Characterization of a high-affinity binding site for the pea albumin 1bFre´de´ric Gressent, Isabelle Rahioui and Yvan Rahbe´ UMR 0203 INRA/INSA de Lyon, BF2I Biologie Fonctionnelle, Inse
Trang 1Characterization of a high-affinity binding site for the pea albumin 1b
Fre´de´ric Gressent, Isabelle Rahioui and Yvan Rahbe´
UMR 0203 INRA/INSA de Lyon, BF2I (Biologie Fonctionnelle, Insectes et Interactions), INSA Baˆtiment Louis Pasteur,
Villeurbanne, France
The toxicity of the pea albumin 1b (PA1b), a 37 amino-acid
peptide extracted from pea seeds, for cereal weevils
(Sito-philus oryzae, Sito(Sito-philus granarius and Sito(Sito-philus zeamais)
was recently discovered.The mechanism of action of this
new entomotoxin is still unknown and potentially involves a
target protein in the insect tissues.This work describes the
characterization of a high-affinity binding site for PA1b in
a microsomal fraction of Sitophilus spp.extracts.Purified
PA1b was labeled to a high specific radioactivity
(c.900 CiÆmmol)1) using125I, and the iodinated ligand was
found to be biologically active.Binding of this ligand to the
microsomal fraction of S oryzae extract was found to be
saturable and reversible, with an affinity (Kd) of 2 6 nM, and
a high maximal binding capacity (Bmax) of 40 pmolÆmg)1of protein.A binding site displaying similar characteristics was detectable in the five susceptible weevils strains tested, as well
as in the pea aphid or in the fruit fly.However, no binding activity was detectable in extracts from four S oryzae strains previously shown to be resistant to the toxin through a recessive monogenic mechanism.Therefore, we suggest that this binding site might be involved in the mechanism
of action of PA1b
Keywords: binding site; pea albumin 1b; Sitophilus; cystine-knot; leginsulin
The cereal weevils (Sitophilus oryzae, Sitophilus granarius
and Sitophilus zeamais) are major pests of stored grains.At
present, the use of chemical insecticides is the main answer
to the damage caused by stored product pests, inducing
ecotoxicity problems and the occurrence of resistance within
insect populations.An alternative for controlling insects is
physical methods, such as cooling or the use of nitrogen or
carbon dioxide atmosphere.However, these methods are
expensive and not always applicable.Plant protection also
takes advantage of the genetic resources residing in crop
plants to create resistant varieties, and of the use of
biological toxins to build up transgenic plants tolerant to
different insect species.The Bacillus thuringiensis toxins [1],
proteins belonging to the lectin family [2], or enzymes
inhibitors [3], are in use or being tested, but to date these
molecules are not adapted to grain protection against
weevils
Therefore, the recent finding of a plant peptide lethal for
these insects has enlarged the possibilities for cereal grain
protection [4].This peptide was purified and sequenced
from Pisumsativumseeds and, being previously known as a
seed albumin [5], it was named PA1b for pea albumin 1b PA1b is the result of the post-translational cleavage of the albumin proprotein PA1, also releasing a second peptide (PA1a).PA1b consists of 37 amino acids, with six cysteines involved in three disulfide bonds which confer the toxin its high stability.Biological activity is conserved when boiled, and the peptide is resistant to digestion by trypsin [6] or by bovine rumen fluid [7]
Although no primary sequence homologies could be found with other proteins in the available databases, it was recently established by NMR studies and molecular modeling that PA1b belongs to the cystine-knot family [8] Characterized only recently as a structural family [9], cystine-knot peptides have now been identified from a variety of sources (plants, fungi, animal venoms, insects), and show very diverse biological activities (elicitor AVR9, trypsin inhibitor, antimicrobial, antiviral or antifungal activities, and many channel blockers [10]).A subfamily of these, the cyclic cystine-knot peptides, also named cyclo-tides, were investigated for their potential as new anti-biotics or anti-HIV properties.PA1b was the first entomotoxic cystine-knot peptide identified (peptidic sequence and disulfide bridges are shown in Fig.1), and the interest of this structural family for insect targets was reinforced by identifying the cyclotide kalata B1 as a peptide active on larval growth of the Lepidoptera Helicoverpa punctigera [11].Moreover, PA1b might belong to a multigenic family, as at least five isoforms
of the peptide exist in a single pea genotype and it seems
to be widespread in legumes [4,5]
Many cystine-knot peptides have inhibitory effects, against channels, proteases, or a-amylase [10].However,
to date, in vitro assays using PA1b failed to reveal any
Correspondence to F.Gressent, UMR 0203 INRA/INSA de Lyon,
BF2I (Biologie Fonctionnelle, Insectes et Interactions), INSA
Baˆtiment Louis Pasteur, 69621 Villeurbanne Cedex, France.
