The complete thermodynamic profile for berberine bind-ing to the quadruplex, at 25C, shows a small negative enthalpy DH of 1.7 kcalÆmol1, an entropy change with TDS of +6.5 kcalÆmol1, and
Trang 1quadruplex – spectroscopic, calorimetric and
molecular modeling studies
Amit Arora1, Chandramouli Balasubramanian1, Niti Kumar1, Saurabh Agrawal1, Rajendra P Ojha2 and Souvik Maiti1
1 Proteomics and Structural Biology Unit, Institute of Genomics and Integrative Biology, CSIR, Delhi, India
2 Biophysics Unit, Department of Physics, DDU Gorakhpur University, India
The telomere is a region of highly repetitive DNA at
the end of a linear chromosome that protects the
terminal ends of chromosomes from being recognized
as damaged DNA and allows faithful chromosome
replication during the cell cycle [1,2] Mammalian
telomeres consist of several kilobase pairs of
double-stranded G-rich DNA and a 100–200 base
single-stranded overhang on the 3¢-end [3,4] A host of
telomere-associated proteins, including TRF1, TRF2
and POT1, ensures that the telomeric single-stranded
overhang does not trigger DNA damage response
pathways or lead to abnormal chromosomal
rearrange-ments [5–7] Exposure of the 3¢-end due to uncapping
results in cellular senescence and apoptosis [8,9]
Telo-merase, a ribonucleoprotein reverse transcriptase
enzyme (composed of both RNA and proteins), uses its internal RNA component (complementary to the telomeric single-stranded overhang) as a template for synthesis of telomeric DNA A(GGGTTA)n, directly at the ends of chromosomes Telomerase is present in most fetal tissues, normal adult male germ cells, inflammatory cells, proliferative cells of renewal tissues, and most tumor cells Importantly, telomerase
is active in a majority of human cancer cells but is inactive in most normal somatic cells [10] It has been shown previously that formation of intramolecular G-quadruplexes by the telomeric G-rich strand inhibits the activity of telomerase [10] Therefore, ligand-induced stabilization of intramolecular telomeric G-quadruplexes has become an attractive strategy for
Keywords
berberine; hydration; quadruplex;
quadruplex–ligand interaction;
thermodynamics
Correspondence
S Maiti, Proteomics and Structural Biology
Unit, Institute of Genomics and Integrative
Biology, CSIR, Mall Road, Delhi 110 007,
India
Fax: +91 11 2766 7471
Tel: +91 11 2766 6156
E-mail: souvik@igib.res.in
(Received 11 April 2008, revised 16 May
2008, accepted 9 June 2008)
doi:10.1111/j.1742-4658.2008.06541.x
This study examines the characteristics of binding of berberine to the human telomeric d[AG3(T2AG3)3] quadruplex By employing UV-visible spectroscopy, fluorescence spectroscopy and isothermal titration calorime-try, we found that the binding affinity of berberine to the human telomeric quadruplex is 106 The complete thermodynamic profile for berberine bind-ing to the quadruplex, at 25C, shows a small negative enthalpy (DH) of )1.7 kcalÆmol)1, an entropy change with TDS of +6.5 kcalÆmol)1, and an overall favorable free energy (DG) of)8.2 kcalÆmol)1.Through the temper-ature dependence of DH, we obtained a heat capacity (DCp) of )94 (± 5) calÆmol)1ÆK)1 The osmotic stress method revealed that there is an uptake of 13 water molecules in the complex relative to the free reactants Furthermore, the molecular modeling studies on different quadruplex– berberine complexes show that berberine stacking at the external G-quartet
is mainly aided by the p–p interaction and the stabilization of the high negative charge density of O6 of guanines by the positively charged N7 of berberine The theoretical heat capacity (DCp) values for quadruplex– berberine models are)89 and )156 calÆmol)1ÆK)1
Abbreviations
H 2 TMPyP 4 , 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(1-methyl-4-pyridyl)-21H,23H-porphine; ITC, isothermal titration calorimetry; MMPBSA, molecular mechanics Poisson–Bolzmann surface area; SASA, solvent-accessible surface area.
