These experiments suggest that a common CYP11B ancestor gene that possessed both 11b-hydroxylase and aldosterone synthase activity under-went a gene duplication event before or shortly a
Trang 1Analyses of the CYP11B gene family in the guinea pig suggest
activity
Hannes E Bu¨low1,* and Rita Bernhardt2
1
Max-Delbru¨ck-Centrum fu¨r Molekulare Medizin, Berlin-Buch, Germany;2Universita¨t des Saarlandes, FR Biochemie, Saarbru¨cken, Germany
In this study we describe the isolation of three genes of the
CYP11Bfamily of the guinea pig CYP11B1 codes for the
previously described 11b-hydroxylase [Bu¨low, H.E., Mo¨bius,
K., Ba¨hr, V & Bernhardt, R (1996) Biochem Biophys Res
Commun 221, 304–312] while CYP11B2 represents the
aldosterone synthase gene As no expression for CYP11B3
was detected this gene might represent a pseudogene
Transient transfection assays show higher substrate
speci-ficity for its proper substrate for CYP11B1 as compared to
CYP11B2, which could account for the zone-specific
syn-thesis of mineralocorticoids and glucocorticoids,
respec-tively Thus, CYP11B2 displayed a fourfold higher ability to
perform 11b-hydroxylation of androstenedione than
CYP11B1, while this difference is diminished with the size of
the C17 substituent of the substrate Furthermore, analyses
with the electron transfer protein adrenodoxin indicate
dif-ferential sensitivity of CYP11B1 and CYP11B2 as well as the
three hydroxylation steps catalysed by CYP11B2 to the availability of reducing equivalents Together, both mecha-nisms point to novel protein intrinsic modalities to achieve tissue-specific production of mineralocorticoids and gluco-corticoids in the guinea pig In addition, we conducted phylogenetic analyses These experiments suggest that a common CYP11B ancestor gene that possessed both 11b-hydroxylase and aldosterone synthase activity under-went a gene duplication event before or shortly after the mammalian radiation with subsequent independent evolu-tion of the system in different lines Thus, a differential mineralocorticoid and glucocorticoid synthesis might be an exclusive achievement of mammals
Keywords: guinea pig; 11b-hydroxylase; aldosterone synth-ase; phylogeny
Higher vertebrates regulate vital processes like volume/
electrolyte homeostasis and glucose/lipid metabolism by
means of steroid hormones, namely mineralocorticoids and
glucocorticoids The biosynthesis of these steroids occurs
primarily in the adrenal cortex within morphologically and
functionally distinct zones Accordingly, mineralocorticoids
are produced by the outer zona glomerulosa while
gluco-corticoids are formed in the two inner layers of the cortex,
the zonae fasciculata/reticularis Originating from
cholester-ol they are synthesized by a number of consecutive
oxidations and dehydrogenations where all oxidative
reac-tions are catalysed by enzymes of the cytochrome P450
superfamily [2] The first and rate-limiting step is the
conversion of cholesterol to pregnenolone by the
mitochon-drial cytochrome P450 side-chain cleavage enzyme (P450scc,
CYP11A1) Subsequently, pregnenolone is
dehydroge-nated and oxidized in position 17 and/or 21 to yield
11-deoxycortisol or 11-deoxycorticosterone, respectively
Both compounds in turn are substrates for the cytochrome P450 enzymes of the CYP11B subfamiliy, namely the 11b-hydroxylase (CYP11B1) and the aldosterone synthase (CYP11B2) While CYP11B1 hydroxylates 11-deoxycorti-sol in position 11 to give corti11-deoxycorti-sol as the major glucocorti-coid, the closely related aldosterone synthase forms aldosterone as the major mineralocorticoid by means of
an 11b-hydroxylation and an 18-hydroxylation/oxidation of 11-deoxycorticosterone Thus, the proteins of the CYP11B subfamily catalysing the last biosynthetic steps are the key enzymes for the synthesis of both mineralocorticoids and glucocorticoids
From molecular cloning of the corresponding genes and analyses of the cDNAs it became obvious that the encoded isoenzymes share a very high degree of similarity ranging up to 95% on the amino acid level for human CYP11B1 and CYP11B2 [3] There are, however, a number of significant species differences For example, humans [3], mice [4], rats [5], and hamsters [6,7], possess at least two functionally different genes with the encoded proteins exhibiting different enzymatic activities While one protein modifies the steroid entity predominantly in position 11, the other one is able to hydroxylate and oxidize position 18 as well In contrast, cows [8], pigs [9], sheep [10], and frogs [11] apparently possess only one type
of a bipotent enzyme that is capable of catalysing the reactions at both positions 11 and 18 Nonetheless, the production of mineralocorticoids and glucocorticoids is strictly zone specific in all species It is, however, unknown
Correspondence to R Bernhardt, Universita¨t des Saarlandes, FR
Biochemie, PO Box 15 11 50, D-66041 Saarbru¨cken, Germany.
Fax: + 49 681302 4739, Tel.: + 49 681302 3005,
E-mail: ritabern@mx.uni-saarland.de
*Present address, Columbia University, College of Physicians &
Surgeons, New York, NY 10032, USA.
Note: a website is available at
http://www.uni-saarland.de/fak8/bernhardt.