Fax: + 33 4 72438534, Tel.:+ 33 4 72437982,
E-mail: gressent@jouy.inra.fr
Abbreviations: PA1b, pea albumin 1b; BBI, soybean Bowman–Birk
inhibitor; E-64, trans-epoxysuccinyl- L
-leucylamido(4-guanidino)-butane.
(Received 21 February 2003, revised 24 March 2003,
accepted 8 April 2003)
Trang 2enzyme inhibitory effect [4].Therefore, the aim of the
present work was to investigate the mode of action of the
toxin, as part of a wider study to determine whether PA1b
could be a valuable tool for insect control.An important
point is to understand the molecular mechanisms of the
sensitivity to the toxin, since resistant strains do exist
naturally: the screening of up to 90 Sitophilus spp.strains for
the susceptibility to PA1b has revealed that three strains, all
belonging to the S oryzae species, contained individuals
able to feed on pea seeds [12] and resistant to the purified
toxin.Other pest insects (the pea aphid Acyrthosiphon pisum
and the flour moth Ephestia kuehniella) were found to be
susceptible to the toxin, but the fruit fly Drosophila
melano-gasterwas shown to be resistant [4].Within the S oryzae
species, a genetic analysis of the resistance demonstrated
that this trait was driven by a single recessive autosomal
gene [12].This result suggested that a single weevil gene
product could be responsible for the susceptibility or
resistance towards the toxin.On this basis, the mechanism
of action of the peptide was likely to involve a discrete
molecular target at the insect side.Therefore our work
focused on the characterization of a PA1b binding site in
Sitophilusspp.extracts, using a125I labeled 3741 Da isoform
of the toxin (peptide sequence in Fig.1 [4]).Given the
biological features presented here, this binding site could
potentially be regarded as the molecular target of the PA1b
toxicity in weevils
Experimental procedures
Biological material
Cereal weevils (S oryzae, zeamais and granarius,
Coleoptera, Curculionidae) were reared on wheat seeds at
27.5C 70% relative humidity.Nine strains were used,
differing in their genetic ability to thrive on pea seeds and
resist the toxic activity of pea albumin PA1b: five susceptible
strains S oryzae WAA42, Benin, and Bouriz, S zeamais
LS, and S granarius Brayard and four fully resistant
S oryzaestrains ISOR3, Mex1, China and GV harboring
a recessive pea-resistance allele [12].The fruit fly D
mel-anogaster(Diptera) larvae were provided by R Allemand
(UMR 5558 CNRS-UCBL, Lyon, France)
Tests of toxicity
The toxicity assays for PA1b or modified PA1b were
performed on the S oryzae susceptible strain WAA42 and
on its partially isogenic resistant strain ISOR3 (three
backcross of a resistant China genotype over the
suscepti-ble WAA42 genotype), according to the protocol described
by Delobel et al.[4].Briefly, in all described experiments,
30 insects were fed with the toxin to be assayed (100 lgÆg)1
of food), and mortality was then monitored daily up to
14 days after the beginning of the treatment
Isolation of membranes All the operations were performed at 4C.Insects (0.5–1 g) were ground with a mortar and pestle in liquid nitrogen The resulting powder was resuspended in 10–20 mL of extraction buffer (20 mM Tris/HCl pH 8; 0.25M sucrose;
2 mMMgCl2; 10 lME-64), and extracted six times for 5 s using an UltraTurrax blender.The slurry was centrifuged for 10 min at 3000 g.The supernatant was further centri-fuged to give a second pellet at 10 000 g (10 min) and a third one at 45 000 g for 45 min (microsomal fraction).The resulting fractions, sedimenting at 3000, 10 000 or 45 000 g, were resuspended in binding buffer (20 mM Tris buffer
pH 7.0 containing 10 lM E-64) with 30% glycerol and stored at)80 C until use
Purification of the toxin One batch of purified toxin isoform, showing a molecular mass of 3741 Da by mass spectrometry, and a pea albumin extract (named SRA1) were provided by J.Gueguen and E.Ferrasson (Laboratoire de Biochimie et Technologie des Prote´ines, Nantes, France).From SRA1, a mixture of PA1b isoforms was obtained by a 45-min incubation at)20 C in acetone/water (80 : 20) followed by a 10-min centrifugation