Trang 2the development of anticancer ligands A molecule that
has (a) a p-delocalized system, (b) a partial positive
charge in the center of the molecular scaffold and
(c) positively charged substituents to interact with the
grooves, loops and the negatively charged phosphate
backbone is most likely to interact with, and thus
stabilize, G-quadruplexes A number of
G-quadruplex-interacting agents with the above-mentioned features,
typically porphyrins [11–16], anthraquinones [17],
perylenes [18] and carbocyanines [19], have been
developed and shown to promote and⁄ or stabilize
quadruplex structures In past few years, Neidle and
co-workers have reported a number of trisubstituted
acridine analogs with a variety of side-chain
modifi-cations and stereoisomer variations exhibiting strong
G-quadruplex binding, high selectivity for quadruplex
over duplex DNA, and associated telomerase
inhibitory activity in the nanomolar range [20–22]
The rational design of new therapeutic agents that
bind to quadruplexes in a structure-specific manner is
of considerable interest and urgency Many small
molecules that bind to quadruplexes have proven to be
effective therapeutic agents, although the exact mode
of binding and nature of thermodynamic forces that
regulate DNA–ligand interactions are often poorly
understood This limited knowledge hampers many
efforts to rationally modify existing ligands and⁄ or
design new therapeutic agents that bind to target
quadruplex structures with predictable affinity and
specificity Characterization of the forces that govern
quadruplex–ligand interactions traditionally relies on
detailed knowledge of the thermodynamic and
struc-tural properties of the ligand, the DNA, and the
com-plex Berberine, an isoquinoline alkaloid from plants,
is a planar molecule with an extended p-delocalized
system having a partial positive charge on N7 [23]
(Fig 1) It has been shown that berberine and its
analogs bind to telomeric G-quadruplex and inhibit the telomerase activity [24,25] Studies show that these molecules have high selectivity for G-quadruplex over duplex DNA, and the aromatic moieties of the mole-cule play a dominant role in quadruplex binding, implying that this molecule could be an attractive scaf-fold to develop new ligands targeting G-quadruplex selectively To obtain comprehensive knowledge on the interaction of this scaffold, we performed spectro-scopic, calorimetric and molecular modeling studies to obtain thermodynamic and structural details of the quadruplex–berberine interaction
Results
Equilibrium binding studies by UV-visible spectroscopy
To gain insight into the interaction between berberine and the G-quadruplex formed by the telomere, UV spectra of berberine in the absence and presence of quadruplex were obtained The resulting absorption spectra are illustrated in Fig 2 The UV spectra of berberine show two distinct peaks at 341 and 421 nm Addition of increasing amounts of quadruplex results
in hypochromicity (34–40%) and a moderate batho-chromic shift of 7 nm for the high-energy peak from
341 to 348 nm in the UV-visible spectra of berberine, and hyperchromicity and a red shift of 19 nm for the lower-energy peak from 421 to 440 nm, indicating
Fig 1 Chemical structure of berberine.
Fig 2 Absorbance spectra of 1 l M berberine in 50 m M MES buffer (pH 7.4) and 100 m M KCl in the absence and presence of succes-sive additions of quadruplex at 25 C The inset is the Scatchard plot of r ⁄ C versus r, where r is the ratio of bound berberine to the total base pair concentration, and C is the concentration of free ligand Data were fitted to the McGhee–von Hippel neighbor exclu-sion model.
Trang 3interaction of berberine with quadruplex The
occur-rence of sharp isobestic points at 359, 383 and 445 nm
clearly indicates the existence of equilibrium in the
binding Ligand binding with DNA through
intercala-tion usually results in hypochromicity and
bathochro-mism due to strong stacking interactions between an
aromatic chromophore and the base pairs of DNA
These spectral characteristics suggest a mode of
bind-ing that involves a stackbind-ing interaction between
berber-ine and the quartet of quadruplex The absorbance
change at 341 nm of the berberine absorption spectra
upon successive addition of quadruplex was used to
construct a Scatchard plot Analysis of this Scatchard
plot yielded a binding affinity of (1.2 ± 0.2)· 106m)1
and a binding site density of 0.9 at 25C
Equilibrium binding studies by the fluorescence
method
Fluorescence emission spectra for berberine in the
absence and presence of different amounts of
quadru-plex were recorded in order to study the binding event
Figure 3 shows the effect of successive addition of
quadruplex on the fluorescence emission spectra of
berberine It is seen that increasing the concentration
of quadruplex results in a gradual increase in the
rescence intensity of berberine The ratio of the
fluo-rescence intensity of berberine in the presence and
absence of quadruplex is about 50 The kmaxin the
flu-orescence emission spectra shifts to the blue end by
5 nm The spectral changes arise from the change in
the environment of berberine, which reveals that
berberine is binding with quadruplex The change in
fluorescence intensity at 522 nm due to addition of
quadruplex solution was used to construct the binding
isotherm (inset of Fig 3) Analysis of this isotherm
following 1 : 1 binding stoichiometry using Eqn (7)
(see Experimental procedures) gives a binding affinity
of (1.2 ± 0.1)· 106m)1 at 25C Thermodynamic
parameters calculated for the quadruplex–berberine
binding are presented in Table 1
Equilibrium binding studies by the isothermal
titration calorimetry (ITC) method
With recent advances in the sensitivity and reliability
of the calorimeter, ITC has become an important tool
for the direct measurement of thermodynamic
para-meters in various biological interactions [26,27] ITC
yields thermodynamic parameters such as Gibbs free
energy change (DG), enthalpy change (DH), and
entropy change (DS), along with the number of
bind-ing sites (n) in a sbind-ingle experiment Also, determination
of binding enthalpy as a function of temperature yields changes in heat capacity (DCp) associated with an interaction that provides valuable insights into the type and magnitude of forces involved Therefore, we have utilized ITC to characterize the thermodynamics of binding of berberine to quadruplex Calorimetric titra-tions were performed at different temperatures to directly measure the binding enthalpy Figure 4A shows a typical titration curve obtained at 25C The area under the heat burst curves was determined by integration to yield the heat of injection associated with the reaction These injection heats were corrected
by subtraction of the corresponding dilution heats derived from the injection of identical amounts of ber-berine into the buffer alone The corrected isotherms obtained at five different temperatures are shown in Fig 4B All related thermodynamic parameters are presented in Table 2 The binding affinity measured from ITC is (0.4 ± 0.1)· 106m)1 at 25C At all temperatures studied, the binding enthalpies were found to be negative, with their magnitude increasing
Fig 3 Fluorescence emission spectra of 0.5 l M berberine in
50 m M MES buffer (pH 7.4) and 100 m M KCl in the absence and presence of successive additions of quadruplex at 25 C The inset
is the plot of DF versus quadruplex concentration Data were fitted
to Eqn (7) to extract the binding affinity (Experimental procedures).