(Received 12 April 2002, revised 11 June 2002, accepted 26 June 2002)
Trang 2which factors convey this specificity and how these similar
but distinct systems evolved
To investigate the zone-specific synthesis of
mineralocor-ticoids and glucocormineralocor-ticoids and the evolution of the
hormonal system in more detail we chose the guinea pig
as a model The guinea pig is an interesting species because
its taxonomical position remains controversial [12,13]
These features should provide new insight into the evolution
and function of the hormonal system We first cloned the
genes of the CYP11B family of the guinea pig The
11b-hydroxylase of the guinea pig showed higher substrate
specificity than the aldosterone synthase In addition, the
aldosterone synthase exhibited unique properties in that
18-hydroxylase activity was strongly dependent on the
presence of high levels of reducing equivalents whereas basic
levels were sufficient for high 11b-hydroxylase activity of
this enzyme This suggests a new regulatory level in
aldosterone synthesis that together with the higher substrate
specificity of the 11b-hydroxylase could be crucial for the
tissue-specific synthesis of steroid hormones Phylogenetic
analyses indicate a gene duplication event of a bipotent
CYP11B ancestor gene before the mammalian radiation
with subsequent distinct evolution in different clades This
indicates that a differential glucocorticoid and
mineralocor-ticoid synthesis is an exclusive property of mammals
E X P E R I M E N T A L P R O C E D U R E S
General procedures
Molecular biology procedures were carried out according to
standard protocols [14] unless stated otherwise Chemicals
and enzymes were purchased from the highest quality
sources commercially available
Screening of a guinea pig genomic library
A total of 1· 106clones of a guinea pig genomic library
(Stratagene, #946110) were screened under low stringency
conditions as described for Southern blots using a guinea
pig CYP11B1 full-length probe (1618 bp XbaI fragment
of pHBL5 [1] Positive clones were purified to
homoge-neity and analysed by Southern blotting using various
restriction endonucleases Appropriate genomic fragments
were subcloned into pBluescript SK(–) (Stratagene) and
sequenced using gene-specific primers Furthermore, to
sequence parts not represented by genomic phage clones
genomic fragments were amplified by PCR and sequenced
directly
RNA preparation
Tissue was homogenized in 6M guandinium thiocyanate
and subsequently RNA was purified by centrifugation
through a CsCl gradient [14] PolyA+RNA was isolated by
three rounds of affinity purification on oligodT cellulose
(Stratagene)
RNAse protection analyses
RNAse protection analyses were carried out using a
HybSpeedTM RPA Kit (Ambion) according to the
manufacturer’s recommendations Briefly, specific 32P labelled RNA antisense transcripts (corresponding to nucleotides 1491–1700 in the CYP11B1 cDNA [1] and nucleotides 1511–1750 in the CYP11B2 cDNA; Fig 2) were hybridized with total RNA from different tissues After digestion of the reaction mixture with RNAse A/H protected fragments were separated by PAGE and visual-ized by autoradiography
RACE The cDNA for CYP11B2 of the guinea pig was amplified and cloned using a Marathon cDNA Amplification Kit (Clontech) following the supplier’s recommendations In brief, after reverse transcription of 1 lg of polyA+RNA and second-strand synthesis an adapter comprising the T7 promoter sequence combined with a NotI and a SmaI site was ligated to both ends of the cDNA pool Using a combination of a primer complementary to the adapter (adapter primer: 5¢-CCATCCTAATACGACTCACTA TAGGGC-3¢) and a gene-specific sense primer (5¢-GCCG CTCGAGTTTGAGTTAGCCAGAAACTCC-3¢, XhoI site underlined) or antisense primer (5¢-ATACGGGCCC GACAGTGGTGTGCCTGGGAAC-3¢, Bsp120I site underlined), respectively, a PCR reaction was carried out with KlenTaqTM(Clontech) under the following conditions:
94C 2 min initial denaturation, 94 C 45 s denaturation,
72C 1 min annealing (annealing temperature reduced at 1.4C per cycle), 72 C 3 min polymerization; 10 cycles, followed by 25 cycles at 94C 45 s, 58 C 1 min and 72 C
3 min with a final extension step for 8 min at 72C The 5¢-RACE product was cloned directly into a TA Cloning vector pCR2.1 (Invitrogen) yielding pCR2.1/HG17 while 3¢-RACE products were inserted by using the XhoI and NotI sites into pBluescript SK(–) (Stratagene) giving pBSSK/3¢RACE HG17
DNA sequencing DNA sequencing was carried out using a Thermo Sequen-aseTMCycle Sequencing Kit (Amersham/USB) in combi-nation with [a-35S]dCTP followed by autoradiography with HyperfilmTMMP (Amersham)
Southern blotting Genomic DNA was digested with the appropriate enzymes, extracted twice with phenol/chloroform and precipitated using EtOHand sodium acetate After extensive washing the DNA was redissolved in Tris/EDTA, pH8.0 and sep-arated on a 1· Tris/borate/EDTA, 0.9% agarose gel After capillary transfer to HybondTMnylon membranes (Amer-sham) nucleic acids were UV cross-linked (0.24 JÆcm)2) Prehybridization was performed in 5· NaCl/Cit, 5 · Den-hardt’s, 0.5% SDS and 50 lgÆmL)1sonicated salmon sperm DNA for 2 h at 65C [a-32P]dCTP labelled DNA probes ( 1 · 106c.p.m.ÆmL)1) were hybridized in the same solu-tion for 16 h For low stringency hybridizasolu-tion the blot was washed twice at room temperature in 2· NaCl/Cit, 0.1% SDS for 10 min followed by two 30 min washes at 50C in
1· NaCl/Cit, 0.1% SDS Autoradiography was carried out with HyperfilmTMMP (Amersham)
Trang 3Construction of expression plasmids
For the construction of pCMV/11B2, pRc/CMV was
digested with Bsp120I, trimmed with Pfu polymerase
(Stratagene) and subsequently digested with NotI Likewise,
pCR2.1/HG17 was digested with SpeI, trimmed with Pfu
polymerase and digested with NotI to release a fragment
comprising the ORF of the guinea pig CYP11B2 This
fragment was ligated using NotI/blunt into the eukaryotic
expression vector
Hydroxylation assays
COS-1 cells were maintained as described previously [15]
Transfections were carried out using LipofectAMINETM
(Gibco/BRL) according to the manufacturer’s
recommen-dations One mL of transfection mix contained 2 lg of the
respective expression construct together with 1 lg pBAdx4
(bovine adrenodoxin; gift of M R Waterman, Vanderbilt
University, Nashville, TN, USA) and 6 lL
LipofectAMINETM unless stated otherwise Twenty-four
h after transfection cells were incubated with appropriate
substrates for 48 h using [1,2-3H]cortisol, [14
C]11-deoxy-corticosterone or [1,2–3H]androstenedione, respectively, as
tracers Media were extracted and analysed by high
performance TLC as described previously [16]
Phylogenetic analyses