at 12 000 g.The supernatant was dried under vacuum, and more than 95% of the resulting powder consisted of a mixture of PA1b isoforms (as checked by HPLC analysis) PA1b or modified PA1b were purified or analyzed by reverse phase C18HPLC column eluted at 1 mLÆmin)1with
a gradient of water; trifluoroacetic acid 0.1%/acetonitrile; trifluoroacetic acid 0.1% (80 : 20 for 2 min, then to 40 : 60
in 20 min).PA1b peptide isoforms were detected by their absorbance at 210 nm (DAD 440, KONTRON, France), quantified by the measurement of the peak area and referred
to known quantities of pure peptides used as standards Labeling of the toxin
The labeling was carried out in 37 lL of 400 mMTris/HCl buffer pH 7.5, 60% methanol with 1.66 lg of the purified
3741 Da PA1b and 1 mCi of carrier free Na125I (Amer-sham).Chloramine-T (1.2 lg) in 3 lL of 50 mMTris/HCl buffer pH 7.5, 60% methanol was added at t¼ 0, 1, 2, and
3 min.After 10 min of incubation the reaction was stopped
by adding 10 lg of tyrosine in 140 lL of water The radiolabeled peptide was separated from non-incorporated iodine by reverse-phase HPLC.In these conditions, incor-poration of iodine ranged from 40 to 50%, and the specific radioactivity of the125I-labelled PA1b ligand on labeling day ranged from 890 to 1120 CiÆmmol)1.The labeled toxin was stored in 60% methanol at)20 C and used within a month after labeling
For iodination of the peptide using nonlabeled iodine, the protocol was as described above, except that 200 lg of the
3741 Da isoform, 0.3 mg of nonlabeled NaI and four times
50 lg of chloramine-T were used in a 100-lL volume Reduction and alkylation of the toxin
Reduction of the 3741 Da toxin (2 mgÆmL)1) was carried out in Tris/HCl buffer (pH 8, 0.1 ) in the presence of
Fig 1 Peptide sequence [4] and disulfide bridges [8] of the 3741 Da
PA1b isoform.
Trang 320 mMdithiothreitol.The mixture was boiled for 10 min,
allowing a complete reduction of the peptide.After cooling
at room temperature, one volume of 0.2Miodoacetamide
was added and the mixture was incubated in the dark for
1 h.Alkylation of the cysteine residues was quantitative,
and the alkylated peptide was then purified by reverse-phase
HPLC
Binding assays
Microsomal proteins (1–3 lg) were incubated in the
pres-ence of 0.4 nM125I-labelled PA1b in binding buffer
supple-mented with 0.2% CHAPS in a total volume of 204 lL.The
nonspecific binding component was determined in the
presence of 1 lMnonlabeled mixture of the PA1b isoforms
Incubations were performed for 2 h at room temperature in
96-well microtiter plates, then assays were transferred onto
MultiScreen filter plates containing GF/B filters and
vacuum drained using the MultiScreen system (Millipore,
USA).Filters were washed with 200 lL of cold washing
buffer (10 mMTris/HCl buffer pH 7, methanol 60%) and
transferred on gamma counter tubes.The radioactivity was
counted on a gamma counter (Riastar, Packard Instrument,
USA), and each point was the mean of triplicates.Binding
data were analyzed using the RADLIG 4 software
(BIO-SOFT, Cambridge, UK), and plots were drawn using the
ORIGIN 5 software (Microcal, USA)
Protein determination
Protein content was measured by the bicinchoninic acid
procedure developed by PIERCE (Rockford, USA) with
bovine serum albumin as reference
Results
The iodinated toxin displays a high specific
radioactivity and is biologically active
The 3741 Da isoform of PA1b contains a single tyrosine
residue in position 31.Assays of iodination were performed
using IodoBeads and chloramine-T.The yield of 125I
incorporated on the toxin was rather low (less than 5%)
with IodoBeads, while a 40–50% incorporation was
achieved using chloramine-T.The need for a high specific
radioactivity for binding studies, and the fact that native
PA1b and labeled PA1b cannot be separated by HPLC, led
us to use stoichiometric amount of toxin and iodine.Under
these conditions, the specific radioactivity of the125I-labelled
PA1b, calculated by the ratio of the radioactivity measured
by gamma counting and the amount of peptide evaluated by
absorbance at 210 nm during HPLC analysis, was about
942 CiÆmmol)1.This value is similar to the theoretical value
