Doctoral thesis on economics solutions to improve the care quality of the vietnamese elderly

MINITRY OF EDUCATION AND TRAINING NATIONAL ECONOMIC UNIVERSITY PHẠM VŨ HOÀNG PHAM VU HOANG Human Administration Ergonomics 62340404 DOCTORAL THESIS ON ECONOMICS Hanoi, 2013... THE THE

MINITRY OF EDUCATION AND TRAINING NATIONAL ECONOMIC UNIVERSITY

PHẠM VŨ HOÀNG PHAM VU HOANG

Human Administration (Ergonomics)

62340404

DOCTORAL THESIS ON ECONOMICS

Hanoi, 2013

THE THESIS HAS BEEN DONE IN THE

NATIONAL ECONOMIC UNIVERSITY

1 Assoc Prof, PhD Tran Xuan Cau

2 PhD Nguyen Ba Thuy

Assoc Prof, PhD Mai Quoc Chanh

PhD Bui Sy Loi Assoc Prof, PhD Mac Van Tien

The thesis will be presented under the assessment of the Council for

thesis evaluation at university level

Meeting at the National Economics University

At day months in 2013

The thesis is available at:

National Library Library of the National Economics University

LIST OF RESEARCH PROJECTS MADE PUBLIC

BY THE AUTHOR

! " # $" ! %& %''(&

'2%'

INTRODUCTION

1 The Rationale

4 " " * + ! *" " " " 556 " ! )

" !! " +! *"! " ! * *" " * ! * * *" "! *$ !" * *"

" " " ! * ! * ! ! "" " " " ! " *$ +

++ " * > " " ++ " " * ) * " ! !? + ! "

" * A *" " ) ! ) " " ! " ! *" + " " !

$ $ * " ! " ! * ! " ! "* ! * ! ** ** * " ! * " " *

*$ ! " & " " ! * "* " " * * " * " $! " !

2.The research purpose

3 The approaches and hypothesis

* " " - ! * )B "* " $ * " &" $! " +

& ! " *? + " " * ! * " ! *"

%& > " " " " !! " " ! A " + " " *

! * *" " ! "

4 Object and scope of research

*"

* " * " %'%'

5 Methods of study

" " *" * * * " " * * ** ** "* $ ! * # * " "

6 Overview

6" * " " 9'* + " 55 " ! " " " ! $ $ " ! * !

* $ "" " " ) " * " ! " ! D " * , !*" "

"

7 The scientific contributions of the Thesis New academic and theoretical contributions

- 3

" H $ " ) " " * $$ !"

! A ! * " " * " + ! ! + " *" " "

! + " ! $ $ J %&# ! ! * ! *J -& "! " ! + * D J 3&

* *" ) " + * * ! " * *" J 9& ! " ' ! " ! ! $! $ *

New proposals from research results

H > " * * ! " * *" * + * * $$ !" $ !" + "

"! ) " * + ! " D * " " * ? " *"! "

" " " + " *" ! D + " * ! * $!

8 Conclusion

*" + ! + ! " " * * * - $" !*F

Chapter 1 RATIONALE AND THE QUALITY OF CARE FOR THE

ELDERLY

* * * !

! " + "* " ! ! * * " $ $ " *"! " ! " ! "

1.1.2 Characteristics of the elderly

"#"#$#"# % &' ( ( ' ' ! ! ) ( '

" ! " + " ! $ $ " " " ! ! $* " + *" ! " ) !

"#"#$#$# ( ' ' ! ! '%! ) ( (

"#"#$#*# ( ' ' ! ! ) ( ' ! + %

9 1

% # E< ,GE < < <E L

1.2.2 Care for the elderly

, + ! " ! " $$ ** " * + +

" !! " " *

Diagram 1.1.Maslow needs pyramid

""$F22 ) * **) * 2 * "

1.2.2 Contents, resources and forms of care for the elderly

Contents of care: & " ! + ! " ! " ) $ * "

" ! * + ! * ! " $$! $! " B )*J -& $ ! " !

"! ) " " " + " " " ! ++ ! " ;$ ! *

Resources of care for the elderly: 6 "! * " ! "

" " $ ) * ! * " !

! " * " !

Diagram 1.3 Resources of care for the elderly

Form of care for the elderly:

! " * " J

" !

Table 1.3 Model of care Resources

Content

"

.

" /

" !

" ! !

! F " !=* ! * !

"!

# E< ,GE < < <E L <G <

1.3.1 The quality of care for the elderly people

! " *

" " *

" ! 2 NG*

!? "2

! "

* " !

Model

of care

( 7

" + " !

1.3.2 Standards to assess the care quality for the elderly people

# !! " " * " * *" + ! " ! " ** ** " A " +

& " + " ! " ! ** ** " " ! A "

" ! + ! " $ $

%& " + ! " ! + ! ** ** " A " + " ! + ! + ! " !