Phylogenetic analyses were conducted using the PHYLIP
package (Version 3.5c, 1993) [17]
The sequences have been submitted to GenBank under
the accession numbers AF191278, AF191279 (for
CYP11B1), AF191281, AF191280 (for CYP11B2), and
AF191282 (for CYP11B3)
R E S U L T S
In a previous study we isolated an 11b-hydroxylase of the
guinea pig [1] by screening an adrenal cDNA library with a
PCR amplified orthologous probe Upon expression, the
isolated cDNA turned out to be a pure 11b-hydroxylase
with no detectable 18-hydroxylation activity suggesting the
existence of additional isoenzymes of the CYP11B
subfam-ily in the guinea pig To investigate this notion, a Southern
blot was performed utilizing an exon-1-specific probe of
CYP11B1under low stringency conditions and digesting the
genomic DNA with various restriction endonucleases that
did not cut within exon 1 The result (Fig 1) strongly
suggested the existence of at least three different genes as
judged from the appearance of three bands if the DNA was,
e.g digested with EcoRI/EcoRV, XbaI, or XbaI/HindIII
Although guinea pigs had been sodium depleted to
stimulate the expression of a putative aldosterone synthase
as much as possible [18], repeated screening of the cDNA
library did not result in the identification of any cDNA
other than CYP11B1 (data not shown) Thus, we devised
another strategy for the identification of additional genes of
the CYP11B subfamily in the guinea pig To this end, a
genomic library was screened under low stringency (see
Experimental procedures) utilizing a full-length guinea pig
CYP11B1 cDNA as a probe As opposed to a cDNA
library, screening of a genomic library should yield clones in
relation to their abundance in the genome rather than their relative abundance due to differential expression Indeed, this approach lead to the isolation of eight genomic clones that were classified into three subgroups based on restriction digests and hybridization experiments (data not shown) One clone termed kHG13 turned out to represent the CYP11B1 gene while kHG17 and kHG15 represented closely related genes of the CYP11B family demonstrated
by similarities of > 75% at the nucleotide level They were tentatively named CYP11B2 and CYP11B3, respectively
To clone the corresponding cDNAs, the RACE tech-nique was used PolyA+RNA was converted into a double-stranded cDNA pool and adapters comprising the promoter sequence of the T7 bacteriophage were ligated to both ends The sequences of the T7 promoter are extremely rare in eukaryotic genomes and thus convey a high degree of specificity in subsequent PCR reactions Using a primer combination of an adapter primer and gene-specific sense or antisense primers, respectively, we were able to amplify two overlapping fragments in case of kHG17 Upon sequencing
of these cDNA fragments the complete sequence of the cDNA of CYP11B2 could be deduced It comprised
2611 bp and an ORF of 1503 bp coding for a putative mitochondrial preprotein of 501 amino acids with a calculated molecular weight of 57.7 kDa (Fig 2) After Leu24 a cleavage site for the matrix-associated protease was predicted resulting in a mature mitochondrial protein of
55 kDa The deduced amino acid sequence showed 81% similarity to the guinea pig CYP11B1 and 80% similarity to the human CYP11B2, respectively (see below) The 3¢-UTR comprised 1079 bp with a canonical polyadenylation site
16 bp upstream of the polyA tail with no indications for the existence of alternative poly adenylation sites (Fig 2)
We next investigated the expression of the CYP11B genes A Northern blot probed with a CYP11B2-specific probe showed a single band of 2.9 kb (data not shown) which is consistent with the length of the isolated cDNA for CYP11B2 assuming a polyA tail of 200–300 adenine residues To see where the CYP11B genes were expressed
Fig 1 Southern blot analyses with a CYP11B1 exon 1-specific probe Fifteen micrograms of guinea pig genomic DNA was digested with the indicated endonucleases After transfer, membranes were probed under low stringency conditions with an exon 1-specific probe of CYP11B1 (nucleotides 1–141; see Experimental procedures for details) Sizes of fragments are indicated on the right.
Trang 4and whether they played a role during postnatal
develop-ment we used a highly sensitive RNAse protection assay
with RNAs from different tissues and developmental stages
As shown in Fig 3, expression of both the 11b-hydroxylase
and the aldosterone synthase was exclusively in the adrenal
gland Moreover, there was no difference in expression
between postnatal day 1 and the adult stages suggesting that
the genes were not differentially regulated during postnatal
development With respect to kHG15 we were not able to
demonstrate expression of the gene in adult tissues using
RT/PCR with various gene-specific primer combinations
(data not shown) Thus, this clone might represent a
pseudogene of the CYP11B family or a gene that is not
expressed in adult tissues
To compare the enzymatic activities of CYP11B2 and
CYP11B1, the cDNAs were cloned under the control of a
viral promoter and transiently transfected into COS-1 cells
Transfected cells were incubated with different substrates
and the resulting metabolites were analysed using TLC As seen in Fig 4A, CYP11B2 converted 11-deoxycorticoster-one to corticoster11-deoxycorticoster-one and both 18(OH)-corticoster11-deoxycorticoster-one and aldosterone These results clearly demonstrate that CYP11B2 is the aldosterone synthase of the guinea pig as
it is capable of modifying position 11 and 18 of the steroid ring In contrast, CYP11B1 produced only corticosterone and traces of 18/19(OH)-deoxycorticosterone, confirming earlier results [1] Furthermore, CYP11B2 transfected cells efficiently converted 11-deoxycortisol to cortisol and fur-ther to 18(OH)-cortisol (Fig 4B) As 11b(OH)-androsten-edione is the major C19 steroid in the guinea pig, we also used androstenedione as a substrate Under the experi-mental conditions large amounts of 11b(OH)-androstendi-one were synthesized by CYP11B2 in comparison with CYP11B1 (Fig 4C) It is noteworthy, that CYP11B2 displayed a higher enzymatic activity than CYP11B1 based
on 11b-hydroxylase activity These differences were highest
Fig 2 Sequence of the CYP11B2 cDNAof the guinea pig The nucleotide sequence and the deduced amino acid sequence are both shown The ORF (putative start and stop codon underlined) encodes a mitochondrial preprotein with a calculated molecular mass of 57.7 kDa An arrowhead indicates the presumptive cleavage site for the mitochondrial matrix associated protease Numbers on the left denote amino acids, those on the right indicate nucleotides A canonical polyadylation site is shown boldface.