of 890 CiÆmmol)1 for a 40%125I incorporation (40% of
the 2220 CiÆmmol)1 125I initial activity)
We next analyzed by HPLC the stability of the
radio-ligand.When stored at )20 C in 60% methanol, the
125I-labelled PA1b showed a moderate but significant
radiolysis, since about 25% of the toxin was degraded after
one month, and less than 20% of radioligand remained
intact after 6 months.Then, the radioligand was used only
during the month following its labeling
The biological activity of the iodinated peptide was verified.For this purpose, a nonradioactive iodinated ligand was synthesized as described in the Experimental procedures section.The mass spectrometry analysis of the product revealed that more than 95% of the peptide incorporated two127I atoms.Toxicity assays on S oryzae showed that the mortality on susceptible strains WAA42 was similar to that of the control (100 lg of native 3741 Da peptide) for comparable toxin amounts, and that the resistant strain ISOR3 was not affected (data not shown)
125 I-Labelled PA1b binds specifically to a proteinaceous component of aS oryzae extract
The results presented in Table 1 show that the three subfractions obtained by differential centrifugation of a crude extract of S oryzae strain WAA42 (susceptible strain) were able to bind specifically the125I-labelled PA1b ligand The specific binding activity was the highest in the 45 000 g fraction (microsomal fraction), which presented an enrich-ment of threefold on a protein basis.However, in terms of total activities, the binding was found with similar values in the 10 000 and 45 000 g fractions.The nonspecific binding component was about 20% of the total binding activity in all three fractions.The specific binding value increases with the increase of microsomal proteins, until it reaches a plateau for 25–30% of the radioligand bound (about 10–15 lg of microsomal proteins, Fig.2).The microsomal
Table 1 Binding activities of 1.1 n M125I-labelled PA1b to particulate fractions prepared by differential centrifugation of S oryzae WAA42 extracts (5 lg of proteins).
Particulate fraction
3000 g 10 000 g 45 000 g Total protein (mg) 18.1 12.4 6.9 Total binding activity (c.p.m · 10 6 ) 24.5 45.2 49.9 Non-specific binding activity
(% of total binding)
22.3 18.9 18.3 Specific binding activity
(c.p.m.Ælg protein)1)
1355 3643 7243
Fig 2 Dose dependence of 125 I-labelled PA1b specific binding to microsomal proteins from S oryzae extract Different amounts (0.8–
30 lg) of proteins of the microsomal fraction of S oryzae extract were incubated in the presence of 0.4 n 125 I-labelled PA1b.
Trang 4fraction of S oryzae WAA42 was then used for further
characterization, with 1–3 lg of protein loaded per assay,
in order to work in the linear part of the curve
The proteinaceous origin of the binding activity was
determined by its sensitivity to proteinase K and to
heat-denaturation.The results reported in Table 2 show that the
binding activity decreased strongly in the presence of
proteinase K, which in control experiments displayed no
activity towards the peptide ligand itself in the conditions of
the binding experiment (data not shown).Adding an
antiprotease cocktail (leupeptin, phenylmethanesulfonyl
fluoride and E-64), or heat-denaturing of the proteinase K
before the incubation with microsomal fraction proteins,
totally prevented the loss of binding activity.Furthermore,
the microsomal fraction proteins were incubated 15 min in
binding buffer at temperatures ranging from 20 to 70C
before performing the binding experiment.The results show
that the binding activity began to decrease when proteins
were preincubated at 40C and was practically
undetect-able at 60C (respectively 95 and 7% as compared to the
control, data not shown)
The binding of theS oryzae microsomal fraction
to125I-labelled PA1b is reversible, saturable,
and displays a high affinity
Binding of the125I-labelled PA1b to the microsomal fraction
proceeded in a time-dependent manner and an apparent
equilibrium was reached after a 90-min incubation at room
temperature.Addition of excess unlabeled ligand after
