich cue
h»v H T V " - ' ° 7 l ; ""' ' ^ ' ^ ^ "*° ^°' ^"'^^ *« hidn qua suy nghTxflc c t a
hay hirii VI dy dmh, dd li nhftng dinh gii Iiu dii dupc Iuu gitt trong ki to
van Hao 20 0) Thii dp ludn dupc hlnh thinh vdi mdt ddi tuons nhif dinh
ttong nhttng tinh hudng nhit djnh, phin inh cich nhln nhin r a n r , L r ' ' cflng nhu xu hudng hanh ddng cfla chfl thi ' ' ' ^ ""*' '*•" """^
hinh v!? t j f s r : ^ r ;:^fc?;^^f^^:t™r"^^ ^
Vdi mpt ddi mpng nhit dtah Nd phin inh tt^gTiiTstl^hin^'Ctet
i
Trang 2^^5iSl^''"^*"'*'^'='"'*'^^™''-"^-''flAdvdiddi
Wicker (1969), Fishbem vi Ajzen ??974) K S I I I ^ ^ ' ""^ "^'"™ '^ "f^ gi»a thii dp vi hinh vi khdni phi b i o i ^ ^ t ed ^ ^ " u ' ^ '^'' '^'^'
taydn tfah Hinh vi phu thudc vi^ nhiiTdSu S k h i h " T "••'""« "h,* kidn chu quan vi khich quan Cic I f ^ t " ^ * khac ,Aau, bao gdm ci diiu
ydu td khie nhau ed Ad inh h u l f d i ^ l ^ ^ " ' ' " ' ^'™ " ^ " ' c hon 40
Be ed dupc sy nhit q u i n T o a S d vn h T-".".- «"*' **' * ' ™ "inh vi
h i n h v i e y A d ( d i n t h ' e o L S l : t u ' , ™ ' ; S j „ * ' ; » ' ' ' ' ' ™ 8 « i i i d p v d i
quan t l ^ ^ " ^ t t ^ ^ ' V ' f V " ^ ' ''^ '^^^ "hi khoa hoc
c t a ttong ttudng hoc, ttong v a r ^ t r i n t S h ?"•* "*™^ ''"* ^''^ "hu vd
hpi ndi Chung NhOns nEhidr^n^ ™®- ^ ™ "'^ ^ * '^^^ hidn tuong xi
ving bdng, dfc bidnf s u t r c i Z , ™ h ™ J ^ ™ '™"* ^ ^ "'•* " " ^ 8 ""u'edn
Vd e t a li ttang Aii mi con n»ud, di^ H ' " L " - ^ ' ' *"*" ""*' ^' * ^ "idn tftong tic qua fai vdi x u n T q u L " g ' h Z ' d d l ? " " -"^"^''™« ""^ '^'"'' cam ttong gia dinh cfla ttd vi r h i l "^ 5 ' *"^ *°"8 cua minh Thii dd vd
sv Ad a, dflng ZTa^,n^„f "'™ ^"^' hidu la tr^g Aii tim Iy Ai hidn bao g i m ' s y l i a ttonrvLTtal%:"t^t T- '''•''' ^'^ ^'•^- '^""B dl den lai ieh bin Ain k h d ^ A i hiTn^iTp r"^''"" ^"' "'""'• '^'' ""•• ' h ' nghT
phuang dien tinh c t a ' ™^ ' " * " • " y«" "h™? cin cd tTen
giup dd ngudi khic cflatt^* thtVnTdn d t r r i f r J " * " "'''' ""•* '' """^ ^' bio Aay ddi nhttng hinh vi n i ^ e t c l e m hpf s^i^' '"' " •"'' ^° ">* "••"• '"
2 Mlu va phu-ffng phip nghien eihi
Otpn mdu
mdi- kit Auc chuong Utah tiiu L^e hi, 7 K "' '^ " ' ° ' ' ' ' ' ' ' " ° ' ™^ cie e,^
n i n g ^ u bidt, nhin S t o Tmtk'nV^^^^^^^^^
sau Sie (Adi diim diiu tta li Aiig 9 ^ ^ ^ I * ^? - ^ i " ' '°" "^™ ""^^ cic em ein tip ttung Ai luc vi t X l h v ' ^J" ^°' '*' ''*>' '^ 8'^^ doan khin khi tidp cin 4dm S Ai niv J^' •' ''•''" " ' " ^"""8 tSi giP khd nghidn Cflu Cd dd mdi m ntnll 2 i ^ , ^ ^ " '! ' * ^ ' ' '''^." ' " " 8 ™5"