Trang 5for androstenedione (fourfold) and lowest for
11-deoxy-cortisol (Fig 4) This shows a higher substrate specifity of
CYP11B1 which could be due to differences in the active
centre and/or the entry channel Moreover, it could be
important for tissue-specific synthesis of glucocorticoids
given the differences in expression levels of the two
enzymes
We next asked whether other accessory proteins might
contribute to the zone-specific synthesis of steroid
hor-mones A good candidate is adrenodoxin, an iron sulfur
containing electron donor protein that is required for the
function of mitochondrial cytochrome P450 proteins [19]
and has been shown to interact directly with the
cyto-chromes To test its significance we carried out an
experi-ment where adrenodoxin was either cotransfected or
omitted After transfection, cells were incubated with
11-deoxycorticosterone as a substrate As shown in Fig 5,
the omission of Adx leads to a sharp decrease in the activity
for the 11b-hydroxylase, CYP11B1 Intriguingly, however,
the 11b-hydroxylase activity of the aldosterone synthase
CYP11B2 was basically unaffected whereas the
18-hydroxy-lation and oxidation potential were abrogated almost
completely These results indicate clear structural differences
on the surface of these proteins involved either in
glucocor-ticoid or in mineralocorglucocor-ticoid biosynthesis despite a high
degree of similarity between the two isoenzymes More
importantly, these results indicate a new level of regulation for tissue-specific aldosterone synthesis depending on the availability of reducing equivalents
One intriguing question is how and when animals developed a hormonal system that differentially regulated the control of both electrolyte/volume homeostasis and glucose metabolism Knowing when and how differential synthetic pathways for mineralocorticoids and glucocorti-coids developed would lead to deeper understanding of these important evolutionary processes Because the guinea pig’s taxonomical classification is controversial [12,13], this species is extremely interesting in terms of vertebrate evolution and might provide insight into some aspects of the evolution of the hormonal system
Fig 4 Enzymatic acivities of CYP11B2 COS-1 cells were transfected with pBAdx4 (bovine adrenodoxin) and the expression plasmid pCMV5 [1] (CYP11B1), pRc/CYP11B2 (CYP11B2), or pRC/CMV (mock), respectively Twenty-four h after transfection cells were incubated for 48 h with 5 l M 11-deoxycorticosterone (DOC) includ-ing 4 nCiÆmL)1 [ 14 C]DOC (A), 5 l M androstendione including 0.5 lCiÆmL)1 [ 3 H]androstendione (B), or 2.5 l M 11-deoxycortisol including 0.5 lCiÆmL [3H]11-deoxycorticosterone (C) Subsequently, steroids were extracted and separated by TLC [16] In culture medium incubated substrates served as an additional control (substrate) Positions of cold standards are denoted on the left On the right percentage of total radioactivity or relative activity is given ± SD; data are from at least two different experiments performed in triplicate.
Fig 3 Tissue and age-specific RNAse protection assays Different
amounts of total RNA from different tissues and stages as indicated
were hybridized in solution with CYP11B1 and CYP11B2-specific
probes Both probes were chosen from the 3¢ untranslated regions of
the genes where sequence divergence was maximal between the two
isoenzymes Following RNAse digestion the probes protected a 210
nucleotide fragment of CYP11B1 (corresponding to nucleotides 1491–
1700 [1]) or a 240 nucleotide fragment for CYP11B2 (corresponding to
nucleotide 1511–1750; Fig 2), respectively A control lane without
RNAse (–RNAse) shows the corresponding undigested riboprobes of
242 nucleotides (for CYP11B1) and 272 nucleotides (for CYP11B2) A
molecular size marker is given on the left Different developmental
stages are denoted on the right: P1, postnatal day 1; adult.