$ ! " + + " !

% ' , #

"#*#*#" % ' , % ) ' - ) ' ( '

! A " $! " *" * " " "! " " ! *" * )

"!

"#*#*#$ ( !! % ' , ( ' /! ' -.

" " + * " * " $! " A " + ! + ! " !

<G <

* *" ) " + * * ! " * *"

) + "* # ) ) " * $$ !" " " * D " + " " " *

" ! *"* + " ! $ $

< 6< < < < <E L <G <

2.1.1 The demographic characteristics of the Vietnamese elderly

" " ! * " + # * * $ $ " *" $! %' " ! " + "

0 '

$ $ " *"! " ! 9 !* ! ! " + ! *" " " " $ $ "

" " 4 " " * ! $ !" %''7 " $ $ " + " * !

%1 38&

5

+! %' 1'H13 ! $& " %0' 7': ! $&

2.1.2 Health Characteristics of the Vietnamese elderly

! ** 6" " ? * 3H9 " * - " * ! + ! " ! $ $

2.1.3 Economic and social characteristics of the Vietnamese Elderly people

$$ * " - 918 %( 18& ! *$ "

2.1.4 Role of the Vietnamese elderly people

* " " " ! ! * $$ !" + " $ !" *" " * "

$ " *" "* " $ *" $! * " + ! % "

! *" $ !" $ " " * " + ! * !

< <E L

2.2.1 Annalysis of the actua care policy for the Vietnamese elderly

89:! 889 +:; ,* ! * " * " $ + ! "

" ?* + ! " ! ! * *" $ " * $! ! "

* $$ !" "* " " ) " ! "

! " "!

$ ;;; & + ,* * *" " ;$ !

" " + " ! $ $ =* $ * " $! * " F

+ , % $ * *" + *

+ , 1 ! $ $ $! ! " "

" ! " " ! $ $ " *$ " ! "! * *$ " *" "

" ! I ! + ! " ! " *" " " * *"

+ ,

" * *" ) " " " * ! * A " * ++ "

* * " " " !" P* " ! *" " " ! + " ! $ $ =* $ *

! * *" " " * ++ " " " " $$! $! " " "

$ !" " * " " *$ + J " ! + ! ! **! "* * " ++ " *

2.2.2 Analysis of the real state of the quality of care for the elderly

$#$#$#"# ( ! ! ) ( ' ! ) ' - ) ' ( '

" " ) "" ! *"! + ! * * *

Table 2.2 Forms of health care for the elderly people

# " "

"

+ ! * +

+ ! " !

H 6 + ! " 2

" !

* " "

H *$ " 2N ! "!"!

*$ " 2 *" " *

*2 "

H ! " *$ "

H < ! !

" !

" )

$! "

H " ! + "

!

"

" !*

H " !

! F " !=* ! * !

(0 ! ! ) ( '

! " !) * ) "" ! " - " *& " " ! !

('8& " * " A ? ! * ! "

( ' % !0( ( ' ! ', ! ) ' ( '

"! " " " ! * ? ! B ! 1 " " - " * ! " " !

" " *" " =* *$ " " " *"! " $! " * -' (8&

*" " =* *$ " * " $! " * " ! " " ! 2 ! + !

"$ " "* ! *$ " 6 * + $ " " "! " " " ! * *" "

! " < " * ! $ $ "

" ! * ? " ! *" +" ) * * ) " * * " " " !=*

$! * ! $"

? *" + * * * " $! + " ! * ? $ ! "* 0 %8& " ! " !

- 3

!

$ " +! " "! ! " " " " * " ! * " A "

*" " + ! " " ! I " * *" + ! " ! $ $

6 " *" " " * *" $ !" +! " " N ! "! *$ " " !

*"! " ! ) " " ! " A $$ " *$ A $ " " $! * "

6 " $! " * " ! $! " *$ " * " ? $ !" " ? + !

$! ! * 6" " ? * " " " " " " ! " "

!

" A " * $ !

"! " " + ! " ! $ $ ) " " A " + " ! * " * ! "

! $ $ =* * " *+ " * + ! ! " ! " + ! * F

$#$#$#$# ( ! ! ) ( - ) ) ' ( % ' ) ' ) ( '

" " * + " ! $ $ " * * +! " * $$ !" + + ) !* "

1 $#2# ( )) ' ) '%! ) ( ! ' ) ' ( '

# " "

/

) ' ( '

H

H * ! "

H " ) + ! "

+ ! " ! $ $ F

+ ! " $ $

! " "

! " !

" " *

" ! " ! + ! " !

* 2 ** " *

! "

! D " *

H +H ! ) "

+ * $$ !"

! F " !=* ! * !