ngudi khdng Audc miu khich Ai L I ^ ^ ^ L g h o * " ' " "'*"* ^ ' " ^'" ^^^^ '
Trang 3vin J^'rTVf^ "K^*"!.™ ' ™ "^^ y^ ^"^'^ ' * < * « la bing hdi vi phdng
SreS 22.0 ' " " ' "* '**° ' ' ' *"'^ "*" """= ™ '5^ hing phin mim eiia rrdlfrv ''^"^ -''*'.'° f ' ' ' * " " " ^ * dupc xiy dyng dd do Aii dd vd c t a cua tte V! thanh men hanh v, lira vide nhi vi hinh vi giflp dd ngudi khic cua
S d ^ ' / WJ:"^ '^^ * ' " « '° "^y ^^° «^"S tu 0,77 din 0,87 ndn cd Ai
su dyng dupc de khio sat thuc tidn
dimo f ™? 1^^^^^ "^^ • " ' ' ^ •"*' ^' " h ^ nidn gdm 28 mdnh dd Ndi
o Z L - - " ^ ^ - ^-"^ ' ™ " ^ 8 hay hinh dpng cua ttd vi Ainh nidn lidn
^ f „ J ? i , ! 'l.'^"- T '^"^ ^^"^ '">" "'" ""^S ngudi ldn", "Khd chiu khi^nguai,han kh,>ng phyc vu minh" hoic nhftng mdnh dd ngupc nghTa: "Cdm mn''"'tZ ^•'S'".''^'"' *"?""• " ¥ «^« '•"" yeu^Lnlv&i ngudi
t T ^ i n h ^ f l " - ' r * " ' *'^' ^^ '*^"' Ph^' hMn thai do vd cim cua ttd
c t a ^ U O U M T ' "J?f ""•"' '^ ™^^ ^*"8 gia dinh li quan hp tinh
cam vol nguoi Aan va muc dp Aam gia vio eic cdng vidc cfla gia dinh
Mdi mpnh dd ttong Aang do ed 5 phuong in tti ldi vi dupc gin cho cic
dimi T ' ™^ •*" T **'"« Si6ng em (tag vdi 1 diim); Gidng mit ehfltp
Aem) Nua giong nfla khdng (3 didm); Gidng phin nhiiu (4 didm) Gidng hoin
S cao A?e - ? f '^/'"^ ' " ^ « ' '=''^"«'°' ""^ " * "i^"- """S biSi ( B ^
c T v i diim ^ n X r - "'- ' t " " " ' " " " " ' ' ^ ^ 8 * ^ hidn rd Khi ttah dp tin
Ciy va didra hung binh cua toin Aang do, nhftng mpnh dd nguac nghTa di duoc
ht sirerg^r-"™ *^"^'"'''"" ^^8 - *^ '•-*^' ^'v^rx
cr, ,A " " ' i , * ? ^ ''° ' ' ^ ' ' " 'hyc hidn vide nhi vi hinh vi giup dd ngudi khic
CO so mpnh de tuang ung li 10 mdnh dd vi 12 mdnh di cfc m d n h T m e^u ti
T i r r ^ t T"-^'' "i""^ ™ ''' •=" '^0 «"- hpc sinh T d A i A™ M^'
hiSi'*rct?-^ -o^ht&^?intc
hinh v r | f l ; t n ^ S l A i c t f l a t ^ v ' i A?H'°'-.''^'f ^' **"= '''" l ' ^ ' '^^ ^i tich t u 4 q'uan vii:i;^q':^y1 A^ig d o ' t t t ""=" ""' ^ ' ™ "^ ''^' ""* " " ^
92 ^ "^
Trang 4'^^^^g:
3 Ket qua agbien cihi thire tien
'hdnh ^ll,!^'' ""' """^ " ' '*"'' "^ "" "'^ "" *""* •"• S'^P ^ cda tri v/
Kdt qui phan tieh nhan td khta pha, vdi Dhuimo r,ha„ t„-„i, - - thinh phin chu ydu (Principle component m k X i T l f d n v '^ v -^'" ' ° " phep ed 5 ydu td dupc ttich xuit, u L g flng v d i l i m e t e b L 4 ™ ^ ' ^ ?