equilibrium had been reached led to the loss of specifically
bound radioligand, and this displacement was complete
within 60 min (Fig.3).The rate constants for association
(kon) was 2.03· 105
M )1Æs)1, and for dissociation (koff) was 8.77· 10)4s)1.The calculated equilibrium dissociation
constant (Kd¼ koff/kon) was then of about 4.3 nM
A saturation experiment, using a freshly synthesized125
I-labelled PA1b, was performed with labeled ligand ranging
from 0.35 to 3.2 nM.The saturation plot showed that the
specific binding was saturable, and the deduced Scatchard
plot revealed a Kd of 2.6 nM and a maximal binding
capacity (Bmax) of 36 pmol per mg of microsomal protein
(Fig.4).The Hill number was 0.98, suggesting the presence
of a single class of binding site.Moreover, a competition
experiment using the homologous nonradioactive 127I2 -labelled PA1b as competitor confirmed the results obtained
by the saturation experiment on the 45 000 g fraction (Ki¼ 2.8 nM, Bmax¼ 39 pmol per mg of protein)
A single PA1b binding site is detectable in membrane fractions of theS oryzae extract, and is specific for the native peptide
Competition experiments were performed on the three subfractions of S oryzae extracts using the 3741 Da PA1b
as the competitor.The results showed that the native peptide displayed the same affinity as the iodinated toxin on the 45 000 g fraction (Ki¼ 2.2 nM; Bmax¼ 40 pmolÆmg of protein).Similar affinities were found on the 3000 and
10 000 g fractions with lower Bmax(a single class of binding site displaying Ki of 2 and 3.5 nM, and Bmax of 7.4 and 15.6 pmol per mg of protein, respectively, data not shown)
Fig 4 Saturation plot and deduced Scatchard plot (inset) of the binding
of 125 I-labelled PA1b to the microsomal fraction of S oryzae extract Experiments were performed using 1 lg of proteins and increasing concentrations of 125 I-labelled PA1b (0.35–3.2 n M ).
Table 2 Effect of proteinase K on the 125I-labelled PA1b binding
activity on the microsomal fraction of S oryzae WAA42 extract.
Treatmenta Binding activity (%)
Proteinase K (0.2 lg) 24
Proteinase K (2 lg) 7
Denaturated proteinase K (0.2 lg)c 107
Proteinase K (0.2 lg) + antiproteases d 104
a
Microsomal fraction aliquots (2 lg of proteins) were incubated
with effectors for 10 min at 37 C before measuring the binding
activity using 0.4 n M of 125 I-labelled PA1b b Incubation in binding
buffer without antiproteases only c Protease was denaturated by
boiling for 10 min.dPhenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride (1 m M ) , 4 l M
leupeptin, and 10 l M E-64.
Fig 3 Association and dissociation kinetics of 125 I-labelled PA1b to the microsomal fraction of S oryzae extract Binding experiments were performed using 2 lg of proteins and 0 4 n M125I-labelled PA1b.Solid squares (j) and circles (d) indicate total binding and non-specific binding during association, respectively, whereas triangles (.) indicate total binding during dissociation.The dissociation process was initi-ated by the addition of 1 l M nonlabeled 3741 Da PA1b (arrow).
Trang 5Next, the selectivity of the binding site was examined by
competition experiments as well: the results showed that
neither a 7-kDa peptide (a Bowman–Birk serine protease
inhibitor), nor the bovine insulin used as competitors were
able to compete with the 125I-labelled PA1b.Moreover,
when the 3741 Da PA1b was reduced and the cysteine
residues alkylated, the modified peptide completely lost its
binding activity.Biological tests performed on S oryzae
showed that the alkylated peptide was not toxic for the
susceptible or resistant weevil strains (data not shown)
The binding activity correlates with the susceptibility
or resistance of theSitophilus spp strains
The specific binding activity of the microsomal fraction of
different weevil strains, of the pea aphid A pisum and of the
fruit fly D melanogaster was determined.Figure 5 shows
that the five susceptible weevil strains tested (S oryzae
WAA42, Be´nin and Bouriz, S granarius Brayard and
S zeamais LS) displayed a high specific binding activity,
between 1700 and 2200 c.p.m per lg of protein By