Trang 6To answer the question how these genes might have
evolved we determined the complete genomic structure of
both genes As shown in Fig 6, both genes exhibit the
typical organization of the family, characterized by nine
exons and eight introns supporting the idea of a gene
duplication event It is, however, noteworthy that the exons
are grouped into three clusters comprising exons 1 and 2,
exons 3–5 and exons 6–9, respectively These clusters are
separated by intron 2 and intron 5, which are not only
larger than any other intron but also show considerable
differences in sequence similarity For example, an
align-ment [20] of intron sequences requires the introduction of 11
and 14 gaps for intron 2 and 5, respectively, as compared to
1 (intron 7) to 7 (intron 6) for the remaining introns Finally,
the 3¢ UTRs of the guinea pig CYP11B genes show only
42% similarity whereas the 3¢UTR of the guinea pig
CYP11B2 gene shares up to 72% identity with the
corresponding human homologue indicative of a close
relationship of CYP11B2 sequences between species
Comparing the protein sequences of the CYP11B family (Table 1) we were surprised to find that both CYP11B1 and CYP11B2 of the guinea pig are always more closely related (or equal) to the CYP11B2 sequences of other species Moreover, the guinea pig CYP11B2 is always more similar
to CYP11B proteins of other species than CYP11B1 of the guinea pig (compare lines A and B) Together these results suggest that the CYP11B2 genes are the primordial genes and that a common ancestor containing both enzymatic activities was duplicated The resulting two genes subse-quently evolved to give both different regio-specificities and differential regulatory circuits
We next asked when the aforementioned gene duplication event might have occurred To this end we conducted phylogenetic analyses with all known sequences of the CYP11B family of proteins Including the sequences of the guinea pig with its highly controversial taxonomical posi-tion into this highly homologous family of proteins could possibly give new insights into both its taxonomical classification and the evolutionary relationships within this protein family Also, these analyses might indicate when the gene duplication event occurred that subsequently led to isoenzymes harbouring different enzymatic activities like, for example, those in humans or to an exclusively differen-tial regulation like seen in cattle Amino acid sequences of 16 CYP11B proteins were subjected to phylogenetic analyses using two fundamentally different methods The use of various methods should provide an estimate of methodical errors On the one hand, two distance matrix methods, the UPGMA (unweighted pairgroup method using arithmetic mean) and the neighbor joining method (reviewed in [21]), were used The distance matrices for the calculation of phylogenetic trees were produced with three different algorithms for amino acid exchanges, namely the Dayhoff model [22], Kimura’s model [23] and the categories model developed by Felsenstein [24] On the other hand, the maximum parsimony method as a single character state algorithm was used to evaluate the phylogenetic relation-ships between these proteins This approach assumes the most probable phylogeny to be the one that requires the fewest nucleotide exchanges [17] The frog was used as an outgroup in all applications and the reliability of a given topology was assessed using the bootstrapping procedure [25]
The results are depicted in Fig 7 No matter which algorithm was used, the guinea pig sequences were grouped together with bootstrapping probabilities of at least 98% The maximum parsimony method placed the guinea pig into one group with rodents requiring 1349 nucleotide exchanges thus supporting monophyly of the rodents Within the rodents the branching consistently grouped the orthologues of rat and mouse together demonstrating the close relationship between these species In contrast, both distance matrix methods showed the guinea pig together
Fig 5 Influence of bovine adrenodoxin on enzymatic activities COS-1
cells were transfected with pBAdx4 (bovine adrenodoxin) and the
expression plasmids pCMV5 [1] (CYP11B1), pRc/CYP11B2
(CYP11B2), or pRC/CMV (mock), respectively Twenty-four hours
after transfection, cells were incubated for 48 h with 5 l M
11-deoxy-corticosterone (DOC) including 4 nCiÆmL)1[ 14 C]DOC Metabolites
were analysed by TLC Enzymatic activity is given as relative
radio-activity White bars represent cotransfection with adrenodoxin (¼ 100)
and black bars represent no cotransfection expressed in relation to
100 ± SD; n ¼ 9 for each data point.
Fig 6 Genomic structure of CYP11B1 and CYP11B2 of the guinea pig.
Shown is the complete genomic structure of CYP11B1 and CYP11B2.
Exon and intron boundaries are indicated Scale bar represents 1000
nucleotides.
Table 1 Pair-wise sequence similarities of CYP11B proteins Similarities for the CYP11B proteins were determined pair-wise using the PALIGN
program (PcGENE, Intelligenetics) for the proteins from human (HS), mouse (MM), rat (RN) hamster (MA), guinea pig (CP), sheep (OA), cow (BT), pig (SS) and frog (RC).
H S B1 H S B2 MM B1 MM B2 RN B1 RN B2 MA B1 MA B2 CP B1 CP B2 OA B0 BT B0 SS B0 RC B0
Trang 7with artiodactyls and primates, i.e supported the paraphyly
of the order rodentia The bootstrapping probabilities were
however, comparatively low (Fig 7D) using the neighbor
joining approach with 49, 52 or 68% for the categories
model, the Dayhoff model or Kimura’s model, respectively
Using UPGMA the probabilities were slightly higher;
between 70 and 82% Moreover, the hamster proteins were
now assigned to their rat and mouse paralogues
Interest-ingly, Kimura’s model consistently produced the highest
bootstrapping probabilities for a given topology
D I S C U S S I O N
In this paper, we describe the isolation and characterization
of the CYP11B genes of the guinea pig In an earlier study
[1] we isolated a single cDNA using an orthologous probe
that had been obtained using degenerated primers to screen
a guinea pig adrenal cDNA library This cDNA proved to
code for the abundantly expressed 11b-hydroxylase,
CYP11B1, of the guinea pig which exhibited exclusive
11b-hydroxylase activity [1] Although cloning strategies
using PCR-based approaches with degenerated primers
have often been successful this is sometimes hampered by
large differences in expression levels Thus, we were unable
to isolate more than one cDNA of the CYP11B family of
the guinea pig either by PCR-based approaches or by
repeated screening of the library under low stringency
conditions, even under conditions in which sodium was
depleted to achieve induction of the aldosterone synthase
gene The enzymatic activity of the cloned protein, however,