so vdi Aang do ban diu), dd tm eav li 0 Kl /^J " > * • * * (bo di 4 menh de
^ vd c t a cua ttd vi Ainh n i ^ Z „ oil J ' ^ ° > ™ '? ^ "^'^ '^^"h bidu hidn
Ain; 2 Khdng Ad h i f n ^ T d ^ t T Z f ' ' ?™-' ' ' "=" " * ' ' "^hr din ban
Khdng quan L din S t a g ^ u v ^ T n ^ - " ' ™ "^^^ * ' " """^ 8ia dinh; 3
4 Thiiu c t a giie cd S to Sif!"^^ I " """.^ "^^ " ^ ^ S ' ^ "^c nha; khi ning n h a y V n h k b i t t g C d & T l S * ' - ™ " ^ " *™^ ^- ™ « " gia dinh (xem Adm Phan TTi S u l r ^ ^ S f Z , " ^ " " " " """^
o-oig gia mnh & tre vl thdnh niin T T e t T™ i ?u ° ^ ^ " " ^^ ""' '''*'"
gii Chung, thii dd vd cim cto h S ' ^ „ J " 5 'v h^c so 8/2016) Ndu dinh
btoh (diim trung binh A ^ g l ^d e t a = 2 !975"d^-'T T ' ^ ' ' ""^-'^'^S cae em dinh gii mflc dd ci& r l hii t - ' - ' ' ^^"^ 'huin = 0,57 Y kiin
didm 2) * • " " '^"^ •"'" hien vo c t a tip ttung nhiiu nhit d mto
hinh vi Auc hidn v i d c X = 2 73 d^i™! ^ ?8 * • " " « ""''=" ( » ™ ^ang do giOp dd ngudi khie ^ ^ 2 ^ , d l ' l ^ c h l S i ' ^ o ' T " ' " ^ " " ^ " " " ^ "" " ^ ^••
cda ,,^vi::Z:i^ *'"* " ' ' "'" ^<r "-y -^Z *««* vi ihtfc hipn vipc nhd
tich ttrangquanvihdi quy s d r h o ' A ^ r m 6 f ; : : h d : ; S c t ^ ^ r u s ^ a : ? ' ' ' ' ' ^ "
Bien Uc dgng:
Thai d9 v6 cam trong gia dinh ciia tre vi
thanb nien
KMog Uij hien sir yen thirong c i , c6 vdi ngudi
Jhan Irong gia dinii
Thilu SJ, nhay cam v6i nhitag Aay dSj ^ ngi^i
than trong gia dinh *
TAPCHfTAMLyHOC,Stf9(2I0),9-20l6
Biea pfau thugc:
Hanh vi tbov hi|i, vigc nba ciia tre
vj thinh nign H| ao totmg quao i HI io hoi qny r*
Trang 5khong lam viec nha ^ • s •
Thiln * cam giac co I6i khi lam gi dd khong
I dnng vdi ngiroi ihjn '•
Ghlebi: '"khip< 0.001: " khip < 0.01
Kdt qui phan tieh ttrmig quan vi hdi quy bic nhit da eho Aiy:
Aons gin!^^^^'-*''^"J^^" **' "^ ^° "^^ cua ttd vi Ainh nien ddu cd
c S n Z f K - I-'-™ ^ * ^^^ " •^'"= hifn vide nha cfla cic em Khi cic em ZZ^r,!i ••" ™ r " ' '™'?8 S'= *"h Ai cic em cing it thyc hidn vidc
vide nhJcflfcWm T o t ^'d" T-1 "^ ''^" '^ « ' '^^"8 '•^" hinh vi Aye hidn nprtn Ain cflf e v • r K - *^'- "*' '*^"S *^ "pn sy ydu Auong cin cd vdi J rCg Aay ^'vthZ ! ' ih'™.'-'- '"=-/*"« " " * '*^'' 8'^ thich dupc I7o/„ ^
A f l h f i r s y t h I i CM „ J ^ " ^ f ^ ' " u " - ' ""* ' ? ^ "^ ™- Bito tic ddng mjmh ^ ndi htoh ddnf Ita t t " " " " * ^ ' '='"• '"^' "*' h°i thim chi cd nhftngTdi