contrast, no binding activity could be detected when
incubating the 125I-labelled PA1b with the microsomal
fraction proteins of extracts of the four strains of S oryzae
resistant to the toxin (China, Mex1, ISOR3 and GV), even
when increasing 25-fold the amount of microsomal proteins
The pea aphid (susceptible to the toxin) was able to bind the
125I-labelled PA1b, to a lesser extent than the susceptible
weevil strains.Surprisingly, the microsomal fraction of an
extract of the resistant insect D melanogaster also displayed
a strong binding capacity
The determination of the characteristics of the binding
site of these different strains or species is presented in
Table 3.The binding activities of extracts from the five
weevil strains of the three species showed very similar
affinities (Ki between 2 and 9 nM) and maximal binding
capacities (Bmaxbetween 33 and 40 pmol per mg of protein) The D melanogaster, but principally the A pisum micro-somal fractions displayed lower affinities (Ki¼ 16 and
58 nM, respectively), but similar Bmax (40 pmol per mg protein) compared to the values obtained on weevil extracts
The radioligand is stable in the presence
of the microsomal fraction ofSitophilus extract
In order to determine the fate of the labeled toxin during the binding test, the125I-labelled PA1b ligand was incubated for
5 h with 5 lg of proteins of the microsomal fraction from
S oryzae WAA42 (susceptible strain) or from S oryzae ISOR3 (resistant strain) in the conditions used for binding experiments.Following incubation, the radioactivity was dissociated from the binding site and recovered at more than 98% by a 60% methanol extraction.The HPLC analysis of this fraction revealed a single radioactive peak at
a retention time corresponding to PA1b (data not shown) Thus, the radioligand was not degraded during incubation with extracts from either the susceptible or the resistant strain
Discussion
The recent finding of the insecticidal properties of the PA1b peptide(s) [4] has opened new possibilities for cereal grain protection against weevils.However, the occurrence
of naturally resistant strains of S oryzae is an important problem, and could limit the usefulness of this peptide for plant protection.Although the mechanism of action of the toxin is still totally unknown, genetical analysis of the resistance within the S oryzae species, implicating a single recessive gene [12], suggested that the toxicity might involve
a specific receptor on the insect side.On this basis, the search for a PA1b binding protein may be the first step towards the cloning of a potential receptor in susceptible insects
In this work, we characterized the binding of PA1b to a proteinaceous component of a particulate fraction of
S oryzaeextracts.The binding was saturable and reversible, and the binding site exhibits a high affinity for the native
3741 Da toxin (Kd¼ 2.4 nM), an affinity compatible with a role in the toxicity mechanism.Furthermore, the binding site showed an unusually high maximal binding capacity (B ¼ 40 pmol per mg of proteins, assuming that the
Table 3 Affinities (K i ) and maximal binding capacity (B max ) of PA1b on different species and strains of insects measured by competitive inhibition
of the 125 I-labelled PA1b binding.
Insects species and strains
K i ± SEM (n M )
B max (pmolÆmg protein)
S oryzae WAA42 2.6 ± 0.3 40
S oryzae Be´nin 6 ± 1.8 39
S oryzae Bouriz 4.5 ± 0.72 33
S granarius Brayard 6.3 ± 1.6 40
S zeamais LS 9 ± 1.6 34
A pisum 58 ± 10 40
D melanogaster 16 ± 3.3 40
Fig 5 Specific binding of the 125 I-labelled PA1b ligand on the
micro-somal fraction extracts from different insect species or strains Bars
indicate specific binding of the 125 I-labelled PA1b (0.4 n M ) (± SEM)
to 2 lg proteins from the microsomal fraction of S oryzae strain
WAA42 (1), Be´nin (2), Bouriz (3), GV (4), Mex1 (6), ISOR3 (8) and
China (10), S zeamais LS (12), S granarius Brayard (13), A pisum
(14) and D melanogaster (15).Bars labeled 5, 7, 9 and 11 correspond to
specific binding displayed by 50 lg of microsomal proteins extracted
from the resistant S oryzae strains GV, Mex1, ISOR3 and China,
respectively.