strongly suggested the existence of additional isoenzymes
with different enzymatic activities To test this hypothesis,
we performed a Southern blot analysis using an exon
1-spe-cific probe of CYP11B1 This experiment indicated the
existence of at least two additional genes of this family in the guinea pig To clone these genes we screened a genomic library which should circumvent difficulties associated with largely differing expression levels This led to the isolation of two additional genes, tentatively named CYP11B2 and CYP11B3 For CYP11B2, we were able to isolate a cDNA with a complete ORF In contrast, no specific transcripts could be detected for CYP11B3 in sensitive RT-PCR experiments with RNA from adult animals Thus, this gene might be a pseudogene that evolved as a consequence of a secondary gene duplication event (see below) Similar observations have also been made in cows that have five genes of the CYP11B family only two of which are functional [8] Alternatively, CYP11B3 might be a developmentally regulated gene as in rats, in which it is expressed solely during
a few specific days of postnatal development [26]
However, no differential expression was observed for either CYP11B1 or CYP11B2 during postnatal develop-ment of the guinea pig using RNAse protection assays Instead, we saw exclusive adrenal expression of both genes This does, however, not rule out expression in other tissues
at lower levels For example, expression of CYP11B genes in the rat has been demonstrated in brain [27] and in the heart [28] using very sensitive RT-PCR and in situ hybridization techniques The physiological significance of this low level expression remains unclear
To compare the catalytic activities of the guinea pig CYP11B isoenzymes we cloned the cDNAs downstream of
a cytomegalovirus promoter to drive expression in COS-1 cells This system has been proven suitable for the characterization of enzymes of the steroidogenic pathway [15] These analyses demonstrated a potent 18-hydroxyla-tion and 18-oxida18-hydroxyla-tion activity of CYP11B2 using various substrates thus showing it to be the aldosterone synthase
of the guinea pig It was interesting to note that CYP11B2
of the guinea pig had a considerably higher enzymatic activity in terms of 11b-hydroxylated product formed than the guinea pig CYP11B1 These results are in contrast with findings in other species For example, the human CYP11B1 has a 20-fold higher activity towards 11-deoxy-cortisol than CYP11B2 [29] Moreover, the activity of the guinea pig CYP11B2 compared to CYP11B1 could be correlated to the size of the C17 substituent of the substrate Thus, the differences were most pronounced with androstenedione and least with 11-deoxycortisol as a substrate These results might indicate steric hindrance in the entry channel of the cytochrome P450 enzymes with CYP11B1 being more selective for its proper substrate This would contribute to the zone-specific synthesis of glucocorticoids given the vast differences in expression level
of the two genes
In a second set of experiments, we investigated the significance of adrenodoxin, an iron sulfur protein that is essential for electron transfer from adrenodoxin reductase
to mitochondrial cytochrome P450 enzymes [19] Adreno-doxin has been shown to significantly increase enzymatic activities of steroidogenic enzymes in transfection experi-ments [15] If this cotransfection was omitted, the two guinea pig enzymes showed differential properties The 11b-hydroxylase activity of CYP11B1 was strongly reduced (Fig 5), whereas that of the aldosterone synthase was basically unaffected, while the 18-hydroxlase and oxidase activity was also greatly diminished These differences can
Fig 7 Phylogenetic analyses Shown are the phylogenetic trees
obtained by the maximum parsimony method (A), the UPGMA
method (categories model) (B), and the neighbour joining method
(categories model) (C) Numbers represent bootstrapping probabilities
of 1000 replicates The Table in D gives the bootstrapping probabilities
for monophyly and paraphyly of the order rodentia in detail Pr,
primates; Ar, artiodactyls; My, myomorphs; Cp, guinea pig.
Trang 8be explained by a lower binding affinity of CYP11B1 to
adrenodoxin when compared with CYP11B2 CYP11B1
has a tryptophan at position 366 while all other proteins of
the CYP11B family including CYP11B2 of the guinea pig
have a basic residue (arginine or lysine, respectively) at the
corresponding position These two basic residues have been
shown in site-directed mutagenesis experiments to be of
significance to the electrostatic interaction of bovine
CYP11A1 (cytochrome P450SCC), a closely related
mito-chondrial protein with adrenodoxin [30] Accordingly, the
11b-hydroxylase activity of CYP11B2 was hardly affected
by omission of cotransfected adrenodoxin However, the
subsequent enzymatic reactions involving the
18-hydroxy-lation and oxidation were severely impaired This could
indicate altered binding affinities for adrenodoxin after
the 11b-hydroxylation In this regard it is interesting to
note that in vitro experiments with purified bovine
CYP11B0 indicate a conformational change of the protein
due to rearrangement of the substrate after the first
hydroxylation step [31] This might account for an altered
binding site for adrenodoxin or modified binding
affini-ties Also, experiments in a reconstituted system with
bovine CYP11B0 using mutant forms of adrenodoxin that
have increased electron transfer capabilities showed a shift
in the spectrum of products formed towards compounds
modified at position 18 [32] Interestingly, studies with the
microsomal cytochrome P450 enzyme 17a-hydroxylase/
17,20-lyase demonstrated a dependence of the more electron
consuming lyase reaction on the presence of high
concen-trations of the electron donor protein [33] Taken together,
our results with the guinea pig suggest a new regulatory level
of aldosterone synthesis by the availability of reducing
equivalents In the light of results with the bovine and
human enzymes [32] this might be a more commonly used
mechanism which could be crucial for the zone-specific
biosynthesis of mineralocorticoids In this respect it would
be interesting to see whether expression of adrenodoxin is
differentially regulated
To investigate the evolution of the CYP11B genes, we
compared protein sequences of the CYP11B family These
analyses showed that CYP11B2 proteins are more closely
related to each other than CYP11B1 proteins across species
Furthermore, the 3¢ UTR of the guinea pig CYP11B2
shows considerable similarity to its human counterpart
while exhibiting only low resemblance to its paralogue in the
guinea pig On a functional level the CYP11B1 proteins also