Table 1 Thermodynamic parameters obtained for quadruplex–ber-berine binding at 25 C K b is the binding constant determined from spectroscopic titrations in 50 m M MES buffer (pH 7.4), DG is the net binding free energy calculated using DG = )RT ln K b , and DH is the binding enthalpy determined directly by ITC and used to calcu-late the entropy change, using DG = DH )TDS.
K b (·10 6
M )1) DG (kcalÆmol)1) DH (kcalÆmol)1) TDS (kcalÆmol)1)
1.2 ± 0.1 )8.2 ± 0.8 )1.7 ± 0.2 6.5 ± 0.7
Trang 4with an increase in temperature In all cases, the
stoi-chiometry was found to be one mole of ligand binding
per mole of quadruplex
Apparent discrepancy between spectroscopic and calorimetric binding constants
Examination of Tables 1 and 2 shows that the Kb val-ues determined from the spectroscopic and ITC data differ by one order at 25 C, despite the use of identi-cal salt and buffer conditions The binding constant can be determined accurately when titrant is added to
a fixed and constant concentration [Q0] of DNA, such that [Q0] is in the range of 1⁄ KA In UV and fluores-cence binding experiment, [Q0] = 1 lm and 0.5 lm respectively, which is in the range of 1⁄ KA (1.2 lm) However, the ITC experiment was performed at [Q0] = 10 lm, which is much larger than 1⁄ KA (1.2 lm) ITC could not be used in this case to obtain
an accurate value for Kb, as the low site concentration required would give a heat signal below the sensitivity
of the instrument For a quadruplex concentration of
1 lm in the cell, the heat output was not significantly greater than the heats of ligand dilution If the dilution heats were small and the binding enthalpy was large, then it would be possible to obtain a binding isotherm using a quadruplex concentration of 0.5–1 lm How-ever, these conditions are not met Despite these prob-lems, ITC can still be used to accurately and directly measure the binding enthalpy and stoichiometry for this interaction ITC remains an invaluable technique for determining binding enthalpies, even in cases where the binding constant cannot be determined accurately [28]
Heat capacity measurements Supplementary Fig S1 shows the temperature depen-dence of all thermodynamic parameters No curvature
in the plots of thermodynamic constants versus tem-perature is apparent over this temtem-perature range, and all of the plots are fitted with linear functions The heat capacity change (DCp) for a binding interaction
Fig 4 (A) Sample thermogram for the calorimetric titration of
100 l M berberine into 10 l M quadruplex at 25 C (B) Integrated
heats (after subtraction of heat of dilution for berberine) versus
ber-berine to quadruplex molar ratio plot at 10 C (h), 15 C (O), 20 C
(D), 25 C (,) and 30 C (e) The first data point was eliminated in
the data fit.
Table 2 Thermodynamic parameters obtained from ITC experiments for quadruplex–berberine binding in 50 m M MES buffer (pH 7.4) buffer containing 100 m M KCl Thermodynamic parameters were obtained for berberine binding to the preformed telomeric quadruplex at 25 C The quadruplex concentration in the cell was 10 l M and the berberine concentration in the syringe was 100 l M DG was determined using the relationship DG = )RT ln K b , where R is the universal gas constant, T is temperature, and K b is the binding affinity for the quadruplex– berberine interaction DH and DS correspond to the enthalpy and entropy change for the binding, respectively, and DG corresponds to the free energy change of binding DCpis the heat capacity change associated with the quadruplex–berberine interaction and is calculated using Eqn (1) as described in the text Values determined from microcalorimetric data.