Trang 6binding implicated only one toxin molecule per binding
site).PA1b seems to bind to a single protein, as only one
binding site is detectable in the microsomal fraction, and the
binding activity in the 3000 and 10 000 g fractions is
probably due to the same protein as the binding in the three
subfractions displayed the same characteristics.In terms of
ligand specificity, we presently do not have available site
directed mutants of the toxin, and a single isoform was
purified from pea seeds to homogeneity, thus restricting the
possibilities to identify the PA1b amino acids involved in
ligand recognition.However, the fact that the iodinated
ligand is still biologically active and displays an affinity
comparable with the affinity of the native peptide indicates
that the tyrosine residue is probably not implicated in ligand
binding.On the contrary, the reduced, alkylated peptide
looses its binding capacity, as its activity on weevils,
suggesting that the tertiary structure of PA1b is critical
This is not surprising, as this is a common feature of many
biologically active sulfur-rich peptides.This result, together
with the absence of recognition of a BBI peptide or the
bovine insulin, confirms that the binding site is probably
highly specific for the PA1b tertiary structure.It was
suggested that PA1b could have a low sequence similarity
with the BBI peptide [5], and Watanabe et al.[13] showed
that the soybean homologue of PA1b (named leginsulin in
this paper) is able to compete with bovine insulin for
binding to a soybean globulin exhibiting functional
simi-larity to the rat insulin receptor.In our case, neither bovine
insulin nor BBI were able to displace PA1b from its binding
site, suggesting that the potential binding capacity of PA1b
to an insulin binding protein, or a putative similarity with
BBI, were not implicated in the toxicity mechanism in
weevils
Within the Sitophilus genus, the presence of the binding
activity fully correlates with the susceptibility to the toxin
All susceptible strains of the three species display similar
affinities, whereas no binding activity could be detected in
the four S oryzae resistant strains, including ISOR3, a
three generation backcross isoline to WAA42 [12].This
result strongly suggests that the high-affinity binding site
is the molecular target of the peptide in Sitophilus, and
that it may play a major role in the toxicity process.As
the labeled ligand was not degraded during the binding
experiment, the absence of binding activity on the
resistant strains demonstrates that the resistance
mechan-ism within the Sitophilus genus involves either a
modifi-cation or the absence of the molecular target.Indeed, the
absence of binding in resistant strains could be due to
the absence of the target protein, or to a mutation within
the site of the binding to PA1b.Actually, target mutation
resistance is widely used by insects to resist a wide range
of toxins, and was reported for different insecticide
targets, as for the GABA receptor, the sodium channels
or the acetylcholinesterases [14]
The presence and density of the binding site in all insect
species tested, and among three insect orders (e.g
Coleoptera, Diptera and Hemiptera) suggests that this
protein is widely represented and conserved in insects, and
that PA1b could share a similar mechanism of action in
all susceptible species.However, the presence of the
binding site in the resistant species D melanogaster, with
characteristics roughly similar to those of the Sitophilus
susceptible strains, suggests that a different mechanism of insensitivity exists in this species.This mechanism seems not to implicate the binding site, and could take place either upstream or downstream of the perception step.We could for example speculate that certain insects are able to enzymatically degrade the peptide in a nonactive form, which is one reported way of resistance of insects against
Bt toxins [15], and proteinase inhibitors [16], or that a protein in a putative signal transduction cascade may differ in Drosophila.Also, the possibility that the PA1b target may be very common in insects will require further biological assays to test side-effects of a PA1b-based biocontrol strategy, in particular on useful insects (e.g ladybird beetle, trichogramma, bee)
In conclusion, this work allowed the first in vitro biochemical characterization of a high-affinity binding site for the product of a plant resistance gene in insects, with binding characteristics fully correlated to the genetical analysis [12], and thus falling in the gene for gene paradigm The occurrence of the binding site in different susceptible insect species indicated that this binding site is probably the molecular target of the toxin, and that resistance within the
S oryzae species potentially involves a variation in this protein.However, the role of the binding protein in insects, and therefore the overall molecular mechanism of toxicity is still unknown.To date, the cystine-knot peptides comprised mainly ion channel blockers and enzyme inhibitors.How-ever, ion channel effectors were only found in animal venoms, with the exception of a unique sulfur-rich plant peptide (the CSab-type c-zeathionin) which has been found recently to be a Na+channel blocker [17].However, all cystine-knot plant peptides with known targets at the present time are enzyme inhibitors (including for example trypsin, a-amylase and carboxypeptidase) [18].PA1b is of plant source, but all inhibitory assays conducted until now has failed to detect any effect on enzymatic activities, including papain, trypsin and chymotrypsin-like activities [4].Although PA1b could have some low similarity with BBI peptides, the absence of consensus residues in the active site results in probable lack of any antiprotease activity [5] Then, the purification of the binding site, and the cloning of the corresponding gene in susceptible and resistant strains will probably help to answer these questions, and will provide us with the molecular tools to monitor the outburst
of resistant populations, and eventually to engineer a pea-related toxin into a peptide active on both resistant and susceptible weevils
Acknowledgements
We thank Francesca Cardinale for carefully reviewing this manuscript.
We thank J.Gueguen and E.Ferrasson for providing us the 3741 Da toxin isoform and the PA1b isoform mixture.