show greater differences across species For example, the
hamster CYP11B1 produces 50% of 19-hydroxylated
product besides the 11b-hydroxylated steroid [7] Moreover,
as mentioned above, human CYP11B1 is a very potent
11b-hydroxylase as compared with CYP11B2 while in the
guinea pig this situation is reversed These findings suggest
that CYP11B2 genes, i.e those encoding bipotent enzymes,
are the primordial genes that underwent a subsequent
duplication and, as a consequence, the CYP11B1 genes
evolved independently in different species within the limits
of functional constraints
To see how this evolution might have occurred, we
determined the complete genomic structure of the two
functional guinea pig genes Interestingly, we observed the
greatest differences between these closely related genes within
intron 2 and intron 5 This could indicate frequent
recom-bination between the genes for which close association has
been shown in mice [4] and humans [34] Indeed, in humans
an unequal crossover between CYP11B genes, fusing the CYP11B2gene under control of the CYP11B1 promoter and vice versa, has been demonstrated to cause glucocorticoid remediable aldosteronism, an autosomal dominant disorder leading to severe hypertension [34], or congenital adrenal hyperplasia [35] In this context it is interesting to note that the crucial determinants for regio-specificity have been shown to reside in exon 5 [29] Moreover, analysis of breakpoints in patients suffering from glucocorticoid reme-diable aldosteronism indicate that important regulatory elements are contained within intron 2 [36] Thus, a scenario
is conceivable where recombination between the two genes in intron 2 and intron 5 eventually lead to both distinct regio-specificities and/or differential regulation
We next sought to determine when this gene duplication event might have occurred To this end, we conducted phylogenetic analyses with 16 sequences of the CYP11B family of proteins To assess possible methodical problems
we used different algorithms, namely the maximum parsimony and two distance matrix methods The maxi-mum parsimony method consistently grouped the guinea pig with a bootstrapping probability of 98% into one clade with rodents thus favouring monophyly of the order rodentia This is in contrast with the findings of Graur and colleagues [12] who postulated paraphyly of the order Our results are however, in accordance with the results of Hasegawa et al [13] who questioned the paraphyly of the order rodentia using the same data as Graur In contrast, the distance matrix algorithms again placed the guinea pig together with artiodactyls and primates, thus supporting paraphyly albeit only with bootstrapping probabilities between 49 and 82% Interestingly, the highest values were obtained when Kimura’s model [23] was used to calculate the matrices This might reflect the fact that this model assumes conservative and nonconservative changes to be equally likely which could lead to an overestimation of conservative changes
According to Frye et al [37] the ambiguity of the phylogeny as seen in our analyses with respect to the guinea pig can be interpreted as insufficient methodology For example, the data and the algorithms might not be adequate
to assign a statistically unambiguous topology if the radia-tion of species has occurred in a sufficiently small time frame Thus, the guinea pig presumably branched off at a very early time point within the mammalian radiation irrespective of the branching order Intriguingly, however, the guinea pig possesses already two functional CYP11B genes as have all other mammals investigated so far Theoretically it is possible that the gene duplication occurred in all lines independently
It seems, however, much more likely that the gene was duplicated in an ancestor mammal In this respect, it is interesting that analyses in the frog as an amphibian gave no indications of two CYP11B genes [11] Thus, the differential mineralocorticoid and glucocorticoid synthesis is presum-ably an exclusive property of mammals
A C K N O W L E D G E M E N T S
We thank K Denner, B Bo¨ttner and members of the Bernhardt lab for helpful discussions and advice We also thank W Oelkers and
V Ba¨hr for guinea pig adrenal tissues This work was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft Grant DFG Be 13436-1.
Trang 9R E F E R E N C E S
1 Bu¨low, H.E., Mo¨bius, K., Ba¨hr, V & Bernhardt, R (1996)
Molecular cloning and functional expression of the cytochrome
P450, 11B-hydroxylase of the guinea pig Biochem Biophys Res.
Commun 221, 304–312.
2 Nelson, D.R., Koymans, L., Kamataki, T., Stegeman, J.J.,
Feyereisen, R., Waxman, D.J., Waterman, M.R., Gotoh, O.,
Coon, M.J., Estabrook, R.W., Gunsalus, I.C & Nebert, D.W.
(1996) P450 superfamily: update on new sequences, gene mapping,
accession numbers and nomenclature Pharmacogenetics 6, 1–42.
3 Mornet, E., Dupont, J., Vitek, A & White, P.C (1989)
Char-acterization of two genes encoding human steroid 11
beta-hydroxylase (P-450 (11) beta) J Biol Chem 264, 20961–20967.
4 Domalik, L.J., Chaplin, D.D., Kirkman, M.S., Wu, R.C., Liu,
W.W., Howard, T.A., Seldin, M.F & Parker, K.L (1991)
Dif-ferent isozymes of mouse 11 beta-hydroxylase produce
miner-alocorticoids and glucocorticoids Mol Endocrinol 5, 1853–1861.
5 Mukai, K., Imai, M., Shimada, H & Ishimura, Y (1993) Isolation
and characterization of rat CYP11B genes involved in late steps of
mineralo- and glucocorticoid syntheses J Biol Chem 268, 9130–
9137.
6 LeHoux, J.G., Mason, J.I., Bernard, H., Ducharme, L., LeHoux,
J., Veronneau, S & Lefebvre, A (1994) The presence of two
cytochrome P450 aldosterone synthase mRNAs in the hamster
adrenal J Steroid Biochem Mol Biol 49, 131–137.
7 Veronneau, S., Bernard, H., Cloutier, M., Courtemanche, J.,
Ducharme, L., Lefebvre, A., Mason, J.I & LeHoux, J.G (1996)
The hamster adrenal cytochrome P450C11 has equipotent
11beta-hydroxylase and 19-11beta-hydroxylase activities, but no aldosterone
synthase activity J Steroid Biochem Mol Biol 57, 125–139.
8 Kirita, S., Hashimoto, T., Kitajima, M., Honda, S., Morohashi,
K & Omura, T (1990) Structural analysis of multiple bovine
P-450 (11 beta) genes and their promoter activities J Biochem.
(Tokyo) 108, 1030–1041.
9 Okamoto, M., Nonaka, Y., Ohta, M., Takemori, H., Halder,
S.K., Wang, Z.N., Sun, T., Hatano, O., Takakusu, A &
Mur-akami, T (1995) Cytochrome P450 (11 beta): structure-function
relationship of the enzyme and its involvement in blood pressure
regulation J Steroid Biochem Mol Biol 53, 89–94.
10 Boon, W.C., Roche, P.J., Butkus, A., McDougall, J.G.,
Jeyasee-lan, K & CoghJeyasee-lan, J.P (1997) Functional and expression analysis
of ovine steroid 11 beta-hydroxylase (cytochrome P450 11 beta).
Endocr Res 23, 325–347.