Temperature (C) DH (kcalÆmol)1) K b · 10)6( M)1) n DG (kcalÆmol)1) TDS (kcalÆmol)1) DC p (calÆmol)1ÆK)1)
Trang 5can be determined from the temperature dependence
of the observed binding enthalpy using the standard
relationship:
The slope of the resulting line of DH versus
tempera-ture (T) in supplementary Fig S1 yields DCp of
)94 ± 5 calÆmol)1ÆK)1 for the binding of berberine to
quadruplex Thus, berberine binding to quadruplex is
associated with a negative heat capacity change that
falls within a range that is frequently observed for
both nucleic acid–ligand and protein–ligand
inter-actions [29,30]
Hydration change due to the binding obtained by
the osmotic stress method
The osmotic stress method has been used extensively
to evaluate the participation of water molecules in a
wide variety of biochemical reactions [30] Any
equilib-rium that involves changes in the water molecules
associated with a biopolymer is sensitive to changes in
the water activity (aW) [31–33] Water activity can in
turn be manipulated by the addition of low molecular
weight cosolutes, which themselves do not interact
with the biopolymer but are assumed to change the
water activity Equilibria that are coupled with
hydra-tion changes are influenced by the osmolyte
concentra-tion, as described by Qu & Chaires [33]:
dlnðKs=K0Þ=d½Osm ¼ Dnw=55:6 ð2Þ
where ln(Ks⁄ K0) is the change in the binding free
energy, [Osm] is the osmolality (moles of solute per kg
of solvent) of the solution, and Dnwis the difference in
the number of bound water molecules between the
complex and the free reactants The change in the
binding affinity upon change in osmolyte concentration
is shown in supplementary Fig S2 As the
concentra-tion of osmolyte increases, the affinity of berberine for
the quadruplex binding site decreases This observation
is consistent with the acquisition of water by the
com-plex relative to the DNA Using Eqn (2), the average
number of exchanged water molecules is found to be
13 ± 2
Molecular modeling studies
Computational methods are widely used to
investi-gate biomolecules and complexes, and have been
shown to be valuable for a deeper understanding of
the structural, dynamic and energetic properties The
mixed hybrid NMR structure of the human telomeric
quadruplex was used for study (supplementary Fig S3) The structure has two external G-quartets that can act individually as binding sites for berber-ine [25] Berberberber-ine was docked against these external G-quartets, and the complexes were simulated in aqueous solution The rmsd values of the heavy atoms of the whole complex (black) and without loop residues (gray) are shown in supplementary Fig S4 The rmsd values of both the MH1 (5¢-end) and MH2 (3¢-end) complexes remain < 3 A˚ The rmsd values for the G-quartet (without loop residues) and berberine are conserved in both cases, and stay at < 1 A˚ during the last 2 ns (inset in supplementary Fig S4) The fluctuations of the loop residues are obvious, as they are not held tightly by hydrogen bonds and hence are free to move during dynamics This observation has also been reported in previous studies on G-quadruplex structures [34,35]
The stacking of berberine over the external G-quartet
is shown in Fig 5 for the models Berberine stacking over the G-quartet plane is aided by the formation of strong p–p aromatic stacking interactions between the berberine scaffold and the G-quartet plane In addition, the positively charged nitrogen atom in berberine positions itself on the axis passing through the center of the G-quartet plane Hence, a strong electrostatic inter-action can be expected between the positively charged nitrogen and the highly electron-rich central area of the G-quartet plane, due to the guanine carbonyl lone pairs The positioning of the nitrogen atom was observed to
be fairly retained in all models during dynamics This suggests that the electrostatic interaction between the negatively charged clouds formed by O6 of guanines and the positively charged nitrogen atom plays an important role in this stabilization
The relative free energy components for the complex formation were estimated by the molecular mechanics Poisson–Bolzmann surface area (MMPBSA) approach The calculations were performed on the basis of the single trajectories of the quadruplex–berberine complexes obtained from the explicit solvent simula-tions The estimates are summarized in supplementary Table S1
Theoretical heat capacity calculation The heat capacity change upon complex formation is
an informative measure that can provide insights into the exchange of water during the process The relations connecting the changes in heat capacity to the burial
of polar and nonpolar solvent-accessible surface area (SASA) during complex formation has been proposed
Trang 6and applied in a number of previous reports [29,36] In
our study, we used the relation proposed by Ren et al
[37], which is given as follows:
DCp¼ 0:382ð 0:026ÞDAnp 0:121ð 0:077ÞDAp ð3Þ
Here, DAnp and DAp represent the changes in SASA for nonpolar and polar groups, respectively A sum-mary of the solvent-accessible areas and DCp values is shown in Table 3 The SASA is reduced upon complex formation, and the majority of the reduction was due
to the burial of nonpolar surface This is reflected
in the negative values of the calculated heat capacity change The calculated values are )89 and )156 calÆmol)1ÆK)1for MH1 and MH2 respectively
Discussion
In order to understand biomolecule–ligand binding in terms of sequence-specific recognition and affinity, it is necessary to complement high-resolution structural data with accurate thermodynamic measurements By using a combination of spectroscopic and ITC tech-niques, we have elucidated a complete thermodynamic profile (DG, DH, DS, Kb, DCpand Dnw) for the binding
of berberine to the telomeric quadruplex UV-visible absorption titration experiments show that the binding
of berberine to G-quadruplexes results in a red shift (10–12 nm) and substantial hypochromicity (34–40%)
in the k341 nmof berberine The red shift in the absorp-tion maxima and the observed hypochromicity of ber-berine in the presence of quadruplex may be interpreted in terms of stacking interactions between the quartet-forming guanine bases and the aromatic groups of berberine Although the observed red shift is intermediate between what is observed for intercalation (> 15 nm) and for outside binding (< 8 nm) [38], the same extent of hypochromicity that is generally seen in the intercalated binding are observed, revealing that berberine interacts with quadruplex through stacking interactions between quartet and berberine, as happens
in case of intercalative binding events Recently, Wei
Table 3 Summary of the changes in SASA in A˚2 and heat capacity changes (DCp) in calÆmol)1ÆK)1calculated for the complex models DAtot
is the change in total accessible surface area, DA np is the change in nonpolar SASA and DA p is the change in polar SASA DC p is calculated using Eqn (3) as described in the text.