References
1 Schnepf, E., Crickmore, N., Van Rie, J., Lereclus, D., Baum, J., Feitelson, J., Zeigler, D.R & Dean, D.H (1998) Bacillus thur-ingiensis and its pesticidal crystal proteins Microbiol Mol Biol Rev 62, 775–806.
2 Peumans, W.J & Vandamme, E.J.M (1995) Lectins as plant defense proteins Plant Physiol 109, 347–352.
Trang 73 Gatehouse, A.M.R & Gatehouse, J.A (1998) Identifying proteins
with insecticidal activity: use of encoding genes to produce
insect-resistant transgenic crops Pestic Sci 52, 165–175.
4 Delobel, B., Grenier, A., Gueguen, J., Ferrasson, E & Mbailao,
M.(1998) Utilisation D’un Polypeptide De´rive´ D’une Albumine
PA1b de Le´gumineuse Comme Insecticide.French Patent 98
05877.
5 Higgins, T.J.V., Chandler, P.M., Randall, P.J., Spencer, D.,
Beach, L R , Blagrove, R J , Kortt, A A & Inglis, A S.
(1986) Gene structure, protein structure and regulation of the
synthesis of a sulfur-rich protein in pea seeds J Biol Chem 261,
11124–11130.
6 Hancock, K.R., Ealing, P.M & White, D.W (1994) Identification
of sulfur-rich proteins which resist rumen degradation and
are hydrolysed rapidly by intestinal proteases Br J Nutr 72,
855–863.
7 Spencer, D., Higgins, T.J.V., Freer, M., Dove, H & Coombe, J.B.
(1988) Monitoring the fate of dietary proteins in rumen fluid using
gel electrophoresis Br J Nutr 60, 241–247.
8 Jouvensal, L., Louis, S., Quillien, L., Gue´guen, J , Rahbe´, Y &
Vovelle, F.(2002) PA1b, an insecticidal peptide extracted from the
seed of the pea Pisumsativum: 1H )2D-NMR study and molecular
modelling.In Proceedings of the XXth International Conference
on Magnetic Resonance in Biological Systems, p.232.Toronto,
Canada.
9.McDonald, N Q.& Hendrickson, W A.(1993) A structural
superfamily of growth factors containing a cystine-knot motif.
Cell 73, 421–424.
10 Craik, D.J., Daly, N.L & Waine, C (2001) The cystine knot motif
in toxins and implications for drug design Toxicon 39, 43–60.
11 Jennings, C , West, J , Waine, C , Craik, D & Anderson, M (2001) Biosynthesis and insecticidal properties of plant cyclotides: the cyclic knotted proteins from Oldenlandia affinis Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98, 10614–10619.
12 Grenier, A.M., Mbauguinam, M.& Delobel, B.(1997) Genetical analysis of the ability of the rice weevil Sitophilus oryzae (Coleoptera, Curculionidae) to breed on split peas Heredity 79, 15–23.
13 Watanabe, Y., Barbashov, S.F., Komatsu, S., Hemmings, A.M., Miyagi, M., Tsunasawa, S & Hirano, H (1994) A peptide that stimulates phosphorylation of the plant insulin-binding protein Eur J Biochem 224, 167–172.
14 Hemingway, J.& Ranson, H.(2000) Insecticide resistance in insect vectors of human disease Annu Rev Entomol 45, 371–391.
15 Keller, M , Sneh, B , Strizhov, N , Prudovsky, E , Regev, A , Koncz, C , Schell, J.& Zilberstein, A.(1996) Digestion of d-endotoxins by gut proteases may explain reduced sensitivity of advanced instar larvae of Spodoptera littoralis to CryIC Insect Biochem Mol Biol 26, 365–373.
16.Girard, C , Le Me´tayer, M., Bonade´-Bottino, M., Pham-Dele`gue, M.H.& Jouanin, L.(1998) High level of resistance to proteinase inhibitors may be conferred by proteolytic cleavage in beetle larvae Insect Biochem Mol Biol 28, 229–237.
17 Kushmerick, C , de Sousa Castro, M , Santos Cruz, J , Bloch, C Jr
& Beirao, P.S.L (1998) Functional and structural features of c-zeathionins, a new class of sodium channel blockers FEBS Lett.
440, 302–306.
18 Norton, R.S & Pallaghy, P.K (1998) The cystine-knot struc-ture of ion channel toxins and related polypeptides Toxicon 11, 1573–1583.