vi h i i T v i ' t S l i t v™c n r ' " ^ " * " • «''•' *'''^'' •^''^^ ' '"''• " " ^ 8 tha/ddi
dpngdleCkhtgtuil'li",^,*?' ?5^"f ""^ "•' ^* "*' '"^'' «^
quy bpi stepwise (dua din v L ^ J^ ^ ^ "'"^"- ^ ' ^^y- Ph^P Phta tich hdi
khoVcdn y^ngl^i;;^ " d u t ' ^ p ' h i t fa"nMt '°?'hf i! T'-"'"'"^-'"^"
vi sit hon vdi Auc ti Toin hd •; h X ! A- fl ^ "'° h'"h hdi quy tdi uu caa ttd vi Atai ni en di^*"du'vio ; ticrh'' " T- T '^^^ "'«" «^^ ""^ nhit gifta cic bidn tic dpng nTy ed g ^ ^ b L V o ^ ) ' " ' ^""' ' " ' " ^ "I"^" '^°
"ing 2: Bamd hinhdu bdo su thay ddi hanh vi thuc hiin viic nhd
cua ire vi thdnh niin
TAP CHf TAMLy HQC, Stf 9 ( 2 1 0 ) , 9 - 2 0 1 6
Trang 6S t g ; : ^ , ^ : ^ * - - - Viec nhi c a li vi diinh „i,n (lan dpn, ,n.l nhi, si, xi,
Bi4n ldc
agng-M6 hinh 3: Khdng t^^U^nZf^I '" ""' ^'"^''' " '''"^''^" "" «"•
"s^'^^n-.«.:Thiax^-:z^:h^S;-si^-g^5;^'
tai ^ ' S ^ ' m S ^ ^ ^ i l ^ ^ : ^ ^ 'h^^ ^ ha md htah dy bio dinh (giii Aich dupc fl'A n h S a v d i ^ r n l t " ^° '* "^*'' ''^" '""8 gia
cic em); (2) Thiiu Ai hien s^vlu thl™ -* ^ J ' '*'"= h'?" "dc nhi cua
din bin Ain (giai Aich d ^ p ^ ( T S t ? ' w"^ " ' " ' *'" "'' '•"• "8hr
vdi ngudi than ttang gia dit^i Ich l^-'cW n^-H^' K I" '^ ''^'i "'^""8 cin cd
d.bii^t^^S'-SZ^inrilhnr^^^T*''''™-^ - i Cfla Cic biin tic dOng-Chin"gZ"tlrdd.bii^t^^S'-SZ^inrilhnr^^^T*''''™-^- 3 d.bii^t^^S'-SZ^inrilhnr^^^T*''''™-^ Arcd";h1;d.bii^t^^S'-SZ^inrilhnr^^^T*''''™-^f
- 0,23 ( ^ J i s ^ ' ^ ^ - t ^ i i u Z Z " " ' ^" • "•'' '*'^" - ^^" * - 8 ) vito tt^g"^:^^^ "^rl'^tSJi "''" V'"-'^"'^^ '^ - vdi cic Ainh
"h»y cta* ;^in ra nhftnrUiav 1 ^^ " ^ i , " ' " ' <''^"' " -"'^ '^ ^^ ^ Aidu
dpng ydu nhilTBeta = J ^ s t S h i v! E - - * " ^ - ' ' T *" "'"" '^ •"«" "^^ "^c u.u^'l tm hanh vi Auc taen viec nha cfla ttd vj Ainh nidn
TAPCHfTAMLyHpc,Stf9(2IO),9-2016
Trang 7ri r k h d f- -"*"- " " * ™ ^^'*'° * ' ^ ' ' - ^ ^ 8iac cd Idi ho^i bin khi Tta diiu
p do khong pha, vol nguoi Ain cfla ttd vi Aanh nidn bi g i t a thidu rit nhiiu
(Khong con y nghia Adng kd)
Ihanh nfiJ^" '""'' '''^ *"" **"""''' ^^' '"*"* "' *''«' ^* "*"*' *'''" """ '" "' Bdng 3: Kit qud phdn tich hrong quan vd hdi quy bdc nhit giOa thdi dp
vo cam vat hdnh vi giup dd ngudi khdc cua tre vi thdnh niin