A
B
G 20
G 2
G 8
G 16
G 4
G 10
G 14
G
Fig 5 Stacking of berberine on the G-quartet face A-MH1, B-MH2.
The G-quartet is shown as a stick model Berberine is shown as a
ball and stick model.
Trang 7et al [15] have studied the interaction of cationic
porphyrin [5,10,15,20-tetrakis(1-methyl-4-pyridyl)-21H,
23H-porphine] (H2TMPyP4) with three distinct
G-quadruplex DNAs, parallel-stranded (TG4T)4,
dimer-hairpin-folded (G4T4G4)2, and monomer-folded
AG3(T2AG3)3, by UV resonance Raman spectroscopy,
UV-visible absorption spectroscopy, fluorescence
spec-troscopy, and surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy
In their UV-visible absorption titration experiments,
the same extent of red shift (11–13 nm) but larger
hypochromicities (56–62%) were observed, indicating
intercalative (containing the end stacking) binding of
H2TMPyP4to these G-quadruplexes Comparing these
observations with ours, it can be concluded that
berberine binds to quadruplex at external quartets
through stacking interactions between the
quartet-forming guanine bases and the aromatic groups of
berberine The lower red shift and moderate
hypo-chromicity can be accounted for by the partial
inter-calation by end stacking with the quartet The 1 : 1
binding stoichiometry, as estimated from the present
results, limits the interaction to a single binding mode
It was seen that addition of increasing concentrations
of quadruplex results in a gradual increase in the
fluorescence intensity of berberine, indicating the
trans-fer of berberine from an aqueous environment to a
hydrophobic environment This observation rules out
the possibility of outside stacking of berberine, where
quenching of the chromophore fluorescence by solvent
molecules could have been continued In a recent
study, Franceschin et al [25], through molecular
modeling, have shown that piperidino-berberine stacks
on the terminal G-tetrad of the quadruplex
The sigmoidal binding isotherms obtained from ITC
experiments are indicative of the existence of either a
single binding site per quadruplex or a number of
equivalent, but not necessarily independent, binding
sites At all temperatures, the stoichiometry for the
quadruplex–berberine binding was found to be 1 : 1,
confirming the results of our spectroscopic binding
studies The binding enthalpies were found to be
neg-ative with increasing magnitudes upon increase in
temperature Berberine binds to quadruplex at 25C
with a small, negative enthalpy (DH) of )1.7
kcalÆmol)1 and an entropy change with TDS of +6.5
kcalÆmol)1 with an overall favorable free energy (DG)
of)8.2 kcalÆmol)1 The favorable binding of berberine
comes from a combination of enthalpy and entropy
terms that vary with temperature The negative values
of DH and positive values of DS are consistent with
the characteristics of a combination of van der Waals,
hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions in the
binding process The temperature dependence of the
binding affinity was used to calculate the van’t Hoff enthalpy, which did not match the calorimetric enthalpy The obtained van’t Hoff enthalpy was )12 kcalÆmol)1, giving DHvH⁄ DHcal ratios in excess of
1 A large difference between the van’t Hoff and calo-rimetric enthalpies could be due to substantial temper-ature-dependent behavior of associated reactions This might originate from changes in hydrophobic hydra-tion [39], in which release of water molecules from hydrophobic surfaces upon binding results in loss of enthalpy (due to stronger hydrogen bonds of struc-tured water) and gain in entropy, a phenomenon known to be temperature-dependent [40–42] Measure-ment of heat capacity changes (DCp) associated with ligand–macromolecule binding can help to differentiate the nature of hydration changes, i.e hydrophobic ver-sus polar hydration [43] Unlike other thermodynamic parameters, which have contributions from various sources, DCpis believed to arise purely from molecular hydration associated with binding [44] This parameter can thus be utilized to estimate the extent of burial or exposure of polar and nonpolar groups to bulk water upon molecular binding The obtained DCp for the quadruplex–berberine interaction was )94 ± 5 calÆmol)1ÆK)1 In the case of intercalative as well as minor groove binding ligands, it was shown that DCp varies from )100 to )400 calÆmol)1ÆK)1 [29,44] How-ever, the large negative heat capacity change is highly correlated with hydration heat capacity changes that arise from burial of the hydrophobic area As we have observed in our UV binding experiment, berberine binds to quadruplex by stacking on the terminal G-tet-rad of the quadruplex, so burial of the hydrophobic group is not extensive enough to show a sufficiently negative heat capacity change upon interaction The free energy (DGhyd) for the hydrophobic transfer of a ligand from aqueous solution to its macromolecular binding pocket is a function of the DCpfor the binding reaction, and is given by the following relationship [44]:
According to this relationship, negative heat capacity changes result in a large negative (favorable) DGhyd value, which, in turn, shows a significant driving force for complex formation As an illustrative example, the Chaires [37] and Wilson [29,45] groups applied Eqn (3)
to show that the major driving force for the binding of various heterocyclic ligands (e.g Hoechst 33258 and penta-amidine) to the minor groove of duplex DNA stems from the hydrophobic transfer of the ligands from solution to the DNA-binding site
Trang 8Careful inspection of Table 1 clearly shows that the
binding of berberine to the human telomeric
quadru-plex having a small negative value of DH and a large
positive value of TDS is predominantly entropically
driven Recently, Chaires has analyzed the binding
data for 26 DNA–ligand interactions and discussed
distinctive thermodynamic signatures for groove
bind-ing and intercalation [46] Groove-bindbind-ing interactions
are largely entropically driven, whereas intercalation
reactions are driven by large favorable enthalpy
con-tributions and are opposed by entropy In the present
study, the observed low negative enthalpy and high
positive entropy change could constitute further
evi-dence in support of stacking with the terminal quartet
rather than intercalation Rigidifying the DNA ought
to exert an entropic cost, and this is the most likely
explanation for the unfavorable entropy associated
with intercalation [47] In contrast, terminal stacking
in the quadruplex structures should not rigidify the
quadruplex structure, thus reducing the entropic cost
as compared to intercalation The origin of the
favor-able entropic term in the present study is not also
apparent It has been argued that groove binding
shows the favorable entropy because of the release of
water molecules upon complex formation, by
dis-placement of the ‘spine of hydration’ within the
minor groove [48] However, the osmotic stress study
shows that the quadruplex–berberine complex
acquires 13 molecules of water on average per mole
of complex at 25C Similar kinds of observation
have been reported recently by Kiser et al [49], where
uptake of water molecules as well as a positive
entropy change were observed when Hoechst, a
groove binder, bound to oligomeric DNA This
dis-crepancy may be due to the inefficiency of the
osmo-tic stress method in measuring the overall hydration
change, as mentioned by Chaires [46] as well as by
Kiser et al [49]
The simulated structures show that the planar
ber-berine molecule is stacked onto the G-quartet,
posi-tioning the N7 positive charge above the center of the
G-tetrad in the region of high negative charge density
generated by the carbonyl groups to stabilize the
complex via favorable p-stacked interactions between
aromatic residues without significant disruption of
the guanine tetrads The binding enthalpy (DH) for the
quadruplex–berberine complexes originates from the
combination of polar solvation energy and favorable
solute electrostatic, van der Waals and nonpolar
sol-vation energy The conformational entropy for the
complexes arises from the loss of translational and
rotational degrees of freedom The overall free energy
change (DG) for the quadruplex–berberine binding is
found to be more favorable for the MH2 berberine– quadruplex complex (supplementary Table S1) Fur-thermore, the calculated DCp is highly negative and arises due to the loss of nonpolar SASA, whereas the accompanying uptake of water is associated with gain
of polar SASA This is because berberine is nonpolar
in nature, and hence the more nonpolar accessible sur-face gets buried upon interacting with the quadruplex
On the other hand, the positive change in the polar surface area (DAp) confirms that there is exposure of the polar surface on complex formation, further imply-ing the uptake of water molecules within the hydration layer
Conclusion
The single-stranded G-rich telomeric 3¢-overhang at the ends of chromosomes can form unique secondary DNA structures, such as G-quadruplexes, which are known to inhibit telomerase activity and have thus become attractive targets for new anticancer ligands However, a structure-based approach needs to be developed to design a new generation of binding agents that can selectively target such unique second-ary DNA structures Ultimately, a comprehensive understanding of the thermodynamic and structural parameters of quadruplex–ligand complexes would aid
in the design of new quadruplex-selective molecules and help to rationalize their in vivo performance In this study, we have obtained comprehensive data
on the thermodynamic and structural parameters involved in the quadruplex–ligand interaction, using a well-characterized human telomeric quadruplex and
an alkaloid, berberine It has been observed that bind-ing of berberine to the human telomeric quadruplex
is associated with a small, negative enthalpy (DH)
of )1.7 kcalÆmol)1, a favorable free energy (DG)