9 1

" $ " ! 7 0$ ! " * " * " ! "! *

! *" " ) ! " +

3 & ' ) ( % ' ) ) ' ( '

" $! $ !" * 3 78& ! " * + ! * * " " "

* + ! * " " " * ++ " + ! " " ** " $! ! "

*" ) * " +

" * * $ ! " " + " ++ " * ) " " ! * * $ !" +

" ! *" $ !" $ " " " * " ++ ! " * 6 %' " !

*" + " ! $ $ 138& * " " " " " ++ " * "

" ! + * *" "

( ! ' ) ) ( '

? + " " ** " *" " " + " "* ) " "

" " $! * " "

" + "

3 & ' ) ( ' 4! ! ' )

( 7

.

" * "! " * " ) " + ! *$ "+ " ! * ! $ ! "*

$ ! "* ! " " " + " *"! + # " ! $ !"*

$! " ! * * $$ !" " "

* $$ !"* +! " ! " " " ! $ $ ! " ! *$ * ) " "

$ $ =* ** " # " !* + " ! " *$ !"* " !" " + !

5 % 6 & ( ' 4! '

$ !" $ " " " " * " )

" $ !" $ " " " *"! " " " * *$

* " ) $! $ ! * ! " " $ !" ! " ! * *" "! " "

" + " ! $ $

" $ "" " " " ! $ $ =* *$ ! " +

2.2.3 Analysis of the care quality status in the elderly people’s care models

*

$#$#*#"# ) ( % 1 ! ' ) ' ( '

! ! & ( ( ' ) ' ( ' * "

' % % ) ' 8 ( ' , ' ' 1.

!! ! & !0 '& 6 !0 ( ' '& 6 !

( ' , % & '! & ' 0 ' '! ) ( '

0 %'

$!

2.2.4 Factors affecting the quality of care for the elderly people

' ! &F "! *+ ! " + * * $ "" ! * * * * )

( & ! ' ' ! ' ! ) ' ( ' 6 " " ;" +

( & ! % ! ) % ! ' .' ! * ! ? + "

" " "

( !.! 1 ) ! 8 ) ' ! ! % * + " *

*" $ ) " ? " * ! * *" ) " + " * + ! * *"

! *$ * " " A " + ! + ! " ! $ $

( - 3 ' ) & & " * ) ? " ! *"! "

" * " * *" * * * ! " * " + *" $ $ "

Chapter 3B SOLUTIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS TO IMPROVE QUALITY OF CARE FOR THE ELDERLY PEOPLE IN VIETNAM

,GE < < <E L <G < 6 6<

3.1.1 Viewpoints on care for the Vietnamese elderly people

" ! " * *"H ! " !? " *" ) " ! ) "

" * ) * $ "*

6" * " ! *$ * ) " + " !" $ $ * " " ! + ! " !

" "

3.1.2 How to enhance the quality of care for the elderly people in Vietnam

* " ** * ! " " " * !

H "! " *" " " + $ $ =* "" !* $! " " ! "

% %%

< <E L <G < 6 6<

3.2.1 These sets of solutions related to the media to promote the change of

behavior, awareness, attitude and care about the elderly people and care for

the elderly people

3.2.2 Set of solutions related to finalizing the policy and policy

implementation about the elderly people and care of the elderly people

Support the empowerment the care policy for the elderly people

! $ $ =* ** * +! " "! " ! **! "*

3.2.3 Set of group solutions to improve the health care quality for the elderly

people

) " " ! "! " " + ! " ! $ $ " "

! " " * D " $ + " $ !" *" "

; " "! " " + ! " ! $ $

3.2.4 Set of group solutions to improve the quality of material care of the elderly people

$ $ " $! " " $ " " + * $! " " + ! " ! $ $

#! " " B )* * " ) + ! " ! $ $

3.2.5 Set of group solutions to improve the quality of spiritual care and promote the role of the elderly people

*$ ! " +

$ $ " " ! **! "* *

3.2.6 Diversifying forms to support the elderly people, promote development

of care models for the elderly people in community

* !" " ! !

3.2.7 Work out a system of assessment criteria in quality care of the elderly people in the community based care model

%- %3

- * "*F

+ ,

*

3.2.8 Develop of basic research as well as professional research on the

elderly people in Vietnam

$! " A " + " ! !

3.3.1 To the National Assembly

! "" " " " ! $ $ =* ** * " !

$! $ ! + ! " ! F *" $ " ! " ! " + " * " + *" ++ *$

3.3.2 To the Government and relevant Ministries

" ! *"*

3.3.3 To the Local Authority

GENERAL CONCLUSION

% ! ' 9 > * $ " ! * ! + " "

" * * ! + * " " ! " * *" + " ! $ $ " !

" * * * ++ !* " ! * "* + ! " * " " " ** ) "