11 Nonaka, Y., Takemori, H., Halder, S.K., Sun, T., Ohta, M.,
Hatano, O., Takakusu, A & Okamoto, M (1995) Frog
cyto-chrome P-450 (11 beta,aldo), a single enzyme involved in the final
steps of glucocorticoid and mineralocorticoid biosynthesis Eur J.
Biochem 229, 249–256.
12 Graur, D., Hide, W.A & Li, W.H (1991) Is the guinea-pig a
rodent? [see comments] Nature 351, 649–652.
13 Hasegawa, M., Cao, Y., Adachi, J & Yano, T (1992) Rodent
polyphyly? Nature 355, 595.
14 Sambrook, J., Fritsch, E.F & Maniatis, T (1989) Molecular
Cloning: A Laboratory Manual, Vol 3, 2nd edn Cold Spring
Harbor Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor, New York.
15 Zuber, M.X., Simpson, E.R & Waterman, M.R (1986)
Expres-sion of bovine 17 alpha-hydroxylase cytochrome P-450 cDNA in
nonsteroidogenic (COS-1) cells Science 234, 1258–1261.
16 Bu¨low, H.E., Mo¨bius, K., Ba¨hr, V & Bernhardt, R (1996)
Functional expression of the guinea pig 11b-hydroxylase in COS-1
cells Endocr Res 22, 479–484.
17 Felsenstein, J (1993) PHYLIP (Phylogeny Inference Package),
Version 3.5c Department of Genetics University of Washington,
Seattle.
18 Holland, O.B & Carr, B (1993) Modulation of aldosterone
syn-thase messenger ribonucleic acid levels by dietary sodium and
potassium and by adrenocorticotropin Endocrinology 132, 2666– 2673.
19 Vickery, L.E (1997) Molecular recognition and electron transfer
in mitochondrial steroid hydroxylase systems Steroids 62, 124– 127.
20 Altschul, S.F., Gish, W., Miller, W., Myers, E.W & Lipman, D.J (1990) Basic local alignment search tool J Mol Biol 215, 403–410.
21 Saitou, N (1996) Reconstruction of gene trees from sequence data Methods Enzymol 266, 427–449.
22 Dayhoff, M.O., Schwartz, R.M & Orcutt, B.C (1978) Atlas of Protein Sequence and Structure 5 Suppl 3 (Dahoff, M.O., ed.), National Biomedical Research Foundation, Washington DC.
23 Kimura, M (1983) The Neutral Theory of Evolution Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, USA
24 Felsenstein, J (1996) Inferring phylogenies from protein sequences
by parsimony, distance, and likelihood methods Methods Enzy-mol 266, 418–427.
25 Felsenstein, J (1985) Confidence limits on phylogenies Evolution
39, 783–791.
26 Mellon, S.H., Bair, S.R & Monis, H (1995) P450c11B3 mRNA, transcribed from a third P450c11 gene, is expressed in a tissue-specific, developmentally, and hormonally regulated fashion in the rodent adrenal and encodes a protein with both 11-hydroxylase and 18-hydroxylase activities J Biol Chem 270, 1643–1649.
27 Erdmann, B., Gerst, H., Lippoldt, A., Bu¨low, H., Ganten, D., Fuxe, K & Bernhardt, R (1996) Expression of cytochrome P45011B1 mRNA in the brain of normal and hypertensive transgenic rats Brain Res 733, 73–82.
28 Silvestre, J.S., Robert, V., Heymes, C., Aupetit-Faisant, B., Mouas, C., Moalic, J.M., Swynghedauw, B & Delcayre, C (1998) Myocardial production of aldosterone and corticosterone in the rat Physiological regulation J Biol Chem 273, 4883–4891.
29 Bo¨ttner, B., Schrauber, H & Bernhardt, R (1996) Engineering a mineralocorticoid- to a glucocorticoid-synthesizing cytochrome P450 J Biol Chem 271, 8028–8033.
30 Wada, A & Waterman, M.R (1992) Identification by site-direc-ted mutagenesis of two lysine residues in cholesterol side chain cleavage cytochrome P450 that are essential for adrenodoxin binding J Biol Chem 267, 22877–22882.
31 Delorme, C., Piffeteau, A., Viger, A & Marquet, A (1995) Inhibition of bovine cytochrome P-450 (11 beta) by 18-unsaturated progesterone derivatives Eur J Biochem 232, 247–256.
32 Cao, P.R & Bernhardt, R (1999) Modulation of aldosterone biosynthesis by adrenodoxin mutants with different electron transport efficiencies Eur J Biochem 265, 152–159.
33 Yanagibashi, K & Hall, P.F (1986) Role of electron transport
in the regulation of the lyase activity of C21 side-chain cleavage P-450 from porcine adrenal and testicular microsomes J Biol Chem 261, 8429–8433.
34 Lifton, R.P., Dluhy, R.G., Powers, M., Rich, G.M., Gutkin, M., Fallo, F., Gill, J.R Jr, Feld, L., Ganguly, A., Laidlaw, J.C.& et al (1992) Hereditary hypertension caused by chimaeric gene dupli-cations and ectopic expression of aldosterone synthase Nature Gene.t 2, 66–74.
35 Hampf, M., Dao, N.T., Hoan, N.T & Bernhardt, R (2001) Unequal crossing-over between aldosterone synthase and 11beta-hydroxylase genes causes congenital adrenal hyperplasia J Clin Endocrinol Metab 86, 4445–4452.
36 Pascoe, L & Curnow, K.M (1995) Genetic recombination as a cause of inherited disorders of aldosterone and cortisol biosyn-thesis and a contributor to genetic variation in blood pressure Steroids 60, 22–27.
37 Frye, M.S & Hedges, S.B (1995) Monophyly of the order Rodentia inferred from mitochondrial DNA sequences of the genes for 12S rRNA, 16S rRNA, and tRNA-valine Mol Biol Evol 12, 168–176.