of )8.2 kcalÆmol)1 and a favorable entropy with TDS value of +6.5 kcalÆmol)1ÆK)1 at 25C A negative heat capacity change was observed when it was calcu-lated using two independent methods experimentally, from the temperature dependence of DH values, and theoretically based on surface area calculations The theoretical value is more negative than the experimen-tal value There was an uptake of 13 water molecules
on average per complex, which provides an unfavor-able contribution to the free energy of the binding Structural studies of the complex obtained from mole-cular dynamic studies reveal that berberine stacks over the G-tetrad, allowing overlap of the p-system of berberine primarily with two bases of each G-tetrad The partial positive charge on the berberine N7 appears to act as a ‘pseudo’ potassium ion, and is
Trang 9positioned above the center of the G-tetrad in the
region of high negative charge density generated by
the carbonyl groups Extension of this study to other
known and well-established ligands, such as porphyrin
and telomestatin, will be reported in due course
Experimental procedures
Berberine chloride was obtained from Sigma and was used
without any further purification The 22-mer
oligonucleo-tide from the telomere end, d(AGGGTTAGGGTTAGG
GTTAGGG), was obtained from Sigma Genosys USA
Concentrations of oligonucleotide solutions were
deter-mined from the absorbance at 260 nm, using the molar
extinction coefficient for the G-rich strand, calculated by
extrapolation of tabulated values of the dimers and
[51] All other reagents were of analytical grade Milli Q
water was used throughout all the experiments All
experiments were performed in 50 mm MES buffer (pH 7.4)
specified
UV-visible and fluorescence spectroscopy
QuadruplexỜberberine binding constants were determined
by UV fluorescence, and Cary 400 (Varian) and
Fluoro-max 4 (Spex) instruments were used for UV and
fluores-cence titration experiments respectively A fixed berberine
concentration was titrated by increasing the quadruplex
concentration in 50 mm MES buffer (pH 7.4) containing
100 mm KCl Data were transformed into a Scatchard plot
ligand for those sites [52] Data were fitted to the McGheeỜ
von Hippel neighbor exclusion model
To determine the affinity of binding between berberine
and quadruplex, fluorescence experiments were carried out
and varying the quadruplex concentration (0Ờ5 lm) For
analysis of data, the observed fluorescence intensity was
considered as the sum of the weighted contributions from
free berberine and berberine bound to quadruplex:
where F is the observed fluorescence intensity at each
fluores-cence intensities of the initial and final states of titration,
observed in the Scatchard plot, it can be shown that:
ơL0a2b đơL0ợ ơQ ợ 1=Kbỡabợ ơQ Ử 0 đ6ỡ
concentration, and [Q] is the added quadruplex concentra-tion
From Eqns (4,5), it can be shown that:
DF Ử đDF max =2ơL0ỡ đơL0ợ ơQ ợ 1=K A ỡ
ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi đơL0ợ ơQ ợ 1=K A ỡ 2 4ơL0ơQ q
đ7ỡ
are the initial and subsequent fluorescence intensities of the berberine at 522 nm, upon quadruplex addition
ITC
ITC measurements were carried out on a VP-ITC titration calorimeter (MicroCal, Northampton, MA, USA) Before loading, the solutions were thoroughly degassed The refer-ence cell was filled with the respective degassed buffer The preformed quadruplex concentration (10 lm) was kept in the sample cell, and berberine (100 lm) in the same buffer was placed in a syringe of volume 300 lL The berberine solution was added sequentially in 10 lL aliquots (for a total of 25 injections, 20 s duration each) at 4 min intervals Sequential titrations were performed to ensure full occu-pancy of the binding sites by loading and titrating with the same ligand without removing the samples from the cell until the titration signal was essentially constant The heats
of dilution were determined in parallel experiments by injecting a berberine solution of the same concentration in the same buffer The respective heat of dilution is sub-tracted from the corresponding binding isotherm prior to curve fitting origin 5.0 software was used to fit the thermodynamic parameters to the heat profiles
Molecular modeling
Literature studies based on NMR data reveal that the 22-mer human telo22-meric sequence assumes multiple intercon-vertible conformations, comprising the parallel, antiparallel and hybrid-type G-quadruplexes, in the presence of potas-sium ions [53] However, no solution structure obtained in the presence of potassium ions is available for the 22-mer human telomeric sequence Furthermore, the telomeric quadruplex adopts a mixed hybrid conformation in the pres-ence of berberine (1 : 1 molar ratio of berberine: telomeric quadruplex), as shown in the CD spectra (supplementary Fig S5) We chose the hybrid-type NMR structure (Protein Data Bank ID 2hy9) [54] of the human telomeric quadru-plex, as shown in supplementary Fig S3 The 2hy9 is a 26-mer mixed-hybrid structure of the human telo26-meric sequence