Bien t i c dong;
T h i i do vo cam trong gia dinh cua tre vi
thanh nien
Khong the hien sir y l u Ihuong cin CO vdi ngirdi
than trong gia dinh
Bien phu thU9c;
Hanh vi giiip d ^ aguiri khac ciia tre
vj thanh nien H$ SO tu-ong quan
Thi^u sir nhay cam, nhan ra nhitag thay d6i ciia
nguoi thin trong gia dinh
Ich ki chi nghr din ban than
Khong qnan tim trong nhi x i y ra chnyin gi,
khong lim v i ^ nha ^
Thiiu di cam giic c6 ldi khi lam gi do khdng
dnng vdi nprdi ihan '
- 0 , 3 0 "
He so hoi quy r"
0,16*
CfccAii.- '"khip < 0.001: "•khip < 0,01
0,09»
0 , 0 7 ' "
0 , 0 5 " * 0,06»
d i n h A i v l d ^ A y c h a ^ v ^ t r n ^ r K ^ ^ r f m l ^ t r g ' ^ ™ - ' ^
n h i n r n h t g A ^ r ^ l f — - 8 ^ - — ^ ^ ^
% TAP CHf TAM l y HOC, Stf 9 ( 2 1 0 ) , 9 - 2016
Trang 8cua tre vi Ihanh nien S "tnac
1 ^ 1 Thien nhay
1 than trone e
3 1 Ich ki chi nf
Mi Unh 4:
r'-022:h&,„<A
1 Khdng ttii t
thfin trone ci
-0,16
J -0,14
I -0,09
0,000 1
0,000 0,004
Chu thich:
Mdhinh I: Khdng flii hiln Stf yin Ihuong
ehi nghl din ban 1 ? ^ '^ ™*^ ^'^ ' ^ '=*"', nh|n ra nhitag thay dii; fch ki
* : ; " ? l r , g S l L ^ ; * r , l ™ ' " - ^ - - • "'*"^ -hOng a y ^^ Ich k,
TAPCHfTAMLyHpC,Stf9(210),9-2016
Trang 9yo, nguoi Am ttang gia dinh la bidn sd cd tic dpng manh nhit giai Akh dupe 16/0 sy Aay doi ve hinh vi giup dd ngudi khic cfla ttd ^ i thinh nien _ Kdt qui cua phep hdi quy bdi stepwise cho Aiy, khi ci 5 khia canh hiiu hien thai dp vo cam cua hpc sinh dupc dua vio phan tich vdi tu cich li bidn tac dpng Al Au dupc bdn md hinh dy bio su Aay ddi hanh vi giflp dd ngudi khac cua eie em hpc sinh, gdm: (I) Khdng Ai hidn su veu Auong ein cd gifta cic Aanh vidn ttong gia dinh (giii Aich dupc 16% nhiing Aay dli vd hinh vi
s u p do ngum khic); (2) Khdng thd hidn sy yeu Auong va Aidu nha>- cim, nhan ra nhitag Aay ddi cua ngudi Ain ttong gia dinh (giii Aich dupc 19%); (J) Khong Ac hien su yeu Auong; Aiiu nh?y cim vi ich ki chi nghl din bin than (glii Aich duoe 21 %); (4) Khdng Ai hipn sy ydu Auong; Aiiu nhw cim;
1 u 7 ° "^ 8iac cd l§i khi lam didu gi khdng phii vdi ngudi Ain (giai
Aich dupc 22%) = o r e
•• k- 7".'^^' ''*' '^"^ niy, cd thi cd cic phuang trinh du bao nhftng Aay ddi
ve hanh vi giup dd nguoi khic cfla trd vi Aanh nidn, vi du vdi md hinh 4 se cd phuang tnnh sau:
Hinh vi giflp dd ngudi khic = 3,83 - 0,26 (Aiiu sy yeu Auong) - 0,16 (Aiiu™ nh»y cam) - 0,14 (sy ich ki) - 0,09 (thidu cam giic cd ldi)
„j m-'^™^ 1"° *''"^ "'y' **' ^^ "h^ hipn d vide khdng Ai hipn su ydu Auong Zh'iTt,'" ' ? " ' ' " - " ' • ' * ' " '^ ' * * ' 8 '^'"5' ^^' l^h^c cua ngudi thin trong gia n^JJl' '" 1 "" '^l ,"1"^ "^"^ "''^' *^" ' ' ^ h vi giup dd ngudi khic bdn
ngoii xi hpi cua hpc sinh (Beta Ian Iupt ed gia tri bing -0,26 vi -0,16)
hinh ^i," "Y-"-'^' "^^ ' ' ^ « "^^ '''^" phip nhim ting cudng vi cung cd nhftng tuii v u S nil" " • ' t ' "."« ""•' "^""^ y' ^'^P " ' "SUM khic c'fla c^Tr?
tuo V thanh men can ehu y ddn mpt sd bidn quan ttong dupc triit xuit trona
Aifdd Aih'iSt h""" T- ^ " " ' "''' P"'' '™ ''" ''° ' - ^' th^nh n n" 0?
Ai, dp the hidn tinh yeu Auong vdi ngudi thin ttong gia dinh giim tfah ich kl
^dtphfi'l d ' T ' '' """^^ "'"'>^" *'"• '"' nhito Sltg dil niy
t ^ hfpn s t ylu th"uo^t' 7 " " ' " ' - " ""' ''' "" P"*' ^'"^ ''• phif cd nhftng ddav Ii n h i f r l H *:, ^^ - T '^'"' '" "^W cam tdi gia dinh Cich thuc nhtag i ^ t a ° t i " ^ ' ''"^-"'1^''"'' ' " ' ^ 8 di eie'em bdc 10, hi tadn
p h t a f v i f siu vdi ciu hn-""r ' ^u"" *^"«' "^"^ ' * " *idi Aye Trong AuOTo eha me vT, ,K ^^l"" """^S l t o nhftng gi dd A i hidn ttah ydu eZllnhZ' '^ *"""« "^"^' **" "•™8 gia dinh?", da sd y kidn tri Idi di bdn nfoif ^ i f "";=T°"« " ' • ""^ '^ha me ddi vdi cic mi, quan hd ban bl kit quTti; tto?A™,-' •'i.tV'P 't' "'' cm, nhu: phii chim chi hpc hinh, dat
'T<^°^Tti^:ZtX':tttoZii:'\^^^^^^^
6 ""• luung xau trong ldp Khong eo nhieu y kidn ndi din
go
Trang 10^vT',$'""- "^ ^^ ? J J * " ^ '*^- "=^8 vdi dd, khi hdi cic bac phu
hujnh: -Eheu g eac con lara khien cho cha me dau long?", nhung cau tri lm
n h ^ dupe cun^ tuong ty nhu nhftng eau tta Idi cua cie con ( ^ l i e o ? h ^
kem, bd hpc, tton hpc, not dd di Aeo su ni rd nia nhA™ k ^ • cic te nan xa hdi) Diiu nay cho thi^ ITt^^U^tieA, T ' ? ' " ™°
«ftotthtJsi^-S -^s
h u d n g d d n „ h f t n g h i n ? ™ X S ' s : u ™ i ; ' 2 r e m ' - ^ - ' " " "^^ " ^
Ket luSn
Tren i
tning g^dinTct ttl^irh "^"""-'-"^ l' * ' ' ^ ^ « "^"^ •^^' '^ ^° cta
Tai lieu tham khao
1 Adzin Bdch khoa loan thu American Association, 2000
2 Knud S Larsen v i U Van Hao Tdm ly hgc xd hgi 2010
T*PCHfTAMLyH(X:,Sd-9(2IO),9-20l6
99