in the presence of potassium ions The four adenine residues, two from each terminal end, were removed for comparison
Trang 10purposes The initial 3D coordinate for berberine was
extracted from the crystal structure of the transcriptional
receptor QacR from the Protein Data Bank (1jum) [55] The
extracted structure was then optimized, and the partial
electro-static potential calculation in the antechamber module
of amber8 The remaining parameters for berberine were
taken from the GAFF forcefield in amber8 [57] The NMR
structures possess two external G-quartets, shown in
supple-mentary Fig S3, that can independently act as binding sites
for berberine stacking The optimized structure of berberine
was docked against the binding sites by defining the external
G-quartet as the active site using the suflexdock module
in sybyl 7.3 [58] This resulted in two quadruplex–
berberine complex models, referred to as MH1 and MH2
the one with the lowest docking energy was considered as
the starting structure for further simulation experiments
Molecular dynamics
Two potassium ions were manually placed in the central
channel between the G-quartet planes in the complex
mod-els The complex models were simulated using the amber8
[59] suite of programs with the Cornell et al all-atom force
field ff99 [60] The complexes were neutralized with
potas-sium ions, with the two inner ions retained inside The
sys-tems were then immersed in a periodic box of TIP3P water
model, which extended approximately 8 A˚ (in each
direc-tion) from the solute in a truncated octahedron unit cell
[61] Simulations were performed with periodic boundary
conditions, and the particle-mesh Ewald method was used
involving bonds to hydrogen atoms were constrained using
equilibration phase, which was 1 fs The direct-space cutoff
used was 10 A˚ Simulations were performed at a constant
temperature of 300 K The Langevin coupling with a
collision frequency of 1.0 was used for temperature
regula-tion [64] A constant pressure of 1 atm with isotropic
mole-cule-based scaling with a relaxation time of 1 ps was used
The equilibration step involves multiple optimization and
relaxation of the solvent and potassium ions in the bulk
solvent with the solute and the two inner potassium ions
fixed with restraints that include 500, 100, 250, 50, 100, 25,
sys-tem was heated from 0 to 300 K at constant volume, and
this was followed by equilibration for 25 ps at a constant
temperature of 300 K and a pressure of 1 atm The
produc-tion phase was started at this stage and continued for 5 ns
All simulations were performed in an SGI Altix 450 cluster
The conformations in the trajectories were collected at
intervals of 2 ps Trajectory analyses were done using the
SASA calculation
The SASA calculation was done using grasp 1.3 [65] The lowest-energy structure evolved during simulation was used for the SASA calculation of the complexes Surfaces for
defined as nonpolar, and the remaining hydrophilic atoms are defined as polar The grasp radii set was used in the calculation
Thermodynamics calculation
The free energy estimates were performed by the MMPBSA approach, where the total free energy of binding is expressed as the sum of the contributions from the gas phase and solvation energies plus an additional term for the solute entropic contribution This can be expressed in the following equation:
G¼ Egasþ Esolvþ TSsolute ð8Þ
corre-sponds to solute entropic effects The analysis was done for the last 2 ns trajectory of the complexes The snapshots for quadruplex and berberine were extracted from the complex trajectories at intervals of 10 ps This yielded 100 snapshots
in total All counterions (except the two spanning the cen-tral channel of the G-quartet planes) and water molecules were stripped out from the trajectory prior to the thermo-dynamic analysis The gas-phase energies of the solutes were calculated using the Cornell et al force field [60] with
no cutoff Solvation free energies were computed as the sum of polar and nonpolar contributions using a contin-uum solvent representation
The polar contribution was calculated with the pbsa program in amber8 The dielectric constants used for the solute and the surrounding solvent were 1 and 80, respec-tively The Cornell et al radii set was used to define atom-centered spheres for the solute atoms, and a probe radius of 1.4 A˚ was used for the solvent to define the dielectric boundary around the molecular surface A lat-tice spacing of two grid points per A˚ was used, and 1000 finite difference iterations were performed, excluding salt effect The nonpolar solvent contribution was estimated
cal-culation for solute entropic contribution was performed with the nmode module in amber8 The snapshots were minimized in the gas phase using the conjugate gradient method for 5000 steps, using a distance-dependent dielec-tric of 4r (r is the interatomic distance) and with a
gradient The frequencies of the vibrational modes were computed for these minimized structures at 300 K, using normal mode analysis methodology The thermodynamic